ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 20486 of 2024
With
CAN No. 1 of 2025
With
CAN No. 2 of 2025
With
CAN No. 3 of 2026
Additional Director General of Police,
State Crime Records Bureau, Kerala
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Nandini Mitra
Mr. Samim Ahammed
Ms. Gulsanwara Pervin
Ms. Saloni Bhattacharya
....For the petitioner.
2
Ms. Manju Manot Agarwal, Ld. AGP
Ms. Sudipta Banerjee
Mr. Bhaskar Bhattacharyya
....For the State.
Mr. Naresh Kohli
.... The Respondent no. 4 in-person.
Hearing Concluded On : 13.11.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 20.11.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 20.11.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1. The issue raised by the petitioner is that whether the respondent no. 3
can claim to be a Micro and Small Enterprises so as to avail the
benefits of the provisions of Section 18 of the Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as “MSMED
Act”).
th
2. By a notice inviting tender dated 10 October, 2018, the petitioner
invited bids from reputed manufacturers/authorized dealers or reputed
venders for the supply, implementation and maintenance of DMR Tier
III based Trunked Wireless Communication System at Thrissur District
valued at Rs. 14.728 Crores. The respondent no. 3 had participated in
nd
the said tender process and was declared as successful bidder. On 22
March, 2019, an agreement was entered between the Kerala
3
Government and the respondent no. 3 for the execution of the works
mentioned in the tender documents.
3. As per Clause 12(1) of the agreement, the respondent no. 3 was
supposed to complete the work within a period of six (6) months from
the date of the issuance of work order. The work order was issued on
nd
22 March, 2019 and the work was supposed to be completed within
nd
22 September, 2019.
4. Mr. Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya, Learned Senior Advocate,
representing the petitioner submits that the respondent no. 3 has not
completed the work and the DMR system has not been commissioned.
th
On 13 September, 2023, the petitioner received an email from the
respondent no.2 requesting the petitioner to appear for conciliation
proceedings in connection with an application filed by the respondent
no.3. He submits that on the date of agreement, the respondent no.3
was not registered under the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises and
as per the application filed before the respondent no.2 it reveals that
the respondent no.3 registered under the MSMED Act, 2006 only on
rd
23 March, 2023 that is much after execution of the agreement
between the petitioner and the respondent no.3.
5. Mr. Bhattacharyya submits that the respondent no. 2 ought not to have
referred the application even for conciliation as on the date of execution
of contract, the respondent no. 3 was not registered as MSME. He
submits that subsequent registration of the respondent no.3 as an
4
MSME would not be applicable retrospectively. The petitioner has filed
a detailed statement of defence and in the statement of defence, the
petitioner specifically pleaded the said fact as a preliminary objection
and it was also pointed out that the respondent no.3 is not a
manufacturer, it cannot take recourse of the provisions of the MSMED
Act, 2006.
6. The conciliator proceeded with the conciliation proceedings under
th
Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006. Ultimately by a notice dated 28
March, 2024, the conciliation process is terminated under Section 18(2)
of the MSMED Act, 2006 and referred the matter for Arbitration under
Section 18(3) of the MSMED Act, 2006. The respondent no.3 has filed
statement of claim in the arbitration proceeding and the petitioner
without prejudice to their rights and contentions, has filed the
th
statement of defence pursuant to the notice dated 28 March, 2024.
st
On 31 July, 2024, the Arbitrator has issued notice to the petitioner by
th
fixing the date of hearing of the arbitration proceeding on 12 August,
2024. He submits that since reference is without jurisdiction, the
Arbitration proceeding cannot be proceeded further.
7. Mr. Bhattacharyya has relied upon the judgment in the case of Gujarat
State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited Vs. Mahakali Foods
Private Limited (UNIT 2) & Anr. reported in (2023) 6 SCC 401 and
submits that a party cannot become a micro or small enterprise or a
supplier to claim the benefit under the MSMED Act, 2006 by
5
submitting a Memorandum to obtain registration subsequent to
entering into the contract and supply of goods or rendering services.
st
8. Mr. Bhattacharyya submits that by a communication dated 31 July,
2024, the Chairman, West Bengal Micro and Small Enterprises
Facilitation Council informed that one Mr. Alok Tibrewal will also be a
member of the Arbitral Tribunal but the petitioner has raised an
objection that Mr. Tibrewal was the member of Facilitation Council and
he should not be the member of Arbitral Tribunal. He has relied upon
the judgment in the case of Tamil Nadu Cements Corporation
Limited Vs. Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council and
Another reported in (2025) 4 SCC 1 and submits that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had referred the matter to the larger Bench of Five
Judges to decide whether the members of MSEFC who undertake
conciliation proceedings, upon failure, can themselves act as
arbitrators of the Arbitral Tribunal in terms of Section 18 of the
MSMED Act, 2006, read with Section 80 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996.
9. Mr. Bhattacharyya submits that unless the larger Bench is not decided
the issue, the Member of the Facilitation Council should not be allowed
to be a member of the Arbitral Tribunal in terms of the several
judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10. Ms. Manju Manot Agarwal, Learned AGP, representing the respondent
nos. 1 and 2 submits that the writ petition filed by the petitioner is
6
premature. Learned AGP submits that the petitioner has participated in
the Facilitation Council by filing statement of defence and after
termination of the conciliation proceeding, the respondent no.3 has
filed statement of claim and the petitioner has filed its statement of
defence and appeared before the Arbitral Tribunal.
11. Ms. Agarwal submits that the petitioner has liberty to take recourse of
Section 16 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by raising the
point of jurisdiction before the Arbitral Tribunal but instead of doing so
has filed the present writ petition.
12. Mr. Naresh Kohli, being the respondent no.4 appeared in-person by
adopting the submissions of Ms. Agarwal submits that the petitioner
has participated in both the proceedings before the Facilitation Council
as well as before the Arbitral Tribunal. He submits that the respondent
th
no.3 has filed statement of claim on 16 April, 2024 and the petitioner
nd
has filed statement of defence on 2 May, 2025. As per the notice
st
dated 31 July, 2024, issued by the Arbitral Tribunal, the petitioner
th
has appeared before the Tribunal on 12 August, 2024 but the fact of
filing of the writ petition was not brought to the notice of the Tribunal,
th
though the petitioner has filed the writ petition on 9 August, 2024.
13. Mr. Kholi submits that though at the time of execution of the
nd
agreement dated 22 March, 2019, the respondent no.3 was not
registered with MSME but the respondent no.3 registered with MSME
7
rd
on 23 March, 2022 and the work continued till 2023 and thus the
respondent no.3 is entitled to get benefit of MSME registration.
14. Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006, reads as follows:
“ 18. Reference to Micro and Small
Enterprises Facilitation Council.—
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any
other law for the time being in force, any
party, to a dispute may, with regard to any
amount due under section 17, make a
reference to the Micro and Small Enterprises
Facilitation Council.
(2) On receipt of a reference under sub-section (1),
the Council shall either itself conduct
conciliation in the matter or seek the
assistance of any institution or centre
providing alternate dispute resolution services
by making a reference to such an institution or
centre, for conducting conciliation and the
provisions of sections 65 to 81 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of
1996) shall apply to such a dispute as if the
conciliation was initiated under Part III of that
Act.
(3) Where the conciliation initiated under sub-
section (2) is not successful and stands
terminated without any settlement between
the parties, the Council shall either itself take
up the dispute for arbitration or refer to it any
institution or centre providing alternate
dispute resolution services for such arbitration
and the provisions of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) shall then
apply to the dispute as if the arbitration was
in pursuance of an arbitration agreement
referred to in sub-section (1) of section 7 of
that Act.
8
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in any
other law for the time being in force, the Micro
and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council or
the centre providing alternate dispute
resolution services shall have jurisdiction to
act as an Arbitrator or Conciliator under this
section in a dispute between the supplier
located within its jurisdiction and a buyer
located anywhere in India.
(5) Every reference made under this section shall
be decided within a period of ninety days from
the date of making such a reference.”
15. In the case of Jharkhand Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd. Vs. State of
Rajasthan reported in (2021) 19 SCC 206, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that:
“ 14. From a reading of Sections 18(2) and
SMED
18(3) of the M Act it is clear that the Council is
obliged to conduct conciliation for which the
provisions of Sections 65 to 81 of the Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 would apply, as if the
conciliation was initiated under Part III of the said
Act. Under Section 18(3), when conciliation fails
and stands terminated, the dispute between the
parties can be resolved by arbitration. The Council
is empowered either to take up arbitration on its
own or to refer the arbitration proceedings to any
institution as specified in the said section. It is open
to the Council to arbitrate and pass an award, after
following the procedure under the relevant
provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996, particularly Sections 20, 23, 24 and 25.
15. There is a fundamental difference
between conciliation and arbitration. In conciliation,
the conciliator assists the parties to arrive at an
amicable settlement, in an impartial and
independent manner. In arbitration, the Arbitral
Tribunal/arbitrator adjudicates the disputes
between the parties. The claim has to be proved
before the arbitrator, if necessary, by adducing
9
evidence, even though the rules of the Civil
Procedure Code or the Evidence Act may not apply.
Unless otherwise agreed, oral hearings are to be
held.
16. If the appellant had not submitted its
reply at the conciliation stage, and failed to appear,
the Facilitation Council could, at best, have
recorded the failure of conciliation and proceeded to
initiate arbitration proceedings in accordance with
the relevant provisions of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, to adjudicate the dispute
and make an award. Proceedings for conciliation
and arbitration cannot be clubbed.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court struck down the order passed by
MSEFC as being nullity and contrary to the provisions of the MSMED
Act, 2006 and the mandatory provisions of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996. The Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that the
order under challenged was not an award in the eye of law hence the
recourse to Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996,
was not required. The writ petition was held to be maintainable
notwithstanding the objections on account of delay and latches.
16. In the case of India Glycols Ltd. & Anr. Vs. S.R. Technologies
reported in (2025) 5 SCC 780, by referring the judgment in the case of
Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. Vs. Mahakali Foods
(P) Ltd. reported in (2023) 3 SCC (Civil) 7 held that a writ petition
under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India was not
maintainable as Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006, provides for
recourse to a statutory remedy for challenging an award under Section
34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. A particular reference
10
was made under Section19 of the MSMED Act, 2006, which states that
no application for setting aside a decree, award or order made by the
MSEFC/ institution / centre providing for alternative dispute resolution
services shall be entertained by a Court unless the appellant (not being
a supplier) has deposited with it seventy five percent of the amount in
terms of the decree, award or order in the manner as directed by the
Court.
17. Section 18 of the MSMED Act, 2006, provides for statutory and
mandatory conciliation on the reference being made to MSEFC by any
party to a dispute with regard to an amount due under Section 17 of
the MSMED Act, 2006. Section 17 states that for the goods supplied or
services rendered by the supplier, the buyer shall be liable to pay the
amount with interest thereon as provided in Section 16. Section 16
states that where a buyer fails to make payment of the amount to the
supplier, as required under Section 15, the buyer shall,
notwithstanding anything contained in any agreement between the
buyer and the supplier or in any other law for the timer being in force,
be liable to pay compound interest with monthly rests to the supplier
from the appointed date or from the date immediately following the date
agreed upon, at three times of the bank rate notified by the Reserve
Bank.
18. Some of the provisions of MSMED Act, 2006 are required to be noted.
The relevant provisions would be Section 2(b) which defines “appointed
day”, Sections 2(e) which defines “enterprise”, Section 2(h) which
11
defines “micro enterprise”, Section 2(m) which defines “small
enterprise”, Section 2(n) which defines “supplier”, also Chapter III
which interalia deals with Classification of Enterprises, Advisory
Committee and Memorandum of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
which contains Sections 7 and 8. Section 7 providing for classification
of enterprises, and Section 8 providing for Memorandum of micro,
small and medium enterprises.
19. The statement of object and reasons specifies that the object of the
legislation is also to provide a single legal framework concerning the
entire small and medium enterprises sector and to address their
concerns. It is in the context of this object and intention of the
legislation, the provisions would be required to be appreciated.
20. It needs to be observed that primarily it would not be for this Court
considering the provisions of the MSMED Act, 2006, and more
particularly in the nature of the present proceedings to make an
endeavour to undertake an exercise of classification of enterprises and
determine as to whether a particular enterprise is an enterprise falling
within Section 2(e) of the Act or whether it is a small enterprise
classified under Section 2(m). This for the reason that for this exercise
there is a special procedure as set out and on the examination of
particular parameters it is for the appropriate authority to certify as to
whether a particular enterprise satisfies a category so as to fall under
the Act. All this would be within the realm and jurisdiction of the
respective authorities as recognized by the MSMED Act.
12
21. Taking into consideration of the above, it is to be seen that whether the
respondent no.3 can claim to be a Micro and Small Enterprises for the
purpose of the present dispute, so as to avail the benefits of the
provisions of Section 18 of the MSMED Act. Admittedly on the date of
execution of contract between the petitioner and the respondent no.3,
the respondent no.3 was not the MSME. The respondent no.3
rd
registered with MSME only on 23 March, 2022. After registration
under MSME, the respondent no.3 submitted reference before the
th
MSEFC on 16 October, 2023.
22. The petitioner has submitted defence statement against the reference
raising the point of maintainability which reads as follows:
“ 1. In the very outset it is submitted that the
reference made by the so called supplier is not
maintainable for the following reasons:-
i. Admittedly as per the data submitted by the
claimant, the date of filing of Udayam
Registration was on 23.03.2022.
ii. It is the further admitted fact that, the
number in Samadhaan portal and the date of
filing application was on 19.9.2023.
iii. It is further admitted by claimant this as
per UDAYAM registration certificate the date of
incorporation was on 26.06.2015, and the
major activity shown for the purpose of
registration is manufacturing but the claimant
had admittedly procured the material from
another manufacturer and agreed to supply to
the buyer i.e respondent herein.
iv. As per the agreement dated 22.03.2019
entered in to between the department and the
'contractor', the scope of work, is supply,
implementation, and maintenance of DMR tier
III, based trunked wireless communication
13
systems, which are admittedly to be procured
by the 'contractor' from another manufacturer.
v. The specifications and the items description
shown in the agreement dated 22.03.2019,
which was agreed to be supplied by the
contractor was not admittedly manufactured
by the contractor /claimant herein.
2. It is further relevant to note that as per the bid
submitted by the contractor/claimant herein, it will
not come within the defined scope of either of
medium, or micro or small enterprises under Sec 2
of MSME Act.
3. The claimant herein does not satisfy definition of
any of the categories i.e medium enterprise as per
Sec 2 (g), or micro enterprise defined under Sec 2
(h) or small enterprise defined under Sec 2 (m).
4. It is the admitted factual of position that the
turnover of the claimant company, is much beyond
the pecuniary limited overed under the MSME Act
(herein after referred as per the Act).
5. It is further clear from the biding document that
the claimant does not come within the defined
scope of 'business concern' engaged in the
manufacture or production of goods, in any manner
pertaining to any industry specified in the first
schedule to the Act 1951.
6. It is further clear that the agreement entered into
between by the department and the claimant
herein is not for providing or rendering of any
service or services.
7. Therefore, it can be safely concluded that the
very reference under Sec 18, made by the claimant
herein is absolutely beyond the scope of MSME Act
and for that reason alone this Hon'ble Council lacks
jurisdiction to entertain the claim.”
th
23. By a memorandum dated 28 March, 2024, the Chairman,
WBSMSEFC terminated the conciliation proceeding without any
settlement between the parties and referred the matter for Arbitration.
14
The petitioner has raised the point of maintainability but the Council
without deciding the issues has held that the Council has the
jurisdiction to act an Arbitrator. In terms of the Memorandum dated
th
28 March, 2024, the respondent no.3 has filed statement of claim and
the petitioner has filed defence statement. In the defence statement also
the petitioner has raised the point of maintainability which reads as
follows:
““ 1. In the very outset it is submitted that the
reference made by the so called supplier is not
maintainable for the following reasons:-
i. Admittedly as per the data submitted by the
claimant, the date of filing of Udayam
Registration was on 23.03.2022.
ii. It is the further admitted fact that, the
number in Samadhaan portal and the date of
filing application was on 19.9.2023.
iii. It is further admitted by claimant this as
per UDAYAM registration certificate the date of
incorporation was on 26.06.2015, and the
major activity shown for the purpose of
registration is manufacturing but the claimant
had admittedly procured the material from
another manufacturer and agreed to supply to
the buyer i.e respondent herein.
iv. As per the agreement dated 22.03.2019
entered in to between the department and the
'contractor', the scope of work, is supply,
implementation, and maintenance of DMR tier
III, based trunked wireless communication
systems, which are admittedly to be procured
by the 'contractor' from another manufacturer.
v. The specifications and the items description
shown in the agreement dated 22.03.2019,
which was agreed to be supplied by the
contractor was not admittedly manufactured
by the contractor /claimant herein.
15
2. It is further relevant to note that as per the bid
submitted by the contractor/claimant herein, it will
not come within the defined scope of either of
medium, or micro or small enterprises under Sec 2
of MSME Act.”
24. In the case of Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that:
“49. One of the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the buyers was that if the party
supplier was not the “supplier” within the meaning
of Section 2(n) of the M SMED Act, 2006 on the date
of the contract entered into between the parties, it
could not have made reference of dispute to Micro
and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council under
Section 18(1) of the M SMED Act, 2006 and in such
cases, the Council would not have the jurisdiction
to decide the disputes as an arbitrator.
50. At this juncture, very pertinent
observations made by this Court in Silpi Industries
case on this issue are required to be reproduced :
“42. … In our view, to seek the benefit of
SMED
provisions under the M Act, the seller
should have registered under the provisions of
the Act, as on the date of entering into the
contract. In any event, for the supplies
pursuant to the contract made before the
registration of the unit under provisions of the
M SMED Act, no benefit can be sought by such
entity, as contemplated under M SMED Act.
43. While interpreting the provisions of
Interest on Delayed Payments to Small Scale
and Ancillary Industrial Undertakings Act,
1993, this Court, in the judgment in Shanti
Conductors (P) Ltd. v. Assam SEB has held
that date of supply of goods/services can be
taken as the relevant date, as opposed to date
on which contract for supply was entered, for
applicability of the aforesaid Act. Even
applying the said ratio also, the appellant is
not entitled to seek the benefit of the Act. By
16
taking recourse to filing memorandum under
sub-section (1) of Section 8 of the Act,
subsequent to entering into contract and
supply of goods and services, one cannot
assume the legal status of being classified
SMED
under the M Act, 2006, as an enterprise,
to claim the benefit retrospectively from the
date on which appellant entered into contract
with the respondent.
44. The appellant cannot become micro or
small enterprise or supplier, to claim the
benefits within the meaning of the M SMED Act
2006, by submitting a memorandum to obtain
registration subsequent to entering into the
contract and supply of goods and services. If
any registration is obtained, same will be
prospective and applies for supply of goods
and services subsequent to registration but
cannot operate retrospectively. Any other
interpretation of the provision would lead to
absurdity and confer unwarranted benefit in
favour of a party not intended by legislation.”
51. Following the abovestated ratio, it is held
that a party who was not the “supplier” as per
Section 2(n) of the M SMED Act, 2006 on the date of
entering into the contract, could not seek any
SMED
benefit as a supplier under the M Act, 2006. A
party cannot become a micro or small enterprise or
a supplier to claim the benefit under the M SMED Act,
2006 by submitting a memorandum to obtain
registration subsequent to entering into the contract
and supply of goods or rendering services. If any
registration is obtained subsequently, the same
would have the effect prospectively and would
apply for the supply of goods and rendering
services subsequent to the registration. The same
cannot operate retrospectively. However, such
issue being jurisdictional issue, if raised could also
be decided by the Facilitation
Council/Institute/Centre acting as an Arbitral
Tribunal under the M SMED Act, 2006.”
25. The petitioner has already filed defence statement before the
Arbitral Tribunal and raised the point of maintainability and
17
jurisdictional issues of the claim made by the respondent no.3. In view
of the above, it is proper that the Arbitral Tribunal should decide the
issue whether the claim filed by the respondents is maintainable and
whether the Tribunal is having jurisdiction to decide the issue raised
by the respondents though at the time of execution of the agreement,
the respondent was not MSME.
26. In view of the above, the Learned Tribunal is directed to decide the
issue as early as possible preferably within the period of eight (8) weeks
from the date of receipt of this order.
27. WPA No. 20486 of 2024 is thus disposed of . Accordingly, all
connected applications are disposed of .
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)