SMT. GANGOTRI BAI vs HIRDERAM KURMI

Court
Chhattisgarh High Court

1


CGHC010255842023 2026:CGHC:47181

NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 1380 of 2023
1 - Smt. Gangotri Bai W/o Late Hirderam, Aged About 40 Years
R/o Village Mudhpar, Tahsil/thana Dongargarh, District
Rajandgaon Chhattisgarh.
2 - Pawan Thakre, S/o Late Hirderam Aged About 15 Years R/o
Village Mudhpar, Tahsil/thana Dongargarh, District Rajandgaon
Chhattisgarh. Minor Legal Gourdian Mother Smt. Gangotri Bai
3 - Pramod Kumar, S/o Late Hirderam Aged About 13 Years R/o
Village Mudhpar, Tahsil/thana Dongargarh, District Rajandgaon
Chhattisgarh. Minor Legal Guardian Mother Smt. Gangotri Bai
4 - Chaganlal Thakre, S/o Late Budhuram Thakre, Aged About 60
Years R/o Village Mudhpar, Tahsil/thana Dongargarh, District
Rajandgaon Chhattisgarh. Minor Legal Gourdian Mother Smt.
Gangotri Bai
... Appellants
versus
1 - Hirderam Kurmi S/o Mahtaruram Kuarmi, R/o Village Mudhpar
Murmanda, Tahsil And Thana Dongargarh, District Rajnandgoan
Chhattisgarh.

2
2 - Ifco Tokiyo General Insurance Company Limted, Through Its
Branch Manager, Branch Office Shop No. 205, Ii Nd Floor, M.M.
Silver Plaza, Near Mining Office, Mahavir Nagar, Ring Road, No.
1, Raipur Chhattisgarh.
... Respondents
For Appellants : Mrs. Bhavika Kotecha, Advocate.
For Respondent No. 1 : None
For Respondent No.2 : Mr. Pravesh Sahu, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal
Order on Board
(16.11.2026)
1. This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (for short the "Act of 1988") has been preferred by the
appellants/claimants seeking enhancement of the amount of
compensation, challenging the impugned award dated
24.02.2023, passed in Motor Accident Claim Case
No.18/2021 by the Additional Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Dongargarh, District Rajnandgaon (C.G.) (for short
‘the Claims Tribunal’), whereby the learned Claims Tribunal
has awarded a total sum of Rs.15,67,000/- as compensation
for the death of Late Shail Kumar Thakre, who died in a
road accident which took place on 09.04.2021.
2. Brief facts of the case are that on 09.04.2021, deceased,

3
Shail Kumar Thakre, was returning home on foot after taking
a bath at Mudpar Nala. At that time, respondent No.1 was
driving the tractor bearing registration No. CG-08-AM-2016.
When the tractor reached near Shail Kumar, its front portion
suddenly overturned due to the field embankment (Medh),
and fell upon Shail Kumar. Consequently, Shail Kumar got
trapped beneath the said portion of the tractor and
sustained grievous injuries, resulting in his instantaneous
death at the spot. The offending vehicle was owned by the
respondent No.1 and was insured with respondent No.2 -
IFCO-Tokiyo General Insurance Company Ltd.
3. A claim petition was filed by the appellants/claimants who
happen to be the legal heirs (mother, 02 minor brothers and
grant-father) of the deceased claiming a compensation of
Rs.80,00,000/- inter alia pleading that the deceased at the
relevant time was young unmarried boy aged about 20
years, he was doing Mason work and used to earn
Rs.15,000/- per month.
4. Pleading of the claimants have, however, been denied by
the respondent No.2/insurance company.
5. After evaluating the evidence available on record, the

4
Tribunal has awarded the compensation of Rs.15,67,000/-
along with interest @ 6% per annum in favour of the
appellants/claimants taking the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.7,500/- per month and Rs.90,000/- per
annum, taking 40% towards future prospect, applying the
multiplier of 18, deducting 1/3 towards his personal
expenses and exonerating the insurance company having
found the breach of policy conditions. Hence, this appeal
for enhancement.
6. Learned counsel for the appellants/claimants submits that
the impugned award passed by the learned Tribunal is on
the lower side and therefore liable to modified suitably.
Learned counsel further submits that the deceased at the
relevant time was doing Mason work and was earning
Rs.15,000/- per month, however, the learned Tribunal only
assessed the monthly income of the deceased at
Rs.7,500/-, which is not justified. She further submits that
under the conventional heads also the learned Claims
Tribunal has awarded meager compensation, which needs
to be enhanced suitably. It has been also submitted that the
learned Tribunal has held that there was a breach of the
policy conditions and has consequently exonerated the

5
Insurance Company from its liability, and directed it to first
satisfy the award amount and then to recover the same from
the respondent No.1, which is proper.
7. None appears for respondent No. 1.
8. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2/Insurance
Company submits that the learned Claims Tribunal, after
appreciating oral and documentary evidence, has rightly
exonerated the insurance company upon finding the breach
of policy condition and passed the impugned award, which
does not call for any interference by this Court.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the appellants and
respondent No.2, considered their rival submissions made
herein-above and went through the records with utmost
circumspection.
10. In the present case, the appellants/claimants pleaded before
the Claims Tribunal that the deceased Shail Kumar Thakre
was earning Rs.15,000/- per month by doing Mason work,
but the learned Claims Tribunal assessed the monthly
income of the deceased at Rs.7,500/-. As regards the
monthly income of the deceased, the claimants did not
produce any cogent and reliable evidence which could
establish that the deceased at the time of accident was

6
doing mason work. Considering that the accident took place
on 09.04.2021 and the deceased who was unmarried, it
would be proper to take his monthly income of Rs.9,200/- as
per the Chhattisgarh Minimum Wages Notification issued by
the office of Labour Commissioner, Chhattisgarh for
unskilled labour. Therefore, to that extent the impugned
award needs to be modified.
11. The learned claims Tribunal, considering the nature of job of
deceased (self employed) at the time of accident
09.04.2021, the fact that he was unmarried aged 20 years
left behind 04 claimants (widow mother, 02 minor brothers
and grand-father), has rightly taken future prospect of 40%,
deducted 1/3 towards personal expenses and applied
multiplier of 18 respectively.
12. The learned Claims Tribunal, while awarding a sum of
Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses and Rs.40,000/-
towards loss of consortium to all the appellants collectively,
has failed to award any amount under the head of loss of
estate and has also awarded an inadequate amount
towards loss of consortium. Having regard to the date of the
accident, i.e., 09.04.2021, and the law laid down by the

7
Hon’ble Supreme Court governing the aforesaid
conventional heads of compensation, the amount awarded
by the learned Claims Tribunal is not found to be just and
reasonable and needs to be modified suitably.
13. Thus, in light of the aforesaid discussion and in light of the
judgments of the Supreme Court rendered in the matters of
1
National Insurance Company Ltd. V. Pranay Sethi , Sarla
2
Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Ors
and Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @
3
Chuhru Ram & Ors , this Court is computing the
compensation as below:-
Sr.
No.
Heads Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Compensation
awarded by this
Court
1 Income Rs.7,500 x 12 =
Rs. 9200 x 12 =
Rs.90,000/-
Rs.1,10,400/-
2. Future
prospect
(+)40% (i.e. Rs.
(+)40% (i.e.
Rs.44,160/-) =
Rs.36,000/-) =
Rs.1,26,000/-
Rs.1,54,560/-
3. Deduction (-) 1/3 (i.e. 42,000/-)
(-) 1/3 (i.e. 51,520) =
= Rs.84,000/-
Rs.1,03,040/-
4. Multiplier (x) 18 =
Rs.15,12,000/-
(x) 18 =
Rs.18,54,720/-
5 Towards
consortium
to all 04
claimants
Rs.40,000/- Rs. 44,000 x 4 =
Rs.1,76,000/-
1(2017) 16 SCC 680
2(2009) 6 SCC 121
3(2018) 18 SCC 130

8
6. Towards
Loss of
Estate.
-- Rs.16,500/-
7. Towards
funeral
expenses.
Rs.15,000/- Rs.16,500/-
Total Rs. 15,75,000/- Rs.20,63,720/-
14. In view of the aforesaid analysis, the amount of
compensation of Rs.15,75,000/- awarded by the Claims
Tribunal is enhanced to Rs.20,63,720/-. Hence, after
deducting the amount of Rs.15,75,000/-, the appellants are
held entitled for an additional amount of Rs.4,88,720/- . The
additional amount of compensation shall carry interest @
6% per annum from the date of filing of the claim application
before the Claims Tribunal till its realization. Rest of the
conditions of the impugned award shall remain intact.
15. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants/claimants is
partly allowed and the impugned award is modified to the
extent as indicated herein-above.
16. The Registry is directed to communicate the claimants in
writing “the enhanced amount” in this appeal as against the
award made by the concerned Tribunal. The said
communication be made in Hindi Deonagri language and
the help of paralegal workers may be availed with a co-

9
ordination of Secretary, Legal Aid of the concerned area
wherein the claimants resides.
Sd/-
(Sanjay Kumar Jaiswal)
Judge
Digitally signed by
VIJAY
pekde
BHARATRAO
PEKDE
Date: 2026.11.17
10:52:16 +0530