C GANAPATHY vs D/o Post

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 of 10
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00138 of 2021
.
th
DATED WEDNESDAY, THE 04 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
HON'BLE MR. M.L. SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(A)
BETWEEN
C. Ganapathy (age 49),
S/o. R. Chellappan,
No.24/57, Mangal Lake,
Tiruvanmiyur,
Chennai-600 041. ...Applicant
(Advocate: M/s. R. Malaichamy )
Versus
Union of India
Rep. by the General Manager,
Postal Accounts & Finance,
Tamil Nadu Circle,
No.4, Ethiraj Salai,
Chennai-600 008. . …….Respondents
(Advocate: Mr. Su. Srinivasan, Sr. CGSC )
CAV ON : 23 .09.2026

2 of 10
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)

This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following relief:-
“i) To direct the respondent to engage the applicant as Mazdoor and
absorb him as MTS for which he has submitted a representation dated
23.12.2020, also to
ii) direct the respondent to pay the second payment of HRA and
CCA as paid to G. Ellappan and others vide order dated 29.06.2016;
and
iii) To pass such further or other orders as this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper.”
2. The facts in brief are that the applicant was working as a Mazdoor in
Respondent Accounts Office from the year 1993 and was assigned with the duties of
providing drinking water including preparation and supply of hot water in the entire
office. He was engaged as such in the leave places of regular Group-D as per Rule
100 of Vol. IV of Posts and Telegraphs Manual – Establishments.
3. The applicant states that while he was working as Mazdoor, he suffered
backache and shoulder pain due to the nature of work assigned to him. Therefore, he
was unable to discharge the duties so assigned and was taking treatment. Due to his
ill health, he was unable to attend office from 2007 onwards. Thereafter, whenever

3 of 10
he approached the respondent to join duty, he was advised that the authority would
inform him about his joining duty in due course.
4. The outsiders/labourers were entitled to payment of H.R.A and C.C.A. It was
being paid from 1971 onwards. However, all of a sudden, the respondent stopped the
payment of H.R.A. and C.C.A. to the outsiders by order dated 17.7.1998. Therefore,
some of the outsiders who were working in the respondent office approached this
Hon'ble Tribunal and got order in their favour. The respondent complied with the
said order and paid HRA and CCA to them. On learning about the same, the
applicant also filed OA before this Hon'ble Tribunal and as per the order of this
Tribunal, the applicant was paid HRA and CCA accordingly.
5. The applicant recently learnt that one Shri. G. Ellappan and others had
approached this Hon'ble Tribunal for absorption and in compliance of the order of
this Tribunal, they were appointed as MTS. Therefore, the applicant submitted a
representation dated 08.10.2020 to the respondent and requested to appoint him as
MTS by extending the benefit given to others. He also requested to pay the arrears
of HRA and CCA as paid to G.Ellappan and others for second time vide order dated
29.06.2016, but till date there is no response.
6. The applicant states that he has no source of income and he along with his wife
and two children are in penury. The delay in submitting representation was due to the

4 of 10
above said circumstances. He submitted another representation on 23.12.2020
requesting to consider his earlier service and engage him as casual labourer and to
absorb him as MTS by extending the benefit given to G.Ellappan and others, but as
there is no reply, he has filed this application.
7. The respondents have entered appearance through their counsel Mr. Su
Srinivasan and filed their reply stating that the applicant was engaged as Mazdoor
and was assigned with jobs connected with upkeep of the office and staff welfare. He
was doing the job of water carrier for some time and was paid remuneration out of
the contingent fund. Due to personal reasons, he stopped attending the office on his
own accord from 23.07.2005 onwards. After a lapse of five years, he filed OA
No.1505/2011 for payment of arrears of HRA & CCA for his service period as the
same was paid to similarly placed contingent workers. As per the order of this
Tribunal dated 09.12.2011, a sum of Rs.54,563/- was drawn and paid to him vide
Sanction memo dated 21.05.2012. There was no further communication from the
applicant till 23.12.2020 for over 8 years. He gave a representation dated 23.12.2020
seeking appointment as MTS and the said representation which was received during
Covid Lockdown period was disposed of vide Letter dated 31.03.2021.
8. It is evident that the applicant was not inclined to continue in the assigned work
and had only claimed his HRA & CCA benefit belatedly after 6 years and now after a
lapse of 8 years, he has filed this OA with a view to get an appointment as MTS

5 of 10
citing other similarly placed persons. Shri G. Ellappan and 5 others were appointed as
MTS in the Respondent's office after following all due formalities in compliance of
the order of this Tribunal in OA No.420/2010 and other similar OAs filed by the
others during the year 2010. The applicant was not at all a party to the said OA.
Now he is seeking for extension of the benefit to him also which is not feasible as the
order passed in personam in the above case is applicable to the applicants in that
particular case only, unless or otherwise there is a specific instruction to extend the
same to all similarly placed persons. Since the applicant had stopped attending office
on his own from 23.07.2005 onwards and during the period from 01.09.2008 to
17.12.2008, he was not at all working in the respondent's office as a casual labourer,
his present claim for appointment as MTS and for payment of arrears of HRA for the
said period, cannot be entertained. Since the claim of applicant is baseless, time
barred and devoid of any merits, they have prayed for dismissal of the OA.
9. Rejoinder and Reply to rejoinder have been filed by the respective parties
reiterating the averments already made.
10. The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that applicant is similarly
placed Mazdoor as that of G. Ellappan and others. While said G. Ellappan and others
were appointed as MTS as per the direction of this Hon'ble Tribunal, the same benefit
has to be extended to applicant also and relied on the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Inder Pal Yadav and others and submitted that similarly placed

6 of 10
persons should not be compelled to knock the door of the Hon'ble Courts to seek
similar relief. Accordingly, he prayed for allowing this OA by extending the benefit
given to G. Ellappan and others to the applicant also.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the HRA & CCA
arrears for the period from 01.01.1996 to 22.07.2005 to the tune of Rs. 54,563/- has
been granted to applicant vide sanction memo dated 21.05.2012 issued in compliance
of the order of this Hon'ble Tribunal in OA 1505/2011 after obtaining order from the
Circle Office dated 07.03.2012. As applicant had stopped attending office on his own
from 23.07.2005 and during the period between 01.09.2008 to 17.12.2008, he was not
at all working in respondent's office as casual labourer, his present claim for payment
of arrears of HRA for the period from 01.09.2008 to 17.12.2008 cannot be
entertained. Further, as applicant's name is not found in the office records beyond
23.07.2005 and he was not a party in OA No.420/2010 and other similar OAs filed by
the others in the year 2010, he cannot be said to be similarly placed. The
representation dated 23.12.2020 given by the applicant was disposed of on 31.03.21
as per Annexure R-9 but he has filed this OA in February 2021 against UOI
represented by GM (PA&F), Tamilnadu Circle only as sole respondent. It is stated in
the said order that his request to appoint him as MTS cannot be considered based on
existing recruitment rules for the post of MTS. Hence he prayed for dismissal of this
OA.

7 of 10
12. We have heard the submissions made by the learned counsels on both sides and
perused the pleadings and material on record.
13. It is admitted by the applicant that he had stopped attending office due to his ill
health. However, he claims that stopped attending office from 2007 which is
contested by the respondents. It is stated by the respondents that due to personal
reasons, applicant stopped attending the office on his own accord from 23.07.2005
onwards and his name is not finding place in the office records beyond 23.07.2005.
No document is produced by the applicant in respect of his claim.
14. It is stated by the applicant that the respondent stopped payment of H.R.A. and
C.C.A. to the outsiders by order dated 17.7.1998 and some of the outsiders working
in the respondent office obtained favourable order from this Tribunal and the same
has been complied by the respondents. On learning the same, the applicant filed OA
No.1505/2011 for payment of arrears of HRA & CCA for his service period after
lapse of five years and in compliance with the order of this Tribunal, the HRA &
CCA arrears amounting to Rs.54,563/- has been paid to applicant on 21.05.2012 for
the period of his service from 01.01.1996 to 22.07.2005. Had the applicant worked
till 2007 as claimed by him, he would have claimed the same in his OA filed in 2011
or contested the order for not paying the same upto 2007 as claimed. It is only on
23/12/2020, after lapse of more than 8 years, on learning that second payment of
HRA and CCA had been paid to G. Ellappan and others vide order dated 29.06.2016

8 of 10
and they were absorbed as MTS that applicant gave a representation for second
payment of HRA and CCA as paid to G. Ellappan and others and for his absorption
as MTS.
15. In view of the admission of the applicant that he was unable to discharge the
duties assigned to him due to his ill health and did not attend office from 2007
onwards, he cannot be said to be similarly placed as G. Ellappan and others who were
continuously in service and discharging their duties and had been subsequently
absorbed. It is stated by the respondents that applicant's name is not found in their
office records beyond 23.07.2005. The claim made by the applicant that whenever he
approached the respondent to join duty, he was advised by the authority that he would
be informed about the same is strongly contested by the respondents. It is stated by
the respondents that his claim that he approached respondent's office for further
engagement is not supported by any documentary evidence and no such
representation in this regard is available in their office records.
16. It is observed that applicant was not a party in OA No.420/2010 and other
similar OAs filed by the others in the year 2010. Though in 2011, applicant filed OA.
No.1505/2011, it was only for HRA and CCA arrears and no relief was sought for a
direction to the respondent to take him back on duty. It appears that he did not have
any intention to rejoin duty after he stopped working in 2005 or even when he filed
the said OA in 2011. Only on 23/12/2020 did the applicant give a representation

9 of 10
seeking absorption as MTS which is highly belated and no explanation is given as to
why he did not approach this Tribunal at any time earlier.
17. In the case of State of Uttar Pradesh v. Arvind Kumar Srivastava [(2015) 1
SCC 347], the Apex Court has observed as under: -
"(1) Normal rule is that when a particular set of employees is given
relief by the Court, all other identically situated persons need to be
treated alike by extending that benefit. Not doing so would amount to
discrimination and would be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution
of India. This principle needs to be applied in service matters more
emphatically as the service jurisprudence evolved by this Court from
time to time postulates that all similarly situated persons should be
treated similarly. Therefore, the normal rule would be that merely
because other similarly situated persons did not approach the Court
earlier, they are not to be treated differently.
(2) However, this principle is subject to well recognized exceptions
in the form of laches and delays as well as acquiescence. Those
persons who did not challenge the wrongful action in their cases and
acquiesced into the same and woke up after long delay only because
of the reason that their counterparts who had approached the Court
earlier in time succeeded in their efforts, then such employees cannot
claim that the benefit of the judgment rendered in the case of similarly
situated persons be extended to them. They would be treated as fence-
sitters and laches and delays, and/or the acquiescence, would be a
valid ground to dismiss their claim.

10 of 10
 (3) However, this exception may not apply in those cases where the
judgment pronounced by the Court was judgment in rem with
intention to give benefit to all similarly situated persons, whether they
approached the Court or not. With such a pronouncement the
obligation is cast upon the authorities to itself extend the benefit
thereof to all similarly situated person. Such a situation can occur
when the subject matter of the decision touches upon the policy
matters, like scheme of regularisation and the like (see K.C. Sharma &
Ors. v. Union of India [(1997) 6 SCC 721]. On the other hand, if the
judgment of the Court was in personam holding that benefit of the said
judgment shall accrue to the parties before the Court and such an
intention is stated expressly in the judgment or it can be impliedly
found out from the tenor and language of the judgment, those who
want to get the benefit of the said judgment extended to them shall
have to satisfy that their petition does not suffer from either laches and
delays or acquiescence.".
18. In the light of the above facts and circumstances of the case and the law cited
above, applicant is a fence-sitter and not entitled to the relief claimed by him. The
unsubstantiated claim of the applicant cannot be accepted. Since the claim of
applicant is baseless and time barred, this OA is devoid of any merits. Accordingly,
the same is dismissed with no order as to costs.
(M.L. Srivastava) (Veena Kothavale)
Member(A) Member(J)
04.11.2026
asvs .
Digitally signed by ASAPU
SRINIVASA VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20 16:29:05
+05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.