Ranjeet Singh vs Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Bathinda Add Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
-1-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
(270-2) CWP No. 25738 of 2025
Date of Decision: 17.11.2026
Ranjeet Singh
......Petitioner
Versus
Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Bathinda and others
.....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH
Present: Mr. M.S. Kathuria, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Ashwani Talwar, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Riya Kaushal, Advocate
for respondent Nos.2 and 3.
Ms. Harmanjot Kaur, Advocate
for respondent No.4.
KIRTI SINGH , J. (ORAL)
1. The present writ petition has been filed under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India seeking quashing of the award dated 20.02.2025
(Annexure P-19) passed by respondent No.1 in Reference No.19 of 2018,
instituted on 05.02.2018, titled Ranjeet Singh Vs. M.D. Nestle India Ltd. and
others , whereby the industrial reference raised by the petitioner-workman
was answered against him and his claim for reinstatement with continuity of
service and full back wages was declined.
2. Briefly stated, as per the pleaded case of the petitioner, he was
engaged on 17.09.2010 as a Packing Helper through respondent No.4, M/s
Shri Krishna Manpower Services Pvt. Ltd., and deployed at the
establishment of respondent Nos.2 and 3. He claims to have worked
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
continuously till 01.03.2013 and to have drawn wages of Rs.7,500/- per
-2-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
month. According to the petitioner, his services were terminated on
01.03.2013 without notice, enquiry or payment of retrenchment
compensation, despite his having completed more than 240 days of service.
Aggrieved, the petitioner raised a demand under Section 2-A of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short, 'the Act of 1947'). Upon failure of
conciliation proceedings, the industrial dispute was referred for adjudication
to the Industrial Tribunal, Bathinda, where it was registered as Reference
No.19 of 2018. The reference required the learned Tribunal to adjudicate
whether the termination of the petitioner-workman was illegal and
unjustified and, if so, to what relief he was entitled. The petitioner filed his
statement of claim, which was contested by the respondent-management.
The stand of the management was that it was providing manpower to Nestle
India Pvt. Ltd. and that, on account of surplus manpower, 75 workers,
including the petitioner, were transferred to M/s Lumex Industry Limited, P.
No.66, Dharuhera Industrial Area, Rewari (Haryana), vide communication
dated 01.03.2013. The petitioner was required to join at the transferred place
by 08.03.2013 and report to M/s R.S. Rana at Gurgaon, Haryana. It was
pleaded that the petitioner did not join at the transferred place and, therefore,
the matter was one of transfer and not termination. The petitioner
controverted the aforesaid stand and maintained that his services had been
terminated without notice, enquiry or compensation. He thus reiterated his
claim for reinstatement with continuity of service and full back wages.
3. The learned Tribunal, after considering the pleadings and the
evidence led by the parties, answered the reference against the workman
vide the impugned award dated 20.02.2025. Aggrieved thereby, the
petitioner has approached this Court by way of the present writ petition.
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
-3-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
Tribunal erred in treating the matter as one of transfer rather than
termination. It is submitted that the petitioner neither received the transfer
letter dated 01.03.2013 nor was the said letter published in any newspaper.
Learned counsel submits that the management witness, in his cross-
examination, admitted that the letters sent to the petitioner through
registered post had been received back and that, thereafter, the management
had not got the said letter published in the newspaper. It is, therefore,
contended that there was no effective communication of the alleged transfer.
5. Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner had
admittedly completed more than 240 days of service and that no
retrenchment compensation was paid to him. It is, therefore, contended that
the termination was in violation of Section 25-F of the Act of 1947. Learned
counsel also submits that the plea of the petitioner that persons junior to him
continued in service was not specifically denied by the management. On
these grounds, interference with the impugned award is sought.
6. Per contra, learned senior counsel appearing for respondent
Nos.2 and 3 submits that the findings recorded by the learned Tribunal are
based upon appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence available on
record. It is submitted that the appointment letter contained a specific
condition enabling the management to transfer the petitioner; that 75
workers, including the petitioner, were transferred; and that the petitioner
did not join at the transferred place. It is, accordingly, submitted that the
learned Tribunal rightly concluded that the case was one of transfer and not
termination.
7. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent no.4 has
also controverted the facts as pleaded by the learned counsel for the
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
petitioner and has opposed the prayer made in the present petition.
-4-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
relevant material on record.
9. The controversy essentially turns upon the question as to
whether the petitioner's services stood terminated on 01.03.2013, as pleaded
by him, or whether he was transferred to another place of deployment, as
pleaded by the respondent-management and found by the learned Tribunal.
10. A perusal of the impugned award reveals that the learned
Tribunal noticed that the management had examined Shashi Pal Singh as
MW-1. He produced on record, inter alia, the list of transferred workers, the
communication dated 01.03.2013, the postal receipt, the appointment letter
of the petitioner and the memorandum of settlement. The management
witness also stated during the course of his examination that the
management had not recruited any workers at Moga after the transfer of the
employees. The Tribunal also took note of Ex.M-1, which contained the
names of 75 workers, including the petitioner, who had been transferred.
11. The petitioner also stepped into the witness-box. The learned
Tribunal noticed that the petitioner had admitted his appointment letter,
Ex.M-5. As recorded by the Tribunal, Clause 10 of the appointment letter
empowered the management to transfer the petitioner according to the
exigencies of service. The Tribunal also considered the transfer
communication and the postal material produced by the management,
including the fact that the address mentioned on the postal receipt was the
petitioner's correct address.
12. At this stage, it is necessary to notice the submission of learned
counsel for the petitioner regarding the transfer communication. MW-1, in
his cross-examination, did state that the letters sent to the petitioner through
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
registered post had been received back and that, thereafter, the management
-5-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
had not got the letter published in the newspaper. Thus, it would not be
correct to proceed on the basis that actual service of the transfer
communication upon the petitioner stood conclusively established merely
from the postal receipt. However, the aforesaid circumstance has to be
considered along with the other evidence on record and the reasons recorded
by the learned Tribunal.
13. Significantly, the learned Tribunal also considered the
petitioner's own affidavit, Ex.WW-1/A, and his statement in cross-
examination. It noticed that the affidavit referred to his having been asked to
report at Rewari, Haryana, pursuant to the communication dated 01.03.2013.
The Tribunal further noticed that the petitioner had not produced any
document to establish that respondent No.4 had terminated his services.
Although the petitioner denied in his cross-examination that he had been
transferred to Rewari, the learned Tribunal considered his affidavit and the
other documentary evidence while examining the rival versions of
termination and transfer. Thus, the conclusion of the Tribunal was not
founded merely upon the postal receipt or upon proof of actual delivery of
the transfer communication, but upon an overall assessment of the evidence
led by the parties.
14. The contention of the petitioner based upon completion of 240
days of service and non-payment of retrenchment compensation under
Section 25-F of the Act of 1947 also cannot be considered independently of
the foundational question as to whether there was a termination of service. If
the finding that the petitioner was transferred and his services were not
terminated is sustainable on the evidence on record, the question of
compliance with Section 25-F of the Act of 1947 would not arise. The
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
completion of 240 days of service, by itself, does not establish that the
-6-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
action of the management amounted to retrenchment.
15. This Court, while exercising jurisdiction under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution, does not sit as an appellate Court over the findings
recorded by the Industrial Tribunal. Interference is warranted where the
finding is based on no evidence, is perverse, suffers from a patent error of
law or jurisdiction, or where material evidence having a bearing on the
adjudication has been ignored. A mere possibility of another view on the
same evidence does not, by itself, furnish a ground for interference.
16. In the present case, the learned Tribunal considered the
appointment letter containing the transfer condition, the list of 75 transferred
workers, the transfer communication and the postal material, as well as the
oral evidence led by the parties. It also considered the petitioner's own
affidavit and his statement in cross-examination, particularly with regard to
the absence of any documentary material establishing his alleged termination
by respondent No.4. The Tribunal, on an overall appreciation of the material
before it, concluded that the petitioner had failed to establish that his
services had been illegally terminated.
17. The fact that the transfer communication was not conclusively
proved to have been served upon the petitioner does not, in the facts of the
present case, by itself render the entire award perverse. The learned Tribunal
had considered the said circumstance along with the other material available
on record. The petitioner has not been able to demonstrate that any material
finding recorded by the Tribunal is based on no evidence or that any such
finding suffers from a patent illegality warranting interference in the
exercise of supervisory jurisdiction.
18. The findings recorded by the learned Tribunal are, therefore,
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
findings of fact based upon appreciation of the evidence on record. This
-7-
CWP No. 25738 of 2025
Court finds no perversity, jurisdictional error or patent error of law
warranting interference in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction. This Court
cannot substitute its own appreciation of the evidence merely because
another view may possibly be taken on the same material.
19. Consequently, no ground for interference with the impugned
award dated 20.02.2025 is made out.
20. The present writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed.
21. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(KIRTI SINGH)
JUDGE
th
November 17 , 2026
Ithlesh
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
ITHLESH KUMAR
2026.11.21 13:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment