Smt. Lalita Tiwari vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
1 WP-8469-2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT
th
ON THE 17 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 8469 of 2018
CNR No.: MPHC010185112018
SMT. LALITA TIWARI
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Amit Kumar Chaturvedi - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Girish Kekre - Government Advocate for the respondent/State.
ORDER
This petition, under Article 226 of Constitution of India, has been filed
seeking the following relief (s):-
"a. By issuance of writ in the nature of 'certiorari' an
dated 13/04/2017 (Annexure/P-1) Recovery statement
(Annexure/P/2, Annexure/P-3) calculating the recovery
to the tune of Rs.3,30,113/ may be quashed in the
interest of justice.
b. By the issuance of writ in the nature of mandamus,
the respondents may be directed to restore the pay
fixation previously made since 01.04.2006 and further
to refund the amount as recovered along with 18%
interest per annum to the petitioner.
c. Grant any other relief as deemed fit and proper in
the circumstances of this case, along with the cost of
this writ petition be also awarded."
2 . It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that initially
the petitioner was appointed on the post of Assistant Grade-III and is
presently working as Assistant Grade-II. The petitioner belongs to Class-III
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
2 WP-8469-2018
service. It is further submitted that no departmental enquiry or criminal case
is pending against the petitioner. The petitioner was granted the benefit of
pay fixation with effect from 01.04.2006 in the pay scale of Rs.8750/- plus
Grade Pay of Rs.2400/-. However, during the audit and verification of the
service book, respondent No.3 raised an objection regarding the correctness
of the pay fixation granted to the petitioner and proposed recovery of the
alleged excess payment.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that without
issuing any show-cause notice or providing any opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner, respondent No.4, merely on the basis of the objection raised by
respondent No.3, passed the impugned order dated 13.04.2017 (Annexure
P/1). It is submitted that the principal amount alleged to have been paid in
excess was calculated at Rs.1,13,472/-, upon which interest at the rate of
12% was imposed, and the total recovery was calculated at Rs.3,30,113/-.
The alleged excess payment has been calculated by refixing the petitioner's
pay from 01.01.2006 to December, 2014. It is further submitted that the
petitioner is a Class-III employee and the alleged excess payment occurred
due to an incorrect fixation of pay by the departmental authorities. The
petitioner neither made any misrepresentation nor committed any fraud for
obtaining the benefit of pay fixation. Therefore, recovery of the alleged
excess amount from the petitioner is impermissible in law. Learned counsel
also submits that the petitioner cannot be held responsible for any mistake
committed by the departmental authorities while fixing his salary. To
strengthen his submissions, learned counsel for the petitioner has placed
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
3 WP-8469-2018
reliance upon the Full Bench decision of this Court in the case of State of
Madhya Pradesh & Others Vs. Jagdish Prasad Dubey, reported in (2024) 2
MPLJ 198.
4 . Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent/State has opposed the petition and submitted that the excess
amount was paid to the petitioner due to erroneous fixation of his salary and,
therefore, the respondents are entitled to recover the amount paid in excess.
It is further submitted that the petitioner had furnished his
consent/undertaking (Annexure R-4), agreeing to refund the excess amount
in case any erroneous payment was subsequently detected. The said
undertaking was furnished voluntarily by the petitioner and, therefore, the
principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Punjab Vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334,
would not be applicable to the present case. On these grounds, learned
counsel for the State submits that the petition deserves to be dismissed.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6. The principal question which arises for consideration in the present
case is whether recovery of the alleged excess payment made on account of
erroneous pay fixation can be effected from the petitioner, who belongs to
Class-III service, particularly when the alleged excess payment was not made
on account of any fraud or misrepresentation on his part.
7. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab Vs. Rafiq
Masih (White Washer) (supra), has considered the question of recovery of
excess payment made to employees on account of erroneous fixation of their
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
4 WP-8469-2018
salary. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that recovery by the employer
would be impermissible in certain situations, including recovery from
employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV services. The relevant portion
of the judgment is reproduced below:-
"18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which
would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where
payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess
of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the decisions
referred to herein above, we may, as a ready reference, summarise
the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and Class-IV
service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due
to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has been
made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required
to work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion,
that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or
harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the
equitable balance of the employer's right to recover."
8. The Full Bench of this Court in the case of State of Madhya
Pradesh & Others Vs. Jagdish Prasad Dubey (supra), has also considered the
issue of recovery of excess payment made on account of erroneous pay
fixation and has held that recovery can be effected on the basis of an
undertaking or indemnity bond given by the employee before grant of the
benefit of pay refixation. However, the question of hardship and the time
period prescribed in the case of Rafiq Masih (supra) are also required to be
considered. The Full Bench has further held that an undertaking obtained at
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
5 WP-8469-2018
the time of grant of financial benefits shall be treated as a forced undertaking
unless it is established that the same was given voluntarily.
9. In the present case, it is not in dispute that the petitioner belongs to
Class-III service and the alleged excess payment has occurred due to pay
fixation carried out by the departmental authorities. There is no allegation
that the petitioner furnished any incorrect information or committed fraud or
misrepresentation for obtaining the benefit of higher pay. The mistake, if
any, was committed by the authorities while fixing the petitioner's salary. In
such circumstances, the petitioner cannot be held responsible for the alleged
erroneous fixation of pay, particularly when the petitioner had no role in
determining or fixing his salary.
10. So far as the contention of learned counsel for the State regarding
the undertaking furnished by the petitioner (Annexure R-4) is concerned, the
Full Bench of this Court in Jagdish Prasad Dubey (supra) has specifically
held that an undertaking obtained at the time of grant of financial benefits on
account of pay refixation cannot automatically be treated as voluntary. The
respondents are required to establish that such undertaking was furnished
voluntarily by the employee. In the present case, merely because the
petitioner furnished an undertaking agreeing to refund the excess amount, the
same would not, by itself, establish that the undertaking was voluntary and
binding upon the petitioner. The respondents are required to establish the
voluntary nature of such undertaking in accordance with the principles laid
down by the Full Bench.
11. Further, the alleged excess payment relates to the period
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
6 WP-8469-2018
commencing from 01.01.2006, whereas the recovery has been initiated in the
year 2017. Thus, the recovery also requires consideration in the light of the
principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (supra),
particularly where the alleged excess payment relates to a period exceeding
five years before issuance of the recovery order. The fact that the
respondents subsequently detected an error in pay fixation cannot, by itself,
justify recovery from an employee belonging to Class-III service,
particularly when there is no allegation of fraud or misrepresentation on his
part.
12. This Court is of the considered view that the petitioner cannot be
made to suffer for an error committed by the departmental authorities in
fixing his pay. The petitioner belongs to Class-III service and the alleged
excess payment was made on account of an erroneous pay fixation by the
department. Further, the recovery has been calculated for a long period
commencing from 2006, without any allegation of fraud or
misrepresentation against the petitioner. In view of the law laid down by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rafiq Masih (supra) and the Full Bench of this
Court in Jagdish Prasad Dubey (supra), the impugned recovery cannot be
sustained.
13. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 13.04.2017 (Annexure P/1)
and the consequential recovery statements (Annexures P/2 and P/3), whereby
recovery of Rs.3,30,113/- has been calculated against the petitioner, are
hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to refund the amount, if
already recovered from the petitioner, within a period of three months from
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91392
7 WP-8469-2018
the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. The respondents shall also
restore the petitioner's pay fixation in accordance with the position prevailing
prior to the impugned order, subject to the applicable rules.
14. The petition is accordingly allowed. In the facts and circumstances
of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.
(ANAND SINGH BAHRAWAT)
JUDGE
DV
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: DINESH VERMA
Signing time: 19-11-2026
10:18:14