State Of Tamil Nadu vs State Of Karnataka

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 1257
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

MISC.APPLICATION NO.2445 OF 2026
IN
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2453 of 2007

STATE OF TAMIL NADU ...APPLICANT (S)
VERSUS
STATE OF KARNATAKA & ORS. ...RESPONDENT(S)

WITH
MISC.APPLICATION D. NO.46291 OF 2026
IN
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2453 of 2007

AND WITH
MISC.APPLICATION NO.2843 OF 2026
IN
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2453 of 2007



J U D G M E N T

VIKRAM NATH, J.
MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO.2445 OF 2026 IN
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 2453 of 2007

1. The present application has been filed by the State of
Signature Not Verified
Tamil Nadu seeking, inter alia , the following reliefs: -
Digitally signed by
SONIA BHASIN
Date: 2026.11.21
11:49:26 IST
Reason:
“i. direct State of Karnataka to implement the
decision of CWMA dated 30.07.2026 and ensure
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
1

release of waters from its two reservoirs at Kabini
and KRS so as to ensure flows at the rate of 3500
cusecs for 15 days, that is, 4.536 TMC, is realised
at inter State Border at Billigundulu on or before
12.08.2026;
ii. direct CWMA to issue appropriate direction to
State of Karnataka to make good the shortfall
during the current irrigation year on pro-rata basis,
at Billigundulu, for the period from 01.06.2026 to
12.08.2026 of 26.954 TMC to be released forthwith;
iii. direct CWMA to monitor the flows in the
reservoirs of Karnataka in every 10 days and issue
appropriate direction to Karnataka to ensure
stipulated monthly/ 10 daily releases at
Billigundulu as per the Findal Order of the Tribunal
as modified by this Hon’ble Court’s judgment dated
16.02.2018 during the current irrigation year;
iv. pass such further Order or any other Orders that
this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and appropriate in
the circumstances of the case.”


2. The inter-State water-sharing dispute involving the
riparian States of Karnataka, Kerala and Tamil Nadu,
and the Union Territory of Puducherry, was
th
adjudicated by this Court vide judgment dated 16
February, 2018, in The State of Karnataka by its
Chief Secretary vs. State of Tamil Nadu by its Chief
1
Secretary and Others .” The said judgment
determined various issues concerning the sharing of
Cauvery River waters among the riparian States and
the Union Territory.

1
(2018) 4 SCC 1.
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
2

3. To facilitate the implementation of the award of the
Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal (“Tribunal”), as
modified by this Court, the Union of India notified the
st
Cauvery Water Management Scheme on 1 June, 2018.
The Scheme established the Cauvery Water
Management Authority (hereinafter, “CWMA”) and the
Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (hereinafter,
“CWRC”) to oversee and regulate the implementation of
the water-sharing arrangements.
4. The CWMA has, from time to time, taken decisions to
facilitate effective compliance with and implementation
of the Tribunal’s award. In view of the rainfall deficit
during the current irrigation year, the applicant-State
th
of Tamil Nadu, by a letter dated 14 July, 2026,
requested the Chairman of the CWMA to issue
appropriate directions to the respondent-State of
Karnataka to release water forthwith from its reservoirs
to make good the shortfall.
th

5. At its 54th meeting, held on 30 July, 2026, the CWMA
reviewed the hydro-meteorological conditions
prevailing in the Cauvery basin and considered the
recommendations of the CWRC. Upon deliberation, it
issued the following directions: -
“After detailed deliberations, the authority decided
that:
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
3

1. Member from Karnataka to ensure releases
from the Krishnaraja Sagara and Kabini
reservoirs put together so that the flows at
the rate of 3500 cusecs are realized at
Biligundulu, starting from 29.07.2026 (8:00
AM) for the next 15 days.
2. The members of the party States need to
further enhance water conservation efforts,
improve reservoir management and make
judicious use of available water by
prioritizing the releases for meeting, drinking
water, industrial and environmental flow
requirements only.”
6. Against the aforesaid factual backdrop, the applicant-
State of Tamil Nadu has approached this Court seeking
appropriate directions.
7. On behalf of the applicant-State, it is contended that
even if the respondent-State of Karnataka complies
with the directions issued by the CWMA, a shortfall of
5.379 TMC would nevertheless remain. It is further
submitted that, in terms of the Central Government’s
notification dated 1st June, 2018, such a backlog ought
not to be permitted to accumulate. The applicant-State
also alleges willful non-compliance by the respondent-
State with the directions issued by the CWMA.

8. Per contra , the respondent-State of Karnataka contends
that the stipulated ten-daily and monthly releases are
not inflexible, and that any shortfall arising during a
particular week or month may be carried forward and
adjusted in subsequent months, up to the end of the
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
4

season in January. It is further submitted that, in a
year of distress, the obligations arising under this
th
Court’s judgment dated 16 February, 2018, may be
proportionately reduced, and that the present year
admittedly falls within that category.
9. Having considered the rival submissions, we are of the
view that the present application is misconceived,
particularly when the expert body entrusted with
monitoring and regulating the release of Cauvery
waters is already seized of the matter.
10. The respondent-State of Karnataka has categorically
stated in its short-reply affidavit that, although there
was initially a shortfall in the release of water, the
deficit was made good once the Wayanad region
received adequate rainfall. In this regard, the
respondent-State submits that it released 1,65,080
cusecs of water from its reservoirs. While fairly
acknowledging a delay of two days in complying with
the directions issued by the CWMA, the respondent-
State contends that the prescribed releases were
subsequently achieved, with a flow of 86,797 cusecs
recorded at Billigundulu, as against the stipulated
release of 45,500 cusecs under the directions issued by
th th 2
the CWMA at its 54 meeting held on 30 July, 2026.

2
Paragraphs 5 & 6 of the Short reply filed by State of Karnataka, being No. 240183
of 2026.
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
5

This position has also been fairly acknowledged by the
applicant-State of Tamil Nadu in its response to the
short-reply affidavit filed by the respondent-State.
11. The release schedule operates on an annual cycle from
June to May. In these circumstances, the apprehension
expressed by the applicant-State of Tamil Nadu that its
annual allocation of water may not be met appears
premature. This is particularly so when both the CWMA
and the CWRC comprise representatives of the States
of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka. We find it difficult to
accept that the concerns of the applicant-State would
be disregarded by these expert bodies, which have been
constituted to secure compliance with and
implementation of the final judgment of this Court.
12. It is also pertinent to note that, as fairly admitted by
both parties, the CWRC has been convening meetings
every fifteen days to review the prevailing situation,
hear the parties concerned, and issue appropriate
directions in light of the circumstances obtaining at the
relevant time.
13. By instituting the present application, the applicant-
State seeks, in effect, to draw this Court into the
continuing process of monitoring and enforcing the
release schedule, a function entrusted to the CWMA
and the CWRC under the Scheme framed pursuant to
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
6

th
this Court’s judgment dated 16 February, 2018. By
the said judgment, this Court modified the Tribunal’s
th
award dated 5 February, 2007, and specifically
directed the Union of India to frame a Scheme to
facilitate compliance with and implementation of the
judgment. The present application would, therefore,
require this Court to assume, in effect, the role of the
very authorities constituted to oversee implementation
of the water-sharing arrangements. Such a course
would be neither warranted nor appropriate,
particularly when the designated expert bodies remain
seized of the matter.
14. In view of the foregoing, we are not inclined to entertain
the present application. The same is, accordingly,
dismissed.
15. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. 2843 OF 2026 IN
C.A. NO. 2453 OF 2007


16. The present application has been filed by the State of
Tamil Nadu seeking, inter alia , the following reliefs: -
“a. Direct State of Karnataka to ensure and
implement the decision of CWMA dated 08.09.2026
to ensure the supply of 6,000 cusecs from
09.09.2026 to 23.09.2026;
b. Direct State of Karnataka to make good short fall
during the period of 01.06.2026 to 09.09.2026, in
the current irrigation year on pro rata basis, at
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
7

Billigundulu of 16.01 TMC be released forthwith;
and
c. pass such further order or any other orders that
this Hon’ble Court made him fit inappropriate in
the cirque stance of the case.”
th
17. Pursuant to the directions issued by the CWMA on 30
July, 2026, the respondent-State of Karnataka was
required to ensure the release of water at the rate of
th
3,500 cusecs for fifteen days commencing from 29
July, 2026. As discussed hereinabove, the respondent-
State subsequently made good the shortfall in
compliance with the said directions.
th

18. Thereafter, on 8 September, 2026, the CWMA
convened its 57th meeting to consider, inter alia , the
deficient monsoon inflows into the reservoirs in the
Cauvery basin. Upon deliberation, the CWMA took the
following decision: -
“1. The Authority has discussed the issue in detail
and taking into consideration the live storage
position of the designated reservoirs in the State of
Karnataka and Tamil Nadu, declining trend in the
gross inflows into the 04 reservoirs of Karnataka,
G&D data of the CWC site u/s of KRS and Kabini,
outlook/forecast of the rainfall activity during the
next fortnight, provided by the IMD representative
during the meeting, deficient contribution from the
un-intercepted catchment (d/s of KRS & Kabini
upto Billigundulu), requirement of Karnataka and
Tamil Nadu for meeting the respective drinking
water, industrial and environment flow
requirements during the remaining period of the
current water year 2026-27, near fag end of the
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
8

south-west monsoon, Northeast monsoon,
benefiting Tamil Nadu, more than Karnataka and
adopting Akash approach due to the IMD’s forecast
and highlighting the El Nino conditions, the
member from state of Karnataka needs to ensure
releases from its devour so that the daily average
flows at the rate of 6000 cusecs are realized at
Billigundulu, starting from 09.09.2026 (8:00 AM)
for the next 15 days.
2. The members of the party States need to further
enhance water conservation efforts, improve
reservoir management and make judicious use of
available water by prioritizing the releases for
beating drinking water, industrial and environment
flow requirements only.
3. The members of the party State/UT need to
coordinate with officers in the agriculture
department for issuing suitable advisories from
time to type for farming community to encourage
them to follow whether based advisories and adopt
suitable agriculture practices.”
19. We have heard learned senior counsel appearing for
both parties and perused the material available on
record.
20. With regard to the first prayer, the assertions advanced
by the applicant-State of Tamil Nadu have been
categorically disputed by the respondent-State of
Karnataka. The respondent-State has further
submitted that it has complied with the directions
th
issued by the CWMA on 8 September, 2026, and has
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
9

released a quantity of water in excess of that stipulated
3
therein.
21. As regards the second prayer, the alleged shortfall and
its quantification involve an assessment of distress and
the flows across the entire Cauvery basin, which fall
within the domain of the CWRC and the CWMA. The
said authorities have been constituted precisely for this
purpose and are entrusted with examining such issues,
taking into account the prevailing hydrological
conditions and the framework governing the sharing of
Cauvery waters. This Court having already determined
the inter-State allocation and the governing principles
for such sharing, we do not consider it appropriate to
issue a separate direction to either State on the basis
of the disputed calculations placed before us. The
matter shall, accordingly, be left to be considered by the
CWRC and the CWMA in accordance with law.
22. Lastly, learned senior counsel appearing for the
applicant-State of Tamil Nadu contended that its
concerns regarding the shortfall in water releases at
Billigundulu were not being adequately addressed by
the CWRC and the CWMA. We are unable to accept this
st
contention. As recorded in our order dated 31 August
2026, this Court had been apprised that the CWRC

3
Paragraph 5.1.6 of Short reply filed by State of Karnataka, being No. 311335 of
2026.
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
10

convenes meetings every fifteen days and, after
reviewing the prevailing situation and hearing the
parties concerned, issues appropriate directions.
Further, we have perused the minutes of the meetings
th
of the CWRC and the CWMA held on 8 September,
2026. A perusal thereof reveals that both authorities
considered the submissions made by all the States,
including the parties herein, and specifically addressed
the grievances raised by the applicant-State of Tamil
Nadu.
4
23. The respondent-State of Karnataka in their reply filed
have specifically contended that CWMA has considered
all the flows up to four reservoirs and factored the flows
in the intermediate catchment and catchment below
the inter-State border lying in Tamil Nadu, which has
been taken note in the proceedings of each of meetings
th th th
of 30 July, 2026, 11 August, 2026, 25 August,
th th
2026, 8 September, 2026 and 24 September, 2026
held under the aegis of CWMA.
24. This is further fortified upon perusal of the minutes of
th th
58 meeting of CWMA held on 24 September, 2026.
CWMA, upon noting the submissions of Member (Water
Resources), has categorically held that it can be

4
I.A. No. 311335 of 2026.
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
11

5
concluded that there is no backlog shortfall. CWMA
thereafter issued further directions to the respondent-
State of Karnataka to ensure that the daily average
flows stipulated by this Court are maintained, with
compliance being monitored by the CWRC and the
CWMA.
25. In view of the aforesaid submissions, we are not
inclined to entertain the present application. The same
is, accordingly, dismissed.
26. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION @ DIARY NO. 46291 OF
2026 IN C.A. NO. 2453 OF 2007

27. The present miscellaneous application has been filed
by the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam in the disposed-of
civil appeal.
28. In our considered opinion, the concerns raised by the
applicant are adequately represented by the State of
th
Tamil Nadu. The scope of the award dated 5 February,
2007, passed by the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal,
as affirmed and modified by this Court vide judgment
th
dated 16 February, 2018, in Civil Appeal No. 2453 of
2007, ought not to be enlarged by entertaining and
adjudicating upon claims or objections raised by an

5 th th
Paragraph 2 on Page 12 of the Minutes of 58 meeting of CWMA held on 24
September, 2026.
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
12

applicant who was not a party to the original
proceedings before the Tribunal.
29. In view of the foregoing, we are not inclined to entertain
the present application. The same is, accordingly,
dismissed.
30. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


……………………………..J.
[VIKRAM NATH]


……………………………..J.
[APARESH KUMAR SINGH]
NEW DELHI;
NOVEMBER 20, 2026
MA NO.2445/2026 IN C.A.No.2453 of 2007 ETC.
13