Sushil Sharma vs Union Of India
- Court
- Supreme Court
REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 809
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012
SUSHIL SHARMA …. APPELLANT
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS …. RESPONDENTS
J U D G M E N T
PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J.
1) The present Appeal assails the judgment and order passed by the
High Court of Delhi, at New Delhi, in W.P.(C) No.307/2011, whereby the
High Court dismissed the said writ petition filed by the appellant and upheld
the orders of compulsory retirement passed against him vide order dated
06.06.2010 by the competent authority.
2)
Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts can be adumbrated as thus:
1
the appellant joined the Central Industrial Security Force as an Assistant
Sub-inspector on 28.06.1982. While in service, he was promoted twice,
firstly to the post of Sub-Inspector on 29.03.1990 and later to the post of
Inspector on 19.09.2003. Upon attaining the age of 50 years, the appellant’s
2
case was placed before the Internal Screening Committee for assessment
Signature Not Verified
under Rule 56(j) of the Fundamental Rules. The Committee found the
Digitally signed by
NISHA KHULBEY
Date: 2026.08.06
15:33:52 IST
Reason:
1
For brevity, “CISF”
2
For brevity, “the Committee”
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 1 of 7
appellant to be unfit for retention in the service. The said view was affirmed
by the Review Committee vide order dated 06.06.2010; consequently, the
appellant was compulsorily retired from service. The appellant’s
representation submitted being aggrieved by the aforesaid order was also
rejected by the Representation Committee.
3) Assailing the order of compulsory retirement, the appellant filed a writ
petition before the High Court. The High Court, after considering the
3
appellant’s Annual Confidential Reports opined that the efficiency of the
appellant to perform his duties slackened in the last 2 years of the period
under review and held that the decision of the Committee in compulsorily
retiring the appellant was not arbitrary or unreasonable. Aggrieved thereby,
the appellant is before us in this Appeal.
4) Heard the learned Counsel for either side and perused the material on
record.
5) The object underlying compulsory retirement is to weed out the dead
wood so as to maintain a high standard of efficiency and integrity in public
service. It is trite law that an order of compulsory retirement is not punitive
in nature and implies neither stigma, prejudice nor any suggestion of
misbehaviour. The order of compulsory retirement is in public interest and
is passed on the subjective satisfaction of the Government. Furthermore, the
principles of natural justice, audi alteram partem find no application in the
context of compulsory retirement. However, this cannot be construed to
mean that the order of compulsory retirement is insulated from judicial
3
For brevity, “ACR”
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 2 of 7
scrutiny. Albeit, the High Court or this Court would not examine the matter
as an Appellate Court, but nevertheless, can interfere, if the order so passed
is malafide , based on no evidence or is arbitrary and perverse.
6) It is also well settled that the Government or the Review Committee,
as the case may be, shall take a decision considering the entire record of
service, attaching more importance to records and performance during the
subsequent years, weighing in both favourable and adverse remarks.
Equally well settled is the principle that an order of compulsory retirement
cannot be invalidated merely because uncommunicated adverse remarks
formed part of the material considered by the authority. Such circumstance,
by itself, does not furnish a ground for judicial interference. [see:
Baikuntha Nath Das and Another v. Chief District Medical Officer,
4
Baripada and Another ]
7) Speaking in consonance with aforementioned adjudication and the
limited role of judicial interference in an order of compulsory retirement, this
Court in the case of Ram Murti Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
5
Another observed as follows:
“ 6. …. The scope for judicial review of an order of compulsory
retirement based on the subjective satisfaction of the employer
is extremely narrow and restricted. Only if it is found to be
based on arbitrary or capricious grounds, vitiated by mala
fides, overlooks relevant materials, could there be limited scope
for interference. The court, in judicial review, cannot sit in
judgment over the same as an appellate authority. Principles of
natural justice have no application in a case of compulsory
retirement.”
4
(1992) 2 SCC 299
5
(2020) 1 SCC 801
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 3 of 7
8) On perusal of the appellant’s ACR, it emerges that his gradings from
1983 to 1999 fluctuated between “Average”, “Good” and “Very Good”, with
the appellant earning his first promotion in 1990 during a period of
improved performance, and his second promotion in 2003 on the string of
“Very Good” gradings from 2000 to 2003. While the appellant's entire service
record is required to be considered, consistent with the settled position of
law, greater weight must necessarily be accorded to the service record of the
immediate preceding years before the order of compulsory retirement. It is,
therefore, the appellant's performance during the period 2004-2009 which
assumes particular significance in the present case. During this period the
appellant was graded “Average” in 2004, “Very Good” in 2005, “Good” in
2006 and 2007 and “Good” for the first quarter of 2008 but thereafter
declined to “Average” for the remainder of 2008 and continued to be graded
“Average” through 2009.
9) It is, thus, apparent that in the last two years immediately preceding
to order of compulsory retirement, the appellant’s performance suffered
discernible decline, with the gradings dropping from “Good” to “Average” and
remaining stagnant thereafter. This is coupled with the fact that after his
last promotion in 2003, the appellant was inflicted with one minor penalty of
censure for furnishing a false reason to obtain leave, apart from being
warned on four occasions for negligence in duties and cautioned twice for
lethargic attitude.
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 4 of 7
10) At this juncture, it is necessary to deal with the appellant’s contention
that the penalties and adverse material preceding his promotion as
Inspector could not have been considered while assessing his suitability for
retention in service. In this regard, a beneficial reference can be made to a
decision of this Court in Rajasthan State Road Transport Corporation
6
and Others v. Babu Lal Jangir , wherein it was observed as follows:
“ 23. The principle of law which is clarified and stands
crystallised after the judgment in Pyare Mohan Lal v. State
of Jharkhand [(2010) 10 SCC 693 : (2011) 1 SCC (L&S) 550]
is that after the promotion of an employee the adverse
entries prior thereto would have no relevance and can be
treated as wiped off when the case of the government
employee is to be considered for further promotion .
However, this “washed-off theory” will have no application
when the case of an employee is being assessed to
determine whether he is fit to be retained in service or
requires to be given compulsory retirement. The rationale
given is that since such an assessment is based on “entire
service record”, there is no question of not taking into
consideration the earlier old adverse entries or record of the old
period. We may hasten to add that while such a record can be
taken into consideration, at the same time, the service record
of the immediate past period will have to be given due credence
and weightage. For example, as against some very old adverse
entries where the immediate past record shows exemplary
performance, ignoring such a record of recent past and acting
only on the basis of old adverse entries, to retire a person will
be a clear example of arbitrary exercise of power. However, if
old record pertains to integrity of a person then that may be
sufficient to justify the order of premature retirement of the
government servant.”
(emphasis supplied)
11) As is clear from the above, while the “washed-off theory” may operate
in matters relating to promotion, it has no application where the competent
authority assesses the suitability of an employee for continued retention in
service. The Committee was, therefore, justified in considering the
appellant's entire service record, including adverse material preceding the
appellant's promotion.
6
(2013) 10 SCC 551
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 5 of 7
12) A similar factual situation arose for consideration before this Court in
7
the case of Posts and Telegraphs Board and Others v. C.S.N. Murthy
wherein, despite the respondent having an otherwise satisfactory service
record, his standard of work had declined during the last two years
immediately preceding the review. While upholding the order of compulsory
retirement, this Court observed thus:
“ 5. ….We are unable to agree. In our opinion, there was
material which showed that the efficiency of the petitioner was
slackening in the last two years of the period under review and
it is, therefore, not possible for us to fault the conclusion of the
department as being mala fide, perverse, arbitrary or
unreasonable….It is true that the earlier record of the
respondent was good but if the record showed that the
standard of work of the respondent had declined and was not
satisfactory, that was certainly material enabling the
department to come to a conclusion under F.R. 56( j ). ….”
13) The aforesaid view also stands re-affirmed in Central Industrial
8
Security Force v. HC (GD) Om Prakash wherein this Court, while dealing
with an order of compulsory retirement passed under Rule 56(j) in respect of
a member of the CISF, reiterated that the entire service record is to be
considered, albeit with greater weight to the recent record of service.
14) In view of the aforesaid discussion, we find no infirmity in the decision
of the Committee. The Committee considered the appellant's entire service
record while according due weight to his declining performance during the
immediate preceding years, in conformity with the settled principles
governing compulsory retirement. We concur with the view taken by the
High Court affirming the same.
7
1992) 2 SCC 317
(
8
(2022) 5 SCC 100
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 6 of 7
15) It also cannot be lost sight of that the appellant was serving in the
CISF, a disciplined and uniformed force entrusted with vital security
functions. Members of such force are expected to maintain a consistently
high standard of efficiency, vigilance and discipline. Viewed in that light, the
decision of the competent authority warrants no interference.
16) Accordingly, the Civil Appeal is sans merit and dismissed.
…………………..........................J.
(PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA)
.………………............................J.
(SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR)
NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 06, 2026.
CIVIL APPEAL NO.8634 OF 2012 Page 7 of 7