Kkh Finvest Pvt. Ltd. vs Ashiesh Shukla

Court
Supreme Court

Non-reportable
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

2026 INSC 803

Civil Appeal No. ..................... of 2026
(@ Special Leave Petition (C) No. 4222 of 2025)



KKH Finvest Pvt. Ltd. and another …Appellants
versus

Ashiesh Shukla and others …Respondents




J U D G M E N T
SANJAY KUMAR, J
1. Leave granted.
2. The scope of this appeal falls within a narrow compass. Notice was
ordered in this matter on 31.01.2025 limited to the observations made in
paragraph Nos. 103 and 104 of the impugned judgment dated 21.10.2024
passed by the Delhi High Court in Arbitration Petition No. 38 of 2024.
3. The short issue that arises for consideration, in the context of
paragraph Nos. 103 and 104 of the judgement, is whether respondent No.
1 herein, Ashiesh Shukla, who was arrayed as respondent No. 6 in the
arbitration petition before the High Court, would also be bound by the
clauses in the Memorandum of Settlement dated 09.05.2022 and would,
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Deepak Guglani
Date: 2026.08.05
16:08:55 IST
Reason:
in consequence, qualify as a veritable party for the purposes of the
arbitration proceedings initiated thereunder.


4. The relevant facts: KKH Finvest Private Limited, appellant No. 1, is
involved in the business of investment, consultancy, development and
promotion of business activities of companies. Appellant No. 1 intended
to take over Sensorise Digital Services Private Limited, appellant No. 2,
and its sister concern, Sensorise Smart Solutions Private Limited, under
Memorandum of Settlement dated 09.05.2022 (MoS). Ashiesh Shukla,
respondent No. 1, was not a signatory to the MoS, which was signed by
appellant No.1 along with appellant No.2, its sister concern and their
promoters, i.e., Sharad Arora and Rajeev Arora. Appellant No. 1 was
referred to as the ‘ buyer’ therein while the following were collectively
referred to as the ‘ ex-Promoter group’ or ‘Sellers ’:
a. ex-Promoters as defined in Schedule 1;
b. the Management Team (MT) as defined in Schedules 1A and 1B;
c. Consultants/Employee Shareholders and ex-MT Members defined
in Schedule 2 and 2A; and
d. Shareholding Family Members and Associate Shareholders defined
under Schedule 2B.

5. Schedule 1 listed the ex-promoters as Rajeev Arora and Sharad
Arora. Schedule 1A named four MT members: Ajay Nandy, Abhishek
Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain. Schedule 1B named a foreign
shareholder/MT member with whom we are not concerned. Schedule 2,
titled ‘List of consultants/employee shareholders’ named Ashiesh Shukla
as a shareholder with 1480 shares, constituting a 0.05% shareholding,
along with another person with whom we are not concerned. Similarly,
Schedules 2A and 2B are not of relevance presently.
2


6. Clause H of the MoS recorded that, based on a consensus that the
buyer would acquire the shares of the sellers and in order to sustain and
maintain appellant No. 2 and its sister concern, the parties to the MoS had
arrived at an understanding to resolve all their disputes once and for all.
Clause I stated that, further to discussions, the buyer agreed to take initial
handover of appellant No. 2 and its sister concern and purchase the
complete shareholding of the sellers for ₹8 crores. The clause recorded
that the shareholding of the persons named in Schedules 1, 1A, 1B and
Schedules 2, 2A and 2B would also be transferred to the buyer.
7. Clause K recorded that, for the sake of convenience, simultaneous
with the MoS, separate Share Purchase Agreements, containing
indemnity, non-disclosure, non-compete and non-solicitation clauses, and
share transfer forms would be executed with persons enlisted in
Schedules 1A, 1B and Schedule 2. It recorded that the ex-promoters
would render full co-operation and assistance in the execution of the said
Share Purchase Agreements and other documents by persons enlisted in
Schedules 1A, 1B, 2 and 2B. It is an admitted fact that, pursuant to the
aforestated clauses in the MoS, Ashiesh Shukla, respondent No. 1, also
executed a Share Purchase Agreement on 09.05.2022. Therein, Ashiesh
Shukla was shown as the seller. Clause E of the said agreement stated
that Ashiesh Shukla was working in appellant No. 2 as a consultant and
was holding 1480 equity shares. Clause G recorded that, based on the
3


consensus, the buyer was acquiring the shares of the ex-promoters, MT,
including the seller and other shareholders of appellant No. 2, for a
settlement amount of ₹8 crore. The assignment of intellectual property;
non-disclosure; non-solicitation and non-compete were all covered by the
clauses that followed thereafter in the said agreement.
8. Clause L of the MoS recorded that, upon acquisition of shares as
aforesaid, appellant No.1 would hold 100% of the issued and paid-up
capital of appellant No. 2 with 100% voting rights, and the sellers’
shareholding would be diluted to nil and get nullified. Sub-clause 20 in
Clause VI, titled ‘Other deeds and documentations’, posited that,
simultaneous to the execution of the MoS, the following documents would
be executed by persons enlisted in Schedules 1A, 1B and Schedule 2:
(1) Share Purchase Agreements containing non-disclosure, non-compete
and non-solicitation and indemnity;
(2) IP assignment deed;
(3) Consultancy Agreement by persons enlisted in Schedule 1A and 1B;
and
(4) All handovers and documentations as required under Schedules 4 and
9 necessary for fulfilment of consultancy for a period of 3 months during
the Transition of Management of appellant No. 2 and its sister concern
as contemplated in the MoS.

9. Sub-clause 43 in Clause X, titled ‘Assignment of intellectual
property’, provided that the persons specified in Schedules 1, 1A, 1B and
2 would assign all registered and/or unregistered copyrights, patents,
trademarks and or designs, referred to as intellectual property, arisen or
created in the course of business or relating to appellant No. 2 or its sister
4


concern’s activities in favour of appellant No. 2. Sub-clause 47 in Clause
XI, titled ‘Non-solicitation and non-compete’ provided that each of the
persons specified in Schedules 1, 1A, 1B and 2 covenant that, for a period
of 4 years after execution of the MoS, they would not directly or indirectly,
jointly, or in conjunction with, any other person, in any manner whatsoever,
except with the prior written consent of appellant No. 1, solicit, interfere
with or endeavour to direct or entice away from appellant No. 2 and its
sister concern, any customer, agent, client, employee or any person, firm
or company dealing with appellant No. 2 or its subsidiaries or affiliates or
associates. Sub-clause 75 in Clause XVIII, titled ‘General Releases’,
provided that the transfer/sale of such shares shall be conclusive,
independent, mutually exclusive and in no way connected with any of the
remaining clauses of the MoS.
10. Sub-clause 78 in Clause XX, titled ‘Dispute Resolution’, provided
that all disputes or differences between the parties in respect of or arising
out of the MoS, including breach, shall at the first instance be resolved
through good faith negotiations between the parties, which negotiations
shall begin promptly after a party delivered to the other party a written
request for such consultation. Sub-clause 79 stated that, if the parties
were unable to resolve the disputes in question within 21 business days
of the commencement of negotiations in terms of sub-clause 78, then the
dispute shall, unless the parties otherwise agree in writing, be referred to
5


1
arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 .
It further provided that the dispute shall be submitted for arbitration to a
sole arbitrator to be jointly appointed by the parties. Sub-clause 80 stated
that, if the parties fail to mutually appoint a sole arbitrator then, in the
absence of such agreement, a sole arbitrator is to be appointed in
accordance with the provisions of the 1996 Act.
11. Disputes did arise after execution of the MoS and in due course
appellant No. 1 issued Arbitration Invocation Notice dated 10.09.2022 to
the ex-promoters, i.e., Rajeev Arora and Sharad Arora. On its application
filed under Section 11 of the 1996 Act, the Delhi High Court appointed
Hon’ble Mr. Justice T.S. Thakur (Retired), Former Chief Justice of India,
as the sole Arbitrator on 12.04.2023.
12. However, in its Statement of Claims filed before the learned
Arbitrator on 11.07.2023, appellant No. 1 included parties who were not
privy to the application filed by it under Section 11 of the 1996 Act. The
parties so added included Ashiesh Shukla, respondent No. 1, and others,
viz., Ajay Nandy, Abhishek Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain, who
figured in Schedule 1A, i.e., the list of MT members. As objections were
raised by them on this ground before the learned Arbitrator, by filing
applications under Section 16 of the 1996 Act, appellant No. 1 and
appellant No. 2 jointly filed another application under Section 11 of the

1
For short, ‘the 1996 Act’
6


1996 Act in Arbitration Petition No. 38 of 2024 seeking reference of the
disputes relating to the aforestated persons, viz., Ashiesh Shukla, Ajay
Nandy, Abhishek Batra Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain, to arbitration before
the same learned Arbitrator.
13. The impugned judgment came to be passed by a learned Judge of
the Delhi High Court upon this application. The learned Judge noted
therein that the issues for consideration were whether, on a prima facie
view, the arbitration agreement contained in the MoS could be extended
to respondent Nos. 2 to 9 who were non-signatories to the MoS and
whether the Court had the power to consolidate arbitration proceedings.
Noting that, being a referral Court, he was only required to take a prima
facie view on whether there existed an arbitration agreement and whether
the respondents who were non-signatories to the MoS were veritable
parties to the same, the learned Judge noted the decision of this Court in
2
.
Cox and Kings Limited vs. SAP India Private Limited and another
14. The learned Judge summed up that that the assessment required
to be undertaken by him so as to ascertain whether the respondents were
veritable parties or not was primarily an assessment regarding the
conduct, role and involvement of such non-signatories in the underlying
contract, i.e., the MoS. He observed that, in order to undertake such
assessment, he was required to consider factors such as mutual intent,

2
(2024) 4 SCC 1
7


relationship between the signatories and non-signatories, commonality of
the subject matter, composite nature of transactions and the performance
of the contract. Apropos Ajay Nandy, Abhishek Batra, Prasun Nigam and
Achin Jain, the learned Judge noted that they fell in Schedule 1A of the
MoS, constituting the MT. The learned Judge noted that the obligations
under the MoS were also required to be performed by them to give full
effect to it and opined that a bare reading of the MoS suggested that they
held specific roles and responsibilities under the MoS, which now formed
the core of the disputes in the ongoing arbitral proceedings. As individual
Share Purchase Agreements were also executed by them which
contained mirror obligations, indicating prima facie the inter-connected
nature of those agreements with the MoS, the learned held that it would
be difficult to dissociate them from the obligations of the MoS carried out
by them. The learned Judge noted that the objective of the MoS was for
appellant No. 1 to take complete control over the business, management,
administration and running of the operations of appellant No. 2 and the
shareholding of the MT necessarily had to be transferred too. Observing
thus, the learned Judge concluded that the Share Purchase Agreements
were a creation of the MoS and the performance of the MoS would not be
complete without execution and performance of those agreements. The
learned Judge accordingly held that, in his prima facie view, the
transactions were composite in nature, as the common goal of both
8


agreements was to ensure complete transfer of control and ownership of
appellant No. 2 and its sister concern to appellant No. 1. As a result, the
learned Judge held that the obligations under the MoS and the Share
Purchase Agreements were so interwoven that the performance under
one agreement directly impacted the obligations under the other in
furthering the overall objective of transition of appellant No. 2 to appellant
No. 1. The learned Judge, therefore, held that Ajay Nandy, Abhishek
Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain were veritable parties to the
arbitration agreement contained in the MoS. The disputes relating to them
were, accordingly, referred to arbitration by the learned Arbitrator who was
already appointed.
15. However, considering the case of Ashiesh Shukla separately, the
learned Judge opined that there was a distinguishing feature in the Share
Purchase Agreement executed by him, i.e., Clause 16, which reads thus:
‘16. The transfer/sale of such shares shall be conclusive, independent,
mutually exclusive and in no way connected with any of the remaining
clauses of the present SPA and the MoS dated 09.05.2022.’

16. Observing that this clause expressly showcased the intention of
Ashiesh Shukla not to be bound by any of the clauses in the MoS, as it
categorically separated the sale of shares from the other obligations and
disputes arising under the MoS, the learned Judge opined that invoking
arbitration against him on the basis of the MoS would be legally
unsustainable. Per the learned Judge, Clause No 16 unambiguously
9


disconnected any and all issues between the Share Purchase Agreement
and the MoS and as there was no separate arbitration agreement between
Ashiesh Shukla and the other contracting parties in his Share Purchase
Agreement, the learned Judge concluded that no case was made out
against Ashiesh Shukla for reference to arbitration. The learned Judge
observed that if he was referred to arbitration, it would render Clause 16
of the Share Purchase Agreement redundant and meaningless.
17. Surprisingly, the learned Judge failed to take note of a crucial fact
while making the above observations. The Share Purchase Agreements
executed by Ajay Nandy, Abhishek Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain
contained a clause identical to Clause 16 in Ashiesh Shukla’s Share
Purchase Agreement. The agreement of Prasun Nigam replicated the
aforestated Clause 16 in Clause 24 while the agreement executed by
Abhishek Batra mirrored it in Clause 24. The agreement executed by Ajay
Nandy duplicated the same in Clause 28 and, lastly, the agreement of
Achin Jain stated to the same effect in Clause 23. Therefore, the logic
applied to the four of them in the context of qualifying them as veritable
parties equally applied to Ashiesh Shukla, notwithstanding Clause 16 in
the Share Purchase Agreement executed by him.
18. We may also note that certain clauses in the Share Purchase
Agreement dated 09.05.2022 executed by Ashiesh Shukla clinched the
issue in so far as he was concerned. The clauses read as under:
10


‘F. Certain disputes arose between the Buyer and the ex-Promoters of
SDS. In order to resolve their pending disputes amicably, the Buyer and
ex-Promoters have entered into a Memorandum of Settlement (“MoS”)
dated 09.05.2022.
G. Now, based on a consensus, the Buyer is acquiring the shares of ex-
Promoters, Management Team including the Seller and other
shareholders of SDS for a Settlement Amount of Rs. 8 Crores ( including
the proportionate Settlement Amount of Seller ).
H. The present SPA is being executed with the Seller for his 1480 equity
shares in SDS and the proportionate settlement amount of Rs.
86,831.60/- (Eighty-Six Thousand Eight Hundred Thirty One Rupees and
Sixty Paisa) is being paid to the Seller by the Buyer for the sale/transfer
of such shares.’ (emphasis is ours)

In the light of the above clauses, there can be no doubting the fact
that Ashiesh Shukla committed himself to the sale of his shares and to be
bound by the terms of the MoS dated 09.05.2022.
19. We may also note that, in terms of the law laid down in Cox and
Kings Limited ( supra ), the principle of ‘veritable parties’ would be
applicable in situations where a person or entity may not sign an
arbitration agreement, yet give the appearance of being a veritable party
to such agreement due to that person/entity’s legal relationship with the
signatory parties and involvement in the performance of the underlying
contract. This Court observed that the participation of a non-signatory in
the performance of the underlying contract is the most important factor to
be considered as the conduct of the non-signatory parties is an indicator
of the intention of those parties to be bound by the arbitration agreement.
This Court further observed that the intention of the parties to be bound
11


by an arbitration agreement could be gauged from the circumstances that
surround the participation of such non-signatory party in the negotiation,
performance and termination of the underlying contract, containing such
agreement. Further, observing that there was a need to strike a balance
between the consensual nature of arbitration and modern commercial
reality, where a non-signatory becomes implicated in a commercial
transaction in a number of different ways, this Court held that the balance
could be adequately achieved if the factors laid down in Oil and Natural
Gas Corporation Limited vs. Discovery Enterprises Private Limited
3
and another are applied holistically. Elaborating further, it was observed
that the involvement of a non-signatory in the performance of the
underlying contract in a manner that suggests that it intended to be bound
by the contract containing the arbitration agreement is an important
aspect. Other factors, such as the composite nature of the transaction and
commonality of subject matter, were also held to suggest that claims
against a non-signatory are interlinked with the issues under arbitration.
20. Applying the aforestated principles, it is clear that the performance
of his obligations by Ashiesh Shukla under his Share Purchase Agreement
was fundamental to the completion of the obligations spelt out in the MoS.
Being a shareholder in his own right, unless Ashiesh Shukla also
transferred his shares, the MoS would inevitably remain incomplete.

3
(2022) 8 SCC 42
12


Further, as already noted supra , the learned Judge had found Ajay Nandy,
Abhishek Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain to be veritable parties in
the context of almost identical Share Purchase Agreements executed by
them. Their obligations as members of the MT may have included certain
functions that were not applicable to Ashiesh Shukla, a consultant
shareholder, but the irrefutable fact remains that all other acts to be
undertaken by persons listed in Schedule 1A, as spelt out by the terms of
the MoS, referred to hereinabove, equally applied to him. In effect, there
was no real point of distinction between Ashiesh Shukla when compared
to Ajay Nandy, Abhishek Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain. The
difference drawn by the learned Judge between these identically situated
persons was not founded on fact and is entirely unsustainable in the light
of the similar agreements executed by all of them.
21. The appeal is accordingly allowed, setting aside the judgment dated
21.10.2024 in so far as it related to Ashiesh Shukla, respondent No. 1. He
is also held to be a veritable party to the MoS and would, therefore, be
amenable to having his disputes with appellant Nos. 1 and 2 referred to
arbitration. As a learned Arbitrator is already seized of the disputes arising
under the MoS and the Share Purchase Agreements executed by Ajay
Nandy, Abhishek Batra, Prasun Nigam and Achin Jain, we deem it
appropriate to refer the disputes pertaining to Ashiesh Shukla also to the
same learned Arbitrator.
13


22. Hon’ble Mr. Justice T.S. Thakur (Retired), Former Chief Justice of
India, is appointed as the sole Arbitrator to undertake adjudication of the
disputes between appellant Nos. 1 and 2 and Ashiesh Shukla, respondent
No. 1. The other terms and conditions spelt out by the Delhi High Court
as to such appointment shall apply. All issues are left open to be
considered by the learned Arbitrator on facts and in accordance with law.
23. Parties shall bear their own costs.
..............................., J.
(SANJAY KUMAR)




..............................., J.
(SANJEEV SACHDEVA)

AUGUST 5, 2026
NEW DELHI.
14