Mahesh Kumar Choudhary vs State Of Haryana

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
1


105 105 105 105
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
ATCHANDIGARH ATCHANDIGARH ATCHANDIGARH ATCHANDIGARH

CRM-M-56875 CRM 56875-2026 2026
CRM CRM 56875 56875 2026 2026

Mahesh Kumar Choudhary
....Petitioner
versus
State of Haryana
....Respondent

Date of Decision: Date of Decision: November 16 Date of Decision: Date of Decision: November 16 November 16, 2026 November 16 , 2026 , 2026 , 2026
Date of Uploading: Date of Uploading: November Date of Uploading: Date of Uploading: November November 17, 2026 November , 2026 , 2026 , 2026

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL
CORAM: CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUMEET GOEL

Present Present: Present Present Mr. Ankit Chauhan, Advocate for the petitioner.

Ms. Mahima Yashpal Singla, Senior DAG Haryana.


SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL SUMEET GOEL , J. (Oral) , J. (Oral) , J. (Oral) , J. (Oral)

rd
Present 3 petition has been filed under Section 482 of
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter to be referred as ‘the
BNSS’) for grant of pre-arrest/anticipatory bail to the petitioner, in case
bearing FIR No.170 dated 25.09.2023, registered for the offence punishable
under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 of the IPC, 1860 and Section 61(1)(a) of
the Excise Act, at Police Station Bajghera, Gurugram.
First anticipatory bail plea of the petitioner was dismissed as
withdrawn, as the petitioner had requested to take requisite steps for laying
challenge to the order whereby he was declared as a proclaimed offender,
vide order dated 21.07.2026 passed in CRM CRM CRM-M-28583 CRM 28583 28583-2026 28583 2026 2026. The last 2026
anticipatory bail plea of the petitioner was dismissed as withdrawn with
liberty to file afresh, on the same cause of action, after disclosing complete
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
2

antecedents of the petitioner, vide order dated 16.09.2026 passed in CRM CRM CRM- CRM
M-52657 52657 52657-2026 52657 2026 2026. 2026
2. For the sake of ease, relevant factual milieu drawn from the
order dated 07.04.2026 passed by the concerned Sessions Court (whereby
anticipatory bail plea of the petitioner was rejected), reads thus:
“ 2. Facts relevant for the disposal of present bail application are that
on 25.09.2023, ASI Sanjeev alongwith fellow officials was on night crime
patrol duty. He received secret information that a Canter bearing
registration No. UP-12AT-5050 will pass through Express-way and
proceed towards Bajghera and the same is loaded with illicit liquor. The
information was reliable and shared with the other police officials. The
police team reached at the disclosed place. After barricading, checking
was started. The public persons were requested to join the proceedings but
they expressed their inability. After some time, a Canter was seen coming.
It was signaled to stop with the use of a torch. The Canter driver stopped
the vehicle and tried to fled away. However, he was apprehended with the
help of fellow officials. He disclosed his name as Balraj son of Nand Lal.
The registration number of the Canter was UP-12AT-5050. The driver
disclosed that the Canter is loaded with the rice. He produced Eway bill,
tax invoice and builty. After checking, it was found that the Canter is
loaded with the cartons of liquor. The driver failed to produce any license
for the same. The superior authorities were informed and the Canter was
brought to Police Station Bajghera, Gurugram. On interrogation, the driver
Balraj disclosed the names of the owners of the liquor as Sattar and Abid
sons of Ayye Khan. The liquor was unloaded. 200 cartons of liquor
Imperial Blue, 149 cartons of Imperial Blue (half), 75 cartons of liquor
Imperial Blue (quarters) and 25 cartons of Mcdowell were recovered. The
samples were taken and sealed with the impression SK. The FIR was
registered. ”

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner has iterated that a bare perusal
of the FIR itself shows that allegations leveled against the petitioner are
concocted, improbable and devoid of any merit. Learned counsel has further
iterated that the petitioner has been falsely implicated into the FIR in question.
It has been urged that the petitioner was neither named in the FIR nor was
either present or apprehended at the spot. Learned counsel has further urged
that alleged recovery of liquor was effected from the co-accused, namely,
Balraj who was driving the vehicle in question. It has been submitted that the
petitioner has been implicated solely on the basis of disclosure statement of co-
accused. Learned counsel has submitted that the vehicle in question was
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
3

already sold vide agreement to sell dated 21.08.2023, i.e., much prior to the
alleged occurrence on 25.09.2023; therefore, the petitioner had no possession
or control over the said vehicle at the relevant time.
3.1. Learned counsel has urged that registered owner of the vehicle,
i.e., Rameshwar Jat has already been granted the concession of anticipatory bail
vide order dated 12.05.2026 passed in CRM CRM CRM-M-15046 CRM 15046 15046-2026 15046 2026 2026. 2026
3.2. Learned counsel has argued that nothing is to be recovered from
the petitioner. Learned counsel has further iterated that the petitioner is
ready and willing to join investigation. On the basis of the aforementioned
submissions, grant of the instant petition is prayed for.
4. Per contra , learned State counsel has filed status report by way
of an affidavit dated 23.10.2026, which is already on record. Role of the
petitioner, as mentioned in the said status report, reads thus:
22. EVIDENCE AGAINST THE PETITIONER EVIDENCE AGAINST THE PETITIONER: That in so far as the
“ EVIDENCE AGAINST THE PETITIONER EVIDENCE AGAINST THE PETITIONER
evidence against the petitioner is concerned, it is submitted that
sufficient incriminating material has been collected during the
course of investigation which established the active involvement of
the petitioner Mahesh Kumar Choudhary in the commission of the
present crime. The petitioner has been specifically named by co-
accused Arun Kumar Gadhwal in his disclosure statement, wherein
he has categorically disclosed that it was the petitioner Mahesh
who had arranged and provided the vehicle bearing registration
No.RJ-02-GA-3720, make Tata 1109, which was subsequently
used for the illegal transportation of liquor after its identity was
altered by engraving fake engine and chassis numbers and
preparing a forged registration certificate. He further disclosed that
the petitioner had arranged three SIM cards for co-accused Sattar
and had provided the white Hyundai i-10 car belonging to his
brother Sunil for piloting the vehicle carrying illicit liquor. The
involvement of the petitioner is further corroborated by the official
registration records obtained from the concerned Transport
Authority, which establishes that the aforesaid vehicle was
registered in the name of his father/accomplice Rameshwar Jat.
Furthermore, during interrogation, petitioner's father Rameshwar
the Jat specifically admitted that the vehicle used in the present
crime had been purchased in his name by the petitioner and that the
petitioner himself was using and driving the same. The pilot
vehicle bearing registration No.RJ-14-TD-7430 was subsequently
recovered in connection with FIR No.227/2023, Police Station
Manesar, Gurugram, and its relevant records were also obtained
during investigation. Apart from the above, the sale agreement of
the vehicle dated 21.08.2023, produced by the petitioner's
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
4

father/co-accused Rameshwar to claim that the vehicle had already
been sold, was found to be fabricated, as the same bore the notarial
attestation of one Rajendra Yadav, who had already expired in the
year 2021, which fact stands verified from his death certificate
obtained during the course of investigation. The petitioner's father
has also disclosed that the said sale agreement was arranged by the
petitioner and that the original document was in the petitioner's
knowledge. Thus, the disclosure statement of the co-accused, the
vehicle registration records, the interrogation of the petitioner's
father, the recovery and identification of the vehicles involved and
the verification of the sale agreement constitute enough
incriminating material collected during investigation, which
connects the petitioner with the commission of the present crime
and warrants his custodial interrogation.

23. ROLE OF THE PETITIONER ROLE OF THE PETITIONER: That in so far as the role of the ROLE OF THE PETITIONER ROLE OF THE PETITIONER
petitioner is concerned, it is submitted that the petitioner Mahesh
Kumar Choudhary has played an active and instrumental role in
the commission of the present crime. The investigation has
revealed that the petitioner was acting in league with his
accomplices and had facilitated the illegal transportation of liquor
by arranging and providing the vehicle used for carrying the illicit
liquor, assisting in concealing its actual identity by forging its
registration particulars and documents and providing necessary
logistical and communication support to his accomplices. The
petitioner had also facilitated the movement of the vehicle carrying
the liquor by arranging a separate vehicle for piloting the same and
alerting the co-accused persons about police checking on the route.
Thus, the role attributed to the petitioner is not merely incidental or
peripheral, but that of an active participant who facilitated the
preparation, execution and concealment of the illegal
transportation of liquor in connivance with the other co-accused
persons.
”

4.1. In respect of antecedents of the petitioner, it has been stated, in
the said status report, as under:
“ 24. That apart from the present case, the complicity of the petitioner
has been found in the following cases:
i. FIR No. 227 dated 02.09.2023 PS Manesar, Gurugram
U/Ss 420, 467, 468, 471 & 120B IPC and Section 61(1)(a)
Excise Act
ii. FIR No. 35 dated 06.02.2024 PS Rani Ki Sarai, Azamgarh,
UP U/Ss 467, 468, 471, 419; 420 & 34 IPC and Section
63/60 Excise Act ”

Raising submissions in tandem with the said status report,
learned State counsel has opposed the grant of anticipatory bail by arguing
that serious allegations have been levelled against the petitioner. The
petitioner does not bear clean antecedents. It has been submitted that
considering seriousness of the allegations, custodial interrogation of the
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
5

petitioner is necessary for fair and effective investigation. Given the severity
of the offence, there exists a substantial likelihood that the petitioner may
abscond or tamper with the evidence, if the petitioner is enlarged on bail.
Thus, dismissal of the petition in hand is prayed for.
5. I have heard the learned counsel for the rival parties and have
gone through the available record of the case.
6. As per the prosecution case, the allegations against the
petitioner are serious in nature. Perusal of the prosecution case, material
available on record, the status report filed by the State, as also the order
whereby anticipatory bail of the petitioner was declined by the concerned
Sessions Court, prima facie reveals that the driver, namely Balraj, was
apprehended at the spot and 474 cartons of illicit liquor were recovered from
the Canter. During investigation, it was revealed that the registration number
plate and other documents of the vehicle were forged. The investigation
further revealed that co-accused – Rameshwar Jat was the registered owner
of the Canter bearing its original registration No.RJ-02GA-3720, and that
the petitioner, who is his son, had allegedly got the registration number and
chassis number of the vehicle forged. Keeping in the view factual milieu of
the case in hand; especially seriousness & gravity of the allegations; this
Court is of the, prima facie , opinion that the petitioner does not deserve the
concession of extraordinary relief of anticipatory bail.
6.1. The petitioner cannot claim parity with the co-accused, namely,
Rameshwar Jat, who was granted the concession of anticipatory bail by this
Court, inasmuch as the petitioner is alleged to have played a distinct and
specific role in the commission of the offence. The petitioner, who is stated
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
6

to be the son of the said co-accused, is specifically alleged to have forged the
registration and chassis numbers of the vehicle in question, which was
allegedly used in the commission of the offence. Thus, the nature and
gravity of the allegations against the petitioner are distinguishable from
those levelled against the aforesaid co-accused.
6.2. Perusal of the status report shows that the petitioner is involved
in 02 more FIR(s). The aforesaid criminal antecedent(s) reveal that petitioner
is a habitual offender with a tendency to indulge in criminal activities. Such
antecedent(s) cannot be brushed aside as a mere coincidence and are a
relevant consideration while adjudicating the prayer for grant of anticipatory
bail. The criminal antecedent(s) of petitioner also raise a reasonable
apprehension that, if enlarged on bail, he may indulge in similar criminal
activities, misuse the concession of bail, or interfere with the fair course of
justice. The possibility of his absconding or influencing prosecution
witnesses also cannot be ruled out.
6.3. The other pleas raised by the petitioner, including those of false
implication etc., are matters to be adjudicated on the basis of evidence
during the course of trial. Such disputed questions of fact(s) cannot be
conclusively determined at the stage of consideration of the petitioner’s
prayer for anticipatory bail.
6.4. No cause nay plausible cause has been shown, at this stage,
from which it can be deciphered that the petitioner has been falsely
implicated into the present FIR.
7. It is befitting to mention here that while considering a plea for
grant of anticipatory bail, the Court has to equilibrate between safeguarding
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
7

individual rights and protecting societal interests. The Court ought to reckon
with the magnitude and nature of the offence; the role attributed to the
accused; the need for free and fair investigation as also the deeper and wider
impact of such alleged iniquities on the society. It is imperative that every
person in the Society can expect an atmosphere free from foreboding & fear
of any transgression. At this stage, there is no material on record to hold that
prima facie case is not made out against the petitioner. The material which
has come on record and preliminary investigation appear to establish a
reasonable basis for the accusations. Thus, it is not appropriate to grant
anticipatory bail to the petitioner, as it would necessarily cause impediment
in effective investigation. In State State State v. Anil Sharma, (1997) 7 SCC 187 : State v. Anil Sharma, (1997) 7 SCC 187 : v. Anil Sharma, (1997) 7 SCC 187 : 1997 v. Anil Sharma, (1997) 7 SCC 187 : 1997 1997 1997
SCC (Cri) 1039] SCC (Cri) 1039], the Supreme Court held as under : (SCC p. 189, para 6) SCC (Cri) 1039] SCC (Cri) 1039]
“ 6. We find force in the submission of CBI that custodial interrogation is
qualitatively more elicitation-oriented than questioning a suspect who is well-
ensconced with a favourable order under Section 438 of the Code. In a case
like this, effective interrogation of a suspected person is of tremendous
advantage in disinterring many useful informations and also materials which
would have been concealed. Success in such interrogation would elude if the
suspected person knows that he is well protected and insulated by a pre-arrest
bail order during the time he is interrogated. Very often interrogation in such
a condition would reduce to a mere ritual. The argument that the custodial
interrogation is fraught with the danger of the person being subjected to third-
degree methods need not be countenanced, for, such an argument can be
advanced by all accused in all criminal cases. The Court has to presume that
responsible police officers would conduct themselves in a responsible manner
and that those entrusted with the task of disinterring offences would not
conduct themselves as offenders. ”

8. In view of the seriousness of the allegations, this Court finds no
compelling ground to extend the benefit of discretionary relief of
anticipatory bail to the petitioner. Moreover, custodial interrogation of the
petitioner is necessary for an effective investigation & to unravel the truth.
The petition is, thus, devoid of merits and is hereby dismissed dismissed dismissed. dismissed
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment

CRM CRM-M-56875 CRM CRM 56875 56875-2026 56875 2026 2026 2026
8

9. Nothing said hereinabove shall be deemed to be an expression
of opinion upon merits of the case/investigation.
10. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed off.









(SUMEET GOEL) (SUMEET GOEL) (SUMEET GOEL) (SUMEET GOEL)
JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE
November 16 November 16, 2026 November 16 November 16 , 2026 , 2026 , 2026
mahavir

Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No

Whether reportable: Yes/No
MAHAVIR SINGH
2026.11.17 11:52
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/ judgment