MAHADEV vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA


KALABURAGI BENCH


TH
DATED THIS THE 15 DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.200308 OF 2025

(374(Cr.PC)/415(BNSS))

BETWEEN:

1. MAHADEV S/O BHIMARAYA HARINDRAL
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC:AGRICULTURE,
R/O TAVARAKHED, TQ: SINDAGI
DIST:VIJAYAPURA-586 202.

2. SAYABANNA @ SAHEBAGOUDA
S/O BHIMARAYA HARINDRAL,
AGE: 42 YEARS,
OCC:AGRICULTURE,
R/O TAVARAKHED, TQ: SINDAGI,
DIST:VIJAYAPURA-586 202.

…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI YELI PRAKASH B., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
THROUGH SINDAGI POLICE STATION,
R/BY ADDL STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT BUILDING, KALABURAGI.

…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI ANIL KUMAR, ADDL. SPP)







Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


THIS CRL.A. IS FILED U/S.374 (2) OF CR.P.C (OLD)
U/SEC 415(2) OF BNSS, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE
RELEVANT RECORDS AND ALLOW THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL BY
SETTING ASIDE THE JUDGEMENT AND ORDER OF CONVICTION
AND SENTENCE INCLUDING FINE AMOUNT DATED 19.09.2025
AND 24.09.2025 RECORDED BY THE LEARNED II ADDL
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPL JUDGE VIJAYAPURA
IN S.C NO.92/2018 FOR THE OFFENCE U/SEC 451, 323, 324,
302, 354, 504, 506 R/W 34 OF IPC AND CONSEQUENTLY
ACQUIT THE APPELLANTS IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND
EQUITY.

THIS APPEAL COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO

ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)
This appeal has been preferred by the
appellants/accused challenging the legality and
correctness of the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 19.09.2025 and 24.09.2025 passed in
Sessions Case No.92/2018 by the Court of learned II
Additional District and Sessions Judge and Special Judge,
Vijayapura (‘ Sessions Court ’ for short).

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


2. We have heard learned counsel Sri. Yeli Prakash
B., for the appellants/accused and learned Addl. SPP Sri.
Anilkumar Navadgi for the respondent-State.
3. Brief facts leading rise to filing of this appeal
are as follows:
3.1. One Nagamma lodged a complaint before the
Almel Police Station on 23.06.2017 contending that, about
4 years ago, she got married to Malakanna, they were
blessed with a daughter by name Boramma, aged about 1
year. Her matrimonial house is situated at New-
Tavarakhed Village. She, her husband and her in-laws
were residing in their house. The house of one Bhimaraya,
who is the brother of her father-in-law is situated beside
her matrimonial house. The said Bhimaraya was having
three sons viz., Mahadev, Sayabanna and Lakkappa. They
own a garden land at Tarapur Road; abutting their land,
the garden land of Bhimaraya is situated. About 15 to 20
days ago, at about 12:00 p.m., when the complainant was

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


in their garden land, at that time, Mahadev was fetching
water to the sugarcane crop grown in his land and at that
time, he called her near and asked her to hold pipe, and
when the complainant went there, he caught hold her and
started dragging her into sugarcane groove. Immediately,
she started raising hue and cry, then the said Mahadev left
the place and the said incident was informed to her
husband, and in turn, her husband informed the said fact
to her in-laws in her house. Thereafter, her husband,
father-in-law and brother-in-law went to Shankreppa
Shivagond of New-Tavarkhed, Gurupad Biradar, Mallappa
Bogundi of Old-Tavarkhed and informed them that
injustice is caused, for which they convened a meeting and
settled the matter. The accused persons were expressing
in the village that Lakkappa and his wife had convened an
unnecessary meeting. As such, they were angry upon
them and kept quite being frightened. It is alleged that,
on 23.06.2017 at about 10:00 a.m., accused
No.1/Mahadev came to her house, stood in frontyard,

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


when her brother-in-law Sharanabasavaraj was in their
residence, asked him as to why they have removed
electrical TC jump, for which he replied that they have not
removed the TC jump and he has not gone to the land
itself and threatened him to see (take revenge). On the
same day, at about 06:00 p.m., when her father-in-
law/Sangappa, her husband/Malakappa, her brother-in-
law/Sharanabasavaraj were sitting in the frontyard
chatting and her mother-in-law was nurturing her
daughter Boramma in the frontyard of their house, and the
complainant and her sister-in-law/Akkamahadevi were
cooking in the kitchen, at that time, accused No.1 came
holding spade and koita /chopper and accused
No.2/Sayabanna came holding axe in their respective
hands to the frontyard of their house, wherein accused
No.2 caught hold of the shirt of her brother-in-
law/Sharanabasavaraj and dragged him outside their
house and assaulted him with the axe on his face, for
which her brother-in-law fell down on the ground, then her

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


father-in-law went to rescue him, at that time, accused
No.1/Mahadev assaulted him with the spade on his right
leg, for which he fell down, then accused No.2/Sayabanna
assaulted him with axe on his head for 2 to 3 times; at
that time, her husband/Malakanna was standing being
frightened, accused No.2/Sayabanna assaulted him with
axe on his chest and head; as such, her husband fell
down; then accused No.1 assaulted her husband with
koita/chopper on his head, left side of his shoulder and
neck; and accused No.2 caught hold of her brother-in-
law/Sharanabasavaraj, dragged down to the ground and
assaulted him with the axe on his chest, forehead and
face; accused No.1 assaulted him with koita/chopper on
the backside of his head and on right hand wrist. When
the complainant, her sister-in-law/Akkamahadevi and her
mother-in-law tried to pacify the quarrel, accused No.1
assaulted Akkamahadevi with the handle of spade on her
left hand wrist, accused No.1 threw the spade and
koita/chopper on the spot and accused No.2 took the axe

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


with him and both the accused persons went away from
the spot on the motorcycle by extending threat to them.
The complainant saw her brother-in-law/Sharanabasavaraj
was lying near cattle shed on sustaining heavy injuries to
his nose, chest, who had succumbed to the injuries, and
her husband was struggling on receiving severe injuries on
his face, head, chest and the blood was oozing from the
said injuries; in front of the house, her father-in-
law/Sangappa had fallen in the pool of blood, on having
sustained injuries on both sides of his head, neck, below
the knee on his right leg and blood was coming. On
hearing the said news, one of their relatives Shankarappa
Ningappa Shivagond came and took her husband in a trax
vehicle towards Almel, on the way, her husband
succumbed to the injuries. Hence, his dead body was
brought to the house. Thereafter, her co-sister informed
the same to her parental people; when they came, the
complainant gave information about the incident to them.
Later on, Mahadev’s younger brother Lakkappa, their

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


maternal uncle Hanamanth Mallari Yadagi of Hikkanguddi
were also involved in committing the murder.
3.2. Later on, the complainant lodged the complaint
against the accused persons after discussing with the
family members and requested to take necessary action
against the accused persons. On 23.06.2017, the
complainant lodged the complaint against the accused
persons in Almel Police Station. The PSI of Almel Police
Station received the complaint from the complainant at
New-Tavarkhed Village and forwarded it to the Police
Station through a Police personnel. He handed over the
said complaint to the SHO of Almel Police Station, who
registered the complaint at Almel Police Station in Crime
No.136/2017 for the offences punishable under Sections
109, 504, 324, 34, 451, 302 and 354 of IPC and forwarded
the original complaint and FIR to the jurisdictional
Magistrate through Police Constable.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


3.3. The investigation was conducted on finding
sufficient material against the accused persons, the
Investigating Officer has filed a charge sheet against the
accused persons for the offences punishable under
Sections 451, 323, 324, 302, 354, 504 and 506 read with
Section 34 of IPC.
3.4. On complying Section 207 of Cr.PC, the learned
Addl. Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Sindagi, has committed
the case to the Sessions Court under Section 209 of Cr.PC
as the offences alleged against the accused persons are
for the offences referred above, which are exclusively
triable by the Court of Sessions, by its order dated
04.06.2018.
3.5. On committal, the case has been registered as
SC No.92/2018. The accused persons were secured and
they were in judicial custody. The Sessions Court has
framed the charges for the aforesaid offences on

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


02.09.2022. The accused persons did not plead guilty and
they claimed to be tried.
3.6. The prosecution, to prove its case, examined
twenty-five witnesses as PW1 to PW25 and marked fifty-
eight documents as Exs.P1 to P58 and twenty-two
material objects as MO1 to MO22.
3.7. After the closure of prosecution evidence, the
accused persons were examined as provided under Section
313 of Cr.PC on 23.07.2025. The accused persons have
denied all the incriminating substances crept in the
evidence.
3.8. The Sessions Court, after hearing the learned
counsel for the parties, framed the following points for
consideration:
“1. Whether the Prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubts that, about 15-20 days prior
23.06.2017, when the Complainant was in her
garden land; when the Accused No 1 was fetching
water to the sugarcane crop in his land, the
Accused No 1 called her to hold waterpipe, when

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


she went to hold the said pipe, the Accused No 1
caught hold her hands and tried to drag her in the
Sugarcan groove; when she raised hue and cry, the
Accused No 1 left her; and thereby committed the
offence punishable U/Secs 354 of IPC?
2. Whether the Prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubts that, on 23.06.2017, at
10:00a.m., the Accused No 1 on tresspassing into
the house of the Complainant, started abusing her
brother-in-law/Sharanabasavaraj in filthy language
questioning him, as to why they have removed the
TC Jump; extending life threat contending to see
(take revenge), thereby the Accused No 1 has
committed the offences punishable U/Sec 451, 504
and 506 of IPC?
3. Whether the Prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubts that, due to the incident taken
place about 15-20 days prior to 23.06.2017, the
parents-in-law of the Complainant informed
Shankareppa Shivgond/CW12, Gurupad
Biradar/CW13, Mallappa Bogundi/CW14, and told
that injustice is caused to them; then they
conveyened Panchayat, wherein Accused No 2 came
and sought appology; and the Accused Nos 1 & 2
on presuming that Sangappa and his sons have
removed the TC Jump; on nurtured vengeance

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


against them, forming motive for commission of the
incident dated 23.06.2017?
4. Whether the Prosecution proves beyond all
reasonable doubts that, on 23.06.2017, the
Accused persons on tresspassing the house of the
Complainant, invengence of the two incidents
caused assault upon Sangappa and both of his sons
viz., Malakappa and Sharanabasavaraj, with the aid
of Spade/MO2, Koita/Chopper/MO1 and Axe/MO9
and caused their death; and when the Complainant,
Shankaramma/CW10 and Akkamahadevi/CW11
went to rescue, the Accused No 2 caused hurt to
them on extending life threat to them to stay away
from the incident; and thereby the Accused persons
have committed the offences punishable U/Secs
451, 323, 324, 302, 506 R/W Sec 34 of IPC?
5. What Order?”

3.9. The Sessions Court, after appreciating the
entire evidence on record, and answered point Nos.1 to 4
in the affirmative and point No.5 as per the final order.
The Sessions Court passed the judgment of conviction and
order of sentence holding that, (i) accused No.1, shall
undergo imprisonment for life, means remainder of his

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


natural life; and shall pay fine of Rs.10,00,000/- for the
offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC, in default to
pay the fine, the same shall be got recovered as Land
Revenue, with the intervention of the Deputy
Commissioner, Vijayapura; accused No.1 shall further
undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 1 year and
shall pay fine of Rs.25,000/-, in default to pay the fine, he
shall further undergo simple imprisonment for a period of
3 months for the offence punishable under Section 354 of
IPC; accused No.1 shall further undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of 2 years and to pay fine of
Rs.30,000/-, in default to pay the fine, he shall further
undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 3 months for
the offence punishable under Section 451 of IPC; accused
No.1 shall undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 6
months and to pay fine of Rs.10,000/-, in default to pay
the fine, he shall further undergo simple imprisonment for
a period of 1 month for the offence punishable under
Section 504 of IPC; accused No.1 shall undergo simple

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


imprisonment for a period of 2 years and to pay fine of
Rs.30,000/-, in default to pay the fine, he shall further
undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 3 months for
the offence punishable under Section 506 of IPC;
(ii) accused No.2 shall undergo imprisonment for life,
means remainder of his natural life and he shall pay fine of
Rs.10,00,000/- for the offence punishable under Section
302 of IPC, in default to pay the fine, the same shall be
recovered as Land Revenue, with the intervention of the
Deputy Commissioner, Vijayapura; accused No.2 shall
undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 2 years and
to pay fine of Rs.30,000/-, in default to pay the fine, he
shall further undergo simple imprisonment for a period of
3 months for the offence punishable under Section 451 of
IPC; accused No.2 shall undergo simple imprisonment for
a period of 6 months and to pay fine of Rs.10,000/-, in
default to pay the fine, he shall further undergo simple
imprisonment for a period of 1 month for the offence
punishable under Section 323 of IPC; accused No.2 shall

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


undergo simple imprisonment for a period of 2 years and
to pay fine of Rs.30,000/-, in default to pay the fine, he
shall further undergo simple imprisonment for a period of
3 months for the offence punishable under Section 324 of
IPC.
4. The appellants/accused persons, aggrieved by
the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence, filed this criminal appeal under Section 415(2)
of BNSS, 2023.
5. Heard the arguments of learned counsel for the
appellants and learned Addl. SPP for the respondent-State.
6. Learned counsel for the appellants submits that,
the impugned judgment of conviction and the order of
sentence and fine passed by the Sessions Court are in
contrary to the facts, law and material on record. He
submits that, while passing the impugned judgment, the
Sessions Court has slipped into an error, resulting in
miscarriage of justice to the case of the appellants. He

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


submits that, the complainant/PW1, PW2 and PW4 are the
partisan witnesses and they are interested witnesses. The
prosecution has not placed any independent witnesses,
though available. He further submits that, the three
witnesses have specifically contended that several other
persons who have witnessed the alleged incident, but the
prosecution has not led the evidence of any independent
witnesses. Under such circumstances, the evidence of
PW1, PW2 and PW4 cannot be believed. He submits that,
in the entire charge sheet, except PW1, PW2 and PW4, no
other independent eye witnesses were cited, in spite of the
alleged incident which took place in the vicinity surrounded
by many houses. He further submits that, the Police
Officers were on the spot at about 07:00 p.m., and as per
the evidence recorded in this case, till 10:30 p.m., no
complaint was prepared and only after the Kalahalli
Villagers i.e., the relatives of PW2 came to the spot after
09:00 p.m., with a due deliberation and discussion, the
complainant came to be prepared at 10:30 p.m. and then

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


it was sent to Almel Police Station and at about 11:30
p.m., the FIR was registered. But most surprisingly, FIR
was submitted to JMFC, Sindagi at about 08:30 a.m., on
24.06.2017 which establishes that there is an inordinate
delay of more than 14 hours in submitting FIR to the
Court. Learned counsel for the appellants admits that, the
deceased persons were not cordial with the native villagers
and surrounding villagers and the people were fed up with
the behaviours of the deceased persons. He submits that,
certain incidents are admitted by PW1 in her cross-
examination. All these aspects were not considered by the
Sessions Court, which goes to the root of the case. He
further submits that, PW3, PW13 and PW14 turned hostile
to the prosecution’s case. He submits that, the post
mortem examination was conducted by a private hospital
Doctor, in spite of availability of the Government Medical
Officers and forensic experts at Vijayapura. He submits
that, alleged incident three murders have taken place, but
bloodstained clothes of neither the accused persons nor

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


the PW3 were seized by the Police. PW23/the
Investigating Officer admitted in his cross-examination
that, he has not seized the clothes worn by the accused
persons during the course of investigation. He submits
that, the complaint was lodged against four persons and
subsequently, two persons were dropped and only the
appellants were charge sheeted. This fact leads to suggest
suspicion in the case of the prosecution. He submits that,
there is no clear cut corroboration in the versions of
prosecution witnesses, more specifically the
complainant/PW1, PW2 and PW4. Thus, there are major
contradictions and omissions, which would create suspicion
in their versions, so as to believe their versions. He
submits that, the Sessions Court, while imposing the
sentence on the appellants, has exceeded its jurisdiction
and imposed the sentence till the remainder of their
natural life, though the Sessions Court not having such a
power to inflict the sentence of imprisonment till the

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


remainder of their natural lives. Hence, on these grounds,
he prays to allow the criminal appeals.
7. Per contra, learned Additional SPP has
supported the impugned judgment of conviction and order
of sentence passed by the Sessions Court. He submits
that, the prosecution has proved beyond all reasonable
doubts that, (i) at about 15 to 20 days back prior to
23.06.2017, when the complainant was in her garden
land, when accused No.1 was fetching water to the
sugarcane crop in his land, accused No.1 called her to hold
water pipe; when she went to hold the said pipe, accused
No.1 caught hold her hands and tried to drag her in the
sugarcane groove; when she raised the hue and cry,
accused No.1 left her, and thereby committed an offence
punishable under Section 354 of IPC; (ii) accused No.1
trespassed into the house of the complainant on the same
day at 10:00 a.m., on 23.06.2017 and started abusing her
brother-in-law Sharanabasavaraj in filthy language
questioning him as to why they have removed the TC

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


jump, extending life threat contending to see (take
revenge), thereby accused No.1 has committed the
offences punishable under Sections 451, 504 and 506 of
IPC; (iii) on 23.06.2017, the parents-in-law of the
complainant informed Shankareppa Shivgond/CW12,
Gurupad Biradar/CW13 and Mallappa Bogundi/CW14, and
informed that injustice is caused to them and then, they
have convened the panchayat , wherein accused No.2
came and sought apology and accused Nos.1 and 2 on
presuming that Sangappa and his sons have reported the
TC jump; on nurtured vengeance against them, forming
motive for commission of the incident on 23.06.2017; (iv)
the accused persons, on trespassing the house of the
complainant, in vengeance of the two incidents caused,
assaulted upon Sangappa and both of his sons Malakappa
and Sharanabasavaraj, with the aid of spade/MO2,
koita/chopper/MO1 and axe/MO9 and caused their death,
and when the complainant, Shankaramma/CW10 and
Akkamahadevi/CW11 went to rescue, accused No.2 caused

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


hurt to them on extending life threat to them to stay away
from the incident and thereby, the accused persons have
committed the offences punishable under Sections 451,
323, 323, 324, 302 and 506 read with Section 34 of IPC.
He submits that, the prosecution has unequivocally proved
that, accused Nos.1 and 2 have trespassed into the house
of the complainant armed with deadly weapons. He further
submits that, accused No.2 has commenced the quarrel by
dragging Sharanabasavaraj, who was sitting along with his
father Sangappa, his brother Malakappa and his mother
Shankramma/PW4 in the frontyard of his house, dragged
him and brought him outside, wherein accused No.2
assaulted Sharanabasavaraj with the axe on his face. He
further submits that, when Sangappa went to rescue his
son Sharanabasavaraj, accused No.1 assaulted him with
spade on his left leg and caused injury, and Sangappa fell
on the ground and accused No.2 assaulted with the axe on
his head and face for about 2 to 3 times. He further
submits that, the prosecution has examined the Doctor as

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


PW21, who deposed that the injuries would have been
caused with the axe, like axe i.e., MO9. Learned Addl. SPP
submits that, accused No.2 assaulted Malakappa with the
axe on his chest and head, when he fell down, accused
No.1 assaulted him with koita/chopper i.e., MO1 on his
head and left side of his shoulder and neck. The said
injuries correspond with the external injury Nos.1 to 4
shown in the post-mortem report of Malakappa, wherein it
is opined by PW21 that injuries would have been caused
with the axe and koita/chopper i.e., MO9 and MO1.
Accused No.2 assaulted Sharanabasavaraj with the axe on
his chest, forehead and fact, and accused No.1 assaulted
with koita/chopper i.e., MO1 on the back side of head and
right hand wrist. The said injuries correspond with the
external injury Nos.1 to 10 shown in the post-mortem
report, wherein PW21 opined that, the said injuries would
have been caused with the axe and koita/chopper i.e.,
MO9 and MO1. Accused Nos.1 and 2 came to the house of
the complainant armed with deadly weapons and the

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


prosecution has established that the accused/appellants
had premeditation and intention to cause injuries which
are likely to cause the deaths. Thus, the prosecution has
proved the case beyond reasonable doubts. Hence, the
Sessions Court has rightly passed the impugned judgment
and order of sentence. Hence, on these grounds, learned
Addl. SPP prays to dismiss the appeal.
8. Perused the records and considered the
submissions of the learned counsel for the parties.
9. The point that would arise for our consideration
is as follows:
Whether the appellants prove that the
judgment of conviction and order of sentence is
perverse, arbitrary and without appreciating the
evidence placed on record?
10. The prosecution, to prove its case, examined 25
witnesses. The detailed discussion of the oral evidence
adduced by the prosecution is follows:

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


i. PW1 is one of Nagamma. She deposed that CW10 is
her mother-in-law; CW11 is her sister-in-law/wife of
Sharana Baswawaraja; CW15/Mahaningappa Pujari is
the father of CW15; Her husband’s name is Malkanna
and she married Malkanna about 9 years ago; they
have a daughter by name Boramma; her husband’s
house situate at Hosa Tavarakheda, and herself, her
husband, brother-in-law and his wife, mother-in-law
and father-in-law lived in her husband's house.
Bhimaraya’s house, who is the brother of PW1’s
father-in-law, situated beside her husband’s house
and he has 3 children, namely Lakkappa, Mahadeva
and Saibanna. Said Mahadeva and Saibanna are the
first and second accused, who are present before the
Court.
ii. She has deposed that about 5 years ago, she went to
Tarapur road near their garden to fetch a firewood.
At that time, Mahadeva was watering his sugarcane
garden; then Mahadeva called her and said that the

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


watering the garden is taking long and asked her to
hold the pipe, pursuant to which she went to hold the
pipe. Then, Mahadeva held her hand and wrestled
with her and when he did not let go of her, she
started shouting, then Mahadeva let go her and then,
the time was 12 noon.
iii. PW1 called her husband-Malakappa through phone

and informed him about the incident and he came to
the spot. Meanwhile, Mahadeva had gone home in
his vehicle. When PW1 and her husband came home,
PW1 narrated the whole incident to her mother-in-
law, father-in-law and brother-in-law. She has
deposed that the accused were angry with them
because they had invited them to their house for
panchayat, due to which, the accused used to scold
them while roaming.
iv. About 20 days after the incident, the accused
Mahadeva came to their house at around 10:00 a.m.

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


and started quarrelling with his son-in-law Sharana
Basawaraj asking him as to why he had cut TC
pump. Then his son-in-law said that he had not gone
to the field and he had not cut the TC. The accused
Mahadeva scolded him and told him that he would
take care of him in the evening and left.
v. On the same day, at around 06:00 p.m. Sangappa

(father-in-law), Malakappa (husband), Sharana
Basawaraj (brother-in-law) and Shankramma
(mother-in-law) along with Boramma (PW1’s
daughter) were sitting in the hall of their house, and
PW1 and AkkaMahadevi (sister-in-law) were cooking.
At that time, the three accused armed with weapons,
entered their house and grabbed the shirt of her
brother-in-law/Sharana Basawaraj’s and dragged him
to the front of the house. Then, her father-in-
law/Sangappa told the accused they are youngsters
and if they have anything to ask, ask him and if they

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


have anybody to hit, hit him and he stood bowing the
head in front of the accused.
vi. The accused Saibanna hit Sangappa on his chest and
face with an axe, on account of which, Sangappa fell
on the ground. Accused No.2/Saibanna hit Sangappa
on the back of his head with a sugarcane and also hit
the left side of the neck. At that time, Malakappa was
standing near the cooking shed. The accused
Saibanna hit Malkappa on the chest and face with an
axe. Accused No.1/Mahadeva hit Malkappa on the
left side of his head and chest with a sugarcane
cutter. Then, Sharana Basawaraj jumped over the
wall of Bullock shed to save his life. Then accused
Saibanna grabbed Sharana Basawaraj and hit him on
the chest and face with an axe. Similarly, Mahadeva
hit Sharana Baswaraj on the face and chest with a
sugarcane cutter.

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


vii. At that time, her father-in-law was lying in the yard
in of the road and Saibanna hit him below the knee
with an axe. Mahadeva also hit Sangappa on the
back of the head with a sugarcane cutter.
viii. At the time of incident, Akkamahadevi and
Shankaramma went to resolve the scuffle between
the accused and Sharana Basawaraj, Malkappa. The
accused/Saibanna hit Akkamahadevi on the left hand
with the handle of axe, as also he hit PW1 on her
waist with the same axe.
ix. While both accused were leaving the place after the
incident, the accused threatened that they would be
back in eight days to kill all his 3 children as well and
left on a motorcycle.
x. The accused/Mahadeva threw the weapons, which he
had brought, in the cattle shed, however
accused/Saibanna took the axe he had brought with
him. It was 06:00 p.m. on that day when the

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


incident took place. Sangappa and Sharanabasawaraj
died on the spot, whereas Malakappa was lying in a
pool of blood and was gasping and suffering from
pain. When Shankrappa, who had arrived at the
spot, took Malkappa to Almel Hospital in cruiser
vehicle. However, Malkappa/her husband died on the
way to the hospital. Later, his body was brought to
their house.
xi. Akkamahadevi called her maternal home and
informed their family members about the incident.
Later, Akkamahadevi’s family members came to their
house and after learning about the incident, Almel
Police came and she narrated the whole incident and,
lodged a complaint against the accused.
xii. Copy of the complaint was confronted to PW1 and
she admits the complaint and the said complaint is
marked as Exhibit P1. She has deposed that it was
written by one Kenchappa Poojari i.e., CW16 on the

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


instruction given by her to Kenchappa to write a
complaint. PW1 submitted the complaint to the police
at her house, when the Police arrived there.
Akkamahadevi and PW1 sustained injuries in the said
incident and they were sent to Sindagi Government
Hospital at 03:00 a.m.
xiii. She has deposed that on the next day, the police

came to the house and she showed the entrance hall
area. The police took photos and made a
panchanama as per Exhibit P2 and the photos are
marked as Exhibits P3 to P7. Later, while drawing the
panchanama, the police took the soil which was
sustained with blood and soil that was not stained
with the blood from the place where her husband
Malkappa fell and from the place where Sangappa
and Sharana Basawaraj died.

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


xiv. During cross-examination, nothing worth has been
elicited from the mouth of this witness to disbelieve
the evidence of PW1.
xv. The prosecution examined Akkamahadevi, who is an
injured witness, as PW2 . Her evidence is on par
with the deposition of PW1. Admittedly, she is an
injured witness and the wound certificate is marked
as Exhibit P40, which clearly discloses that PW2 has
sustained injuries in the incident occurred on the
date of offence.
xvi. The prosecution examined one Shankreppa as
PW3 /CW12, who has deposed that he is a resident
of Hosa Tavarakheda. He has acquaintance with
Nagamma-PW1 (CW1), Shankremma (CW10) and
Akkamahadevi-PW2 (CW11) and he is also
acquainted with the accused who are before the
Court. He has deposed that he also knows
Sharanabasu, Malkappa and Sangappa, who are

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


deceased now, and do not know how many years
ago, all three of them died. The said witness turned
hostile and he has been treated as hostile.
xvii. The prosecution examined on Shankremma as PW4 .
She has deposed that she is the resident of Hosa
Tavarakhed. That, her husband Sangappa and sons-
Sharanabasu and Malakappa were killed. She has
deposed that their land is situated about 2 km from
their village on Tharapur road and she has deposed
about the occurrence of incident and that she had
insisted her husband Sangappa to convene a
panchayat meeting.
xviii. The prosecution examined one Bojappa as PW5 . He
has deposed that deceased Sangappa, Sharanappa
and Malkappa were known to him. On 23.06.2017 at
09:00 p.m., they went to Tavarakheda Village and
that, Sangappa, Sharanappa and Malkappa were
found murdered in the house of the deceased

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Malkappa. The police had also asked him to
accompany Shankaragouda's father/Hanumantraya
Biradar i.e. CW2 to join them, for which they agreed.
On 24.06.2017 at 12:15 midnight, the CPI came and
conducted a panchanama of Sangappa's body from
12:15 to 01:00 am. Sangappa's body was lying on
the Government road in front of his house with his
head facing east. He was wearing a light blue shirt,
white munda banion, and wearing a coloured
underwear and a white dhoti and that all the clothes
were blood stained.
xix. The police drawn a panchanama and it was read over
to him and the said panchanama was marked as
Exhibit P17 and the police took photographs and the
witness identified the photographs, which are marked
as Exhibit P18 i.e. inquest photo.
xx. On the same day, the police also conducted a
panchanama of the deceased Sharanbasu from 01:30

- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


a.m. to 02:30 a.m. in the presence of himself and
CW2. Sharanabasu’s body was lying in the bullock
shed of his house. Akkamahadevi showed the said
dead body, which was lying south-north direction and
there were wounds all over the dead body, and
Sharanabasu was wearing a pant, shirt, banion,
knickers, a silver belt around the waist, silver
bracelet in hand. There was blood on the clothes and
the Police sent the dead body for postmortem
examination and the inquest panchanama is marked
as Exhibit P19 and his signature is marked as Exhibit
P19(a). The police took photographs as per Exhibits
P12 and P13.
xxi. During cross-examination, it is elicited that he does
not know who wrote the panchanamas, but the
witness volunteers that the police wrote the
panchanamas as per Exhibits P17 and P19. It is
denied that he has been a witness to Exhibits P17

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


and 19 panchanamas at the request of
Mahaningappa poojari.
xxii. The prosecution examined one Shivalingappa as
PW6 who has deposed that he knew the deceased
Sangappa Sharanabasu, and Malkappa. On
23.06.2017 at 09:00 p.m., Mahaningappa took him
to Tavarakheda village, wherein the deceased
Sangappa, Sharanabasu and Malkappa were
murdered. CW1 and 11 showed him the dead bodies
and he was informed that they were killed by being
beaten with an axe and sugarcane harvest cutter;
the police in his presence and others conducted an
inquest panchanama on the body of deceased
Malkappa from 12:30 to 01:30 a.m. Malkappa's body
was found lying in the courtyard of the house facing
south. Malkappa was wearing a shirt, banion, pant
and knicker, which were covered in blood.
Nagamma-PW1/CW1 showed the body and the
inquest panchanama of Malkappa is marked as

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Exhibit P20 and the signature of the witness is
marked as Exhibit P20(a). The police took a
photograph as per Exhibit P21 and he has identified
his presence in Exhibit P21.
xxiii. During cross-examination, it is elicited that the he
and Suresh Poojari are the residents of Kallahalli
village. He and CW5 together went to Hasa
Tawarkheda with Mahaningappa Poojari.
Mahaningappa Poojari and himself are having
acquaintance. Mahaningappa Poojari and CW5 are of
the same caste and it is elicited that the police wrote
the panchanama and they cannot name the scribe of
Exhibit P20. It is elicited that neither himself nor
CW5 gave instructions to the police to make them
the panchas.
xxiv. The prosecution examined one Shankaragouda
Biradar as PW7 who has deposed that on
23.06.2017, he came from Kallahalli to Hosa

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Tawarkheda Village at 09:00 p.m. On arrival, he
went to the house of the deceased Sangappa. He
saw the dead body of deceased Sangappa lying on
the road, in front of his house. Sharanabasu’s body
was lying in a Bullock shed and Malkappa's body was
lying on the side of the house. He has deposed that
Akkamahadevi, Shankaramma and Nagamma, i.e.
PW1, PW2 and PW4 were sitting and crying. When he
went and met Akkamahadevi, she narrated that
Sangappa, Sharanabasu and Malkappa were killed by
the accused by using axe and sugarcane cutter. He
also deposed that the police had reached the place of
occurrence at 12:00 a.m. before he had been there
and drawn inquest panchanama on the body of the
deceased Sangappa and the said inquest
panchanama is marked as Exhibit P17 and his
signature is marked as Exhibit P17(b) and he also
deposed that the photograph of deceased Sangappa
was taken and it is marked as Exhibit P18.

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


xxv. Later on, a panchanama was conducted on the body
of Sharanabasu and the said inquest panchanama is
marked as Exhibit P19 and the signature of this
witness is marked as Exhibit P19(b). MO Nos.1 and 2
are marked through this witness i.e. iron axe and
cutter. He also deposed that the Police have
conducted the spot panchanama on 24.06.2017 and
the said panchanama is marked as Exhibit P22 and
his signature is marked as Exhibit P22(a) and Exhibit
P23 and his signature is marked as Exhibit P23(a);
Another panchanama of clothes marked as Exhibit
P24 and signature of this witness is marked as
Exhibit P24(a). During cross-examination it is
suggested that he is giving false evidence. The said
suggestion was denied by this witness.
xxvi. One Suresh Natika was examined as PW8 , who has
deposed that about 5 to 6 years ago at 11 - 12 a.m.
in the morning, he went to the field. Then police and
CW1/PW1-Nagamma, called him to accompany them

- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


to the field of PW1. He went with her and he was
standing at a little distance away; when PW1 told
police something, the police had noted it and drawn
a spot panchanama marked as Exhibit P8 and his
signature is marked as Exhibit P8(a) and the police
have taken the photographs marked as Exhibits P9
and 10 and one YAllappa has signed on Exhibit P8.
His signature is marked as Exhibit P8(b) and this
witness was treated as a hostile.
xxvii. During cross-examination by the Public Prosecutor he
has admitted that there is a water supply office in
Tavarakhed Village and people were working and
they were appointed by the Government and
Nagamma i.e., PW1 had shown the place of
occurrence and the police had written the
panchanama as shown by PW1 and he has signed on
the panchanama.

- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


xxviii. Learned counsel for the appellant has cross-
examined this witness. It is elicited that, he has not
informed the police that he has studied in Marathi
and he could not read and write Kannada.
xxix. One Yallappa was examined as PW9 who is a punch
witness to Exhibit P8. His signature is marked as
Exhibit P8(b). This witness was treated as hostile and
the learned Public Prosecutor has cross examined
him.
xxx. One Shivaji Jadhav was examined as PW10 who is a
pancha, and has deposed that on 28.06.2017, the
Tahsildar Sindgi called him over the phone and asked
him to come to Almel Police station. Accordingly,
himself and CW9 went to Almel Police Station at
around 10:00 a.m. in the morning. By the time, they
reached the Almel Police station, 2 accused were
present in the police station. The witness identified
the accused Nos.1 and 2 present before the court

- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


and the accused present were the same persons who
were present in the Almel Police station on that day
and the police have introduced the accused to him
then. They have produced the axe and motorcycle
used in the crime. Himself, another witness and CPI
and other police personnel along with the accused
left in a Government vehicle and accused told them
to go towards Kadani from Almel and they went in
the sugarcane field and axe with blue warnish handle
was lying on the western side of the sugarcane field
and the said weapons were seized and photographs
were taken and the said seizure panchanama is
marked as Exhibit P25 and his signature is marked
as Exhibit P25(a) and the police has seized the bike
under Exhibit P28 i.e., Honda Shine and his signature
is marked as Exhibit P28(a). CW9 has also signed on
Exhibit P28. Two photographs were marked as
Exhibits P29 and 30 through this witness.

- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


xxxi. During cross-examination, it is elicited that he does
not remember which police officer wrote the
panchanama as per Exhibit P25. Exhibit P25 was
confronted to the said witness. The witness replied
that it is a document of seizure of property. It is
deposed that apart from Exhibit P25, there are no
other documents written at the said place.
xxxii. Prosecution examined Mahalingappa Poojari as
PW11 , who is the father of PW2 i.e., Akkamahadevi.
He has deposed that 4 years before the incident,
Akkamahadevi married Sharanabasu. He has
deposed that in her matrimonial house, his daughter,
her husband, her in-laws, brother-in- law and his
wife were all living together. Four days before the
incident, he went to his daughter's house in Hosa
Tavarkhed Village. They were all sitting at their
house talking and at that time, Nagamma came to
know that Mahadev / accused No.1 had grabbed her
by hand and pulled her. The deceased Sangappa had

- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


narrated the said incident to him and for the said
reason, they had taken the matter to Panchayath in
the village and it was reported that they had reached
a compromise by shaking hands.
xxxiii. He has further deposed that 7 years ago, he was the
resident of Kallahalli. One day around 08:00 p.m. his
daughter/PW2 called and cried and informed that her
husband, brother-in-law and father-in-law were killed
by accused Nos.1 and 2. Immediately, he came to
the spot around 09:00 p.m. with Shivalingappa
Gowda, Shankara Gowda and Bhojappa Gowda.
Some others had come from behind. When he had
been there, the dead bodies of Sharanabasu was
lying in the bullock shed, he had injuries on his
chest, head and near his nose, there was blood
flowing all around his dead body. The dead body of
his brother – Sangappa Gowda was lying on the road
in front of his house, he had injuries on his head, left
leg and he was lying in a pool of blood. Malkappa’s

- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


dead body was lying on a white sheet in front of the
house. He had injuries on his chest, head and leg. He
inquired with his daughter PW2 about the incident.
She has narrated the whole incident.
xxxiv. Nothing worth is elicited from the mouth of this
witness in his cross-examination to disbelieve the
deposition.
xxxv. The prosecution examined one Kenchappa Poojari as
PW12 . He has deposed that CW15 is his uncle and
their house and his uncle’s house are situated
adjacent in Kallahali village. He has deposed that on
23.06.2017 at around 08:00 p.m., he heard a loud
banging sound coming from his uncle’s house. Then
he went to his uncle’s house and asked what
happened. PW2 called and she told that her husband,
her husband’s brother and her father-in-law were
murdered by accused Nos.1 and 2 and he saw 3
bodies lying face down. He has written a complaint

- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


as per the instructions of PW2 and Exhibit P1 is the
complaint and his signature is marked as Exhibit
P1(a).
xxxvi. During cross-examination, he has deposed that
about 20 to 30 people from Kallahalli came to Hosa
Tavarkheda. The police were there, when he arrived
and he does not know when the police arrived at the
place of occurrence.
xxxvii. One Gurupad A. Biradar was examined as PW13 .
The said witness was treated hostile.
xxxviii. The prosecution examined one Mallappa R.Bogundi
as PW14 . This witness turned hostile.
xxxix. One D.L. Pujari was examined as PW15 . He has
deposed that he has worked as a Constable at Almel
Police Station from 2010 to 2018. On 23.06.2017
around 7 p.m. when he was at police station, the PSI
informed him that CW18 and C19, there have been

- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


murders that took place in Hosa Tavarkhed village
and took them to that place. At that spot, the bodies
of Sangappa, Sharanbasu were lying in a pool of
blood. Since Malakappa was injured, Shankaragouda
had taken him to Almel Government Hospital for
treatment. After some time, Malakappa succumbed
to the injuries on his way to the hospital in the
vehicle.
xl. He has deposed that he has put the body in front of
the house of PW1 and handed over the complaint to
the PSI at 10:30 p.m. and asked him to hand it over
to the SHO of Almel Police Station. Accordingly, he
and CW9 went to the police station and handed over
the complaint to SHO i.e., CW24. Then PSI asked to
return to Hosa Tavarkhed Village, hence they
returned to Tavarkhed village. The police has
conducted an examination on Malakappa's body and
they took the photographs marked as Exhibits P12,
13, 18 and 21 and also seized MO Nos.10 to 13 and

- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


he has identified the material objects as MO Nos.0 to
13 as per Exhibit P34 and his signature is marked as
Exhibit P34(a).
xli. During cross-examination, he has deposed that
Exhibit P34 was typed by him and he admits in
Exhibit P34, the date is not entered and it is
suggested that he has given a false affidavit in order
to support the case of the prosecution.
xlii. One S.B. Dindawar was examined as PW16 . He has
deposed that he has worked as a Constable at Almel
Police Station from 2016 to December 2023. He has
deposed that on 23.06.2017 at 07:00 p.m. when he
was in the police station, the PSI informed him that
the murders have taken took place in Hosa
Tavarkhed village and took him along with CW17, 19
and CPC No.404 and went to the place of occurrence.
At the spot, the bodies of Sangappa, Sharanabasu
were found lying in a pool of blood and Malakappa

- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


was injured and he was taken to Almel Government
Hospital for treatment by Shankarppa Shivagonda
and later, he succumbed to the injuries on the way to
the hospital in the vehicle and his body was placed in
front of the house. The PSI conducted a panchanama
on the body of Sharanbasu and seized the MOs that
are marked as MO Nos.14 to 17 and he has prepared
a report as per Exhibit P35 on 24.06.2017 and his
signature is marked as Exhibit P35(a). During cross-
examination, except denial, nothing has been elicited
from the mouth of this witness.
xliii. One Revana Siddappa Nagalagaon was examined as
PW17 . He has deposed that he was working as a
Constable at Almel Police Station from 2012 to 2018.
He has deposed that the CPI conducted a
panchanama on the bodies of Sangappa and
Sharanabasu and he wrote the panchanamas. He
identified his signature on Exhibits P17 and P19. His
signature on Exhibit P17 is marked as Exhibit P17(c)

- 49 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


and his signature on Exhibit P19 is marked as Exhibit
P19(c).
xliv. The prosecution examined one S.M.Benkanahalli as
PW18 , who has deposed that he has worked as an
ASI in the police station. He has registered a case in
Crime No.136 of 2017 and sent to the Court through
CPC No.519 and he has seen the complaint received
by the witness and identified his signature as Exhibit
P1(b).
xlv. The prosecution examined one Ravi J.Solapur as
PW19, who has prepared the spot sketch marked as
Exhibit P39 and his signature is marked as Exhibit
P39(a).
xlvi. One Dr. Manjunath S.A. was examined as PW20 . He
has deposed that from 2016 to 2021, he haas
worked as a Doctor at Taluka General Hospital at
Sindagi. On 24.06.2017, at about 03.05 A.M. a
patient by name Akkamahadevi Sharanabasappa

- 50 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Harindral was brought by Sharanabasappa Shivappa
Vastar with a history of assault on 23.06.2017 at
about 6.00 P.M., whom he treated. He noticed the
following injuries on her: Patterned contusion over
dorsum of left forearm. The nature of injury is simple
and fresh. The same was entered in the medical
register of the hospital. The Doctor identified t h e
wound certificate issued by him. Hence, it wa s
marked as Ex.P. 40 and his signature as Ex.P.40(a).
The doctor has deposed that the injury mentioned in
Ex.P.40 could be caused from any hard and blunt
object. The handle of MO.9 was shown to the witness
and the Doctor has opined that, the injury mentioned
Ex.P.40 could be caused from said handle.
xlvii. He has deposed that on the same day, at about
03.05 AM, a patient by name Nagamma Malakappa
Harindral was brought by Sharanabasappa Shivappa
vastar with a history of assault on 23.06.2017 at
about 6.00 P.M, who also he treated and that he

- 51 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


noticed the following injuries on him: Patterned
contusion over the right lateral side of back in
thoracic region. The nature of injury is simple and
fresh. The same was entered in the medical register
of the hospital. The Doctor identified the wound
certificate issued by him and it is marked as Ex.P.41
and his signature as Ex.P.41(a). The doctor has
stated that the injury mentioned in Ex.P.41 could be
caused from any hard and blunt object. The Handle
of MO.9 was shown to the witness and the Doctor
opined that, the injury mentioned in Ex.P.41 could be
caused from the said handle.
xlviii. On the same day, at about 03.05 A.M., a patient by
name Shankarabai Sanganna Harindral was brought
by Sharanabasappa Shivappa vastar with a history of
assault on 23.06.2017 at about 6.00 P.M., whom he
treated, however, he found no external injuries on
the said patient. The same was entered in the
medical register of the hospital. The Doctor identified

- 52 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


t h e wound certificate issued by him. Hence it is
marked as Ex.P.42 and his signature Ex.P.42(a).
xlix. In Cross-examination, it is elicited that in Exs.P.40
to 42 t h e OPD number of t h e patient is not
mentioned and that the MLC number also is not
mentioned in Exs.P.40 to 42, and admitted that in
the wound certificate, OPD number, MLC number
have to be mentioned and that in the wound
certificates, he has not mentioned from which object
the said injures was caused. It is elicited that the
patients will be attended separately and that in all
wound certificates, he has mentioned 03.05 AM as
examination time, then the witness volunteered that
due to over sight same is mentioned. He has denied
the suggestion that, he has deposed falsely to
overcome the information mentioned in the Exs.P.40
to 42 and that, in order to help the case false
certificates have been created on 04.09.2017 and
issued to the IO. He has also denied the suggestion

- 53 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


that, because of said reason he has not mentioned
the OPD number and MLC number in the wound
certificates.
l. The prosecution has examined one Dr.D.A.Bagali as
PW-21. He has deposed that, from last 15 years, I
am working in Almel Medical College as forensic
expert. He has deposed that on 24.06.2017, he
received a requisition under form Nos.146(i) and
146(ii) from CPI, Sindagi in Crime No.136/2017 for
conducting post-mortem of Sangapa S/o
Hanamantraya Harindral who died with a history of
assault with sharp object and the post-mortem was
conducted at Sindagi Government Hospital Mortuary.
He had conducted the post-mortem of deceased
Sangapa S/o Hanamantraya Harindral from 09.00 AM
to 10.00 AM on 24.06.2017. At the time of post-
mortem, he has found the clothes and articles on the
dead body as under: (i) Light blue color full shirt with
blood stains; (ii) White color local made banian with

- 54 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


blood stains; (iii) White color dhoti with blood stains
at places; (iv) Red and black vertically strips local
made underwear with blood stains at places; (v)
White color waist thread and all the above cloths and
articles were handed over to CPC 519 in unsealed
manner. He has deposed that the dead body that of
a male measuring 5 feet 6 inches in length,
Moderately built, rigor mortis present all over the
body, faint postmortem staining present over back,
Nail beds are pale, Dried blood stains present over
face; with 1) External injuries: Obliquely placed chop
wound over right side occipital region measuring 16
cm X 1½ cm bone deep underneath head hairs, scalp
and skull bone are clean cut, blood clots presents,
vertically placed chop wound over the left side parito
occipital region measuring 12½ cm x 2 cm x cranial
cavity deep underneath head hairs, scalp, skill,
meninges, brain are clean cut, blood clots present,
obliquely placed glancing chop wound over left side

- 55 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


occipital region measuring 10 cm x 2 cm x bone deep
underneath head hairs, scalp, are clean cut blood
clots are present, horizontally placed contused
laceration over left supraorbital region measuring 2½
x ½ cm x bone deep, blood clots present, Contused
abrasion over left maxillary region measuring 4½ cm
x 3 cm, Contused abrasion over left side nose
measuring 3½ x 1 cm, Obliquely placed chop wound
over outer aspect of upper part of left leg measuring
23½ x 5½ x bone deep underneath skin, muscles
and bones are clean cut blood clots present. 2)
Internal examination: On reflection of the scalp blood
extravasated over left side parieto occipital region
diffusely. Skull: Fissured fracture over right side
parito occipital region extending to posterior cranial
fossa, middle cranial fossa, sella turcica, cribriform,
ethemoid, bone blood clots present and left side
parito occipital region skull clean cut blood clots
present. Membrane: clean cut at the site of injury

- 56 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


blood clots present. Brain: clean cut at the left side of
parito occipital region and covered by subdural and
sub-archnoid, hemorrhage diffusely. Remaining all
organs are intact. All the injuries are ante-mortem in
nature and the time since death 12 to 24 hours prior
to PM. The doctor opined that the cause of death was
due to hemorrhage shock as result of injury
sustained.
li. The witness identified the requisition Form
No.146(i), which was marked as Ex.P.43 and his
signature at Ex.P.43(a); he h as identified the
requisition Form No.146(ii), which was marked as
Ex.P.44. The witness identified PM report issued by
him and it was marked as Ex.P.45 and his signature
at Ex.P.45(a).
lii. MO.1 chopper ( PÀ§Äâ PÀrAiÀÄĪÀ PÉÆå¬ÄvÀ) and MO.9 axe
(
PÉÆqÀ°) was shown to the doctor and the Doctor
opined that except injury Nos.4, 5 and 6, the

- 57 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


remaining injuries mentioned in Ex.P.45 could be
caused through MOs.1 and 9 type weapons.

liii. MO.2 ( ) was shown to the doctor and the
doctor opined that except the injury Nos.4, 5 and 6,
the remaining injuries mentioned in Ex.P.45 could be
caused through MO.2 type weapon.
liv. He has deposed that on 24.06.2017, he received a
requisition under form Nos.146(i) and 146(ii) from
PSI Alamel in crime No.136/2017 for conducting the
post-mortem of Malakappa S/o Sangappa Harindral
who died with a history of assault with sharp object
and he had conducted a post mortem at Sindagi
Government Hospital mortuary on deceased
Malakappa S/o Sangappa Harindral from 10.00 AM to
11.00 AM On 24.06.2017. He has deposed that at
the time of post-mortem, he found the clothes and
articles on the dead body as follows: (i) White color
block strips check design full shirt with cut over right

- 58 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


side front portion with blood stains (ii) White color
shadow banian with blood stains; (iii) Blue color pant
with blood stains at places; (iv) Light green color
underwear (v) White metal color chain present over
waist and all the above clothes and articles were
handed over to CPC-1379 in unsealed manner; the
doctor had deposed that the dead body was that of a
male measuring 5 feet 4 inches in length. Moderately
built and nourished, rigor mortis present all over the
body, faint postmortem staining present over back.
Nail beds are pale in color. Dried blood stains present
over head and both upper limps. External injuries.
Chop wound over middle of fronto partial region
measuring 4 cm X 2 cm X cranial cavity deep,
underneath hairs, scalp, bone clean cut, blood clots
presents. Obliquely placed chop wound over the right
side fronto parietal region measuring 8½ cm X 2½
cm X cranial cavity deep, scalp and bone clean cut,
blood clots present. Horizontally placed chop wound

- 59 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


present over left side lower part of neck measuring 4
½ cm X 2 ½ cm X tracheal deep underneath
muscles, arteries, veins are clean cut blood clots are
present. Obliquely placed chop wound present over
right side front of middle of upper part of chest
measuring 13 ½ X 5 ½ cm X thoracic cavity deep
blood clots present. Internal examination: On
reflection of the scalp blood extravasated over fronto
parital region. Skull: Clean cut over middle of fronto
partial region extending to right side anterior cranial
fossa, bloods clots present. Membrance: clean cut
over middle of frontparital region blood clots
present. Brain: clean cut over middle of
frontopartial region blood clots present and covered
by subaorconied, hemorrhage diffusely. Sternum:
Clean cut over upper portion blood clots present.
Pleurae: Clean cut at injury side blood clots present.
Remaining all organs are intact and pale. All the
injuries are antemortem in nature and the time since

- 60 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


death was 12 to 24 hours prior to post mortem. The
doctor has opined as far as cause of death was due to
hemorrhage shock as result of injury sustained. The
doctor identified the requisition form No.146(i)
and it is marked as Ex.P. 46 and his signature at
Ex.P.46(a); the requisition form No.146(ii) and it is
marked as Ex.P. 47; the PM report issued by him is
marked as Ex.P.48 and his signature at Ex.P.48(a).
lv. MO.1 chopper ( PÀ§Äâ PÀrAiÀÄĪÀ PÉÆå¬ÄvÀ) and MO.9 axe
( PÉÆqÀ°) was shown to the doctor and he opined that all
the injuries mentioned in Ex.P. 48 could be caused
through MO.1 and 9 type weapon.
lvi. He has further deposed that on 24.06.2017, he has
received requisition under form Nos.146(i) and
146(ii) from CPI sindagi in Crime No.136 of 2017 for
conducting a post mortem of Sharanabasu S/o
Sangappa Harindral who died with a history of
assault with sharp object and the PM was conducted

- 61 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


at Sindagi Government hospital mortuary. He has
conducted PM of deceased Sharanabasu S/o
Sangappa Harindral from 11.00 AM to 12.00 PM On
24.06.2017 and at the time of PM, he found the
clothes and articles on the dead body as under: Right
ash color T shirt, cut over left side lower portion of
neck with blood stains; White color shandow banian
with blood stains; Blue color pant with blood stains
at places; Red color underwear with front portion of
waist name ESSA; Metal color chain present over
waist; Metal color chain present over right side wrist
joint three in rows, and that all the above clothes and
articles were handed over to CPC-574 in an unsealed
manner; and that the dead body was that of a male
measuring 5 feet 7 inches in length, moderately built
and nourished, rigor mortis present all over the
body, faint postmortem staining present over back;
Nail beds are pale; Dried blood stains present over
head, neck and upper limps; External injuries:

- 62 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Obliquely placed chop wound present over right side
fronto tamporal regions measuring 7 ½ X 1/c X bone
deep margins are clean cut underneath head hairs
and scalp are clean cut blood clots present; Vertically
placed chop wound present over right side parieto
front maxillary region measuring 15 ½ X 2 ½ cm X
cranial cavity and maxillary bone deep underneath
skin, muscles, bones are clean cut blood clots
present; Contused laceration over left side fronto
parital region measuring 3 ½ CM X 2 ½ X muscle
deep blood clots present; Obliquely placed chop
wound over left side parieto occipital region
measuring 4 ½ cm x ½ cm X cranial cavity deep
underneath head hairs, scalp are clean cut blood
clots present; Obliquely placed chop wound present
over left side lower part of coller bone measuring 11
cm X 4 cm X muscle deep underneath skin, and
muscles are clean cut blood clots present; Contused
abrasion over left mastoid region measuring 3 ½ cm

- 63 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


X 2 ½ cm; Obliquely placed incised laceration
laceration over outer aspect of upper part of right
arm measuring 8 cm X 1 ½ X muscle deep blood
clots present; Horizontally placed chop wound
present over back of middle of right forearm
measuring 7 ½ X 2 ½ X bone deep underneath skin,
muscle, tendones are clean cut blood clots present.
Contused laceration over outer aspect of upper part
of left arm measuring 7 ½ cm x ½ cm X skin deep
blood clots present; After reflection of chest skin
blood extravasated over lower part of left coller
bone. Internal examination; On reflection of the
scalp blood extravasated over right side franto
parietal and left parieto occipital region diffusely;
Skull:Fissured fracture over right side franto parietal
region and left side parieto occipittal region clean cut
blood clots present; Membrane: Lacerated at
fracture site and clean cut over left side parieto
occipital region blood clots present; Brain: Covered

- 64 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


by subdural and subarchnoid, hemorrhage
diffusely; All other organs were intact and pale; All
the injuries are antemortem in nature and the time
since death 12 to 24 hours prior to PM; and has
opined regarding cause of death was due to
hemorrhage shock as result of injury sustained; The
doctor identified the requisition form No.146(i),
which is marked as Ex.P. 49 and his signature at
Ex.P. 49(a); requisition form No.146(ii), which is
marked as Ex.P.50; PM report issued by him is
marked as Ex.P.51 and his signature at Ex.P.51(a).
lvii. MO.1 chopper ( PÀ§Äâ PÀrAiÀÄĪÀ PÉÆå¬ÄvÀ and MO.9 axe
MO.2
PÉÆqÀ° ( ¸À¤PÉ ) shown to the doctor and
the Doctor has opined that all the injuries
mentioned in Ex.P. 51 except injury Nos.3, 6, 9, 10
could be caused through MO.1 and 9 type weapon
and the injury Nos.3, 6, 9, 10 could be caused by
MO.2 weapon type.

- 65 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


lviii. In Cross-examination, it is elicited that the
postmortem staining starts to develop after 20 to
30 minutes after the death and at the time,
activity of brain and heart stopped; that the
postmortem staining will complete from 6 to 12
hours. It was denied that same will be completed
within 6 to 8 hours. Faint postmortem staining
means minimal amount of blood stored in the
dependent body. It was denied that, as per his
medical report, the death had occured within 12
hours. He has deposed that it is not possible to
assault on the face of a person if he is in a bow-down
position and in the same manner, assault cannot be
made on the chest. He has deposed that MOs.1, 2, 9
were not sent for my examination and opinion.
lix. He has deposed that injury Nos.1 to 3 as mentioned
in Ex.P. 45 could not be possible at one attempt. He
has deposed that it could be possible in three
different attempts and injury Nos.4 to 6 as

- 66 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


mentioned in Ex.P. 45 could not be possible at one
attempt and that it could be possible in three
different attempts.
lx. He has deposed that injury Nos.1 to 3 as mentioned
in Ex.P. 48 could not be possible at one attempt and
that it could be possible in multiple different
attempts. In Ex.P. 48 postmortem report there are no
defense wounds. Injury Nos.1 and 2 as mentioned in
Ex.P. 51 could not be possible at one attempt. He
has deposed that it could be possible in multiple
different attempts. That injury Nos.3 and 4 as
mentioned in Ex.P.51 could not be possible at one
attempt and it could be possible in multiple different
attempts. Injury Nos.5 and 6 as mentioned in Ex.P.
51 could not be possible at one attempt and it could
be possible in multiple different attempts and both
are different in nature.

- 67 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


lxi. He has deposed that in Vijayapura, there is District
Government Hospital. However, he has denied that,
in the District hospital, there is forensic medicine
department and that without conducting proper PM,
he has issued a false report as per the request of
investigation officer.
lxii. The prosecution examined one Anilkumar H.D., Police
Inspector, State Intelligence, Bengaluru as PW-22 .
He has deposed that he was serving as the PSI of
Almela Police Station from 20.07.2016 to
03.08.2018. He has deposed that on 23.06.2017,
when he was in the Almela Police Station, he has
received an information that murder of Father and
Sons had taken place at New Tavaraked village. He
has deposed that he along with Police personnel went
to the said village, and found that three persons viz.,
Sangappa Hanumantraya Harindral, Sharanbasu
Sangappa Harindral and Malakappa Sangappa
Harindral, were murdered and he had informed the

- 68 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


said fact to his Higher Authorities. He has deposed
that on the same day, in the night at about 10.30pm
C.W.1/P.W.1 lodged a written Complaint before him
at Tavarakhed village. He has deposed that on
receiving the said Complaint, he had sent the said
Complaint to Almela Police Station through
C.W.17/P.W.15.
lxiii. The said Complaint was confronted to the witness
which is already marked as Ex.P.1 and he has
identified his signature, which is marked as Ex.P.1(c).
He has deposed that on 24.06.2017, he has
conducted the Inquest Mahazar upon the dead body
of Malakappa Sangappa Harindral as per the
directions of CPI Sindagi/C.W.26 at New Tavarkhed
village, as per Ex.P.20; and that the said Inquest
Mahazar is conducted in the presence of C.W.4/P.W.6
and C.W.5; got clicked Positive Photograph as per
Ex.P.21; the said Mahazar proceedings were
conducted in-between 00.30 to 01.30am. On

- 69 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


identification signatures of the witness on the
Inquest Mahazar/Ex.P.20 are marked as Ex.P.20(B)
and Ex.P.20(C). He has deposed that thereafter he
had sent the dead body of Malakappa Sangappa
Harindral through C.W.17/P.W.15 to Al-Ameen
Medical College, Vijayapura for conducting
Postmortem, as per Ex.P.46 and Ex.P.47. On
identification signatures of the witness are marked as
Ex.P.46(b) and Ex.P.47(a).
lxiv. He has deposed that on 27.06.2017, he along with
H.C. 1212, PC 519, PC 1386, PC1543, PC-1379
and PC-565 went to Basagi village of Afzalpur Taluka
and apprehended Accused persons viz., Mahadev
Bhimaray Harindral and Saibanna Bhimaray
Harindral; and produced them before CPI Sindagi/
C.W.26. He has deposed that he had filed his report
before CPI Sindagi/C.W.26. On identification the said
report is marked as Ex.P.52, signature of the witness

- 70 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


is marked as Ex.P.52(a). Witness identified Accused
Nos.1 and 2 produced before this Court through V.C.
lxv. During cross-examination, it is elicited that he had
received a Phone call at about 7.00 pm in the
evening, when he was in Almela Police Station and
that thereafter he reached New Tavarakhed village at
about 7.30pm. It is elicited that the Complainant/C.W.1
/P.W.1 did not lodge the Complaint from 7.30 pm to
10.30pm, contending that she will discuss with her
relatives and then will lodge the Complaint. He
pleaded ignorance as to whether relatives of
C.W.11/P.W.2 of Kalhalli village had come at 8.00pm
near the Spot. He has denied that, himself, CPI
Sindagi/C.W.26, relatives who had come from
Kalhalli, Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1 and her other
relatives on having discussed, got prepared the
Complaint as per Ex.P.1; due to the said reason
there was delay in filing the Complaint from 7.30pm
to 10.30pm. He has denied that, the Panchas of the

- 71 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Inquest Mahazar / Ex.P.20 viz., C.W.4/P.W.6 and
C.W.5 are the relatives of C.W.11/P.W.2. He
admitted that, the said Panchas are not the residents
of New Tavarakhed village, but they are the
residents of Kalhalli village. He pleaded ignorance as
to whether C.W.4/P.W.6 and C.W.5 had come to New
Tavarakhed village with one Mahalingappa
Pujar/C.W.15/P.W.11, who is the father of C.W.11/
P.W.2. It is elected that he had enquired
C.W.4/P.W.6 and C.W.5, for which they informed
that they have come from Kalhalli village. He has
dnied that, New Tavarkhed village is located at a
distance of about 25 kms from Kalhalli village.
Witness volunteered that the distance between the
two villages might be about 15 kms. It is elicted that
he had asked the local residents of New Tavarakhed
village to act as a Panchas for conducting Inquest
Mahazar upon the Dead body of Malakappa, however
no one agreed, as such he had taken C.W.4/P.W.6

- 72 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


and C.W.5 as Panchas. He admitted that he had not
reported CPI Sindagi/C.W.26 that localities from New
Tavarakhed village are not willing to act as Panchas
to the Inquest Mahazar. He has denied that, he had
apprehended accused Nos.1 and 2, from their
respective houses, situate at New Tavarakhed
village; and not apprehended them from Baski village
in Afzalpur Taluka. He denied that, he has filed a
false report contending that Accused Nos.1 and 2
were absconding from New Tavarakhed village and
they were traced at Baski village in Afzalpur Taluka.
lxvi. The prosecution examined one Sharanagouda
Nyamannavar, CPI, Shahapur Police Circle, Dist:
Yadagir. as PW-23. He has deposed that he was
serving as CPI at Police Circle Sindagi since
11.07.2016 to 17.12.2017. He has deposed that on
23.06.2017, at about 8.00pm in the night C.W.25/
P.W.22/PSI Almela called him over Phone and
informed that murder of Sangappa Harindral and his

- 73 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


two Sons had taken place at New Tavarakhed village.
He has deposed that on the same day, he had visited
the place of incident and on the place of incident,
Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1 filed a written Complaint
before PSI Alamela/C.W.25/P.W.22; on receiving the
said Complaint PSI Alamela had sent it to Alamela
Police Station through CPC–1379/C.W.17/P.W.15.
C.W.24/P.W.18 had got registered FIR on the basis
of the said Complaint at Almela PS Cr.No.136/2017.
The copy of the said FIR was handed over to him by
C.W.17/P.W.15, at New Tavarkhed village. He has
deposed that he had taken the charge of this case for
further investigation from C.W.24/ P.W.18.
lxvii. He has deposed that on 24.06.2017, he had
conducted the Inquest Mahazar on the dead body of
Sangappa S/o.Hanumantray Harindral, as per
Ex.P.17, got clicked Positive Photograph as per
Ex.P.18; in the presence of two panchas viz.,
C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.3/P.W.5; the said Mahazar

- 74 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


proceeding were conducted in-between 00.15 to
01.15am. On identification, signatures of the witness
on the Inquest Mahazar/ Ex.P.17 are marked as
Ex.P.17(d) and Ex.P.17(e). He has deposed that on
the same day, he had instructed the PSI/ C.W.25/
P.W.22 to conduct Inquest Mahazar on the dead
body of Malakappa Sangappa Harindral and
thereafter, he had conducted the Inquest Mahazar on
the dead body of Sharanabasu S/o. Sangappa
Harindral, as per Ex.P.19, got clicked Positive
Photographs as per Ex.P.12 and 13; in the presence
of two panchas viz., C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.3/P.W.5;
the said Mahazar proceeding were conducted in-
between 01.30 to 02.30am. On identification
signatures of the witness on the Inquest Mahazar/
Ex.P.19 is marked as Ex.P.19(d) and Ex.P.19(e).
Thereafter I have sent the dead body of Sangappa
Harindral through C.W.19 for conducting the
Postmortem to Government Hospital Sindagi; and

- 75 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


the dead body of Sharanabasu Harindral was sent
through C.W.18 for conducting the Postmortem to
Government Hospital Sindagi, by addressing the
letters to Al-Ameen Medical College, Vijayapura, as
per Ex.P.43 and Ex.P.44 in respect of deceased
Sangappa Harindral and Ex.P.49 and Ex.P.50 in
respect of Sharanabasu Harindral. On identification
signatures of the witness are marked as Ex.P.43(b),
Ex.P.44(a), Ex.P.49(b), Ex.P.50(a). He has deposed
that thereafter PSI/C.W.25/P.W.22 has furnished the
Inquest Mahazar as per Ex.P.20 before him. He has
deposed that on the same day, he has sent the
injured persons viz., C.W.1/ P.W.1, C.W.10/P.W.4,
C.W.11/P.W.2 to the Government Hospital, Sindagi
through 108 Ambulance. He has deposed that on the
same day, he has deputed Police Personnel to keep
vigil on the Spot of incident, as it was late night. He
has deposed that on 24.06.2017, he has visited the
injured persons who were taking treatment at

- 76 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Government Hospital Sindagi. He has deposed that
he had contacted the officials of Department of
Forensic and Medical Science, Al-Ameen Medical
College, Vijayapura and informed them to come over
to Government Hospital Sindagi, to conduct the
Postmortem on the dead-bodies of Sangappa
Harindral, Sharanabasu Harindral and Malakappa
Harindral. He has deposed that in the morning, he
had visited the Spot of incident at New Tavarakhed
village, it was at about 11.00am, as per the Spot
shown by C.W.1/P.W.1, he had conducted the Spot
Mahazar as per Ex.P.2, in the presence of two
panchas viz., C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.5; got drawn the
Sketch; got clicked Positive Photographs as per
Ex.P.3 to Ex.P.7; got seized M.O.1 to M.O.8; the said
Mahazar proceedings were conducted in-between
11.30am to 01.00pm. On identification signature of
the witness on the Spot Mahazar/Ex.P.2 is marked as
Ex.P.2(b). On identification Sketch is marked as

- 77 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Ex.P.53, signature of the witness is marked as
Ex.P.53(a). The witness was confronted shown M.O.1
to M.O.8 and questioned him to identify them.
Witness identified M.O.1 to M.O.8 and his signatures
on the slips affixed on the said material objects.
lxviii. He has deposed that after completion of Postmortem
on the dead bodies of Sangappa, Malakappa and
Sharanabasu, he had handed over the said dead
bodies to their relatives. He has deposed that on the
same day, C.W.17/P.W.15 had presented the clothes
of deceased Malakappa, for which he had seized the
said clothes, as per M.O.10/Shirt, M.O.11/Half
banian, M.O.12/Pant, M.O.13/Underwear, by drawing
the Seizure Mahazar as per Ex.P.22, in the presence
of C.W.2/ P.W.7 and C.W.5; the said Mahazar
proceedings were conducted in-between 4.30pm to
05.00pm in the evening. He has deposed that on
identification, signature of the witness on the Seizure
Mahazar/ Ex.P.22 is marked as Ex.P.22(B). He has

- 78 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


deposed that on the same day, C.W.18/ P.W.16 has
presented the clothes of deceased Sharanabasu, for
which he had seized the said clothes, as per
M.O.14/T-Shirt, M.O.15/White Banian, M.O.16/Pant,
M.O.17/Underwear, by drawing the Seizure Mahazar
as per Ex.P.23, in the presence of C.W.2/P.W.7 and
C.W.5; the said Mahazar proceedings were conducted
in-between 5.15pm to 05.45pm in the evening. On
identification signature of the witness on the Seizure
Mahazar/Ex.P.23 is marked as Ex.P.23(B). He has
deposed that on the same day, C.W.19/P.W.17 has
presented the clothes of deceased Sangappa, for
which he had seized the said clothes, as per
M.O.18/Shirt, M.O.19/Banian, M.O.20/Dhotara,
M.O.21/Strips Underwear, by drawing the Seizure
Mahazar as per Ex.P.24, in the presence of
C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.5; the said Mahazar
proceedings were conducted in-between 6.00 pm to
06.30 pm in the evening. On identification signature

- 79 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


of the witness on the Seizure Mahazar/Ex.P.24 is
marked as Ex.P.24(B). He has deposed that he had
sent the P.F. in respect of M.O.10 to M.O.21 to the
Jurisdictional Magistrate. Witness identified M.O.10
to M.O.21, present in the Open Court today; and
identified the signatures on the slips affixed on the
said material objects. He has deposed that on the
same day, he had recorded the Statement of
C.W.1/P.W.1, C.W.10/P.W.4, C.W.11/P.W.2,
C.W.12/P.W.3, as per Ex.P.15. He has deposed that
on the same day, he had issued oral direction to PSI
Almela/ C.W.24/ P.W.22 to find out the whereabouts
of Accused persons; and to present them before him.
He has deposed that on 25.06.2017, the
Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1 has shown the Spot,
contending that Mahadev Harindral has caught hold
her hand and dragged her with an intention to
outrage her modesty; for which he had drawn the
Spot Mahazar as per Ex.P.8; in the presence of two

- 80 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


panchas viz., C.W.6/P.W.9 and C.W.7/P.W.8; got
clicked Positive Photograph as per Ex.P. 9 and
Ex.P.10; the said Mahazar proceedings were
conducted in-between 10.00am to 11.00 am in the
morning. On identification signature of the witness
on the Spot Mahazar/Ex.P.8 is marked as Ex.P.8(C).
He has deposed that on the same day, he had
recorded the Statements of C.W.13/P.W.13 as per
Ex.P.31, C.W.14/P.W.14 as per Ex.P.33,
C.W.15/P.W.11, C.W.16/P.W.12. He has deposed
that on the same day, he had issued a requisition to
the Assistant Executive Engineer, PWD, Sindagi, to
furnish the Sketch pertaining to the Spot of incident.
He has deposed that on the same day, he had
issued a requisition to PDO, Kadani Gram Panchayat
to furnish the house Property Extract of the Spot of
incident and that on the same day, he had issued a
requisition to Deputy Tahashildar, Nadakacheri
Alamel to furnish the RTC Extract of the Spot of

- 81 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


incident. He has deposed that on 27.06.2017, PSI
Almel/C.W.25/P.W.22 has produced Accused Nos.1
and 2 before him in the afternoon at about 3.00 pm
and on enquiry, Accused Nos.1 and 2 have admitted
the guilt, as such he had arrested Accused Nos.1 and
2, on following the arrest procedures; at the request
of Accused Nos.1 and 2, he had recorded their
Voluntary Statements, wherein both the Accused
have stated that they will show the Axe and
Motorcycle, used in the Crime. Witness identified the
said Voluntary Statements. The contents of Voluntary
Statements leading to discovery, of Accused No.1 is
marked as Ex.P.54; and of Accused No.2 is marked
as Ex.P.55. On the same day since it was night I
have kept the Accused Nos.1 and 2 in the Police
Lockup at Alamel Police Station. On 28.06.2017, I
have requested Tahashildar Sindagi to furnish two
panchas to conduct the Mahazar. Accordingly, the
Tahashildar Sindagi had sent C.W.8/P.W.10 and

- 82 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


C.W.9. He has deposed that on securing the said
panchas, he had shown Accused Nos.1 and 2 to the
said panchas; and requested the panchas to
cooperate for conducting the Mahazar of the Spots to
be shown by Accused Nos.1 and 2. He has deposed
that both the panchas have enquired Accused Nos.1
and 2, in his presence; wherein Accused Nos.1 and 2
have contended that they will show the place where
they have thrown the Axe and parked the
Motorcycle, used in this Crime. He has deposed that
thereafter myself, Police Personnel, Panchas and
Accused Nos.1 and 2 went in the Police Jeep bearing
REG. KA-28/G-462 to the place, taken by Accused
Nos.1 and 2 and the said place is situated in the
Sugarcane field of Manohar S/o. Ramachandra
Basame, located on the Kadani-Tarapur Road. He has
deposed that Accused No.2 has shown the Axe which
was kept hidden in the sugarcane crops raised in the
said land; and presented it and the said Axe was

- 83 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


having a wooden handle which was containing blue
colour; the said handle was measuring about 2½
feet. He has deposed that he had seized the said Axe
in the presence of both the panchas, on drawing the
Seizure Mahazar/Ex.P.25, got clicked two Positive
Photographs as per Ex.P.26 and 27; the said
Mahazar proceedings were conducted in between
11.15 am to 12.00 noon. On identification, signature
of the witness is marked as Ex.P.25(b). The witness
was shown Axe/M.O.9 present in the Open Court and
questioned him to identify the Axe. Witness identified
the Axe/M.O.9; and contended that it is bearing his
signature on the slip attached to it. He has deposed
that thereafter Accused Nos.1 and 2 have taken
them to Golasar village of Indi Taluka; they asked us
to stop the vehicle near Ambedkar Circle; they got
down and went in the passage abating Golsar Bus
stop and presented the Motorcycle. The said
Motorcycle bears Reg.No. KA-28/EE-3949; the said

- 84 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Motorcycle pertains to Honda Shine Company.
Witness identified the Motorcycle parked in the Court
Premises, which is already marked as M.O.22. He
has deposed that he had seized the said Motorcycle
by drawing the Seizure Mahazar as per Ex.P.28; got
clicked Positive Photographs as per Ex.P.29 and
Ex.P.30 in the presence of C.W.8/P.W.10 and C.W.9;
the said Mahazar proceedings were conducted in-
between 1.00 pm to 2.00 pm in the afternoon. On
identification signature of the witness on the Seizure
Mahazar is marked as Ex.P.28(B).
lxix. He has deposed that on the same day, on returning
to Almel Police Station, on having Medical
Examination of the Accused persons, he had
produced the Accused persons before the
Jurisdictional Magistrate, along with the remand
application, wherein Accused Nos.1 and 2 have been
remanded to Judicial Custody. He has deposed that
he had filed P.F. in respect of Axe/M.O.9 and

- 85 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Motorcycle/M.O.22 before the Jurisdictional
Magistrate and on the same day, he had received the
report submitted by C.W.24/P.W.18, as per Ex.P.38.
On identification signature of the witness is marked
as Ex.P.38(b).
lxx. He has deposed that on 30.06.2017, he had
presented the Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1,
C.W.12/P.W.3 and C.W.14/P.W.14 before the
Jurisdictional Magistrate, for recording their
Statements as contemplated U/Sec.164(5) of CrPC
and accordingly, the Jurisdictional Magistrate has
recorded the Statements of the said witnesses. He
has deposed that he had secured the said
Statements, which are already marked as Ex.P.11,
14, 16 and 32.
lxxi. He has deposed that on 29.07.2017, Accused Nos.3
and 4 shown in the FIR had appeared before him
along with Anticipatory Bail Orders and on following

- 86 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


the conditions, he had arrested the Accused Nos.3
and 4 and released them on Bail.
lxxii. He has deposed that on the same day, he had
secured the Certificate from the PDO,
Gramapanchayat Kadani. On identification, the said
Certificate is marked as Ex.P.56, signature of the
witness is marked as Ex.P.56(a).
lxxiii. He has deposed that on 14.08.2017, he had secured
the Postmortem Report of deceased Sangappa,
Malakappa and Sharanabasu from C.W.22/P.W.21, as
per Ex.P.45, 48 and 51, respectively. On
identification, signature of the witness is marked as
Ex.P.45(b), Ex.P.48(b) and Ex.P.51(b).
lxxiv. He has deposed that on 04.09.2017, he had secured
the Wound Certificates of C.W.11/P.W.2,
C.W.1/P.W.1 and C.W.10/P.W.4 as per Ex.P.40 to
42 respectively from C.W.21/P.W.20. On

- 87 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


identification, signatures of the witness are marked
as Ex.P.40(b), Ex.P.41(b) and Ex.P.42(b).
lxxv. He has deposed that on 13.09.2017, he had sent the
seized articles, in all 20 items, from Scientific
Investigation to RFSL Belagavi through P.C.1517 of
Alamel Police Station and on 15.09.2017, P.C. 1517
has furnished the acknowledgment.
lxxvi. He has deposed that on 23.09.2017, h e h a d
secured the Spot Sketch from C.W.20/P.W.19 as
per Ex.P.39. On identification, signature of the
witness is marked as Ex.P.39(e).
lxxvii. He has deposed that on the same day, he had
secured the RTC Extract of the land pertaining to the
Spot of incident from Tahashildar Sindagi. On
identification, the said RTC Extract is marked as
Ex.P.57, signature of the witness is marked as
Ex.P.57(a).

- 88 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


lxxviii. He has deposed that on the same day, on findings
materials against Accused Nos.1 and 2, he has filed
the Charge-sheet against Accused Nos.1 and 2 for
the offence punishable under Sections 451, 323,
324, 302, 354, 504 and 506 read with Sections 34 of
IPC, keeping pending receipt of RFSL report.
lxxix. In Cross-examination, it is elicited that when he
received a Phone call from C.W.25/ P.W.22/PSI
Almel, he was in his office i.e. office of CPI, Sindagi.
On receiving the Phone call from C.W.25/P.W.22, he
did not enquire him as to from which place he is
informing me. It is elicited that after reaching New
Tavarakhed village, he had not enquired
C.W.25/P.W.22, as to from which place he had called
him over telephone. It is elicited that he went to

New Tavarakhed village by 8.45 pm on 23.06.2017

and when he reached New Tavarakhed village,
C.W.25/P.W.22/PSI Almel along with 3-4 Police
Personnel were present on the Spot; till he reached

- 89 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


the spot of incident i.e., up to 8.40 pm, the
Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1 had not filed Complaint
with C.W.25/ P.W.22/PSI Almel. It is elicited that at
about 10.00 pm, the relatives of deceased have
arrived from Kalhalli village. It is elicited that the
said relatives means C.W.2/P.W.7, C.W.3/P.W.5,
C.W.4/P.W.6, C.W.5, C.W.15/P.W.11 and C.W.16/
P.W.12. He has denied that after arrival relatives
from Kalhalli village, the Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1

on discussing with the said relatives, with him and

with PSI Almel, the Complaint was received from
the Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1. It is elicited that as
per the endorsement of PSI Almel, the
Complaint/Ex.P.1 was received by him at 22.30 hrs
on 23.06.2017. He has admitted that, from 8.40 pm
to 10.30 pm, the Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1 had not
lodged the Complaint. Witness volunteered that the
Complainant/ C.W.1/P.W.1 was in sorrow and grief,
as such, she might not have lodged the Complaint

- 90 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


immediately. It is elicited that he has not mentioned
in the Prosecution papers, suggesting that
Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1 was in sorrow and grief,
so she might not have lodged the Complaint
immediately. He has denied that, himself and PSI
Almel/C.W.22/P.W.25, did not receive the Complaint
from the Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1, till arrival of her
relatives from Kalhalli village viz., C.W.2 to C.W.5
and C.W.15 and 16; and after having discussion with
the said relatives, they had received the Complaint
as per Ex.P.1. He has admitted that,
C.W.15/P.W.11/Mahaningappa is the father of
C.W.11/P.W.2/Akkamahadevi and that, the Panchas
to Inquest Mahazars / Ex.P.17 and Ex.P.19 viz.,
C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.3/P.W.5 are the relatives of
the Complainant/C.W.1/P.W.1; and they are the
residents of Kalhalli village. Witness volunteered that
they might be distant relatives. It is elicited that
since the residents of the locality did not come

- 91 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


forward to be the Inquest Panchas, he had taken
C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.3/P.W.5 as Panchas to both
the Inquest Mahazars, but he has not mentioned the
said fact, either in the Inquest Mahazars/Ex.P.17 and
19, or in any of the Prosecution documents. He has
further admitted that, Al-Ameen Medical College and
Hospital, Vijayapura is a Private Hospital and that,
there is District Hospital working at Vijayapura; and
that he had not issued any written requisition to
District Hospital Vijayapura, in this Case for
conducting Postmortem on the dead bodies of
deceased Malakappa, Sangappa and Sharanabasu.
Witness volunteered that he had contacted the
Medical Officer, District Hospital Vijayapura on
Telephone; and the said Medical Officer had informed
him that Forensic Medicine Experts are not available
in District Hospital Vijayapura to conduct Postmortem
on the dead bodies; so he had issued requisition to
Al-Ameen Medical College and Hospital, Vijayapura.

- 92 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


It is elicited that he has not mentioned the said fact
in any of the Charge-sheet documents.
lxxx. He has denied that, since the Medical Officer of Al-
Ameen Medical College and Hospital Vijayapura will
give favourable Postmortem Report, as such he has
referred the dead bodies for conducting of
Postmortem to the said Medical Hospital. He has
also denied that, he is deposing falsely that, he had
sent C.W.1/P.W.1, C.W.10/P.W.4 and C.W.11/P.W.2
for treatment to Government Hospital Sindagi
through Ambulance. He has denied that, all the three
persons viz., C.W.1/P.W.1, C.W.10/P.W.4 and
C.W.11/P.W.2 had not received any injuries. He has
negated the suggestion that, he has purposely
chosen C.W.2/ P.W.7 and C.W.5 as Panchas for
conducting the Spot Mahazar on 24.06.2017, since
they are the relatives of the C.W.11/ P.W.2 and
C.W.15/ P.W.11, though they are not the residents of
the vicinity in which the Spot Mahazar was

- 93 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


conducted. He negated that suggestion that, Kalhalli
village is located at a distance of about 20kms from
New Tavarakhed village. Witness volunteered that it
might be about 15kms. It is elicited that since the
localities from the vicinity where the Spot Mahazar/
Ex.P.2 was drawn did not come forward, as such he
was constrained to take C.W.2/P.W.7 and C.W.5 as
Panchas, though they are the residents of Kalhalli
village. He has admitted that he has not mentioned
the said fact, either in the Spot Mahazar/Ex.P.2 or in
the Charge-sheet papers. He has denied that, he has
purposely chosen C.W.2/ P.W.7 and C.W.5 as
Panchas for conducting the Seizure Mahazars/
Ex.P.22 to 24, conducted on 24.06.2017, since they
are the relatives of the C.W.11/P.W.2 and
C.W.15/P.W.11, though they are not the residents of
New Tavarakhed village. Since the localities from
New Tavarakhed village did not come forward, as
such he was constrained to take C.W.2/P.W.7 and

- 94 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


C.W.5 as Panchas, to conduct Seizure
Mahazars/Ex.P.22 to 24. He has admitted that he has
not mentioned the said fact, either in the Seizure
Mahazar/Ex.P.22 to 24 or in the Charge-sheet
papers. He has denied the suggestion that, on one
side residents of Accused persons is situated; and on
another side house of Sharanappa Yallappa Harindral
is situated. He has admitted that, the residential
houses of Accused persons, of the Complainant and
of Sharanappa Yallappa Harindral are facing towards
Eastern side. He has denied suggestion that,
opposite to the residential houses of the Accused
persons, the Complainant and Sharanappa Yallappa
Harindral, about 5-6 residential houses are located.
Witness volunteered that there might be 2-3
houses, amongst them the house of Siddappa Pujari
is located. He pleaded ignorance as to whether on
23.06.2017 the Accused persons were residing in
their residential houses along with their parents,

- 95 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


respective wives and children. It is elicited that he
made inquiries to this effect and this fact did not
come to his notice, as the residents of the houses of
Accused persons have not cooperated me. It is
elicited that he has not mentioned the said fact in the
Charge-sheet papers, however, it is stated by him
that he had made inquiries with the residents of the
house of Sharnappa Harindral, but the said residents
did not cooperate him to state the facts, as they
were afraid, so also he had not recorded their
Statements, since they were afraid. It is elicited that
he has not mentioned the said facts in the Charge-
sheet papers. It is elicited that he made inquiries
with the residents of the 2-3 houses located opposite
to the houses of Accused persons; even those
residents did not cooperate him to tell the facts, as
they were afraid and that he has not recorded their
Statements, since they were afraid. He has admitted

- 96 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


that he had not mentioned the said facts in the
Charge-sheet papers.
lxxxi. The witness admitted that, he has not shown
independent Eye witnesses in the Charge-sheet. He
has denied the suggest that, in order to conceive the
occurrence of the real facts, he has purposely
avoided to show independent Eye witnesses in the
Charge-sheet. It is elicited that he has not issued any
written directions to PSI Almel/C.W.24/ P.W.22, for
search of Accused persons and produce them before
me.
lxxxii. He has denied the suggestion that, since PSI
Almel/C.W.24/ P.W.22 has apprehended Accused
Nos.1 and 2 from their respective residents on
27.06.2017, as such he had not issued any written
instruction/requisition to PSI Almel/C.W.24/P.W.22
for search of Accused persons and to produce them
before him. He has also denied that, he got prepared

- 97 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


the Spot Mahazar as per Ex.P.8 in his office; and
falsely contending that the said Mahazar proceedings
were conducted in the agricultural field, in the
presence of two panchas viz., C.W.6/P.W.9 and
C.W.7/P.W.8, on the spot shown by C.W. 1/P.W.1.
He has denied that, none of the Prosecution
witnesses have given any Statements before him,
however, he has got prepared the said Statements,
in order to get support to his investigation. He has
denied the suggestion that, he got prepared all the
Mahazars in his office, in order to suit the purpose
for his investigation.
lxxxiii. He has denied that, he has shown in the Charge-
sheet papers that Accused No.1 was holding Koyta in
one hand and Spade/Salike in another hand, which is
unnatural; and that, the Accused persons had not
given their Voluntary Statement as per Ex.P.54 and
55. It is elicited that he has not seized the clothes
worn by Accused persons, during the course of his

- 98 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


investigation. He has denied that, since he was
aware that Accused persons were not involved in the
Crime, he has not seized the clothes worn by the
Accused persons, in this case. Witness volunteered
that since the Accused persons contended that they
have got washed their clothes, as such he has not
seized the clothes of the Accused persons.
lxxxiv. He has denied that, generally when the blood-stained
clothes are washed, the blood stains will not be
totally wiped off from the said clothes. It is elicited
that since the Accused persons did not disclose about
hiding of the washed clothes by them, as such he has
not seized the clothes worn by the Accused persons,
in this Case. It is elicited that he has not mentioned
the said facts in the Charge-sheet papers.
lxxxv. He has negated the suggestion that, C.W.8/P.W.10
and C.W.9 shown as the Panchas in Seizure
Mahazars/Ex.P.25 and 28 are holding their office in

- 99 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


front of Almel Police Station; and they are favourable
to Almel Police, so they were chosen as Panchas to
the said Seizure Mahazars. He denied the suggestion
that, they could have obtained independent Panchas
from the respective places shown in the Seizure
mahazars/ Ex.P.25 and 28, but have taken
C.W.8/P.W.10 and C.W.9 as Panchas, due to
favourism to be extracted from the said Panchas.
lxxxvi. The witness has denied that, he had got drawn
Seizure Mahazars as per Ex.P.25 and 25 in his office;
and not drawn at the Spots shown in it. He has
denied that, he had tutored and instigated C.W.1/
P.W.1, C.W.10/P.W.4, C.W.12/P.W.3 and
C.W.14/P.W.14 to give their Statements to be
recorded U/Sec.164(5) of CrPC before the Magistrate
as per Ex.P.11, 16, 14 and 32 respectively. He denid
that, he got prepared Postmortem Report and RFSL
Report from the respective officers, in the manner
required for him to suit the purpose in this Case. It is

- 100 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


elicited that he has investigated with regard to the
conduct of deceased Sangappa, deceased Malakappa
and deceased Sharanabasu with the neighbors and
villagers of New Tavarakhed village. He denied that,
all the three deceased persons had availed loans
from the villagers of New Tavarakhed village and
that, all the three deceased persons were not in good
terms with Sharnappa, as deceased Malakappa had
flown his Bullock-cart upon the grandson of
Sharanappa, due to which the grandson of
Sharanappa succumb to the injuries. He has also
denied that, all the three deceased persons were not
having good terms with Gurulingappa Pujari, as
deceased Malakappa had assaulted Gurulingappa
Pujari and had caused injury to the heel of
Gurulingappa Pujari. He negated that, had he
investigated the matter properly, all the above facts
pertaining to the conduct of all the deceased persons
would have come to light; and that since he had

- 101 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


conducted the investigation one sided and arbitrary,
as such, the above said fact could have been missed,
from coming on record.
lxxxvii. The witness denied the suggestion that, in order to
drag the Accused persons into this Crime, he got
prepared the Charge-sheet in this Case and that,
though the Accused persons have not committed any
crime, he has filed a false Charge-sheet against
them.
lxxxviii. The prosecution examined one Guruprasad Kulkarni,
Judicial Officer, District Judge, Chikkamagaluru as
PW-24 . He has deposed that he was working as
Senior Civil Judge and JMFC at Sindagi since
17.12.2015 to 16.05.2019. On 30.06.2017, Almel
Police have brought Nagamma Harindral,
Shankrappa Shivagond, Shankramma Harindral and
Mallappa Bogonde before him for recording their
Statements as contemplated U/Sec.164(5) of CrPC.

- 102 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


He has deposed that on informing the consequences
and on following the procedure, he has recorded
their Statements on 30.06.2017. He has deposed
that he can identify the said Statements recorded by
him and when the Statements marked at Ex.P.11,
14, 16 and 32 were shown to the witness, the
witness identified the said Statements. He has
deposed that on identification, the signatures of the
witness is marked as Ex.P.11(a); on Ex.P.14 as
Ex.P.14(c); on Ex.P.16 as Ex.P.16(a) and on Ex.P.32
as Ex.P.32(c). He has deposed that due to
typographical error with regard to the date, the date
of taking Oath by the respective witnesses is shown
as 29.06.2017 instead of 30.06.2017. He has
deposed that the witnesses have affixed their
signatures on the Statements/ Ex.P.11, 14, 16 and
32, on getting it read over and on understanding it.
lxxxix. In cross-examination, it is elicited that prior to
recording the Statements of witnesses, he has

- 103 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


informed the witnesses that making of the Statement
by them is not obligatory. It is elicited that he has
not recorded the said fact in the Statements/
Ex.P.11, 14, 16 and 32. It is elicited that he has
enquired the witnesses as to whether they have been
forced to give any Statement by the Police. He has
admitted that, he has not recorded the said fact in
the Statements/ Ex.P.11, 14, 16 and 32.
xc. The prosecution examined one Mahantesh
Damannavar Krishnappa, Police Inspector, Market
Police Station, Belagavi as PW-25 . He has deposed
that he was serving as CPI at Police Circle Sindagi
since 17.12.2017 to 19.07.2019. He has deposed that
on 28.03.2018, he had secured the RFSL report
along with sample seal from RFSL Belagavi through
DySP Indi; and submitted the same before the
Jurisdictional Magistrate. The RFSL report dated:
28.02.2018 was shown to the witness and
questioned him to identify the same and the witness

- 104 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


identified the said report and on identification, RFSL
report is marked as Ex.P.58, and his Signature is
marked as Ex.P.58(a).
xci. The Cross examination of P.W.25 by Accused persons
is taken as ‘NIL’ as the learned counsel for Accused
Nos.1 and 2 submits that Accused persons have no
Cross examination towards P.W.25.

On a perusal of the entire oral and documentary
evidence on record, it is clear that PW-1 has deposed that,
when she was in her land, accused No.1 called her to hold
the water pipe, as she was fetching water to the
sugarcane crop in his hand; and when she went there,
accused No.1 caught hold her hand and tried to drag her
into the sugarcane groove; when she raised hue and cry,
then he left her. She called her husband and informed her
in-laws and after due deliberation, they decided to
convene a panchayat .

- 105 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


In her cross-examination, PW1 has deposed as
follows:
ಈ
“ …
                  

              
.
                       

                     
.
                   

                     

                    

                   

                  

                        
ಆ
. … … 1
                

                    
.
                   
ದ ಈ

                    
1
                   

                    

                     
. … …”
      

As per this evidence, complainant/PW1 contends that, at
the time of alleged incident neighbours did not come and
viewed the incident. She affirms the suggestion made to
her that, due to hue and cry in quarrel, neighbours came

- 106 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


to the spot. Further she affirms that many have witnessed
the incident, but none have come to rescue. cross-
examination of PW2, page 20, paragraph No.9, line Nos.11
to 13, which reads as under:
   
" ,
   
.
    

    
.
  
.”

As per this evidence Akkamahadevi/PW2 contends that,
though they had raised hue and cry but nobody come
there; several persons viewed the incident from outside.
11. Looking at the above circumstances and
situation prevailing in the case at hand, it can be said that
relationship of the witnesses viz., PW1, PW2 and PW4,
who are the wives of the respective deceased persons is of
no consequences, as the possibility of outsiders being
available inside the house of the complainant and the
deceased persons is very remote. Further, out of the said

- 107 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


three eye-witnesses, one is shown to be the injured eye-
witness, it makes her testimony more credible and more
believable. Outrightly, the testimonies of PW1, PW2 and
PW4 cannot be ignored, since they are the wives of the
respective deceased persons in this case; so also when
those persons appears to be the natural witnesses and not
the chance witnesses; further, no any reasons have been
placed on record to show as to why their versions cannot
be believed, or to say that their versions are tentated with
some mala fides . At the most, it can be said that the
testimony of PW1, PW2 & PW4 being the wives of
respective three deceased persons is required to be
examined cautiously.
12. It is a trite principle of law that, to believe the
version of PW1, PW2 and PW4, amongst whom PW4 is
shown to be present with the all the three deceased
persons in the frontyard at the time of incident; the
second witness is shown to be the injured eye-witness;
and the third eye-witness is the complainant herself, under

- 108 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


these circumstances it is necessary to seek corroboration
with the other piece of evidence on record. Rule of
prudence always requires to have corroboration to the
testimony, to believe and find a person guilty of certain
acts.
13. It is the case of the prosecution that, the
Investigating Agency has conducted the spot-cum-seizure
mahazar and seized koita/MO1, spade/MO2, blood stained
muds and sample muds from three places where the dead
bodies of Sangappa, Sharanabasavaraj were lying, and
where Malakappa was found lying injured; in the presence
of two Panchas i.e., CW2/PW7 and CW5, as per Ex.P2; got
drawn the sketch as per Ex.P53; got secured the
handsketch from PWD Authorities as per Ex.P39; and got
clicked positive photographs as per Exs.P3 to P7. Further,
it is the case of the prosecution that, since Malakkappa
was found struggling for life, he was taken by
Shankareppa Shivgond/CW12/PW3 in the vehicle to the

- 109 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Hospital, but on the way he collapsed/died, so he was
brought return/back.
14. The prosecution has led the evidence of one of
the Pancha witness to the said mahazar proceedings i.e.,
CW2/PW7. On careful perusal of the ocular evidence of
this witness, this witness has specifically contended about
conducting of spot and seizure mahazar on the said
places. This witness has specifically contended that, he
was called upon by the Police to act as Pancha ; on the
request of the Police, he has acted as Pancha .
15. Further, the Prosecution has produced the
inquest mahazar conducted on the deadbody of Sangappa
at Ex.P17 in the presence of two Panchas i.e., CW2/PW7
and CW3/PW5. On careful perusal of said inquest
mahazar, it is seen that:
(a) the said inquest mahzar is conducted on the
deadbody of Sangappa which was lying on the
road; the road is situated in front of the house
of the complainant.

- 110 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


This fact gets corroborated, firstly with the
version of all the three eye-witnesses viz.,
complainant/PW1, Akkamahadevi/PW2 and
Shankaramma/PW4.
Secondly, this fact gets corroborated with
the place of first incident of assault caused
upon Sangappa, the place which is shown in the
spot-cum-seizure mahazar/Ex.P2, which is seen
in the positive photograph/Ex.P6.
(b) with regard to the clothes worn by Sangappa
which were seized under Seizure
Mahzar/Ex.P24, which found mention in the
inquest mahazar.
Firstly, the said clothes have been
identified by all the three eye-witnesses viz.,
complainant/PW1, Akkamahadevi/PW2 and
Shankaramma/PW4, which forms corroborative
piece of evidence.
Secondly, the said clothes got
corroborated with the clothes seized by the
Investigating Officer, which was produced by
CW19/PW17 under seizure mahazar/Ex.P24,
which are marked at MO18 to MO21.

- 111 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Thirdly, most importantly, one of the
Pancha witnesses to the inquest mahazar viz.,
PW7 is also the Pancha to the spot-cum-seizure
mahazar/Ex.P2 and the seizure
mahazar/Ex.P24, this forms linking material
corroborative piece of evidence. And said
witness has stood to the cross-examination
done on behalf of accused Nos.1 and 2.
(c) with regard to the injures sustained by
Sangappa:
The injuries found on the deadbody of
Sangappa mentioned in inquest mahzar/Ex.P17
get corroborated with the injuries mentioned in
Form Nos.146(i)/Ex.P43 and 146(ii)/Ex.P.44.
Secondly the injuries found on the person
of Sangappa shown in Inquest Mahzar/Ex.P.17
get corroborated with the Injuries shown in the
Postmortem Report/Ex.P.45.

16. The prosecution has led the evidence of Doctor
who has conducted the post-mortem viz., CW22/PW21/
M.A.Bagali, wherein he has opined that except injury
Nos.3, 6, 9 & 10, the remaining injuries mentioned in

- 112 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


Ex.P51 can be caused through koita/MO1 and axe/MO9;
and injury Nos.3, 6, 9 & 10 shown in Ex.P51 can be
caused through spade/MO2. It is a linking piece of
evidence, linking weapons koita/MO1, spade/MO2 and
axe/MO9 the injuries found on the deadbody of
Sharanabasavaraj.
17. Thus, on viewing the matter from every angle,
it can be said that, the versions of eye-witnesses viz.,
complainant/PW1, Akkamahadevi/PW2 and
Shankaramma/PW4 have been got corroborated with the
medical evidence placed by the prosecution.
18. The Sessions Court, after considering the entire
material on record, has passed the impugned judgment.
While passing the impugned judgment, the Sessions Court
has passed an order for life imprisonment, means
remainder of natural lives of the accused persons. The
Sessions Court has committed an error in imposing the
punishment with such a direction to the imprisonment for

- 113 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


life. In that light, we are of the considered opinion that the
appellants have made out a case to interfere insofar as the
imposition of sentence is concerned.
19. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Kiran
1
Vs. The State of Karnataka , has held in paragraph
No.15 as follows:
“15. Going by the decisions cited, it has to be held
that life imprisonment awarded would be for the rest of
the life, the power to grant remission and commutation
under Sections 432 to 435 Cr. P.C. cannot be curtailed by
the Sessions Court, when the remission as provided
under the Constitution was declared to be not permissible
of interference by the Constitutional Courts. The power of
alternate sentencing to cover the hiatus between 14
years and death, cannot be applied by the Sessions
Courts. Hence, the sentence of life imprisonment cannot
be directed to be till the end of natural life, by the
Sessions Court which direction would be in conflict with
the provisions of the Cr. P.C. The power of remission or
commutation conferred on the State cannot be taken
away and the sentence as awarded by the trial court and
confirmed by the High Court for the offence under Section

1
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2863

- 114 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


302 of the Penal Code, 1860 is confirmed as
imprisonment for life.”

20. Learned counsel for the appellants has also
placed reliance on the judgment passed by the Co-
ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Durgappa S/o
2
Sangappa Timmapur Vs. The State of Karnataka ,
wherein the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court was of the
opinion that the Sessions Court cannot impose sentence of
life imprisonment till the end of the natural life. It is only
the Constitutional Courts i.e., High Courts and Supreme
Court can impose sentence of life imprisonment till the end
of natural life.
Further, it must be observed here that even though
this Court is of the view that the accused deserve severe
punishment for the heinous crime they have committed,
the State has not preferred an appeal seeking imposition
of death sentence.

2
Crl.A No.200001 of 2014, disposed of on 10.08.2020

- 115 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


21. In view of the above discussion, we proceed to
pass the following:
ORDER
i. The appeal is allowed-in-part ;
ii. The impugned judgment of conviction
dated 19.09.2025 passed by the
Sessions Court in SC No.92/2018 for
the offences punishable under
Sections 354, 451, 504, 506, 323,
324, 302 read with Section 34 of IPC,
is hereby confirmed ;
iii. The order of sentence dated
24.09.2025 passed by the Sessions
Court in SC No.92/2018 is hereby
modified ;
iv. Accused persons are sentenced to
undergo life imprisonment and shall
pay a fine of Rs.5,00,000/- to the

- 116 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:9669-DB
CRL.A No. 200308 of 2025


CNR: KAHC030137622025


State for the offence punishable under
Section 302 of IPC. In default to pay
the fine amount, they shall undergo
simple imprisonment for a period of 1
year;
v. Pending IA(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
Sd/-

(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO)
JUDGE
PA/RK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 3