MANIMEGALAI vs V.VENKATESA REDDY (DIED)

Court
Madras High Court

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON: 01-10-2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 16.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P. DHANABAL
SA No. 852 of 2014
CNR:{HCMA011094012014}
and S.A. No.853 of 2014
SA N o . 85 2 of 2014
Manimegalai W/o Murthy
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. V.Venkatesa Reddy (deceased)
S/o Veeraraghava Reddy
M.C.Chandran (Died)
represented by its legal representatives /
respondents 6 to 8
2. Amirthammal W/o Late Perumal Reddy
3. Ulaganathan S/o Late Perumal Reddy
4. Sarasa D/O LATE PERUMAL REDDY
5. Ranjani D/o Late Perumal Reddy
6. C. Vasanthi W/o Late M.C.Chandran
7. C.Saravanan S/o Late M.C. Chanderan
8. C.Kalai D/o Late M.C.Chanderan
9. Muniammal W/o Venkatesa Reddy
10.Ramasamy (died) S/o Venkatesa Reddy
11.Boobathy S/o Venkatesa Reddy
12.Elumalai S/o Venkatesa Reddy
13.Govindasamy S/o Venkatesa Reddy
14.Seenivasan S/o Venkatesa Reddy
15.Kumaravel S/o Venkatesa Reddy
16.Kumari W/o.Late Ramaswamy
17.Ramesh S/o. Late Ramaswamy
18.Magesh S/o. Late Ramaswamy
19.Karthic S/o.Late Ramaswamy
__________
Page 1 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
[1. R6 cause title amended vide court order
dated 27/02/2024 made in C.M.P. Nos 2705
and 2707 of 2024.
2. R6 to R8 were brought on Record as legal
representatives of the deceased M.C. Chandran.
3. R9 to R15 were brought on record as legal
representatives of the deceased R1 vide order
dated 01.08.2014 made in C.M.P. Nos.1 to 7 of
2014.
4. R10 died, R16 to 19 were brought on record
as legal heirs of the deceased R10 vide court
order dated 26/10/2022 made in C.M.P. Nos
6490,6491 and 6492 of 2022]
..Respondent(s)
SA No. 853 of 2014
CNR:{HCMA011094152014}
Manimegalai W/o Murthy
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. V.Venkatesa Reddy (died)
S/o Veeraraghava Reddy
2. Amirthammal W/o Late Perumal Reddy
3. Ranjani D/o Late Perumal Reddy
4. Ulaganathan S/o Late Perumal Reddy
5. Sarasa D/o Late Perumal Reddy
6. Govindasamy S/o Kuppambodi Kuppu Reddy
7. Rosi Relddy S/o Kuppambodi Kuppu Reddy
M.C.Chandran [Died]
8. C.Vasanthi W/o M.C. Chandran
9. C. Saravanan Late Of M.C. Chandran
10.C.Kalai D/o Late M.C.Chanderan
11.Muniammal W/o Venkatesa Reddy
12.RAMASAMY(died) W/o Venkatesa Reddy
13.Boobathy S/o Venkatesa Reddy
14.Elumalai S/o Venkatesa Reddy
15.Govindasamy S/o Venkatesa Reddy
16.Seenivasan S/o Venkatesa Reddy
__________
Page 2 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
17.Kumaravel S/o Venkatesa Reddy
18.Kumari W/o.late Ramaswamy
19.Ramesh S/o.late Ramaswamy
20.Magesh S/o.late Ramaswamy
21.Karthic S/o.late Ramaswamy
[1. R8 cause title amended vide court order
dated 27/02/2024 made in C.M.P. Nos. 2705
and 2707 of 2024.
2. R8 to R10 were brought on record as legal
representatives of the deceased M.C. Chandran
and R11 to R17 were brought on records as
legal representatives of the deceased R1 vide
order dated 01.08.2014 made in M.P. Nos.1 to 7
of 2013.
3. R12 died, R18 to 21 were brought on record
as legal representatives of the deceased R12
vide order dated 26/10/2022 made in C.M.P.
Nos 6477,6479 and 6480 of 2022)
..Respondent(s)
PRAYER in S.A. No. 852 of 201 4 : The Second Appeal has been filed under
Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code as against the judgment and decree dated
17.12.2012 made in A.S. No.16 of 2012 on the file of the Sub Judge, Thiruttani
reversing the judgment and decree dated 27.09.2004 made in O.S. No.180 of
1987 on the file of the District Munsif, Thiruttani.
PRAYER in S.A. No.853 of 2014: The Second Appeal has been filed under
Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code as against the judgment and decree dated
17.12.2012 made in A.S. No.17 of 2012 on the file of the Sub Judge, Thiruttani
reversing the judgment and decree dated 27.09.2004 made in O.S. No.1287 of
1987 on the file of the District Munsif, Thiruttani.
__________
Page 3 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
For Appellant(s):
[Both appeals]
M/s.D.Ravichander
For Respondent(s):
S.A. No.852 of 2014
Mr. S.A. Udhayakumar [for R2 to R5]
Mr. P. Madhan for
M/s. Majestic Law Firm [for R9, R11 to R19]
R6 to R8 – Served – No appearance.
R1 and R10 – Died.
S.A. No.853 of 2014
Mr. S.A. Udhayakumar [for R2 to R5]
M/s. A. Lakshmi Narasimhan
Mr. A.M. Kannan [for R8 to R10]
Mr. P. Madhan for
M/s. Majestic Law Firm [for R11, R13 to R21]
R6, R7 – Not ready
R1 and R12 – Died.
COMMON JUDGMENT
These Second Appeals have been preferred as against the common
judgment and decrees passed by the Subordinate Judge, Thiruttani in A.S.
Nos.16 of 2012 and 17 of 2012. The appellant in S. A. No.853 of 2014 has filed
a Suit in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 on the file of the District Munsif, Thiruttani for
st
the reliefs of declaration and permanent injunction. The 1 respondent in S.A.
No.852 of 2014 has filed a Suit in O.S. No.180 of 1987 on the file of the
District Munsif, Thiruttani for the reliefs of partition and separate possession.
Both the Suits were tried jointly together and a common judgment has been
passed by the trial Court and the trial Court decreed the Suit in O.S. No.1287 of
__________
Page 4 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
1987 and dismissed the Suit in O.S. No.180 of 1987. Aggrieved by the said
decrees and common judgment, the Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of 1987 has
st
preferred an appeal in A.S. No.16 of 2012. The 1 defendant in O.S. No.1287
of 1987 has preferred an appeal in A.S. No.17 of 2012. The First Appellate
Court through a common judgment dated 17.12.2012, reversed and set aside the
common judgment and decrees passed by the trial Court. The Suit in O.S.
No.180 of 1987 was decreed and the Suit in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 was
dismissed. Aggrieved by the said common judgment and decrees, these Second
appeals have been preferred.
2. The case of the Plaintiff in O.S. No. 180 of 1987 is as follows:
The Suit schedule property is the ancestral property of the Plaintiff and
st
the 1 defendant, who are the brothers. They divided all the joint family
properties except the Suit schedule property, which was kept as common. The
st
Plaintiff and the 1 defendant have been in joint possession and enjoyment of
the Suit property and the patta stands in the name of the grand father of the
st st
Plaintiff and the 1 defendant. While so, the 1 defendant sold the entire
schedule mentioned properties including the Plaintiff’s undivided share to the
nd nd
2 defendant through a Sale Deed dated 17.01.1986. The 2 defendant did not
pay any consideration for the above said sale. The Sale Deed in favour of the
nd
2 defendant is not true. Therefore, the Plaintiff filed the Suit.
__________
Page 5 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
nd
2.1. The 2 defendant in O.S. No.180 of 1987 has filed a Written
nd
statement denying the averments of the Plaint. According to the 2 defendant,
the Plaintiff has no right, title or interest over the property. Already the Plaintiff
sent a notice to his brother Perumal Reddy with false averments and the same
st
was suitably replied. The 1 defendant Perumal Reddy obtained the property
through a Sale Deed and thereby, it is his separate property and the same was
nd nd
sold to the 2 defendant. The 2 defendant instead of executing Mortgage
Deed, executed a Sale Deed in favour of one Subramania Chetty and again he
nd
purchased the property and thereby, the 2 defendant is in possession and
enjoyment of the property. The Suit property is not an ancestral property of the
st
Plaintiff and the 1 defendant. In fact, the property belonged to one Kuppam
Muniappa Reddy. After the demise of the said Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, his
son Duraisamy Reddy, in the year 1966 and 1970, sold so many properties of
st
his father. While so, the 1 defendant also purchased the property through a
st
Sale Deed dated 01.01.1960. In turn, the 1 defendant sold the property to the
nd nd
2 defendant through a Sale Deed dated 17.01.1986, thereby, the 2 defendant
is in possession and enjoyment of the property. After sale of the property, now
st
the Plaintiff and the 1 defendant have collusively filed this Suit to grab the
nd
property from the 2 defendant. The Plaintiff is not entitled to any share over
nd
the Suit property. Already the 2 defendant entered into an agreement with one
Manimegalai. At that time, there was a dispute between the Plaintiff and the
defendants. While so, the revenue authorities granted patta in favour of one
__________
Page 6 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
Nagammal, wife of Duraisamy and her son Subramania Reddy. Thereafter, the
said Nagammal and Subramania Reddy sold the property to the said
Manimegalai. Already Suits in O.S. Nos.646 of 1986 and 180 of 1987 are
nd
pending. The 2 defendant is in possession and enjoyment of the property.
Therefore, the Suit is liable to be dismissed.
th
2.2. The 7 defendant in O.S. No.180 of 1987 has filed a Written
th
statement denying the averments made in the Plaint. According to the 7
defendant, the Suit property is not an ancestral property and the same is
originally belonged to one Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The daughter in law of
the said Kuppam Muniappa Reddy namely Nagammal and her son Subramania
Reddy on one hand and the Plaintiff herein, one Chandran and Govindasamy
Reddy on the other hand, have applied to the Tahsildar, Thiruttani for grnat of
patta in their favour respectively. After due enquiry, the Tahsildar has
transferred patta in the name of the said Nagammal and Subramani on
th
10.09.1996. After seeing the patta, the 7 defendant purchased the property and
thereafter, this defendant also transferred the patta in her name. The Plaintiff,
Govindasamy Reddy and M.C. Chandran had appealed before the RDO,
Tiruvallur District and the same was also dismissed. Therefore, neither the
Plaintiff nor the M.C. Chandran and Perumal Reddy have not applied for the
cancellation of patta granted in the name of Nagammal and Subramani and also
th st
in the name of the 7 defendant. The Plaintiff and the 1 defendant are not joint
__________
Page 7 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
owners. Therefore, the Suit is not maintainable and the same is liable to be
dismissed.
3. The case of the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 is as follows:-
The Suit schedule property originally belonged to one Kuppam Muniappa
Reddy. Nagammal and Subramani, who are the vendors of the Plaintiff, are the
legal heirs of one Duraisamy Reddy, who is the son of the said Kuppam
Muniappa Reddy. One Venkatesa Reddy, Govindasamy Reddy, M.C. Chandran
and the Plaintiff’s vendors Nagammal, Subramani had applied for patta before
Tahsildar, Tiruttani and Tahsildar passed an order by granting patta to the
Plaintiff’s vendors Nagammal and Subramani. Thereafter, the said Venkatesa
Reddy, Govindasamy Reddy and M.C. Chandran have preferred an appeal
before the RDO, Tiruvallur. After due enquiry, the appeal was dismissed and
thereby, the Plaintiff purchased the property from Nagammal and Subramani
through a Sale Deed dated 07.10.1986 and she is in possession and enjoyment
of the property. While so, the defendants attempted to trespass into the property
and thereby, filed the Suit for declaration and consequential relief of permanent
injunction.
3.1. The gist of the Written statement filed by the 4 to 6 defendants in
O.S. No. 1287 of 1987 is as follows:-
The Suit is not maintainable. The vendors of the Plaintiff namely
__________
Page 8 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
Nagammal and Subramani have no manner of right, title or interest over the
property. The Sale Deed in favour of the Plaintiff is not valid and binding on
the defendants. The vendors of the Plaintiff are not the original legal heirs of
the Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The order regarding transfer of patta passed by
the Tahsildar is not valid and binding on the defendants. Neither the Plaintiff
nor the vendors of the Plaintiff were in possession of the Suit property at any
time. The grand father of the defendants belonged to the Suit village and he had
other lands in the Suit village, which were sold by these defendants. The
property is not an ancestral property of Venkatesa Reddy and Perumal Reddy.
They have no manner of right, title or interest over the Suit property. Already
these defendants have filed a Suit in O.S. No.646 of 2019. Therefore, the Suit is
liable to be dismissed.
th
3.2. The brief averments of the Written statement filed by the 5
defendant in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 are as follows:-
The Suit is not maintainable. Originally the Suit property belonged to
nd
Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, who is none other than the grand father of the 2
st
defendant and the 1 defendant. The said Nagammal and Subramani are not the
legal heirs of Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The patta granted in favour of the said
nd
Nagammal and Subramani is not valid. The father of the 2 defendant never
th
executed any letter or deed and the same was created by the 9 defendant for the
purpose of grabbing the Suit property. Therefore, the Suit is liable to be
dismissed.
__________
Page 9 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
th
3.3. The brief averments of the Written statement filed by the 9
defendant in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 are as follows:-
The Suit is not maintainable. In the Suit village, number of Muniappa
Reddys were there. Originally the Suit property belonged to one Ortukuppa
Muniappa Reddy and he had a son Kuppi Reddy and he executed a Sale letter in
th
favour of one Perumal Reddy and in turn, he sold the same to the 9 defendant
through a Sale Deed dated 17.01.1986. Already the Tahsildar passed an order
by transferring the patta in the name of Nagammal and Subramani and the same
th
was challenged before RDO, and the said appeal was also dismissed. The 9
defendant is in possession and enjoyment of the property. Therefore, the Suit is
liable to be dismissed.
4. Based on the above pleadings and after hearing both sides, the trial
Court has framed the following issues:
O.S. No.180 of 1987
(i) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to ½ share over the Suit property?
(ii) Whether the Suit property is an ancestral property of the Plaintiff
and the defendants 1 and 2?
st
(iii) Whether the 1 defendant executed a Sale Deed dated 17.01.1986 in
nd
favour of the 2 defendant?
__________
Page 10 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
th
(iv) Whether the 7 defendant has purchased the Suit property through
a Sale Deed dated 07.10.1986 from the legal heirs?
(v) To what other reliefs, the Plaintiff is entitled?
O.S. No.1287 of 1987
(i) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the reliefs of declaration and
consequential relief of permanent injunction as prayed for?
(ii) Whether the Plaintiff has purchased the Suit property through a
Sale Deed dated 07.10.1986 from the legal heirs? If so, whether the said sale
is valid and whether the same is binding on the defendants?
(iii) Whether the Suit property is an ancestral property of the
defendants 1 and 2?
th
(iv) As per the Sale Letter dated 17.01.1986, whether the 9 defendant
has purchased the Suit property?
(v) Whether the defendants 7 and 8 are the absolute owners of the Suit
property?
(vi) Whether the Suit property is under the possession and enjoyment of
the parties?
(vii) To what other reliefs, the Plaintiff is entitled?
5. Thereafter, both the Suits were tried jointly and the Suit in O.S.
No.180 of 1987 was taken as main Suit and the evidences recorded in that Suit
__________
Page 11 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
were treated as evidence in the connected case. Before the trial court, on the
side of the Plaintiff, PW1 to PW3 were examined and the documents Ex.A1 to
Ex.A.12 were marked. On the side of the defendant, DW1 to DW6 were
examined and Ex.B.1 to Ex.B.31 were marked. The Commissioner’s report and
plan were marked as Ex.C1 and Ex.C2. The trial court, after evaluating the oral
and documentary evidences adduced on both sides and perusing the records,
passed a common judgment dated 27.09.2004 by decreeing the Suit in O.S.
No.1287 of 1987 and by dismissing the Suit in O.S. No.180 of 1987. Aggrieved
by the said common judgment and decrees, the Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of 1987
st
has preferred an appeal in A.S. No.16 of 2012 and the 1 defendant in O.S.
No.1287 of 1987 has preferred an appeal in A.S. No.17 of 2012 on the file of
the Subordinate Judge, Tiruttani on various grounds.
6. The First Appellate Court has framed the following points for
determination:
(i) Whether the respondent Manimegalai derived title over the Suit
property?
(ii) Whether the appellant Venkatesa Reddy has got undivided half
share in the Suit property?
(iii) Whether the common judgment and decrees dated 27.09.2004 in
O.S. No.180 of 1987 and O.S. No.1287 of 1987 on the file of the District
Munsif, Tiruttani are liable to be set aside?
(iv) To what other reliefs?
__________
Page 12 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
7. Thereafter, the First Appellate Court through its common judgment
dated 17.12.2012, reversed the common judgment of the trial Court and the Suit
in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 was dismissed and O.S. No.180 of 1987 was decreed
by granting preliminary decree. Aggrieved by the said common judgment and
decrees, these second appeals have been preferred.
8. For the sake of convenience and brevity, the parties herein are referred
as plaintiff and defendants, as referred before the trial Court.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant in both the appeals
would submit that originally the Suit property belonged to one Kuppam
Muniappa Reddy and he had one son namely Duraisamy Reddy. After the
demise of the said Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, his son Duraisamy Reddy had
been in possession and enjoyment of the property. The said Duraisamy Reddy
died intestate leaving behind his wife Nagammal and son Subramani. The said
Nagammal and Subramani approached the Tahsildar, Tiruttani and obtained
patta in their favour. For the same property, other persons namely
Govindasamy Reddy, Venkatesa Reddy and M.C. Chandran had also
approached Tahsildar for getting patta. After due enquiry, by recognizing the
ownership of the property, the patta was granted in favour of the said
Nagammal and Subramani through an order dated 20.10.1986. Thereafter, the
said Govindasamy Reddy, Venkatesa Reddy and M.C. Chandran had preferred
__________
Page 13 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
an appeal before RDO, Tiruvallur and the same was also dismissed by
confirming the order of the Tahsildar on 01.04.1987. Thereafter, the appellant
purchased the property from Nagammal and Subramani through a Sale Deed
dated 07.10.1986. Pursuant to the same, she is in possession and enjoyment of
the property. While so, the respondents attempted to interfere with the
appellant’s peaceful possession and enjoymnet of the property, thereby, she
filed the Suit in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 for the reliefs of declaration and
permanent injunction.
9.1. The learned counsel for the appellant would further submit that the
st
1 respondent herein Venkatesa Reddy also filed a Suit in O.S. No.180 of 1987
for the reliefs of partition and separate possession claiming that the said
st
Kuppam Muniappa Reddy is the grand father of the Plaintiff and the 1
defendant and after the demise of their grand father, the property was enjoyed
st
by their father and thereafter, the Plaintiff and the 1 defendant are in possession
st
and enjoyment of the property. While so, the 1 defendant sold the property to
one M.C. Chandran including the share of the Plaintiff and thereby, he filed the
Suit for partition and separate possession. Both the Suits were tried together.
The trial Court has correctly appreciated the facts and decreed the Suit filed by
st
the appellant and dismissed the Suit filed by the 1 respondent. However, the
First Appellate Court reversed the judgment of the trial Court and set aside the
decrees and common judgment passed by the trial Court and decreed the Suit
__________
Page 14 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
st
filed by the 1 respondent and dismissed the Suit filed by the appellant. The
First Appellate Court failed to consider that Kuppam Muniappa Reddy died
leaving behind his son Duraisamy Reddy and the said Duraisamy Reddy died
leaving behind his wife Nagammal and son Subramani and the appellant
purchased the Suit property from Nagammal and Subramani. The First
Appellate Court failed to consider that the respondents have not filed any
st
documents to show that the 1 respondent and Perumal Reddy, are the grand
sons of the said Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The First Appellate Court failed to
consider that the patta was issued in favour of the vendors of the appellant and
they are the legal heirs of the deceased Duraisamy Reddy, who is the son of the
Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The said Duraisamy Reddy had already sold the
other properties of his father through Sale Deeds, which have been marked as
Ex.B.26 and Ex.B.29 . The First Appellate Court failed to consider that the
appellant has produced title deeds of the property and patta was issued in favour
of the vendors of the appellant after due enquiry and the same was challenged
st
before RDO, Tiruvallur and the same was dismissed. The 1 respondent in the
Suit filed by him for partition, has suppressed the RDO proceedings and in the
evidence, he admitted that patta was issued in favour of the vendors of the
st
appellant and also stated that he filed an appeal. The 1 respondent failed to
prove that he is the legal heir of the Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. As per the legal
heirs of M.C. Chandran, the respondents 5 to 8 in S.A. No.852 of 2014 and 8 to
10 in S.A. No.853 of 2014, the deceased M.C. Chandran purchased the property
__________
Page 15 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
from Perumal Reddy and the said Perumal Reddy purchased the property
through a Sale Letter from one Kuppu Reddy, son of Muniappa Reddy.
However, the Tahsildar granted patta to the legal heirs of the deceased
Duraisamy Reddy, who are the vendors of the appellant and thereby, the trial
Court, after considering the evidences in a proper and perspective manner, has
correctly decreed the Suit filed by the appellant and dismissed the Suit filed by
st
the 1 respondent. The First Appellate Court, without considering the judgment
st
and decree passed by the trial Court, erroneously decreed the Suit filed by the 1
respondent and dismissed the Suit filed by the appellant. Therefore, the
judgment and decree passed by the First Appellate Court are liable to be set
aside.
10. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents 2 to 5 in both the
st
appeals would submit that the respondents 9 to 15 are the legal heirs of the 1
respondent. Originally the property belonged to one Kuppam Muniappa Reddy
and the same was sold to one Perumal Reddy. In turn, the Perumal Reddy sold
th
the property to one M.C. Chandran, who is the husband of the 6 respondent
and father of the respondents 7 and 8. Thereafter, he has been in possession and
enjoyment of the property. When he mortgaged the property to one Subramania
Chetty, a Sale Deed was executed in spite of a Mortgage deed and thereafter,
again he purchased the said property and thereby, the said M.C. Chandran was
in possession and enjoyment of the property. After his demise, the respondents
__________
Page 16 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
6 to 8 are in possession and enjoyment of the property. The said M.C. Chandran
also applied for patta in respect of the said property, but the Tahsildar granted
patta in favour of the vendors of the appellant namely Nagammal and her son
Subramani. Thereafter, they preferred an appeal. The Courts below failed to
consider the sale deed executed in favour of M.C. Chandran. Therefore, these
second appeals are liable to be dismissed.
10.1. The learned counsel appearing for the respondents 9 to 15 in both
the appeals would submit that originally the property belonged to Kuppam
Muniappa Reddy. The said Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, who is none other than
st
the grand father of the 1 respondent and Perumal Reddy. The family properties
of Perumal Reddy and Venkatesa Reddy were orally partitioned between them.
However, the Suit property was not partitioned and it was kept as common.
st
While so, the brother of the 1 respondent namely Perumal Reddy, sold the
st
property to one M.C. Chandran including the share of the 1 respondent,
thereby, he filed a Suit for partition. The trial Court failed to consider the case
st
of the 1 respondent in a proper and perspective manner and dismissed the Suit
filed by the Venkatesa Reddy for partition and decreed the Suit filed by the
appellant for declaration. However, the First Appellate Court after considering
the evidences in a proper and perspective manner, has correctly set aside the
common judgment and decrees passed by the trial Court and decreed the Suit
st
filed by the 1 respondent and dismissed the Suit filed by the appellant.
__________
Page 17 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
Therefore, the First Appellate Court has rendered correct findings and correctly
appreciated the facts and law and set aside the judgment and decrees passed by
the trial Court. Therefore, these second appeals are liable to be dismissed.
11. This Court heard both sides and perused the records.
12. This Court has framed the following substantial questions of law:
S.A. No.852 of 2014
Whether the First Appellate Court is right in decreeing the Suit, when
the Plaintiff failed to establish his case, through his pleadings and evidences
as to how he is entitled to the Suit property?
S.A. No.853 of 2014
Whether the First Appellate Court is right in dismissing the appeal for
want of title deeds for the ancestral properties and non suited the Plaintiff on
the ground of suppression of O.S. No.180 of 1987, when both the Suits were
tried jointly?
13. In this case, it is an admitted fact that originally the Suit property
belonged to one Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of
1987 has claimed the property stating that the original owner of the Suit
property namely Kuppam Muniappa Reddy is his grand father. The Plaintiff in
__________
Page 18 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
O.S. No.1287 of 1987 is a purchaser, who claimed the Suit property stating that
she has purchased the property from Nagammal and Subramani, who are the
legal heirs of the deceased Duraisamy, who is the son of the original owner
Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. Both the parties have not disputed that the Suit
property originally belonged to the said Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The
Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of 1987 and the vendors of the Plaintiff in O.S.
No.1287 of 1987 are claiming that they are the legal heirs of the deceased
Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. Both the parties have not filed any document to
show that they are the legal heirs of the deceased Kuppam Muniappa Reddy.
14. The Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 has produced a document
Ex.P.11, the Patta transfer order passed by the Tahsildar in favour of the
vendors of the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987. At the time of patta transfer
proceedings, the Tahsildar also passed the order after due enquiry. The enquiry
proceedings were produced by the concerned officials of Tahsildar office and
the same have been marked as documents and as per the statement of Venkatesa
Reddy, the Kuppam Muniappa Reddy is the maternal uncle of the Plaintiff in
O.S. No.180 of 1987 and he died issueless and thereby, he claimed patta.
Similarly, his brother Perumal Reddy also stated that Kuppam Muniappa Reddy
died issueless and claiming patta in his favour and in favour of his brother
Venkatesa Reddy. Further, the person who obtained Sale Deed from Perumal
Reddy namely M.C. Chandran, has given statement that Nagammal and her son
__________
Page 19 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
Subramani are the legal heirs of the deceased Duraisamy Reddy, who is the son
of Kuppam Muniappa Reddy and thereafter, the patta was transferred in the
names of Nagammal and Subramani. The said M.C. Chandran, Govindasamy
Reddy and Venkatesa Reddy have preferred an appeal and the same was also
dismissed. Thereby, the patta stands in the names of Nagammal and Subramani
and based on the said patta, the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 has purchased
the Suit property from Nagammal and Subramani.
15. The person, who is claiming the title of the property through Kuppam
Muniappa Reddy and claiming partition stating that he and his brother Perumal
Reddy are the legal heirs of Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, has not proved his case
that he is one of the legal heirs of the deceased Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. The
Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 has proved that she purchased the Suit
property from the legal heirs of Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, whereas the Plaintiff
in O.S. No.180 of 1987 failed to prove that they are the legal heirs of the
deceased Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. Though the deceased M.C. Chandran is
also claiming the property stating that he purchased the property from Perumal
Reddy, the said Perumal Reddy had no title over the property and only based on
the Sale Letter allegedly executed by one Kuppu Reddy, he purchased the
property from Perumal Reddy. The Perumal Reddy himself denied the
execution of said deed. The Perumal Reddy had no any right over the property
to sell the same to M.C. Chandran. Moreover, the said M.C. Chandran has also
__________
Page 20 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
participated in the patta proceedings and after granting patta in favour of the
vendors of the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987, he had preferred an appeal and
the said appeal was also dismissed and no further appeal was filed and the order
of Tahsildar issuing patta in favour of Nagammal and Subramani is final.
Further the said Chandran has not preferred any appeal as against the judgments
and decrees passed by the Courts below. Therefore, the Plaintiff in O.S.
No.1287 of 1987 has proved her title through sufficient evidences and the
Plaintiff in O.S. No..180 of 1987 has failed to prove that he is the legal heir of
the deceased Kuppam Muniappa Reddy. Therefore, the Suit in O.S. No.1287 of
1987 is liable to be decreed and the Suit in O.S. No.180 of 1987 is liable to be
dismissed.
16. The trial Court after elaborate discussions, dismissed the Suit filed by
the Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of 1987 and decreed the Suit in O.S. No.1287 of
1987. However, the First Appellate Court has reversed the judgment passed by
the trial Court by holding that the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 has not
produced any previous title deeds for the property. Admittedly there is no
dispute that the property originally belonged to Kuppam Muniappa Reddy and
since it is the ancestral property, there are no title deeds to the property and the
revenue authorities also, after enquiry, granted patta in the names of the legal
heirs of the deceased Kuppam Muniappa Reddy and once the parties admitted
that originally the property belonged to Kuppam Muniappa Reddy and the
__________
Page 21 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 has purchased the property from the legal
heirs of Duraisamy Reddy, Son of Kuppam Muniappa Reddy, she is entitled to
decree for declaration and the Courts need not expect the title deeds for the
ancestral property. The First Appellate Court, without considering that the
Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of 1987 has not proved that he is the legal heir of the
deceased Kuppam Muniappa Reddy and without considering the documents
filed by the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 to show that her vendors are the
legal heirs of the Duraisamy Reddy, son of Kuppam Muniappa Reddy,
erroneously decreed the Suit filed by the Plaintiff in O.S. No.180 of 1987.
Further the First Appellate Court rendered findings that the Plaintiff in O.S.
No.1287 of 1987 has filed the Suit, after filing of the Suit in O.S. No.180 of
1987, by suppressing the filing of previous Suit in O.S. No.180 of 1987. It is
true that the Plaintiff in O.S. No.1287 of 1987 is subsequent to the Suit in O.S.
No.180 of 1987. But both the Suits were tried jointly and common judgment
was pased, therey no question of suppression of previous Suit would arise.
Thus, the substantial question of law formulated in S.A. No.852 of 2014 was
answered in favour of the appellant and as against the respondents and the
substantial question of Law formulated in S.A. No.853 of 2014 is answered in
favour of the appellant and as against the respondents. Therefore, the decrees
and the common judgment passed by the First Appellate Court are liable to be
set aside and the decrees and the common judgment passed by the trial Court
are to be restored.
__________
Page 22 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
17. Accordingly, these second appeals are allowed. The decrees and
common judgment dated 17.12.2012 passed by the First Appellate Court in
A.S. Nos.16 of 2012 and 17 of 2012 on the file of Subordinate Judge,
Thiruttani are set aside. The decrees and the common judgment dated
27.09.2004 passed by the trial Court in O.S. No.180 of 1987 and O.S. No.1287
of 1987 on the file of the District Munsif, Thiruttani are restored. T here shall
be no order as to costs.
16-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
MJS
To
1. The Subordinate Judge, Thiruttani.
2. The District Munsif, Thiruttani.
__________
Page 23 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )

SA Nos. 852 and 853 of 2014
P.DHANABAL J.
MJS
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT IN
SA No. 852 of 2014
AND
SA No. 853 OF 2014
16-11-2026
__________
Page 24 of 24
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )