Nandi Devi & Anr vs Megha
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRM M-47741 of 2017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
116 CRM M-47741 of 2017
Date of Decision: 12.11.2026
Nandi Devi and another ...Petitioners
Versus
Mega ... Respondent
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE N.S.SHEKHAWAT
Present : Mr. Vipul Aggarwal, Advocate, for the petitioners.
Mr. Bhanu Bains, Advocate, for the respondent.
N.S.SHEKHAWAT , J. (Oral)
1. The petitioners have filed the present petition under
Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure with a prayer to quash the
protest petition in complaint bearing No.16 dated 24.05.2012 titled as
‘M egha vs. Nandi Devi and others’, under Sections 406, 420, 120-B
and 506 of IPC, Police Station Civil Lines, Karnal (Annexure P-1),
impugned summoning order dated 20.12.2016 (Annexure P-12) as
well as the impugned orders dated 14.06.2017 (Annexure P-13) and
dated 12.10.2017 (Annexure P-16) passed by the Court of Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Karnal and the Additional Sessions Judge, Karnal
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -2-
respectively, whereby, the petitioners were ordered to be
chargesheeted for commission of offences under Sections 420 read
with Section 120-B IPC.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioners has vehemently
argued that the petitioners have been falsely involved in a protest
petition-cum-complaint (Annexure P-1) at the instance of the
respondent. In fact, the petitioner No. 1 is a bona fide purchaser of
land by way of registered sale deed and petitioner No. 2 had appeared
on her behalf at the time of registration of sale deeds. After a long
delay, the respondent lodged a false complaint only with the view to
convert a civil dispute in a criminal case without any justification.
Learned counsel for the petitioners has vehemently argued that
initially respondent got registered an FIR No. 240 dated 06.03.2009
under Sections 406, 420, 120-B and 506 of IPC, Police Station Civil
Lines, Karnal against the present petitioners. After registration of the
FIR, a detailed investigation was conducted by the police and a
cancellation report was prepared in the case as no substance was
found in the allegations leveled by the respondent. Thereafter, the
respondent filed the impugned protest petition-cum-complaint
(Annexure P-1) against the petitioners and three other accused before
the Court of CJM, Karnal. In the complaint, it was alleged that some
land was mutated in the name of respondent, her brother and her
mother, as a consequence of a Court decree in a suit for partition filed
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -3-
by the co-sharers of the said khewat. Mukesh Kumar Patwari,
co-accused told the respondent and her family members that the land
was subjected to river action and was ‘Sailab’ land and the respondent
and her family members could sell it for a good price. Mukesh Kumar
introduced the complainant and her family members with Pintu
Kumar, a property dealer, and he also advised the respondent on the
same lines. Ultimately, the respondent agreed to sell their ‘Sailab’
land only in favour of petitioner No. 1 and the respondent and her
family members were called in the office of Sub-Registrar, Karnal, on
09.06.2008. The respondent and her other family members were made
to sign on certain documents and no document was ever read over to
the respondent or her family members. Even, the respondent and her
family members were produced before the Sub-Registrar and were
photographed and they had signed on all the documents on the asking
of Mukesh Kumar and Pintu Kumar. Ultimately, the respondent and
her family members came to know that apart from ‘Sailab’ land,
within their ‘Chahi’ (irrigated) land had also been sold by way of two
registered sale deeds bearing numbers 1979/1 and 1981/1 dated
09.06.2008 in favour of the petitioner No.1. Even, the petitioner No.2
had appeared in place of petitioner No.1.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued
that in fact the respondent and her other family members had
executed the above mentioned two sale deeds in favour of petitioner
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -4-
No. 1 and even the land in excess of their share was illegally sold to
the petitioners. The possession of respondent and her family members
was on 18 Kanals 0 Marlas whereas they had executed the sale deed
regarding total land measuring 19 Kanals 14 Marlas. Consequently,
the petitioner No. 1 filed a suit for declaration and in alternative a
suit for recovery of Rs.1,31,250/- against the respondent and her other
family members as they had committed a fraud with the present
petitioners. The summons of the Civil Suit (Annexure P-4) were
received by respondent and her family members on 14.01.2009 and as
a counter blast, they lodged a complaint dated 28.01.2009 against the
petitioners and others by concocting a false story. The said complaint
was sent by the Court of CJM Karnal under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
and as a consequence of which, the FIR No. 240 dated 06.03.2009
under Sections 406, 420, 120-B and 506 of IPC, Police Station Civil
Lines, Karnal, was registered against the petitioners and others. In
order to put more pressure on the petitioners, the respondent and her
other family members filed a civil suit on 02.05.2009 seeking a
decree of declaration to the effect that the registered sale deeds
numbers 1979/1 and 1981/1 dated 09.06.2008 in favour of the
petitioner No. 1 were ineffective and not binding on the rights of the
respondent and her family members and were a result of fraud and
misrepresentation of facts and without any consideration. Learned
counsel further submits that the civil suit filed by respondent has
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -5-
already been dismissed by the trial Court. Even, an appeal filed by the
respondent and her other family members has also been dismissed by
the Court of Additional District Judge, Karnal on 07.07.2026. Thus,
the validity of the sale deeds which are the subject matters of the
present complaint has already been upheld by the Civil Court and it
has been found that the sale deeds were validly executed by
respondent and other sellers having received the sale considerations
before the Sub-Registrar. Even, the respondent failed to bring on file
any evidence except their self-serving statements to show that the sale
deeds were result and outcome of a fraud. Still further, both the sale
deeds are registered documents and there is a sanctity attached to the
registered document. Even, during the course of preliminary evidence
before the trial Court, the respondent could not prove any evidence to
show that a fraud has been committed by the petitioners. The
respondent herself appeared as CW1 and exhibited certain documents
which clearly demonstrated that the ingredients of the offences under
Sections 420/120-B IPC were clearly missing in the present case.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent has
vehemently argued that the respondent and her family members were
illiterate persons and were taken to the office of Sub-Registrar by
petitioners and their co-accused. In fact, the respondent had only
agreed to sell ‘Sailab’ land to petitioner No. 1. However, the
respondent and other sellers were made to sign and thumb marked
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -6-
certain blank and printed papers and no document was ever read over
to the respondent and her family members. Even, the respondent and
her family members were photographed at two places and it was
falsely represented that only the ‘Sailab’ land was being transferred to
the petitioner No. 1. Thus, the registered sale deeds were result of
fraud played by the accused on the respondent. However, learned
counsel for the respondent could not dispute the fact that the validity
of both the sale deeds, which are subject matters of the present
complaint has already been upheld by the Civil Court as well as by
the Appellate Court. Rather, the Appellate Court has clearly held that
the respondent had admitted that the sale deed was duly executed and
they had gone to the Tehsildar/Sub-Registrar and had put their thumb
impressions and also got their photographs done. Even, the
respondent had admitted that the possession of the land in question
was also transferred to petitioner No.1.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record very carefully.
6. The Hon'ble Supreme Court had taken notice of the fact
that nowadays the civil disputes were given the flavour of criminal
offence and observed in Indian Oil Corporation versus NEPC India
Limited, 2006 (6) SCC 736, as follows:-
"13. While on this issue, it is necessary to take notice of
a growing tendency in business circles to convert purely
civil disputes into criminal cases. This is obviously on
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -7-
account of a prevalent impression that civil law remedies
are time consuming and do not adequately protect the
interests of lenders/creditors. Such a tendency is seen in
several family disputes also, leading to irretrievable
breakdown of marriages/families. There is also an
impression that if a person could somehow be entangled
in a criminal prosecution, there is a likelihood of
imminent settlement. Any effort to settle civil disputes
and claims, which do not involve any criminal offence,
by applying pressure through criminal prosecution
should be deprecated and discouraged. In G. Sagar Suri
v. State of U.P. [(2000) 2 SCC 636 : 2000 SCC (Cri)
513] this Court observed: (SCC p. 643, para 8)
"It is to be seen if a matter, which is essentially of a civil
nature, has been given a cloak of criminal offence.
Criminal proceedings are not a short cut of other
remedies available in law. Before issuing process in a
criminal court has to exercise a great deal of caution.
For the accused it is a serious matter. This Court has
laid certain principles on the basis of which the High
Court is to exercise its jurisdiction under Section 482 of
the Code. Jurisdiction under this section has to be
exercised to prevent abuse of the process of any court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice.
"While no one with a legitimate cause or grievance
should be prevented from seeking remedies available in
criminal law, a complainant who initiates or persists
with a prosecution, being fully aware that the criminal
proceedings are unwarranted and his remedy lies only in
civil law, should himself be made accountable, at the end
of such misconceived criminal proceedings, in
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -8-
accordance with law. One positive step that can be taken
by the courts, to curb unnecessary prosecutions and
harassment of innocent parties, is to exercise their power
under Section 250 CrPC more frequently, where they
discern malice or frivolousness or ulterior motives on the
part of the complainant. Be that as it may".
7. Even, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a recent judgment
rendered in G. Swaminathan and another versus the State and
another, in Criminal Appeal No. 3565 of 2026, arising out of Special
Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 10294 of 2025, has held as follows:-
"8.1 In this regard, we find it apposite to refer to this
Court's decision in Binod Kumar vs. State of Bihar,
(2014) 10 SCC 663 wherein it considered a criminal
complaint arising out of retention of bill amount in the
course of a commercial transaction and found that the
essential ingredients of criminal breach of trust or
dishonest intention of inducement, which formed the
foundation of the complaint missing. The relevant
portion of the judgment reads as follows:
"18. In the present case, looking at the allegations in the
complaint on the face of it, we find that no allegations
are made attracting the ingredients of Section 405 IPC.
Likewise, there are no allegations as to cheating or the
dishonest intention of the appellants in retaining the
money in order to have wrongful gain to themselves or
causing wrongful loss to the complainant. Excepting the
bald allegations that the appellants did not make
payment to the second respondent and that the appellants
utilised the amounts either by themselves or for some
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -9-
other work, there is no iota of allegation as to the
dishonest intention in misappropriating the property. To
make out a case of criminal breach of trust, it is not
sufficient to show that money has been retained by the
appellants. It must also be shown that the appellants
dishonestly disposed of the same in some way or
dishonestly retained the same. The mere fact that the
appellants did not pay the money to the complainant
does not amount to criminal breach of trust."
(underlining by us)
8.2 On a prima facie view of the allegations contained in
the FIR and the chargesheet, it appears that the
complainant has attempted to hold the accused persons
criminally liable for breach of a contract. This court in
Hridaya Ranjan Prasad Verma vs. State of Bihar,
(2000) 4 SCC 168, held that a mere breach of contract
cannot give rise to criminal prosecution unless a
fraudulent and dishonest intention of the accused is
proved from the very inception of the transaction. The
relevant portion of the judgment reads as follows:
"15. In determining the question it has to be kept in mind
that the distinction between mere breach of contract and
the offence of cheating is a fine one. It depends upon the
intention of the accused at the time of inducement which
may be judged by his subsequent conduct but for this
subsequent conduct is not the sole test. Mere breach of
contract cannot give rise to criminal prosecution for
cheating unless fraudulent or dishonest intention is
shown right at the beginning of the transaction, that is
the time when the offence is said to have been committed.
Therefore it is the intention which is the gist of the
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -10-
offence. To hold a person guilty of cheating it is
necessary to show that he had fraudulent or dishonest
intention at the time of making the promise. From his
mere failure to keep up promise subsequently such a
culpable intention right at the beginning, that is, when he
made the promise cannot be presumed.
"8.3 The aforesaid dictum was reiterated by this Court in
the case of Dalip Kaur vs. Jagnar Singh, (2009) 14 SCC
696, wherein it was held as under:
"10. The High Court, therefore, should have posed a
question as to whether any act of inducement on the part
of the appellant has been raised by the second
respondent and whether the appellant had an intention to
cheat him from the very inception. If the dispute between
the parties was essentially a civil dispute resulting from a
breach of contract on the part of the appellants by non-
refunding the amount of advance the same would not
constitute an offence of cheating. Similar is the legal
position in respect of an offence of criminal breach of
trust having regard to its definition contained in Section
405 of the Penal Code."
8. Now, adverting to the facts of the present case, it is
apparent that only allegations levelled by the respondent in the
present case is that the respondent and her family members were the
owners in possession of some land at village Khirazpur, Tehsil and
District Karnal. In fact, they had agreed to sell the land, which was
subject matter to river action to petitioner No. 1 for a sale
consideration. However, the petitioners and other accused had taken
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -11-
the respondent and their family members to the office of
Sub-Registrar and the signatures of the respondent and her family
members were fraudulently taken. Even, they were made to thumb
mark and sign certain blank and printed papers and no document was
ever read over to the respondent and her family members. The
respondent and her family members were photographed at two places
and they were told that there was system of taking photographs at two
places. However, in support of the said allegations, the respondent has
failed to examine any witness and the summoning of the petitioners
has been ordered only on the basis of self-serving statement of the
respondent. Even, the respondent has failed to examine the other
co-sharers, who had also gone to the office of Sub-Registrar and had
signed the two registered sale deeds in favour of petitioner No.1.
Rather from the facts, it is apparent that two registered sale deeds
Nos. 1979/1 and 1981/1 dated 09.06.2008 are outcome of fraud and
misrepresentation of facts and without any consideration. However,
no evidence was led by the respondent to prove the said fact. Rather,
the respondent and her family members had challenged the validity of
both registered sale deeds by way of civil suit (Annexure P-5) and the
civil suit has already been dismissed by the Civil Court. Even, the
appeal filed by the respondent has already been dismissed by the
Appellate Court by observing that the respondent herself had admitted
that the sale deed was duly executed and the vendors had gone to
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -12-
Tehsil office and had put their thumb impressions and signatures and
also got their photographs clicked. Even, both the sale deeds are
registered documents and presumption of truth lies in favour of the
registered documents until and unless the person challenging these
documents proves the fraud committed regarding such documents.
Moreover, it is also proved on the file that the averments made in both
the registered sale deeds were read over and explained to the
respondent and her family members and as a token of its correctness,
the respondent herself had signed on the sale deeds. Apart from that,
even it is an admitted case of the complainant that even the possession
of the land in question was transferred in favour of the petitioners.
Thus, apparently a civil dispute has been illegally converted into a
criminal offence.
9. As a result of above discussion, it is observed that the
dispute in question is purely of civil nature and respondent
complainant has already availed her remedies before the Civil Court
and has rather lost the battle before the trial Court as well as Appellate
Court. As a consequence in the facts and circumstances of the present
case and also in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, the initiation of criminal proceedings by the respondent against
the petitioner is clearly an abuse of the process of the Court.
Consequently, it would be appropriate to invoke the inherent powers
of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the protest petition in
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM M-47741 of 2017 -13-
complaint bearing No.16 dated 24.05.2012 titled as ‘M egha vs.
Nandi Devi and others’, under Sections 406, 420, 120-B and 506 of
IPC, Police Station Civil Lines, Karnal (Annexure P-1), the impugned
summoning order dated 20.12.2016 (Annexure P-12) as well as the
impugned orders dated 14.06.2017 (Annexure P-13) and dated
12.10.2017 (Annexure P-16) passed by the Court of Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Karnal and the Additional Sessions Judge, Karnal
respectively, qua the petitioners only.
10. Ordered accordingly.
11. All pending applications, if any, are disposed off,
accordingly.
12.11.2026 (N.S.SHEKHAWAT)
amit rana JUDGE
Whether reasoned/speaking : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
AMIT RANA
2026.11.17 17:46
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document