AADIL vs WESTERN RAILWAY

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

:: 1 :: OA No.414/2025




CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 414/2025

th
Dated this the 05 day of November, 2026.


Reserved On: 07.10.2026
Pronounced On: 05.11.2026



CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)


Shri Aadil
S/o. Imtiyazhusen Malek
Aged 31 years
Trainee/App/Fitter III/KRCA YARD, VADODARA
R/o.: 40, Christian Street, Nr. Ramdev Pir Temple,
Nizampura, Vadodara – 390 002.
… Applicants


(By Advocate Ms. S S Chaturvedi)

V/s.


1. Union of India,
Notice to be served through,
General Manager (E), Western Railway,
Churchgate, Mumbai – 400 020.

2. Divisional Railway Manager (E),
Western Railway, DRM’s Office,
Pratapnagar, Vadodara - 390 004.

… Respondents


(By Advocate Mr. H D Shukla)







P ANUKUMA

:: 2 :: OA No.414/2025




ORDER

Per: Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed the present OA, under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs:
“8.1 Lord Ships be pleased to admit this petition. And be
pleased to issue an order quash and set aside
Annexure Order no. 890/60/1/CGA/Forwarding of
Application Vol.II Dated 14.08.2025 (Annex/A/1),
Order No. E File no. 52712 dated 13.02.2024 (Annex.
A/2) and Order no. E/Conf/890/1 (008/22) dated
26.06.2024 (Annex. A/3)
8.2 And be pleased to direct the respondent to
Appont/reconsider the applicant appointment as CLA
(Chief Law Assistant) on Compassionate grounds
w.e.f. the date he was initially appointed as Fitter III
and grant him notional seniority from the date with all
consequential benefits.
8.3 The Hon’ble Tribunal may be kindly pleased to call for
the entire record of the applicant in possession of the
respondent for its kind perusal.
8.4 any other relief which the Hon’ble Tribunal deems fit.
8.5 That the Hon’ble Tribunal in the facts and
circumstances of the present case may further be
pleased to grant the cost of the application to the
applicant.
2. Brief facts of the case as stated by the applicant are as under: -
2.1 The father of the applicant, Late Shri Imtiyaz Husen Malek, was
serving as Assistant Sub-Inspector in the Railway Protection Force
(RPF), Western Railway. He died in harness on 09.08.2021.
2.2 The applicant, being a dependent son, sought appointment on
compassionate grounds. The respondents initiated the process of
considering his candidature for appointment in Group 'C'.
2.3 Initially, the applicant was considered for the post of Sub-
Inspector, RPF. He appeared in the Physical Efficiency Test (PET)
held on 24.03.2022 but could not qualify.
2.4 Thereafter, the applicant was considered for appointment in the
divisional cadre. He appeared in the common Computer Based
Test (CBT) and secured 48 marks out of 100.
P ANUKUMA

:: 3 :: OA No.414/2025



2.5 The applicant was found medically fit in medical category and was
considered by the Screening Committee for different Group ‘C’
categories.
2.6 The applicant was initially recommended for the post of
Commercial-cum-Ticket Clerk, but the competent authority did not
agree with the recommendation. Subsequently, the Screening
Committee recommended his candidature for the post of Station
Master, Level-6, having regard to his educational qualification,
medical classification and availability of vacancies.
2.7 The applicant, however, expressed his preference for the post of
Staff and Welfare Inspector (S&WLI), referring to his educational
qualification of B.A., LL.B., with specialisation in Labour Laws.
His application dated 28.07.2022 was submitted in this regard.
2.8 The respondents contend that no vacancy under the Direct
Recruitment Quota was available for the post of Welfare Inspector
at the relevant time. The applicant was accordingly advised to
undergo the prescribed written examination for the post of Station
Master.
2.9 The applicant qualified in the written examination but could not
qualify the prescribed Psychological/Aptitude Test, despite being
granted two opportunities.
2.10 Subsequently, the applicant appeared before the Screening
Committee on 02.01.2024 and was recommended for the post of
Technician (Fitter) Grade-III in the Mechanical Department
(C&W), Level-2.
2.11 Accordingly, an offer of appointment dated 13.02.2024 (Annexure
A/2) was issued to the applicant. The applicant, however,
submitted a representation dated 15.02.2024 to the Divisional
Railway Manager, Vadodara, seeking appointment as Welfare
Inspector on compassionate grounds.
2.12 The respondents, vide communication dated 26.06.2024
(Annexure A/3), rejected his request for appointment as Staff and
Welfare Inspector and directed him to join the allotted category
P ANUKUMA

:: 4 :: OA No.414/2025



within 15 days, failing which his candidature was liable to be
treated as cancelled.
2.13 The applicant also relied upon the case of Ku. Shanu Singh, who
was initially offered appointment as Welder Grade-III on
compassionate grounds and was subsequently appointed as Chief
Law Assistant in Vadodara Division, vide order dated 10.11.2023,
having regard to her higher educational qualifications.
2.14 The applicant submitted a further representation dated 01.06.2024,
addressed to the Principal Chief Personnel Officer, Western
Railway, Churchgate, Mumbai, and received for dispatch in the
office of the Divisional Railway Manager, Vadodara on
02.07.2024, seeking appointment as Chief Law Assistant
(Annexure A/12).
2.15 The applicant had earlier approached this Tribunal in O.A. No. 216
of 2025. By order dated 05.05.2025, the Tribunal directed the
respondents to consider his representation in accordance with law
(Annexure A/13).
2.16 In compliance with the aforesaid order, the General Manager
(Establishment), Western Railway, issued the impugned
communication dated 14.08.2025 (Annexure A/1), rejecting the
applicant’s request on the ground that he had already accepted the
offer of appointment and joined as Technician (Fitter) Grade-III
and under the extant instructions, change of category was not
permissible after acceptance of the offer and medical examination.
Hence, the present OA.
3. Submission of learned counsel for the applicant
3.1 Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the applicant
possesses the qualification of B.A., LL.B., with specialisation in
Labour Laws and his educational qualification was relevant for
consideration against suitable legal or welfare-related Group 'C'
posts.
3.2 Learned counsel submitted that the respondents failed to properly
consider the applicant’s claim under Master Circular No. 16
governing compassionate appointments in the Indian Railways.
P ANUKUMA

:: 5 :: OA No.414/2025



Particular reliance was placed upon paragraph 6 of Master
Circular No. 16, which provides for assessment of the suitability of
candidates through a Screening Committee consisting of three
Senior Scale Officers, one of whom should be a Personnel Officer,
and, in sub-paragraph (ii), prescribes the number of chances to be
given. The relevant portion of sub-paragraph (ii) reads as under: -
“6….
(ii) Number of chances: -
Maximum of three chances to the wards and four chances may
be given to widow/wife commensurate with their educational
qualification to the post and suitability may be adjudged
accordingly. Second chance should be given as a rule and
nd
uniformly followed. 2 chance to wards and widow should be
given with the approval of competent authority
rd
(DRMs/HODs/CWMs as the case may be. However, 3 chance
th
to ward/widow/wife and 4 chance to widow/wife will require
personal approval of the General Manager”.
It was submitted that where a candidate possesses the requisite
minimum qualifications for Group 'C' posts, his suitability for
different categories should be assessed and recorded by the
Screening Committee, which should also indicate the categories
for which the candidate has not been found suitable.
3.3 Learned counsel further argued that the respondents restricted their
consideration to the posts of Sub-Inspector, RPF and Station
Master and, upon the applicant’s failure to qualify the tests specific
to those categories, allotted him the technical post of Technician
(Fitter) Grade-III without properly examining his suitability for
other categories.
3.4 It was submitted that failure in the Physical Efficiency Test for the
RPF post or in the Psychological/Aptitude Test for the post of
Station Master cannot automatically be treated as a finding of
unsuitability for a legal or welfare-related post, which involves
different eligibility requirements and duties.
3.5 Learned counsel also relied upon Railway Board’s letter RBE No.
26/2021 dated 05.04.2021 concerning eligibility criteria for the
post of Chief Law Assistant in Level-7 and submitted that a degree
in Law is recognised under the relevant Railway instructions.
3.6 It was further submitted that the case of Ku. Shanu Singh
demonstrates that the Railway Administration has, in appropriate
P ANUKUMA

:: 6 :: OA No.414/2025



circumstances, considered compassionate appointment to the post
of Chief Law Assistant, having regard to the candidate's
qualifications and availability of vacancy.
3.7 Learned counsel placed reliance upon the judgment of the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. No. 1128 of 2015 ,
decided on 15.11.2017, wherein the Tribunal considered the
Railway Board’s circular dated 07.08.2009 concerning change of
category in compassionate appointment cases.
3.8 Reliance was also placed upon the order passed by the Jammu
Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. No. 61/1001/2021, dated
29.02.2024/24.04.2024, wherein the claim of a qualified dependent
for appointment to a higher post was considered in the context of
the applicable compassionate appointment rules and the
availability of similarly situated candidates.
3.9 It was contended that the applicant had repeatedly requested
consideration of his case even before joining the post of
Technician (Fitter) Grade-III and his subsequent joining was in the
circumstances arising from the respondents’ communication dated
26.06.2024, which required him to join within 15 days, failing
which his candidature would be cancelled.
3.10 Learned counsel submitted that the impugned order dated
14.08.2025 does not deal with the applicant’s specific
representations, the relevant policy provisions or the exception
contained in the Railway Board’s circular dated 07.08.2009.
3.11 On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel prayed that the impugned
orders be quashed and the respondents be directed to reconsider
the applicant’s appointment as Chief Law Assistant on
compassionate grounds with appropriate consequential benefits.
4. Submission of learned counsel for the respondent
4.1 Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents have filed their
reply and submitted that the applicant has no enforceable right to
claim appointment to a particular post on compassionate grounds.
4.2 It was submitted that the object of compassionate appointment is to
provide immediate financial assistance to the family of a deceased
P ANUKUMA

:: 7 :: OA No.414/2025



employee and not to secure employment to a dependent according
to his individual preference or educational status.
4.3 Learned counsel submitted that the applicant was initially
considered for the post of Sub-Inspector in the RPF Department
but could not qualify the Physical Efficiency Test.
4.4 Thereafter, the applicant was considered for the post of Station
Master, Level-6, on the basis of his medical classification A/2 and
availability of vacancy. Although he qualified in the written
examination, he failed to qualify the Psychological/Aptitude Test
even after being granted a second opportunity.
4.5 It was submitted that the applicant was thereafter considered by a
duly constituted Screening Committee and recommended for the
post of Technician (Fitter) Grade-III, in accordance with his
performance in the common CBT and the applicable criteria.
4.6 Learned counsel further submitted that no vacancy under the
Direct Recruitment Quota was available for the post of Staff and
Welfare Inspector when the applicant initially sought consideration
for the said category on 28.07.2022.
4.7 It was argued that the applicant repeatedly changed his preference
from Staff and Welfare Inspector to Station Master and thereafter
to Chief Law Assistant, resulting in unnecessary administrative
inconvenience.
4.8 Learned counsel relied upon Railway Board’s letter dated
07.08.2009, which provides that a change in the category allotted
to a compassionate appointment candidate can be considered only
before acceptance of the offer of appointment and medical
examination. Once the offer is accepted and the candidate
undergoes medical examination, a change of category can be made
only on account of medical unfitness or by an authority higher than
the authority which decided the original allotment.
4.9 It was submitted that the applicant had accepted the offer of
appointment and joined as Technician (Fitter) Grade-III on
05.09.2024. Therefore, his subsequent request for appointment to a
higher post was not permissible.
P ANUKUMA

:: 8 :: OA No.414/2025



4.10 Learned counsel also relied upon Railway Board’s letter dated
02.11.1989, RBE No. 274/1989, which provides that the type of
job offered to a candidate found suitable for compassionate
appointment is within the discretion of the competent authority,
depending upon the suitability of the candidate for the particular
job and the merits of each case and the relevant portion of the said
RBE reads as under: -
“3. Board have also decided that the type of job to be
offered to a candidate found suitable for compassionate
appointment will be left to the discretion of the
competent authority and it will depend on the suitability
of the candidate for the particular job and the merits of
each case.

4. Board desire that while considering cases for
appointment on compassionate grounds, the decisions
of the Board as mentioned in the preceding paragraphs,
may be kept in view”.

4.11 With regard to the case of Ku. Shanu Singh, learned counsel
submitted that her case was entirely different. She was initially
allotted the post of Welder Grade-III at Dahod Workshop.
Subsequently, on the request of her family, her compassionate
appointment case was transferred to Vadodara Division under the
applicable instructions.
4.12 It was submitted that Ku. Shanu Singh possessed the qualifications
of M.A. and LL.M. and was medically fit in category B/1. Her
case was considered against an anticipated vacancy for Chief Law
Assistant, having regard to her qualifications, medical
classification and the applicable instructions.
4.13 Learned counsel therefore submitted that the applicant cannot claim
parity with Ku. Shanu Singh merely on the basis of her
appointment.
4.14 Learned counsel also relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana,
(1994) 4 SCC 138, and submitted that compassionate appointment
is a concession and not a matter of right.
4.15 Learned counsel further placed reliance upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in The Director of Town Panchayat &
P ANUKUMA

:: 9 :: OA No.414/2025



Others v. M. Jayabal & Another, Civil Appeal Nos. 12640–12643
of 2025, decided on 12.12.2025, to contend that an employee who
has accepted and joined a post on compassionate grounds cannot
subsequently claim appointment to a higher post merely on the
basis of superior educational qualifications. Learned counsel
submitted that the judgment relied upon by the applicant in O.A.
No. 1128 of 2015 is distinguishable and cannot override the
subsequent law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Hence,
the present OA should be dismissed.
5. Applicant has filed rejoinder and additional submissions as under:
5.1 It was submitted that the applicant was initially recommended for
Group-'C' appointment by the Screening Committee on 13.01.2022
and was subsequently considered for various categories, including
Commercial Clerk, Sub-Inspector and Assistant Station Master. He
was also permitted to appear in the common CBT examination.
5.2 Learned counsel contended that despite possessing an LL.B.
degree and having no ITI or Diploma qualification, the applicant
was allotted the technical post of Technician/Fitter Grade-III
without properly considering his suitability for legal or ministerial
categories, contrary to the spirit of Railway Board’s Master
Circular No.16.
5.3 It was further submitted that the applicant continuously requested
consideration for Welfare Inspector and Chief Law Assistant
through various representations, including those dated 15.02.2024
and 01.06.2024. Therefore, he never voluntarily accepted the
technical category without protest.
5.4 Learned counsel relied upon the case of Ku. Shanu Singh, who
was initially allotted the post of Welder Grade-III but was
subsequently considered and accommodated as Chief Law
Assistant on the basis of her legal qualification and anticipated
vacancy. It was contended that denial of similar consideration to
the applicant, who also possesses a law degree, amounts to
discrimination and violates Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India.
P ANUKUMA

:: 10 :: OA No.414/2025



5.5 It was submitted that the judgments in Umesh Kumar Nagpal v.
State of Haryana and The Director of Town Panchayat v. M.
Jayabal are distinguishable, as the applicant is not claiming a
higher post merely on the basis of qualification but is seeking fair
consideration for a suitable category under the applicable Railway
policy.
5.6 Learned counsel further relied upon the RTI reply dated
05.03.2026 (Annexure A/22), wherein the respondents clarified
that no seniority is assigned during training and that seniority is
assigned only after regularisation, successful completion of
training and passing of the trade test. Therefore, the applicant
contended that his request for reconsideration should not have been
rejected mechanically on the ground of change of category.
6. Respondents have filed additional affidavit and submitted that the
applicant’s appointment as Technician/Fitter Grade-III on
compassionate grounds was made in accordance with the
applicable Railway Board instructions.
6.1 Railway Board Circular No. RBE 113/2000 dated 19.06.2000
specifically prescribes 10th pass as the minimum educational
qualification for compassionate appointment as Skilled Artisan
Grade-III, with three years of training. The ITI/Act Apprenticeship
requirement applies to open-market recruitment.
6.2 RBE No. 34/2008 and RBE No. 166/2010 further provide for three
years of training for matriculates and candidates possessing non-
technical higher qualifications. The applicant’s B.A./LL.B.
qualification falls within the category of non-technical higher
qualification. Thus, his appointment was permissible subject to
prescribed training.
6.3 RBE No. 92/2024 dated 09.10.2024 revised the training
provisions. Subsequently, RBE No. 51/2025 dated 06.06.2025
clarified that matriculation or any higher qualification may be
considered for the prescribed two-year training category. These
subsequent instructions do not invalidate the applicant’s earlier
appointment.
P ANUKUMA

:: 11 :: OA No.414/2025



6.4 The Applicant was screened on 02.01.2024 and recommended for
Technician/Fitter Grade-III by the competent authority. The
Respondents submit that the allotment was made after considering
the applicable scheme and relevant conditions.
6.5 The applicant’s B.A./LL.B. qualification does not confer an
automatic right to appointment as Chief Law Assistant or Welfare
Inspector. Such appointment depends upon eligibility, suitability,
availability of vacancies and approval of the competent authority.
6.6 In view of the above, the respondents submit that the appointment
of the applicant as Technician/Fitter Grade-III was permissible
under the applicable rules and that no illegality is made out. The
OA, therefore, deserves to be dismissed.
7. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
8. The principal question which arises for consideration is whether
the applicant, having been appointed as Technician/Fitter Grade-III
on compassionate grounds, is entitled to a direction for his
appointment or reconsideration for the post of Chief Law Assistant
(CLA) on the basis of his B.A., LL.B. qualification.
9. There is no dispute that the father of the applicant died in harness
while serving in the Railway Protection Force. The applicant was
thereafter considered for compassionate appointment and was
examined for different categories. He could not qualify the
Physical Efficiency Test for the post of Sub-Inspector, RPF.
Subsequently, although he qualified in the written examination for
the post of Station Master, he could not qualify the prescribed
Psychological/Aptitude Test despite being given another
opportunity.
10. The record further indicates that the applicant was thereafter
considered by the Screening Committee on 02.01.2024 and
recommended for appointment as Technician/Fitter Grade-III in
the Mechanical Department, Level-2. Accordingly, an offer of
appointment dated 13.02.2024 was issued to him. The applicant
ultimately joined the said post on 05.09.2024.
P ANUKUMA

:: 12 :: OA No.414/2025



11. The applicant has primarily contended that, being a B.A., LL.B.
graduate with specialisation in Labour Laws, his suitability for a
legal or welfare-related post, particularly Chief Law Assistant,
ought to have been considered before allotting him the technical
post of Technician/Fitter Grade-III. It is also stated that he had
repeatedly represented against the allotment and, therefore, his
joining cannot be treated as voluntary acceptance of the technical
category.
12. On the other hand, the respondents have submitted that the
appointment as Technician/Fitter Grade-III was permissible under
the specific Railway Board instructions governing compassionate
appointment to the Skilled Artisan category. In this regard, reliance
has been placed upon RBE No. 113/2000 dated 19.06.2000.
12 .1 The said circular specifically provides that the minimum
educational qualification for compassionate appointment to the
post of Skilled Artisan Grade-III shall be 10th pass, while retaining
the separate qualification of Act Apprenticeship/ITI in the relevant
trade for open-market recruitment. It also prescribes a training
period of three years for such compassionate appointees.
13. The respondents have further relied upon RBE No. 34/2008 and
RBE No. 166/2010, which provide for the prescribed training
period for matriculates and persons possessing non-technical
higher qualifications. The applicant's B.A., LL.B. qualification
falls within the category of non-technical higher qualification for
this purpose.
14. We also take note of RBE No. 92/2024 dated 09.10.2024 and the
subsequent corrigendum RBE No. 51/2025 dated 06.06.2025. The
latter clarifies the training category by including matriculation
alone or matriculation along with non-relevant ITI courses or any
other higher qualification. These instructions concern the period of
training and do not, by themselves, establish any entitlement to
appointment as Chief Law Assistant.
15. In view of the aforesaid instructions, we are unable to accept the
contention that the applicant’s appointment as Technician/Fitter
P ANUKUMA

:: 13 :: OA No.414/2025



Grade-III was illegal merely because he did not possess ITI or
technical qualification. The specific compassionate appointment
instructions relied upon by the respondents prescribe a different
educational qualification from that applicable to open-market
recruitment. The appointment was, however, subject to the
prescribed training and other applicable conditions.
16. The next question is whether the applicant's educational qualification
gives him an enforceable right to appointment as Chief Law
Assistant. In this regard, it is well settled that compassionate
appointment is an exception to the general rule of recruitment and
is intended to provide immediate financial assistance to the family
of a deceased employee. It cannot be treated as a mode of
recruitment through which a dependent can claim a particular post
merely on the basis of his educational qualification.
17. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of
Haryana, (1994) 4 SCC 138, observed that compassionate
appointment cannot be claimed as a matter of right and must be
governed by the applicable rules and instructions.
18. The applicant has placed reliance upon RBE No. 26/2021
concerning the eligibility criteria for the post of Chief Law
Assistant. Even assuming that the applicant possesses the requisite
educational qualification for consideration against the said post,
mere possession of the prescribed qualification does not confer an
automatic right to compassionate appointment as Chief Law
Assistant. His claim would also depend upon the applicable
compassionate appointment policy, suitability, availability of
vacancy and approval of the competent authority.
19. The provision in Master Circular No. 16 concerning consideration
of suitable candidates for Group-C posts, including legal
categories, has to be read along with the other applicable Railway
Board instructions. It cannot be interpreted as conferring an
unconditional right to demand a particular post.
20. The applicant has also relied upon the case of Ku. Shanu Singh,
who was initially allotted the post of Welder Grade-III and was
P ANUKUMA

:: 14 :: OA No.414/2025



subsequently considered for the post of Chief Law Assistant in
Vadodara Division. The respondents have explained that her case
involved different circumstances, including transfer of her
compassionate appointment case to Vadodara Division, her
educational qualifications, medical classification and consideration
against an anticipated vacancy.
21. In our considered view, the case of another employee cannot create
an enforceable right in favour of the applicant. The applicant
would be required to establish that the cases were identical in all
material respects and that the benefit extended to the other
employee was in accordance with the applicable rules. The
respondents have pointed out material differences in her case,
namely transfer of her case to Vadodara Division, her
qualifications of M.A. and LL.M., her medical category B/1 and
consideration against an anticipated vacancy, and the applicant has
not shown that he was similarly placed. Further, negative
discrimination cannot be claimed where no right is made out (M.
Jayabal (supra), para 24).
22. In this context, the recent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in The Director of Town Panchayat & Others v. M. Jayabal &
Another, Civil Appeal Nos. 12640–12643 of 2025 and connected
matters, decided on 12.12.2025, is relevant. The relevant portion
of the judgment reads as under: -
“22. If the facts of the case in hand are considered, in our
view, belated applications made by the respondents seeking
appointment on a higher post, after they had already been
appointed on a lower post, was rightly rejected by the
competent authority. The view expressed by learned Single
Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court directing
their appointment on a higher post w.e.f the date of
judgement was certainly erroneous and contrary to the spirit
of the law laid down by this Court on the subject.

23. In our view, the issue of discrepancies/anomalies, as
were sought to be pointed out with respect to the relevant
government orders, or the rights which, according to the
respondents, were flowing to them on the basis of the said
government orders, is not required to be touched as, for the
purpose of grant or refusal of relief to the respondents,
nothing hinges on the said government orders.

24. The only plea raised by the respondents/M. Jayabal & S.
Veeramani for seeking appointment on a higher post was
P ANUKUMA

:: 15 :: OA No.414/2025



that they were ignorant about their right for such
appointment, initially, on a higher post and that a similar
relief having been granted to others, the respondents should
not be discriminated against. It is well-settled that ignorance
of law is not an excuse, as a result of which, such plea
raised by the respondents cannot be entertained. Further,
negative discrimination cannot be claimed if a no right can
be made out as per the settled position of law.

25. For the reasons mentioned above, we find merit in the
present appeals. The same are accordingly allowed and the
impugned judgment/s of the High Court are set aside.
Resultantly, W.P.No.16759 of 2015 filed by respondent/M.
Jayabal and W.P. No 16758 of 2015 filed by respondent/S.
Veeramani before the High Court are dismissed. There shall
be no order as to costs”.

23. The representations dated 15.02.2024 and 01.06.2024 are on
record. In the first, addressed to the Divisional Railway Manager,
Vadodara, the applicant sought appointment as Welfare Inspector,
referring to the Railway Board’s letter No. E(NG)II/2021/RR-I/66
dated 13.04.2022 and to his earlier applications. It states that he
had applied on 28.01.2022 with reference to the said letter dated
13.04.2022, which is not possible in point of time; nothing,
however, turns on this. In the second, addressed to the Principal
Chief Personnel Officer, he sought appointment as Chief Law
Assistant on the basis of his LL.B. degree, stating that he had
failed the psychological test for Station Master twice, that the post
of Fitter-III was not suitable for a law graduate, that he was willing
to work in any division of the Western Railway, and that his
family was facing financial difficulty. Neither representation raises
the grounds now urged before us, namely Master Circular No. 16,
the Railway Board’s letter dated 07.08.2009, the case of Ku. Shanu
Singh, or discrimination under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution. These grounds have been raised for the first time in
the OA and the rejoinder. The competent authority cannot be
faulted for not dealing with grounds which were never placed
before it.
23.1 The representations preceded his joining on 05.09.2024, but this
does not alter the position. Both sought a post of his choice on the
basis of his educational qualification alone, after he had been
considered for different categories and allotted a post by the
P ANUKUMA

:: 16 :: OA No.414/2025



Screening Committee. The principle reiterated in M. Jayabal
(supra), that a person given compassionate appointment cannot
claim appointment to a higher post on that basis, applies. The
representations entitled him to have his request considered, not to
the post he sought.
24. The impugned communication dated 14.08.2025 was issued by the
General Manager (Establishment), Western Railway, in
compliance with the earlier direction of this Tribunal in O.A. No.
216 of 2025. The applicant’s request was considered and rejected
with reference to his acceptance of the offered appointment and the
applicable instructions. The communication is thus a reasoned
decision on the request as actually made. We find no material
before us to establish that the said decision was taken by an
authority lacking competence or that the applicant had an absolute
right to the change sought.
25 . The applicant has also relied upon the RTI reply dated 05.03.2026,
according to which seniority is not assigned during training and is
assigned after regularisation, successful completion of training and
passing of the trade test. The said information relates to the manner
in which seniority is determined in the Technician category. It does
not establish any right in favour of the applicant to be appointed as
Chief Law Assistant.
26. The decisions of the Principal Bench in O.A. No. 1128 of 2015 and
of the Jammu Bench in O.A. No. 61/1001/2021 relied upon by the
applicant are based on different facts and circumstances and orders
were passed as they were discriminated against similarly situated
persons which is not the case here. In view of the principles laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal
(supra) and M. Jayabal (supra), the said decisions, therefore, do
not advance the applicant’s case.
27 . We are, therefore, of the considered view that the applicant has
failed to establish any enforceable right to be appointed as Chief
Law Assistant on compassionate grounds from the date of his
initial appointment as Technician/Fitter Grade-III. His educational
P ANUKUMA

:: 17 :: OA No.414/2025



qualification, though relevant for determining eligibility for a
particular post, cannot by itself confer a right to such appointment
or to notional seniority and consequential benefits. The
respondents have also placed on record the relevant Railway Board
instructions to demonstrate that the initial appointment as
Technician/Fitter Grade-III was permissible under the
compassionate appointment scheme, subject to prescribed training.
No sufficient ground has been made out for setting aside the
impugned communications dated 26.06.2024 and 14.08.2025 or
the appointment order dated 13.02.2024.
28. In view of the foregoing discussions:
(i) OA stands dismissed.
(ii) There shall be no order as to costs.
(iii) MA pending if any, also stands disposed of.




(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)


//Anu//
P ANUKUMA