ROHINI MAHAJAN AND ORS vs KENDRIYA VIDYALAYA SANGATHAN (KVS)
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No. 04 - Court 3
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench
New Delhi
OA No. 4568/2026
MA No. 5872/2026
MA No. 5873/2026
th
This the 13 day of November, 2026
Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Sanjeeva Kumar, Member(A)
1. ROHINI MAHAJAN, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV
BADDOWAL; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 20.09.2003) C/O
DINESH GUPTA R/O H.NO. 51-B, VIKAS NAGAR, NEAR GEETA
MANDIR, BASANT AVENUE, LUDHIANA, PUNJAB-141013
2. ARTY DWIVEDI, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at PM SHRI KV
NO. 2 JALAHALLI EAST, BENGALURU; Date of joining KVS as
PRT: 24.01.2009) W/O VINEET KUMAR MISHRA R/O TOWER 13,
FLAT NO. 202, 2ND FLOOR, SHRIRAM SAMEEKSHA, NAIDU
LAYOUT, KUVEMPUNAGAR, NEAR GANGAMMA POLICE
STATION, JALAHALLI EAST, BANGALORE NORTH,
BENGALURU, KARNATAKA-560014
3. EKTA PURI, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at PM SHRI KV SSG
CISF SURAJPUR, GREATER NOIDA; Date of joining KVS as PRT:
30.05.2011) W/O KISHORE KUMAR PURI R/O A-149, SECTOR 20,
NEAR POLICE STATION, NOIDA, DISTRICT GAUTAM BUDDHA
NAGAR, UTTAR PRADESH-201301
4. GAGANDEEP KAUR, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV NFR
MALIGAON, GUWAHATI; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 27.03.2009)
C/O LAKHVINDER SINGH R/O D-45, SECOND FLOOR, FATEH
NAGAR, CHOPRA RICKSHAW, TILAK NAGAR, WEST DELHI,
DELHI-110018
5. KAMAL JIT, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at PM SHRI KV 3
BRD AFS CHANDIGARH; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 13.06.2007)
S/O HANS RAJ R/O QUARTER NO. 14, TYPE 2, KV STAFF
QUARTER, 3 BRD, CHANDIGARH-160003
6. KAMLESH, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV NFR
MALIGAON, GUWAHATI; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 27.01.2009)
W/O TAPTESH KUMAR MEENA R/O 428, SHREE YOGENDAR
NAGAR, SITAPURA, SANGANER BAZAR, SANGANER, JAIPUR,
RAJASTHAN-302029
7. KAMLESH ALIAS DIMPLE, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at
KV SECTOR 25 ROHINI, DELHI; Date of joining KVS as PRT:
10.11.2003) C/O NARESH KUMAR R/O FLAT NO. 619, POCKET
GH-4, B-BLOCK, ROHINI HEIGHTS, SECTOR- 29, ROHINI,
SAHIBABAD DAULAT PUR, NORTH WEST DELHI, DELHI-
110042
8. MADHURA HARISH THAKKAR, (Presently working as PRT in KVS
at PM SHRI KV CRPF GANDHINAGAR, GUJARAT; Date of joining
KVS as PRT: 06.11.2007) W/O ANKITKUMAR THAKKAR R/O C/5,
SUNIL SOCIETY, ON KANS, NEAR NIRMAL SOCIETY,
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
2
Item No. 04 - Court 3
MANINAGAR, AHMEDABAD CITY, AHMEDABAD, GUJARAT-
380008
9. NEELAM JAINI, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV
RAIWALA; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 10.09.2009) D/O TEJ
BHAN JAINI R/O A2/414, JAL VAYU TOWER, SECTOR 56,
GURGAON, HARYANA-122011
10. POOJA, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV ONGC JORHAT;
Date of joining KVS as PRT: 10.09.2009) W/O KAMAL KUMAR R/O
HOUSE NO. 46/4, KRISHNA COLONY, BHIWANI, HARYANA-
127021
11. RENU NARWAL @ RENU MALIK, (Presently working as PRT in
KVS at KV IIT GUWAHATI; Date of joining KVS as PRT:
02.02.2009) W/O KAPIL MALIK R/O C-77, SECTOR-56, NOIDA,
DISTRICT GAUTAM BUDDHA NAGAR, UTTAR PRADESH-
201301
12. SUMAN SHARMA, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV
BADDOWAL; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 27.12.2010) W/O AJAY
KUMAR SHARMA R/O HOUSE NO. 30, STREET NO. 1, NEAR
AHLUWALIA COLONY, JAPPAN COLONY, LUDHIANA,
PUNJAB-141008
13. SUNITA DWIVEDI, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV NO. 2
HALWARA; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 11.11.2003) C/O ANIL
KUMAR SHUKLA R/O A-5/434, JANAPRIYA GREENWOOD
APARTMENT, NEW PIPELINE ROAD, CHIKKABANAVARA
LAKE, SOMASHETTI HALLI, CHIKKABANAVARA,
BENGALURU, KARNATAKA-560090
14. RANJU VERMA, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at PM SHRI KV
NO. 1 JALANDHAR CANTT; Date of joining KVS as PRT:
28.01.2009) W/O DINESH DIWAN R/O AM-130, SHALIMAR
BAGH, NORTH WEST DELHI, DELHI-110088
15. WAHEED HUSSAIN KHAN, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at
PM SHRI KV SAWAI MADHOPUR; Date of joining KVS as PRT:
02.02.2009) S/O FARID HUSSAIN KHAN R/O WARD NO. 10,
NEAR MASJID, POST PAWAI, VTC PAWAI, DISTRICT PANNA,
MADHYA PRADESH-488446
16. VIJAY VERMA, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at PM SHRI KV
NO. 2 BAILEY ROAD (FIRST SHIFT), PATNA; Date of joining KVS
as PRT: 13.09.2007) S/O LATE BABU LAL VERMA R/O BIHAR
BUZURG, DISTRICT KUSHINAGAR, UTTAR PRADESH-274401
17. MANOJ PRASAD, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV IIT
PATNA; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 23.02.2005) S/O Deenanath
Prasad R/O West Champaran, Bihar
18. MAHENDRA PRATAP, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV
PACHMARHI; Date of joining KVS as PRT: 22.09.2009) S/O
DEENATH PRASAD R/O D1/204, IIT PATNA CAMPUS, BIHAR-
801106
19. MADHU SINGH, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at PM SHRI KV
NO. 2 BAILEY ROAD (FIRST SHIFT), PATNA; Date of joining KVS
as PRT: 30.03.2009) C/O VINAY KUMAR R/O M2-22-SF, M-
BLOCK, BPTP SECTOR-83, PARK ELITE FLOORS, KHERI
KHURD (114), FARIDABAD, HARYANA-121002
20. SARIKA GUPTA, C/O NIRAJ KUMAR GUPTA R/O A-302,
AJNARA LE GARDEN, SECTOR-16, GREATER NOIDA WEST,
BISHRAKH, DISTRICT GAUTAM BUDDHA NAGAR, UTTAR
PRADESH-201306
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
3
Item No. 04 - Court 3
21. ARPITA CHOUDHURY, D/O PANKAJ KUMAR CHOUDHURY
R/O 132, BARASAT ROAD, OPPOSITE OVERSEAS BANK,
BARRACKPORE, NONACHANDANPUKUR, DISTRICT NORTH
24 PARGANAS, WEST BENGAL-700122
22. MILI MORAL, D/O GANESH KANTI MORAL R/O 4,
NATUNPARA, TEZPUR, DISTRICT SONITPUR, ASSAM-784001
23. SUNIT KUMAR, S/O BRAHM SINGH R/O C-3/6, NEW KONDLI,
EAST DELHI, DELHI-110096
24. VITHTHAL BHEEMAPPA CHATTARAKI, S/O BHEEMAPPA
CHATTARAKI R/O HOUSE NO. 53/B, WARD NO. 35, NEAR
HANUMAN TEMPLE, TREASURY COLONY, BIJAPUR, PO
BIJAPUR AMC, DISTRICT VIJAYAPURA, KARNATAKA-586108
25. SHILPI GUPTA, D/O NARENDER GUPTA R/O H. NO. 2957,
STREET NO. 221, VISHRAM NAGAR, TRI NAGAR, NORTH
WEST DELHI, DELHI-110035
26. AMIT KUMAR SAHOO, (Presently working as PRT in KVS at KV
ARC CHARBATIA, CUTTACK, ODISHA) S/O DADHIBAMAN
SAHOO R/O C/64, SECTOR-9, CDA, CUTTACK, ODISHA
27. JYOTIRMAYAACHARYA, S/0 LAKSHMI PRASAD ACHARYA
R/0 G-230, SECTOR-6, ROURKELA (M), DISTRICT
SUNDERGARH, ODISHA-769002
28. MANASRANJANDARJEE, S/0 MAHENDRA KUMAR DARJEE
R/0 KADOBAHAL,DISTRICT BARGARH,ODISHA-768102
..Applicant(s)
(By Advocates: Mr. Shubham Upadhyay with Mr. Neeraj Yadav
and Ms. Anukriti Bajpai)
Versus
THE COMMISSIONER,
KENDRIYA VIDYALAYA SANGATHAN,
No. 18, Institutional Area,
Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg,
New Delhi - 110016
...Respondent(s)
(By Advocate: Mr. S Rajappa, Mr. R Gowrishankar and Ms. G
Dhivyasri, Mr. Dilbag Singh for R2)
O R D E R(Oral)
Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member(J)
MA No. 5872/2026
For the reasons stated herein, this MA seeking
joining together is allowed.
MA No. 5873/2026
2. For the reasons stated herein, this MA seeking
exemption is allowed, subject to just exceptions.
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
4
Item No. 04 - Court 3
OA No. 4568/2026
3. The present OA has been filed by the applicants,
28 in number, who are serving on the post of PRT. They
claim similar relief, that is, consideration for promotion
to the post of Headmaster.
4. Learned counsel for the applicants would submit
that, in terms of the new Rules notified by the KVS as
recently as March 2025, the applicants had appeared
in and qualified the CTET examination conducted by
the CBSE in February 2026. He would submit that,
having acquired the CTET qualification, the applicants
are now fully eligible for consideration for promotion to
the next post under the regular promotion mode.
5. He would further submit that, after notifying the
amended Rules in March 2025, the respondents had
initiated the process of conducting the DPC and, while
the process was still underway, the applicants had
qualified in the CTET examination. He would submit
that other similarly situated candidates had
approached this Tribunal in OA No. 2264/2026 and
that the Tribunal, vide order dated 07.09.2026, granted
one opportunity to the said candidates to be considered
for promotion. The Tribunal further directed the
respondents to conduct a review DPC and, in case the
applicants were otherwise eligible and within the zone
of consideration, to consider them for promotion.
6. He would submit that the applicants herein, being
junior to the applicants in OA No. 2265/2026, had
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA
5
Item No. 04 - Court 3
approached the respondents by way of a
representation. However, the same is not on record.
7. Considering the above, without going into the
merits of the case, it would be appropriate that the
present OA be disposed of with directions to the
respondents to take a call on the pending
representation. If required, they may also treat the
instant OA as a representation. In case the applicants
are found to be identically situated to those in OA No.
2265/2026, they may be extended similar treatment.
Let this exercise be completed within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of
this order.
8. The OA is disposed of at the admission stage
itself, in the aforesaid terms. No costs.
(Sanjeeva Kumar) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member(A) Member(J)
/ss/
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA