Narendra Singh And Others vs State of U.P.

Court
Allahabad High Court

Reserved On :- 11.08.2026
Delivered On :- 17.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 542 of 1990
Narendra Singh And Others
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : G.S. Hajela, Vivek Sharma
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Dga

Court No. - 43
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH, J.
HON'BLE VINAI KUMAR DWIVEDI, J.
(Delivered By Hon'ble Siddharth, J.)
1. Heard Sri Vivek Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant no. 2; Sri
Ashwani Yadav, learned A.G.A-I for the State and perused the trial court
record and judgment & order passed by the trial court.
2. This criminal appeal has been preferred against the order and judgment of
Additional Sessions Judge, Moradabad passed in Sessions Trial No. 247 of
1987 dated 19.03.1990 convicting the appellants under Section 302 IPC and
sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life.
3. During the pendency of this criminal appeal the appellant no. 1, Narendra
Singh and appellant no. 3, Dharam Singh, have died and the appeal has
already been dismissed as abated against them. The appeal is being heard
only with regard to appellant no. 2, Chatarpal Singh, who is alive.
4. The prosecution case in brief is that the complainant, Narain Singh,
resides in village Dhaurala, P.S. Bachraon, District Moradabad. The name of
his grand father is Ischman Singh. He married twice. From his first wife,
Roshan Singh was born and from his second wife Risal Singh and Bahal
Singh were born. Risal Singh is father of the complainant. Complainant's
uncle Bahal Singh (deceased) was unmarried. He has also not adopted any
son. Roshan Singh has got two sons, Khacharu and Raghuvir Singh.
Khacharu was murdered about ten years prior to this incident. Accused

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
2
Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal are sons of Khacharu. Accused Dharam
Singh is related to accused Narendra and Chattar Pal. Accused Indar Pal is
son of accused Dharam Singh.
5. Bahal Singh (deceased) used to live with the complainant and his
agricultural land was being cultivated by the complainant Narain Singh.
Bahal Singh has got ten bighas of land. He wanted to give his entire
agricultural land to the complainant and wanted to execute a sale deed in
favour of the complainant. The accused anyhow came to know that Bahal
Singh wanted to execute a sale deed of his land in favour of Narain Singh.
The accused themselves wanted to take the land belonging to Bahal Singh.
Therefore, they started ill will against Bahal Singh.
6. The case of the prosecution is that on 16.8.1986, the complainant, Narain
Singh, along with his uncle, Bahal Singh, went to village Kunwar Khera to
bring a pumping set for the purpose of irrigation. They had gone to obtain
the pumping set from their relative, Mahendra Singh. When they reached the
house of Mahendra Singh, they were informed that his pumping set was not
available, as it was already in use. Therefore, both the complainant and his
uncle, Bahal Singh, started returning home through a narrow lane ( Pagdandi
). When they reached near the field of Moti Singh, it was about 8:00 a.m.
The accused Narendra, Chattar Pal and Inder Pal, armed with Tamancha ,
and Dharam Singh, armed with an SBBL gun, met them. The accused
persons abused Bahal Singh and said that since he would not give his land to
them, they would shoot him dead and take possession of the land
themselves. Thereupon, the accused Inder Pal and Chattar Pal exhorted the
others to shoot him dead. The accused Narendra Singh and Dharam Singh
fired at Bahal Singh with their respective weapons, as a result of which he
fell to the ground. Hearing the sound of gunfire, the witnesses Khem Singh,
Vijay Veer, Prem Singh and Koorey Singh reached the spot. Upon seeing the
witnesses, all four accused persons fled towards the south. Bahal Singh died
on the spot. In the meantime, several other villagers also assembled there.
The complainant, Narain Singh, prepared the written report of the incident
(Ext. Ka 1) and handed it over to O.P. Dhanaura Mandi, P.S. Bachraon. On
the basis of the written report (Ext. Ka 1), a chik report (Ext. Ka 11) was
prepared by Pooran Singh, Head Constable. He also made entries in the
General Diary, a copy of which is Ext. Ka 12. The investigation was taken
up by Sri D.K. Gupta, Sub-Inspector. He recorded the statements of the
witnesses and inspected the place of occurrence. He prepared the site plan

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
3
(Ext. Ka 2). He also inspected the dead body of Bahal Singh, aged about 60
years, and prepared the inquest report in the presence of the Panch witnesses.
The inquest report is Ext. Ka 3.
7. The post mortem of the dead body of deceased, Bahal Singh was
conducted by Dr. Virendra Gupta, Medical Officer, District Hospital,
Moradabad, on 17.8.86 at 2 p.m.
Antemortem Injuries :-
(i) Ten small lacerated wound 1/2cm x 1/2cm in an area of 13
cms & 9cms over the back of chest both side 16cms below the
7th cervical spine, no blackening, charring or tattooing, on
dissection three large metallic shots recovered. one from left lung
and two from anterior chest wall upper part one on either side.
(ii) Lacerated wound of entry 3cm x 3cm over left side of face
2.5cm infront of left ear, Blackening, charring and tattooing
present, there is fracture of maxilla, base of skull and right
temporal bone, tongue is lacerated, margins and brain lacerated.
Six (018) small metallic shots recovered, two from maxilla, four
from scalp on right side and rest with a cap and two wadding
from brain.
(iii) Lacerated wound of entry 2.5cm x 2cm over the upper part of
left ear directed back wards, No charring, tattooing or blackening,
a large yellow metallic bullet, second from scalp 5cm behind the
left ear.
External Examination:-
The deceased was of average built body. Rigor mortis has passed from lower
part of the body. Blood was present in mouth, ear and nostril.
Internal Examination:-
Right temporal bone of skull and maxilla were fractured. Mind, membranes
and base were fractured. Two ounce of liquid food was present in stomach.
Death of deceased occured due to fire arm injuries. The Post
Opinion:-
mortem report is Ext. Ka 14. The Medical
Officer has opined that injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course of

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
4
nature to cause death. All the three injuries were caused by fire arm. They
were caused by three different fire arms. From injury no.1, four big pellets
and from injury no. 2, six small pellets and from injury no. 3, a bullet were
recovered. Injuries could be of 16.08.1986 at 8 a.m.
8. The Investigating Officer after completing the investigation submitted
charge sheet against the accused persons which is Ext. Ka 10. The I.O. also
collected simple soil and blood stained soil from the place of occurrence. A
pair of shoes of the deceased and one empty cartridge were also recovered
from the place of occurrence and a memo was prepared which is Ext. Ka 13.
9. The accused have denied the allegations and have stated that they have
been falsely implicated in the case due to enmity. They pleaded not guilty to
the charge and claimed to be tried.
10. The prosecution have examined Narain Singh, P.W.1; Vijai Veer Singh,
P.W.2; C/S-Sheo Kumar Singh, P.W.3; S.I., Dalip Gupta, P.W.4 and Dr.
Devendra Gupta, P.W.5. P.W.1 is a complainant as well as an eye witness of
the incident. P.W.2 is also an eye-witness of the incident. P.W.3 is a formal
witness, who took the dead body of deceased Bahal Singh to Mortuary for
post mortem. P.W.4 is an Investigating Officer. P.W.5 is a Medical Officer,
who conducted post mortem on the dead body of Bahal Singh. No one has
been examined by accused in their defence.
11. Narain Singh (P.W. 1) is the complainant as well as an eye-witness of
the incident. He has stated that the accused and the deceased belonged to the
same family. His grandfather was Lachman Singh, who had two wives.
From his first wife, Roshan Singh was born, while from his second wife,
Risal Singh and Bahal Singh were born. Risal Singh is the father of the
complainant, whereas Bahal Singh (deceased) was his uncle. Bahal Singh
was unmarried and had not adopted any child. Roshan Singh had two sons,
namely, Khacharu and Raghuvir Singh. Khacharu was murdered about ten
years prior to the incident. The accused Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal are
the sons of Khacharu Singh. The accused Dharam Singh is a relative of the
accused Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal. The accused Inder Pal is the son of
the accused Dharam Singh.
12. He has further stated that his uncle, Bahal Singh, was residing with him
and that he was cultivating his land. Bahal Singh owned about ten bighas of
land. Bahal Singh wanted to execute a sale deed in respect of his land in

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
5
favour of the complainant. The accused came to know that Bahal Singh
wanted to transfer his land in favour of the complainant, Narain Singh.
Therefore, the accused became annoyed with Bahal Singh. The accused
Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal themselves wanted to take possession of the
said land. It is alleged that the offence was committed against this
background. He has stated that on 16.8.1986, he had gone to village Koun
Khera along with Bahal Singh to bring the pumping set of Mahendra Singh
for irrigating his land. When they reached village Koun Khera, they were
informed that the pumping set of Mahendra Singh was not available, as it
was already in use. Therefore, the complainant and Bahal Singh started
returning home from village Koun Khera. They were returning through a
narrow lane ( Pagdandi ) and, at about 8:00 a.m., reached near the field of
Moti Singh. The accused Narendra Singh, Chattar Pal, Dharam Singh and
Inder Pal met them there. The accused Narendra Singh, Chattar Pal and
Inder Pal were armed with Tamancha , while the accused Dharam Singh was
armed with an SBBL gun. The accused threatened Bahal Singh to give his
land to them, failing which they would kill him. Bahal Singh refused to give
his land to them. Thereupon, the accused Narendra Singh, Chattar Pal and
Dharam Singh fired at Bahal Singh with their respective weapons. Bahal
Singh sustained firearm injuries, as a result of which he fell to the ground.
Hearing the sound of gunfire, the witnesses Vijai Veer Singh, Khem Singh
and Prem Singh reached the spot. Several other villagers also arrived
thereafter. After the incident, the accused persons ran away towards the
south-west. Bahal Singh died on the spot.
13. Thereafter, the complainant, Narain Singh, prepared the report of the
incident and handed it over to the police. He has proved his report (Ext. Ka
1). He has explained that, at the time of preparing the F.I.R., he was very
much perturbed and terrified. Therefore, he forgot to mention the name of
the accused Chattar Pal as one of the assailants. However, on the same day,
when his statement was recorded by the I.O., he disclosed the name of the
accused Chattar Pal as an assailant. He has admitted in his cross-examination
that no quarrel had taken place between the accused and the deceased, Bahal
Singh, prior to the incident. He has also stated that after the murder of Bahal
Singh, his entire land came into the name of his father, whose name was
mutated in the revenue records, and that the accused did not file any
objection in the mutation proceedings. He has further stated that the pathway
through which he was returning from village Koun Khera was about 1½ feet

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
6
wide and that dense Kans grass, about 2½ to 3 feet in height, was standing
on both sides of the pathway. The accused Narendra Singh was at a distance
of about three paces from the deceased. The other accused persons were also
at the same distance. Vijai Veer Singh (P.W. 2) is an eye-witness of the
occurrence. He has stated that on the day of the alleged occurrence, he had
gone to ease himself in the field of Moti Singh, where Kans grass was
standing. It was about 8:00 a.m. At the time of the incident, he was towards
the east and south of the Pagdandi on which the incident took place.
14. He has stated that while he was easing himself, he heard the sound of an
altercation. On hearing the altercation and after washing himself, he got up
and saw that the accused Narendra Singh, Dharam Singh, Chattar Pal and
Inder Pal were asking Bahal Singh to give his land to them. Bahal Singh
refused to do so. Thereupon, the accused Chattar Pal and Inder Pal exhorted
that he should be shot dead and that they would take possession of the land
thereafter. The accused Narendra Singh, Chattar Pal and Dharam Singh fired
at Bahal Singh with their respective weapons, as a result of which Bahal
Singh sustained firearm injuries, fell to the ground and died on the spot. The
accused Narendra Singh, Inder Pal and Chattar Pal were armed with country-
made pistols, whereas the accused Dharam Singh was armed with an SBBL
gun. All the accused, except Inder Pal, fired a single shot at Bahal Singh
with their respective weapons. He has further stated that he witnessed the
entire incident with his own eyes. Apart from him, the witnesses Narain
Singh, Khem Singh and Prem Singh were also present at the spot and
witnessed the incident. After the incident, the accused persons ran away
towards the south. He has also stated that the deceased, Bahal Singh, wanted
to give his land to the complainant, Narain Singh. Therefore, the accused
bore enmity with Bahal Singh. He has categorically stated that the accused
Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal are real brothers, whereas the accused
Dharam Singh and Inder Pal are father and son, respectively, and are related
to the accused Narendra Singh. This witness has also admitted that the
accused Dharam Singh had borrowed Rs. 5,000/- from Nanak, his cousin
uncle, out of which Rs. 1,000/- had been repaid by Dharam Singh, while the
remaining amount had not been paid. However, he has denied the suggestion
that Bahal Singh was not murdered on account of the said amount but was
murdered because of his land.
15. The alleged occurrence took place on 16.8.1986 at 8:00 a.m. in the
jungle of village Dhaurala, P.S. Bachraon, which is situated at a distance of

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
7
about 7 kilometres from the police station. The report was lodged at Police
Outpost Dhanaura Mandi on the same day, i.e., 16.8.1986, at 9:15 a.m. Thus,
the report was promptly lodged at the police station. Therefore, it inspires
confidence. The motive for the crime is said to be that the deceased, Bahal
Singh, was unmarried and had not adopted any child. The accused wanted to
acquire his ten bighas of land, but Bahal Singh refused to transfer the land in
their favour. Therefore, the accused bore enmity towards Bahal Singh and,
on account of this annoyance, committed the alleged crime. Narain Singh
(P.W. 1) and Vijai Veer Singh (P.W. 2) are eye-witnesses of the incident.
They have clearly stated that the accused Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal
wanted to acquire the land of the deceased. The accused Dharam Singh and
Inder Pal are their relatives. The evidence on record shows that the land of
Bahal Singh was being cultivated by Narain Singh during his lifetime. This
was not liked by the accused. Therefore, the motive alleged by the
prosecution is clearly established. The accused had a strong motive for
committing the alleged crime. The plea of the defence that the death of
Bahal Singh was more beneficial to the complainant than to the accused
cannot be accepted, because the complainant was already cultivating the
land of Bahal Singh during his lifetime. Therefore, he was not going to gain
anything after the death of Bahal Singh. Moreover, the complainant was
legally entitled to the land belonging to the deceased, Bahal Singh, even
after his death. While Bahal Singh was alive, he had intended to give the
land to the complainant. Therefore, the complainant cannot be said to have
been interested in the death of the deceased, Bahal Singh. Since Bahal Singh
had refused to transfer his land in favour of the accused, they were annoyed
with him and, on account of this annoyance, committed the alleged crime.
Therefore, the motive alleged by the prosecution is clearly established.
16. Narain Singh (P.W. 1) is the complainant as well as an eye-witness of
the incident. He remained with the deceased throughout the period from the
morning until his death. This witness was returning with Bahal Singh from
village Kaun Khera when the alleged incident took place on their way. This
witness has given a detailed description of the incident. He has stated that
the accused Narendra Singh and Chattar Pal fired at Bahal Singh with their
country-made pistols, while the accused Dharam Singh fired at him with his
SBBL gun. As per the post-mortem report, three ante-mortem firearm
injuries were found on the person of the deceased, Bahal Singh. The Medical
Officer has further opined that three firearms of different kinds were used, as

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
8
big pellets, small pellets and a bullet were recovered from the body of the
deceased. This shows that three assailants fired at the deceased with their
respective weapons. This witness, Narain Singh, has stated that Narendra
Singh and Chattar Pal were armed with country-made pistols and fired at
Bahal Singh, while the accused Dharam Singh fired at him with his SBBL
gun. Therefore, the testimony of this witness is fully corroborated by the
medical evidence. Thus, the statement of this witness, being corroborated by
the medical evidence, proves the prosecution case.
17. We find that P.W.-1 is an eyewitness to the incident and is also the real
nephew of the deceased. In the F.I.R., he named only appellant no. 1,
Narendra Singh, and appellant no. 3, Dharam Singh, as the assailants. In his
statement recorded by the Investigating Officer (P.W.-4), the surviving
appellant no. 2, Chatarpal Singh, was named for the first time. P.W.-1
admitted that the writing on the page of the case diary, where his statement
was recorded, is large at the top and small at the bottom. It appears that the
prosecution changed its version after receiving the post-mortem report of the
deceased, as three firearm injuries were found in the said report. The name
of appellant no. 2, Chatarpal Singh, was mentioned before the Court by
P.W.-1 and P.W.-3. Therefore, there is no question of assigning any overt act
to him. No weapon was recovered at the instance of the surviving appellant
no. 2 at all.
18. The Apex Court in the case of
State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Raghuvir
Singh, 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 158 held that :-
" Omission to name all perpetrators in FIR by eyewitness – The omission
by a complainant, claiming to be an eyewitness, to name all perpetrators
in the FIR is a relevant fact under Section 11. Such an omission renders
the complainant's account highly improbable, as it is unnatural for an
eyewitness to selectively name some accused while excluding others
without justification. In a murder case, the Court upheld the acquittal of
an accused, observing that the complainant (the deceased's father) failed
to mention two perpetrators in the FIR, despite alleging their presence at
the crime scene. Such omissions undermine the credibility of the
prosecution's case and are admissible under Section 11 to evaluate the
reliability of the complainant's testimony."
19. In view of the above dictum of the Apex Court, we find that the
statement of P.W.-2 does not appear to be reliable. He claimed that he had
gone to ease himself at a place situated to the west of the village at about

CRLA No. 542 of 1990
9
8:00 a.m., when the incident took place on the village road running through
the middle of the fields, and that he witnessed the incident from there. The
statement of P.W.-2 does not inspire confidence, particularly because, in
villages, people generally wake up early in the morning and go to the field to
ease. This was all the more true in the year 1984 as compared to the present
times. It does not appears probable that P.W.-2 would have gone to ease
himself at 8:00 a.m. in broad daylight and thereafter witnessed the incident
from there.
20. In view of the above consideration, we are inclined to extend benefit of
doubt to surviving appellant no. 2, Chatarpal Singh.
21. The criminal appeal is allowed, qua surviving appellant no. 2, Chatarpal
Singh.
22. The appellant no. 2 is on bail. His bail bond is cancelled and sureties are
discharged. He need not to surrender in this case.
23. Office is directed to return the trial court record along with copy of the
judgment to the trial court for necessary compliance.
November 17, 2026
Rohit
(Vinai Kumar Dwivedi,J.) (Siddharth,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
ROHIT DAS
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad