Mahendrabhai Shankarbhai Amin Through His Constituted Attorney Yogesh Mahendrabhai Amin vs Daxa Maghraj Golecha
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM020315972024
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
ARBITRATION PETITION NO. 351 OF 2025
Mahendrabhai Shankarbhai Amin,Through His
Constituted Attorney Yogesh Mahendrabhai Amin …Petitioner
Versus
Daxa Maghraj Golecha …Respondent
Mr. Mehul Shah a/w Mr. Subham Kanade , for the Petitioner.
Mr. Mayur Khandeparkar, a/w Mr. Monil Punjabi, i/b Mr. Madhur
Surana for Respondent.
Digitally
signed by
ASHWINI
JANARDAN
VALLAKATI
Date:
2026.11.19
15:46:45
+0530
ASHWINI
JANARDAN
VALLAKATI
CORAM: SOMASEKHAR SUNDARESAN, J.
RESERVED ON: APRIL 28, 2026
PRONOUNCED ON: NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Context and Factual Background
1. This is a petition under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 (“ Arbitration Act ”). The Petitioner, Mr. Mahendrabhai Shankarbhai
Amin (“ Amin ”), the Claimant in the arbitration proceedings, challenges an
order dated August 2, 2024 (“ Impugned Order ”) passed by a Learned Sole
Arbitrator.
Page 1 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
2. The Impugned Order dismissed Amin’s application dated March 14,
2024 under Section 17 of the Arbitration Act (“ Section 17 Application ”). The
Respondent in this Petition and in the arbitration is Ms. Daxa Maghraj
Golecha (“ Golecha ”). Amin sues through his constituted attorney, Yogesh
Mahendrabhai Amin.
3. The dispute is between the two continuing partners of M/s. Navakar
Developers (“ Firm ”). The Firm was first formed in 1988 and was reconstituted
1
several times. The present partnership rests on a Deed of Partnership dated
March 17, 2011 (“ Deed ”). Amin holds a 33% share in profits and losses while
Golecha holds 67%. Two earlier partners, Narmadabai Mahendrabhai Amin
and Anil Kumar Gulabchand Jain, retired when the Deed was made – the
Impugned Order terms the retiring partners as the wife and son of Amin.
4. The Firm carries on business as builders, developers, contractors and
dealers in land. It owns land at Malegaon, Nashik, bearing S. No. 302/A,
C.T.S. No. 1105, Plot No. 78, admeasuring about 2 Hectares 81.69 R. It bought
the land under a registered deed of conveyance dated May 11, 1989 for
Rs.10,50,000. The land has been laid out in plots. Buildings have been
constructed on some of them. Flats have been sold in those buildings. Some
plots have been sold as well.
1
The recital in the Deed (Compilation p. 3) says the Firm was initially formed and registered
on March 24, 1988. The Impugned Order (para 37, p. 131) refers to an original partnership
deed of August 11, 1988.
Page 2 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
5. Golecha is the Managing Partner under the Deed. Amin is a “Silent
Partner”. The relevant clauses are reproduced:
“4. It is further expressly agreed by the all the partners hereto i.e. parties of the
First to the Second part that Mrs. Daxa Meghraj Golecha (party of the Second Part
above) (hereinafter referred to as the Managing Partner) shall act as Managing
Partner of the firm and the other Partner i.e. the party of the first part has
empowered her to do all such acts deeds and things in respect of all the transactions
and deals by the firm which shall be binding on all other partners of the firm.
The partnership will open operate existing bank accounts with such bank or banks as
the Managing partner hereto may decide from time to time and the same shall be
operated upon by the sole signature of Mrs. Daxa Meghraj Golechha (party of the
Second Part above).
5. It is hereby expressly mutually agreed by the Partners i.e. parties of the First
to the Second part that all the business policies and other decisions pertaining to the
business of the said firm including in its ordinary course of business or otherwise
relating to all properties, assets including the immovable property which belongs to
the firm or which may be acquired by the Firm including sale of such property/s shall
be taken by the managing partner and same shall be binding on all the partner/s. The
other partner for the time being shall be a Silent Partner.
6. It is further mutually agreed by the partners that the Managing Partner viz.
Mrs. Daxa Meghraj Golecha has express authority on behalf of all the partners to
execute, sign, and enter into any agreements, memorandum of understanding,
development agreements, contracts, etc. for sale/purchase of property in the course of
carrying on any businesses of the Partnership Firm. No document will be binding on
the firm unless it is executed by the Managing Partner solely for and on behalf of the
firm.
7. It is mutually agreed that the Managing Partner viz. Mrs. Daxa Meghraj
Golechha (party of the Second Part above) has express authority on behalf of all the
Page 3 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
partners to execute, sign, acknowledge, and enter into any agreements, memorandum
of understanding, development agreement, leave & license agreements, contracts,
sale, mortgage, lease, etc. in respect of the any immovable property/s of the Firm
situated at viz. property bearing no. 302A, CC.T.S. No. 1105(part), Final plot no. 78
admeasuring 2 hectors, 81.69R situated at village Malegaon, Taluka Malegaon,
District Nasik (Said land) and any building, flat, Row house, Villas, commercial
complex etc. constructed or to be constructed on the said land and also any other
immovable property bought, acquired, either in any joint venture or owned by the
firm in the future all such deals entered into by the said Managing Partner shall be
binding upon the Firm unconditionally and further No ratification will be required
for all or any such act of the Managing Partner.
10. It is further expressly agreed by all the above partners that Mrs. Daxa
Meghraj Golechha (party of the Second Part above)shall represent all the partners as
their constituted attorney in respect of all the transactions and deals by the firm. She
will have power to execute any deeds or documents in respect of any transaction
relating to the business of the firm, to represent the firm while dealing with the
outsiders, or in any court matter and for that purpose to sign and declare pleadings,
affidavits, and other papers, to appoint advocates and to do all acts and things
required to be done in that behalf, to purchase and sell any land, immovable
property, or any part thereof which the Firm would be dealing for its business and
further to do all such acts and deeds which may be necessary for efficient
management and dealing of the Partnership business. A Power of Attorney for this
purpose is executed simultaneously on execution hereof.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
6. Clause 22 deals with dissolution. Both sides call it central to the
dispute:
Page 4 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
“22. The said firm is in the process of commencing the development of the said
land for which purpose the firm is likely to enter into various agreements/contracts
for selling/allotting the premises to Investors/Purchasers and also for raising money
from financial institutions, banks, family members of the partners, their group
companies and/or associates in the course of such development. In the event the
said firm is to be dissolved for any reason whatsoever then in such an event neither
partner shall be entitled to have the said land partitioned by metes and bound,
however the managing partners shall continue the Development of the land and
maintain a separate account thereof. The partners shall respectively be entitled to
profits made from such development on piecemeal basis i.e. as and when there is
sale of premises/units constructed on the said land pursuant to the said development
thereof till such time the said land is fully developed by utilsing the entire
development potential available and land is transferred. On such dissolution any
contracts which are entered into either for purpose of development in favour of any
Purchaser, institution or other entities referred to above will be honoured on
priority basis and prior to making payment to any partner on dissolution. Neither of
the partner shall be entitled to dispute any such contracts for sale, borrowing etc.
and the same shall be binding on the partners.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
7. Clause 22 is to be read with Section 47 of the Indian Partnership Act,
1932 (“ Partnership Act ”). Section 47 reads thus:
“47. Continuing authority of partners for purposes of winding up.—
After the dissolution of a firm the authority of each partner to bind the firm, and the
other mutual rights and obligations of the partners, continue notwithstanding the
dissolution, so far as may be necessary to wind up the affairs of the firm and to
complete transactions begun but unfinished at the time of the dissolution, but not
otherwise:
Page 5 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
Provided that the firm is in no case bound by the acts of a partner who has been
adjudicated insolvent; but this proviso does not affect the liability of any person who
has after the adjudication represented himself or knowingly permitted himself to be
represented as a partner of the insolvent.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
8. The Deed also makes the Firm a partnership at will. It sends all
disputes to a sole arbitrator (Clause 25):
“25. The partnership shall be at will and all disputes and questions which shall
either during the continuance of the partnership or afterwards arise between the
partners or their representatives touching these presents or the construction or
application thereof or any clause or thing herein contained or any account. Valuation
or division of assets, debts or liabilities of any partner under these presents shall be
referred to the Arbitration of a sole arbitrator who will be either a practicing
Chartered Accountant or any Counsel practicing in High Court Mumbai subject to
the provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 or any statutory modification
or re-enactment thereof for the time being in force.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
9. Amin’s case in the arbitration is that Golecha has been in exclusive
control of the Firm’s business. She has rendered no accounts and shared no
profit. She developed the land behind his back, built apartment buildings and
sold a large part of them. She misused the powers in the Deed and in a
General Power of Attorney granted to her. She sold the Firm’s properties at
low prices to show continuous losses. She shared the Firm’s profits with her
Page 6 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
husband’s company. She kept cheque books, bank statements and title
2
documents away from him.
3
10. The General Power of Attorney is dated March 22, 2011 (“ GPA ”). Amin
4
revoked the GPA by an advocate’s notice dated July 24, 2019. He issued a
public notice on July 25, 2019 detailing the cancellation of the GPA and wrote
to authorities on July 30, 2019 informing of the same. Golecha issued a public
notice on July 29, 2019 in response. She said she continued as the Managing
Partner and was transacting under the Deed. On March 29, 2023, Amin
issued a “notice of dissolution” through his advocates. He called on Golecha to
cease and desist from running the Firm’s business and from dealing with its
assets. He treats this as dissolving the Firm.
11. Golecha’s case is that she acts as Managing Partner with express
authority under the Deed. She also relies on minutes of a meeting of the two
partners dated September 27, 2011. They read as follows:
2
Impugned Order, paras 6 to 8 (pp. 95 to 97). Amin’s Statement of Claim seeks a declaration
that the Firm stands dissolved, accounts, a share of the surplus assets and profits with
interest at 18% per annum, and injunctions (para 2, pp. 90 to 94).
3
Compilation pp. 100 to 107. The Impugned Order (para 49, p. 136) records it as dated
March 22, 2012 and as granted by the erstwhile partners, the wife and son of Amin. Amin’s
Brief Note (p. 2) describes it as granted by Amin. The signature block (Compilation p. 107)
names Narmadabai Mahendrabhai Amin, Anilkumar Gulabchand Jain and Mahendrabhai
Amin.
4
Compilation pp. 112 to 115. The Impugned Order records the notice as dated July 24, 2019
in para 7 (p. 96) but as dated September 24, 2019 in para 26(xiv) (p. 114).
Page 7 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
“MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD ON 27/09/2011 of M/s. Navakar Developers
(“firm”) at Malegaon wherein Mahendrabhai Amin and Daxa Golecha partners of
the firm were present and have agreed as follows:
1. The firm is developing the property at Malegaon, Mrs. Daxa Golecha is the
partner who is authorized and is looking after the entire development process and is
authorized which includes the following:-
(i) To settle with the tenants, including by way of paying them full
compensation and/or part compensation and part constructed area or in any
other manner as she may deem fit.
(ii) To complete all formalities as may be required to obtain Non-
Agricultural permissions.
(iii) To get the plan prepared and have the same approved by the
concerned department/authority and for that purpose to appoint architect,
engineers etc.
(iv) To accept bookings in respect of the premises to be constructed at any
time including prior to approval of the plans or thereafter in the interest of the
firm at any price above Rs.1300/- per sq.ft. built up area.
2. It is agreed by parties that the decisions taken by the Daxa Golecha as per the
discussions held in the meeting and as narrated above and/or in respecft of any other
matter arising during the course of development will be binding on the firm and the
partners.
3. Both partners have accepted the above minutes and in token of acceptances
have signed at the foot of these minutes.
Date: 27/09/2011”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 8 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
12. Golecha says Amin is a sleeping partner who has contributed nothing to
the Firm’s expenses and has overdrawn his capital account. She says the Firm
is involved in a RERA-registered project with obligations to flat purchasers.
She says Clause 22 and Section 47 allow her to continue with the development
and sale even if the Firm stands dissolved. She disputes that the Firm stands
validly dissolved. She has filed a Counter Claim.
13. Amin first approached this Court under Section 9 of the Arbitration Act
(Arbitration Petition (L) No. 10328 of 2023). On April 26, 2023, this Court
declined to grant injunctive reliefs without a proper reply, in an ongoing
development project. It directed Golecha to file a detailed affidavit-in-reply,
placing on record the relevant details with supporting documents. It also
directed her to make appropriate disclosure, limited to prayer clause (f) of the
5
Section 9 Petition.
14. Amin then applied under Section 11 (Arbitration Application (L) No.
11244 of 2023). By an order dated January 10, 2024, this Court appointed the
Learned Sole Arbitrator. On February 8, 2024, the Section 9 petition was
disposed of with liberty to apply under Section 17 before the Learned Sole
Arbitrator.
5
Exhibit “AG” (pp. 64 to 65), reproduced at Compilation pp. 477 to 478. The petition (para
4, p. 15, and Ground J, p. 22) and the synopsis (p. 7) incorrectly date this order April 26,
2024. The order itself reads April 26, 2023.
Page 9 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
15. Amin filed his Statement of Claim and the Section 17 Application on
March 14, 2024. Golecha replied on April 15, 2024. Amin tendered a Brief
Aide Memoire on June 26, 2024. Golecha replied to it. Amin filed a brief
response, a compilation and a note on the appointment of a Receiver. After
the hearing ended, Amin’s advocate wrote on July 27, 2024 that Golecha had
completed one more transaction, on July 19, 2024.
16. The Section 17 Application sought the following:
A] a disclosure on oath, an inspection of originals and the true
accounts: the Firm’s books of accounts from inception, the agreements
and MoUs, and Golecha’s personal bank statements from March 17,
2011;
B] an injunction against creating third-party rights in the Firm’s
assets or dealing with its plots;
C] restraint on Golecha, her family and agents from carrying on the
Firm’s business, operating its bank accounts, or alienating, mortgaging
or encumbering its properties;
D] a direction to deposit Rs.15,26,15,826 as the estimated share of
Amin’s profits; and
E] appointment of a Receiver of the Firm’s business, assets and
books.
Page 10 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
17. Amin summarised his grievances under five heads:
A] Golecha carrying on the Firm’s business after its dissolution and
after revocation of the power of attorney;
B] Sale of units at or below Ready Reckoner value by Golecha;
C] Sale transactions with third parties in contravention of the Deed
and in bad faith by Golecha, contrary to Clauses 13 and 27 and Sections
9 and 10 of the Partnership Act;
D] Fraud by Golecha; and
E] Golecha dealing with assets that she could not deal with. His brief
Aide Memoire listed seven instances: sales and gifts to purported
relatives below the ready reckoner price; two leave and licence
agreements dated September 22, 2019; the alteration of the property
card; five flats given on leave and licence; creation of a mortgage against
property of the firm; the MoU dated November 17, 2022 with Suhit
Buildwell LLP; and sales to Anup Pahade.
18. The Impugned Order, which dismisses the Section 17 Application, may
be summarised in a nutshell, thus:
A] Clause 22 of the Deed read with Section 47 of the Partnership Act,
indicates prima facie that Golecha continues to have the power, and the
duty, to carry on the Firm’s business after dissolution;
Page 11 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
B] The Deed gives Golecha all the powers of a Managing Partner and
makes her the constituted attorney of the other partners under Clause
10. The minutes and the General Power of Attorney also empower her;
C] Amin is a Silent Partner with a 33% share, and Golecha does the
entire work. No real challenge was found to her authority to carry on
the business under Clause 22 after dissolution. The real objection is the
allegation of fraud through undervaluation;
D] The allegation of a cash element in the sales was made only in oral
arguments and in the written note, and not in the pleadings;
E] It was held to be difficult to accept that every sale at or below
Ready Reckoner value was fraudulent, recording Golecha’s explanations
for the sale prices. A Sleeping Partner is justified in keeping a watchful
eye but cannot allege fraud “at the drop of a hat” without reasonably
acceptable evidence;
F] Sale of immovable property by a firm in the business of
developing and selling land cannot automatically be construed as waste
of the Firm’s property;
G] Much of the material can be part of the evidence at the final
hearing. There was no need to stop the progress of the ongoing project,
which was in the best interest of the Firm and its partners. A Receiver
Page 12 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
and an injunction are not needed where Amin as the claimant can be
compensated in money; and
H] Amin’s grievance of unilateral business decisions is not tenable
because the Deed makes Golecha the Managing Partner. While the
power of attorney is alleged to have been revoked, Golecha has not acted
under it and has acted as Managing Partner.
19. Amin is aggrieved that the Impugned Order accepts the dominance of
Clause 22. He says the arguments made by the parties were not considered.
He says the Arbitrator refused disclosures, inspection and security for his
claim. The Section 37 Court is called upon to set aside the Impugned Order
and allow the Section 17 Application. In the alternative, modifications are
sought: security by deposit of the amount of the claim; a restraint on Golecha
from creating third-party rights or executing documents in respect of the
Firm’s assets; and disclosures sought in the Section 17 Application.
20. Against this backdrop, I have heard at length, Mr. Mehul Shah, Learned
Advocate on behalf of Amin and Mr. Mayur Khandeparkar, Learned Advocate
on behalf of Golecha. With their assistance, I have examined the record and
by consent of the advocates the Section 37 Petition was taken up for final
hearing.
Page 13 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
Points for Determination:
21. The grounds of challenge in the petition broadly fall into five heads,
which are indicative of the following points for determination:
A] Whether the Learned Sole Arbitrator’s reading of Clause 22 of the
Deed and Section 47 of the Partnership Act as allowing Golecha to deal
with the Firm’s assets even after dissolution is tenable considering
Section 28 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, Section 115 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 and Sections 7, 9, 10, 15, 16 and 43 of the
Partnership Act;
B] Whether Amin’s contention that Golecha had no authority to deal
with the Firm’s assets after the 2019 revocation of the power of attorney
and the March 29, 2023 notice of dissolution is tenable;
C] Whether Amin’s contention that the sales of flats and plots at or
below Ready Reckoner value, including the sales to Golecha’s relatives,
the sale of 18 flats to Dipen Jain, the gifted flat and the sales to Anup
Pahade, make out a prima facie case of fraud and loss to the Firm;
D] Whether payments to Rajebahadur Pannalal Manufacturing Co.
Pvt. Ltd. (“ Rajebahadur Company ”), the lessee, the leave and licence
agreements, the mortgage, the MoU with Suhit Buildwell LLP and the
Page 14 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
property card, show siphoning of the Firm’s funds, in breach of Sections
10, 15 and 16 of the Partnership Act; and
E] Whether the Learned Sole Arbitrator ought to have directed
disclosures and accounts, restrained further dealings, secured his claim
or appointed a Receiver.
Analysis and Findings
22. Each of these points is dealt with below, bearing in mind the scope of
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 37 of the Arbitration Act. In a
nutshell, it must be remembered that the Section 37 Court must not substitute
the wisdom of a Learned Arbitral Tribunal only because another view is
possible but it has to consider whether the Learned Arbitral Tribunal being the
best judge of the matter in hand has taken a view that is perverse and
untenable, warranting intervention.
Standard of Review:
23. It is well settled law that appeals (and this would include appeals under
Section 37 of the Arbitration Act) are to be regarded as a continuation of the
original proceeding, and unless there is a statutory requirement to the
contrary, the powers of the appellate forum are co-extensive with the power of
6
the forum whose adjudication is under appeal – in this case the Section 17
6
Jute Corporation of India Ltd. Vs. CIT – 1991 Supp 2 SCC 744
Page 15 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
jurisdiction of the Learned Arbitral Tribunal. Therefore, it is well settled that
when this Court exercises its jurisdiction under Section 37 of the Arbitration
Act, its power may be exercised in the same manner in which power was
exercisable under Section 17 of the Arbitration Act.
24. Equally, an appellate Court exercising the power under Section 37 of the
Arbitration Act, to review the exercise of discretion by an Arbitral Tribunal, is
well guided by the principles set out by the Supreme Court in Wander vs.
7
Antox . The Section 37 Court may interfere only if there is something perverse
or implausible in the exercise of discretion. The following extract would
suffice:
“14. The appeals before the Division Bench were against the exercise of discretion
by the Single Judge. In such appeals, the appellate court will not interfere with the
exercise of discretion of the court of first instance and substitute its own discretion
except where the discretion has been shown to have been exercised arbitrarily, or
capriciously or perversely or where the court had ignored the settled principles of
law regulating grant or refusal of interlocutory injunctions. An appeal against
exercise of discretion is said to be an appeal on principle. Appellate court will not
reassess the material and seek to reach a conclusion different from the one reached
by the court below if the one reached by that court was reasonably possible on the
material. The appellate court would normally not be justified in interfering with the
exercise of discretion under appeal solely on the ground that if it had considered the
matter at the trial stage, it would have come to a contrary conclusion. If the
discretion has been exercised by the trial court reasonably and in a judicial manner
7
Wander Ltd. Vs. Antox India (P) Ltd. – 1990 Supp SCC 727
Page 16 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
the fact that the appellate court would have taken a different view may not justify
interference with the trial court's exercise of discretion.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
25. In a plethora of judgements, the principle articulated in Wander vs.
Antox has been followed and reiterated. With this in mind, I have set out my
judgement on the points for determination listed above.
Clause 22 and Section 47 and Authority :
26. Amin’s contention is essentially that Clause 22 of the Deed cannot
constrain his legal remedy. An agreement that absolutely restricts a party
from enforcing his rights by the usual legal proceedings is void to that extent.
Towards this end, he would invoke Section 28 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872
(“ Contract Act ”), which reads thus:
“28. Agreements in restraint of legal proceedings, void.:
Every agreement,- (a) by which any party thereto is restricted absolutely from
enforcing his rights under or in respect of any contract, by the usual legal
proceedings in the ordinary tribunals, or which limits the time within which he may
thus enforce his rights; or (b) which extinguishes the rights of any party thereto, or
discharges any party thereto, from any liability, under or in respect of any contract
on the expiry of a specified period so as to restrict any party from enforcing his
rights, is void to that extent.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
Page 17 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
27. Amin would contend that Clause 22 applies only where there is no other
dispute. Golecha cannot use Clause 22 to sell properties at undervalued
consideration, and the Tribunal cannot be powerless to stop it. Put differently,
he would submit that his consent in the Deed inasmuch as the Managing
Partner’s decisions bind him, does not estop him from exercising his legal
rights. He would invoke Section 115 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
8
(“ Evidence Act ”) which reads thus :
“115. Estoppel :-
When one person has, by his declaration, act or omission, intentionally caused or
permitted another person to believe a thing to be true and to act upon such belief,
neither he nor his representative shall be allowed, in any suit or proceeding between
himself and such person or his representative, to deny the truth of that thing.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
28. A consent that is contrary to law is no consent. Regardless of the
consent in the Deed, Amin’s rights under Sections 7, 9, 10, 15, 16 and 43 of the
Partnership Act remain intact. Moreover, the words “ for the time being ” in
Clause 5 of the Deed (extracted above) cannot make Amin a silent partner in
perpetuity. The parties never intended him to be a “mute spectator” to
Golecha’s illegalities. That apart, once the Firm is dissolved, no partner can
use it exclusively. Amin contends that, on dissolution of a partnership at will,
each partner is entitled to the property of the Firm under Section 47 of the
8
The Evidence Act has been repealed and substituted by the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam,
2023
Page 18 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
9
Partnership Act . Golecha’s continuing sales contravene Section 47 and are
meant to frustrate his interests in the form of his 33% share.
29. Amin would also contend that the power of attorney was revoked on
July 24, 2019 while the Firm was dissolved on March 29, 2023. Yet, Golecha
entered into sale agreements after the revocation of such power. Golecha also
sold plots to Anup Pahade on April 4, 2024, after the Section 17 Application
was filed, and again on July 19, 2024, after the hearing ended. Amin had
written to the Learned Sole Arbitrator about the July 19, 2024 sale and he took
no action.
30. Amin would also submit that Golecha’s “unilateral” decisions on the
flats she had sold to Dipen Jain on her own say-so, without recourse to Amin,
and the alteration of the property card behind his back necessitate
intervention. Her conduct is accused as a fraud to deprive the Firm and Amin
of their rights, and therefore, she ought not to be permitted to continue to run
the Firm’s affairs in these circumstances.
31. The Impugned Order records that Golecha for her part would contend
that her authority comes from the Deed (Clauses 4 to 7, 10 and 22), not from
the power of attorney. They let her sell the Firm’s immovable property, bind
the Firm and act as the other partners’ attorney. Amin is a Silent Partner. The
9
The provision cited here ought to be Section 46 of the Partnership Act since Section 47
relates to continuing authority to bind the firm whereas Section 46 covers the right of
partners to have business wound up after dissolution.
Page 19 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
business of the Firm includes sale of land and flats. With that context, Clause
22 and Section 47 apply even on dissolution. As the Managing Partner she is
required to continue with the development. Contracts for sale and borrowing
are honoured on priority and cannot be disputed by either partner. She has
not signed as constituted attorney. She has acted as Managing Partner, and
Amin does not deny it.
32. Besides, Golecha would contend that the minutes of September 21, 2011
expressly authorise her to settle with the lessee, to obtain permissions and to
accept bookings at any price above Rs.1,300 per sq. ft. built-up. Her decisions
bind the Firm and both partners. Amin’s notice of July 24, 2019 itself sought
to dissolve the Firm. (Amin has contended that the dissolution was by notice
dated March 29, 2023). Section 47 then applied, and the Firm could take on
no new obligations, but it had to complete its current projects. When the sales
to Anup Pahade had been made, there was no embargo or injunction. This
Court had declined ad-interim relief on April 26, 2023.
33. Golecha would also contend that the dissolution is itself disputed. The
question is whether the partnership is at will and whether it can be dissolved
before the project is complete. In any case, after the alleged dissolution,
Golecha could take on no new obligations, and therefore, the funds from sales
were needed to complete current projects.
Page 20 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
34. I have carefully examined what has weighed with the Learned Sole
Arbitrator in this context. I must highlight and reiterate that while the
emphasis of submissions made at an interim stage is being dealt with, an
impression may be carried that the Learned Arbitral Tribunal has taken a firm
and final view on some facets of the matter, the legal reality is that nothing in
the Impugned Order subserves any analysis beyond examining if any
interlocutory arrangement in the form of an injunction is necessary. The
Learned Sole Arbitrator has analysed the contentions on questions of law –
primarily on authority and the implications of Clause 22 of the Deed and
Section 47 of the Partnership Act, and I find that his approach is not perverse
or contrary to law.
35. Clause 22 of the Deed and Section 47 of the Partnership Act have been
extracted above. Indeed, the Deed indicates that Amin is a silent partner and
agency over the decisions of the Firm was firmly vested in Golecha. Indeed,
this cannot be a licence to run the Firm without being accountable, but equally
for disputed transactions to be regarded as fraud, evidence would need to be
led and the allegation would need to be subjected to trial. Clause 22 records
that the Firm was in the process of commencing development of the particular
parcel of land and that the Firm was likely to enter into various contracts and
also raise funds including from family members and group companies. Clause
22 also envisaged the prospect of dissolution of the Firm and recorded that in
Page 21 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
such event the land cannot be partitioned, and that the Managing Partner shall
continue the development and maintain a separate account, with the partners
being entitled to profits. Contracts already executed would have to be
honoured on a priority basis ahead of payments to any partner payable on
dissolution.
36. In this context Section 47 of the Partnership Act must be analysed.
After dissolution, the authority of the partners to bind the Firm and other
mutual rights and obligations would continue notwithstanding the dissolution .
This is to the extent necessary to wind up the Firm and to complete
transactions begun but unfinished at the time of dissolution.
37. When one examines the analysis in the Impugned Order in this regard,
it is difficult to find fault with the Learned Sole Arbitrator. Indeed, Section 47
of the Partnership Act provides for continuation of the mutual rights and
obligations among partners. The mutual rights and obligations are those
reduced to writing in the Deed. This includes all the clauses of the Deed
extracted above. The terms of the partnership entailed giving Golecha the
primacy to take decisions and bind the Firm. This does not mean that Golecha
would have a free pass to not be accountable to the Firm – and her conduct
including value-erosive decisions can form subject matter of trial in the
arbitration. That would entail evidence and demonstration of the allegations
of fraud and value erosion as alleged by Amin. The question at this stage is
Page 22 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
whether a case is made out to injunct Golecha from acting further – to my
mind, the decision of the Learned Sole Arbitrator is to respect the provisions
contracted in the Deed, which read with Section 47 of the Partnership Act,
does not place the Impugned Order in the realm of illegality or perversity to
warrant interference by the Section 37 Court.
38. The provisions of Sections 7, 9, 10, 15, 16 and 43 of the Partnership Act,
relied upon by Amin, are noteworthy and extracted below:
“7. Partnership at will.—
Where no provision is made by contract between the partners for the duration of their
partnership, or for the determination of their partnership, the partnership is
“partnership at will”.”
“9. General duties of partners.—
Partners are bound to carry on the business of the firm to the greatest common
advantage, to be just and faithful to each other, and to render true accounts and full
information of all things affecting the firm to any partner, his heir or legal
representative.”
“10. Duty to indemnify for loss caused by fraud :-
Every partner shall indemnify the firm for any loss caused to it by his fraud in the
conduct of the business of the firm.”
“15. Application of the property of the firm :-
Subject to contract between the partners, the property of the firm shall be held and
used by the partners exclusively for the purposes of the business.”
Page 23 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
“16. Personal profits earned by partners. –
Subject to contract between the partners, - (a) if a partner derives any profit for
himself from any transaction of the firm, or from the use of the property or business
connection of the firm or the firm name, he shall account for that profit and pay it to
the firm; (b) if a partner carries on any business of the same nature as and competing
with that of the firm, he shall account for and pay to the firm all profits made by him
in that business.”
“43. Dissolution by notice of partnership at will.—
Where the partnership is at will, the firm may be dissolved by any partner giving
notice in writing to all the other partners of his intention to dissolve the firm. The firm
is dissolved as from the date mentioned in the notice as the date of dissolution or, if
no date is so mentioned, as from the date of the communication of the notice.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
39. As stated earlier, these are the provisions that enshrine the duty and
accountability that a partner owes to another in a partnership firm, and that is
not wiped out at all. All that the Impugned Order does effectively is to hold
that this would need to be proved and subjected to trial and there cannot be
interim relief to secure damages. I have no doubt in my mind that the
accountability mechanisms will run their course in the course of the trial, with
both sides having their entitlement to prove their respective positions. The
question today is whether injunctive relief ought to be granted to Amin on the
basis of his allegations. The Learned Sole Arbitrator has concluded that in his
view, it is not necessary to injunct Golecha from running the firm. I don’t see
the need to interfere with that position.
Page 24 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
40. In my view, Golecha does not have a free pass to not be accountable.
That accountability would flow from the trial to be conducted in the
arbitration, based on pleadings, marshalling of evidence and appreciation of
the same. The findings in the Impugned Order and in this judgement are only
in aid of assessing whether a different conclusion is warranted on what is an
appropriate interlocutory arrangement.
41. In the result, on the first two points of determination listed above, I do
not find a need to interfere with the Impugned Order.
Value Eroding and Fraudulent Transactions:
42. This brings me to the next issue of the gravity of the allegations made –
in particular the contention that transactions are being done with
undervaluation and with related parties in a manner that erodes value for the
Firm. Amin has filed a chart of 69 flats sold showing the booking date, the
agreed price, the Ready Reckoner value and the registration date. Almost all
the sales are below Ready Reckoner value, he contends. Such value being
merely a benchmark for stamp duty, and not a true market value barometer,
Amin contends that the Ready Reckoner value on the date of the agreement
and its registration would be higher than the date on which the booking was
done. Flats were booked in 2014 but registered in 2020 while flats sold in
2019 to 2022 record much the same rates.
Page 25 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
43. Amin alleges that Golecha sold a flat to her son, Nishit M. Golecha, at
the Ready Reckoner price with no clear visibility that payment was indeed
received. She is alleged to have sold flats to Sunil S. Golecha, whom Amin says
is also a relative. She gifted a flat to Shri Akhil Bharatiya Samastha Jain
Shravak Sangh, a trust run by Mohanlal Golecha, whom Amin says is also a
relative. He adds that a trustee is her brother-in-law and chartered
accountant. A total of 18 flats were sold to Dipen Jain, nine of them with three
bedrooms and nine with two bedrooms at Rs.22 lakhs and Rs.18 lakhs
respectively, all below the Ready Reckoner value. A cost of Rs.11 lakhs per flat
was waived as interior cost (as pleaded in Ground P), so the effective price is
about Rs.11 lakh per flat even while the market value per flat is about Rs.50
lakhs.
44. Transactions with Mr Anup Pahade have also come in for serious
allegations. Various sub-plots of Plot 78/A are said to have been sold with
only 60% consideration coming to the Firm and 40% going to a company in
which Golecha’s husband is a shareholder. Amin alleges that a sale deed was
executed against post-dated cheques, which indicates a large cash component.
He says Section 19(2)(g) of the Partnership Act bars one partner from selling
the Firm’s immovable property. Amin apprehends undisclosed cash
consideration. The low recorded prices indicates that cash was pocketed.
Page 26 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
45. The sales are alleged to be violative of Clauses 13 and 27 of the Deed and
Sections 9 and 10 of the Partnership Act. While Sections 9 and 10 of the
Partnership Act have been extracted above, Clauses 13 and 27 of the Deed are
extracted below:
“13. Each partner hereto subject to what is herein provided shall be just and
faithful to each other and indemnify the Firm for any loss caused to it by willful
negligence or fraud in the conduct of the business.
27. Each partner shall: a. be just and faithful to the others of them in all
transactions relating to the partnership and b. At all times give to the other of them a
just and faithful account of the transactions relating to the partnership and also upon
every reasonable request furnish a full and correct explanation thereof to the other.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
46. Golecha contends that sales at Ready Reckoner value must not be
presumed to be undervalued. There is no basis for Amin’s valuation.
Undervaluation is a disputed question of fact that needs evidence on oath,
tested in cross-examination. In the absence of specific sale instances, the
Ready Reckoner can be treated as market value. Golecha offered Amin the
unsold flats at the rate he said was genuine, and he declined. He valued the
flats at Rs.4,500 per sq. ft., about Rs.38,55,000 per flat for a two-bedroom
flat, and would not buy even at the discounted rates. Golecha also finds fault
with Amin for comparing the Ready Reckoner rate at the time of possession,
Page 27 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
when the bookings were made years earlier, between 2013 and 2017, and the
money went into the Firm’s bank account.
47. Golecha denies being related to Sunil Golecha. The flat sold to Nishit
Golecha was sold at the Ready Reckoner value of Rs.27.21 lakh. The flats sold
to Sunil Golecha (Flat Nos. 101 and 104) were funded by a housing loan from
Bank of Baroda, secured only by a mortgage of those flats. The 18 flats sold to
Dipen Jain were bare-shell flats, sold in bulk in December 2020, during the
pandemic and in a bad market. Funds were needed for construction. The
Government had allowed a 20% reduction below Ready Reckoner value for
flats sold during the pandemic. Amin was offered 29 flats on the same
discount and refused. The sale of Flat E-201 for Rs.22 lakh to Dipen Jain was
cancelled on December 28, 2023. The Firm sold it for Rs.33.93 lakh to Yogesh
Jadhav.
48. Golecha contends that Flat 101 was gifted to the Jain Sangh Trust as a
business decision, for a temple (derasar), to attract buyers from the Jain
community. Mr. Mohanlal Golecha is neither her relative nor the only trustee
of the Jain Sangh Trust, the Impugned Order records Golecha as contending.
49. As regards Plot 78/A, Golecha contends that the sales were at Ready
Reckoner values as on the dates of sale. Index II of neighbouring plots shows
identical rates in the vicinity (Rs.10,950 per sq. m.). There was no embargo
Page 28 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
and no ad-interim order. Anup Pahade is not a party and no prayer is made to
annul the sales. The sale of land is within Clause 2 of the Deed. The 40%
share went to Rajebahadur Company because it was the lessee in possession
and possession had to be given to the buyer. The minutes of September 21,
2011 had authorised Golecha to settle with the lessee.
50. I have examined these allegations and the manner in which the
Impugned Order dealt with them. On the face of it, there are apparently
strong counter-arguments presenting a prima facie counter-view on each of
the allegations. The Learned Arbitral Tribunal has taken a view that these
allegations would need to be subjected to trial. At first blush, sales at Ready
Reckoner values indeed appear odd, but equally, the market conditions at the
relevant time and the justifications for the sale would need to be subjected to
trial. Indeed, if Amin had been offered the same rates, he ought to have been
able to get buyers at those terms even if he was not capable of purchasing
himself.
51. In my view, with the caveat that nothing in the Impugned Order
(including observations about fraud allegations being made “at the drop of a
hat”) is to be taken as firm findings of any conclusive nature but observations
in aid of prima facie observations at an interlocutory stage, and with a
clarification that nothing in the Impugned Order would be indicative of the
quality of evidence being commented upon for the trial stage, I am not
Page 29 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
inclined to hold that the assessment by the Learned Arbitral Tribunal was a
perverse assessment. Purely as an equity measure, that the offer was made to
Amin himself does balance the consideration of an interlocutory arrangement.
A claim for indemnity requires the loss to be indemnified to be proved. This
would involve answering a question of fact and would be subject matter of
evidence and trial.
52. I am conscious that appointment of a Receiver is ordinarily followed in
the event of dissolution of a partnership, but in this case, the Deed records the
arrangement between the parties in the event of the Firm being dissolved. The
Deed contains a conscious bargain among the parties, including a bargain on
how the partners would conduct themselves upon the event of dissolution.
Therefore, I am not inclined to second-guess the Learned Arbitral Tribunal’s
view in this regard.
Certain Directions:
53. I think it appropriate to issue certain directions to enable flow of precise
information to the Learned Arbitral Tribunal to be able to assess and factor in
such information in the course of the proceedings. While the Learned Arbitral
Tribunal’s decision is not interfered with, it would appear that in the interests
of justice and full transparency, the Learned Arbitral Tribunal should have
access to fuller information about certain facets of the transactions to enable
Page 30 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
the Learned Arbitral Tribunal to make a better-informed assessment of the
conduct of the parties and to fashion any measures necessary.
54. It is made clear that all allegations including the role of Rajebahadur
Company and its payment of lease rentals and probity of its 40% share in the
sale consideration shall be subjected to trial. The precise stake and interest of
Golecha’s husband in this entity would also need to be demonstrated, along
with documentary evidence in support of such stake. All dealings between the
entity and the Firm including the status of payment of lease rentals and the
justification of the 40% share of consideration shall be provided by way of an
affidavit, along with documentary evidence in support. The Learned Arbitral
Tribunal shall issue appropriate instructions for disclosures in this regard.
55. Likewise, the facts and circumstances surrounding the grant of leave
and licence agreements in 2019 for 18 flats would need to be subjected to
evidence and trial. Suffice it to say, full disclosures of all transactions are to be
given by Golecha to Amin as a matter of disclosure and in discharge of
obligations as a partner of the firm to another partner. Golecha’s answer
appears to be that these agreements were unwound. The precise status of
when the leave and licence agreements were executed, registered, and when
they were unwound, and truthful account of all commercial and monetary
transactions relating to the leave and licence agreements shall be provided by
Page 31 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
Golecha to the Learned Arbitral Tribunal and to Amin, along with
documentary evidence in support.
56. Finally, on the transactions with Anup Pahade, there are discrepancies
although not material. It appears that the plot numbers, the year, and the
price across the submissions of the parties and the Impugned Order appear to
have some variations. The July 19, 2024 sale is not dealt with in the
Impugned Order and is not addressed by Golecha in the record squarely. The
precise details of all transactions with Anup Pahade along with documentary
evidence in support shall be filed with the Learned Arbitral Tribunal by
Golecha by way of an affidavit.
57. Such disclosures shall be made by Golecha on affidavit within a period
of four weeks from the upload of this judgement on the Court’s website and
filed with the Learned Arbitral Tribunal and with Amin. It is for the Learned
Arbitral Tribunal to take a view on such information and it shall be open to the
Learned Arbitral Tribunal to issue any supplemental remedial directions
should such disclosures necessitate any further interlocutory measures, after
hearing the parties. Aside of this, I am not inclined to make any other
intervention.
Summary of Conclusions:
58. To summarise:
Page 32 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
A] I cannot fault the Learned Arbitral Tribunal in its approach to
interpreting Clause 22 of the Deed read with Section 47 of the
Partnership Act. The provisions of Section 28 of the Contract Act and
Section 115 of the Evidence Act, and the accountability framework
contained in Sections 7, 9, 10, 15, 16 and 43 of the Partnership Act do
not alter this view;
B] The view of the Learned Arbitral Tribunal in approaching
Golecha’s authority to deal with the Firm’s business cannot be faulted –
needless to say, the allegations of fraud are subject to trial and nothing
in the Impugned Order is a firm conclusive finding that would influence
or affect the trial of these facts;
C] The instances cited to infer fraud would be subjected to trial. At
this interlocutory stage, no interference is necessary with the findings in
the Impugned Order;
D] Loss to the Firm can be proved during the trial, after which the
statutory indemnity would kick in. At this stage, the only intervention
in relation to Rajebahadur Company and the leave and licence
agreements is the disclosure of information as directed above;
E] The decision not to appoint a Receiver is not faulted with in view
of the nature of the bargain contracted in the Deed. This does not mean
Page 33 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Ashwini V. F-J-ARBP-351-2025
Golecha has a complete free pass without being accountable in terms of
the Partnership Act, which will be subjected to trial in the arbitration;
and
F] The Affidavit with disclosures along with documentary evidence
in support shall be filed by Golecha as directed above.
59. In the result, in my opinion, save and except for the disclosures directed
as above, the captioned Petition deserves to be finally disposed of without any
other intervention.
60. All actions required to be taken pursuant to this order shall be taken
upon receipt of a downloaded copy as available on this Court’s website.
[SOMASEKHAR SUNDARESAN J.]
Page 34 of 34
November 19, 2026
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 15:50:59
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)