Malabar alias shajahan vs The inspector of police

Court
Madras High Court

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 19-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE D.LINGESWARAN
Crl.A(MD) No.356 of 2019
CNR:{HCMD010716452019}
Malapar alias Shajahan
..Appellant/Sole Accused
Vs
The Inspector of Police
Kulithalai Police Station,
Karur District,
Cr No.646 of 2015
..Respondent
PRAYER: This Criminal Appeal is filed under Section 374(2) of
Cr.P.C., to set aside the conviction and sentence passed by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge, Karur made in S.C.No.75 of 2017 dated
31.05.2019.
For Appellant :Mr.M.Suresh
For Respondent :Mr.A.Robinson
Additional Public Prosecutor
JUDGMENT
This Criminal Appeal is directed against the judgment of
conviction and sentence passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Karur, in S.C.No.75 of 2017, dated 31.05.2019.
__________
Page  1  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
The case:
2.The prosecution case, in brief, is that on 17.09.2015, at about
22.00 hours, the appellant trespassed into the house of the defacto
complainant with the intention of committing robbery. Finding her
alone in the house, he allegedly snatched her gold chain. When she
resisted and held on to the chain, the appellant struck her with a small
grinding stone - P.M.O.4) on her forehead and cut her
(
குழவிக்கல்
hand with a knife (P.M.O.5), bit her on the shoulder and back. He
thereafter escaped with the piece of chain (P.M.O.1), which contained
gold coins (kasu-P.M.O.2) and gold tubes (P.M.O.3).
3. The defacto complainant was admitted to hospital on the
following day. The Police recorded her statement while she was
undergoing treatment and registered a case in Crime No.646 of 2015.
According to the Police version, the appellant was arrested on
20.09.2015. Pursuant to his alleged disclosure statement, portions of
the gold chain and the articles attached to it were recovered from his
possession.
4.On completion of the investigation, the final report was filed
__________
Page  2  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
before the learned Judicial Magistrate No.II, Kulithalai. The case was
thereafter committed to the Sessions Court, Karur, and numbered as
S.C.No.75 of 2017. It was made over to the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Karur, for trial.
The trial:
5.The trial Court framed charges against the appellant under
Sections 449 and 394 of the Indian Penal Code. The appellant pleaded
not guilty. The prosecution examined 11 witnesses, marked 13
documents and produced M.O.1 to M.O.5. The defence did not
examine any witness or mark any document or material object. On an
appreciation of the evidence, the trial Court found the appellant guilty
of both charges and imposed the following sentences:
Section Sentence imposed by the trial Court
Section 449 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and a fine of
Rs.500/-, with the default sentence.
Section 394 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and a fine of
Rs.500/-, with the default sentence.
The Appeal:
6. Aggrieved by the conviction and sentence, the appellant has
__________
Page  3  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
preferred this appeal.
Arguments:
7. The learned counsel for the appellant assailed the reliability of
the identification, the genesis of the prosecution case and the alleged
arrest and recovery. It was contended that PW1 had identified the
appellant for the first time in Court and that her identification was
therefore doubtful. The learned counsel also relied upon certain
inconsistencies in the evidence of PWs.1 to 3 and the Investigating
Officer. In particular, it was argued that Ex.P1, the complaint, was
recorded only on 18.09.2015, while PW1 admitted in cross-
examination that the Police had visited the scene at about 23.00 hours
on the night of occurrence, questioned her and taken away a portion of
the chain along with two coins (kasu) attached to it.
8. The learned counsel further submitted that, according to PW3,
the appellant was apprehended while emerging from the house with the
stolen chain and was immediately handed over to the police on the
night of occurrence. If that version were true, the subsequent claim that
the appellant was arrested on 20.09.2015 and that the chain was
recovered pursuant to a disclosure statement would be false. The
__________
Page  4  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
defence therefore questioned the genuineness of the arrest, disclosure
statement and recovery.
9. Attention was also drawn to Ex.P6, the seizure memorandum,
which records the recovery of two pieces of chain weighing 20.4
grams, two coins and two gold tubes (Gnana kulaai) weighing
approximately four grams each, the total weight being 27.8 grams. It
was argued that the articles allegedly recovered did not tally with
account of PW1 that she had handed over a portion of the chain along
with two coins to the police. This, according to the defence, further
rendered the recovery doubtful.
10. It was lastly contended that the appellant had been falsely
implicated at the instance of PW2, the husband of the defacto
complainant. The defence relied on the fact that PW1 had allegedly
informed the doctor and PW2 that an unknown person had committed
the robbery. On the cumulative effect of these circumstances, the
learned counsel sought acquittal.
__________
Page  5  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
11. Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor submitted
that the appellant was already known to PW1. In support of that
submission, reliance was placed on Ex.P1, in which PW1 had furnished
the name of the appellant and place of residence. It was argued that her
statement in cross-examination that she was seeing the appellant for the
first time in Court could not be read in isolation or detached from the
contents of her earliest complaint.
12. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor also relied on the
evidence of PW3, who stated that the appellant was known to him and
that he had apprehended him while he was attempting to conceal
himself in a bush near the house. It was further submitted that PW1 was
an injured eyewitness; her injuries were corroborated by the medical
evidence; and the defects in the investigation would not, by themselves,
discredit otherwise reliable ocular evidence. The prosecution therefore
sought confirmation of the conviction and sentence.
13. This Court has carefully considered the rival submissions and
examined the evidence and materials on record.
__________
Page  6  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
14. Point for consideration:
Whether the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant by
the trial Court are sustainable in law and on the evidence available on
record?
Answer:
Identity of the appellant:
15. The first challenge relates to the identity of the appellant. The
record discloses that, in the statement recorded on 18.09.2015 while she
was undergoing treatment, PW1 had furnished the name of the appellant
and his place of residence. Ex.P1 was proved through PW1 during trial.
The defence did not confront her with the specific assertion in Ex.P1
that she had named the appellant and identified his place of residence,
nor did it elicit any explanation suggesting that the name had been
inserted later or at the instance of another person. The statement that she
was seeing the appellant for the first time in Court must therefore be
assessed in the context of the entire evidence and not in isolation.
__________
Page  7  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
16. More importantly, the prosecution case does not rest on a
fleeting or obstructed observation of a stranger. The occurrence took
place inside house of PW1, and she had an opportunity to see the
assailant at close quarters during the attack. She sustained injuries in the
very occurrence and consistently attributed the assault and robbery to the
appellant. Her evidence as an injured witness carries considerable
evidentiary weight. Though the status of an injured witness does not
make her testimony immune from scrutiny, the defence has not brought
out any convincing reason for her to falsely implicate the appellant.
17. The suggestion that PW1 was acting under pressure from PW2
was denied. No material was elicited to establish either the alleged
pressure or the reason why PW1 would substitute the real offender with
the appellant. A mere suggestion, unsupported by evidence or by
circumstances emerging from the record, cannot displace otherwise
credible testimony. The fact that PW1 identified the stolen jewel by
referring to the shop initials printed on the chain provides an additional
circumstance supporting her account of the robbery.
__________
Page  8  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
Police story Vs. version of PW3:
18. The evidence of PW3 requires separate consideration because
it differs materially from the police version regarding the apprehension
of the appellant and the recovery of the stolen property. PW3 stated
that he caught the appellant when the latter came out of the house and
attempted to hide in a bush nearby. He further stated that he secured the
chain and handed the appellant over to the police on the night of
occurrence. When questioned, PW3 affirmed that he had given this
version to the police as well.
19. Once PW3 affirmed that he had made the said statement to the
police, the proper course for the defence, if it intended to contradict
him by relying on an omission or inconsistency in his former statement,
was to draw his attention to the relevant portion and thereafter prove
the contradiction in the manner required by Section 145 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872. In the present case, although PW3 affirmed that he
had made the statement, the relevant matter was not put to the
Investigating Officer for the purpose of proving the alleged
contradiction. Consequently, the alleged inconsistency between
__________
Page  9  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
testimony of PW3 and his former statement before Police was not duly
proved. The Court must, therefore, assess testimony of PW3 as it stands
in evidence, while keeping in view the other circumstances on record.
20. The difference between account of PW3 and the police version
undoubtedly exposes a serious defect in the investigation and creates
doubt about the official account of the arrest of the appellant on
20.09.2015 and the subsequent recovery said to have been made
pursuant to a disclosure statement. The discrepancy in the description
and quantity of the articles recorded in Ex.P6 also calls for caution.
This Court is not prepared to treat the police version regarding the
arrest and recovery as an independently reliable circumstance without
resolving those discrepancies. However, the weakness of the alleged
recovery does not automatically render the entire prosecution case
false. The central question remains whether the trustworthy oral
evidence establishes the participation of the appellant in the occurrence
beyond reasonable doubt.
Evidence of PW1:
21. On that question, evidence of PW1 is direct and arises from
__________
Page  10  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
her personal experience of the occurrence. She sustained injuries during
the robbery, and her account receives support from the evidence of
PW3, who spoke to the apprehension of the appellant in the immediate
aftermath of the occurrence. The medical evidence of PW6 and Ex.P7
corroborates the fact that PW1 had sustained injuries of the nature
spoken to by her. The medical evidence is not, by itself, proof of the
identity of the assailant; its significance lies in its consistency with the
occurrence described by PW1.
Defective Investigation:
22. The defence has rightly highlighted the defects in the
investigation. The police ought to have recorded the earliest version
accurately, documented the steps taken at the scene, and explained the
apparent difference between account of PW3 and the subsequent arrest
and recovery records. Such lapses cannot be condoned. Nevertheless, a
defective investigation is not, by itself, a ground to acquit an accused
where the substantive evidence of reliable witnesses establishes the
charge. In Karnel Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1995) 5 SCC
518, the Hon'ble Supreme Court recognized that an omission or lapse in
investigation does not necessarily result in the failure of the prosecution
case when the evidence of the witnesses is otherwise trustworthy. In
__________
Page  11  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
Arvind Kumar @ Nemichand and Others Vs. State of Rajasthan
(2021 SCC Online SC 1099) and C.Muniappan Vs. State of Tamil
Nadu (2010 (9) SCC 567), it was held that the Courts must examine the
reliability of the prosecution evidence and whether any investigation
lapse affected the process of finding the truth.
23. The Court must, however, distinguish between declining to
rely on a doubtful investigative procedure and affirmatively finding
that the Police fabricated the entire case. The evidence on record
justifies the former conclusion; it does not require the latter. The
discrepancies surrounding the formal arrest and seizure weaken those
particular circumstances, but they do not displace the credible and
mutually supportive evidence of PW1 and PW3 concerning the
occurrence and the involvement of the appellant.
Conclusion:
24. Having regard to the injured eyewitness account of PW1, the
corroborative evidence of PW3, and the medical evidence supporting
the factum of the assault, this Court finds no sufficient reason to reject
the core prosecution case. The defence has not demonstrated that the
__________
Page  12  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
discrepancies identified in the investigation create a reasonable doubt
about the identity or participation of the appellant. The prosecution has
therefore proved the charges beyond reasonable doubt. The conviction
is liable to be affirmed.
Sentence:
25. Turning to the question of sentence, the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor submitted that the appellant was involved in three
other criminal cases. Crime No.72 of 2013 was registered before the
occurrence in the present case, while Crime Nos.67 of 2022 and 1596
of 2022 were registered thereafter. It was stated that robbery was the
principal allegation in those cases; one had ended in acquittal and the
other two were pending.
26. The pendency of a criminal case, without a finding of guilt,
cannot be treated as proof of criminal antecedents or used to aggravate
the sentence in the present case. Equally, a case which has ended in
acquittal cannot be relied upon as an adverse antecedent. The mere
registration of Crime No.72 of 2013, without material establishing a
conviction or other legally relevant finding, is also insufficient to treat
__________
Page  13  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
the appellant as a habitual offender. The sentence must therefore be
determined primarily on the basis of the gravity and circumstances of
the offence proved in this case and the relevant mitigating
circumstances.
27. The offences are undoubtedly serious. The appellant entered
the house of a woman at night, attacked her when she resisted the
robbery, and caused injuries with a knife and other objects. The victim
was entitled to security in her own home, and the violence used to
overcome her resistance aggravates the seriousness of the occurrence.
At the same time, the sentencing exercise must remain individualized
and proportionate. The trial Court imposed ten years of Rigorous
Imprisonment for each offence, though the statutory provisions permit
a lesser term. Having regard to the circumstances of the occurrence, the
age of the appellant as placed before this Court, and the overall facts of
the case, this Court is of the view that a term of three years of Rigorous
Imprisonment for each offence would meet the ends of justice. The
reduction is not founded on the subsequent cases, nor does it dilute the
seriousness of the crime; it reflects an assessment of the appropriate
proportionate sentence on the material legally available.
__________
Page  14  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
Result:
28. In the result, this Criminal Appeal is partly allowed. The
conviction of the appellant under Sections 449 and 394 of the Indian
Penal Code is confirmed. The sentence of ten years of Rigorous
Imprisonment imposed for each offence is reduced to three years of
Rigorous Imprisonment for each offence. The fine imposed for each
offence, together with the respective default sentences, is maintained. The
substantive sentences shall run concurrently. The appellant is entitled to
the benefit of set-off under Section 428 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973. The bail bond of the appellant is cancelled. The
appellant is directed to surrender before the Trial Court to undergo the
remaining period of sentence within a week from today, failing which,
the Trial Court shall issue a non bailable warrant to secure him and
execute the sentence.
19-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
Indu
__________
Page  15  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
To
1. The learned Additional Sessions Judge, Karur.
2. The Inspector of Police
Kulithalai Police Station,
Karur District.
3. The Additional Public Prosecutor
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
Madurai
Copy To :
Section Officer ( VR Section )
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court
__________
Page  16  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
D.LINGESWARAN, J.
Indu
Crl.A(MD) No.356 of 2019
19-11-2026
__________
Page  17  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )

CRL A(MD) No. 356 of 2019
__________
Page  18  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 12:52:47 pm )