Malik Singh Kang And Others vs State Of Haryana And Another

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 1
THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
275
1. CWP No.16690 of 2023 (O&M)
Malik Singh Kang and others
.....Petitioners
Versus
State of Haryana and others
.....Respondents
2. CWP No.1511 of 2023 (O&M)
Gurpreet Kaur
.....Petitioner
Versus
State of Haryana and another
.....Respondents
th
Date of decision: November 16 , 2026
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS BAHL
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE DIVYA SHARMA
Present: Mr. Puneet Bali, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Gagandeep Singh,
Mr. Jasman Singh Gill and
Mr. Aryaman Jagga, Advocates
for the petitioners in CWP-16690-2023.
Mr. V.P. Sangwan, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-1511-2023.
Mr. Saurabh Mago, Deputy Advocate General, Haryana.
VIKAS BAHL, J. (ORAL)
INDEX
Sr. No. Contents Paras Pages
1 Challenge in the writ petitions 1-4 2-3
2 Facts of the case in CWP-16690-2023 5-17 3-14
3 Facts of the case in CWP-1511-2023 18-22 14-18
4 Arguments on behalf of the petitioner(s) 23 18-19
5 Arguments on behalf of the respondents 24 19-20
6 Analysis and findings 25-46 20-38
(i) With respect to CWP-16690-2023 25-31 20-25
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 2
(ii) With respect to CWP-1511-2023 32-33 25-27
(iii) Consideration of the provisions of law
and the legal precedents:
34-46 27-35
(iv) Conclusion 47 35-38
CHALLENGE IN THE WRIT PETITIONS:
1. The present order would dispose of the above-mentioned two
writ petitions as common questions of law and facts arise in both the writ
petitions.
2. CWP-16690-2023 has been filed by six persons i.e.
Malik Singh Kang son of Tej Partap Singh, Aman Bahadur Singh Kang,
Ajay Singh alias Ajay Singh Kang, Jashan Bahudar Singh Kang all three
sons of Jang Bahadur Singh Kang, Harbir Singh son of Karambir Singh and
Harpreet Kaur daughter of Karambir Singh. CWP-1511-2023 has been filed
by Gurpreet Kaur daughter of Ravinder Kaur, who is the daughter of
Tej Partap Singh.
3. In CWP No.16690 of 2023, the following prayers have been
made in the headnote:
“CIVIL WRIT PETITION under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, for issuance of a Writ in the nature of
Mandamus directing the Respondents to either hand over the
vacant possession of the land measuring 4059.65 sq. yds.
situated in Hadbast No. 379, Khewat No. 1516//1484, Khatoni
No. 1698, Khasra No. 204/4 in Village Darar Kalan, Tehsil
Thanesar, District Kurukshetra, over which the Respondents
have built the Kurukshetra to Jhansa Road without acquiring
the same, or to pay compensation for the aforesaid land as per
the market value and as per the provisions of the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 3
AND/OR
FURTHER to issue any other appropriate Writ, Order or
Direction, as this Hon'ble Court may deem just and proper,
keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
present case.”
4. In CWP No.1511 of 2023, the following prayers have been
made in the headnote:
“CIVIL WRIT PETITION under Articles 226/27 of The
Constitution of India for issuance of an appropriate writ
particularly in the nature of Mandamus commanding the
respondents either to hand over the vacant possession of land
measuring 45 Marlas forming part of Khasra No.204/5 relating
to village Darra Kalan, Tehsil Thanesar, District Kurukshetra to
the petitioner and other land owners or to pay the compensation
for the aforesaid land as per the market value as well as per the
provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency
in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
2013.
For issuance of an appropriate writ particularly in the nature of
Mandamus commanding the respondents to decide the legal
Notice dated 30.3.2022 (Annexure P-4) by passing a speaking
order within a time bound manner.”
FACTS OF THE CASE IN CWP-16690-2023:
5. Six petitioners have filed the present petition on the plea that
one late Tej Partap, son of Rai Singh was the owner of land measuring 19
kanals, 16 marlas situated in Hadbast No. 379, Khewat No.1516//1484,
Khatoni No. 1698, Khasra No. 204/4 in Village Darar Kalan, Tehsil
Thanesar, District Kurukshetra. It is further pleaded that after consolidation,
the said land was transferred in names of the three sons of the said Tej
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 4
rd
Partap, each son getting 1/3 share. Petitioner No.1 is stated to be the first
son, Jang Bahadur Singh, father of petitioner No.2 to 4, is stated to be the
second son and Karambir Singh, father of petitioners No.5 and 6, is stated to
be the third son. It is further pointed out that the said Tej Pratap had died in
the year 1971 and subsequently even Jang Bahadur Singh and Karambir
Singh had died and thus, the petitioners became the owners of the property
in question. Reference has been made to the jamabandi for the year 2020-
2021, which has been annexed by the State as Annexure R-1 (running page
No.165 of the paper book) to highlight the fact that petitioner No.1 is the
rd
owner of 1/3 share of the land comprised in Khasra No.204/4 (19 kanal 16
marla). Petitioners No.2 to 4 are jointly shown to be owners to the extent of
rd
1/3 share in the said khasra number and petitioners No.5 and 6 are jointly
shown to be owners to the extent of 1159/3564 share, in the said khasra
number.
6. It is the case of the petitioners that a large number of persons
had trespassed upon the land in question and thus, various applications were
submitted to the Tehsildar, Thanesar seeking demarcation of the land. The
first application which has been referred to is dated 15.11.2017 (Annexure
P-2) in which a specific prayer had been made that demarcation of the land
measuring 19 kanals, 16 marlas be carried out. The said application
(Annexure P-2) has been signed by the Tehsildar, Thanesar. Further,
applications dated 01.02.2021, 08.06.2021, 02.02.2022 have also been
annexed along with the present petition as Annexures P-3 to P-5. A detailed
application dated 04.03.2022 has also been annexed as Annexure P-6,
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 5
wherein a request for demarcation was made to all the concerned authorities
and it had been stated in the same that a large number of persons were
trespassing onto the land of the petitioners in connivance with the official
respondents.
7. As no action was taken by the respondents on the applications
seeking demarcation of the land in question, petitioner No.2 filed CWP No.
10683 of 2022 titled as “Aman Bahadur Singh versus State of Haryana and
others”, in which the primary prayer made by petitioner No.2 was for
directing the respondents to take appropriate steps, in a time-bound manner,
to demarcate the land in question. In the said case, a written statement dated
25.07.2022 (Annexure P-7) was filed by the Tehsildar, Thanesar, who was
respondent No.6 in the said writ petition and in the said written statement, it
was stated that as per the Jamabandi for the year 2020-21, land measuring 5
kanals 0 marla, comprised in Khasra No.204/4, which is the land in question,
was stated to be “Gair Mumkin Sadak/road” and the remaining land
measuring 14 kanals 16 marlas, was shown to be “Gair Mumkin Abadi”.
The said Jamabandi was annexed as Annexure R-1 along with the reply filed
in CWP-10683-2022. In the said written statement, the plea with respect to
the said portion of land in question having been utilized for the purpose of
construction of a road known as the “Kurukshetra to Jhansa Road” was also
raised. It is the case of the petitioners that it was only after the perusal of the
said reply that the petitioners got to know for the first time that a part of the
land owned by the petitioners had been utilized by the respondent authorities
for constructing the said road without acquiring the same and without paying
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 6
any compensation to the petitioners.
8. It is further the case of the petitioners that the petitioners had
filed several applications under the Right to Information Act, 2005, to
various authorities seeking information about the year of the construction of
the road, the details of the acquisition proceedings, if any, initiated in respect
of the land in question and the compensation, if any, paid to any person in
this regard. The said applications filed under the Right to Information Act,
2005, dated 06.12.2022, to various authorities have been annexed as
Annexure P-8 to P-10. On 19.12.2022, the State Public Information Officer-
cum-District Revenue Officer had written to the Land Acquisition Collector
informing that the application filed by the petitioners had been transferred to
his office for necessary compliance. The said letter has been annexed as
Annexure P-11 along with the writ petition. Further correspondences issued
by the officials, dated 26.12.2022 and 27.12.2022, have been annexed as
Annexures P-12 and P-13. Vide letter dated 24.05.2023 (Annexure P-14),
the Executive Engineer, Provincial Division No.2, PWD B&R Department,
informed petitioner No.2 that the record of the land owners whose land was
taken for the construction of the Thanesar-Jhansa Road was not available
and that even the record with respect to any compensation having been paid
to the land owners was also not available. It is, thus, pleaded that there was
nothing on record to show that the land had been acquired or any
compensation had been given to the landowners, much less petitioners. It is
stated that in view of the same, petitioner No.2 withdrew CWP No.10683 of
2022 on 09.03.2023 with liberty to avail remedy in accordance with law.
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 7
9. It is further the case of the petitioners that in the year 2016, the
respondents-State widened the road in question. The said aspect has been
admitted in the written statement filed on behalf of the respondents. Thus, it
is the case of the petitioners that the land of the petitioners has been utilized
without acquiring the same and without payment of any compensation and
the same is in violation of the constitutional rights of the petitioners under
Article 300A of the Constitution of India. On the basis of the abovesaid
pleadings, the present writ petition has been filed.
10. In the said case, on 03.08.2023, a Coordinate Division Bench of
this Court was pleased to pass the following order:-
"Present: Mr. Puneet Bali, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Uday Agnihotri, Advocate for the petitioners.
*
1. On the oral request of the learned State counsel, Deputy
Commissioner, Kurukshetra is impleaded as co-respondent No. 3,
in the array of respondents in the memo of parties.
2. The Registry of this Court is directed to make requisite
corrections in the memo of parties.
3. Notice of motion.
4. Mr. Ankur Mittal, Addl. A.G., Haryana waives service on
behalf of the respondents-State.
5. At this stage, without granting relief to the petitioners, this
Court yet directs the respondent concerned, to ensure that a valid
demarcation of the writ land, by the empowered revenue officer, is
conducted. The said demarcation shall be carried on the basis of a
masavi maintained in the office of the District Collector
concerned.
6. The report of the empowered revenue officer, be ensured to be
placed on record on or before the subsequent date of hearing.
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 8
7. List on 31.8.2023.
8. To be heard along with CWP-1511-2023.
August 03, 2023"
11. The Court had directed the respondent-authorities to carry out
the demarcation and to place on record the report on or before the next date
of hearing i.e., 31.08.2023. The act of the respondents in pursuance of the
said order was contemptuous and deserves to be deprecated. It is not in
dispute that, in pursuance of the said order, a letter dated 08.08.2023 was
issued by the Collector to the Tehsildar, Thanesar, with a request to comply
with the aforesaid order of the High Court. The said letter has been annexed
as Annexure A-2 along with CM-11273-CWP-2025 filed by the petitioners.
It was specifically stated in the said letter that the Tehsildar was required to
ensure that the demarcation report be submitted before the next date of
hearing, and if there was any delay, then it would be the said Tehsildar who
would be responsible for disobeying the orders of the Court. The letter also
records that Kuldeep Singh, retired Kanungo, was appointed as the Local
Commissioner for the said purpose.
12. It is not in dispute that a demarcation report dated 22.08.2023
was prepared. The copy of the said demarcation report has been annexed as
Annexure A-3 along with the said CM-11273-CWP-2025. A perusal of the
said demarcation report would show that the same was being done in
compliance with the order passed by the Collector dated 08.08.2023, as well
as that of the Tehsildar, Thanesar, dated 17.08.2023 and in pursuance of the
orders passed by the Coordinate Division Bench. The demarcation was
conducted in the presence of 13 people, including Shri J.K. Arora, Senior
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 9
Section Officer, Railway, Vijay Arora, Senior Section Officer, Railway,
Narender Singh, Nambardar of the concerned area, Salinder Patwari, Suresh
Kumar, DGPS Machine Operator, Abhimanyu, Naib Tehsildar, Paramjit
Singh Patwari of Darra Khurd, and other persons, and all the said persons
had duly signed the attendance sheet attached alongwith the demarcation
report in addition to the Halka Kanungo who had also signed the
demarcation report. A further perusal of the said report would show that the
officers who had come from the Railway Department had brought the record
of the Railway Department and the revenue record of Halka Darra Khurd,
Thanesar, and Darra Kalan (Thanesar), was also taken into consideration,
and even the Musavi, which was a coloured photocopy, had also been taken
from the office of the Tehsildar, Thanesar. The information regarding
demarcation was given to the parties by the Halka Patwari. Reference was also
made to an earlier demarcation report dated 03.09.2021, carried out in respect
of Khasra No.204/5, which is the subject matter of the other writ petition. A
perusal of the demarcation report dated 22.08.2023 would further show that the
demarcation was done with the help of the DGPS machine, and the site plan
which had been prepared by the Railway Department officers at the spot, was
found to be accurate as per the original record. It was noticed that the site plan
of the railway track which had been provided by the Senior Section Engineer,
was prepared in the year 1937 and as per the said site plan, all the dimensions
were found to be correct. After duly conducting the demarcation, it was found
that land measuring 2 Kanal 19 Marlas, as shown in red colour in the site plan
attached along with the demarcation report had been used by the respondent
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 10
authorities for the purpose of constructing the road and the drain. The said site
plan has also been annexed alongwith CM-11273-CWP-2025.
13. Thus, from the said demarcation report, which was conducted in
pursuance of the order passed by the Coordinate Division Bench, it was
apparent that land measuring 2 Kanal 19 Marlas, out of 19 Kanal 16 Marlas
comprising in Khasra No.204/4, was used by the respondent authorities for
the purpose of constructing the road and the drain. It was the duty of the
respondent authorities to produce the said report on record, as was directed
by the Coordinate Division Bench on 03.08.2023. However, the respondent
authorities did not choose to do the same and when the matter was taken up
on 10.09.2024, more time was sought by the State to file reply, on which a
conditional cost of 5,000 was imposed, and it was never informed on ₹
behalf of the respondents that a demarcation report had been prepared. Order
dated 10.09.2024 is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“Present:- Ms. Anu Garg, Advocate, appearing for
Mr. Ravi Dutt Sharma, Advocate for the petitioner
(in CWP No.1511 of 2013).
Ms. Bhagyashri, Advocate appearing for
Mr. Vibhav Jain, Advocate, for the petitioner
(in CWP No.16690 of 2023).
Mr. Saurabh Mago, DAG, Haryana.
*
Learned State counsel seeks more time to file reply.
Adjourned to 11.02.2025.
Conditional cost of Rs.5000/- is imposed upon the State in each
case, to be paid to Institute of Blind, Sector 26, Chandigarh, in
case replies are not filed on or before the next date of hearing.
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 11
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of the connected
case.
September 10, 2024”
14. Thereafter, the respondent authorities, without seeking any
permission from the Court, and in order to avoid their liability, sought to
challenge their own demarcation report dated 22.08.2023. However, the
petitioner, after learning about the said demarcation report, by filing CM-
11273-CWP-2025, placed all the aforesaid facts before this Court, and the
Coordinate Division Bench of this Court, vide order dated 07.08.2025,
stayed the challenge made by the respondent authorities to the said
demarcation report. Order dated 07.08.2025 is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“Present: Mr. Puneet Bali, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Abhishek Sharma, Advocate and
Mr. Jasman Singh Gill, Advocate
for the applicants-petitioners.
Mr. Pradeep Prakash Chahar, Senior DAG, Haryana.
*
Learned senior counsel appearing for the applicants-petitioners
submits that on 03.08.2023, while issuing notice in the applicants’
main petition, this Court had directed the State to ensure that a
demarcation of the land in question, by an empowered revenue
officer, is conducted; the said demarcation was further directed to
be carried out on the basis of a masavi maintained in the office of
the concerned District Collector; after conducting the demarcation,
the demarcation report was to be placed on record of this Court
before 31.08.2023; in terms of the interim order of this Court
dated 03.08.2023, a demarcation was got conducted by the State
on 22.08.2023; the demarcation report, which was prepared
thereafter, was signed by as many as 13 persons including 10
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 12
officials and 03 of the applicants; in violation of the directions
issued by this Court on 03.08.2023, the State, till date, has not
placed the demarcation report on the record of this Court; rather,
since the demarcation report was in favour of the applicants, while
the matter was sub-judice, the State challenged the said report
before the Deputy Commissioner, Kurukshetra, who further
delegated the said proceedings to the concerned SDO (Civil), who
had no authority to decide the matter and that the afore facts not
only show the illegality and arbitrariness on the part of the State
but that the action of the State is also contemptuous.
Notice of the application be issued to the respondents for the
date already fixed in the main case i.e. 12.08.2025.
Mr. Pradeep Prakash Chahar, Senior DAG, Haryana accepts
notice on behalf of the respondents and prays for time to file a
reply.
Till the adjourned date, proceedings with regard to the
challenge to the aforesaid demarcation report by the State shall
remain stayed.
To be taken up in the urgent list.
07.08.2025”
15. It is only after the petitioner had placed on record the said
demarcation report that the respondent-authorities, by virtue of an additional
affidavit dated 19.11.2025, sought to place on record the said demarcation
report dated 22.08.2023, as Annexure R-2, (page 161 of the paper book).
The said conduct of the respondent authorities as stated hereinabove is
contumacious. However in view of the fact that since the lis is being finally
decided thus, we do not wish to take any further action on the same.
16. In the written statement dated 20.11.2025, filed on behalf of
respondent Nos.1 and 2, the case set up by the respondents is that the road in
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 13
question, i.e., the Thanesar-Jhansa Road, was constructed in the year 1974-
75, and that the land was offered by the landowners out of their free will and
consent. It is further their case that the petitioners and their predecessor-in-
interest had the knowledge of the road since the year 1975-76 and that they
had approached this Court after much delay and thus, their case deserves to
be rejected on the ground of delay and laches. In the said written statement,
further plea was taken that the widening of the road had been done by the
PWD Department in the year 1992, 2000 and 2016. Relevant portion of the
said para of the written statement/preliminary submission No.1 is
reproduced hereinbelow:-
“...Thereafter, the widening of the above said road has been done
by the PWD Department in the year 1992 as well as in the year
2000 and 2016….”
17. The fact that the petitioners were the owners of the land, which
has been stated in the writ petition was not disputed and even the fact that
the petitioners had applied under the Right to Information Act, and the
response thereto was also not disputed. The respondents relied upon
Annexure R-1 and R-2, which are the documents which showed that the road
was widened, as has been averred by the respondents in the written
statement. Respondent No.3, Deputy Commissioner, Kurukshetra also filed
an additional affidavit dated 19.11.2025, in which affidavit the respondents
placed reliance upon the Jamabandi for the year 2020–21, which clearly
showed that the entire Khasra No., i.e., 204/4, was measuring 19 Kanal 16
Marlas, and out of the same, 5 Kanal 0 Marlas was recorded as “Gair
Mumkin Sadak”. Thus, from the revenue record, which has been relied upon
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 14
by the respondent State itself, it is apparent that the land owned by the
petitioners was presently occupied by the said road.
FACTS OF THE CASE IN CWP-1511-2023:
18. The case of Gurpreet Kaur, who has filed CWP No.1511 of
2023, when briefly put, is similar to the case as set forth in the case of Malik
Singh Kang and others i.e., CWP No. 16690 of 2022. The said Gurpreet
Kaur has averred, that, Tej Pratap was the owner of land measuring 7 Kanal
2 Marlas comprised in Khasra No.204/5, situated in Village Darra Kalan,
Tehsil Thanesar, District Kurukshetra, in addition to other land. It was
further the case of the said petitioner Gurpreet Kaur that Tej Pratap Singh
had died in the year 1971, and his share in Khasra No. 204/5 was mutated in
favour of his daughters, namely Ravinder Kaur and Jasjeet Kaur, and after
the death of Ravinder Kaur, her share was transferred in equal proportion in
favour of Charanjit Singh Gill, Ranvijay Singh, being the sons, and Gurpreet
Kaur, being the daughter of Ravinder Kaur. The said aspect was specifically
pleaded in para 2 and 3 of the writ petition, which has not been denied in
the written statement filed by the respondents in the said case.
19. It was further the case of the petitioner that an application for
demarcation was made on 22.03.2021 by the petitioner and the Tehsildar,
Thanesar, vide report dated 30.03.2021, had submitted a detailed
demarcation report with respect to Khasra No.204/5. The said demarcation
report has been annexed as Annexure R-1 (page 145/147 of the paper book)
and a perusal of the same would show that the demarcation had been duly
carried out. The relevant portion of the said demarcation report is
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 15
reproduced hereinbelow:-
“Report of demarcation proceeding as L/C as ordered by Tehsildar
Thanesar dated 30.03.2021
Village Darra Kalan (Thanesar) Tehsil Thanesar, District
Kurukshetra Khasra no. 204/5 (7K-2M)
Today, a demarcation was carried out as per order of the
Tehsildar Thanesar dated 30-3-2021 on the application of Sh.
Dalbir Singh s/o Ravinder Singh as per programme at reached at
Village Darra Kalla (Thanesar), Satbir Singh Patwari Halqa, found
present on the site with revenue records and measuring equipment.
The list of persons present on the site is attached on a separate
paper. The concerned parties for the demarcation have already
been informed through the Halqa Patwari. The notice of
information is also attached, After this, because there are no
survey points etc. around this land as per revenue records and this
land is adjacent to the railway line, therefore with the help of
railway department officials and employees, the railway tracks
point which is shown as point "A" in the computer generated map
and the second railway track point which is shown as point "B" in
the map, were measured using GPS machine by measuring all
around the Khasra no. 204/5 and marking boundary points. After
demarcation it was found that in the eastern direction of Khasra
number 204/5, a permanent boundary wall is built along the
railway line, which is correct in its place. In the western direction
of Khasra number, there is permanent road of P.W.D. in area of
409 sq. meters rakba 0K-16M and a footpath in eastern direction
of the road in ares of 724 sq meters rakba 1K-9M and in the
remaining rakba 4K-17M of Khasra number 204/5 a market has
been built, the computer generated map of which is attached. No
objection was raised on the site during the demarcation. Fees of
Rs.4000/- were received in cash from the applicant and a receipt
was given.
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 16
After completion, original report along with notice and other
documents, it is sent to Tehsildar Thanesar for information and
further necessary action.
Sd/-
Kgo Rtd.
L/C 3/9/21”
20. A perusal of the said demarcation report and the attendance
sheet would show that the said demarcation had been carried out in
pursuance of the order passed by the Tehsildar, Thanesar, and it was carried
out in the presence of 12 persons, including Devi Dayal, Road Mate, PWD
Shahabad; Raghbir Singh, Beldar, PWD Shahabad; Budh Ram, Beldar,
PWD Shahabad; J.K. Arora, Senior Section Engineer, Railway Line Kaithal;
Vijay Kumar, JE, Railway Department Kurukshetra; Satbir Singh, Patwari
Halqa; and Suresh Kumar, DGPS Machine Operator, who had duly signed
the said report (page 148 of the paper book). In the said demarcation report
also, it has been stated that notice was given to the parties by the Halqa
Patwari and even the Railway Department officials were present and the
railway tracks from point A to point B were duly established, and the
measurement of the same was carried out by using the DGPS machine, and
that the PWD Department had made a permanent road in an area measuring
409 square meters (0 Kanal 16 Marlas), and had also paved a footpath
measuring 724 square meters (1 Kanal 9 Marlas) in Khasra No.204//5. It was
noted that no objection was raised on the site during the demarcation. Thus,
from the said demarcation report, which was prepared in the presence of
several officials including the ones from the PWD Department, it was found
that land measuring 2 Kanal 5 Marlas comprising in Khasra No. 204/5 had
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 17
been used by the respondent department in constructing the road.
Admittedly, the present petitioner is a co-sharer in the said land.
21. It is the case of the petitioner that in pursuance of the said
demarcation, the petitioner for the first time learnt that the respondents had
used the land which was owned by the petitioner along with other co-shares
for the purpose of making the said road and neither the said land had been
acquired nor any compensation had been given to the petitioner for the same.
Legal pleas as have been raised in the other writ petition are raised in the
present writ petition also.
22. After the issuance of notice of motion, written statement dated
20.11.2025 was filed on behalf of respondents no.1 and 2 in which similar
pleas, as has been taken in the reply filed in CWP-16690-2023, were taken.
Even in the written statement filed in the case of Gurpreet Kaur, it was stated
that forefathers of the petitioner along with other villagers, with their free
will and consent, had given the land in question to the respondent
authorities, for the purpose of constructing the road and that the said
forefathers were aware of the acquisition since the year 1974-75. The fact
that the PWD Department had widened the said road in the year 1992, 2000
as well as 2016 was reiterated in the said written statement. The ownership
of the petitioner was not disputed and in fact along with the written
statement, jamabandi for the year 2020-21 (Annexure R-9) was annexed in
which the ownership of Gurpreet Kaur was reflected. It would be relevant to
note that the pleas raised in the said written statement were self
contradictory in as much as on the one hand the respondent authorities had
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 18
stated that the land of the petitioner was taken after obtaining the consent of
the forefathers of petitioner and on the other hand, the aspect that some part
of land comprised in khasra no.204/5 was actually taken for the purpose of
constructing the road was being contested. On 19.11.2025, an additional
affidavit was filed by Vishram Kumar Meena, Deputy Commissioner,
Kurukshetra, who admitted the fact that the demarcation report dated
03.09.2021 had been prepared but has further stated that the letter dated
03.02.2025 was written by the Executive Engineer to the Deputy
Commissioner, Kurukshetra against the demarcation report dated
03.09.2021. It is thus apparent that, after a period of more than 3 years and 5
months and after filing of the present writ petition, which was filed in the
year 2023, the respondents are trying to wriggle out of the said demarcation
report. It was not the case of the respondents that they had acquired the land
and paid the compensation to the petitioners in either of the two writ
petitions.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS:
23. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners in CWP-16690-2023
as well as learned counsel for the petitioner in CWP-1511-2023 have
submitted that it is proved beyond doubt that the petitioners are the owners
of the land in question which has been used by the respondent authorities for
the purpose of construction of the road without acquiring the land of the
petitioners and without paying them any compensation. It is submitted that
the said act of the respondents is in violation of the constitutional right of the
petitioners under Article 300A of the Constitution of India and in support of
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 19
their arguments, learned senior counsel for the petitioners has relied upon
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Vidya Devi vs.
State of Himchal Pradesh and others reported as (2020) 2 Supreme Court
Cases 569; Sukh Dutt Ratra and another vs. State of Himchal Pradesh and
others reported as (2022) 7 Supreme Court Cases 508; Abdul Rashid Wani
vs. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir and others reported as 2026 Law
Finder (SC) 5218. It is further submitted that the act and conduct of the
respondent authorities in the present cases is contumacious as they were
playing hide and seek with respect to the demarcation report which the
respondent authorities were required to place on record but chose not to
place on record. It is jointly prayed that in the said circumstances, the writ
petitions filed by the petitioners be allowed and the respondents be either
directed to return the land of the petitioners or the petitioners should be
compensated as per the provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
2013.
ARGUMENTS ON BEAHLF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
24. Learned counsel for the respondent-State, on the other hand, has
submitted that in the present case, it is the specific stand of the respondents
that the road in question was constructed in the year 1974-75 with the
consent of the forefathers of the petitioners with free will who had given the
said land without seeking any compensation and the petitioners have woken
up after several decades to claim compensation, which claim deserves to be
rejected solely on the ground of delay and latches. Learned counsel for the
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 20
respondents in support of his arguments, has relied upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Maharashtra vs. Digambar
reported as 1995(4) SCC 683. It is further submitted that a perusal of the sale
deed which has been annexed as Annexure R-4 dated 15.06.1970 and
Annexure R-6 dated 11.07.1974 annexed with reply filed in CWP-16690-
2023 would show that the petitioners and their forefathers were aware of the
fact that there was a road which was in existence and the petitioners had not
approached the Court within a reasonable time in spite of having knowledge
of the said road having been there and thus, their case deserves to be
dismissed solely on the ground of delay and latches.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
(i) WITH RESPECT TO CWP-16690-2023
25. The fact that six petitioners in CWP-16690-2023 are owners of
the land measuring 19 kanal 12 marlas (approximately) out of land
measuring 19 kanals 16 marlas situated in khasra no.204/4 in village Darar
Kalan, Tehsil Thanesar, District Kurukshetra is not disputed. Specific
averments with respect to the individual ownership of the petitioners have
been made in the writ petition which aspect has also not been disputed and
moreover, the respondents in their affidavit dated 19.11.2025 have placed on
record the jamabandi for the year 2020-21 (page 165 of the paper book)
rd
which clearly shows that petitioner no.1 has 1/3 share in the land
measuring 19 kanal 16 marlas comprised in khasra no.204/4 and similarly
rd
petitioners no.2 to 4 also jointly have 1/3 share in the said land, whereas
petitioners no.4 and 5 together have 1159/3564 share in the khasra no.204/4.
The further fact that a substantial part of the land out of the said land has
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 21
been utilized by the respondents for the purpose of construction of the road
i.e., Kurukshetra to Jhansa Road is also not in dispute. The jamabandi for the
years 2020-21 shows that 5 kanals out of the said land is recorded to be Gair
Mumkin Sadak. Presumption of truth is attached to the jamabandi. The said
document at page no. 165 of the paperbook has been annexed by the
respondent State itself and it is not even remotely the plea of the respondent-
State that entries in the same are incorrect. From the said jambanadi, it is
clear that 5 kanal of the land, in which the petitioners are majority share
holders, has been utilized by the respondent-State. The same has been done
without acquiring the land in question and without paying any compensation
to the petitioners.
26. Additionally, when the present writ petition had come up for
hearing, the Co-ordinate Division Bench, vide order dated 03.08.2023,
which order has been reproduced in the earlier part of the present judgment,
had directed a demarcation to be carried and to be placed on record. The
demarcation was carried out, which aspects have also been detailed
hereinabove, and a demarcation report dated 22.08.2023 was prepared and as
per the same it was found that 2 kanals 19 marlas of land out of khasra
no.204/4 had been utilized by the PWD department for the construction of
the road. Although on the basis of the revenue record, regarding which there
is a presumption of truth, it was open to the petitioners to have pursued their
prayer for compensation of their share in 5 kanal land comprised in khasra
no.204/4, but on behalf of the petitioners, a very fair stand has been taken to
the effect that they would abide by the finding in the demarcation report,
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 22
which had been carried out in pursuance of the orders passed by the Co-
ordinate Division Bench. The said stand taken on behalf of the petitioners is
appreciated. Thus, it is claimed by the petitioners that either land measuring
2 kanal 19 marlas be returned or compensation under the 2013 Act with
respect to the said land be paid to the petitioners.
27. It is not the case of the respondents that the said land of the
petitioners was acquired or any compensation was paid to the petitioners.
The plea raised on behalf of the respondents to the effect that there was an
oral consent given by the forefathers of the petitioners, without there being
any written document executed by the predecessor-in-interest of the
petitioners or by the other land owners, has no legal basis and deserves to be
rejected, which aspect would be detailed hereinafter. It is the case of the
respondents that the road was widened in the years 1992, 2000 as well as
2016 and thus, the argument raised on behalf of the respondents to the effect
that at every stage they have been taking oral consent, apart from not being
substantiated, is not believable.
28. The stand of the respondents to the effect that, since there were
certain sale deeds executed by the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners
showing that the petitioners were aware of the fact that there was
Kurukshetra to Jhansa road constructed and thus, the cases of the petitioners
deserve to be rejected on the ground of delay and laches, is also
misconceived. Specific reference has been made on behalf of the
respondents to the two sale deeds (Annexures R-4 and R-6). A perusal of
Annexure R-4 (page 114) would show that the same refers to a plot sold by
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 23
the father of petitioner no.1 and does not refer to any khasra number, much
less khasra no.204/4. It has been mentioned in the said sale deed that on the
eastern side of the plot, there is Jhansa road. The said sale deed does not
even remotely show that the father of petitioner no.1 had admitted the fact
that the respondents had constructed the road on khasra no.204/4 and rather
indicates that the plot, which the father of the petitioner no.1 had sold was
bounded by the road on the eastern side, which would necessarily mean that
the road was not a part of the property of the father of the petitioner and at
best was abutting the same. Further a perusal of the sale deed 11.07.1974
(Annexure R-6) which is also relied upon by the respondents would show
that no reference to any khasra number, much less khasra no.204/4, has been
made in the same and while depicting the boundaries of the plot which was
sold, it has been stated that the same is situated “near Jhansa Road”. The
recital of the said sale deed, instead of furthering the case of the respondents,
in fact furthers the case of the petitioners to the effect that the said Jhansa
road is near the plot owned by the father of petitioner no.1 and does not in
any way indicate that the father of petitioner no.1 had knowledge, to the
effect that the road had been constructed on a part of the land owned by him
in khasra no.204/4.
29. The prayer for dismissal of the writ petition on the ground of
delay and laches raised on behalf of the respondents also deserves to be
rejected. In the written statement filed by the respondents, it is the case of
the respondents themselves that the road was widened in the year 1992,
thereafter in the year 2000 and again in the year 2016. A perusal of the map
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 24
annexed as Annexure A-3, Page 19 of the CM-11273-CWP-2025, which
forms a part of the demarcation report dated 22.03.2023, would show that
khasra no.204/4 is situated in such a manner that the encroachment by the
respondent-State, in all probability, would have occurred, when the last
widening of the road would have been done. Moreover, the respondents have
not been able to highlight any specific overt act/incident to show that the
petitioners, who are co-sharers in a large tract of land, had knowledge that
some part of the land owned by them, has been utilized for the purpose of
the construction of road.
30. Further, the facts which have been highlighted before this Court
on behalf of the writ petitioners would clearly show that the petitioners had
no knowledge about the fact that the respondents had utilized a portion of
the land owned by them for constructing the road. It is not in dispute that the
petitioners had been repeatedly filing applications for seeking demarcation,
including the application dated 15.11.2017 (Annexure P-2), 01.02.2021
(Annexure P-3), 08.06.2021 (Annexure P-4), 02.02.2022 (Annexure P-5)
and 04.03.2022 (Annexure P-6). A perusal of the said applications, would
show that it was specifically stated in the same that the petitioners were not
aware of the boundaries of their land and that as a result of the same there
was an apprehension of a dispute arising and had also further raised the plea
that certain persons were trying to trespass on the land in question and thus,
had prayed that demarcation be done for which they were ready to pay the
necessary fee. It is also undisputed that when the said applications were not
allowed, petitioner No.2 had filed CWP-10688-2022 titled as “Aman
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 25
Bahadur Singh Kang Versus State of Haryana and another” in which one of
the main prayers was to seek a direction to the respondents to take
appropriate steps in a time bound manner to demarcate the land in question.
31. It is the case of the petitioners that, it is only when the written
statement dated 25.07.2022 was filed by the respondents in the said writ
petition, the petitioners for the first time learnt that the road had been
constructed on the khasra number which was owned by the petitioners i.e.
204/4. The present writ petition had been thereafter filed in the year 2023
after collecting information under the RTI Act, which information was partly
supplied vide letter dated 24.05.2023 (Annexure P-14). Thus in the
abovesaid facts and circumstances, we are of the opinion that the writ
petition filed by the petitioners does not deserve to be dismissed on the
ground of delay and laches, more so in view of the law which has been
considered in detail hereinafter, and rather the petitioners are entitled to
compensation, which aspect would also be considered in detail hereinafter.
(ii) WITH RESPECT TO CWP-1511-2023
32. There is no dispute with respect to the fact that petitioner-
Gurpreet Kaur in CWP-1511-2023 has a share in Khasra No.204/5 (7 kanal-
2 marla). The averments made regarding ownership in paragraphs 2 and 3 of
the said writ petition have not been disputed in the written statement.
Moreover, the jamabandi (Annexure R-9) (page 82 of the paper book),
which has been placed on record by the respondents clearly reflects the share
of the said petitioner in the abovesaid khasra number i.e. 204/5. The
demarcation dated 03.09.2021 (Annexure R-1), relevant portion of which
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 26
has been reproduced hereinabove, was duly carried out in pursuance of the
order of the Tehsildar and was in the presence of 12 persons including
several officials including the officials from the PWD Department, Railway
Department as well as the Revenue Officers i.e. the Patwari and the
Kanungo, as well as the GPS Machine Operator and the demarcation report,
clearly shows that the land measuring 2 kanals and 5 marlas out of Khasra
No.204/5 (7 kanal-2 marla) had been encroached upon by the respondent-
State for the purpose of constructing the road and a footpath.
33. The stand of the respondents to question the said demarcation
report on the basis of the letter dated 03.02.2025, after a lapse of more than
3½ years and after notice of motion had been issued in the writ petition, in
the year 2023, is apparently an attempt to deny the rightful claim of the
petitioner. Moreover, the pleas raised in the written statement by the State
are self-contradictory. On the one hand, the respondents have taken the plea
that the land in question of the petitioner, along with other landowners, was
utilized on the basis of consent taken from the forefathers of the petitioner,
and on the other hand, the respondents are now trying to deny the fact that
they had taken the said land. The plea for dismissal of the writ petition on
the ground of delay and laches taken by the respondents deserves to be
rejected on the same basis as in the case of Malik Singh Kang, which has
been noted hereinabove and also in view of the law, detail reference of
which has been made hereinafter. Moreover, even in the case of Gurpreet
Kaur, the respondents have taken the plea in the written statement to the
effect that the road was widened in the year 1992, 2000 as well as in 2016.
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 27
Aditionally, it would be relevant to note that it is the case of the petitioner
that she learnt about the encroachment for the first time after the land was
demarcated and the demarcation report dated 03.09.2021 was prepared.
(iii) CONSIDERATION OF THE PROVISIONS OF LAW AND THE LEGAL
PRECEDENTS:
34. Having considered the facts of both the cases, we would now
enumerate the provisions of law and the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court on the basis of which, in our opinion, both the writ petitions deserve to
be allowed, in the manner detailed in the concluding part of the judgment.
35. When the Constitution came into force on 26.01.1950, the right
to property was a fundamental right, which was recognized by Article 19(1)
th
(f) and Article 31 of the Constitution of India. It was by virtue of the 44
Amendment Act, 1978 that these two Articles were repealed and a new
Article namely Article 300A was inserted. Article 300A, which was inserted,
reads as under:
“300A. Persons not to be deprived of property save by authority
of law.-
No person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of
law.”
36. A perusal of the abovesaid provision would show that no person
is to be deprived of his property except by authority of law and the right of
the individual which has been protected with respect to property is a part of
the Constitution and is thus, his constitutional right.
37. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Vidya Devi (supra),
th
had observed that even after the 44 amendment to the Constitution, the
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 28
right to property continued to be a human right as well as a constitutional
right and thus, the State could not take away the property of the citizen
without following the procedure established by law and would be under an
obligation to pay compensation, even though the same is not expressly
mentioned in Article 300A of the Constitution of India. In the said judgment,
reliance was placed upon several earlier judgments wherein it was observed
that the right to property is an indispensable safeguard against tyranny and
economic oppression by the Government and that “property must be secured
else liberty cannot subsist”. In the said case also, a plea was sought to be
raised on behalf of the State that the predecessors of the landowner had
orally consented to the acquisition, which plea was held to be completely
baseless and it was observed that the authorities had no legal sanction in
compulsorily divesting the appellant therein of her property and that in a
democratic polity governed by the rule of law, the State could not deprive a
citizen of his property without the sanction of law. The plea raised by the
State to the effect that they were in continuous possession of the land for
over 42 years and that the same tantamounted to adverse possession was also
rejected by the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the observation that State being
a welfare State cannot be permitted to take the plea of adverse possession.
38. The said case was a case in which the respondent-State had
taken over the land of the appellant therein in the year 1967-68 for the
construction of a major district road and had even completed the
construction in the year 1975 and it was only in the year 2010 that the
appellant therein had filed a writ petition seeking a direction to pay
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 29
compensation. The State had raised a strong objection with respect to the
maintainability of the writ petition on the ground of delay and laches,
contending that the road was constructed in the year 1975 and a further
objection of having taken verbal consent from the predecessor-in-interest of
the appellant therein was also pressed. The High Court, in the said case, had
permitted the appellant to file a civil suit, as it was observed that there were
disputed questions of fact, on the aspect as to what was the starting point of
limitation. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, however, after holding that the right
to property was not only a constitutional right but also a human right,
observed that the cause of action in the case was a continuing one and that
the authorities had taken the property of the appellant in the year 1967
without any legal sanction or by following due process of law. Accordingly,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court set aside the judgment of the High Court and
granted compensation to the appellant therein. The law laid down in the
abovesaid judgment would apply on all fours to the facts of the present set of
cases. In fact, the facts of the present cases are on a higher footing than the
facts of the abovesaid case as in the present case, as has been detailed
hereinabove, the petitioners have approached the Court immediately on
gaining knowledge about the illegality committed by the respondent-
authorities and have been pursuing their rights diligently.
39. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of Sukh Dutt Ratra and
another (supra), while considering a case in which the High Court had
disposed of the writ petition, filed by the appellant therein, with liberty to
institute a civil suit and while considering a case in which the land had been
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 30
taken over for the construction of a road in the year 1972-73 had granted
relief in the writ petition filed by the appellant therein, in the year 2011 and
had set aside the order of the High Court. In the said case, a plea was raised
on behalf of the State that there was an inordinate delay of 38 years in filing
the writ petition and a further delay of six years in approaching the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. A further objection was raised on behalf of the State to the
effect that the landowners had given a verbal consent for voluntarily giving
up their land. Reference to the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of State of Maharashtra Versus Digambar (supra) was also made in
the said judgment, reliance on which has been placed by the learned State
counsel before us. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, after considering all the
aspects, observed that the State cannot in such a situation, shield itself
behind the ground of delay and laches. The plea of taking verbal consent
was rejected on the ground that no material had been placed on record to
substantiate the said plea and that in the absence of written consent to
voluntarily give up their land, the appellants therein were held entitled to
compensation in terms of law. The judgment in the case ofVidya Devi
(supra) was reiterated and the relief was granted to the appellant therein.
40. The law laid down in the abovesaid judgment also applies on all
fours to the facts of the present set of cases. Moreover, the plea sought to be
raised on behalf of the respondents before us with respect to verbal consent
deserves to be rejected in view of the facts and circumstances detailed
hereinabove and also in view of the law laid down in the abovesaid
judgment as well as in the case of Vidya Devi (supra).
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 31
41. Three Judges Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its latest
judgment in the case of Abdul Rashid Wani (supra), while dealing with a
case in which the land was acquired for the construction of a Police Station
in the year 1953 and where the appellant before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
had slept over his rights for a period of 68 years and had only made
representation in the year 2020 and thereafter had filed the writ petition,
which was dismissed on the ground of delay and acquiescence, had partly
allowed the appeal and had set aside the impugned order passed by the High
Court and for the purpose of assessing the amount payable to the appellant
therein, had remitted the matter, after observing that once the respondent-
State had admitted that the land was utilized for a public purpose without
acquiring the same, then, it is imperative that the due amount of
compensation be paid to the landowners and that the respondents need to be
sensitive towards the constitutional rights of the landowners, as the private
property of the said landowners cannot be taken over without following the
prescribed procedure of law. In the said case, no plea was raised on behalf of
the appellant therein to highlight as to why a delay of 68 years was caused in
approaching the Court. The facts in the present set of cases are on a higher
footing than the facts in the abovesaid case.
42. The Constitutional Bench of Five Hon’ble Judges of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of K.T. Plantation Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. Vs.
State of Karnataka reported as 2011(4) SCC (Civil) 414, has observed that
public purpose is a pre-condition for deprivation of a person from his
property under Article 300A of the Constitution of India and the right to
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 32
claim compensation is also inbuilt in the said Article.
43. Reliance sought to be placed by learned counsel for the State on
the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Maharashtra Versus Digambar (supra) would not further the case of the
respondents in the present set of cases and would not call for dismissal of the
present writ petitions. The facts of the said case are clearly distinguishable
from the facts of the present set of cases. In para 2 of the said judgment, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court had noted that in the year 1971-72, there were acute
scarcity conditions prevalent in nearly 23,000 villages of the State of
Maharashtra and large scale scarcity relief works had to be undertaken by
the State Government to provide employment to small agriculturists for the
purpose of their livelihood and such relief work included the construction of
38000 kilometres of road works. It was further noticed that as the State
Government was not in a position to divert relief funds at its disposal for
payment of compensation for lands to be utilised for the purpose of the road,
thus, the Collectors, who were in-charge of the said works, were instructed
not to accord sanction to them without ensuring that they did not involve any
payment of compensation by the Government and special instructions were
passed to the Collectors to impress upon the non-official and other social
workers to use their good offices in ensuring that the land required for such
scarcity relief works were donated to the Government without any claim for
compensation. It is in the said background that the judgment was passed in
the abovesaid case. In the present case, no such case has been set up by the
respondents and only a vague plea with respect to verbal consent without
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 33
specifying any further details has been taken in the written statement.
44. In the said case, it was additionally noticed that as many as 191
writ petitions were filed after the work had been undertaken and had been
completed in the year 1972. The State liability was stated to be more than
400 crores if all the said writ petitions were entertained. The said figure was
noticed in the judgment passed in the year 1995. In the said backdrop, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court had observed that the writ petition filed under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, which is a discretionary relief,
should be entertained only if the High Court is satisfied that the facts and
circumstances of the case justified the delay or laches in approaching the
Court. Importantly, it was noticed that the counsel for the writ petitioners
who were respondents before the Hon'ble Supreme Court and other similarly
concerned persons did not even choose to address any argument supporting
the view of the High Court to the effect that the High Court, under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, could grant relief to a person without
examining the question of delay and laches on his part. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court took note of the fact that even the averments made on behalf
of the writ petitioners was to the effect that certain extent of land had been
taken away in the year 1971-72 by the agency of the State for the scarcity
relief road works undertaken by the State Government in the year 1971-72 to
find work for small agriculturists and agricultural labourers in the then
prevailing severe drought conditions, and thus from the said averments
made, the plea raised by the respondent State stood substantiated. It was
observed that no attempt had been made by the writ petitioners who were
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 34
respondents before the Hon’ble Supreme Court to explain their conduct with
respect to undue delay and laches, and thus the Hon'ble Supreme Court came
to the conclusion that the delay had not been satisfactorily explained, and the
facts and circumstances suggested that there had been acquiescence for
acquisition without compensation.
45. As has been noticed hereinabove, the facts of the present set of
cases are on a completely different footing and the petitioners had
immediately approached this Court on gaining knowledge of the illegality
committed by the State. Moreover, even as per the stand of the respondents,
the widening of the road was also done in the year 2016. From the facts and
circumstances of the present set of cases, the petitioners cannot be stated to
be guilty of delay and laches in approaching the Court. Further, it is not in
dispute that in addition to the land which has been utilized by the State
comprised in Khasra No.204/4 and Khasra No.204/5, the petitioners have
other land in the said Khasra numbers, and thus they continue to be co-
sharers with respect to the land comprised in the said Khasra numbers, and
the present case is not a case where the entire landholding of the petitioners
has been taken and the possession from the petitioners has been taken on a
particular date.
46. Thus, keeping in view the abovesaid facts and circumstances,
we are of the opinion that both the writ petitions deserve to be allowed. The
next question which arises before this Court is, as to what relief the
petitioners should be granted. The prayer made by the petitioners for return
of the land cannot possibly be granted as the road is already in existence and
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 35
the petitioners have very fairly not pressed the said prayer. Although on
behalf of the petitioners, at one stage, it was urged that the respondents be
directed to acquire the land in accordance with the provision of the 2013 Act
and the petitioners be also paid additional benefits from the date the road
was constructed till the time the payment is made, but in view of the law laid
down by this Court in CWP-17369-2001 titled as “Bhupal Sharma vs. State
of Haryana and another” and connected matters, a very fair stand has been
taken on behalf of the petitioners and the petitioners have stated that they
would be satisfied in case the relief is granted to the petitioners on the same
lines as has been granted in the said judgment.
(iv) CONCLUSION:
47. Keeping in view the above said facts and circumstances, the
present writ petitions are disposed of with the following observations/
directions:-
i) As per the jamabandi for the year 2020-21 (Annexure R-1 page
165 of CWP-16690-2023) which has been appended by the
respondent-State, land measuring 5 kanals out of 19 kanals 16
marlas comprised in khasra no.204/4 is stated to have been
utilized for the purpose of gair mumkin sadak but in view of the
demarcation report dated 22.08.2023 which had been carried out
in pursuance of the order dated 03.08.2023 passed by the Co-
ordinate Division Bench, the land of the petitioners in CWP-
16690-2023 which has been utilized by the respondent-State for
the purpose of making the road etc. is stated to be 2 kanals 19
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 36
marlas. A very fair statement has been made on behalf of the
petitioners, as has been noticed hereinabove, to the effect that they
would claim compensation to the extent of their share in 2 kanals
19 marlas and not 5 kanals, as they stand by the demarcation
report. The petitioners in CWP-16690-2023 are thus held entitled
accordingly.
ii) With respect to CWP-15112-2023 keeping in view the
demarcation report dated 03.09.2021 (Annexure R-1) (page 147)
in CWP-1511-2023 and the facts and circumstances detailed
hereinabove, the land which has been utilized by the respondent-
State without paying any compensation is held to be 2 kanals 5
marlas out of the total land measuring 7 kanals 2 marals
comprised in khasra no.204/5.
iii) The respondents-State, after granting an opportunity of hearing to
the petitioners/their authorized representatives, within a period of
three months from today, after seeing the latest revenue record,
would find out the exact share of the petitioners in the abovesaid
land in both the writ petitions. Needless to say that since
admittedly no partition has been effected, the share of the
petitioners in the abovesaid land would be proportionate to their
share in the entire khasra numbers i.e. Khasra No.204/4 (19-16)
and Khasra No.204/5 (7-2). The same can be best explained by
giving an example. In case the petitioners in CWP-16690-2023
are found to be owners of 19 kanals 12 marlas (392 marlas) out of
total land measuring 19 kanals 16 marals (396 marlas), then the
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 37
share of the said petitioners in the land measuring 2 kanal 19
marals (59 marlas) would be 392/396 X 59 = X marlas. It is for
the land (X marlas) that the respondents would be liable to pay
compensation to the petitioners as per the directions given by this
Court.
iv) In proviso to Section 26(1) of the 2013 Act, it has been stated that
the date to be taken for determination of the market value of the
land shall be the date on which the Notification has been issued
under Section 11 of the 2013 Act. In the present case, the date for
determination of the market value shall be the date on which the
present judgment has been passed.
v) On account of fair concession made on behalf of the petitioners, it
is ordered that the Collector’s rate, which is prevalent on the date
of the present judgment with respect to the land in question,
would be taken as the market value of the land in question.
vi) The solatium, as stated in Section 30 of the 2013 Act, would be
equivalent to 100% of the amount assessed under the abovesaid
directions i.e., the market value of the land in question.
vii) 12% rate of interest, as provided under Sub Section (3) of Section
30 of 2013 Act, would be paid to the petitioners from the date of
the present judgment until the amount is actually paid.
viii) It has been agreed that no other aspect is to be taken into
consideration before assessing the final compensation.
ix) Since all the factors stand crystallized, the respondents are
directed to ascertain the amount of compensation within a period
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh

CWP Nos.16690 and 1511 of 2023 (O&M) 38
of five months from today and make payment to the petitioner(s)
within a further period of one month from the date of the said
assessment i.e., within a period of six months from today.
x) The petitioners, as agreed before this Court, would execute a
registered sale deed in favour of the State of Haryana with respect
to their shares, which have been found under direction No.iii, at
the time of receiving the said compensation. The same is done to
avoid unnecessary cost and effort in carrying out the acquisition
proceedings.
xi) Further, as has been stated before this Court, the petitioners would
not claim any other amount from the respondent-State with
respect to the road in question, which has already been
constructed.
xii) Learned senior counsel/counsel for the petitioners have further
fairly stated that the compensation, which would be assessed on
the basis of the directions given by this Court, would be accepted
by the petitioners with no further challenge to the same.
(VIKAS BAHL)
JUDGE
th
November 16 , 2026 (DIVYA SHARMA)
Puneet/pawan/davinder JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : Yes
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.11.21 12:42
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh