YOGESH PANDEY vs STATE OF CHHATTISGARH
- Court
- Chhattisgarh High Court
Page 1 of 13
CGHC010306512022 2026:CGHC:47130
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRR No. 1008 of 2022
Reserved on: 02.09.2026
Delivered on: 16.11.2026
• Yogesh Pandey S/o Late Shri Ashok Kumar Pandey, Aged About 37
Years R/o Geetanjali City, Phase 01, House No. 16/A, Street No. 09, PS
Sarkanda, District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
... Applicant
versus
•
State of Chhattisgarh Through SHO, PS Civil Lines, Bilaspur, District :
Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
For Applicant : Mr. S.C. Verma, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Pankaj
Singh, Advocate
For State : Mrs. Supriya Upasane, Government Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas
CAV ORDER
1. The applicant has filed the present criminal revision under Section 397
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 assailing the order dated
15.07.2022 (Annexure P/1) passed by learned Special Judge
Prevention of Corruption Act, Bilaspur (C.G.) in Special Case No.
01/2022 for commission of offence punishable under Section 7 of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 arising out of final report dated
05.04.2022 in respect of FIR No. 150/2022 dated 04.02.2022
registered at PS Civil Lines, Bilaspur.
BHUMIKA
ANGARE
HIGH COURT OF
CHHATTISGARH
Page 2 of 13
2. The brief facts, as reflected from the records, are that the complainant
has lodged an FIR before the Police Station Civil Lines, Bilaspur on
04.02.2022 against the applicant for commission of offence under
Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act alleging that the
complainant is posted as Lecturer in Government School, Jaijaipur,
Rivadih and his wife Smt. Lalita Sahu was selected for the post of
Teacher and after release of the selection list, one person namely
Nandkumar Sahu who was posted in the BEO Office demanded bribe
regarding selection and posting of his wife for which they transferred
Rs. 52,000/- in cash and Rs. 33,000/- through internet banking as bribe
for getting his wife to be posted at the desired place.
3. On the basis of the FIR, the prosecution investigated the matter and
during investigation memorandum statement of co-accused
Nandkumar Sahu was recorded wherein he has stated that he is
posted as a Teacher at Bahtarai, Upper Middle School, Bilaspur and at
present he is working in B.E.O. Office, Tilak Nagar, Bilaspur. He further
stated that 15 days ago Yogesh Pandey (Teacher) called him and
came to meet in his office who told him that selection list for the
Teacher recruitment examination conducted in the year 2019 has been
released where verification and posting of the Teachers is going on. He
further stated that the applicant told him that he has some link in the
office of Joint Director, School Department who can post the
candidates according to their convenience and he will also give
commission to him. Thereafter, the co-accused got convinced and
agreed to work then he was asked to contact the candidates from the
list which was given by the applicant wherein their names and mobile
numbers were mentioned and was also asked to demand Rs. 85,000/-
out of which Rs. 5,000/- was to be given to him as commission. He
Page 3 of 13
further stated that from the given list he contacted 10-12 candidates
and when he contacted Lalita Sahu on mobile then he had
conversation with her husband (Bhupendra Sahu) whom he demanded
Rs. 85,000/- then Bhupendra Sahu gave Rs. 52,000/- as cash and Rs.
33,000/- was sent in his bank account. Similarly, he had contacted
other candidate namely Sita Sahu whose husband Durgesh Sahu gave
Rs. 65,000/- in cash and Rs. 15,000/- through Google Pay, out of the
money received from both the candidates, he gave Rs. 1 lakh to
Yogesh Pandey and kept the remaining amount of Rs. 65,000/- with
him which has been incurred and also disclosed the list.
4. Memorandum statement of the applicant was also recorded wherein he
stated that Nandkumar Sahu has given Rs. 1,00,000/- to him which
was received in the name of candidates namely Lalita Sahu resident of
Jaijaipur, Janjgir and Sita Sahu resident of Korba out of which Rs.
82,000/- has been incurred and Rs. 18,000/- is kept with him and the
same has been seized. He also stated that he has thrown the mobile
which was used while talking to Nandkumar Sahu and the prosecution
has seized list of the selected candidates from him. The prosecution
has submitted charge-sheet before the learned Special Judge
Prevention of Corruption Act on 05.04.2022 and on the basis of the
charge-sheet, charges have been framed against the applicant which
reads as under:-
^*vkius ladqy leUo;d ladqy eYVhijil fcykliqj esa f'k{kd ds in ij
yksd lsod ds :i esa dk;Zjr jgrs gq;s] fnukad 23-01-2022 ls 26-01-2022
ds e/; vius inh; drZO; ds fuoZgu esa izkFkhZ@f'kdk;rdrkZ ls mldh
iRuh ,oa vU; izkfFkZ;k lhrk lkgw ls eupkgs txg iksfLaVx djkus ds ,ot~
esa lgvfHk;qDr uan dqekj lkgw }kjk oS/k ikfjJfed ls fHkUu izkIr
85]000@& :i;s ,oa 80]000@& :i;s esa ls 1]00]000@& :i;s
LosPN;kiwoZd fj'or izkIr dj vkijkf/kd vopkj dkfjr fd;k vkSj ,slk dj
vkius og vijk/k fd;k gS] tks /kkjk 7 Hkz"Vkpkj fuokj.k vf/kfu;e 1988 ,oa
la'kks/ku vf/kfu;e 2018 ds rgr n.Muh; gSA^*
Page 4 of 13
5. Learned senior counsel for the applicant would submit that the FIR
does not contain even a whisper about the involvement of the applicant
crime in question much less any allegation of demand or acceptance of
any illegal gratification by him. He would further submit that during
investigation, neither the complainant (Bhupendra Sahu) nor the victim
(Smt. Lalita Sahu) accepted the demand and the applicant came to be
roped in the aforesaid crime on strength of the memorandum
statement of co-accused Nandkumar Sahu recorded under Section 27
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 wherein name of the applicant is
alleged to have surfaced for the first time which has no legal sanctity,
as such, the learned Special Judge should have not framed charges
under Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act. He would further
submit that neither the complainant nor the victim named the applicant
and no demand is attributed to the applicant, as such initiation of
prosecution case against him is nothing but suffers from illegality. He
would further submit that the solitary material against the applicant i.e.
the memorandum statements are inadmissible in law and stands
wholly uncorroborated and cannot be relied upon by the prosecution as
held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Dipakbhai
Jagdishchandra Patel vs. State of Gujarat reported in (2019) 16
SCC 547 , as such framing of charge against the applicant is bad in
law.
6. He would further submit that the ingredients of Section 7 of the PC Act
are conspicuously absent as from the material so collected by the
prosecution does not reflect that any demand was made by the
applicant or the amount has been accepted which is sine qua non for
involving the applicant in crime in question under Section 7 of the PC
Page 5 of 13
Act. To substantiate his submission he has referred to the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of B. Jayaraj Vs. State of Andhra
Pradesh reported in (2014) 13 SCC 55 and also in case of K.
Shanthamma Vs. State of Telangana reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC)
192 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has set-aside the conviction of
the applicant on the basis that the prosecution is unable to prove
demand and acceptance by the Government Servant which is sine qua
non for conviction under the P.C. Act. Thus, he would submit that
seizing of the money, mobile number and photocopy of the select list
are wholly innocuous as it is very much available on the internet and it
is within the public domain, as such, the framing of charge is per se
illegal. He would further submit that there is no such material on the
basis of which charge can be framed, as such framing of the charge is
nothing but abuse of process of law. To substantiate his submission, he
has referred to the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in case of Union of India Vs. Prafulla Kumar Samal reported in
( 1979) 3 SCC 4 and would pray for quashing of the charge-sheet.
7. Per contra learned counsel for the State referring to the record would
submit that the Investigating Officer has recorded the statement of
witnesses namely Bhupendra Sahu, Shivcharan Sahu. Smt. Mohar Bai
Sahu, Smt. Sita Sahu, Durgesh Sahu and Vijay Komar Som wherein
they have categorically stated that the accused persons have hatched
conspiracy and demanded money from the candidates for posting at
desired places for which they have paid money in cash as well as
through online. He would further submit that the State Government has
granted sanction to prosecute the applicant and after completing all the
requisite formalities, charge-sheet has been submitted before the
Court, and the learned trial Court on the basis of material has rightly
Page 6 of 13
framed the charge. He would further submit that the proceedings at the
stage of framing of charges, the prosecution material has to consider
the material and not the defence of the accused whereas all the
submissions advanced by the applicant is his defence which can very
well be adjudicated during the course of the trial, thus he would pray
for dismissal of the criminal revision.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record with utmost circumspection.
9. From the above submissions, the point emerged for determination by
this Court is:-
“Whether framing of charge against the applicant under
Section 7 of the PC Act which relates to public servant being
bribed is legal and justified?"
10. To appreciate this point, it is expedient for this Court to extract Section
7 of the PC Act which reads as under:-
“ 7. Offence relating to public servant being bribed - Any
public servant who,-
(a) obtains or accepts or attempts to obtain from any person,
an undue advantage, with the intention to perform or cause
performance of public duty improperly or dishonestly or to
forbear or cause forbearance to perform such duty either by
himself or by another public servant; or
(b) obtains or accepts or attempts to obtain, an undue
advantage from any person as a reward for the improper or
dishonest performance of a public duty or for forbearing to
perform such duty either by himself or another public servant;
or
(c) performs or induces another public servant to perform
improperly or dishonestly a public duty or to forbear
performance of such duty in anticipation of or in consequence
of accepting an undue advantage from any person,
shall be punishable, with imprisonment for a term which shall
not be less than three years but which may extend to seven
years and shall also be liable to fine.”
Explanation 1. - For the purpose of this section, the obtaining,
accepting, or the attempting to obtain an undue advantage
shall itself constitute an offence even if the performance of a
public duty by public servant, is not or has not been improper.
Illustration. - A public servant, 'S' asks a person, 'P' to give
him an amount of five thousand rupees to process his routine
ration card application on time. 'S' is guilty of an offence
Page 7 of 13
under this section.
Explanation 2. - For the purpose of this section,-
(i) the expressions "obtains" or "accepts" or "attempts to
obtain" shall cover cases where a person being a public
servant, obtains or "accepts" or attempts to obtain, any undue
advantage for himself or for another person, by abusing his
position as a public servant or by using his personal influence
over another public servant; or by any other corrupt or illegal
means;
(ii) it shall be immaterial whether such person being a public
servant obtains or accepts, or attempts to obtain the undue
advantage directly or through a third party.
11. From perusal of the Section 7 as amended on 26.07.2018 it is quite
vivid that the provisions under the PC Act of 1988 came to be
extensively amended by (Amendment) Act of 2018, so as to fill in the
gaps in description and coverage of offence of bribery and to bring it in
line with the current international practices and enable India to
discharge its obligations under the Convention. The Bill introduced is
intended to make the existing anti corruption laws more effective by
widening their coverage and strengthening the provisions. Section 7 of
the PC Act which covers the offence of public servant taking
gratification other than legal remuneration in respect of an official act,
came to be substituted by new comprehensive definition which covers
all aspects of passive bribery, including the solicitation and acceptance
or bribe through intermediaries and also acts of public servants acting
outside their competence. The amendment which introduced the new
definitions of bribery, both as regards the solicitation and acceptance of
undue advantage and as regards the promise, offering or giving, to a
public official, directly or indirectly, of an undue advantage, are found to
be comprehensive enough to cover all offences presently provided in
Section 8 of the PC Act, which covers taking gratification, in order, by
corrupt or illegal means, to influence public servants.
12. Further from perusal of the explanation, it is quite vivid that where a
Page 8 of 13
person being a public servant obtains or accepts or attempts to obtain
any undue advantage for himself or for any other person by abusing
his position as a public servant or by using his personal influence over
another public servant or by any other corrupt or illegal means and the
explanation further provides that if a public servant obtains or accepts
an attempt to obtain the undue advantage directly or through a third
party then act committed by the Government Servants will be offence
relating to public servant being bribed as per Section 7 of the PC Act
as amended on 26.07.2018.
13. In the light of above amended provisions with effect from 26.07.2018
and from the memorandum statement of the accused it is quite vivid
that the applicant in his memorandum statement has stated that Nand
Kumar Sahu has given One Lakh Rupees of Lalita Sahu and Savita
Sahu out of which he has made expenditure. Similarly, the other
accused Nandkumar Sahu in his memorandum statement has also
alleged about the involvement of the present applicant that he has
given the amount to the present applicant which he has received from
the teachers regarding posting as per their choice. Thus, there is prima
facie material against the applicant for framing of charges. Though, the
credibility, authenticity and correctness of the memorandum statement
is to be tested during the trial by examining the witnesses, the
submission of learned senior counsel for the applicant that the only
basis of memorandum statement of the accused the framing of charge
involving the applicant in the commission of offence under Section 7 of
the Act Prevention of Corruption Act 1988, is not sustainable and same
deserves to be rejected and accordingly it is rejected.
14. Further submission of learned Senior Counsel that since the name of
the applicant was not mentioned in the FIR, as such also framing of
Page 9 of 13
charges by the trial Court deserves to be rejected. In view of well
settled position of law that the FIR is not the encyclopedia of the crime
but, the entire charge-sheet and the material collected by the
prosecution has to be evaluated while quashing of the charge-sheet,
as such, the submission made by the learned senior counsel for the
applicant that no named FIR has been registered against the applicant
therefore, the charges should not have been framed deserves to be
rejected and accordingly it is rejected.
15. It is pertinent to mention here that Hon’ble the Supreme Court while
quashing of the FIR/investigation in case of Prevention of Corruption
Act has cautioned the Court to adopt the principle of non-interference
except in cases with very special feature exists which is not available in
the facts and circumstances of the present case. Hon’ble the Supreme
Court in case of State of Chhattisgarh Vs. Aman Kumar Singh
[(2023) 6 SCC 559] h as held in paragraph 80 to 83 as under:-
“80. Having regard to what we have observed above in paragraph
49 (supra) and to maintain probity in the system of governance as
well as to ensure that societal pollutants are weeded out at the
earliest, it would be eminently desirable if the high courts maintain
a hands-off approach and not quash a first information report
pertaining to “corruption” cases, specially at the stage of
investigation, even though certain elements of strong-arm tactics of
the ruling dispensation might be discernible. The considerations
that could apply to quashing of first information reports pertaining to
offences punishable under general penal statutes ex proprio vigore
may not be applicable to a P.C. Act offence. Majorly, the proper
course for the high courts to follow, in cases under the P.C. Act,
would be to permit the investigation to be taken to its logical
conclusion and leave the aggrieved party to pursue the remedy
made available by law at an appropriate stage. If at all interference
in any case is considered necessary, the same should rest on the
very special features of the case.
81. Although what would constitute the special features has
necessarily to depend on the peculiar facts of each case,
interference could be made in exceptional cases where the records
reveal absolutely no material to support even a reasonable
suspicion of a public servant having intentionally enriched himself
illicitly during the period of his service and nothing other than mala
fide is the basis for subjecting such servant to an investigation.
Page 10 of 13
82. We quite appreciate that there could be cases of innocent
public servants being entangled in investigations arising out of
motivated complaints and the consequent mental agony, emotional
pain and social stigma that they would have to encounter in the
process, but this small price has to be paid if there is to be a
society governed by the rule of law. While we do not intend to fetter
the high courts from intervening in appropriate cases, it is only just
and proper to remind the courts to be careful, circumspect and
cautious in quashing first information reports resting on mala fide of
the nature alleged herein.
83. For the foregoing reasons, we have no option but to hold
that there are no cogent grounds for quashing the FIR in the
present case even on the ground of mala fide.”
16. The submission made by the learned Counsel for the applicant as discussed
above is the defence of the applicant which cannot be adjudicated by this
Court at the time of examining the legality and propriety of the charges
framed by the trial Court as settled by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in
case of Manendra Prasad Tiwari Vs. Amit Kumar Tiwari & another
[(2022) 20 SCC 757] wherein it has been held in paragraphs 23, 24 &
25 as under:-
“23. It is also well settled that when the petition is filed by the
accused under Section 482 CrPC or a revision Petition under
Section 397 read with Section 401 of the CrPC seeking for the
quashing of charge framed against him, the Court should not
interfere with the order unless there are strong reasons to hold
that in the interest of justice and to avoid abuse of the process
of the Court a charge framed against the accused needs to be
quashed. Such an order can be passed only in exceptional
cases and on rare occasions. It is to be kept in mind that once
the trial court has framed a charge against an accused the
trial must proceed without unnecessary interference by a
superior court and the entire evidence from the prosecution
side should be placed on record. Any attempt by an accused
for quashing of a charge before the entire prosecution
evidence has come on record should not be entertained sans
exceptional cases. [see State of Delhi v. Gyan Devi, (2000) 8
SCC 239].
24. The scope of interference and exercise of jurisdiction
under Section 397 of CrPC has been time and again
explained by this Court. Further, the scope of interference
under Section 397 CrPC at a stage, when charge had been
framed, is also well settled. At the stage of framing of a
charge, the court is concerned not with the proof of the
Page 11 of 13
allegation rather it has to focus on the material and form an
opinion whether there is strong suspicion that the accused has
committed an offence, which if put to trial, could prove his
guilt. The framing of charge is not a stage, at which stage the
final test of guilt is to be applied. Thus, to hold that at the
stage of framing the charge, the court should form an opinion
that the accused is certainly guilty of committing an offence, is
to hold something which is neither permissible nor is in
consonance with the scheme of Code of Criminal Procedure.
25. Section 397 CrPC vests the court with the power to call for
and examine the records of an inferior court for the purposes
of satisfying itself as to the legality and regularity of any
proceedings or order made in a case. The object of this
provision is to set right a patent defect or an error of
jurisdiction or law or the perversity which has crept in the
proceeding.”
17. Again Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of State of Orissa Vs.
Pratima Behera [AIR 2025 SC 218] has held in paragraphs 10, 11 &
12 as under:-
“10. We may hasten to state at this juncture that though at the
stage of framing of issue what is to be seen is only whether
there is a prima facie case to make the accused to stand the
trial at the trial, certainly, the presumption of innocence should
be in favour of the accused.
11. Taking note of the fact that in the case on hand, the High
Court set aside the charge framed against the respondent
while exercising the revisional power, it is relevant to refer to
the decision in Minakshi Bala v. Criminal Appeal No.3175 of
2024 Sudhir Kumar & Ors4. This Court on the question of
quashing of charge by the High Court made the following
pertinent observations:-
“7…To put it differently, once charges are framed under
Section 240 CrPC the High Court in its revisional
jurisdiction would not be justified in relying upon documents
other than those referred to in Sections 239 and 240 CrPC;
nor would it be justified in invoking its inherent jurisdiction
under Section 482 CrPC to quash the same except in those
rare cases where forensic exigencies and formidable
compulsions justify such a course. We hasten to add even
in such exceptional cases the High Court can look into only
those documents which are unimpeachable and can be
legally translated into relevant evidence.
8. Apart from the infirmity in the approach of the High Court
in dealing with the matter which we have already noticed,
we further find that instead of adverting to and confining its
Page 12 of 13
attention to the documents referred to in Sections 239 and
240 CrPC the High Court has (1994) 4 SCC 142; 1994
INSC 201 Criminal Appeal No.3175 of 2024 dealt with the
rival contentions of the parties raised through their
respective affidavits at length and on a threadbare
discussion thereof passed the impugned order. The course
so adopted cannot be supported; firstly, because finding
regarding commission of an offence cannot be recorded on
the basis of affidavit evidence and secondly, because at the
stage of framing of charge the Court cannot usurp the
functions of a Trial Court to delve into and decide upon the
respective merits of the case.” (underline supplied)
12. In short, while reiterating the position that in a prosecution,
presumption of innocence should be in favour of the accused,
it has to be said that at the stage of framing charge, even a
very strong suspicion, of course, founded upon materials and
presumptive opinion would enable the Court to frame charge
against an accused.”
18. Considering the well settled position of law, particularly in a case under
the Act, 1988 in case of Aman Kumar Singh (supra) wherein Hon’ble
the Supreme Court has held that principle of non-interference has to be
followed by the Court, except in such cases where special feature
exists which is not available in the present facts and circumstances of
the case in view of amended provisions of Section 7 of the PC Act with
effect from 26.07.2018, and further considering that this Court while
hearing the petition against the framing of charges, is required to
examine whether the material placed by the prosecution, if accepted at
its face value, discloses the ingredients of the offences alleged and
whether there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
The Court is not required to conduct a roving or meticulous
examination of the evidence or to determine whether the prosecution
will ultimately succeed in establishing the charges beyond reasonable
doubt. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court is
of the opinion that the material collected during investigation cannot be
said to be so deficient or inherently improbable as to warrant
Page 13 of 13
interference with the order framing charges. Thus, the instant criminal
revision deserves to be dismissed.
19. Accordingly, the criminal revision is dismissed . The order framing
charges under Section 7 as amended vide Amendment Act 2018,
against the applicant for offence punishable under Sections 7 is hereby
affirmed.
20. It is made clear that the observations made herein are confined solely
to the consideration of the present revision against the order framing
charge which shall not prejudice the case of the applicant or the
prosecution during the trial and the learned trial Court shall decide the
case strictly on the basis of the evidence adduced before it,
uninfluenced by any observation made in this order on its own merit.
21. It is further directed that the applicant is at liberty to take all his defence
which is available to him during the trial Court and the trial Court will
decide the criminal case pending before it in accordance with law
without being influenced from any of the observations made by this
Court while deciding the criminal revision as this court has only taken
into consideration the facts for adjudicating the submissions made by
both the parties and has not examined the merit of the rival
submissions made by them.
22. The interim order passed by this Court on 23.01.2023 is vacated.
Sd/-
(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
Bhumika