HEERA MANI vs STATE AND ANR

Court
Rajasthan High Court

[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB]
Reportable
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 1349/2011
CNR: RJHC010328302009 | URN: SAW / 3146U / 2011
Heera Mani Wife of Late Shri Kailash Chandra Sharma, resident
of Gram Post Kotkasim, District Alwar.
----Appellant
Versus
1. The State of Rajasthan through Director General of Police,
Rajasthan, Jaipur.
2. Superintendent of Police, Barmer.
----Respondents
For Appellant(s) : Mr. DS Sodha
Mr. Manvendra Singh
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Sandeep Soni
Ms. Sulochno Bishnoi for
Mr. B.L. Bhati, AAG
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJAY K. AGRAWAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINIT KUMAR MATHUR
Judgment
16/09/2026
Sanjay K. Agrawal, CJ.
1. The appellant (wife of the deceased Government servant)
has filed this writ appeal under Rule 134 of the Rajasthan High
Court Rules, 1952 questioning the validity and correctness of
judgment and order dated 11.12.2008 by which the substantive
writ petition filed by her has been dismissed by the learned Single
Judge on the ground of availability of alternative remedy and on
ground of delay and latches.
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(2 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
2. The appellant’s husband was initially appointed on the post
of Constable in the year 1979 in the respondent Department.
Unfortunately, he was suffering from Tuberculosis and owing to his
prolonged illness and deteriorating health condition, he was not in
a position to discharge his duties regularly during the particular
period and leading to institution of the departmental enquiry. A
charge-sheet under Rules 16 of the CCA Rules, 1958 was issued
against him, wherein following as many as six charges were
levelled against him, which read as under:-
“ Charge & 1 fd vki csgksns dkfu 133 iq0 yk0 ckM+esj ds inLFkkiUu
FksA fnukad 17-07-1994 ih ,e ls jkf= dLCkk xLr xSj gkftj gq, fnukad
17-07-1994 dks vken dk vkns'k ysdj tfj;s jiV la0 1099 ds gktj
M;qVh gq,A
Charge &
2 nks"kh deZpkjh ij yxk;k x;k vkjksi bl izdkj gS fd
fnukad 02-08-1994 dks viuh M;qVh dLCkk eksckbZy esa mEesn flag lmfu ds
lkFk yxh gqbZ Fkh vki M;qVh ij ugha x;s] ftl ij vkidh xSj gktjh
tfj;s jiV la0 107 ij ntZ dh x;hA fnukad 13-08-1994 dks vkne vkns'k
izkIr dj mifLFkr M;qVh gq, ftl ij vken tfj;s jiV la0 657 ds dh
xbZA
Charge &
3 nks’kh deZpkjh ij yxk;k x;k vkjksi bl izdkj gS fd
fnukad 17-08-94 dks jkf= xLr M;qVh esa u tkus ij vkidh xSj gkftj
tfj;s jiV la[;k 864 oDr ih ,e ntZ dh xbZ fnukad 20-09-1994 dks
vken vkns'k izkIr dj mifLFkr gq, vken jiV la[;k 1028 oDr 6 ih,e
ij dh xbZA
Charge & 4 nks"kh deZpkjh ij yxk;k x;k vkjksi fuEu gS fd fnukad
18-10-1994 dks vkidh M;qVh ohvkbZih M;qVh esa yxh gqbZ FkhA M;qVh ij u
tkus ls tfj;s jiV la0 889 oDr 10-30 ,,e ij vkidh xSj gktjh ntZ
dh xbZA fnukad 19-10-1994 dks vken dk vkns”k izkIr dj mifLFkr M;qVh
nh gq,A vken tfj;s jiV la0 950 oDr 10-30 ,,e ij dh xbZA
Charge
& 5 nks"kh deZpkjh ij yxk;k x;k vkjksi bl izdkj gS fd
fnukad 23-10-1994 dks vkidh M;qV DokZVj xkMZ M;qVh Fkh exj vki M;qVh
ls xSj gkftj gks x;s ftl ij tfj;s jiV la0 1178 oDr 8-35 ih,e ij
xSj gktjh ntZ dh xbZA fnukad 29-10-1994 dks vken vkns”k izkIr dj
mifLFkr M;qVh gq,A vken tfj;s jiV la0 1462 odr 12-00 ,,e ij dh
xbZA
Charge
& 6 nks’kh deZpkjh ij yxk;k x;k vkjksi bl izdkj gS fd
fnukad 30-10-1994 dks iq0 yk0 ckM+esj esa gktjh eqyktekuks dh ysus ij
vki xSj gkftj ik, Fks ftl ij tfj;s jiV la0 1512 nksigj 12 cts ij
vkidh xSj gktjh ntZ dh xbZA fnukad 1-11-1994 dks vken vkns”k izkIr
dj mifLFkr M;qVh gq,] ftl ij tfj;s jiV la0 13 oDr 11 ,,e ij
”
vken dh xbZA
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(3 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
3. The allegation for remaining absent was 57 days on six
occasions to which he filed a detailed reply refuting the charges
and submitted requisite documents regarding his illness.
Thereafter vide order dated 01.05.1995, the Disciplinary Authority
i.e. Superintendent of Police, Barmer appointed the Additional
Superintendent of Police, Barmer as an Enquiry Officer. The
Enquiry Officer, after conducting the enquiry, submitted its enquiry
report to the Disciplinary Authority, wherein it is mentioned that
the appellant’s husband could not appear personally and he
nominated one Khoraj Ram as his representative and two
witnesses, viz, Naval Singh, Constable 786 and Udai Raj Constable
173, were produced as defence witnesses. The said witnesses
categorically deposed that the husband of the appellant was
suffering from Tuberculosis and was not in a position to appear
before the Enquiry Officer and there was no other member in the
family to look after him and his treatment was going on.
4. The Enquiry Officer after conducting enquiry, submitted the
enquiry report to the disciplinary authority, wherein he held that
the husband of the appellant was guilty of the charges levelled
against him.
5. It is the case of the appellant’s husband that the enquiry
report was not supplied by the Enquiry Officer to him as provided
under Rule 16(10) of the CCA Rules. Thus, the said action of the
authority concerned is in utter violation of principles of natural
justice depriving the husband of the appellant an opportunity to
examine the finding recorded therein and to submit a
representation, if any. However, the disciplinary authority by order
dated 26.10.1996 after considering the enquiry report concurred
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(4 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
with the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer and consequently
imposed the penalty of termination of service upon the husband of
the appellant.
6. The appellant’s husband passed away after a prolonged
illness. However, the appellant and her family member could not
file an appeal in time and even he could not file writ petition on
account of being resident of remote district of Alwar. Ultimately,
she decided to file a writ petition being S.B. Civil Writ Petition
No.2021/2001 . Learned Single Judge after hearing the learned
counsel for the parties dismissed the said writ petition vide order
dated 11.12.2008 on preliminary ground of availability of
alternative remedy and delay in filing the writ petition, against
which this writ appeal has been preferred.
7. Mr. D.S. Sodha, learned counsel for the appellant submits
that learned Single Judge was absolutely unjustified in dismissing
the writ petition on the ground of delay and latches by recording a
finding that the appellant being widow was having no means to file
the writ petition in time, whereas the learned Single Judge ought
to have decided the writ petition on its merit. Otherwise as per
the statements of two witnesses namely Naval Singh, Constable
786 and Udai Raj Constable 173, wherein they have categorically
deposed before the Enquiry Officer that the husband of the
appellant was suffering from Tuberculosis. It is, therefore,
submitted that his absence from duty was on account of his
medical condition and the same was neither deliberate nor willful.
Though the charge of unauthorized absence was levelled against
the deceased government servant, but the department failed to
establish that such absence was willful or not. In support of his
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(5 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
contention, he relied upon the judgment of their Lordships of
Supreme Court in case of Krushnakant B. Parmar Vs. Union of
1
India and Ors. He further submits that copy of the enquiry
report was not served upon the appellant’s husband, which was
required to be supplied as per the ratio laid down judgment of
their Lordships of the Supreme Court in case of Union of India
2
Vs. Mohd. Ramzan Khan & H.P. State Electricity Board Ltd.
3
v. Mahesh Dahiya . He, therefore, prays that the writ petition
may kindly be allowed and the impugned order may be quashed
and set aside.
8. Learned counsel for the respondents would support the
impugned judgment. He submits that the husband of the appellant
was asked to furnish the medical certificate in support of his
illness, but the same could not be produced by him during the
course of inquiry.
9. We have considered the rival submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available
on record.
10. In the present case, this Court finds the following question to
be determined :
“Whether the learned Single Judge is absolutely
justified in dismissing the writ petition upholding the
order of termination?”
11. The first submission that has been raised on behalf of the
appellant is that the appellant’s husband was suffering from
1 2012 (3) SCC 178
2 (1991) 1 SCC 588
3 (2016) 12 SCC 583
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(6 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
prolonged illness i.e. Tuberculosis, therefore, he remained absent,
thus, the said absence was neither willful nor deliberate.
12. “Willful absence” has been considered by the Supreme Court
in the matter of Krushnakat B. Parmar v. Union of India wherein it
has been held that for sustaining allegations of failure to maintain
devotion to duty due to absence and conduct unbecoming of
government servant and dismissal based thereupon it must be
proved that unauthorized absence was willful. If absence is due to
compelling circumstances under which it is not possible to report
for or perform duty, such absence cannot be held to be willful and
employee guilty of misconduct. Their Lordships have further held
that absence from duty without any application or prior permission
may amount to unauthorized absence, but it would not be willful.
Paragraphs 15, 16, 17, 18 & 19 of the report read as under:-
“15. In the case of Appellant referring to unauthorized
absence the disciplinary authority alleged that he failed to
maintain devotion of duty and his behavior was unbecoming
of a Government servant.
16. The question whether 'unauthorized absence from duty'
amounts to failure of devotion to duty or behavior
unbecoming of a Government servant cannot be decided
without deciding the question whether absence is willful or
because of compelling circumstances.
17. If the absence is the result of compelling circumstances
under which it was not possible to report or perform duty,
such absence can not be held to be willful.
18. Absence from duty without any application or prior
permission may amount to unauthorized absence, but it
does not always mean willful. There may be different
eventualities due to which an employee may abstain from
duty, including compelling circumstances beyond his control
like illness, accident, hospitalization, etc., but in such case
the employee cannot be held guilty of failure of devotion to
duty or behavior unbecoming of a Government servant.
19. In a Departmental proceeding, if allegation of
unauthorized absence from duty is made, the disciplinary
authority is required to prove that the absence is willful, in
absence of such finding, the absence will not amount to
misconduct”.
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(7 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
13. Similarly, in the matter of Chhel Singh v. M.G.B. Gramin
4
Bank, Pali and Others , the Supreme Court has held that in
order to hold a person guilty for unauthorized absence from duty,
the unauthorized absence from duty must be willful and
deliberate. In paragraph 15 of the report, their Lordships of
Supreme Court observed as under:-
“15. ….There was no allegation that the appellant’s
unauthorized absence from duty was willful and
deliberate. The Inquiry Officer has also not held that
appellant’s absence from duty was willful and
deliberate. It is neither case of the disciplinary
Authority nor the Inquiry Officer that the medical
reports submitted by the appellant were forged or
fabricated or obtained for any consideration though
he was not ill during the said period. In absence of
such evidence and finding, it was not open to the
Inquiry Officer or the Disciplinary Authority to
disbelieve the medical certificates issued by the
doctors without any valid reason on the ground of 24
days delay.”
14. Coming to the facts of the present case in the light of the
aforesaid principle laid down by their Lordships of Supreme Court,
it is evident that although the charge of unauthorized absence was
levelled against the deceased Government servant, but the
department could not establish that his absence was willful. On
the contrary, on behalf of the deceased Government servant,
Constable No.786 Naval Singh and Constable No.173 Udai Raj
were examined, who categorically deposed that during the
relevant period, the husband of the appellant was unwell and was
suffering from tuberculosis and, therefore, he remained absent
from duties. Shri Udai Raj, Constable No.173 has also reiterated
that the deceased Government servant was suffering from
tuberculosis for a considerable period and that on account of such
4 2014 AIR SCW 6539
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(8 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
prolonged illness, he remained absent on several occasions. Thus,
there was sufficient evidence available on record to establish that
the absence was not willful but occasioned due to his prolonged
illness.
15. Their Lordships of Supreme Court in Krushnakant (supra)
has clearly held that if allegation of willful absence is refuted by
showing compelling circumstances under which it was not possible
for a government servant to report on duty or perform his duties
owing to such circumstances, the absence cannot be treated as
willful absence. In such circumstances, the employee’s absence
cannot be held to be unbecoming of a Government servant as
provided under Rules.
16. In view of the aforesaid, we are unable to uphold the order
of termination as the respondent Department was not able to
prove that the deceased Government servant was willfully absent
from his duties. Furthermore on behalf of the deceased
Government servant, ample evidence has been brought on record
to show that his absence was not willful but the same was on
account of his prolonged illness i.e. Tuberculosis. There is one
more reason for setting aside the termination order because
deceased Government servant specifically stated that the copy of
enquiry report was not served upon him as provided under Rules
16 (10) of the CCA Rules, 1958. Their Lordships of Supreme Court
in the case of Mohd. Ramzan Khan (supra) has held that the
delinquent employee is entitled to have a copy of the enquriy
report before the disciplinary authority takes a final decision. The
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:58 AM)

(9 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
relevant paragraphs of the said judgment are reproduced as
under:-
“18. We make it clear that wherever there has been an
Inquiry Officer and he has furnished a report to the
disciplinary authority at the conclusion of the inquiry holding
the delinquent guilty of all or any of the charges with
proposal for any particular punishment or not, the delinquent
is entitled to a copy of such report and will also be entitled to
make a representation against it, if he so desires, and non-
furnishing of the report would amount to violation of rules of
natural justice and make the final order liable to challenge
hereafter.
19. On the basis of this conclusion, the appeals are allowed
and the disciplinary action in every case is set aside. There
shall be no order for costs. We would clarify that this decision
may not preclude the disciplinary authority from revising the
proceeding and continuing with it in accordance with law
from the stage of supply of the inquiry report in cases where
dismissal or removal was the punishment. Appeals allowed”.
16. Furthermore, Their Lordships of Supreme Court in the case
of Mahesh Dahiya (supra) has held that when the disciplinary
authority forms an opinion to punish a delinquent employee with
major penalty even before forwarding copy of the enquiry report
to him, the same is nothing but in clear violation of principles of
natural justice.
17. In view of the discussions made here-in-above, this Court
finds that the respondent-department has failed to establish that
the absence of the husband of the appellant was willful.
Furthermore, non-supply of the enquriy report resulted into
violation of principle of natural justice.
18. Accordingly, the special appeal (writ) is allowed. The order of
termination dated 26.10.1996 as well as the order of learned
Single Judge dated 11.12.2008 are hereby quashed as set aside.
Since the husband of the appellant (deceased Government
servant) has already died, the appellant (wife) will be entitled for
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:59 AM)

(10 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JD:44608-DB] [SAW-1349/2011]
all consequential service/retiral benefits within a period of 45 days
from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
(VINIT KUMAR MATHUR),J (SANJAY K. AGRAWAL),CJ
22/Payal Rani/Sanjay Solanki
(Uploaded on 18/09/2026 at 01:17:16 PM)
(Downloaded on 19/09/2026 at 12:08:59 AM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)