Sakil vs State Of Haryana

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M)
Date of decision : 19.11.2026
110-I
SANJAY
..... APPELLANT
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA
..... RESPONDENT
110-II
CRA-S-1649-SB-2005 (O&M)
SAKIL
..... APPELLANT
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA
..... RESPONDENT
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH
Present : Mr. Atul Dhankhar, Advocate &
Mr. Bijender Dhankhar, Advocate
for the appellant(s).
Mr. Ramender Singh Chauhan, AAG, Haryana .
*
SURYA PARTAP SINGH , J .
1. Both the appeals are against conviction.
2. For the commission of offence punishable under Sections
398/401/379/411 Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 25 of Arms Act, vide
FIR No.61 dated 17.04.2004, Police Station Ganaur, Sonepat, the appellants
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 2
were sent to face trial in the Court of Sessions. The trial was conduced in the
Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge, Sonepat, hereinafter being
referred to as ‘trial Court’. By virtue of judgment impugned in the present
appeal, i.e. judgment dated 12.07.2005, both the appellants were held guilty
and convicted under Sections 398, 401, 411 IPC and Section 25 of the Indian
Arms Act. Thus, by virtue of order on the quantum of sentence of even date,
hereinafter being referred to as ‘impugned order’, following sentences were
awarded to the appellants :-
Offence under
Sections Sentence
398 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for a period of four years
each and to pay a fine of Rs.1000/- each.
401 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for a period of four years
each and to pay a fine of Rs.1000/- each.
411 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for a period of three years
each.
25 of Indian Rigorous imprisonment for a period of six months
Arms Act each.
It was further ordered that in case of default in payment of fine
the appellants would have to undergo further imprisonment for a period of
two months, and that all the sentences would run concurrently.
3. In nut-shell, the facts emerging from record are that the FIR of
this case came into being at the instance of a police officer namely ‘ASI Rajiv
Kumar’. It was reported by the above-named police officer that on
17.04.2004 he was leading a team of police officials, deputed for patrolling
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 3
duty and detection of crime. According to above-named police officer during
the course of above-mentioned duty a reliable source gave him a tip-off that
appellants ‘Sanjay’ and ‘Sakil’ alongwith ‘Narender @ Manu’ (now
deceased) were armed with deadly weapons, and that they were present on
the culvert on the road leading to village ‘Rajlu Garhi’. As per above-named
police officer it was also informed that the above-named persons were
involved in various heinous crimes earlier also, and that they were planning
to commit robbery with the passerby. The above-named police officer further
reported that in response to above-mentioned information he took a decision
to conduct a raid without any delay, and therefore, with the help of
accompanying police officers, firstly the area, where the appellants and their
co-accused were present, was cordoned-off and one independent witness
namely ‘Ishwar’ was joined in the proceedings. As per above-named police
officer ‘Ishwar’ was instructed to approach the spot, where the appellants and
their co-accused were present, and that two police officials namely ‘ASI
Kanwal Singh’ and ‘Head Constable Bhagat Singh’, who were in civil clothes
were asked to accompany ‘Ishwar Singh’. According to above-named police
officer when the above-named three persons approached the spot, where the
appellants and their co-accused, armed with various deadly weapons such as
pistol, mini sword and axe, were present. As per above-named police officer
the moment ‘Ishwar Singh’, ‘Kanwal Singh’ and ‘Bhagat Singh’ reached the
culvert, the appellants and their co-accused stopped them by displaying their
respective weapons and asked them to handover their valuables. The above-
named police officer further reported that at this juncture a raid was conduced
and all the above-named three assailants were apprehended alongwith their
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 4
respective weapons.
4. It was a case of the prosecution that in view of above-mentioned
report, formal FIR of this case was lodged and the investigation taken up. It
was further alleged by the prosecution that, during the course of
investigation, the Investigating Officer inspected the spot, prepared rough
site-plan of the place of occurrence, recorded the statement of witnesses
under Section 161 CrPC, and completed usual formalities of investigation.
Thereafter, the final report under Section 173 CrPC was filed.
5. Heard.
6. It has been contended by learned counsel for the appellants that
in the present case the learned trial Court failed to properly appreciate that the
evidence adduced by the prosecution was not only grossly inadequate, but
also self-contradictory, and that the quality of above-mentioned evidence was
not good enough to draw an inference in favour of the prosecution. According
to learned counsel for the appellants an error of judgment was committed by
the learned trial Court when it ignored the principle of law that it was the
duty of the prosecution to prove its case beyond the shadow of reasonable
doubt and that the above-mentioned duty was not performed by the
prosecution. The learned counsel for the appellants has also contended that
the entire prosecution case was based upon the testimonies of official
witnesses only, and that the sole eye-witness of the occurrence, i.e. ‘Ishwar’
was not examined by the prosecution. As per learned counsel for the
appellants the above-mentioned lapse on the part of prosecuting agency in
itself was serious and grave enough to discredit the prosecution case.
7. It has also been contended by learned counsel for the appellants
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 5
that the learned trial Court also failed to appreciate that the entire prosecution
case was founded upon the plea that there was a secret information to the
police officer, and that it was told by the informer that appellants and their
co-accused were already involved in various criminal activities in the past
also. With regard to above, the learned counsel for the appellants has
contended that any such event with regard to involvement of appellants in
any other case was not proved during the course of trial. As per learned
counsel for the appellants even the custody certificates placed on record in
appeals, would show that either before or after the filing of present FIR, the
appellants were not prosecuted in any other case. In view of above, the
learned counsel for the appellants has contended that an imaginary story was
believed by the learned trial Court and therefore, the impugned judgment is
not sustainable and needs indulgence and interference of appellate
jurisdiction of this Court.
8. The learned counsel for the respondent/State has controverted
the above-mentioned arguments. While defending the impugned verdict, it
has been contended by learned counsel for the respondent/State that on
proper appreciation of fact as well as law a right conclusion was drawn by the
learned trial Court. According to learned counsel for the respondent/State it is
not the rule of law that in each and every case there must be independent
witness. As per learned counsel for the respondent/State the law no where
prescribes that a charge cannot be proved with the help of official witnesses.
According to learned counsel for the respondent/State in the present case as
many as fourteen witnesses were examined by the prosecution, and that all of
them supported the prosecution case in toto. In view of above, the learned
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 6
counsel for the respondent/State has contended that there is no scope for
indulgence or interference in the verdict of learned trial Court, and that the
present appeals being devoid of merits and deserves dismissal.
9. The record has been perused carefully.
10. To prove its case the prosecution in the present case examined as
many as fourteen prosecution witnesses. Amongst them PW-1 ‘Sushil
Kumar’ was only a formal witness, who proved the scaled site plan of the
place of occurrence.
11. The next witness, namely ‘Parkash Chand’, was examined as
PW-2. The PW-2 had proved that his colour television was stolen on
25.01.2003. As per PW-2 with regard to above-mentioned theft he had filed a
complaint before the police, and that the above-mentioned television was
recovered by the police, which was identified by him in April, 2004.
However, with regard to identity of the persons from whose possession the
above-mentioned television was recovered, the deposition of PW-2 was
silent.
12. On similar lines the next witness examined as PW-3 namely
‘Chander Shekhar’ deposed that his television, too, was stolen from the shop,
and that it was recovered later on. As per PW-3 he was called in the police
station for identification of his stolen television, and that he had identified the
same. However, like PW-2, the PW-3, too did not depose anything about the
identity of the persons, who was responsible for the above-mentioned theft.
13. The next witness, examined as PW-4, namely ‘Ram Parkash’
was an official in the office of District Magistrate Sonepat. The PW-4 proved
the ‘Sanction Order’ (Ex.PF) issued by the District Magistrate for the
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 7
prosecution of appellant ‘Sanjay’, for the commission of offence punishable
under Section 25 of Arms Act.
14. The PW-5 namely ASI Azad Singh was an Arm Expert
(armourer), who deposed that he had tested the above-mentioned firearm
recovered from the possession of appellant ‘Sanjay’. As per PW-5 on testing
he found that the above-mentioned pistol was in working condition. With
regard to above, the test report Ex.PG was proved by PW-5.
15. The PW-6 ‘Head Constable Phool Kumar’ had proved the FIR
No.84 of 2004 as Ex.PJ. This FIR was for the commission of offence
publishable under Sections 457/380 IPC.
16. Another witness examined as PW-7 ‘Constable Yash Kumar’
had proved another FIR, i.e. FIR No.93 of 2004 as Ex. PM. The above-said
FIR, too, was for the commission of offence punishable under Section 457
IPC.
17. The next witness examined by the prosecution, in the present
case, was ‘Smt. Sudesh’. She was examined as PW-9. Like PW-2 and PW-3,
the PW-8, too, deposed that her television was stolen in the intervening night
of 12/13, March, 2004. According to PW-8 the above-mentioned television,
Ex.P5, was recovered later on by the police.
18. The FIR of this case was lodged by ‘ASI Tatbir Singh’. He was
examined as PW-9. The PW-9 in his testimony duly supported the
prosecution case by deposing the fact that on receipt of information-memo
the FIR of this case was recorded by him, as Ex.PO/1
19. The next witness examined by the prosecution was ‘Head
Constable Suresh Chander’. He was examined as PW-10. The PW-10
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 8
testified that on 19.04.2004 in his presence the appellant ‘Sanjay’ was
interrogated by the Investigating Officer of this case, namely ‘ASI Rajiv
Kumar’. As per PW-10 during the course of interrogation the appellant
‘Sanjay’ had suffered disclosure statement Ex.PR, which was reduced into
writing. In his testimony the PW-10 also deposed that co-accused ‘Narender’
and another appellant ‘Sakil’, too, were interrogated by the above-named
Investigating Officer, and that they, too, suffered their respective disclosure
statements as Ex.PS and Ex.PT. However, with regard to incident for which
the appellants were prosecuted, nothing was deposed by PW-10.
20. In the present case another formal witness examined by the
prosecution was PW-12. The PW-12 namely ‘Kanhiya Lal’ had deposed that
his gas cylinder was stolen from his house, and that it was later on recovered.
21. Another witness examined by the prosecution was ‘Rattan Lal’,
examined as PW-14. The PW-14 had deposed that from his shop five gas
cylinders were stolen, and that later on the above-mentioned cylinders were
recovered by the police.
22. With regard to incident dated 17.04.2004 the prosecution had
examined two witnesses, i.e.. PW-11 and PW-13. They were ‘ASI Kanwal
Singh’ and ‘ASI Rajiv Kumar’ respectively. Both the above-named witnesses
being police officers duly supported and corroborated the prosecution story
by reproducing the same facts. However, in their respective cross-
examinations, certain contradictions had surfaced.
23. In the present case, it is also relevant to mention here that in
defence evidence the appellants tried to build up a case that they were picked
up from their home two days prior to the incident, and that with regard to
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 9
above-mentioned the wife of appellant ‘Sanjay’, namely ‘Sudesh’, had filed
an application in the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate on 16.04.2004.
According to defence version on the above-mentioned application, Ex.P1, the
learned Court sought report from the concerned police officer, and that on
16.04.2004, itself, it was reported by the police, vide report Ex.D2, that
neither the appellant ‘Sanjay’ was in custody nor he was wanted in any case.
According to appellants in the backdrop of above-mentioned facts on the very
next day, i.e. 17.04.2004 a fake case, i.e. the instant was planted upon the
appellants, by cooking up a false story.
24. To prove above-mentioned allegations the copy of application
was placed on record by the appellants as Ex.D1 and the report of police
officer as Ex.D2. Both the documents were duly proved in accordance with
law.
25. If the facts and circumstances of the present case, and the
evidence adduced by the prosecution, would have been evaluated in the
backdrop of above-mentioned facts it would have transpired that:-
(a) the entire prosecution case was based upon the testimony
of official witnesses only, who being disciplined officer of
police department were duty bound to support the
prosecution case.
(b) the only independent witness of the occurrence, i.e.
‘Ishwar Singh’ was not examined by the prosecution and
this lapse on the part of the prosecution was fatal because
the above-named witness was withheld without any
justification.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 10
With regard to a situation when the case is totally based
on the testimony of police officers, there may be two
situations, one situation may be when an independent
witness was not present on the spot at the time of
occurrence. In such circumstances the failure of
Investigating Officer to join independent witness may not
be fatal.
However the second situation may be when an
independent witness was joined at the time of
investigation on the spot, but he was not examined. The
above-mentioned lapse of the prosecution, in the present
case, renders the prosecution story doubtful.
The present case comes within the ambit of second
situation.
26. Thus, the principles of law propounded by Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in the case of ‘The State of Himachal Pradesh V/s Kansara
Mayur Criminal Appeal No.1515 of 2015’ and ‘Kamaljit Singh @Pappu V/s
State of Punjab 2020(14) SCC 9’ are applicable to the facts of the present
case.
27. In the present case the most significant and important component
which shatters the credibility of prosecution story was the defence version
duly proved with the assistance of DW1 and the contents of Ex.D1 and
Ex.D2. The above-mentioned evidence would go to show that one day prior
to the incident wife of one of the appellant had approached the Court
informing that her husband was picked up by the police. When report from
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 11
the concerned police station was sought by the Court of learned Magistrate, it
was reported to the Court, on 16.04.2004, that neither the appellant ‘Sanjay’
was in custody of police nor he was wanted in any case. In such a scenario on
the very next day the present FIR was lodged.
28. The above-mentioned chronology of event in themselves would
speak in volumes about the manner in which the FIR was lodged. In my
considered opinion, it fails to convince a prudent mind that a person who was
approaching the Court, through his wife, with the allegation that he was
illegally picked up by the police and was kept in illegal confinement, was
found committing robbery on the very next day in the jurisdiction of same
police station.
29. If the entire scenario discussed in the forgoing paragraph is
considered co-jointly it would lead to a definite conclusion that evidence
adduced by the prosecution for want of corroboration by any independent
evidence was unable to meet the standard prescribed for proving a charge in a
criminal case. Thus, in my considered opinion an error of judgment was
committed by the learned trial Court when it failed to appreciate the above-
mentioned relevant factors, prevailing in the present case and held the
appellants guilty for the commission of offence punishable under Sections
398, 401, 411 IPC and Section 25 of Indian Arms Act.
30. As a sequel to above-mentioned observations, it is hereby held
that present appeals have got merits, and that the impugned judgment of
conviction as well as impugned order on quantum of sentence deserves to be
set aside. Hence, by allowing the present appeals the ‘impugned judgment’
and ‘impugned order’ are hereby set aside and the appellants are acquitted of
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


CRA-S-1489-SB-2005 (O&M) and connected case 12
the charges framed against them. Both the appeals stand allowed accordingly.
31. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
32. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected
case.
(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)
JUDGE
19.11.2026
vipin
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.21 18:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document