SHRI GURU RAM RAI INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES DEHRADUN vs HIMANI PANDEY

Court
Uttarakhand High Court

UKHC010007872023

2026:UHC:10382-DB

Office Notes, reports,
orders or proceedings
or directions and
Registrar’s order with
SL
.
No
.
Date
COURT’S OR JUDGE’S ORDERS
Signatures
SPA/15/2023

Shri Guru Ram Rai Institute of Medical and Health Sciences,
Dehradun --Appellant
Versus
Archit Chauhan and others --Respondents

with
SPA/14/2023
Shri Guru Ram Rai Institute of Medical and Health Sciences,
Dehradun --Appellant
Versus
Himani Pandey and others --Respondents


Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, A.C.J.
Hon’ble Subhash Upadhyay, J.
Mr. Shubhang Dobhal and Mr. Bhupendra
Singh Bora, learned counsel for the appellant.
2. Mr. Pooran Singh Rawat and Mr. M.C.
Upadhyay, learned counsel for respondent no.1 in
SPA No.15/2023.
3. Ms. Mamta Bisht, learned counsel for
respondent no.1 in SPA No.14/2023.
4. Mr. Parikshit Saini, learned counsel for
respondent no.2/National Medical Commission.
5. Mr. Tilak Ram Sharma, learned counsel
holding brief of Mr. Shailendra Nauriyal, learned
counsel for respondent no.3.
6. These intra-court appeals are directed
against judgment and order dated 19.12.2022,
rendered by learned Single Judge in WPMS
Nos.3234/2022 and 3235/2022. The impugned
judgment is reproduced below:-
“By filing this writ application, the petitioner
has prayed for the following reliefs:
“i). Issue a appropriate writ, order or direction in
the nature of mandamus directing the respondent
to return the original certificate of the documents of
the petitioner. And do not charge further fee to the
petitioner.
ii) Issue a appropriate writ, order or direction in
the nature of mandamus directing the
respondents to permit the petitioner to discontinue
MBBS curt. Anid fill up the seat allotted to the

UKHC010007872023

2026:UHC:10382-DB

petitioner through upcoming Mop Up round of
counselling or stray round of counselling.
iii) Issue a appropriate writ, order or direction in
the nature of mandamus directing the
respondents to refund the fee deposited by the
petitioner after deducting the admission fee,
counselling fee.
iv) Issue a appropriate writ, order or direction in
the nature of mandamus directing the respondent
to refund the amount of Rs.25 lakhs after
deducting the admission fee, counselling fee.

In Writ Petition no.3235 of 2022 (M/S)the petitioner
has prayed as follows:-

i) Issue a appropriate order or direction in the
nature of mandamus directing the respondent
to continue the admission of the petitioner in
MBBS Course under state quota under category
of URDPW which was obtained by her
st
pursuant to the 1 round of counselling NEET
UG-2022.

Issue a appropriate writ, order or direction in
ii)
the nature of mandamus directing the
respondents fill up the seat allotted to the
nd
petitioner in the 2 round of counselling through
upcoming Mop Up round of counselling or stray
round of counselling.

Issue a appropriate writ, order or direction in
iii)
the nature of mandamus directing the
respondent to refund the amount of difference
of the tuition fee between All India Quota
Management Quota and State quota i.e. Rs.
378400.00 to the petitioner.


2. It is not disputed that petitioner Archit Chauhan
appeared in the NEET Examination, and was selected for
taking admission in MBBS stream in Sri Guru Ram Rai
Institute of Medical & Health Sciences, Dehradun.
Another applicant has filed the application bearing Writ
Petition No. 3235 of 2022 (M/S) with a prayer to continue
the admission of the petitioner in MBBS course under the
State Quota under category of URDPW which was obtained
st
by her pursuant to the 1 round of counselling NEET UG-
2022.

3. The case of the said second petitioner Himani
Pandey is that though she was selected in URDPW category,
but at the time of filling form, she made mistake
and clicked on All India Management Quota, and,
therefore, she has to pay very high admission and tuition
fee to the college. It is also borne from the record
that said Himani Pandey has taken admission in Sri Guru
Ram Rai Institute of Medical & Health Sciences,
Dehradun.

4. Keeping in view the fact that respondent no. 3 is
engaged in imparting medical education, and, is
therefore, amenable to writ jurisdiction, this Court is of
opinion that it should not enrich unjustly. Both the
petitions are allowed. Respondent no. 3-Sri Guru Ram Rai
Institute of Medical & Health Sciences Dehradun, is directed
to cancel the admission of the petitioner Archit Chauhan
and refund the money deposited by him within 15 days
from the date of production of certified copy of the order.

UKHC010007872023

2026:UHC:10382-DB

In the connected writ petition, it is directed that
respondent no. 3 shall adjust Himani Pandey in the post
vacated by Archit Chauhan and refund the excess
amount deposited by her. Respondent no. 3 shall
also fill up the seat vacated by Himani Pandey in the All
India Management Quota.”

7. Learned counsel for appellant submits that
even though learned Single Judge has granted all
reliefs as prayed for by respondents in their writ
petitions, however, no reason whatsoever has
been indicated for granting such reliefs. He relies
upon a judgment rendered by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Vishal Ashwin Patel Vs. Assistant
Commissioner of Income Tax Circle 25(3) &
Ors. Civil Appeal No.2200/2022 and
connected appeals for contending that every
order passed by a judicial forum has to be
supported by reasons. Para nos.2.3 and 2.4 of
the said judgment are reproduced below:-
“2.3 While emphasising the necessity to pass a reasoned
order, in the case of Central Board of Trustees Vs.
Indore Composite Private Limited, (2018) 8 SCC 443 ,
it is observed and held by this Court that the courts need to
pass a reasoned order in every case which must contain the
narration of the bare facts of the case of the parties to the
lis, the issues arising in the case, the submissions urged by
the parties, the legal principles applicable to the issues
involved and the reasons in support of the findings on all the
issues arising in the case and urged by the learned counsel
for the parties in support of its conclusion. It is further
observed in the said decision that an order bereft of
reasoning causes prejudice to the parties because it deprives
them to know the reasons as to why one party has won and
other has lost.

2.4 In the recent decision in the case of Union Public
Service Commission Vs. Bibhu Prasad Sarangi and
Ors., (2021) 4 SCC 516 , while emphasising the reasons to
be given by the High Court while exercising powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, it is observed and
held by this Court that the reasons constitute the soul of
judicial decision and how Judges communicate in their
judgment is a defining characteristic of judicial process since
quality of justice brings legitimacy to the judiciary. It is
further observed that though statistics of disposal of cases is
important of higher value is the intrinsic content of
judgment. It is further observed that in exercise of powers
under Article 226 the courts require to independently
consider the issues involved.”

8. Learned counsel for appellant further

UKHC010007872023

2026:UHC:10382-DB

submits that writ petitioners were bound by
terms and conditions of counselling and also
undertaking given in their affidavits, however,
that aspect was completely ignored by learned
Single Judge.
9. Perusal of impugned judgment indicates
that writ petitions filed by Archit Chauhan and
Himani Pandey were allowed by common
judgment on the ground that respondent no.3,
which is imparting medical education, is
amenable to writ jurisdiction and it should not
enrich unjustly.
10. Learned Single Judge overlooked terms and
conditions mentioned in the notification issued by
Uttarakhand Medical Education University on
15.11.2022 and also undertaking given by Archit
Chauhan at the time of admission pursuant to
first counselling.
11. We are of the view that every judicial order
should be backed by reasons and order without
reasoning becomes unsustainable in law. Since
impugned judgment is cryptic and non-speaking,
therefore, without entering into merits of the
case, we set aside the impugned judgment and
remand the matter back to learned Writ Court for
deciding the writ petitions afresh.
12. The special appeal is disposed of in
aforesaid terms.





(Subhash Upadhyay, J.) (Manoj Kumar Tiwari, A.C.J.)

1 6.11.2026 16.11.2026

SS/PP