Shubh Karan vs State Of Punjab
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
383 CRA-S-170-SB-2006 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 18.11 .2026
Duli Chand
......Appellant
Versus
State of Punjab
...... Respondent
CRA-S-279-SB-2006 (O&M)
Shubh Karan
......Appellant
Versus
State of Punjab
...... Respondent
SURYA PARTAP SINGH
CORAM: HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE
Amicus Curiae
Present : Mr. Hitesh Verma, Advocate-
for the appellant in CRA-S-170-SB-2006.
Mr. N.K.Banka, Advocate for the appellant
in CRA-S-279-SB-2006
Mr. I.P.S. Sabharwal, DAG, Punjab.
SURYA PARTAP SINGH , J . (Oral) :
The present appeals have been preferred by the appellants/convicts
against the judgment of conviction dated 09.12.2005 and order of sentence
dated 12.12.2005, passed by the Court of learned Judge, Special Court,
Ferozepur (designated under Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1985), hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’ only.
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 2
2. Briefly stating the facts emerging from record are that one FIR, i.e.
FIR No.5 dated 06.01.2001, was lodged at the instance of ‘ASI Kulwant
Singh’ . The abovesaid FIR was lodged for the commission of offence
punishable under Section-18 of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1985 , hereinafter being referred to as ‘NDPS Act’, Police Station Sadar
Abohar. In the wake of abovementioned FIR, the investigation was taken up
by the police, and as an outcome of abovesaid investigation, the appellants
were sent to face trial before the Court.
3. The appellants participated in the abovementioned trial. By virtue
of judgment dated 09.12.2005, hereinafter being referred to as ‘impugned
judgment’, the abovesaid trial culminated into conviction of the appellants.
Thus, vide order dated 12.12.2005, on the point of quantum of sentence,
hereinafter being referred to as ‘impugned order’, following sentences were
awarded to the appellants:-
Offence under Sentence
Section
Rigorous imprisonment for a period of six years and to
pay a fine of Rs.15000/- each. In default thereof to
undergo further imprisonment (rigorous) for a period
of six months each.
18(c) of NDPS
Act
It was also ordered that the period of detention, if any, already
undergone by the accused during the course of trial, would be set-off in
accordance with law.
4. In nut-shell, the facts emerging from record are that the FIR of this
case came into being at the instance of ‘ASI Kulwant Singh’, who reported
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 3
that on 06.01.2001, he was leading a team of police officials deputed for
patrolling duty and was present near the bridge of Drain in the area of village
Ramsara. As per above named police officer, during the course of above
mentioned duty the above said team of police officials was holding a picket
for traffic checking. According to above named police officer, the police party
spotted a motorcycle bearing registration No.HR-05D-3824 being driven by
‘Duli Chand’ and ‘Shubh Karan’ (the appellants herein) was pillion rider
thereupon. It was further stated by the above named police officer that when
contents of bag hanging on the left side of the motorcycle were checked, 2.10
kg. of ‘Opium’ wrapped in glazed paper was recovered. According to above
₹
named police officer, during search of the appellant ‘Duli Chand’, 100/- and
₹
from ‘Shubh Karan’ 130/- was recovered.
5. It was a case of the prosecution that pursuant to recovery of
abovementioned contraband, necessary formalities with regard to seizure &
sealing of contraband, lodging of FIR, and formal arrest of the accused were
completed, and further investigation taken up. According to prosecution,
during the course of investigation, the Investigating Officer inspected the
spot, prepared rough site plan of the place of recovery, and completed usual
formalities of investigation. Thereafter, the final report under Section 173 of
CrPC was filed in the Court.
6. Heard.
7. It has been contended on behalf of appellants that the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence, passed by the learned trial
Court were perverse and unsustainable. According to learned counsel for the
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 4
appellants, merely on the basis of assumptions and presumptions, the
unreliable and self-contradictory evidence adduced by the prosecution was
believed by the learned trial Court. As per learned counsel for the appellants ,
the learned trial Court failed to apply its judicial mind to the facts of the case,
and merely, on the basis of conjectures and surmises, the finding of conviction
of appellants, for the commission of offence under Section 18(c) of NDPS
Act, was recorded.
8. It has been further contended on behalf of appellants that the
learned trial Court ignored this cardinal principle of criminal jurisprudence
that the prosecution had to prove its case beyond the shadow of all reasonable
doubts. According to learned counsel for the appellants, the evidence adduced
by the prosecution was grossly inadequate to draw an inference that all the
essential ingredients, meant for the commission of offence, for which the
appellants were convicted, had been proved. In view of above, the learned
counsel for the appellants has contended that the case against the appellants
was not proved by the prosecution, but erroneously the learned trial Court
returned the finding of conviction.
9. However, during the course of arguments, the learned counsel for
the appellants has contended that in the instant appeal, the appellants are not
inclined to challenge the finding of conviction recorded by the learned trial
Court. The learned counsel for the appellants has categorically contended that
at this stage, by virtue of present appeal, the appellants are challenging the
order on the point of quantum of sentence only.
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 5
10. It has been further contended by learned counsel for the appellants
that the incident had taken place way back in the year 2001. According to
learned counsel for the appellants, the appellants are facing the agony of
litigation for the last more than 25 years and has, in fact, already suffered
more punishment than they deserved. According to learned counsel for the
appellants, in the last more than 25 years, the appellants have not been
prosecuted for any other offence.
11. In addition to above, the learned counsel for the appellants and has
also argued that the quantity of contraband recovered in this case was within
the ambit of ‘non-commercial quantity’ and that in the present case, the
appellant ‘Duli Chand’ has already undergone imprisonment for a period of
one year, six months and fourteen days and appellant Subh Karan for a period
of five years, three months and twelve days. According to learned counsel for
the appellants, in view of above-discussed factors, and the fact that minimum
sentence has not been prescribed for the offence, for which the appellants
have been convicted, the sentence already undergone by the appellants may
be treated to be sufficient.
12. Per contra , the learned counsel for the respondent/State has argued
that the appellants were found guilty for the commission of offence
punishable under Section 18(c) of NDPS Act. According to learned counsel
for the respondent/State, the sentence awarded to the appellants, i.e.
imprisonment for a period of six years, is already on lower side, and that the
appellants are not entitled to a sentence, awarded to them. As per learned
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 6
counsel for the respondent/State, the instant appeal has no merits and deserves
dismissal.
13. The record has been perused carefully.
14. Although it is categorical stand of the appellants that they are not
challenging the judgment of conviction, passed by the learned trial Court, yet,
with a purpose to evaluate evidence, the record has been perused carefully. A
perusal of trial Court record shows that the evidence adduced by the
prosecution was thoroughly consistent, and good enough to bring home guilt
of the appellants, for which they were charge-sheeted. Thus, it is hereby held
that there is no scope for interference or indulgence in the findings recorded
by the learned trial Court, with regard to conviction of appellants, for the
offence under Section 18(c) of NDPS Act. Accordingly, the abovementioned
finding is hereby affirmed and qua the judgment of conviction instant appeal
is hereby dismissed.
15. As far as the order on quantum of sentence is concerned, in view
of the fact that the appellant (Duli Chand) has already undergone
imprisonment for a period of one year, six months and fourteen days and
appellant (Shubhkaran) for a period of five years, three months and twelve
days, against the awarded sentence of six years, it is hereby held that the
appellants are entitled to a lenient view.
16. In the light of above observations, if factual matrix of the present
case is analyzed, it transpires that following are the points which are required
to be taken into consideration: -
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 7
(a) that the quantity of contraband recovered in this case was non-
commercial quantity, for which minimum sentence has not
been prescribed;
(b) that the incident in question had taken place about 25 years
ago;
(c) that the appellants are facing the agony of protracted trial for
the last more than 25 years;
(d) that against the awarded sentence of six years, the appellant
‘Duli Chand’ has already undergone imprisonment for a period
of one year, six months and fourteen days and appellant
‘Shubh Karan’ for a period of five years, three months and
twelve days;
(e) that it was the first offence committed by the appellants; and
(f) that in the last more than 25 years, the appellants have not
been prosecuted for any other offence.
17. In view of abovementioned observations, the sentence awarded to
the appellants is hereby held to be harsh and, as a consequence thereof, it is
hereby observed that with regard to quantum of sentence, there is need for
interference and indulgence in the impugned order, i.e. the order on the point
of quantum of sentence, by exercising the appellate jurisdiction vested in this
Court. Thus, in my opinion, by exercising the abovementioned jurisdiction,
the sentence awarded to the appellants needs to be rationalized and reduced.
18. As a cumulative effect of abovementioned observations, it is
hereby held that in the present case, the appellants are entitled to a lenient
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
CRA-S-170 & 279-SB-2006 (O&M) 8
view, and that the sentence already undergone in the present case, is adequate
to meet the ends of justice.
19. As a sequel to the aforesaid discussions, the present appeal is
hereby partly allowed . The judgment of conviction is upheld; but order on
the point of quantum of sentence is modified, and the sentence awarded to the
appellants is reduced to the period already undergone by them.
20. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed of,
accordingly.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected case.
(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)
JUDGE
18.11.2026
Manoj Bhutani
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
MANOJ KUMAR
2026.11.19 17:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document