Manish Kumar vs Railway Board And Anr

Court
Delhi High Court

$~39
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
# CNR No. DLHC010969222025
+ W.P.(C) 18345/2025
MANISH KUMAR .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Amar Jain and Mr. Sarah,
Advs.

versus
RAILWAY BOARD AND ANR .....Respondents
Through: Mr. P.S. Singh, CGSC with Ms.
Rupali Sinha, GP for UOI

CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
% 08.09.2026

C.HARI SHANKAR, J.

1
1. The Union Public Service Commission issued Notification
dated 28 September 2016 for conducting the Engineering Services
Examination 2017. The petitioner applied as a physically handicapped
category. He cleared the preliminary examination, the mains
examination and a personality test. He was thereafter subjected to a
medical examination conducted by the Railway Board on 11 October
2017. Aggrieved by the decision of the Railway Board, the petitioner
appealed to the Appellate Medical Board which, by its report dated 11
January 2018, opined that the petitioner was suffering from
neurological complaints with Generalised Dystonia with Myoclonus

1
“UPSC” hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 1 of 7

and Dysarthria. This report resulted in the issuance, to the petitioner, a
show cause notice dated 12 February 2018, requiring him to show
cause as to how he could be considered as a candidate suffering with
disabilities, as the neurological condition of Generalised Dystonia
with Myoclonus and Dysarthria was not an identified disability in
2
Annexure I to the Engineering Services Examination Rules, 2017 .

2. The petitioner responded on 15 February 2018. In his response,
the petitioner submitted that he was in possession of three disability
certificates, of which one was issued by the Govind Ballabh Pant
3
Hospital and another by the Institute of Human Behaviour and Allied
4
Sciences , apart from a certificate which stated that his neurological
condition had affected his speech. The petitioner submitted, therefore,
that his disabilities constituted “physical disability” within the
5
meaning of Section 2(zc) of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities
6 7
Act, 2016 read with Clause 1(D)1 of the Schedule thereto. The
petitioner further submitted that he was capable of performing a
majority of the physical requirements enlisted in Annexure I to the
ESE Rules and that the Appellate Medical Board had also confirmed
that both legs and hands of the petitioner were well formed, so that his
disability would not come in the way of discharge of his duties. Given
these facts, and the fact that he was a meritorious candidate who had
cleared all rounds of the selection, the petitioner submitted that his

2
"the ESE Rules" hereinafter.
3
"the GB Pant Hospital" hereinafter
4
“IHBAS” hereinafter
5
(zc) “specified disability” means the disabilities as specified in the Schedule.
6
“the RPwD Act" hereinafter
7
“ 1(D)1 Physical disability-
*
D. "speech and language disability" means a permanent disability arising out of conditions
such as laryngectomy or aphasia affecting one or more components of speech and language due to
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 2 of 7

candidature ought not to be cancelled.

3. Apparently dissatisfied with the response of the petitioner, the
Railway Board, vide communication dated 12/13 March 2018,
cancelled the petitioner’s candidature for the ESE 2017 on the ground
that the neurological condition of Generalised Dystonia with
Myoclonus and Dysarthria, from which the petitioner was suffering,
was not identified as suitable for any of the services/posts which were
proposed to be filled by the ESE.

4. Aggrieved by the said decision, the petitioner approached this
Court by means of WP (C) 4200/2018 which, by order dated 29 April
2019, was transferred by this Court to the Central Administrative
8
Tribunal , where it was registered as OA 1409/2019.

5. On the ground that the neurological disorder from which the
petitioner was suffering was not classified as a disorder which would
entitle the candidates to be appointed in the civil engineering category
to which he aspired, the Tribunal has, by judgment dated 27
September 2024, dismissed the OA filed by the petitioner.

6. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has approached this Court by
means of the present writ petition.

7. We have heard Mr. Amar Jain, learned Counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. P.S. Singh, learned CGSC for the respondent, at
length.

organic or neurological causes.
8
"the Tribunal" hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 3 of 7

8. Mr. Jain points out that, on the basis of the disability certificate
9
issued to him, the petitioner was issued a Unique Disability ID card
by the Government of India, which certified the type of disability from
which he was suffering to be “locomotor disability” to the extent of
45%. A screenshot of the UDID card issued to the petitioner issued to
the petitioner may be provided as under:




9. Mr. Jain further submits that Notification dated 1 June 2001
issued by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, which is
the nodal Ministry dealing with the administration of the RPwD Act,
has defined “locomotor disability” as “a person’s inability to execute
distinctive activities associated with moving both himself and objects,
from place to place and such inability resulting from affliction of
musculoskeletal and/or nervous system”. The medical certificate
issued to the petitioner, it is pointed out, certified that, owing to his
neurological condition, his movement and ability to execute
movement were restricted. This, submits Mr. Jain, would constitute
“locomotor disability” as defined in the Notification dated 1 June
2001.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 4 of 7

10. In this context, Mr. Jain also places reliance on order dated 18
May 2018 issued by the State Commissioner for Persons with
10
Disabilities , which confirmed that the petitioner was a person
suffering from locomotor disability. Paras 14, 15 and 16 of the said
order read thus:

“14. In view of the position explained in the preceding
paragraphs there has definitely been an error on the part of the
certifying authority of Respondent No. 1 while issuing disability
certificate to the complainant to his disadvantage. In my view,
therefore, Respondent No. 1 should correct the error and issue the
disability certificate in respect of the complainant in Form-IV or
Form-IX for locomotor disability based on the assessment based
on the assessment made in 2012 as his disability was permanent
physical impairment as per the disability certificate issued on
03.07.2012 and I recommend accordingly.

15. It is also observed that the neurological condition has
majorly affected the locomotive condition of the right arm of the
complainant. It has caused mild speech impairment with no impact
on his functional ability. The impact on other body parts of the
complainant also does not appear to be so disabling as to affect his
functional ability.

16. Although determination of suitability or otherwise of the
complainant for civil engineering job falls within the purview of
Railway Board/Determination of Empowerment of Persons with
Disabilities/Chief Commissioner for Persons with Disabilities,
government of India yet I feel it in the fitness of things to record
my view that the study of civil engineering involves practical and
if the complainant with the same extent of disability has
successfully completed his studies, performed the practical sand
has secured the degree, there is no reason why such a person
should not be considered suitable for the engineering service
involving civil engineering functions. Moreover, it has been
proved by many persons with disabilities that no 2 persons with
same type and percentage of disability can be functionally the
same. For example, a person with both arms amputated is doing
the work of a tailor and is earning his livelihood in India though
the post of Taylor is not identified a person know has disability

9
“UDID” hereinafter
10
"SCPD" hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 5 of 7

even in one arm. This explains why the notification of MSJ&E
containing list of identified posts clarifies that those lists are not
exhaustive and while the establishments can add to the lists, they
cannot exclude any post from the list of identified posts. I,
therefore, see no justification for disqualifying the complainant for
any Civil Engineering jobs/post merely on the ground of the
disability that he has, for whatever reason.”


11. Mr. Singh, on the other hand, adopts the reasoning contained in
the impugned judgment.

12. Having heard the learned Counsel for the parties, keeping in
mind
(i) the specific recognition by the Government of India
itself, in the UDID card dated 25 July 2022 issued to the
petitioner that he suffers from locomotor disability,
(ii) notification dated 1 June 2001 issued by the Ministry of
Social Justice and Empowerment, specifically including, in the
category of “locomotor disability”, “inability resulting from
affliction of musculoskeletal and / or nervous system”,
(iii) the medical certificate which clearly demonstrates that,
owing to the ailment suffered by the petitioner, his movement
and his ability to execute activities relating to movement were
affected,
(iv) order dated 18 May 2018 of the SCPD, and
(v) paragraph 51 of the judgment of the Supreme Court in
11
Om Rathod v. The Director General of Health Services
which clearly states that a person who has a valid disability
certificate cannot be subjected to medical examination to arrive

11
(2024) 19 SCC 70
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 6 of 7

at a conclusion contrary to that recorded in the disability
certificate,
we are of the opinion that the Tribunal has erred in treating the
petitioner as ineligible for recruitment to the Civil Engineering
Service.

13. The Tribunal, unfortunately, has not examined all these aspects.

14. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 27 September 2024 is
quashed and set aside. The decision to cancel the petitioner’s
candidature, taken on 13 March 2018 is also quashed and set aside.
The OA would stand allowed in terms of prayer C therein with
consequential relief.

15. Let necessary orders be issued in favour of the petitioner within
a period of four weeks from today.

16. The writ petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms.



C. HARI SHANKAR, J.

VINOD KUMAR, J.
SEPTEMBER 8, 2026 /aky

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:25.09.2026
18:01:53
W.P.(C) 18345/2025 Page 7 of 7