Shiv Dayal Soni vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
1 WP-10777-2016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT
th
ON THE 16 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 10777 of 2016
CNR No.: MPHC010320592016
SHIV DAYAL SONI
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Anand Singh Thakur - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri D. Mishra - Panel Lawyer for the respondent/State.
ORDER
This petition, under Article 226 of Constitution of India, has been filed
seeking the following relief (s):-
“(i)
This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to command
the respondents to stop recovery proceedings against the
petitioner and restrain them from making any recovery of the
amount from the pension amount payable to the petitioner.
(ii) This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to command
the respondents to immediately refund the entire amount
illegally recovered from the salary of the petitioner with
interest.
(iii) Any other relief which this Hon’ble Court finds the
petitioner to be
entitled be also granted.
(iv) Cost of the petition. ”
2. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
2 WP-10777-2016
petitioner was initially appointed to the post of Upper Division Teacher vide
order dated 18.01.1980 and subsequently retired from the post of Headmaster
on 31.10.2025. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the
respondents have arbitrarily deducted an amount of Rs.68,553/- from the
petitioner's salary on the ground that he had received excess payment during
the period when he was working as Headmaster, without assigning any
justifiable reason. The said deductions are evident from the details of
deductions reflected in the Annual Pay Slips for the period from January
2014 to October 2015. It is further submitted that the Block Education
Officer, Block Jaisinghnagar (respondent No.6), vide letter dated 25.01.2016,
informed the Joint Director, Treasuries, Accounts and Pension Cell, Rewa
Division, Rewa, that the petitioner's Service Book and pay fixation had not
been verified and approved by the competent authority. Accordingly, the
petitioner's Service Book was forwarded to the Joint Director for verification
and approval so that the alleged excess payment made to the petitioner could
be recovered. Learned counsel for the petitioner also submits that the
petitioner had earlier filed a writ petition, registered as W.P. No.2056/2015,
which was allowed vide order dated 11.02.2015. In compliance with the
aforesaid order, the petitioner submitted a representation requesting the
respondents to take appropriate action in terms of the directions issued by
this Court. However, as no response was received, the petitioner filed
another writ petition, registered as W.P. No.8497/2016. Since the issues
relating to retiral dues and grant of higher pay scales had been clubbed
together in the said petition, the petitioner sought permission to withdraw the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
3 WP-10777-2016
same with liberty to file a fresh, properly constituted petition. Accordingly,
the said writ petition was dismissed as withdrawn with the aforesaid liberty
vide order dated 13.05.2016.
3. Learned counsel for petitioner submits that without giving any
show-cause notice or without affording an opportunity of hearing, without
following the principle of natural justice. Learned counsel for petitioner
submits that petitioner stood retired from the post of Head Master which is a
Class III post and recovery after retirement of employee is not permissible. It
is submitted that alleged excess amount has been paid on account of wrong
fixation of petitioner in the year 1998, however, petitioner is not responsible
for wrong fixation. To strengthen his submission, learned counsel for
petitioner placed reliance on the Full Bench decision of this Court in the case
of State of Madhya Pradesh & others Vs. Jagdish Prasad Dubey reported in
(2024) 2 M.P.L.J.198.
4 . Per contra, learned counsel for the State opposed the prayer and
submitted that at the time of pay up gradation of the petitioner he has given
an undertakings, whereby he has given a specific undertaking dated that any
amount is being paid to him in excess for which he is not entitled and he will
return the same. It is further submitted that the said undertaking had been
given by petitioner voluntarily therefore the principle laid down by Hon'ble
Apex Court in the case of State of Punjab Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer),
(2015) 4 SCC 334 is not applicable in case of petitioner.
5. Considered the submissions put forth by learned counsel for the
parties and perused the record.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
4 WP-10777-2016
6. The Full Bench of this Court in the case of Jagdish Prasad Dubey
(supra), has dealt with the similar issue and held as under:
"35. (a) Question No. 1 is answered by holding that recovery can be
effected from the pensionary benefits or from the salary based on the
undertaking or the indemnity bond given by the employee before the grant
of benefit of pay refixation. The question of hardship of a Government
servant has to be taken note of in pursuance to the judgment passed by the
Larger Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Syed Abdul
Qadir (supra). The time period as fixed in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra)
reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 requires to be followed. Converselyan
undertaking given at the stage of payment of retiral dues with reference to
the refixation of pay or increments done decades ago cannot be enforced.
(b) Question No. 2 is answered by holding that recovery can be made
towards the excess payment made in terms of Rules 65 and 66 of the Rules
of 1976 provided that the entire procedures as contemplated in Chapter
VIII of the Rules of 1976 are followed by the employer. However, no
recovery can be made in pursuance to Rule 65 of the Rules of 1976
towards revision of pay which has been extended to a Government servant
much earlier. In such cases, recovery can be made in terms of the answer
to Question No.1.
(c) Question No.3 is answered by holding that the undertaking given by
the employee at the time of grant of financial benefits on account of
refixation of pay is a forced undertaking and is therefore not enforceable
in the light of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Limited (supra) unless the
undertaking is given voluntarily."
7. The Apex Court has also dealt with the similar issue in the case of
Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (supra), wherein, the Apex Court held as
under:-
"18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be
that as it may, based on the decisions referred to herein above, we may, as
a ready reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
5 WP-10777-2016
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV service
(or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to retire
within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has been made
for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been required to
discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to work against an inferior
post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion, that
recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.
8. The Supreme Court in the case of Jogeswar Sahoo and others Vs.
District Judge, Cuttack and others reported in 2025 (3) M.P.L.J. (S.C.) 25
has held as under:
“11. In the case at hand, the appellants were working on the post of
Stenographers when the subject illegal payment was made to them. It is
not reflected in the record that such payment was made to the appellants
on account of any fraud or misrepresentation by them. It seems, when the
financial benefit was extended to the appellants by the District Judge,
Cuttack, the same was subsequently not approved by the High Court
which resulted in the subsequent order of recovery. It is also not in dispute
that the payment was made in the year 2017 whereas the recovery was
directed in the year 2023. However, in the meanwhile, the appellants have
retired in the year 2020. It is also an admitted position that the appellants
were not afforded any opportunity of hearing before issuing the order of
recovery. The appellants having superannuated on a ministerial post of
Stenographer were admittedly not holding any gazetted post as such
applying the principle enunciated by this Court in the above quoted
judgment, the recovery is found unsustainable.”
9. The co-ordinate Bench of this Court has already decided the matter
pertaining to the undertaking in the case of Ravindra Kumar Joshi Vs. The
State of Madhya Pradesh and others [Writ Petition No.17831/2019 vide order
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
6 WP-10777-2016
dated 13.05.2024], relevant of which is reproduced below for ready reference
and convenience:
8. …..........It is brought on record by the respondents that at the time of
extending benefit of time scale pay, petitioner has submitted an
undertaking which is placed on record by the learned counsel for
respondents/State and as per the undertaking, the petitioner had
undertaken to repay the amount, if it was found that the same was
extended to him erroneously. In the matter of High Court of Punjab and
Haryana Vs. Jagdev Singh (supra), the Apex Court has held that if any
undertaking is submitted at the time of grant of financialbenefits on
account of refixation of pay, the amount is refundable to the Government
or the same is adjustable in future, and therefore, the action of the
respondent/Department appears to be correct. Full Bench of this Court, in
the matter of State of Madhya Pradesh and others Vs. Jadish Prasad
Dubey and others (supra) has answered the question No.3 by holding that
the undertaking given by the employee at the time of grant of financial
benefits on account of refixation of pay is forced and the same is not
forcible in the light of the Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
of Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. and another Vs. Brojo
Nath Ganguly and another (1986) 3 SCC 136, unless the undertaking is
given voluntarily meaning thereby that if undertaking is given voluntarily,
recovery is permissible and if undertaking is forced, then no recovery is
permissible.
9. In the present matter, respondent/State has not established that
petitioner had given undertaking voluntarily. Therefore, the undertaking
shall be treated as obtained forcefully and therefore, there is no
circumstance available in the case to consider the undertaking, which was
not given voluntarily. On the strength of undertaking, recovery can not be
affected.”
10. Undertaking (R/3) relied by respondents cannot be treated as
voluntarily given undertaking unless the undertaking is given voluntarily
meaning thereby that if undertaking is given voluntarily, recovery is
permissible and if undertaking is forced, then no recovery is permissible. In
the present matter, respondent/State has not established that petitioner had
given undertaking voluntarily. Therefore, the undertaking shall be treated as
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91944
7 WP-10777-2016
obtained forcefully and therefore, there is no circumstance available in the
case to consider the undertaking, which was not given voluntarily. On the
.
strength of undertaking, recovery can not be effected.
11. Petitioner stood retired on 31.10.2015. Recovery pertains to 1998
and it was initiated without giving any show-cause notice to him or an
opportunity of being heard. Furthermore, petitioner employee was a Class III
employee (Head Master). In view of the aforesaid legal position, the
impugned recovery is not permissible. Therefore, while setting aside the
impugned recovery, the respondents are directed to refund the amount of
Rs.68,553/- to petitioner. The respondents shall pay interest @ 6% per
annum on Rs.68,553/- w.e.f. the date of retirement till actual payment. It is
made clear that in case no recovery is made from the retiral dues, petitioner is
not entitled to the aforesaid relief.
12. Let the said exercise, as directed above, be completed within a
period of 90 days from the date of submission of certified copy of this order,
failing which respondents are directed to give interest @ 12% per annum on
the aforesaid amount from the date of entitlement till actual payment is
made.
13. The petition is, accordingly, disposed of.
(ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT)
JUDGE
DV
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
18:19:09