Patil Pranjal Lahensingh vs UNION OF INDIA

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi

O.A. No.4634/2024
MA No.2827/2026

Order reserved on : 06.10.2026
Order pronounced on: 04.11.2026

Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J)


Patil Pranjal Lahensingh, IAS, Group 'A',
Aged About 36 Years,
D/o Sh. L.B. Patil,
R/o 16/11, Rajpur Road,
Civil Lines, New Delhi-110054.
…Applicant

(By Advocate : Ms. Priyanka Bhardwaj with Shri M.K.
Bhardwaj)


Versus

1. Union of India,
through its Secretary,
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions,
Department of Personnel & Training,
North Block, New Delhi-110001


2. The Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs,
Govt. of India, North Block,
New Delhi-110001


3. The Addl. Secretary (U.T.)
Ministry of Home Affairs,
Govt. of India, North Block,
New Delhi-110001

4. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
through its Chief Secretary,
New Secretariat, I.P. Estate,
New Delhi.

Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
...Respondents
(By Advocate : Shri Gyanendra Singh)

2
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

(ORDER)
The applicant is an IAS officer of the 2017 batch
who suffers from 100% visual loss due to absolute
stage secondary glaucoma, anterior staphyloma, and
recurrent corneal erosions in both eyes, having had no
perception of light since childhood. Initially allocated to
the Kerala cadre, her request for an inter-cadre
transfer was accepted on 21.05.2018 under the
Physically Handicapped Policy dated 14.02.2014,
allowing her to join the AGMUT cadre in Delhi in early
2020 to access essential medical and social support.
On 12.09.2024, the Ministry of Home Affairs abruptly
transferred her from Delhi to Arunachal Pradesh, a
hard station, which was followed by a relieving order
on 17.10.2024. The applicant submitted
representations highlighting that she requires
continuous specialized medical care under an
ophthalmologist at Sitaram Bhartia Institute and
ICARE Eye Hospital, Noida, alongside regular visits to
AIIMS, and that her sole caregiver grandmother had
unfortunately passed away on 10.09.2024. Although
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
she approached the Tribunal in OA No. 4127/2024 in
an earlier round of litigation, where the Tribunal
directed the respondents on 22.10.2024 to pass a

3
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

reasoned speaking order on her representation, the
respondents mechanically rejected it on 06.11.2024.
2. The learned counsel for the applicant contended
that her transfer violates Section 20 of the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, DoP&T Office
Memorandum dated 31.03.2014 which exempts
persons with disabilities from rotational transfers, and
the fundamental right to equality under Article 14. In
this context he relied upon the DOP&T OM dated
31.03.2024 and the judgment of Hon’ble High Court in
the case of R.S. Chaudhary Vs. State of M.P. as well
as OM dated 08.10.2018.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that
the respondents have completely ignored the fact that
the applicant would not be able to get proper medical
facilities as required by her in view of the opinion of the
medical experts and that the applicant was transferred
to Delhi keeping in view her peculiar medical condition
as well as requirement of regular support without any
language barrier and the she will be facing same
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
hardship in a hard station like Arunachal Pradesh. It
is further contended that the order dated 06.11.2024

4
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

was served upon the applicant through whatsapp and
that too after repeated requests.
4. Learned counsel for the applicant relied heavily
on the following judgments in support of his
contentions to establish that treating unequals as
equals violates the Constitution and that the executive
approach toward the differently abled must be
proactive, liberal, and relief-oriented :
(i) Decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in
WP(C) No.7927/2020 titled Anju Mehra Vs. Canara
Bank & Ors;
(ii) Decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in LPA
No.133/2024 and C.M. No.9793/2024 titled Ircon
International Ltd. Vs. Bhavneet Singh;
(iii) Decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
I.A.No.10/2015 in WP(C) No.116/1998 titled Justice
Sunanda Bhandare Foundation Vs. Union of India
and Another.
5. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
that the transfer of the applicant from Delhi to
Arunachal Pradesh via orders dated 12.09.2024 and
17.10.2024 is entirely legal, valid, and in public

5
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

interest. Learned counsel for the respondents
contended that at the time of processing her inter-
cadre transfer from Kerala to AGMUT in 2018, both
DoP&T on 23.03.2018 and senior MHA officials during
an interaction on 15.05.2018 explicitly informed the
applicant that the AGMUT cadre comprises diverse
State and Union Territory segments across the
country, requiring officers to serve in any part of the
cadre rather than any single segment indefinitely. The
respondents stated that the applicant knowingly
acquiesced to these conditions and reiterated AGMUT
as her first preference. Furthermore, under the
Transfer/Posting Guidelines for AGMUT officers of
2016, senior-scale IAS officers are required to complete
a minimum tenure in hard areas, and direct-recruit
officers promoted to the Senior Time Scale on
01.01.2021 were invariably due for movement from
regular category A segments to hard category B
segments. Since the applicant spent nearly four years
exclusively in Delhi with zero tenure in category B
segments, her transfer was necessitated by
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
administrative requirements and a deficit of senior
scale officers in Arunachal Pradesh. The respondents
argue that DoP&T Office Memorandum dated

6
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

31.03.2014 protects persons with disabilities only
"subject to administrative constraints," which does not
bar the movement of officers within a joint cadre on
administrative grounds. Complying with the Tribunal's
direction of 22.10.2024, the MHA thoroughly reviewed
her representations and passed a detailed speaking
order on 06.11.2024 before rejecting her request and
directing her to report to Arunachal Pradesh.
6. Furthermore, the transfer order of the applicant
was issued on the basis of Transfer/Posting
Guidelines, 2016 issued by the respondent Ministry.
Para 7 of the said Guidelines stipulates that Senior
Scale IAS officers shall complete a minimum tenure of
five years (in 2 tenures) in Category ‘B’ segments of the
cadre. Since joining the AGMUT cadre on 13.01.2020,
the applicant has been posted only in Delhi. Her total
tenure in Category ‘B’ segments (other than Delhi) of
the cadre was NIL. Para 17 of the same Guidelines,
2016 allows the MHA to transfer or post any AIS
officer of the Joint AGMUT cadre to any of the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
constituent segment at any time on administrative
grounds or public interest. It is also not the case of the
applicant that her representations were not considered.
Her first representation was considered and rejected

7
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

and the second representation preferred by her was
considered and rejected pursuant to filing of the OA
No.4127/2024.
7. In her rejoinder, the applicant refuted the counter
affidavit filed by the respondents, asserting that their
reliance on routine transfer guidelines cannot override
statutory protections and constitutional mandates. She
pointed out that the respondents themselves admitted
in their pleadings that she originally sought the
AGMUT cadre to secure a posting in Delhi as a
metropolitan city equipped with necessary medical
infrastructure and accessibility for visually impaired
individuals, thereby invalidating their claim that she
willingly consented to being posted to remote hard
stations. The applicant emphasized that mere reference
to executive transfer policies cannot create an estoppel
that strips a 100% visually impaired officer of her
statutory rights under the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities Act, 2016. She reiterated that the
respondents failed to establish any genuine service
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
exigency or administrative constraint that justifies
sending a completely blind officer to Arunachal
Pradesh while disregarding specialized medical advice
and the absence of a family support system.

8
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

Terminating her continuous presence in Delhi directly
threatens her ongoing medical management and
violates the benevolent objectives of disability
legislation. Consequently, she maintained that the
rejection order dated 06.11.2024 is mechanical,
arbitrary, and violative of Articles 14, 16, and 21 of the
Constitution, warranting the complete setting aside of
the transfer and relieving orders.
ANALYSIS
8. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at
length and perused the pleadings, the impugned orders
dated 12.09.2024, 17.10.2024 and 06.11.2024, the
medical record and the judgments cited at the Bar.
9. The following questions arise for consideration:
(i) Whether, while transferring an officer with a
benchmark disability, the cadre controlling authority is
bound by Section 20 of the Rights of Persons with
Disabilities Act, 2016 (hereinafter "the 2016 Act") and
the instructions of the Department of Personnel and
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Training on posting and transfer of persons with
disabilities, or whether the Transfer/Posting Guidelines
for IAS/IPS officers of the Joint AGMUT Cadre, 2016

9
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

(hereinafter "the Guidelines, 2016") operate
independently of them;
(ii) Whether the transfer of the applicant is a routine or
rotational transfer within the meaning of those
instructions;
(iii) Whether the respondents have established
administrative constraints justifying the departure
from those instructions, and on whom the burden lies;
(iv) Whether the order dated 06.11.2024 reflects a
genuine and individualised consideration of the
applicant's case, as required by the duty of reasonable
accommodation; and
(v) Whether the applicant is precluded, by her
acceptance of the AGMUT cadre in 2018, from claiming
the protection she now seeks.
The general law on transfer
10. The law on judicial review of transfer orders is well
settled. Transfer is an incident of service; an employee
holding a transferable post has no vested right to
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
remain at a particular station; and courts and
tribunals do not interfere with a transfer order unless
it is vitiated by mala fides, is made by an incompetent

10
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

authority, or is in violation of a statutory provision or
of an instruction having statutory force. These
principles have been laid down, among others, in
Shilpi Bose v. State of Bihar, 1991 Supp (2) SCC
Union of India v. S.L. Abbas
659, , (1993) 4 SCC 357,
and S.C. Saxena v. Union of India , (2006) 9 SCC 583,
and have been reiterated by the Hon'ble High Court of
Delhi in Shalu Pruthi v. Kendriya Vidyalaya
Sangathan , W.P.(C) 3022/2026, decided on
25.03.2026 (paragraph 16). We respectfully follow
them.
11. Learned counsel for the applicant also relied on
R.S. Chaudhary v. State of M.P., ILR [2007] MP 1329,
a decision of a Division Bench of the High Court of
Madhya Pradesh, it holds that where a transfer is
alleged to be contrary to the transfer policy, the
employee's remedy in the first instance is a
representation to the competent authority. The
applicant has availed that remedy, and her
representation was decided pursuant to the directions
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
of this Tribunal in O.A. No. 4127/2024. The decision
therefore does not stand in the way of the present
application, but neither does it advance the applicant's
case on merits.

11
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

The statutory overlay in the case of persons with
disabilities
12. The general principles noticed above do not,
however, exhaust the inquiry where the employee is a
person with disability. Parliament enacted the 2016 Act
to give effect to the United Nations Convention on the
Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Section 20 of the
2016 Act, so far as relevant, reads:
"20. Non-discrimination in employment.-
(1) No Government establishment shall discriminate
against any person with disability in any matter
relating to employment: ...
(2) Every Government establishment shall provide
reasonable accommodation and appropriate barrier
free and conducive environment to employees with
disability.
(3) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely
on the ground of disability.
xxx xxx xxx
(5) The appropriate Government may frame policies
for posting and transfer of employees with
disabilities."
Section 3 of the 2016 Act guarantees equality and
non-discrimination; Section 2(y) defines reasonable
accommodation; and Rule 8(3)(c) of the Rights of
Persons with Disabilities Rules, 2017 requires the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
equal opportunity policy of every establishment to
provide for preference in transfer and posting. The

12
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

relevant sections are reproduced for sake of
convenience:
3. (1) The appropriate Government shall ensure
that the persons with disabilities enjoy the right to
equality, life with dignity and respect for his or
her integrity equally with others.
(2) The appropriate Government shall take steps
to utilise the capacity of persons with disabilities
by providing appropriate environment.
(3) No person with disability shall be
discriminated on the ground of disability, unless it
is shown that the impugned act or omission is a
proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
(4) No person shall be deprived of his or her
personal liberty only on the ground of disability.
(5) The appropriate Government shall take
necessary steps to ensure reasonable
accommodation for persons with disabilities.
2(y) “reasonable accommodation” means
necessary and appropriate modification and
adjustments, without imposing a disproportionate
or undue burden in a 4 particular case, to ensure
to persons with disabilities the enjoyment or
exercise of rights equally with others;
13. In exercise of the policy-making function now
recognised by Section 20(5), the Department of
Personnel and Training issued Office Memorandum No.
36035/3/2013-Estt.(Res) dated 31.03.2014 laying
down guidelines for persons with disabilities already in
Government employment. Part ‘H’ thereof reads:
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
"H. Preference in transfer/posting. As far as
possible, the persons with disabilities may be
exempted from the rotational transfer
policy/transfer and be allowed to continue in the
same job, where they would have achieved the
desired performance. Further, preference in place of
posting at the time of transfer/promotion may be
given to the persons with disability subject to the

13
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

administrative constraints. The practice of
considering choice of place of posting in case of
persons with disabilities may be continued. To the
extent feasible, they may be retained in the same
job, where their services could be optimally
utilised."
The same instruction has been reiterated, in identical
terms, in O.M. No. 36035/44/2023-Estt(Res-II) dated
02.02.2024. The reference in paragraph 2 above to an
O.M. dated "31.03.2024" is to be read as a reference to
the O.M. 5 dated 31.03.2014, as reiterated on
02.02.2024. The O.M. dated 08.10.2018, also relied
upon by the applicant, concerns Government servants
who are caregivers of dependants with disability; it
does not in terms apply to the applicant, who is herself
the person with disability, though it reflects the same
policy.
14. Two features of Part ‘H’ deserve notice. First, it has
two distinct limbs: the first exempts persons with
disabilities from rotational transfer "as far as possible"
and favours their retention in the same job; the second
gives them preference as to the place of posting when a
transfer or promotion does take place, subject to
administrative constraints. The respondents, in
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
paragraph 5 of their reply as recorded above, read the
qualification "subject to administrative constraints" as
governing the whole instruction. That is not what the

14
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

instruction says, though we shall assume in their
favour that the exemption under the first limb also
yields to genuine administrative compulsion. Secondly,
Part H is not a concession granted as a matter of grace.
It is the means by which the Government discharges,
in the sphere of posting and transfer, its statutory
obligation under Section 20(2) to provide reasonable
accommodation.
The decisions of the Hon'ble High Court and the
Hon'ble Supreme Court
15. The interplay between the general law on transfer
and the 2016 Act was examined by a Division Bench of
the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in Ircon International
Ltd. v. Bhavneet Singh , LPA 133/2024, decided on
18.07.2024 (2024:DHC:5269-DB). The Division Bench
accepted that the scope of interference in transfer
matters is narrow (paragraph 3), but held that those
principles apply to persons with disabilities subject to
the caveats contained in the 2016 Act, the Rules and
the Office Memoranda (paragraphs 3.1 and 3.2). It
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
identified the factors an employer must keep in view,
including that the employee should ordinarily be
exempted from rotational transfer and should be

15
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

posted where the required medical and infrastructural
facilities are readily available (paragraph 4). Most
importantly, it held that when a transfer order
concerning a person with disability is passed, the
employer bears the burden to prove that it was
triggered by administrative exigencies or constraints,
and that a vague averment does not discharge that
burden (paragraph 37):
“37. Thus, when a transfer order is passed concerning
a differently-abled person, the burden to prove that it
was triggered due to administrative exigencies or
constraints would be on the employer. In this particular
case, the employer, i.e., IRCON IL, has not been able to
discharge that burden. In our view, a vague averment
that the five (5) persons [whose names are mentioned
in paragraph fourteen (14) above] were assigned other
jobs and hence could not be transferred to Bilaspur
was insufficient to discharge the burden placed on
IRCON IL. Besides the employees referred to in
paragraph fourteen (14) above, the respondent has
also taken the position that several other persons who
have spent five (5) years or more in one location and
therefore, could have been transferred instead of him-
is an assertion answered by taking recourse to a bald
rebuttal.”
The Division Bench further held that the Office
Memoranda dated 31.03.2014 and 02.02.2024 bind
even a Central Public Sector Enterprise (paragraph 40),
and that any contractual stipulation as to transfer
stands subordinate to the 2016 Act and the Rules
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
framed under it (paragraphs 43 to 44.1). The learned
Single Judge's order setting aside the transfer of the

16
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

employee from Delhi to Bilaspur was affirmed with
costs.
16. The same principle has since been applied by
another Division Bench of the Hon'ble High Court in
Defence Research and Development Organisation v.
Dr. Deepti Bhardwaj , W.P.(C) 12454/2026, decided on
03.09.2026, which declined to interfere with an order
of this Tribunal staying the transfer of an officer who
was the caregiver of a child with benchmark disability.
The High Court held that the onus to establish
organisational constraints lies on the employer; that
where the transfer order is silent as to such
constraints and states only that it is made in public
interest, the deficiency cannot be supplied by
averments in an affidavit filed in the litigation,
following Commissioner of Police, Bombay v.
Gordhandas Bhanji , 1951 SCC 1088 and Mohinder
Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, (1978) 1
SCC 405 (paragraph 14); and that the Office
Memoranda, being a step in aid of reasonable
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
accommodation under Section 2(y), must be
interpreted expansively and given full effect, in the light
of Vikash Kumar v. Union Public Service
Commission , (2021) 5 SCC 370, Rajive Raturi v.

17
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

Union of India, (2024) 16 SCC 654 and In Re:
Recruitment of Visually Impaired in Judicial
Services , 2025 SCC OnLine SC 481. Hon'ble High
Court in Dr. Deepti Bhardwaj , held thus,
“17. We have to be mindful, in a case such as this, that
we are dealing with the applicability of the RPWD Act.
The Supreme Court has repeatedly emphasized in
Vikash Kumar v. Union Public Service Commission
(2021) 5 SCC 370 that the principle of reasonable
accommodation which, permeates the RPWD Act and
has exhorted on courts to ensure that, while they apply
the principles and the provisions of the RPWD Act, the
goal of reasonable accommodation is always borne in
mind. The immunity from transfer available to parents of
a dependent child suffering from benchmark disability,
as provided in the aforenoted DOPT OMs is clearly a
step-in aid of reasonable accommodation as envisaged
by Section 2(y) of the RPWD Act. It has, therefore, to be
interpreted expansively and given full scope and effect.
Any restrictive interpretation by us would be doing
violence not only to the provisions of the RPWD Act but
also to the philosophy underling the judgments of the
Supreme Court in Vikash Kumar , as well as Rajiv
Raturi v. Union of India (2024) 16 SCC 654 and
Recruitment of Visually Impaired in Judicial
Services Re: 2025 SCC OnLine SC 481.”
17. The constitutional basis of these principles was
explained by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Net Ram
Yadav v. State of Rajasthan, (2022) 15 SCC 81. Their
Lordships observed that one of the principal
disadvantages of a person with disability is the
inability to move freely and easily; that the object of
instructions permitting such persons to be posted at
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
places of their choice is to enable them to be posted
where assistance, whether of family or of institutions,
is readily available; and that a benefit so conferred

18
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

cannot be rendered otiose by the manner of its
application (paragraph 31). Their Lordships also held
that instructions for the benefit of persons with
disabilities must receive a purposive interpretation in
harmony with the Convention (paragraph 29), and
concluded that the treatment of unequals as equals,
ignoring their special needs, violates Article 14 of the
Constitution (paragraph 33).
18. In Justice Sunanda Bhandare Foundation v.
Union of India , I.A. No. 10 of 2015 in W.P.(C) No. 116
of 1998, decided on 25.04.2017 ([2017] 3 SCR 723),
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while monitoring
implementation of disability legislation, reiterated its
earlier observation in Justice Sunanda Bhandare
Foundation v. Union of India , (2014) 14 SCC 383
that in matters of providing relief to the differently
abled, the approach and attitude of the executive must
be liberal and relief oriented and not obstructive or
lethargic (paragraph 4), and emphasised that under
the 2016 Act the responsibilities of the State have
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
grown (paragraph 24). This sets the standard against
which the respondents' handling of the applicant's
representation must be judged.

19
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

19. Learned counsel for the applicant also cited Anju
Mehra v. Canara Bank (2020:DHC:3183). That
decision has been noticed in Ircon (paragraph 32.5) as
holding that the general law on transfer has been
overtaken by the 2016 Act in matters concerning
persons with disabilities. Since the principle is in any
event established by the decisions discussed above, we
do not find it necessary to rest our conclusions on it.
Question (i): The Guidelines, 2016 and the
statutory obligation
20. The Guidelines, 2016 are administrative
instructions issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs as
the cadre controlling authority for postings within the
Joint AGMUT cadre. They serve a legitimate purpose,
namely to ensure that no segment of the cadre is
starved of officers and that service in hard areas is
shared. But they are executive instructions; they do
not and cannot override a statute. The obligation in
Section 20(2) of the 2016 Act binds every Government
establishment, including the respondent Ministry, and
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
the instructions of the Department of Personnel and
Training under Part H are the Government's own policy
for discharging that obligation in matters of posting. If,

20
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

as held in Ircon , those instructions bind a public
sector enterprise, they bind a Ministry of the
Government of India a fortiori. Paragraphs 7 and 17 of
the Guidelines, 2016 must therefore be read and
applied subject to Section 20 of the 2016 Act and Part
H of the O.M. dated 31.03.2014. Where an officer with
a benchmark disability is concerned, the power under
paragraph 17 to post an officer to any segment at any
time is not an unguided power; it must be exercised
consistently with the duty of reasonable
accommodation.
Question (i) is answered accordingly.
Question (ii): Nature of the transfer
21. On the respondents' own showing, the applicant
was moved because the Guidelines, 2016 require
senior scale officers to complete a minimum tenure in
Category B segments; because direct recruit officers
promoted to the Senior Time Scale on 01.01.2021 were
"invariably due" for movement from Category A to
Category B segments; and because her Category B
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
tenure was nil. A movement made because an officer
has completed a tenure in one category and is due,
along with her batch, for a tenure in another category

21
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

is the very definition of a routine or rotational transfer.
The applicant's transfer is not a transfer on promotion,
nor a transfer on any ground personal to her. It is
precisely the class of transfer from which Part H says
persons with disabilities should, as far as possible, be
exempted. The respondents cannot, in the same
breath, justify the transfer by the rotational tenure
requirement and contend that the protection against
rotational transfer does not apply.
Question (ii) is answered in favour of the applicant.
Question (iii): Administrative constraints and the
burden of proof
22. The respondents have pleaded two matters as
constituting administrative constraints: that the
applicant had no tenure in Category B segments, and
that there was a deficit of senior scale officers in
Arunachal Pradesh.
23. The first is not an administrative constraint at all.
It is the very rule from which the applicant claims
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
exemption. To treat the requirement of the rotational
policy as the constraint that defeats the exemption
from that policy would render Part H meaningless,

22
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

which is the outcome the Hon'ble Supreme Court
cautioned against in Net Ram Yadav (paragraph 31).
24. As to the second, the burden lay on the
respondents (Ircon , paragraph 37; Deepti Bhardwaj,
paragraph 14). Nothing has been placed before us to
show the sanctioned and working strength of senior
scale officers in the Arunachal Pradesh segment, the
number of vacancies, the number of senior scale
officers in Category A segments with nil or deficient
Category B tenure who were available for posting, or
why the deficit could be met only by moving the one
officer in the batch who is totally blind. Nor is there
any averment that no post was available for the
applicant in Delhi or in any other Category A segment.
A bare assertion of a deficit, unsupported by
particulars, is the kind of vague averment that Ircon
held insufficient.
Question (iii) is answered against the respondents.
Question (iv): The order dated 06.11.2024 and
reasonable accommodation
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
25. This Tribunal, in O.A. No. 4127/2024, directed the
respondents to decide the applicant's representation by
a reasoned and speaking order. A speaking order in a

23
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

case of this nature is not satisfied by restating the
transfer policy. Reasonable accommodation is, by its
nature, individual; what is required is an assessment
of what this officer needs in order to discharge her
duties with dignity and equally with others, and
whether that need can be met consistently with the
requirements of the cadre ( Vikash Kumar v. Union
Public Service Commission , (2021) 5 SCC 370;
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal v. Union of India, (2023) 2
SCC 209).
26. The material before the respondents was specific
and weighty. The applicant has had no perception of
light since childhood. She is under continuous
specialised care at the Sitaram Bhartia Institute and
ICARE Eye Hospital, Noida, and visits AIIMS regularly.
Her sole caregiver, her grandmother, died on
10.09.2024, two days before the transfer order was
issued. Her inter-cadre transfer from Kerala to AGMUT
was itself accepted in 2018 under a policy for
physically handicapped officers, in recognition of her
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
need for medical and social support, and the
respondents admit in their pleadings that she sought
the AGMUT cadre for a posting in Delhi on that
account.

24
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

27. The respondents have not placed any material to
show that specialised ophthalmic care of the kind the
applicant requires, or any support system substituting
for that which she has in Delhi, is available at her
place of posting in Arunachal Pradesh. Applying to a
totally blind officer, without individual assessment, the
same tenure rule that applies to able-bodied officers is
the treatment of unequals as equals which the Hon'ble
Supreme Court held to be violative of Article 14 in Net
Ram Yadav (paragraph 33). The order dated
06.11.2024 is therefore unsustainable.
Question (iv) is answered in favour of the applicant.
Question (v): Acquiescence and estoppel
28. The respondents contend that the applicant was
told in 2018 that the AGMUT cadre is a multi-segment
cadre and that she nonetheless chose it. We are unable
to accept that this precludes her. First, a statutory
right cannot be waived by acceptance of a general
transfer liability; any such term is subordinate to the
2016 Act (Ircon, paragraphs 43 to 44.1). Secondly,
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
what the applicant accepted was membership of the
cadre, which carries liability to serve in any segment; it
was not, and could not be, an agreement that the cadre

25
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

controlling authority would disregard Section 20 and
Part H when exercising that power in her case. Thirdly,
the respondents themselves accept that the inter-cadre
transfer was granted under a policy for physically
handicapped officers and that the applicant sought
AGMUT in order to be in Delhi for medical reasons. The
plea of estoppel fails.
The decisions relied upon by the respondents
29. Reliance was placed on behalf of the respondents
on the settled principles noticed in paragraph 10
above. We have applied them. In Shalu Pruthi (supra) ,
on which the respondents may draw support, the
Hon'ble High Court accepted the obligation of
reasonable accommodation but held that its
applicability depends on the factual foundation laid,
and the petitioner there had not established a
benchmark disability or the threshold under the
applicable policy (paragraphs 23 and 24). The present
case is the converse: the applicant's 100% visual
disability is certified and is not disputed. That decision
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
is clearly distinguishable.



26
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

Protection of the applicant's career
30. We are conscious that completion of tenure in hard
areas may be relevant under the Guidelines, 2016 or
otherwise for central deputation, empanelment and
promotion. Section 20(3) of the 2016 Act provides that
no promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the
ground of disability. An officer who is not posted to a
Category B segment because of her disability cannot be
prejudiced in her career for not having completed such
tenure. Appropriate directions are therefore necessary.
CONCLUSION
31. In the result, the Original Application is allowed in
the following terms:
(a) The transfer order dated 12.09.2024, insofar as it
relates to the applicant, the relieving order dated
17.10.2024 and the order dated 06.11.2024 rejecting
the applicant's representation are quashed and set
aside.
(b) The respondents shall continue the applicant in, or
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
as the case may be repost her to, the NCT of Delhi
segment of the Joint AGMUT cadre, within four weeks
of receipt of a certified copy of this order. The
intervening period, if any, shall be regularised in

27
Item 15(C-V)
OA No.4634/2024

accordance with the rules, treating the applicant as not
at fault.
(c) Should any administrative necessity hereafter arise
to post the applicant outside Delhi, the respondents
shall not do so except by a reasoned order, passed
after hearing her, which records the specific
administrative constraint, considers her medical
condition and support requirements on current
medical evidence, and examines whether she can be
accommodated in Delhi or in another Category A
segment where comparable specialised ophthalmic care
and support are available.
(d) The applicant's non-completion of tenure in
Category B segments, on account of her disability,
shall not be held against her for the purposes of
promotion, empanelment, central deputation or any
other service benefit.
All the pending MAs, if any, shall stand disposed
of. There shall be no order as to costs.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR



(Rajveer Singh Verma)
Member (J)

„rk/py‟