Icici Lombard General Insurance Co.Ltd. vs Smt. Harjeet Kaur & Ors.

Court
Delhi High Court

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
Reserved on : 12 October 2026.
th
Pronounced on: 19 November 2026
th
Uploaded on : 20 November 2026

# CNR No. DLHC010593062023
+ MAC.APP. 49/2024

ICICI LOMBARD GENERAL INSURANCE CO.LTD.
.....Appellant
Through: Ms. Suman Bagga, Ms. Mouli
Sharma, Advs. Mr. Gautam Jha,
Advocates
versus

SMT. HARJEET KAUR & ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Dhananjay Gupta, Mr.
Gurjeet Singh, Mr. Narendra
Mohan Rajesh, Advs. for
Respondent No.1

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL

JUDGMENT
%

ANISH DAYAL, J.
1. This appeal has been filed by the Insurance Company assailing
st
award dated 31 July 2023 passed the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Central District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi [‘ MACT/Tribunal ’] awarding
compensation of Rs.27,13,262/- along with interest at the rate of 9% per
annum.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 1 of 25

The Accident
th
2. The accident occurred on 25 September 2014 at about 02:15 a.m.
when Tarandeep Singh (hereinafter, ‘ deceased ’) was driving an Accent
car on the mall road towards Gurudwara Sisganj Sahib, Chandni Chowk
when his car collided with the rear of a JCB bearing No. HR 74 2045
(‘ offending vehicle ’) which had been stationary on the road.
3. The offending vehicle was alleged to have been wrongfully and
improperly parked in the middle of the road without blinkers, parking
indicators or reflectors at an unlit spot. Deceased was taken to the
Trauma Centre for initial treatment and then to the hospital where he
th
remained under treatment till his death 30 September 2014. FIR
425/2014 was registered in this respect.

Submissions on behalf of parties
4. Ms. Suman Bagga , counsel for Insurance Company, argues that
the offending vehicle was not covered by the Insurance Policy under the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (‘ MV Act ’) but had been merely taken as,
“ Contractors Plant & Machinery Policy ” (hereinafter, ‘ CPM Policy ’)
that covered the risk of any damage or injury or death caused at the site
where the offending vehicle was deployed.
5. Ms. Bagga , contented that the machine was used as an equipment
and therefore, had been insured against risks of use of that equipment
and not as a motor vehicle . She submitted that the MACT had failed to
appreciate the nature, scope and contractual limitations of the CPM
Policy.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 2 of 25

6. Ms. Bagga , drew attention of this Court to the relevant aspects of
th th
the CPM policy. The policy was valid from 05 October 2013 till 04
October 2014 in favour of the owner/ Gemini Equipment and Rentals
Private Limited . Indemnification of the insured/owner was against
unforeseen and sudden physical damage by any cause (not excluded) to
the insured whilst “ at the location mentioned ”. One of the exclusions to
the CPM policy was contained in Clause (h) which stated, “ loss or
damage whilst in transit, from one location to another location (public
liability will not be payable while Contractors Plant and Machinery are
on public roads). ”
7. Mr. Dhananjay Gupta , counsel for claimant, on the other hand,
drew attention of the Court to the endorsement, ‘ CPM 3: Third Party
Liability (TPL)’ , which stated that in consideration of an additional
premium of Rs. 80/- , the Insurance Company would indemnify the
insured/owner against legal liability for accidental loss or damage caused
to the property of other persons and, “ against legal liability for fatal or
non-fatal injury to any persons other than the insured or his own
employees or employees of the other firms/connected with the work or
members of the family of the insured ”.
8. While, Ms. Bagga contended that as per this, third-party liability
was restricted to the operation of the offending vehicle on site and not
for being driven as a motor vehicle on the road, Mr. Gupta countered it
by stating that there was a specific assumption of coverage of risk by the
Insurance Company with respect to third-party liability.

9. Ms. Bagga , relied on Section 147 of MV Act, stating that it covers
only motor vehicles which have been defined under Section 2 (28) of
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 3 of 25

MV Act and did not cover the offending vehicle which was essentially a
machine/equipment. She contended that the CPM Policy does not
provide statutory third-party insurance as mandated under the MV Act
and no premium towards third-party had been charged or paid. Liability
towards third-party referred above was merely contractual in nature and
was restricted both in scope and quantum, with the liability capped at
Rs.2,65,168/- and therefore cannot be expanded to include the
compensation payable to the claimant.
10. Ms. Bagga , placed reliance on the decisions of Supreme Court in
United India Insurance Co. Ltd v. Harchand Rai Chandanlal (2004) 8
SCC 644 and General Assurance Society Ltd. v. Chandmull Jain &
Anr. AIR 1966 SC 1644 and the decisions of High Court of Karnataka in
Ranganath C. v. Sany Heavy Industries 2023:KHC:24666 and Iffco
Tokio General Insurance v. Taslim Banu , 2021:KHC-K:6430-DB.
11. She highlighted that the exclusions under Third-Party Liability
(TPL) Extension Clause also included an exclusion in Clause c(iii)
which stated that “ any accident caused by vehicles licensed for general
road or by waterborne vessels or used aircraft ”.
12. Per contra, Mr. Dhananjay Gupta , stated that a crane or a JCB
machine fell within the definition of a Motor Vehicle under Section
2(28) of MV Act and cannot fall within the exception of a special type of
vehicle adapted solely for use in a factory. In his support, he relies on the
decision of this Court in United India Insurance Company Limited v.
Jagat and Others 2024:DHC:2974, which held that vehicles such as,
cranes used on public roads are covered under the definition of a motor
vehicle in the MV Act.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 4 of 25

13. Mr. Gupta also placed reliance on the decision of a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in National Insurance Company Limited v. Ram
Bai & Ors. , 2019:DHC:5589.
14. Aside from this, Ms. Bagga raised the issue of contributory
negligence to be fastened on the deceased. Ms. Bagga contended that the
finding that the offending vehicle had been negligently parked in the
middle of the road, without indicators, was contrary to the site plan,
which shows that it was stationary, on the side of the road.
15. Mr. Gupta , however, contended that the vehicle was parked
without blinkers and parking indicators and on noticing the same, the
driver tried to avoid the accident, however, he struck against the rear
right portion of the offending vehicle. He relies on the decision in
Lakshmi Devi and others v. Mehboob Ali SLP (C) No. 30423/2019
th
decided on 25 August 2023, where the accident had occurred with a
stationary vehicle parked in the middle of the road. The Supreme Court
held that there was no contributory negligence of deceased, when there
was no visibility of the truck and the deceased was only able to notice
the vehicle when he approached it. Therefore, in such circumstance,
entire negligence was fastened on the driver of offending vehicle.
16. Ms. Suman Bagga stated that without prejudice to the above, in
case the liability is imposed upon driver of the offending vehicle,
Insurance Company should be entitled to recovery rights, since there was
a clear breach of the conditions of insurance policy and an absence of
statutory coverage.

17. Further on the issue of quantum of compensation, she contended
that future prospects at 50% were wrongly granted, which is against the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 5 of 25

principles enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi ,
(2017) 16 SCC 680.
Analysis
th
18. The accident occurred on 25 September 2014 at about 02:15 a.m.
when the deceased was driving his Accent car proceeding on Mall Road
highway near Khyber Pass Petro Pump and crashed into the offending
vehicle, which was parked stationary in the middle of the road allegedly
without blinkers and parking indicators. Tarandeep Singh (deceased)
suffered multiple grievous injuries and his car was also hugely damaged.
He was rushed to Trauma Centre, then later to Vinayak Hospital, Model
Town and then to Fortis Hospital, Shalimar Bagh, where he remained
th
under treatment until his passing away on 30 September 2014. The
deceased was aged about 22 years and was running his own shop of raw
veg and non-veg snacks.
19. The driver and owner filed a joint written statement blaming the
deceased for negligence and for not driving safely. Written statement
filed by Insurance Company also corroborated the same, stating that the
offending vehicle was not insured under the MV Act, but under CPM
policy and no third-party premium under the MV Act was charged. Only
limited liability to the extent of Rs.2,65,160/- was covered, which did not
apply in the present case, since the said JCB/offending vehicle was on a
public road and not on site.
20. There were no eyewitnesses to the accident. Mother of deceased
deposed as PW1 and stated that the offending vehicle was parked in the
middle of the road without any blinkers or indicator lights, due to which
the deceased dashed into the offending vehicle.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 6 of 25

21. MACT noted that the oral testimony of PW1 remained unrebutted
and unchallenged by the driver & owner, as they did not cross-examine
PW1 . No material had been placed on record by the Insurance Company
to reject the oral testimony of PW1 . Since the driver was charge-sheeted
and he did not step into the witness box, this was considered to be a
persuasive circumstance and an adverse inference was drawn.
22. It was noted that the deceased was travelling on the right
carriageway and the offending vehicle had been improperly parked on
the side. The driver did not make any statement as to circumstances
under which the offending vehicle had been wrongly and improperly
parked and, there was no evidence of any mechanical defect in the
offending vehicle or any proof of omission on the part of deceased.
23. The detailed accident report (‘ DAR ’) noted the position of
offending vehicle as, “ JCB was standing near Mall Road Petrol Pump ”
and the lane in which accident took place was a two-way lane . It
recorded at Serial No.16(x) [ whether there were any traffic lights near
the place of accident and, if they were functional ] a ‘No ’ to the said
question.
24. As per the DAR, the road was divided by a painted median and the
condition of the light was ‘ dark (street lights on, continuous) ’. DAR was
filed by ASI Lekhraj who deposed as PW2 and the site plan was
exhibited as Ex. PW2/2 . As per the site plan, extracted below, the
collision happened at point ‘A’ which was in the middle of the road and
it was noted that blinkers or similar indicators were “ not on ” to assess
whether the JCB/offending vehicle was non-functional or stationary. The
petrol pump was located slightly further away on the left side.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 7 of 25

25. The insurance policy describes the JCB/offending vehicle as ‘ JCB
432ZX Wheel Loader’ with an engine and chassis number. The insurance
policy, which is a CPM policy, covers the JCB/offending vehicle as an
equipment , along with an endorsement for third-party liability as CPM-3
restricted at 10% of the sum insured Rs.26,51,683/- i.e. Rs.2,65,168/-.
The insurance policy itself mentioned that the insured property was
covered “ at the location ” and would cover the equipment whenever it
was at work or at rest, being dismantled for the purpose of cleaning or
overhauling or in the course of operations, or when it is being shifted
within the premises.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 8 of 25

26. Loss or damage whilst in transit from one location to another was
excluded with the specific statement that, “ public liability will not be
payable when contractors’ plant and machinery’s are on public roads ”.
The clause for third-party liability as part of CPM-3 endorsement
covered legal liability for accidental loss or damage caused to the
property of other persons, and for fatal or non-fatal injury to any persons
other than the insured or his own employees or employees of the owner
of the works/site or employees of other firms/connected with the work
site or members of the family of the insured.
27. Ms. Bagga submitted was that the insurance policy in itself did not
cover JCB/offending vehicle as a motor vehicle and specifically
excluded its liability when it was on the road. The clause for third-party
liability under CPM-3 was merely related to damage to any third party
while the JCB/offending vehicle is present on the location.
28. In this regard, it would be instructive to see how a wheel loader is
categorized under the MV Act and Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989
(‘ CMV Rules ’). Rule 2 (cab) [ renumbered from Rule 2(ca) pursuant to
st
G.S.R. 212(E) w.e.f from 1 April 2015 ] of the CMV Rules which
defines a construction equipment vehicle, includes a loader as part of the
definition. Notably, the said definition includes a number of other similar
equipments and qualifies it with the phrase ‘ but modified and
manufactured’ with “on or off ” or “ on and off ” highway capabilities.
The explanation itself states that such a vehicle shall be a non-transport
vehicle and driving on the road of such a vehicle will be incidental to the
main off-highway function and for a short duration not exceeding 50
kmph. The said Rule is extracted as under:
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 9 of 25

“2. Definitions.— In these rules, unless the context
otherwise requires—
(cab) "construction equipment vehicle" means rubber
tyred (including pneumatic tyred), rubber padded or
steel drum wheel mounted, self-propelled, excavator,
loader, backhoe, compactor roller, dumper, motor
grader, mobile crane, dozer, fork lift truck, self-loading
concrete mixer or any other construction equipment
vehicle or combination thereof designed for off-
highway operations in mining, industrial undertaking,
irrigation and general construction but modified and
manufactured with "on or off" or "on and off" highway
capabilities.
Explanation.—A construction equipment vehicle shall
be a non-transport vehicle the driving on the road of
which is incidental to the main off-highway function
and for a short duration at a speed not exceeding 50
kms per hour, but such vehicle does not include other
purely off highway construction equipment vehicle
designed and adopted for use in any enclosed
premises, factory or mine other than road network, not
equipped to travel on public roads on their own
power.”
(emphasis added)

29. Given the above specifications, it is imperative to consider the
nature of JCB/offending vehicle, and for this purpose an image of said
JCB/offending vehicle as taken from the official JCB site
[ https://www.jcb.com/en-ZA/products/machines/wheel-loaders/432zx/ ]
is extracted below for reference:

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 10 of 25

30. Certain other relevant provisions which pertain to a construction
equipment vehicle as per the CMV Rules are inter alia , Rule 104A, 105,
107A, 109, 126B .
31. Of these, Rule 109 of the CMV Rules is relevant to this case and
reads as under:
“109. Parking light— Every construction equipment
vehicle, combine harvester and motor vehicle and
every motor vehicle other than motor cycles and three
wheeled invalid carriages shall be provided with one
white or amber parking light on each side in the front.
In addition to the front lights, two red parking lights
one on each side in the rear shall be provided. The
front and rear parking lights shall remain lit even
when the vehicle is kept stationary on the road:
Provided that these rear lamps can be the same as the
rear lamps referred to in rule 105, sub-rule (2)
Provided also that construction equipment vehicles and
combine harvesters, which are installed with flood
light lamps or spot lights at the front, rear or side of
the vehicle for their off-highway or construction
operations, shall have separate control for such lamps
or lights and these shall be permanently switched off
when the vehicle is travelling on the road.”
(emphasis added)

32. Rule 109 clearly states that every construction equipment vehicle
shall be provided with one white or amber parking light on each side in
the front and two red parking lights on each side in the rear. Both the
front and rear parking lights ‘ shall remain lit ’ even when the vehicle is
kept stationary on the road. Whether this mandate was complied with by
driver of the offending vehicle, is an issue which can be potentially
disputed. However, considering that between the driver and the
deceased, only the driver of offending vehicle is available as a possible
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 11 of 25

eyewitness, who chose not to appear and give his testimony before the
MACT, adverse inference therefore, is to be drawn that the
JCB/offending vehicle was standing in the middle of the road (as evident
from the site plan) without any parking lights or indicator lights at 02:15
a.m. Even if the street lights were on, there is no way of knowing as to
what would be the visibility of the vehicle at that time, which is quite
large in its dimensions and potentially could not be visible in the middle
of the road in the middle of the night.
33. Therefore, the aspect of contributory negligence, as pleaded by the
Insurance Company, cannot be accepted. In order to prove contributory
negligence, there has to be evidence in support provided by the party
seeking to stake claim on the same. This has been clearly held by the
Supreme Court in Yashwant Krishna Kumbar v. Divisional Manager ,
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. SLP (C) NO. 22599/2024 by order
th
dated 25 November 2025, where the Supreme Court was adjudicating
an appeal filed by the pillion rider on the ground that contributory
negligence of 50% was attributed by the Tribunal and High Court.
Allowing the pillion rider’s appeal, the Supreme Court held as under:
“16. In cases where contributory negligence is sought
to be attributed to a pillion rider in a motor vehicle
accident, the burden squarely lies on the party alleging
such negligence to establish, by cogent material, that
any act or omission on the part of the pillion rider
contributed to the occurrence of the accident. In the
absence of such proof, no finding of contributory
negligence can be sustained against a pillion rider.
17. This Court is therefore of the considered view that
the Tribunal committed a manifest error in reducing
the compensation by 50% on the ground of alleged
contributory negligence of the claimant. The insurer,
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 12 of 25

on whom the burden squarely rested, led no evidence
to establish even remote negligence attributable to the
claimant. Consequently, the finding of contributory
negligence cannot be sustained and is liable to be set
aside, restoring the claimant’s entitlement to the full
measure of compensation determined in accordance
with law.”
(emphasis added)

34. The primary issue then arises, whether the owner would be liable
since the offending vehicle was not insured as a motor vehicle to ply on
the roads or would the insurance policy, as it existed, cover its use on the
roads. It is quite evident from the CPM Policy, that the insured owner
did not wish to get the vehicle covered for its use of the roads, as clearly
borne out of the particular exclusion clause. Whether third-party liability
endorsement, relied upon by Mr. Gupta , can provide unlimited liability
under the MV Act in favour of the claimant is to be considered. In the
opinion of this Court, prima facie it does not seem so.
35. However, it will be instructive to note various judgments which
have rendered decisions in similar circumstances.
(i) In Tara Chanda v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. ,
2016 SCC OnLine KAR 8413, the vehicle in dispute was a mobile
crane , classified as a construction equipment vehicle, registered as
a motor vehicle under the MV Act, read with CMV Rules. Since the
Insurance Company had issued a CPM policy, MACT had absolved
the insurer from paying compensation. In appeal, the claimants
submitted that the crane was attached to the motor vehicle, thereby,
conforming to the definition of heavy goods vehicle under Section
2(16) of MV Act. While the CPM policy covered the risk of 64
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 13 of 25

cranes, located at the site, clause (h) being an exclusion clause
provided for loss of damage while in transit, from one location to
another, but did not cover public liability on public roads. The
policy also included a third-party liability endorsement for accident
on site. Therefore, the MACT held that the CPM policy covered
risk and damage at the site of work and not third-party risk arising
out of an accident on a public road.
While, the Insurance Company contended that the crane was not a
motor vehicle, however, this submission was rejected by the High
Court noting Rule 2(ca) of CMV Rules [ subsequently renumbered
as Rule 2(cab) ], defining construction equipment vehicle.
Reference was made to General Regulations of the All-India Tariff
on Contractors Plant and Machinery Insurance (hereinafter, ‘ Tariff
Regulations ’) [ since denotified by IRDAI vide Notification dated
March 20, 2024 ] and specifically Regulation 3 which is extracted as
under for ease of reference:
“ 3. SCOPE
The cover shall be as per the standard policy form in
respect of Contractor's Plant & Machinery Insurance.
The Insurance of all types of Contractor's Plant
Machinery and Equipments (including those governed
by the Motor Vehicles Act or rateable under Motor
Tariff) engaged for work at any specified location in
India, shall be subject to these General Regulations.
In respect of Machinery/equipments, whether
registered with RTO or not, but engaged at the Project
site, the Insured, has an option either to select the
Motor/Non-Motor Policy under Motor Tariff or CPM
Policy in the Engineering Department.
In case of doubt as to the applicability of Rate
Schedule and these General Regulations, the matter
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 14 of 25

should be referred to the Tariff Advisory Committee
through Head Office of the Insurers .”
(emphasis added)
The Court noted that the insured had an option to select either
Motor/Non-Motor Policy under the Motor Tariff or the CPM
policy. Therefore, it was held that since the crane was attached to
the heavy goods vehicle, it was both a construction equipment
vehicle, as well as, a heavy goods vehicle for the purpose of MV
Act and held that the insurer was bound to satisfy the claims for
compensation.
(ii) IFFCO Tokio General Insurance v. Taslim Banu
2021:KHC-K:6430-DB, a decision delivered by the Division Bench
of Karnataka High Court was a case where the accident occurred
when the deceased was crushed between a tipper used for
transporting mud from inside of a filter bed water board and a
Hitachi machine which was parked near it. Insurance company
contended that the Hitachi Machine was not a motor vehicle and
was insured under the CPM policy, whereby, third party liability
was restricted to 10%. Claimant on the other hand placed reliance
on Rule 2 (cab) of CMV Rules to state that an excavator was
covered under the definition of a motor vehicle. Reliance was also
placed on the decision of Supreme Court in Bose Abraham v. State
of Kerala , AIR 2001 SC 835, where it was held that road rollers
are motor vehicles for the purpose of MV Act. Relevant paragraph
of the decision in Bose Abraham ( supra ) is extracted as under:
“ We hold that the excavators and road rollers are
motor vehicles for the purpose of the Motor
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 15 of 25

Vehicles Act and they are registered under that
Act. The High Court has noticed the admission of
the appellants that the excavators and road
rollers are suitable for use on roads. However,
the contention put forth now is that they are
intended for use in the enclosed premises. Merely
because a motor vehicle is put to a specific use
such as being confined to an enclosed premises,
will not render the same to be a different kind of
vehicle. Hence, in our view, the High Court has
correctly decided the matter and the impugned
order does not call for any interference by us.
However, the question whether any motor vehicle
has entered into a local area to attract tax under
the Entry Tax Act or any concession given under
the local Sales Tax Act will have to be dealt with
in the course of assessment arising under the
Entry Tax Act. ”
(emphasis added)

The Karnataka High Court noted that explanation to Rule 2 (cab) of
CMV Rules, makes it clear that a construction equipment vehicle
shall be a non-transport vehicle and driving on the road, which is
incidental to the main off-highway function, would be for a short
duration. Therefore, the Court held that the machinery was covered
under the definition of construction equipment vehicle under Rule 2
(cab) of CMV Rules. As per their limited liability, the Insurance
Company was held liable to pay 10% of the sum insured, however,
recovery rights were granted in view of the decision in National
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Swaran Singh AIR 2004 SC 1531.
(iii) In Ranganath C. v. M/s. Sany Heavy Industry India Pvt.
Ltd. 2023:KHC:24666, the insurance policy in question was a CPM
policy issued for a Motor Taradar (JCB) which was registered as a
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 16 of 25

category of Motor Taradar . It was noted that the insurance policy
had been issued for machineries/equipments after a contract of
insurance was executed with the owner. The Karnataka High Court
also noted the exclusion under clause (h) limiting public liability. It
was held that the third-party liability endorsement was only with
respect to third party damage caused at the location mentioned in
the insurance policy and not while it is in transit from one location
to another. The decision in Tara Chanda ( supra ) was distinguished,
since the offending vehicle in that case was a mobile crane attached
to a heavy goods vehicle and it was considered to be both a
construction equipment vehicle and a heavy goods vehicle.
However, there was no evidence in this case whether the motor
taradar was a heavy goods vehicle. Since premium had not been
paid for covering risk for third-party when the machinery was in
transit, the liability was fastened on the owner.
(iv) The Karnataka High Court in Munilakshmma v. ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. 2023:KHC:24741 was
dealing with the CPM Policy issued in respect of a lorry . Extra
premium had been paid towards covering third party risk and
liability had been fastened on the Insurance Company by MACT.
Challenging this finding, the Insurance Company relied upon the
CPM policy, which had not been issued under the MV Act, but was
a pure contractual policy. The Karnataka High Court held that a
contractual policy is different from a statutory policy and even
though the concrete mixer is fitted with the lorry and is movable
from place to place, the owner was supposed to purchase an
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 17 of 25

insurance policy under the provisions of MV Act to cover risk
towards third party as per Section 147 of MV Act. The exclusion
provided in clause (h) of the CPM policy was noted and the owner
was stated to be bound by these terms and conditions. Insurance
Company’s appeal was allowed and the liability was then fixed on
the owner.
(v) In Manjunatha v. Sri Ravi & Ors. MFA 12091/2011 a
th
decision delivered on 13 April 2024, the Division Bench of
Karnataka High Court was dealing with an accident where a JCB
had dashed into the claimant while he was carrying out work on the
road. A claim petition was subsequently filed for injuries sustained.
Insurance Company contended that the vehicle in question was a
JCB/Excavator/Construction Equipment and therefore, is not
covered under within the definition of light motor vehicle (‘ LMV ’)
under Section 2 (21) of MV Act. Additionally, it was contended that
the driver was not carrying a valid driving license since no separate
endorsement was issued. Aside from the issue of license, the issue
before the Court was whether such a vehicle is a transport vehicle
or not.
Relying on Section 2 (47) of MV Act which defines a transport
vehicle, the Court concluded that the vehicle in question was not
covered within the definition. Further, relying on the explanation
for Rule 2 (ca) of CMV Rules [ subsequently renumbered as Rule
2(cab) ] the Court concluded that the construction equipment is a
non-transport vehicle and the class or category of the vehicle must
be understood first. It was therefore held that the JCB does not
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 18 of 25

come within the definition of Section 2 (21) of MV Act, but is ‘ a
motor vehicle of special description ’. On the issue of liability, it
was held that the driver was not competent to drive the said vehicle,
merely because he held an LMV license, therefore, the Insurance
Company was held to satisfy the amount in favour of the claimant,
with liberty to recover from the owner. This case pertinently does
not throw any light on the nature of the insurance policy, which was
issued by the Insurance Company. SLP (C) Diary No. 51336/2025
was preferred against this order, however, the said petition is still
pending before the Supreme Court.
(vi) United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Jagat & Ors.
th
2024:DHC:2974, delivered on 15 April 2024 by a predecessor
Bench of this Court was a review petition filed by the registered
owner challenging rights of recovery granted against them by
th
judgment dated 28 July 2017. The Insurance Company had issued
a CPM policy for a crane which was stationed for loading and
unloading of empty containers at the CCI Empty Yard,
Tughlakabad, Delhi. Upholding the Tribunal’s finding that the
crane was a motor vehicle within the definition of MV Act, this
Court upheld the recovery rights granted to the Insurance Company
on account of fake driving license of the driver of crane. While the
review petition was preferred by the owner and only limited to the
extent of grant of recovery rights against them, in the decision
th
delivered on 15 April 2024, this Court did not interfere with the
previous finding on the nature of insurance policy, as well as, the
grant of recovery rights.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 19 of 25

36. It would also be instructive to assess the judgment of Division
Bench of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla in M/s. Italian-Thai Development
Public Company Limited v. State of HP 2016 SCC OnLine HP 2768
where the question before the Court was whether construction equipment
vehicles such as, water tankers, heavy hyva, farm tractors, transit
mixtures and other heavy machines do not fall within the scope and
purview of the definition of motor vehicles and are thus exempted from
tax. Relying upon Rule 2(ca) of CMV Rules [ subsequently renumbered
as Rule 2(cab) ], it was stated that these construction equipment vehicles
have been termed as ‘non-transport vehicles’ which has been further
defined under Rule 2(h) of CMV Rules. Basis Rule 2(h), the High Court
noted that nonetheless they will be motor vehicles within the definition
of Section 2(28) of MV Act. Even if driving on the road is incidental and
less than 50 kmph, only those vehicles which are purely off-highway
construction and not equipped to travel on public roads on their own
were not included in the definition. The Court relied upon various
judgments on the aspect of applicability of tax on such vehicles,
including Bose Abraham ( supra ) and held that construction equipment
vehicles fall within the definition of ‘ motor vehicles ’ and could not claim
any exemption against imposition of tax. Once these vehicles have been
registered as motor vehicles, there cannot be any reason to state that they
do not fall within the definition of ‘ motor vehicle ’, only because they are
adopted for use in enclosed premises.
37. This Court has perused the judgments relied upon by Ms. Bagga ,
counsel for Insurance Company. The question before the Supreme Court
in Harchand Rai ( supra ) was regarding definition of the term ‘burglary’
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 20 of 25

in the insurance policy and also whether theft should have been preceded
with force or violence as per the terms of insurance policy. Employing a
strict interpretation of the insurance policy, the Court held that no
outside interpretation can be employed while interpreting the terms of a
contract, unless the meaning is ambiguous. The discussion by the
Supreme Court in Chandmull Jain ( supra ) also does not particularly
deal with the issue of a CPM Policy but reinforces the assertion made by
the Insurance Company that interpretation of a contract of insurance
must be strictly restricted to the terms agreed upon between the parties,
without making a new contract.
38. On the basis of the abovementioned documents and statutory
provisions, the Court is of the opinion that the offending vehicle, i.e. a
JCB wheel loader falls within the definition of a construction equipment
vehicle as per the explanation to Rule 2 (cab) of CMV Rules, but
nevertheless falls within the purview of a non-transport vehicle, being a
motor vehicle, as per Rule 2 (h). It would therefore, be covered under the
definition of ‘ motor vehicle ’ under Section 2 (28) of MV Act, since such
a vehicle has the ability to move, has a chassis and is mechanically
propelled and adapted for use upon roads.
39. The next issue then before the Court is whether the insurance
policy did cover such third-party liability resulting from use of this
motor vehicle on the road.
40. At the outset, the CPM policy has not been issued within the
purview of Section 147 of MV Act. The Insurance Policy, being a
Contractors Plant & Machinery Policy ( CPM ), essentially covers
indemnification to any insured property ‘ whilst at the location .’ The
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 21 of 25

exception provided under clause (h) was clear and categorical, stating
that the Insurance Company will not be liable for loss or damage whilst
in transit i.e. public liability will not be covered while the insured vehicle
is on public road.
41. Additionally, to cover third party liability, provided under CPM-3,
the Endorsement covered legal liability for fatal or non-fatal injury to
any persons other than the insured or his own employees. An exclusion
is further provided under this Endorsement stating that the Insurance
Company will not indemnify the insured, if an accident is caused by the
vehicle licensed for general road.
42. In any event, upon a holistic reading, the Court is of the opinion
that the Endorsement under CPM-3 does not cover third party liability
while the insured vehicle was being deployed on the road.
43. The owner clearly chose not to take statutory cover mandated
under Section 146 of MV Act and would be liable in accordance with
law. Therefore, since the offending vehicle was uninsured for the
purposes of movement on roads and the accident occurred while it was
parked on the road, liability would be fastened upon the owner of the
vehicle.
th
44. By order dated 19 January 2024, the Court had issued notice to
the owner, along with directing deposit of the entire awarded amount
along with accrued interest and release of Rs. 7,00,000/- to the claimant.
Thereafter, the owner did not enter appearance before this Court.
45. Accordingly, in the opinion of this Court, the appeal filed by
Insurance Company would have to be allowed, considering that there
was no valid Insurance Policy as provided under Section 147 of MV Act,
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 22 of 25

which prescribes the requirements of the policy and limits of liability.
The owner had a statutory mandate, as per Section 146 of MV Act, to
cover third party risk, which would not be covered within the ambit of
the CPM Policy. Therefore, the Insurance Company would be
exonerated and liability would have to be jointly borne by the owner and
driver.
46. As regards the compensation awarded, alignments shall be made
with respect to the standardization provided by the Constitutional Bench
of Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi ,
(2017) 16 SCC 680. Therefore, future prospects will be awarded at 40%
and not 50%, since the deceased was working in a private job. Loss of
estate and funeral expenses shall be awarded at Rs. 15,000/- each and
loss of consortium shall be awarded at Rs. 40,000/-, since there was only
one claimant.
47. The revised compensation shall be as under:
S. No. Heads Awarded by the
Awarded by this
Tribunal
Court
1 Income of deceased (A) Rs.1,62,750/- Rs. 1,62,750/-
2 Add: Future Prospects (B) Rs. 81,375/- Rs. 65,100/-
3 Less: Personal expenses of
deceased (C)
Rs. 1,22,062.5/-

Rs. 1,13,925/-

4 Loss of dependency (A+B)-
C=D
Rs. 1,22,062.5/- Rs. 1,13,925/-
5 Multiplier (E) 18 18
6 Total loss of dependency (D
x E)= (F)
Rs. 21,97,125/- Rs. 20,50,650/-
7 Medical Expenses (G) Rs. 4,32,137/- Rs. 4,32,137/-
8 Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Rs. 44,000/- Rs. 40,000/-
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 23 of 25

9 Compensation for loss of
estate (I)
Rs. 20,000/- Rs. 15,000/-
10 Compensation towards
funeral expenses (J)
Rs. 20,000/- Rs. 15,000/-
11 Total compensation
(F+G+H+I+J)=K
Rs. 27,13,262/- Rs. 25,52,787/-
12 Rate of Interest Awarded 9% 9%
13 Reduced Compensation Rs. 1,60,475/-

Directions
48. Accordingly, compensation has been reduced by Rs. 1,60,475/-
(‘ reduced compensation ’).
th
49. By order dated 19 January 2024, this Court had directed the
Insurance Company to deposit the entire amount of compensation
(‘ deposited amount ’) before the MACT and further directed release of
Rs. 7,00,000/- to the claimant.
50. Considering that the Insurance Company has been exonerated
from paying compensation, the Insurance Company shall be at liberty to
recover the amount which has already been released to the claimant i.e.
Rs. 7,00,000/- , from the driver and owner. However, the same shall not
be recoverable from the claimant.
51. Balance amount from the deposited amount, along with accrued
interest, shall be refunded to the Insurance Company.
52. The revised compensation, along with accrued interest, shall be
deposited by the owner before the MACT within 4 weeks, which will be
released as lumpsum to the claimant within 2 weeks thereafter.
53. The appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
54. Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
55. Copy of this judgment be sent to the MACT and Bank for
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 24 of 25

information and compliance.
56. Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to the Insurance
Company.
57. Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.


(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 19, 2026/sm/ sp







Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
Signing Date:19.11.2026
15:50:13
MAC.APP.49/2024 Page 25 of 25