Sri Brajendra Reang and ors vs The State of Tripura and ors
- Court
- Tripura High Court
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 1 of 23
TRHC010002702026
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 21/2026
1.Sri Brajendra Reang and ors
son of Mahendra Reang, resident of Pratiprasat Para, P.O- Kalachara,
P.S- Santirbazar, sub-division- Santirbazar, District- South Tripura, PIN- 799144
2.Smt. Kuchuti Reang
daughter of Mahendra Reang, resident of Pratiprasat Para, P.O.- Kalachara,
P.S.- santirbazar, Sub-division- Santirbazar, District- South Tripura, PIN- 799144
3.Smt. Urmila Reang
daughter of Mahendra Reang, resident of Pratiprasat Para, P.O- Kalachara,
P.S- Santirbazar, Sub-division- Santirbazar, District- South Tripura, PIN- 799144
4.Sri Shyam Bahadur Reang
daughter of Mahendra Reang, resident of Pratiprasat Para, P.O- Kalachara,
P.S- Santirbazar, Sub-division- Santirbazar, District- South Tripura, PIN- 799144
..........Appellant(s)
Versus
1.The State of Tripura and ors
represented by the commissioner and Secretary, Revenue Department,
Government of Tripura, having his office at New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, Sub Division-
Sadar, District- West Tripura
2.The Commissioner and secretary,
Revenue department, Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, Sub
Division- Sadar, District- West Tripura.
3.The District Magistrate and Collector,
South Tripura District, having his office at Belonia, P.O and P.S- Belonia,
District- South Tripura, PIN- 799155
4.The Sub-divisional Magistrate
Santirbazar having his office at Santirbazar, P.O. and P.S- Santirbazar, District-
South Tripura, Pin- 799144.
5.The Revenue Officer,
Santirbazar having his office at Santirbazar, P.O. and P.S.- Santirbazar, District-
South Tripura, PIN- 700144
6.Sri Sachindra Kumar Debnath
son of not known, Village- Santirbazar, P.O- Santirbazar, P.S- Santirbazar, Sub-
division- Santirbazar, District- South Tripura, PIN- 799144
..........Respondent(s)
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 2 of 23
TRHC010002702026
For Appellant(s) : Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Abir Baran, Advocate
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing : 22.09.2026
Date of pronouncement : 13.11.2026
Whether fit for reporting : YES
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
JUDGMENT & ORDER
1) This writ appeal is filed against the judgment dated 19.01.2026 of the learned
Single Judge in WP(C)479 of 2025.
2) The appellants had filed the said Writ petition in this court challenging the
order dt. 02.07.2024 in case No. 02/R/2017 passed by the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, Santirbazar ( respondent no.4).
3) The appellants , who are the members of the Scheduled Tribe Community,
had approached the respondent No.4 in 2014 claiming that they are lawful
owners of 02 acres of land in Hal (present) Plot No.5947, 5971, 5948, 5950,
5972, 5951, 5975 comprised in Khatian No. 854 page 1, 2 & 3 of Mouja &
T.K. Santirbazar under Santirbazar Revenue Circle of Santirbazar Sub-
Division. The said case was numbered initially as Case.No.12/R of 2017 by
respondent no.4.
4) The appellants had contended in their application that one Sachindra Kr.
Debnath ( respondent no.6) and others had been occupying various portions of
the above land and that the possession of the said land should be restored to
them in view of Section 187 of the Tripura Land Revenue & Land Reforms
Act, 1960 by evicting the said persons.
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 3 of 23
TRHC010002702026
5) Sachindra Kr. Debnath and others had been impleaded as parties in the said
proceeding.
6) Before the respondent no.4, the appellants contended that the recorded owner
of the said property is Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury who belongs to the
Reang Community, and the appellants are also members of the said
community, which is a Scheduled Tribe Community; and that the respondent
no.6 and others are in possession of the aforementioned 2 acres of land and
they ought to be evicted. They contended that under the Tripura Land
Revenue & Land Reforms Act, 1960 ( for short „the Act‟) the relevant date is
01.01.1969 and any decree of compromise or order of any court other than
that of the Revenue court is liable to be treated as unlawful and invalid.
7) The respondent No.6 contended that the appellants are not legal heirs of the
original owner Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury as they do not have any
documents or certificate indicating the same. They also filed the following
documents:
st
(i) 1 one P.Copy of certified copy is filed by Krishna Kr.
Debnath against Mahendra Reang vide TS Case No. 212/1971
disposed on 2.9.71 and obtained decree for adverse possession
for land measuring area, 1.42 Dec from C/S Plot No. 2685,2686
(Original produced).
(ii) 3 pages – P/Copy of certified copies of Restoration case No.
724/R/76, one copy of compromise 2 pages and one copy is of
Collectors order where collector told that the transfer was made
before 01.01.69 and the Collector did not restored the land of
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 4 of 23
TRHC010002702026
case No. T.S. 212/1971. Restoration case was filed by
Mahendra Choudhury against Krishna Kr. Debnath.
(iii) One P/Copy of Judgement of T.S case No. 174/71 of
Munsiff Court, Belonia which was filed by Sachindra Kr.
Debnath and other one against Sri Mahendra Kr. Roy
Choudhury, Decree obtained by the plaintiff against Mahendra
Kr. Roy Choudhury for land measuring area 1.30 Dec. as tenant
on paying rent since 1959 AD.
(iv) Another P/Copy of decree has been submitted by Sri
Sridam Saha & Other vide T.S. 71/71 filed against Mahendra
Choudhury and other where they have been in possession since
1957 as under rayat / tenant or Korfa under Jotedar on paying
rent which Mahendra Choudhury admitted before Civil Court.
8) The respondent no.6 and others contended that the appellants could
not prove the date of transfer from their side and that from the side of the
private respondents, the date of transfer was earlier to 1960 and was one of
adverse possession and for the others was as tenants, and that all the
transactions were admitted by the Jotedar before the court and that they
occurred prior to 1960 and so the case should be dismissed.
9) There was delay in disposal of the said application by the respondent no.4.
10) So the appellants approached this court by filing WP(C)332/2022. This
Court disposed of the said Writ petition on 13.04.2022 by directing the
respondent no.4 to dispose of the said proceeding within six months from the
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 5 of 23
TRHC010002702026
date when the copy of the order would be placed before him by the
appellants/petitioners therein.
11) Thereafter, the respondent no.4 passed the impugned order on 02.07.2024
after hearing the appellants as well as the private respondent No.6 & others
and dismissed it.
The Order dt.2.7.2024 of the respondent no.4
12) As regards the claim of the appellants that they are the legal heirs of Lt.
Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury, the appellants had submitted a certificate
issued on 29.06.2022 stating that they are the legal heirs of the said person,
and so the respondent no.4 accepted it as genuine.
13) The respondent no.4 held that there was firstly, that there was a transfer
from Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury to Sridam Saha and that a decree dt.
11.05.1971 in T.S. 71/1971 was passed wherein it was mentioned that
Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury admitted before the Civil Court as under
rayat/tenant, a korfa or Jotedar and that that Sridam Saha has been in
possession since 1957 . The respondent no.4 also referred to an enquiry by the
DCM, Santirbazar who submitted report dt.26.9.2023 stating that Sridam
Saha and his survivors had been in possession of land measuring 0.300 acres
of Khatian No.854/1 & R.S. Plot 5971 since 53 years.
14) The respondent no.4 next held that there was a transfer of some portion of
land by Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury to Krishna Debnath, but the restoration
case filed by Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury against Krishna Debnath in case
No. 724/4/76 ended in compromise and the Collector recorded in the order
that the transfer was made before 01.01.1969 and the Collector did not restore
the land in T.S. 212/1971 by decree Dt. 20.12.1971.
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 6 of 23
TRHC010002702026
15) The respondent no.4 then held that one Sachindra Kr. Debnath and
another filed T.S. 174/1971 against Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury and
obtained a decree against the latter as a tenant paying rent since 1959 for land
admeasuring 1.30 acres and the decree in the said order was passed on
23.06.1972. The DCM, Santirbazar report also showed that Sachindra kr
Debnath and others possessed land measuring 0.420 acres of Khatian
No.854/1,2 & R.S.Plot No.5948,5947 since 53 years; and as per Khatian
No.854/2,3 land of extent 0.180 acres is possessed by Naryan Chandra
Debnath, R.S.Plot 5950,5951.
16) The respondent no.4 further held that the appellants neither mentioned
any date when they were dispossessed from the suit land, nor had they
produced any proof of it, and in absence of authenticated proof in respect of
date of transfer of the subject land, he had no choice but to depend on the
evidence which indicated that the probable date of transfer was before
01.01.1969.
17) The respondent no.4 also held that Section 187(3)(a) of the Act applies
only in those cases where transfers were made after 01.01.1969, and since the
transfers in the instant case appears to have been made before 01.01.1969,
Section 187 of the Act has no application.
18) Challenging the said order the appellants filed W.P.No.479 of 2025 in this
Court.
Writ Petition
19) For the first time in the Writ petition, the appellants relied on Section 187-
B of the Act. The said provision enables restoration of possession of land to a
person who belongs to a Scheduled tribe by a prescribed Revenue Officer
where such transfer of land occurred on or after 01.01.1969 without the
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 7 of 23
TRHC010002702026
previous permission of the Collector in writing as mandated by sub-section
(1) of Section 187 of the Act .
20) The said provision had come on the statute book by Tripura Land
th
Revenue & Land Reforms (6 Amendment) Act, 1994 notified on 18.10.1996
which also substituted Section 187.
21) Before the learned Single Judge, the respondent No.6 was however not
served notice in the Writ Petition and it was decided at the stage of admission
of the Writ Petition itself.
22) The official respondents filed a counter affidavit supporting the order of
the respondent no.4 and contended that the provision of Section 187(3)(a) of
the Act would not apply since the transfer has occurred on or before
01.01.1969.
23) Learned Single Judge, in the impugned judgment, extracted the order dt.
02.07.1974 of the respondent no.4 and concluded that the appellants failed to
prove their case before the respondent no.4 as they failed to show when they
were dispossessed from the subject land. He also held that the appellants had
failed to show any allotment order from the authority or that transfer of
property to the private respondents and others were made on or after
01.01.1969, particularly when the respondent no.4 had held that the transfer
was made before 01.01.1969.
24) Learned Single Judge held that it was an instance of chance litigation by
appellants and that they had not approached the court with clean hands and
their claim is hit by laches. He held that it is a frivolous and unfair litigation
and therefore, dismissed the writ petition with costs of Rs.50,000/-.
The Writ Appeal
25) Assailing the same, this appeal has been filed.
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 8 of 23
TRHC010002702026
26) Counsel for the appellant contended that the judgment of the learned
Single Judge is erroneous and cannot be sustained. It is contended by the
counsel for the appellant that the learned single judge had failed to take note
of Section 187B & Section 187C of the Act.
27) Section 187 of the Act as amended by Second Amendment Act, 1974
states:
[Special provision regarding scheduled Tribes]
187. (1) No transfer of land by a person who is a member of the
Scheduled Tribes shall be valid unless—
(a) the transfer is to another member of the Scheduled tribes; or
(b) where the transfer is to a person who is not a member of any
such tribe, it is made with the previous permission of the collector in
writing in the manner prescribed; or
(c) the transfer is by way of mortgage to a co-operative society or
to a bank or to the central or the State Government;
Provided that the land transferred to a co-operative
society or to a bank by way of mortgage in pursuance of clause (c)
shall not be transferred by such society or bank 70 to a person who
is not a member of the scheduled tribes without the permission of
the collector in writing.
Explanation.—In this sub-section, the expression „a bank‟
shall have the same meaning as in section 109.
(2) (a) Notwithstanding anything contained in the transfer of
Property Act, 1882, but subject to the provisions of section 187A, no
transfer of land by a person belonging to a scheduled tribe shall be
valid unless made by a registered instrument.
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 9 of 23
TRHC010002702026
(b) No instrument of transfer made in contravention of sub-
section (1) shall be registered or in anyway recognised as valid in
any court exercising civil, criminal or revenue jurisdiction.
(3) (a) If a transfer of land belonging to a person who is a member
of the scheduled tribes is made on or after the first January, 1969 in
contravention of the provisions of sub-section (1), any revenue
officer, appointed specially for this purpose by the state government
by notification in the Official gazette, may, of his own motion or on
an application made in that behalf, and after giving the transferee
an opportunity of being heard, by an order in writing eject the
transferee or any person claiming under him from such land or part
thereof.
(b) When the revenue officer has passed any order under clause (a)
he shall restore the transferred land or part thereof to the transferer
or his successor in-interest;
Provided that such order shall have effect from the first day of
Baisakh next following the date of the order.
(4) No decree or order shall be passed by any court for the sale of
the land or any portion thereof, of a person belonging to a
Scheduled tribe nor shall any such land be sold in execution of any
decree or order.
(5) When a certificate is filed for recovery of an arrear of land
revenue in respect of the land of a person belonging to a Scheduled
Tribe, the Certificate Official shall, before a proclamation for sale
of the land is issue in execution of the certificate, refer the case to a
revenue officer appointed under clause (a) of sub-section (3) who
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 10 of 23
TRHC010002702026
may sell the land to a member of the Scheduled Tribes, if available,
and if not available, to any other person at a fair market price to be
fixed by such revenue officer, not being less than the amount due in
respect of the certificate:
Provided that if the homestead of the defaulting person is
comprised in the lands such homestead shall not be sold: Provided
further that any amount remaining out of the sale proceeds after
satisfaction of the amount due in respect of the certificate shall be
paid to the defaulting person.”
28) Thus though Section 187 (1) required a transfer by a person belonging to
Schedule Tribe community to a person who is not a Scheduled tribe to be
validly done after securing permission of Collector in writing, under sub-
section (3)(a) of section 187, power to restore possession is conferred on the
Revenue officer to the Scheduled Tribe person only if such transfer occurs
after 1.1.1969.
29) This legal position is not altered even by the Tripura Land Revenue and
Land Reforms (Sixth Amendment )Act,1994 which substituted Section 187
and also added Sections 187-A to Section 187G w.e.f 18.10.1996.
30) After this amendment, the said provisions state:
“ 187 . (1) No transfer of land belonging to a person who is a
member of the Scheduled Tribes shall be valid unless—
(a) the transfer is to another member of the Scheduled Tribes; or
(b) where the transfer is to a person who is not a member of the
Scheduled Tribes, it is made with the previous permission of the
Collector in writing in the manner to be prescribed by rule, or
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 11 of 23
TRHC010002702026
(c) the transfer is by way of mortgage to a Co-operative Society or
to a Bank or to the Tripura Housing Board, or to the Central or the
State Government or any other financial institutions or
Corporations as may be notified by the Government in the Official
Gazette from time to time for the purpose.
Provided that the land so mortgaged in pursuance of Clause
(c) shall not be transferred by such mortgage to a person who is
not a member of the Scheduled Tribes.
Explanation.—In this sub-section, the expression „a bank‟
shall have the same meaning as in section 109.
(2) (a) Notwithstanding anything contained in the transfer of
Property Act, 1882, but subject to the provisions of section 187A,
no transfer of land belonging to a person who is a member of the
scheduled tribes shall be valid unless made by a registered
instrument.
(b) No transfer or instrument of transfer including a decree or
order passed by any court, Tribunal or Authority, made in
contravention of sub-section (1) shall be registered or in any way
recognised as valid in any court, Tribunal or Authority.
3. No decree or order shall be passed by any court for the sale of
the land or any portion thereof, of a person belonging to a
Scheduled tribe nor shall any such land be sold in execution of any
decree or order.
187A….
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 12 of 23
TRHC010002702026
187B. (1) On or after the 1st January, 1969 ---
(a) if a transfer of land belonging to a person who is a member of
the scheduled Tribes is made in contravention of the provisions of
sub-section (1) of section 187 to a person other than a member of
the Scheduled Tribes, a Revenue Officer specially appointed for
this purpose by a notification in the Official Gazette, and having
local jurisdiction may, notwithstanding anything contained in any
other law for the time being in force, on its own motion or on an
application made in that behalf, and after giving the transferee and
the transferer an opportunity of being heard, by an order in writing
evict such or any person claiming under him from such land or
part thereof and shall restore the possession of the land to the
transferer, or his successor in interest and for this purpose the
Revenue Officer may use or cause to be used such force as may be
considered necessary.
(b) if any land owned by person belonging to the Scheduled Tribes
is occupied by any person who is not a member of the Scheduled
Tribes without lawful authority, then the Revenue Officer in the
same manner as provided in Clause (a) may restore the possession
of such land to the person or successor in interest so dispossessed.
(c) if a person belonging to the scheduled Tribes is in occupation of
Government land and eligible for allotment of such land under
Section 14 of this Act, parts with possession or is dispossessed
there from by a person not belonging to the Scheduled Tribes, then
the Revenue Officer in the same manner as provided in clause (a)
may restore the possession of such land to that person. Or his
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 13 of 23
TRHC010002702026
successor-in-interest as the case may be and refer to the competent
authority under Section 14 of this Act for allotment of the land to
such person.
Explanation—For the purpose of this sub-section, the
successor-in-interest means heirs, transferee or assignee in
accordance with law or custom as applicable.
(2) If any person not being a member of the Scheduled Tribes
occupies or possesses the land held by or in occupation of a person
belonging to the Scheduled Tribes in any manner as specified in
sub-section (1) after the commencement of the Tripura Land
Revenue and Land Reforms (Sixth Amendment) Act, 1994 without
any lawful authority he shall be punishable with imprisonment for
a term which may extend to two years and also with a fine which
may extend to three thousand rupees.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal
Procedure 1973 every offence punishable under sub-section (2)
shall be cognizable and non-bailable and wherever any person is
arrested and detained in custody in pursuance of provision of this
section, the officer-in-charge of the Police Station or Police Officer
making the arrest shall forward the person to the Presiding Officer
holding the special Court of the jurisdiction and the provision of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 shall apply mutates
mutandis for summary trial.
(4) For the purpose of speedy trial of offence under this section the
State Government may, after consultation with the High Court by
notification constitute as many special Courts s may be considered
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 14 of 23
TRHC010002702026
necessary, each consisting of an Officer not below the rank of a
Judicial Magistrate of the First Class.
(5) For the cases referred to in sub-section (2), the Revenue
Officer immediately after restoration of land under sub-section (1)
shall file a complaint in the special Court constituted under sub-
section (4) for action as provided, in sub-section (2). (6) An appeal
shall lie to the High court from every order passed by a special
court under this section within sixty days of the passing of such
order.
187. C. Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for
the time being in force, the burden of proof for the purpose of
section 187 B that transfer of land was not made in contravention
of sub-section (1) of section 187 or occupation of land was not
made without lawful authority shall lie on the transferee or
occupier, as the case may be.
187. D . Where the possession of any land is restored to a person
belonging to the Scheduled Tribes under any of the above
provisions is re- transferred by the person belonging Scheduled
Tribes in contravention of section 187 and the Revenue Officer
specially empowered has reasons to believe that the land holder
belonging to Scheduled Tribes shall not be in a position to retain
the land so re- transferred even after subsequent restoration, the
Revenue Officer shall evict the person to whom the land was re
transferred and entrust the management of the same to a
Committee as may be constituted by the State Government with
scheduled Tribes members and government Officials for a period
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 15 of 23
TRHC010002702026
of one year and if, after the expiry of this period, the Committee
holds that the land holder belonging to the scheduled Tribes shall
not be in a position to retain the land if restored, then such land
shall vest to the Government free from all encumbrances and the
Collector shall allot the land to the eligible tribal‟s of the area
under such condition as may be prescribed.
(2) The manner of constitution conduct of business, powers and
function of the committee referred to in sub-section (1) shall be
such as may be prescribed.
Explanation: - For the purpose of Section 187, 187B, 187C
an 187D, the word „transfer‟ shall mean sale, mortgage, lease,
exchange and gift as defined in Transfer of property Act, 1882 and
include parting with fully or partly of ownership or possession of
any land or any interest therein in any other manner whatsoever
but shall not include the requisition and acquisition of land under
any law for the time being in force.
187. E. Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the
time being in force, a petition for restoration of possession of land
by a person belonging to the Scheduled Tribes against a person not
belonging to the scheduled Tribes shall lie at any time.
187. F. Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for
the time being in force, no suit for declaration of title over any land
belonging to the Scheduled Tribes shall lie in a civil Court and no
Civil Court shall pass a decree or order by which title of land
stands transferred from a person belonging to the Scheduled Tribes
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 16 of 23
TRHC010002702026
to a person not belonging to the Scheduled Tribes.” (emphasis
supplied)
31) Thus both in Section 187 (3) (a) (before amendment in 1996), and in
clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 187 B (post-amendment after 1996),
there cannot be restoration of possession of land to persons belonging to
Schedule Tribe community by the designated Revenue Officer from
transferees (who do not belong to the Scheduled tribe community), if such
transfer occurred prior to 1.1.1969 . Even with regard to land occupied prior
to 1.1.1969 by a person not belonging to a Scheduled Tribe Community of
land owned by a person belonging to the Scheduled Tribe without lawful
authority, clause (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 187B does not permit
restoration of possession by the designated Revenue Officer.
32) No doubt Section 187-E permits filing of applications for restoration by
persons of Schedule Tribe community „ at any time ‟ against a person not
belonging to a Scheduled Tribe. Since the power to restore land conferred on
the Revenue Officer is controlled by clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1) of
Section 187 B, it has to be read harmoniously with Section 187 E. So the
designated Revenue Officer has no power to restore possession if the transfer
had occurred to a non-schedule tribe person before 1.1.1969 or if the land was
occupied by a non-schedule tribe person prior to 1.1.1969
33) This legal position is evident from the plain language of Section 187-B (1)
(a) and (b) after the amendment in 1996.
1
34) But in Kalimohan Sahaji and Anr v. State of Tripura , a Division Bench
of the Gauhati High Court took the view that after deletion of sub-section(3)
1
2012 SCC Online Gau 746 (DB) : 2012 4 Gau LR 520
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 17 of 23
TRHC010002702026
of Section 187 by the sixth amendment Act , there is nothing to claim that
transfer of land before 1.1.1969 shall not be disturbed . The said judgment
has also been followed in Rangamayee Choudhury v. State of Tripura and
2
ors .
35) Both Division Benches of the Gauhati High Court did not take note of the
st
words “ on or after 1 January,1969 ” occurring in sub-section (1) of Section
187B of the Act and ignore the same , which is impermissible. Thus
notwithstanding the deletion of sub-section (3) of Section 187 by the 1996
st
amendment, in view of the use of the words “ on or after 1 January,1969 ” in
subsection (1) of Section 187B before clauses (a) and (b) thereof, there is no
power conferred on the revenue officer to restore land when the transfer is
prior to 1.1.1969.
st
36) The words “ on or after 1 January,1969 ” in subsection (1) of Section
187B before clauses (a) and (b) thereof could not have been lost sight of by
the said Division Benches of the Gauhati High Court.
37) A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Hardeep Singh v. State of
Punjab 3 emphasized the settled principle of law that an interpretation which
leads to the conclusion that a word used by the legislature is redundant should
be avoided, as the presumption is that the legislature has deliberately and
consciously used the words for carrying out the purpose of the Act. The legal
maxim a verbis legis non est recedendum which means, “from the words of
law, there must be no departure” has to be kept in mind. The Court declared:
“43. The court cannot proceed with an assumption that the
legislature enacting the statute has committed a mistake and
2
(2013) 1 Gauhati Law reports 121 (DB)
3
(2014) 3 SCC 92 : (2014) 2 SCC (Cri) 86, at page 121
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 18 of 23
TRHC010002702026
where the language of the statute is plain and unambiguous, the
court cannot go behind the language of the statute so as to add or
subtract a word playing the role of a political reformer or of a
wise counsel to the legislature. The court has to proceed on the
footing that the legislature intended what it has said and even if
there is some defect in the phraseology, etc., it is for others than
the court to remedy that defect. The statute requires to be
interpreted without doing any violence to the language used
therein. The court cannot rewrite, recast or reframe the
legislation for the reason that it has no power to legislate.
44. No word in a statute has to be construed as surplusage. No
word can be rendered ineffective or purposeless. Courts are
required to carry out the legislative intent fully and completely.
While construing a provision, full effect is to be given to the
language used therein, giving reference to the context and other
provisions of the statute. By construction, a provision should not
be reduced to a “dead letter” or “useless lumber”. An
interpretation which renders a provision otiose should be avoided
otherwise it would mean that in enacting such a provision, the
legislature was involved in “an exercise in futility” and the
product came as a “purposeless piece” of legislation and that the
provision had been enacted without any purpose and the entire
exercise to enact such a provision was “most unwarranted
besides being uncharitable”. (Vide Patel Chunibhai Dajibha v.
Narayanrao Khanderao Jambekar, Martin Burn Ltd. v. Corpn.
of Calcutta, M.V. Elisabeth v. Harwan Investment and Trading
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 19 of 23
TRHC010002702026
(P) Ltd, Sultana Begum v. Prem Chand Jain, State of Bihar v.
Bihar Distillery Ltd., Institute of Chartered Accountants of
India v. Price Waterhouse and South Central Railway
Employees Coop. Credit Society Employees’ Union v. Registrar
of Coop. Societies. )
4
36
45. This Court in Rohitash Kumar v. Om Prakash Sharma ,
after placing reliance on various earlier judgments of this Court
held : (SCC pp. 460-61, paras 27-29)
“27. The court has to keep in mind the fact that, while
interpreting the provisions of a statute, it can neither add, nor
subtract even a single word. … A section is to be interpreted
by reading all of its parts together, and it is not permissible to
omit any part thereof. The court cannot proceed with the
assumption that the legislature, while enacting the statute has
committed a mistake; it must proceed on the footing that the
legislature intended what it has said; even if there is some
defect in the phraseology used by it in framing the statute, and
it is not open to the court to add and amend, or by
construction, make up for the deficiencies, which have been
left in the Act. …
28. The statute is not to be construed in light of certain notions
that the legislature might have had in mind, or what the
legislature is expected to have said, or what the legislature
might have done, or what the duty of the legislature to have
said or done was. The courts have to administer the law as
4
(2013) 11 SCC 451
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 20 of 23
TRHC010002702026
they find it, and it is not permissible for the court to twist the
clear language of the enactment in order to avoid any real or
imaginary hardship which such literal interpretation may
cause. …
29. … under the garb of interpreting the provision, the court
does not have the power to add or subtract even a single word,
as it would not amount to interpretation, but legislation.”
(emphasis in original)
38) This important principle was not noticed by both the Division Benches of
the Gauhati High Court in the above referred decisions. Though the
st
legislature used the specific words “ On or after 1 January 1969 ” in sub-
section (1) of Section 187B before clauses (a) and (b), the Division Benches
ignored these words and erroneously took the view that „ there is nothing to
claim that transfer of land before 1.1.1969 shall not be disturbed‟ .
39) If the view of the said High Court is to be accepted it would jeopardize
possession of non-tribals (i) who have secured such possession of land prior
to 1.1.1969 or (ii) to whom land had been transferred prior to 1.1.1969 by
persons belonging to Scheduled Tribes, causing large scale hardship and
harassment to them. In our opinion, the legislature in it‟s wisdom did confer
power on the Revenue Officer to direct restoration of possession of land to
the persons belonging to Scheduled Tribe community only if transfers
occurred or possession was taken after 1.1.1969 and not before the said date .
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 21 of 23
TRHC010002702026
40) We therefore hold that Kalimohan Sahaji and Anr (1 supra) and
Rangamayee Choudhury( 2 supra) do not lay down the law correctly and
have been decided „ per incuriam‟ and are therefore not binding on this Court .
5
,
41) In Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India the Supreme Court has held
that if a judgment has been rendered ignoring a provision in a statute, it
becomes a decision „ per incuriam ‟ and it will therefore be not a binding
precedent.
“153. Thus, although it is the ratio decidendi which is a
precedent and not the final order in the judgment, however,
there are certain exceptions to the rule of precedents which
are expressed by the doctrines of per incuriam and sub
silentio. Incuria legally means carelessness and per incuriam
may be equated with per ignoratium. If a judgment is rendered
in ignoratium of a statute or a binding authority, it becomes a
decision per incuriam. Thus, a decision rendered by ignorance
of a previous binding decision of its own or of a court of
coordinate or higher jurisdiction or in ignorance of the terms
of a statute or of a rule having the force of law is per incuriam.
Such a per incuriam decision would not have a precedential
value. If a decision has been rendered per incuriam, it cannot
be said that it lays down good law, even if it has not been
expressly overruled vide Mukesh K. Tripathi v. LIC 92, para
23. Thus, a decision per incuriam is not binding.”
5
(2024) 5 SCC 481 : (2024) 2 SCC (Cri) 692, at page 592 :
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 22 of 23
TRHC010002702026
42) So we hold that if:
(i) transfers of land were made prior to 1.1.1969 by a person who belongs to
a Scheduled tribe community to a person who does not belong to the
Scheduled tribe community or
(ii) any land owned by a person belonging to the Scheduled tribe community
is occupied prior to 1.1.1969 by a person who is not a member of the
Scheduled Tribe community,
the Revenue Officer designated cannot direct restoration of possession.
43) In the instant case, a finding has been recorded by the respondent no.4
th
that the transfers in question from Mahendra Kr. Roy Choudhury to the 6
respondent and other respondents had occurred before 01.01.1969 . The said
finding is based on appreciation of evidence adduced by the parties before
him.
44) When the respondent no.4, on an appreciation of the evidence adduced by
the parties before him had come to the said conclusion which cannot be said
to be perverse or based on no evidence, the said finding of fact cannot be
interfered with by this court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
45) Learned Single Judge had also rightly agreed with the findings of the
respondent no.4 on this aspect and had declined to exercise jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India in favour of the appellant particularly
th
when the application is filed seeking restoration in 2014 when the 6
respondent and others have been found to be in possession from prior to
1.1.1969.
46) We, therefore, do not find any merit in the Writ Appeal.
2026:THC:1500-DB Page 23 of 23
TRHC010002702026
47) However, to the extent the learned Single Judge had imposed costs of Rs.
50,000/- on the appellant, we are inclined to modify the same as such a harsh
measure may not be warranted. Each appellant shall therefore pay costs of
Rs.5000/- to the High Court Legal Services Committee, Tripura within 4
weeks from today.
48) Therefore, the judgment of the learned single Judge is modified only to
the above extent, but the rest of the judgment of the Single Judge is affirmed.
49) The Writ Appeal is partly allowed to the above extent.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(BISWAJIT PALIT, J) (M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
PULAK BANIK
Digitally signed by PULAK BANIK
Date: 2026.11.13 19:14:51 +05'30'