Kuldeep Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 1 of 9
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
212 CWP-8415-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision: 18.11.2026
Kuldeep Kumar ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
State of Haryana and another ...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:- Mr. Sunil K. Nehra, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Rahil Mahajan, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Harish Kumar Nain, D.A.G., Haryana.
*
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
Present Civil Writ Petition under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioner for issuance of a writ
in the nature of Certiorari quashing the impugned letter dated 11.12.2024
(Annexure P-4) as the same has been issued in violation of the notification
dated 13.01.2023 (Annexure P-1) and notification dated 10.05.2023
(Annexure P-2); AND Issuance of a writ in the nature of Mandamus
directing the respondents to carry out the transfer drive only after fixing
the cut off date as 31.03.2025 for the purpose of calculating number of
vacancies, merit points and stay at a place of posting and till then no
transfer drive be carried out in pursuance to the impugned letter dated
11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4).
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 2 of 9
2. Ld. Senior counsel for the petitioner inter alia submits that
the Petitioner was appointed as Section Officer on 28.12.2011.
Subsequently, petitioner was promoted as Accounts Officer on
10.10.2022.
3. Ld. Senior Counsel submits that vide Notification dated
13.01.2023, the respondent-State had notified the Online Transfer Policy
(Annexure P-1) to regulate the transfer of Accounts Officer of SAS (OB)
Cadre in Treasury and Accounts, Department, Haryana (Finance
Department). As per the said Policy ‘Prescribed Tenure’ is defined in
Clause 3(c) as follows: -
“3(c) ‘Prescribed Tenure' means the tenure of appointment
for a period of five years or more in a Zone and three years in
an office within the Zone. While calculating the tenure of an
employee for the purpose of this policy, the date from which
someone is working in an office upto 31 March of the
Calendar year of transfer shall be counted irrespective of the
fact that he has been posted by temporary transfer or
otherwise. However, an employee may participate in the
transfer drive subject to completion on minimum three years'
service in a Zone or two years within a Zone.
‘Qualifying date is defined in Clause 3(d) as follows:-
“3(d) 'Qualifying date' for the purpose of calculation of
st
vacant post(s) shall be the 31 March of the calendar year of
transfer;”
Further, Time Schedule for online transfer is stipulated in
Clause 4(i)(b) and (c) as follows: -
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 3 of 9
“4(i)(b) The online process will be completed up to 31st
March and implemented on 1st of May of each year or any
subsequent date or as per exigency/convenience of the
Department/Government.
(c). The qualifying date for calculating number of vacancies,
merit points and stay at a place of posting shall be 31st
March of the calendar year in which the transfers are to be
made.”
4. It is pointed out that thereafter, vide Notification dated
10.05.2023 (Annexure P-2), an amendment was made in the definition of
‘Prescribed Tenure’ and definition of ‘Zone’. Clause 3(c) reads as under: -
“3(c) ‘Prescribed Tenure' means the tenure of appointment
for a period of three years in a Zone. While calculating the
tenure of an employee for the purpose of this policy, the date
from which someone is working in an office upto 31st March
of the Calendar year of transfer shall be counted irrespective
of the fact that he has been posted by temporary transfer or
otherwise. However, an employee may participate in the
transfer drive subject to completion of minimum one years'
service in a Zone.”
5. Ld. Senior Counsel submits that from the reading of the
above, it is clear that an employee may participate in the Transfer Drive
subject to minimum one year’s service. As such, as per the amended
Policy dated 10.05.2023 (Annexure P-2), petitioner had completed one
year on 16.02.2025; and, therefore, if cut off date in terms of Clause 4(i)
(b) and (c) is taken to be 31.03.2025, petitioner was eligible to participate
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 4 of 9
in 2025 Transfer Drive. However, vide the impugned letter dated
11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4), the cut-off date on which verification is to be
done, was stipulated to be 30.11.2024. As a result, petitioner was
rendered ineligible to participate in the transfer drive. Resultantly, vide
Communication dated 18.03.2025 (Annexure P-5) issued by the Director,
Treasuries and Accounts Department, Haryana, list of scores of Accounts
Officers, who are eligible to participate in the Online Transfer Drive has
been given; and name of the petitioner is not mentioned therein. Ld.
Senior Counsel submits that the aforesaid is contrary to the terms and
conditions of the Transfer Drive of the respondents and cannot be
maintained.
6. Ld. Senior Counsel further submits that no doubt under
Clause 12 of the Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023 (Annexure P-1),
respondents have the power to relax the terms and conditions of the
Policy. However, the said power in the present case, has not been
exercised correctly as no reasons have been given by the Administrative
Secretary as to why cut off date has been changed.
7. Ld. Senior Counsel also points out that while issuing Notice of
Motion vide order dated 01.04.2025, the Predecessor Bench had granted
interim relief by directing that “ In the meanwhile, the petitioner is
permitted to provisionally participate in the transfer policy, however, any
decision on consideration of the petitioner shall be kept in abeyance till
the next date of hearing.”. Hence, interim relief already stands granted to
the petitioner.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 5 of 9
8. In support of his contention, ld. Senior Counsel for the
petitioner relies upon a judgment of the Coordinate Bench of this Court in
CWP-3-2025 titled as Vijay Garg vs. State of Haryana and others, decided
on 16.01.2025, Neutral Citation No. 2025: PHHC:006235 .
9. It is accordingly prayed that present Writ Petition be allowed;
and following prayers be accepted: -
“i. Issue a writ in the nature of Certiorari quashing the
impugned letter dated 11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4) as the
same has been issued in violation of the notification dated
13.01.2023 (Annexure P-1) and notification dated 10.05.2023
(Annexure P-2);
ii. Issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondents to carry out the transfer drive only after fixing
the cut off date as 31.03.2025 for the purpose of calculating
number of vacancies, merit points and stay at a place of
posting and till then no transfer drive be carried out in
pursuance to the impugned letter dated 11.12.2024
(Annexure P-4).”
10. Per contra, learned State Counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondents vehemently opposes submissions advanced on behalf of the
petitioner and submits that in terms of the Policy dated 13.01.2023
(Annexure P-1), the first Transfer Drive was undertaken in the year 2024.
In the said Transfer Drive of 2024, the cut off date was mentioned to be
30.11.2023. Despite that, the petitioner had duly participated in the said
Transfer Drive without raising any objection to the cut off date of
30.11.2023 and had duly got transferred. However, now in the 2025, when
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 6 of 9
the cut off date has been changed to 30.11.2024, petitioner is objecting as
it does not suit him. It is argued that as the petitioner has accepted
aforesaid conditions for the Transfer Drive of 2024, petitioner is estopped
from objecting to the same for the Transfer Drive of 2025.
11. Ld. State Counsel further submits that there is valid reason
for which the respondent State was compelled to exercise the power of
relaxation under Clause 12. It is pointed out that as per the Policy dated
13.01.2023 (Annexure P-1), respondents are required to complete the
st
Transfer Drive by 31 March of every respective year and implement it on
st
the 1 of May of each year. It is submitted that for the reasons beyond
their control, respondents could not start the Transfer Drive 2025 in time;
and, therefore, the cut off date was extended to 30.11.2024. Thus, it
became necessary to change the cut off date to 30.11.2024 instead of
31.03.2024. He accordingly prays for dismissal of the present Writ
Petition.
12. No other argument has been raised on behalf of learned
counsel for the parties. I have heard learned counsel and perused the case
file in detail. I find merit in the submissions of the petitioner.
13. The relevant Clauses of the Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023
(Annexure P-1) have already been noted herein above. Contention of the
respondent-State is that power of relaxation available to the respondents
under Clause 12 of the Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023 (Annexure P-1)
has been correctly exercised, and cut off date was extended upto
30.11.2024 vide impugned Communication dated 11.12.2024 (Annexure
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 7 of 9
P-4), on the ground that there was delay in initiating the Transfer Drive for
the year 2025. Clause 12 of Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023 (Annexure P-
1) is as follows:
“ 12. Power to relax: Notwithstanding anything contained in
the policy, the Administrative Secretary, Finance Department,
Haryana with the prior approval of Chief Minister, Haryana,
shall be competent to transfer an employee to any place in
relaxation of any or all of the above provisions after recording
reasons justifying such relaxation.”
14. A perusal of the above shows that it is categorically stipulated
therein that terms and conditions of the Policy are liable to be relaxed by
the Administrative Secretary, Finance Department, Haryana – however,
with the prior approval of the Chief Minister, Haryana - and “ after
recording reasons justifying such relaxation.” In the present case, nothing
has been shown to this Court that the said power has been exercised after
prior approval of the Chief Minister. Further, a perusal of the impugned
order dated 11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4) shows that it records no such
reasons as have been now mentioned by the learned State Counsel. It is to
be appreciated that Policy dated 13.01.2023 (Annexure P-1) is a statutory
Policy framed by the respondents and has been duly published in the
Haryana Government Gazette. As such, compliance with terms and
conditions thereof is a mandatory requirement and cannot be done away
with. In this regard, reference may be made to observations made by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Vijay Garg (supra) wherein,
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 8 of 9
while dealing with the power assigned to the respondents to relax
provision of the Policy, it has been observed as follows: -
“8. It is evident from perusal of the same that even though
the Government has the power to relax any/or all of the
provisions contained in the online transfer policy, however,
the procedure required to be followed for the same is that the
Administrative Secretary of the Department has to seek prior
approval of the Chief Minister after recording reasons
justifying such relaxation. Even though the office file shows
that there is an approval by way of WhatsApp message
received from the office of the Officer on Special Duty to the
Chief Minister, Haryana, there is no justifiable reason that
was ever set out by the Administrative Secretary seeking
relaxation of the provisions of the online transfer policy. The
respondents-State cannot supplant a justification in a reply
filed before the Court. A justification for such a transfer is
required to be reflected through the file notings when the
proposal for transfer of the petitioner from the post in
question was mooted by the respondent-Department.
Further, it is also reflected from the initial proposal of
transfer, the petitioner was not amongst the persons to be
transferred and that the said proposal was inducted only on
receipt of WhatsApp message from the Officer on Special
Duty in the office of the Chief Minister, Haryana. Thus, the
office noting on the file and the proposal do not support the
argument advanced today by the respondent.
Notwithstanding the above, another reason cited by the
respondents is that the department wanted to optimally
utilize the long experience of the petitioner, however, it is
evident from a perusal of the reply filed by the respondents
that the petitioner had been regularly promoted only in the
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-8415-2025 (O&M) 9 of 9
month of June, 2023 and as such, it cannot be said that the
petitioner had a long standing career as Executive Engineer.
Thus, the aforesaid justification sought to be portrayed
before this Court also stands falsified.”
15. The present case is covered by the ratio of the above
judgment. No judgment to the contrary has been cited by the ld. State
Counsel.
16. As regards the contention of the respondent-State that the
petitioner is estopped from raising objection in the present Transfer Drive,
the same is without merit. There can be no negative parity. The petitioner
has become ineligible to participate in the online Transfer Drive for the
present year despite completion of one year service due to impugned
action of changing the essential terms and conditions of the Transfer
Policy.
17. Keeping in view the entire conspectus of the afore-noted
factual and legal position, present Writ Petition is allowed ; and impugned
letter dated 11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4) is quashed. The interim direction
of this Court dated 1.4.2025 is made absolute.
18. Pending application(s) if any also stand(s) disposed of.
18.11.2026 (NIDHI GUPTA)
Divyanshi
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document