Durgapur Steel Plant vs Bidhan Chandra Chowdhury

Court
Supreme Court

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
2026 INSC 459
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(@ SLP (CIVIL) NO. 41 OF 2020)

DURGAPUR STEEL PLANT & ORS. ... APPELLANTS

VERSUS
BIDHAN CHANDRA CHOWDHURY & ORS. … RESPONDENTS

WITH

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(@ SLP (CIVIL) NO. 14491 OF 2021)

J U D G M E N T
ALOK ARADHE, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. These appeals arise out of the order dated 19.07.2019 and the
judgment dated 27.09.2019 passed by the Division Bench of the
Calcutta High Court (High Court) in a writ petition. By its order
dated 19.07.2019, the High Court granted liberty to the Appellant
No.2 to examine and assess the candidature of the respondents for
appointment to the post of Plant Attendant-cum-Junior
Technician (Plant Attendant), and directed that the result of such
assessment be produced before it. Subsequently, by judgment
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Jayant Kumar Arora
Date: 2026.05.07
17:03:41 IST
Reason:
dated 27.09.2019, the High Court affirmed the order dated
27.03.2018 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal
1

(Tribunal), Calcutta Bench, and dismissed the writ petition
preferred by the appellants.
3. The facts, in brief, leading to the filing of these appeals are as
follows. The appellant no.1, namely Durgapur Steel Plant, is one
of the five integrated Steel Plants of Steel Authority of India
Limited, a Public Sector Enterprise of the Central Government. An
advertisement dated 16.10.2007 was issued by Appellant No.1, for
recruitment to the post of Plant Attendant. Initially, 90 posts were
advertised, which were subsequently increased to 150 and
thereafter to 200 posts due to additional requirements. The
selection process comprised a written examination and an
interview, followed by a medical examination of successful
candidates. The conduct of the written examination was
outsourced to an independent agency. In response to the
advertisement, 52,000 applications were received. The written
examination was conducted on 23.03.2008, in which 29,459
candidates appeared; out of these 1,530 candidates qualified and
their names were published on the website.
4. On 17.06.2008, a merit list containing the roll numbers of
candidates shortlisted for interview was published. Thereafter,
appointment offers were issued to 150 candidates, out of whom
2

139 joined service. Subsequently, in view of additional vacancies
arising during the same recruitment cycle, 55 more candidates
were offered appointments, resulting in a total of 194 candidates
joining service.
5. In January 2009, the respondents filed a writ petition seeking a
direction for production of the results of the written examination
and disclosure of the marks obtained by them. They also sought a
direction restraining the appellants from issuing appointment
orders to the selected candidates. Another writ petition was filed
challenging the advertisement dated 04.03.2010 issued by the
appellants, for filling posts of Junior Technician/Operator. By
orders dated 07.02.2012 and 14.02.2012 both writ petitions were
transferred to the Tribunal.
6. The Tribunal, by a common order dated 27.03.2018, inter alia
held:
(i) the marks of the written test were neither produced
before the Tribunal nor disclosed to the respondents;
(ii) despite the pendency of the writ petitions, the records
were not preserved after finalisation of appointments of
194 candidates; and
3

(iii) there was no documentary evidence to establish that
the respondents had failed in the examination.

7. Accordingly, the Tribunal directed the appellants to offer
appointments to the respondents to the post of Plant Attendant or
an equivalent post, with suitable age relaxation, within a period of
16 weeks. It was further directed that the respondents would be
placed at the bottom of the seniority list and that the benefits
arising from such appointment would be prospective.
8. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the appellants filed a writ petition
before the High Court. By an interim order dated 19.07.2019, the
High Court directed the Appellant No. 2 to assess the candidature
of the respondents and place the result before it. Thereafter, by
judgment dated 27.09.2019, the High Court dismissed the writ
petition. It is in this factual backdrop that the present appeals
have been filed.
9. Mr. Ranjit Kumar, learned senior counsel for the Appellants
submitted that the conduct of the written examination was
outsourced to an independent agency, and there was no
requirement to maintain or publish the results of all 29,459
candidates who appeared in the examination. It was further
contended that no specific relief of appointment had been sought
4

by the respondents. It was also argued that the qualifications for
the post of Plant Attendant were revised in 2008, and at this stage,
it is not feasible to accommodate the respondents.
10. Per contra, Mr. Subhasish Bhowmick, learned counsel for the
Respondent No. 1 submitted that the Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 are
no longer interested in prosecuting the matter, and he has
instructions to contest only on behalf of the Respondent No.1. It
was contended that the recruitment process was ex facie arbitrary
and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, inasmuch as no cut-
off marks, evaluation criteria, or selection methodology was
disclosed either in the advertisement or thereafter. It was further
submitted that the appellants merely published the roll numbers
of the shortlisted candidates without disclosing their marks,
thereby vitiating the entire selection process due to lack of
transparency.
11. It was argued that, owing to non-production and/or destruction of
records, an adverse inference must be drawn against the
appellants, and the relief granted by the Tribunal is justified. It
was also urged that the Respondent No.1 was never shown to have
5

failed in the examination. Reliance was placed on the decisions of
1
this Court .
12. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the record.
13. The State or its instrumentalities, while filling vacancies, are
obligated to adhere to the principle of comparative merit of
candidates based on their performance in the recruitment process,
and no discrimination is permissible. It is well settled in law that
a candidate whose name appears in the select list does not acquire
any indefeasible right to appointment to the post in the absence of
2
any specific rule entitling such appointment .
14. In the present case, neither the recruitment rules nor the
advertisement required the publication of the marks obtained by
all the candidates, who appeared in the written examination. It is
not the case of the respondents that they had passed the
examination. There is no material on record to indicate that the
respondents had passed in the written examination. Merely
because the respondents were not shown to have failed, no

1
Kerala Public Service Commission & Ors. v. State Information Commission & Anr., (2016) 3 SCC 417;
Sachin Kumar & Ors., v. Delhi Subordinate Service Selection Board (DSSSB) & Ors.; (2021) 4 SCC 631,
Union of India & Ors., v. O. Chakradhar, (2002) 3 SCC 146 and Poonam Rani v. State of Haryana & Anr.;
(2012) 6 SCC 596.
2
Union Territory of Chandigarh v. Dilbagh Singh & Ors., (1993) 1 SCC 154; Mohd. Rashid v. Director ,
Local Bodies, New Secretariat & Ors. (2020) 2 SCC 582 and State of Manipur & Anr. v. Takhelmayum
Khelendro Meitei & Ors., (2019) 3 SCC 331
6

inference could be drawn that they had passed the written
examination.
15. The written examination was conducted through an independent
agency. Neither the rules nor the advertisement prescribed the
duration for which the records of the selection process were to be
preserved. Therefore, the explanation of the appellants for non-
production of the record that the same were unavailable or had
been destroyed appears to be bona fide. Mere non-production of
such records does not justify drawing an inference that the
respondents had cleared the written test.
16. It is also noteworthy that, in the writ petitions, the respondents
had sought a direction to call for the results of 56 candidates who
were subsequently selected, and had not sought appointment for
themselves. For an additional reason, a direction for appointment
of the respondents to the post of Plant Attendant cannot be
granted. The qualifications for the post of Plant Attendant were
revised in the year 2008, and therefore, the appellants cannot be
directed to appoint the respondents. For the aforesaid reasons, the
order of the Tribunal directing appointment of the respondents to
the post of Plant Attendant, as well as the judgment of the High
Court cannot be sustained.
7

17. It was submitted before us that respondent nos. 2 and 3 are no
longer interested in contesting the matter. Respondent no.1 alone
has continued to pursue the litigation since 2008. As we are
setting aside the orders of the Tribunal and the High Court
whereby the respondents were held entitled to appointment to the
post of Plant Attendant, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of
the case, we deem it appropriate to direct the appellants to pay a
sum of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five Lakhs) to respondent no.1
within a period of two months.

18. Accordingly, the impugned order and judgment, in so far as it
directs the appellants to provide appointment to the respondents
to the post of Plant Attendant, is set aside.
19. In the result, the appeals are disposed of. There shall be no order
as to costs.

….………..…………….………….……….J.
[PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA]



....…….……………….………….……….J.
[ALOK ARADHE]


NEW DELHI;
MAY 7, 2026.

8