Brij Pal Alias Vedpal vs State Of U.P.
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 1891 of 1984
Brij Pal alias Vedpal …..Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P. …..Respondents(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Anil Malik, B. Ram, Kapil Tyagi,
Syed, Ali Murtaza.
Counsel for Respondent(s) : A.G.A.
Court No. - 29
HON’BLE SIDDHARHTA VARMA, J.
HON’BLE JAI KRISHNA UPADHYAY, J.
1. T he present Criminal Appeal has been preferred against the judgment
and order dated 18.05.1984 passed by the VIIth Additional Sessions
Judge, Ghaziabad, whereby the appellant was convicted under Section
302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment, and further convicted under
Section 376 IPC and sentenced to 10 years of rigorous imprisonment.
Both the sentences were directed to run concurrently.
2. When the dead body of the niece of the first informant Ganga Saran
was found on 28.09.1982 at around 5:00p.m. in the sugarcane field of
Jagvir Singh, then an FIR was lodged on the dictation of Ganga Saran
that on 27.09.1982 his niece Kunta, aged eight years, had at around
3:00p.m. brought food for the younger brother of the first informant
2
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
named Jai Deva and for that purpose she had gone to give food to Jai
Deva in the Mohan wali garden. While she was returning after having
given food to her father Jai Deva, Brij Pal son of Atar Singh had
followed her. Brij Pal had also gone to give food to his own father in the
same grove. That Brij Pal had followed Kunta, was seen by Jai Deva and
other individuals.
3. However, when on 27.09.1982 the daughter of Jai Deva did not
reach her home, then on 28.09.1982, a search was made by Jai Deva and
Raghubir (nephew of the first informant) and they had found the dead
body in the sugarcane field of Jagvir Singh. The dead body was in a bad
shape and that the frock which she had worn, she had been hung from
her neck. The undergarment which she was wearing was also not tied
around her waist and had got torn and it revealed that she had been raped
and therefore blood was also oozing out from her private parts.
4. In the FIR itself, it had been mentioned that Sheesh Pal, the son of
the first informant had also seen the accused Brij Pal coming out from
the sugarcane field. In the FIR itself, a prayer was made that the police
may take action against the guilty.
5. Upon the lodging of the first information report, the police got into
action and recovered the undergarment which the victim was wearing
and the memo of which was prepared and was exhibited as Exhibit Ka-3.
The pyjama and undergarment which the accused was wearing and
which had blood stain on it were also taken by the police. The memo of
the recovering of the underwear and pyjama was exhibited as Exhibit
3
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
Ka-4. From the place where the dead body was recovered, the plain and
blood stained soil was also taken and the memo was also prepared as
exhibit Ka-5. Exhibit Ka-6 was the memo of the recovery of the remains
of Makka plant which was growing in the place where the dead body
was found.
6. When the dead body was recovered, a panchayatnama was also
prepared on 28.09.1982 itself. It had commenced at 19:30 p.m. and had
concluded at 22:10 p.m. The postmortem of the dead body of the victim
was done on 29.09.1982 at 4:00 p.m. Thereafter Brij Pal was examined
by a doctor and no visible injury on his penis was found at the time of
the medical examination.
7. Upon the completion of the investigation, the police report was
sent to the court and on the 04.09.1983 the VIIIth Additional District and
Session Judge Ghaziabad framed charges under Section 302 and 376
IPC. During the trial, as many as eleven witnesses were produced by the
prosecution.
8. Ganga Saran PW-1 was the first informant. In the examination in
chief, the PW-1 had stated that in between 12:00 noon and 1:00 p.m. the
victim had gone to give food to Jai Deva, her father and thereafter the
accused had followed the victim and when the victim was not found in
her house, the PW-1 had got it announced that the victim had
disappeared. It was only then that the PW-1 was informed by Sheesh Pal,
his son that he had seen Brij Pal, the accused at around 3:30 to 4:00 p.m
exiting the field of Jagvir having sugarcane crop and it was from the
4
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
sugarcane fields of Jagvir that the victim's dead body was found. He had
stated that even his own brother Jai Deva had seen his daughter being
followed by the accused. He had also stated that the FIR was got lodged
by him and that it was written on his dictation by one Sri Satya Prakash
Sharma. He had stated that the victim was hung by the cord by which her
underwear was tied. In the cross-examination he had stated that his
house was around fifty steps away from the house of his brother Jai
deva. He had stated that he was not aware if there was any enmity
between Jagvir and the father of the accused Atar Singh.
9. PW-2 was Jai Deva, the father of the victim. He had also stated
somewhat the same facts as were stated by PW-1, his brother Ganga
Saran. He had also stated that after the dead body was recovered, the
nephew Sheesh Pal(son of first informant) had told him that at around
3:30 p.m. of the previous day he had seen the accused coming out of the
sugarcane field of Jagvir. He had stated that the accused had followed
the victim which was seen by Atar Singh, i.e. the father of the accused
and also other relatives of the co-accused namely Kawal Singh, Jeeve
Singh and Parasari. He had further stated that the accused had stayed in
the village till the dead body was not found and after it was found he had
disappeared. In the cross-examination he had stated somewhat the same
facts as were stated in the examination-in-chief. He had also stated that
he had no knowledge about any cases between Atar Singh, i.e. the father
of the accused and Jagvir, under Section 107 /117 of the Cr.P.C.
10. PW-3 was Sheesh Pal, who was the son of the first informant. In
examination-in-chief he had again stated that he had seen Brij Pal
5
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
coming out of the sugarcane fields of Jagvir. About Brij Pal coming out
of the field, he had stated that he had told about it to his father and uncle
on the next day after the dead body was found.
11. PW-4 was Satya Prakash Sharma the scribe of the first information
report.
12. PW-5 was the constable Chhatrapal (0107). He had taken the dead
body for postmortem.
13. PW-6 Jagvir Singh was the person before whom it was stated that
on the previous day before the dead body was recovered at around 2:00
to 2:30 A.M., in the dark of night, the accused had gone to his house and
had waked him up and had stated that he had committed a big mistake
and that the accused had stated that he had taken the victim after giving
ten paise to her into the field of PW-6 and thereafter had raped her.
When the victim had shouted, he had filled her mouth with cloth and
thereafter had throttled her to death and then he had requested the PW-6
to save him. He had then stated that thereafter he had informed the
police about the confession which the accused had made before him.
Thereafter the police had taken the pajama and the undergarment of the
accused into custody. He had also stated that the clothes of the victim
were also taken into custody by the police. In the cross-examination,
however, he had stated that he was not aware as to who had seen the
dead body first. He had then also upon a suggestion being made that
there was enmity between the families of the accused and the family of
6
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
the PW-6, stated that he was not aware of any case which might have
been fought amongst them earlier.
14. PW-7 was the Jyoti Prakash Tyagi and he was the person who had
prepared the chik of the FIR.
15. PW-8 Om Prakash Saraswat was the Station House Officer and
had investigated the case.
16. PW-9 B.D. Verma who was a witness in the panchanama and had
stated that on the panchanama there was no case crime number.
17. PW-10 was Ram Singh who was one of the investigating officers
and had stated that the blood and the semen which was found on the
pyjama of the accused was sent for the chemical examination by him.
18. PW-11 was the Dr. K.K. Karoli and he was the doctor who had
prepared the postmortem report.
19. As court witnesses, Dr. J.D.S. Sharma and Dr. Gyanendra Kumar
had appeared. Dr. J.D.S. Sharma had appeared as court witness no.1. He
had in his evidence stated that the accused was around 15 to 16 years of
age. The CW-2 was Dr. Gyanendra Kumar, radiologist and had stated
that he was the person who had got the X-ray done of the accused.
20. Thereafter the statement of the accused was got recorded. As of
before the charges were denied. In the statement under Section 313
CrPC. also the commission of the incident was denied and had stated
that since there was groupism in the village, therefore, he was falsely
implicated.
7
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
21. Upon the judgment being delivered and upon the accused being
found guilty under Section 376 and 302 IPC, the instant criminal appeal
was filed.
22. Learned counsel for the appellant Sri Syed Ali Murtaza, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Sri Kapil Tyagi, has submitted that this was a case
in which there was no direct evidence. PW-2 Jai Deva had seen the
accused only following the victim and Sheesh Pal PW-3 had seen the
accused coming out alone from the sugarcane field. Learned counsel for
the appellant therefore states that these witnesses had not even seen the
appellant and the victim together at any point of time. Learned counsel
for the appellant further states that there is evidence led to the effect that
the accused had made some extra judicial confession before the PW-6
Jagvir Singh. He states that definitely there had been litigation between
the predecessor-in-interest of the accused and PW-6 Jagvir Singh before
whom it was alleged that some extra judicial confession was made. The
case numbers have been given out as Case Crime No. 705 of 1963 under
Sections 436 and 323 IPC. Then it has been stated that vis-a-vis the Case
Crime No. 145 of 1963, the case was registered under Section 107 /117
of the Cr.P.C. Similarly, it has been mentioned that there was Case Crime
No. 144 of 1963 in the court of S.D.M. Hapur and after pointing to these
cases which were fought between the predecessor-in-interest, it was
submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that the accused to
make an extra judicial confession would definitely not approach the
PW-6 as there were litigations between the family of the accused and
that of the PW-6.
8
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
23. Learned counsel for the appellant further states that the court
below had drawn an adverse inference by stating that the accused had
refused to give his semen for medical examination. It has been stated in
the judgment of the Trial Court that chemical examination of semen on
the pyjama of the accused and that on the body of the deceased were of
category B. However the doctor, had stated that in fact no definite
conclusion could be drawn as to whether the semen found on the private
parts of the victim was that of the accused.
24. Learned counsel for the appellant states that no adverse inference
could be drawn if the accused had refused to give his semen for chemical
examination and he had submitted that no accused could be forced to
lead evidence against himself.
25. Learned counsel for the appellant relied upon the Smt.Nandini
Satpathy v. P.L. Dani & another reported in (1978) 2 SCC 424 and he
specifically relied upon paragraph 53 to 55 and paragraph 72 and they
are being reproduced hereas under
“53.The policy of the law is that each individual, accused
included, by virtue of his guaranteed dignity, has a right to a
private enclave where he may lead a free life without overbearing
investigatory invasion or even crypto-coercion. The protean forms
gendarme duress assumes, the environmental pressures of police
presence, compounded by incommunicado confinement and
psychic exhaustion, torturesome interrogation and physical
menaces and other ingenious, sophisticated procedures — the
condition, mental, physical, cultural and social, of the accused, the
length of the interrogation and the manner of its conduct and a
variety of like circumstances, will go into the pathology of
9
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
coerced para-confessional answers. The benefit of doubt, where
reasonable doubt exists, must go in favour of the accused. The
U.S. Supreme Court declared, and we agree with it, that
“… our contemplation cannot be only of what has been but
of what may be. Under any other rule a constitution would
indeed be as easy of application as it would be deficient in
efficacy and power. Its general principles would have little
value and be converted by precedent into impotent and
lifeless formulas. Rights declared in words might be lost in
reality. And this has been recognised. The meaning and
vitality of the Constitution have developed against narrow
and restrictive construction.” [54 L Ed 793, 810]
Making Article 20(3) effective in action.
54. Impregnability of the constitutional fortress built around
Article 20(3) is the careful concern of the Court and, for this
purpose, concrete directives must be spelt out. To leave the
situation fluid, after a general discussion and statement of broad
conclusions, may not be proper where glittering phrases pale into
gloomy realities in the dark recesses where the law has to
perform. Law is what law does and not what law says. This
realisation obligates us to set down concrete guidelines to make
the law a working companion of life. In this context we must
certainly be aware of the burdens which law enforcement officials
bear, often under trying circumstances and public ballyhoo and
amidst escalating as well as novel crime proliferation. Our
conclusions are, therefore, based upon an appreciation of the
difficulties of the police and the necessities of the Constitution.
55. The functional role and practical sense of the law is of crucial
moment. “An acre in Middlesex”, said Macaulay, “is better than a
principality in Utopia” [Introduction to “Law in America” by
Bernard Schwartz]. This realism has great relevance when dealing
with interrogation, incrimination, police station, the Constitution
and the Code…
10
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
72. We have declared the law on a thorny constitutional question
where the amber light from American rulings and beacon beams
from Indian precedents have aided us in our decision. It is quite
probable that the very act of directing a woman to come to the
police station in violation of Section 160(1) CrPC may make for
tension and negate voluntariness. It is likely that some of the
questions are self-criminatory. More importantly, the admitted
circumstances are such that the trying Magistrate may have to
hold an elaborate enquiry about other investigations, potential and
actual, to decide about the self-accusatory character of the
answers. And, finally, the process of proving proneness for self-
incrimination will itself strike a blow on the very protection under
Article 20(3). We have more reasons than one to conclude that the
ends of justice will be ill-served by an endless magisterial chase of
a charge the legal clarity of which is, by this judgment, being
authoritatively unveiled and the factual foundation of which may
have some infirmities. And the consequences of refusal to answer,
if most of the questions are self-condemning and a few formal
ones innocuous, were not gone into by us. So, we suggested to
Counsel that the authority of the law be vindicated by the accused
undertaking to answer all relevant, not criminatory, interrogations
and, on this pledge of compliance, the State withdraw the
prosecution pro tempore. If the accused went back on the
undertaking prosecution could again be launched and the party
proceeded against for breach of the plighted word. The response
from the State is a remarkable assertion of legal rectitude and
exposition of the principles for exercise of the power to withdraw,
and, finally, a conclusion couched thus:
“After careful consideration from all angles and in the facts
and circumstances on record, Government have come to the
conclusion, that there are no circumstances to justify withdrawal
by the State Government.”
11
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
26. Learned counsel for the appellant to bolster his argument with
regard to the fact that no accused can be forced to lead evidence against
himself relied upon the Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India. Since
he relied upon this article, the same is being reproduced hereas under: -
“20(3) No person accused of any offence shall be compelled to be
a witness against himself.”
27. He also relied upon the judgments reported in Manak Chand @
Mani v. State of Haryana reported in 2023 SCC Online SC 1397,
Bijender @ Mandar v. State of Haryana reported in (2022) 1 SCC 92,
Balasaheb @ Ramesh Laxman Deshmukh v. State of Maharashtra
reported in (2011) 1 SCC 364, Prem Prakash v. Union of India reported
in 2024 (9) SCC 787, Amlesh Kumar v. State of Bihar reported in 2025
SCC OnLine SC 1326 and Smt.Selvi v. State of Karnataka reported in
(2010) 7 SCC 263.
28. Learned counsel for the appellant has stated that since the refusal
by the accused to provide the evidence against himself was coming in
the way of the investigating authorities, Section 53 CrPC was suitably
amended and the explanation was added by an amendment which came
rd
into effect on 23 June 2006. The amendment was incorporated by Act
25 of 2005 which is being reproduced here as under:-
Explanation.—In this section and in sections 53A and 54,—
(a) “examination” shall include the examination of blood, blood
stains, semen, swabs in case of sexual offences, sputum and
sweat, hair samples and finger nail clippings by the use of modern
and scientific techniques including DNA profiling and such other
12
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
tests which the registered medical practitioner thinks necessary in
a particular case;
(b) “registered medical practitioner” means a medical practitioner
who possesses any medical qualification as defined in clause (h)
of section 2 of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (102 of
1956) and whose name has been entered in a State Medical
Register.”
The earlier explanation read as under : -
“Explanation.- In this Section and in section 54, “registered
medical practitioner” means a medical practitioner who possesses
any recognized medical qualification as defined in clause (h) of
section 2 of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (102 of 1956),
and whose name has been entered in a State Medical Register”.
Also Section 53A was added to the CrPC by the same amending Act.
The Section 53A is being reproduced hereas under
“ 53A. Examination of person accused of rape by medical practitioner.—
(1) When a person is arrested on a charge of committing an offence of rape or
an attempt to commit rape and there are reasonable grounds for believing that
an examination of his person will afford evidence as to the commission of
such offence, it shall be lawful for a registered medical practitioner employed
in a hospital run by the Government or by a local authority and in the absence
of such a practitioner within the radius of sixteen kilometres from the place
where the offence has been committed, by any other registered medical
practitioner, acting at the request of a police officer not below the rank of a
sub-inspector, and for any person acting in good faith in his aid and under his
direction, to make such an examination of the arrested person and to use such
force as is reasonably necessary for that purpose.
(2) The registered medical practitioner conducting such examination shall,
without delay, examine such person and prepare a report of his examination
giving the following particulars, namely:—
(i) the name and address of the accused and of the person by whom he was
brought,
13
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
(ii) the age of the accused,
(iii) marks of injury, if any, on the person of the accused,
(iv) the description of material taken from the person of the accused for DNA
profiling, and
(v) other material particulars in reasonable detail.
(3) The report shall state precisely the reasons for each conclusion arrived at.
(4) The exact time of commencement and completion of the examination
shall also be noted in the report.
(5) The registered medical practitioner shall, without delay, forward the
report to the investigating officer, who shall forward it to the Magistrate
referred to in section 173 as part of the documents referred to in clause (a) of
sub-section (5) of that section. ”
29. Learned counsel for the appellant therefore states that before the
amendment Act 25 of 2005 came into effect, there was no law under
which the accused was under any obligation to provide his semen for
investigation and, therefore, he submits that the adverse inference which
the trial court had drawn was not called for. Therefore when no evidence
was there to implicate the appellant, then he should have been acquitted.
30. Learned counsel for the appellant further had submitted that the
appellant was juvenile. His date of birth was 4.5.1967. Going by this
date of birth, he was 15 years and 4 months and 25 days at the time of
the occurrence. When an application was filed by the appellant for
declaring him juvenile, the matter was sent to the Juvenile Justice Board
and it had also found that the appellant was a juvenile at the time of the
commission of the offence. Learned counsel also submitted that none of
the victims who were not of the family and had seen the appellant along
with the victim were ever examined.
14
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
31. Learned counsel for the appellant therefore submitted that the
appellant was innocent and therefore he be exonerated of the charges
which were levelled against him after allowing the appeal.
32. Learned AGA Sri Amit Sinha, has, however, opposed the appeal
and has submitted that when there were enough evidence of the fact that
the accused had gone with the victim into the sugarcane field and when
the dead body was found in the sugarcane field itself, then there was no
other option but to convict the appellant. He further submits that the
extra judicial confession before the PW-6 Jagvir Singh was also an
important piece of evidence and this itself could have been made the
basis for the conviction.
33. Having heard the learned counsel for the appellant Sri Syed Ali
Murtaza, Senior Advocate, assisted by Sri Kapil Tyagi, advocate for the
appellant and the learned AGA Sri Amit Sinha, we find that there was no
direct evidence for convicting the appellant. The incident was never seen
by any of the witnesses. In fact, there was no eyewitness account. Also
there was no evidence of anyone who might have last seen the accused
with the victim. PW-2 had seen the accused following the victim. PW-3
Sheesh Pal had also seen only the accused coming out of the sugarcane
field. PW-3 had never revealed that he had seen the accused coming out
of the sugarcane field before the dead body was found in the sugarcane
field. This leads us to hold that the accused was never seen actually by
anyone along with the victim. The PW-3 had mentioned about his seeing
the accused coming out the field only after the dead body was found in
the sugarcane field. PW-2 when had told his brother that he had seen the
15
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
accused following the victim then no definite inference could be drawn
from what he had stated, as both the accused and the victim had gone to
provide food to their fathers in the field of Mohan. It was normal for one
person to follow the other when they had done with the giving of the
food to their fathers.
34. Also, the accused had been implicated on account of the fact that
his pyjama had blood and semen. However, neither was the blood ever
connected with the blood of the victim and nor was the semen on the
pyjama of the accused connected with the semen found on the private
parts of the deceased.
35. The argument of the learned AGA that an adverse inference ought
to be drawn when the appellant did not accede to the providing of the
semen for comparing it with the semen on the private parts of the
deceased has to be dealt with only to be rejected. The law of the land at
the time when the case was being decided was totally governed by the
provisions of Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India. Definitely
nobody could be forced to provide evidence against himself. Also, we
find that the appellant at the time of commission of crime was only 15
years of age. Therefore definitely the brutality as has been shown on the
body of the deceased victim could not be believably have been
committed by such a young person.
36. In this view of the matter, for all the reasons which have been
given above, we are of the view that the appellant deserves to be
acquitted of the charges levelled against him. The judgment and order
16
CRLA No.1891 of 1984
dated 18.5.1984 passed by the VIIth Additional Sessions Judge,
Ghaziabad, is set aside. The criminal appeal is accordingly allowed. The
appellant is already on bail.
The bail bonds are discharged.
(Jai Krishna Upadhyay,J.)(Siddhartha Varma,J.)
November 20, 2026
PK
Digitally signed by :-
PRAVEEN KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad