Attar Singh vs State Of Haryana And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 1 of 12
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
207 (2 cases)
Date of Decision: 19.11.2026
1. CWP-24172-2023 (O&M)
Attar Singh ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
State of Haryana and others ...Respondent(s)
AND
2. CWP-19658-2023 (O&M)
Attar Singh ...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
State of Haryana and others ...Respondent(s)
CORAM: HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GUPTA
Present:- Mr. Ankur Lal, Advocate for the petitioner(s).
Dr. Neha Awasthi, Addl.A.G., Haryana.
Mr. Sarfraj Hussain, Advocate for
respondent No.5.
NIDHI GUPTA, J.
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M)
Present Civil Writ Petition under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioners for the issuance of a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the order No. 4859-63 dated
25.08.2023 (Annexure P-1), passed by the respondent no.2 whereby the
services of the petitioner have been terminated illegally, arbitrary, without
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 2 of 12
giving the petitioner any opportunity of being heard and further in view of
the fact that the petitioner has not been conveyed the impugned order by
official channels till date, as the petitioner has been working as the
tubewell operator in village Hidayatpur since the year 17.03.2020 till date
(Annexure P-2), without any break in service.
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M)
Present Civil Writ Petition under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioner for the issuance of a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the order dated 25.08.2023
(Annexure P-1) passed by the respondent no.2 whereby it has been
ordered for recovery of the salary paid to the petitioner on the basis of no
work no pay principle, illegally and arbitrarily as the petitioner has been
working as the tubewell operator in village Hidayatpur since the year
17.03.2020 till date (Annexure P-2).
2. With the consent of learned counsel for both the parties, both
the aforesaid Writ Petitions are being decided by this common order as the
facts, issues and parties involved in both the cases are identical. For the
sake of facility, facts are being drawn from CWP-24172-2023 titled as Attar
Singh vs. State of Haryana and others.
3. It is inter alia submitted by ld. Counsel for the petitioner that
petitioner is a registered Pump Operator under the respondent No.5/Gram
Panchayat of village Hidayatpur. Petitioner was appointed as such vide the
Resolution No. 5 dated 17.03.2020 (Annexure P-6) passed by the
DIVYANSHI respondent No.5/Gram Panchayat. Subsequently, petitioner had received a
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 3 of 12
notice dated 22.06.2023 (Annexure P-9) from respondent No.2 seeking
reply to the Resolution No.2 dated 15.02.2023 passed by respondent No.5
against him for unsatisfactory work. Petitioner had replied to the same vide
reply dated 26.06.2023 (Annexure P-10) explaining that petitioner had been
working as Pump Operator for the past 5 years and no complaint had ever
been received against him.
4. Ld. Counsel submits that notwithstanding the above reply filed
by the petitioner, vide order dated 25.08.2023 (Annexure P-4) (impugned in
CWP-19658-2023), recovery of salary from the year 2019 to August 2022
was sought to be made on the ground that before 2022, tubewell of V.
Hidayatpur was not commissioned as electric connection had not been
released.
5. Ld. Counsel submits that upon receiving the aforesaid order,
petitioner had duly demonstrated to the respondents by way of electricity
bills for the period 01.09.2018 till 10.07.2021 (Annexure P-8) that the sole
reason on which recovery was sought to be made from the petitioner, was
incorrect. As the said reply filed by the petitioner was ignored, as such,
petitioner had challenged the said order of recovery before this Court by
way of the connected CWP-19658-2023; in which vide order dated
05.09.2023, respondents were restrained from effecting recovery from the
petitioner.
6. Ld. Counsel submits that unknown to the petitioner vide order
of even date i.e. 25.08.2023 (Annexure P-1) (impugned in CWP-24172-
DIVYANSHI 2023), services of the petitioner had also been terminated without giving
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 4 of 12
any opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. Ld. Counsel clarifies that as the
said order of termination was not conveyed to the petitioner, accordingly,
petitioner was constrained to challenge the same by way of
separate/present CWP-24172-2023; in which also vide order dated
20.10.2023, operation of the impugned order of termination dated
25.08.2023 was stayed.
7. Ld. Counsel submits that in the meantime, in view of the fact
that petitioner had duly demonstrated the incorrectness of the impugned
orders by way of the electricity bills (P-8), the respondents were left with no
choice, but to accept their mistake. Accordingly, vide letter/order dated
18.09.2023 (Annexure P-11), the respondents acknowledged that tubewell
was commissioned since 2018-19 and electricity bills were also paid to the
DHBVNL. However now the respondent presented a different ground for
effecting recovery from the petitioner, as also for sustaining order of
termination. It was now stated that for Jal Jeevan Mission work, laying
pipeline was completed during August 2022. As such, pipeline supplying the
water was not there, and, therefore, services of the petitioner had been
wrongly engaged.
8. In this regard, Ld. Counsel draws the attention of this Court to
the stand taken by the respondent No.1 to 4 in the written statement dated
09.02.2024; wherein it has been stated that as there was no pipeline in the
village Hidayatpur therefore, work of Pump Operator was not required and
petitioner was not rendering any service on that post and had therefore,
DIVYANSHI received salary without work. Ld. Counsel submits that accordingly,
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 5 of 12
petitioner had sought information in regard to the pipeline, under RTI. Vide
reply dated 15.02.2025 (Annexure P-12) (brought on record with the
replication dated 07.04.2025), it was informed that: -
Sr.
No.
Question Answer
5. A verified copy of the bill
regarding when the old
water supply line was
buried in village Hidayatpur
should be given.
The documents and bills with
regard to laying of old pipeline
in village Hidayatpur which was
used for the supply of water are
not available since the record is
very old and the same is not
available in the office.
9. It is submitted that therefore, it was admitted in the RTI reply
that old pipeline was there; however, respondents had refused to supply
the record with regard to laying of the pipeline.
10. It is further pointed out that vide letter dated 27.10.2023
(Annexure R-3) issued by the Sub Divisional Engineer, Public Health
Engineering Department, it had been informed that Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM)
had been conducted in village Hidayatpur in August 2021. It is contended
that therefore, even the second ground on which services of the petitioner
are sought to be terminated, is baseless.
11. Ld. Counsel argues that as per law, it is not permitted to
change/supplement ground for termination of Service. In support of his
contention, ld. Counsel for the petitioner relies upon a judgment passed by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rashmi Metaliks Ltd. v. Kolkata Metropolitan
Development Authority (SC): Law Finder Doc Id # 479301 to submit that
once the order is passed, it cannot be supplemented by further grounds. Ld.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 6 of 12
Counsel further argues that from the above facts, malafide intent of the
respondents for seeking termination of the service of the petitioner; as also
to effect illegal recovery of salary paid to the petitioner on one pretext or
the other, is evident. It is accordingly prayed that the present Writ Petition
be allowed; and following prayer be accepted: -
“For issuance of writ in the nature of certiorari for
quashing the order No. 4859-63 dated 25.08.2023 (Annexure
P-1) passed by the respondent no.2 whereby the services of the
petitioner have been ordered to be terminated illegally,
arbitrary and without giving the petitioner an opportunity of
being heard and thus being in complete oblivion of the golden
doctrine of law 'Audi Alterem Partem' and further not
conveying the impugned order to the petitioner till date,
despite the fact that the petitioner has been working as the
tubewell operator in village Hidayatpur since the year
17.03.2020 till date (Annexure P-2). ”
12. Per contra, ld. Counsel representing respondent No.5-Gram
Panchayat supported by ld. Counsel for the official respondents/State have
opposed submissions of the petitioner and argued that at the time of
appointment of the petitioner, wife of the petitioner was Sarpanch and,
therefore, appointment of the petitioner as Pump Operator (Jal Karmi) was
wrongly made. It is also submitted that even the Resolution dated
17.03.2020 (Annexure P-6) is not found in the record of the Gram Panchayat
and the same has been prepared and procured fraudulently by the
petitioner (as mentioned in para 12 of the Preliminary Submissions of the
reply dated 09.02.2024 filed on behalf of respondents No.1 to 4 by the
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 7 of 12
BDPO Hodal). Ld. Counsel also refers to para 6 of the Preliminary
Submissions of the said reply; wherein it is mentioned as follows: -
“6-That taking advantage of his wife, being on the post of
village GP Sarpanch, the petitioner interfered into the affairs of
the Gram Panchayat and secured his appointment as pump
operator (Jalkarmi) on Tubewell No.1 and distribution pipeline,
which in fact, was drilled in village during the year 2018-2019.
Before August, 2021, the tube-well of village Hidayatpur was
not commissioned due to non-release of electric connection.
However, the same had been commissioned in August, 2021
after release of electric connection along with distribution
pipeline. The above said fact is duly mentioned in letter bearing
No. 1548 dated 27.10.2023 written by SDO(PHED), Sub-Division
No. 2 to Chief Executive Officer, Zila Parishad, Palwal. A copy of
letter dated 27.10.2023 is annexed herewith as Annexure R-1.”
13. It is contended that therefore, the petitioner was working even
when the tubewell was not installed. He accordingly prays for dismissal of
the present Writ Petition.
14. No other argument is raised on behalf of the ld. Counsel for
the parties. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
case file in great detail. I find merit in the submissions of the petitioner.
15. Factual matrix of the case has already been noted herein
above. Although it has been contended on behalf of the respondents that
the Resolution dated 17.03.2020 (Annexure P-6); whereby petitioner was
appointed as Pump Operator (Jal Karmi) is not available with the
respondent No.5-Gram Panchayat; and that the petitioner has prepared the
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 8 of 12
said Resolution fraudulently, however, there would appear to be no truth to
the said contention as, if that was so, where was the occasion for the
respondents to pass the impugned orders effecting recovery from the
petitioner and terminating the services of the petitioner. It is the view of
this Court that this in itself is sufficient to demonstrate ill-intent of the
respondent-Gram Panchayat towards the petitioner.
16. Furthermore, as per the order of recovery dated 25.08.2023
(Annexure P-4), salary paid to the petitioner from the year 2019 till August
2022 was sought to be recovered on the following grounds: -
“ Water supply in village Hidayatpur is being maintained
through 1 no. tubewell & Distribution pipeline. This tubewell
was drilled in village during the year 2018-2019. Before
08/2022 tubewell of village Hidayatpur was not commissioned
due to electric connection not release. But the same has been
commissioned during the period of 08/2022 after release of
electric connection alongwith distribution pipeline. On the
basis of report of combined committee recovery of salary of
Attar Singh from the period of 2019 to August, 2022 should be
implemented.”.
17. As such, recovery was sought to be made from the petitioner
on the ground that before August 2022, tubewell was not commissioned in
village Hidayatpur as electric connection had not been released.
18. A perusal of order dated 25.8.2023 (Annexure P-1), shows that
services of the petitioner were sought to be terminated by the respondents
on the following grounds: -
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 9 of 12
“Water supply in village Hidayatpur is being maintained
through 1 no. tubewell & Distribution pipeline. This tubewell
was drilled in village during the year 2018-2019. Before
08/2022 tubewell of village Hidayatpur was not commissioned
due to electric connection not release. But the same has been
commissioned during the period of 08/2022 after release of
electric connection alongwith distribution pipeline.
On the basis of the report of the combined committee the
pump operator has received salary since the year 2019 till 2022
without any work and he is guilty of the same and also his
work was not satisfactory and therefore, Sh. Attar Singh Pump
Operator son of Sh. Bhikan, resident of Gram Panchayat
Hidayatpur, Tehsil Hodal is terminated from his post of pump
operator”.
19. Thus, reading of the above shows that impugned orders of
recovery and termination were passed primarily on the ground that
tubewell was not commissioned in the village Hidayatpur prior to August
2022 as there was no electricity connection.
20. However, petitioner has successfully demonstrated from the
electricity bills for the period 01.09.2018 till 10.07.2021 (Annexure P-8),
there was already electricity connection installed at the tubewell bearing
Account No. BAPW-0019 and electricity bills for the same were duly raised
by the Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd; and the same were being
paid by the Sub Divisional Officer Public Health Engineering Department,
Palwal. As such, the pretext on which infant orders were passed, were
without basis.
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 10 of 12
21. Accordingly, Respondents now took a somersault and vide
letter dated 18.09.2023 (Annexure P-11) admitted their mistake “ that this
T/w was commissioned since 2018-19 and electricity bill has also been paid
to the DHBVNL by this office. The JJM work for laying of pipe line was
completed during 08/2022 and scheme was functional.” However,
respondents now sought to justify the impugned order on the pretext that
for Jal Jeevan Mission, laying of pipeline was completed only in August
2022. Similar stance has been taken by respondents No.1 to 4 in their reply
dated 09.02.2024; wherein in para 11 and 12 of the Preliminary
Submissions, it has been stated as follows: -
“11- That since there was neither any pipeline in village
Hidayatpur for working as a pump operator nor the petitioner
was rendering any of his service on that post, however,
received the salary without any work, hence, the orders of
dismissal as well as recovery were validly passed against him.
12- That it is relevant to mention here that even the resolution
dated 17.03.2020 (Annexure P-6) has no record in the Gram
Panchayat and the same has also been prepared and procured
fraudulently by the petitioner.”
22. The petitioner had duly sought clarification with respect to
new stance adopted by the respondents and in order to show that he was
duly working as a tubewell pump operator since the date of his
appointment had sought information under the Right to Information Act
from the office of Sub Divisional Engineer, Public Health Department, Sub
Division No.2 Palwal, with regard to the fact that an earlier/old pipeline was
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 11 of 12
already present and was in working condition and connected to the
tubewell which had been used for supplying of water to the village, was in
existence even prior to the appointment of the petitioner. The respondents
had supplied the information to the petitioner vide memo No.331 dated
15.02.2025 (Annexure P-12), which showed that there was an old pipeline
in existence which is buried under the ground and now a new pipeline has
also been laid under the JJM scheme which got commissioned in the year
2022. Thus, the new ground on basis of which impugned orders were
sought to be justified by the respondents, was also falsified and proved to
be incorrect.
23. Such a practice of change in stance has been decried by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rashmi Metaliks Ltd.’s case (supra) as under: -
“12..........The impugned Judgment is indubitably a cryptic one
and does not contain the reasons on which the decision is
predicated. Since reasons are not contained in the impugned
Judgment itself, it must be set aside on the short ground that a
party cannot be permitted to travel beyond the stand adopted
and.. expressed by it in its earlier decision. The following
observations found in the celebrated decision in Mohinder
Singh Gill v. The Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi, AIR
1978 Supreme Court 851 , are relevant to this question:
"8. The second equally relevant matter is that when a statutory
functionary makes an order based on certain grounds, its
validity must be judged by the reasons so mentioned and
cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the shape of
affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order bad in the
beginning may, by the time it comes to court on account of a
challenge, get validated by additional grounds later brought
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24172-2023 (O&M) &
CWP-19658-2023 (O&M) 12 of 12
out. We may here draw attention to the observations of Bose J.
in Gordhandas Bhanji (AIR 1952 Supreme Court 16) (at p.18):
"Public orders publicly made, in exercise of a statutory
authority cannot be construed in the light of explanations
subsequently given by the officer making the order of what he
meant, or of what was in his mind, or what he intended to do.
Public orders made by public authorities are meant to have
public effect and are intended to affect the acting and conduct
of those to whom they are addressed and must be construed
objectively with reference to the language used in the order
itself.
Orders are not like old wine becoming better as they grow
order.”
24. Ld. Counsel for the respondents are unable to dispute the
above said factual and legal position.
25. Accordingly, both the above said Writ Petitions are allowed ;
and impugned order dated 25.08.2023 (Annexure P-1 CWP-24172-2023)
and another impugned order dated 25.08.2023 (Annexure P-1 in CWP-
19658-2023) are set aside.
26. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
19.11.2026 (NIDHI GUPTA)
Divyanshi
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
DIVYANSHI
2026.11.20 16:28
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document