ANDY vs AV IQBAL AHMED

Court
Madras High Court

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATUE AT MADRAS
Reserved on: 30.09.2026
Pronounced on: 16.11.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.DHANABAL
S.A.No.1163 of 2007
1.Andy
2.Chinnapaiyan ...Appellants
Vs.
1.A.V.Iqbal Ahmed Saheb
2.The Tahsildar,
Tirupattur Taluk,
Vellore District. ... Respondents
Prayer:- This appeal has been filed under Section 100 CPC against the
judgment and decree dated 30.07.2007 in A.S.No.45 of 2005 on the file
of Subordinate Judge, Tirupattur, reversing the judgment and order dated
14.03.2005 in O.S.No.6 of 1996 on the file of District Munsif Court,
Tirupattur.
For Appellants : Mr.T.S.Bharath Gowtham
for Mr.T.R.Rajaraman
For R1 : Mr.V.Ravi
For R2 : Mr.P.R.Vineeth, GA
1/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
JUDGMENT
This second appeal has been filed as against the judgment and
decree passed by the Subordinate Judge, Tirupattur, in A.S.No.45 of
2005, dated 30.07.2007, reversing the judgment and decree passed by the
District Munsif Court, Tirupattur, in O.S.No.6 of 1996, dated 14.03.2005.
2. The appellants herein are the plaintiffs, and respondents herein
are the defendants in the suit. For the sake of convenience and better
understanding, the parties will be referred to as arrayed in the suit.
3. The case of the plaintiffs before the trial Court is that the first
item of the suit property was originally purchased by one Mandarakuttai
Chinnapaiyan, son of Andi Goundar, through a sale deed dated
27.02.1939. The said Mandarakuttai Chinnapaiyan died intestate in the
year 1950 leaving behind his wife/Belli Anjiammal, and his
sons/plaintiffs. The said Belli Anjiammal also died subsequently. After
the demise of his father, the plaintiffs have been in possession and
enjoyment of the first item of the suit property. With regard to second
item of the suit property, it is their case that they have purchased the
second item, which is on the southern side of the first item, under a sale
2/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
deed dated 17.06.1952 from one L.Jaquet Ammal, wife of J.A.Jaquet.
From the date of the said purchase, they have been in continuous
possession of the same and they have been paying kist for the said second
item of the suit property as well. While so, on 02.04.1962, there was an
exchange of lands between the first plaintiff and one Lilly Jaquet.
However, the said exchange was only nominal and it was not acted upon.
4. It is the further case of the plaintiffs that on the eastern side of
the second item of the suit property, the first defendant is having a landed
property; and similarly, on the southern side of the second item also, the
first defendant is owning a portion of the landed property. The first
defendant has no right or title over the suit property belonging to the
plaintiffs. However, taking advantage of the illiteracy of the plaintiffs, the
first defendant unlawfully encroached upon the second item of the suit
property and that the encroached portion would be about 10 feet breadth
throughout eastern side of the second item of the suit property. The
plaintiffs annexed rough plan of the suit schedule, wherein encroached
portion has been marked as ‘ABCD’ on the eastern side and ‘EFGH’ on
the southern side. Such an encroachment made by the first defendant has
lead to filing of this suit.
3/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
5. The case of the first defendant is that the averments made in the
plaint are incorrect. Infact, the total extent of the first item of the suit
property situated in S.No.91 is 9.58 acres. The said property was initially
purchased through court auction on 31.08.1932 bearing small cause case
No.412/1931 by one Duraisamy Ayyar represented by his power agent
Munusamy Goundar. Whileso, the averment that on 27.02.1939, the said
property was purchased by the plaintiffs’ father is false. In fact, under the
exchange deed dated 02.04.1962, the plaintiffs themselves have admitted
that out of total extent of 9.58 acres in S.No.91, 4.80 acres belongs to
Lilly Jaquet. The plaintiffs are entitled to claim their share only as shown
in the exchange deed dated 02.04.1962 and they have no locus standi to
claim more than what is shown in the exchange deed dated 02.04.1962.
After the said exchange deed, the plaintiffs have retained only 1.20 acres
out of 6 acres of the second item of the suit property, and only in the said
extent alone, they have been cultivating by digging well. In the rest of
the land, i.e., 4.80 acres, the first defendant has been cultivating and he
has been paying kist for the said land. It is also his further case that on
04.04.1962 itself, i.e. 2 days of the exchange deed, the said Lilly Jaquet
has sold 4.80 acres to the firs defendant. Subsequently, he has been in
continuous possession and enjoyment of the suit property. Therefore, the
averment that the first defendant has encroached a portion of the suit
4/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
property is false. The plan annexed in the plaint is also not correct. The
suit is liable to be dismissed.
6. The case of the second defendant is that the second defendant is
unnecessary party, and the plaintiffs have to prove the sale deeds dated
27.02.1939 and 17.06.1952, and exchange deed dated 02.04.1962.
Without issuing pre-suit notice, the suit has been filed. There is no cause
of action for filing the suit, and therefore, the suit is liable to be
dismissed.
7. Based on the aforesaid pleadings, the trial Court has framed the
following issues:-
(a) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to suit
properties?
(b) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to seek the
relief of declaration?
(c) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to seek the
relief of permanent injunction?
(d) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to seek the
relief of recovery of possession?
(e) Whether the second defendant is unnecessary
party?
(f) Is there any cause of action for filing the suit?
(g) To what other reliefs the plaintiffs entitled?
5/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
8. Before the trial Court, on the side of the plaintiffs, Exs.A1 to
A64 were marked, and P.Ws.1 to 6 were examined; On the side of
defendants, Exs.B1 to B23 were marked, and DW1 and DW2 were
examined. Advocate Commissioner report and plan have been marked as
Exs.C1 and C2. After considering the evidence adduced by the parties,
the trial Court has decreed the suit on 14.03.2005. Aggrieved by the
same, the first defendant has preferred an appeal and the first appellate
court reversed judgment and decree passed by the trial Court in
A.S.No.45 of 2005, dated 30.07.2007, and dismissed the said suit.
Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiffs have preferred this second second
appeal.
9. This Court, at the time of admission, framed the following
substantial question of law:
“A. When the 1st defendant, having not
disputed and claimed any title with reference to Item
1, still is the learned Subordinate Judge right in
allowing the appeal and dismissing the suit with
reference to Item 1?
B. When the plaintiffs, having produced Revenue
Records in proof of their possession even beyond the
6/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
date of execution of the alleged Exchange Deed, still
is the learned Subordinate Judge right in allowing
the appeal?”
10. The learned counsel for the appellants/plaintiffs would submit
that originally, the first item of the suit property was purchased by the
plaintiffs’ father through a sale deed dated 27.02.1939. The second item
of the suit property was purchased by the plaintiffs themselves on
17.06.1952 from one L.Jaquet Ammal. After the death of the plaintiffs’
father in the year 1950, they have been in continuous possession and
enjoyment of the suit property. Whileso, the first defendant attempted to
encroach upon the suit property, which has lead to filing of the present
suit. He would further submit that there was an exchange deed dated
02.04.1962 executed between the first plaintiff and one Lilly Jaquet.
However, the said exchange deed was not acted upon. Even after the
execution of the exchange deed, the plaintiffs have been in peaceful
possession and enjoyment of both items of the suit properties. The first
defendant is claiming right of the second item of the suit property through
a sale deed dated 04.04.1962 said to have been executed by one Lilly
Jaquet. However, the fact is that the said Lilly Jaquet herself does not
have a proper title. Therefore, the trial Court, after considering the
7/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
evidence placed on record by both parties, has rightly decreed the suit.
However, the first appellate court, without considering the evidence in
proper perspective, set aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial
Court. The first appellate court has also failed to take note of the fact that
there was no dispute with regard to first item of the suit property, which
was originally purchased by the plaintiffs’ father in the year 1939. He
would further submit that the first defendant has failed to prove Ex.B5-
exchange deed. Even as per Ex.B5, the first plaintiff alone is a party to
the said document, and the second defendant is not a party to the said
document. But, the first appellate has failed to take note of the said fact
and has dismissed the suit in entirety. When the first defendant having
not disputed and claimed any title with reference to first item of the suit
property, and the plaintiffs having produced the revenue records to prove
their title, the judgment and decree passed by the first appellate court are
not sustainable and the same are liable to be set aside.
11. The learned counsel for the first respondent would submit that
the plaintiffs have filed the suit for declaration, permanent injunction and
recovery of possession. The plaintiffs purchased the second item of the
suit property through a sale deed dated 17.06.1952 from one Lilly Jaquet
to an extent of 6 acres, and thereafter, the said Lilly Jaquet executed an
8/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
exchange deed dated 02.04.1962 with the first plaintiff, as per which, out
of 6 acres, the plaintiffs have retained 1.20 acres and the remaining 4.80
acres were given to Lilly Jaquet. The said Lilly Jaquet subsequently sold
the said extent to the first defendant through a sale deed dated
04.04.1962, which is just 2 days after the exchange deed. The plaintiffs
having not challenged the exchange deed dated 02.04.1962, they cannot
deny the same, and the said exchange deed was acted upon and based on
the said exchange deed, the said Lilly Jaquet sold 4.80 acres of land in
favour of the first defendant.
11.1. He would further submit that the first defendant has examined
DW1 and DW2 and also marked Exs.B1 to B23 in support of his case.
However, the trial Court without considering the evidence adduced by the
first defendant, erroneously decreed the suit. The first appellate court
after elaborately discussing the exhibits relied upon by both the parties,
declined to grant the relief and dismissed the suit. Therefore, the second
appeal is liable to be dismissed.
12. Heard the learned counsel appearing on either side and perused
the materials available before this Court.
9/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
DISCUSSION:
13. The plaintiffs have filed this suit for declaration of title,
permanent injunction and for recovery of possession. According to the
plaintiffs, the first item of the suit property was purchased by their father
through a registered sale deed dated 27.02.1939 from one Rama Goundar.
The father of the plaintiffs died in the year 1950. Till his life time, he was
in possession and enjoyment of the first item of the suit property. After
his demise, his sons/plaintiffs have been in possession and enjoyment of
the same. The second item of the suit property was purchased by the
plaintiffs under a sale deed dated 17.06.1952 to an extent of 6 acres from
Lilly Jaquet and others, which has been marked as Ex.A3. Thereafter, the
first plaintiff and the said Lilly Jaquet entered into an exchange deed
dated 02.04.1962, which has been marked as Ex.B5, as per which, the
plaintiffs have retained 1.20 acres with them and they gave 4.80 acres in
favour of Lilly Jaquet; and similarly, in exchange of the same, the said
Lilly Jaquet gave 4.80 acres in S.No.91 to the plaintiffs. According to the
plaintiffs, with regard to second item of the suit property, as seen from
Ex.B5, in S.No.92/1, they retained 1.20 acres and gave balance 4.80 acres
to one Lilly Jaquet. Though the plaintiffs admitted the execution of
exchange deed, they have contended that the said exchange deed was
10/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
never acted upon, and they have been in peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the second item of the suit property even after execution of
the exchange deed.
14. According to the first defendant, the aforesaid Lilly Jaquet has
executed a sale deed dated 04.04.1962 in his favour to an extent of 12
acres including the 4.80 acres obtained through the exchange deed,
which is just 2 days after the execution of the exchange deed dated
02.04.1962. On this basis, the first defendant has resisted the claim of the
plaintiffs with regard to second item of the suit property. In order to
prove the case of the plaintiffs, P.Ws.1 to 6 were examined and Exs.A1 to
A64 were marked. Ex.A1 is the sale deed dated 27.02.1939 by one Rama
Goundar in favour of Chinnapaiya Goundar; Ex.A2 is the patta in favour
of the plaintiffs’ father and another; Ex.A3 is the sale deed dated
17.06.1952 executed by L.Jaquet and others in favour of the plaintiffs.
The other documents marked by them are revenue records.
15. As far as the first item of the suit property is concerned, the
plaintiffs are claiming 4.79 acres through the sale deed dated 27.02.1939
marked as Ex.A1. However, in the schedule of the suit property, while
referring sub-division S.No.91/2, the extent of the property mentioned as
11/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
6.03 acres of dry land. Similarly, while referring to the second item of
the property, they are claiming 6 acres in S.No.92/1, however, it was later
sub-divided as S.No.92/1A, but, they did not mention the extent of land
for the said sub-division.
16. In fact, the plaintiffs have admitted the execution of the
exchange deed, however, according to them, the said exchange deed was
not acted upon. A bare perusal of the exchange deed dated
02.04.1962/Ex.B5 would show that out of 6 acres in S.No.92/1 (second
item), the plaintiffs have retained 1.20 acres with them and they gave the
remaining lands i.e. 4.80 acres to Lilly Jaquet; and similarly, in exchange
of the same, the said Lilly Jaquet gave 4.80 acres to the plaintiffs. It is
also seen from the records that just 2 days after the exchange deed, the
aforesaid Lilly Jaquet sold the said property to the first defendant through
the sale deed dated 04.04.1962. P.W.1/second plaintiff, in his cross-
examination, admitted that out of 6 acres, they have been in peaceful
possession only to an extent of 1.20 acres and the remaining 4.80 acres is
with the first defendant. While this being the factual position, the
contention of the plaintiffs that the exchange deed dated 02.04.1962 was
never acted upon cannot be sustained. Had the exchange deed not been
acted upon, the subsequent sale to the first defendant by the said Lilly
12/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
Jaquet wound not have taken place.
17. It is at this juncture, the learned counsel for the
appellants/plaintiffs would submit that even assuming that the exchange
deed was acted upon, it was executed by the first plaintiff alone, whereas
the said property was purchased by the plaintiffs 1 and 2 to an extent of 6
acres, and therefore, the share of the first plaintiff alone could be
exchanged. In this context, it is to be noted that the aforesaid exchange
deed was executed in the year 1962, but, the suit was filed by the
plaintiffs only in the year 1996, which is after a period of 34 years, i.e.
after the limitation period. Therefore, the plaintiffs cannot claim any
right, that too, after a period of 34 years, in the second item of the suit
property to an extent of 4.80 acres, and they are admittedly entitled to
only 1.20 acres.
18. As far as the first item of the suit property is concerned, though
they purchased the same through Ex.A1 to an extent of 4.79 acres, later it
was sub-divided and as per the sub-division, i.e. S.No.91/2, the extent of
the land is 6.03 acres. The plaintiffs have also not disputed the sale in
favour of the first defendant by the aforesaid Lilly Jaquet, which is just 2
days after the exchange deed. In the schedule of property, with regard to
13/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
second item, the plaintiffs have mentioned the total extent as 27.20 acres
in S.No.92/1, and this was later sub-divided as 92/1A to an extent of 6
acres. From the above, it is clear that the plaintiffs have failed to prove
that both the items of the suit properties belong to them. It is well settled
law that the plaintiff, who has filed the suit for declaration, permanent
injunciton and for recovery of possession, has to prove his case based on
his own evidence, and he cannot take advantage of the defendant’s case,
and he has to prove his case independently. In the case on hand, the
plaintiffs’ father purchased the first item of the suit property to an extent
of 4.79 acres through the sale deed dated 27.02.1939 marked as Ex.A1,
but, later in the schedule of property, it is stated that the aforesaid
property was sub-divided as S.No.91/2 to an extent of 6.03 acres. But,
there is no explanation on the side of the plaintiffs as to how they are
entitled to 6.03 acres.
19. As far as the second item of the suit property is concerned, as
stated above, the plaintiffs have purchased 6 acres of land through the
sale deed dated 17.06.1952 from one Lilly Jaquet. Thereafter, the first
plaintiff entered into an exchange deed dated 02.04.1962 with Lilly
Jaquet to an extent of 4.80 acres, and the plaintiffs have retained the
balance 1.20 acres with them. However, they have filed the suit for entire
14/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
extent of 6 acres by mentioning Survey No.92/1A. Therefore, as stated
above, the plaintiffs have failed to prove their case through proper
evidence. The trial Court, without considering the exchange deed and the
sale deed dated 04.04.1962 in favour of the first defendant, erroneously
decreed the suit. However, the first appellate court, after considering the
evidence adduced by both the parties in a proper perspective, has rightly
set aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court by dismissing
the suit.
20. Further the first appellate court has also taken note of the
evidence of PW5/Palani, son of the second plaintiff, who has deposed
that he did not know the exact extent of the property belonging to him
and also admitted that the plaintiffs have already obtained electricity
connection by mentioning the extent as 4.79 acres and 1.20 acres in
S.Nos.91/2 and 92/1 respectively. He further deposed that the plaintiffs
have failed to produce those documents submitted by them before the
electricity department. In his further deposition, PW5 admitted that there
is a 10 feet pathway in S.Nos.91/2 and 92/1. But, the same has not been
mentioned in the plaint by the plaintiffs.
15/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
21. The first appellate court has rendered its findings based on the
evidence. Though the first defendant has not disputed the first item of the
suit property to an extent of 4.79 acres, but, in the schedule of property,
the plaintiffs are claiming entire extent of 6 acres in S.No.91/2. There is
no explanation as to how the plaintiffs are entitled to such an extent of
excess land. Therefore, the first appellate court is correct in allowing the
appeal and dismissing the suit in respect of the first item of the suit
property. As far as the second item of the suit property is concerned,
though the plaintiffs have produced the revenue records to prove their
possession, those documents are not sufficient. As stated above, the
plaintiffs have failed to prove that the exchange deed/Ex.B5 was not
acted upon. As seen from Ex.B6/sale deed dated 04.04.1962, the
aforesaid Lilly Jaquet executed a sale deed in favour of the first
defendant, which is just 2 days after the exchange deed. In the said sale
deed dated 04.04.1962, there is a recital about the Ex.B5/exchange deed.
Therefore, in the considered view of this Court, exchange deed/Ex.B5
was acted upon and mere filing of revenue records are not sufficient to
prove the title.
22. For the foregoing reasons, the substantial question of law are
are answered in favour of the first respondent/first defendant and against
16/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
appellant/plaintiffs. Consequently, the second appeal stands dismissed.
No Costs.
16.11.2026
rkm
Neutral Citation: yes/no
To
1.District Munsif Court,
Tirupattur.
2.Sub-Court,
Tirupattur.
17/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )

S.A.No.1163 of 2007
P.DHANABAL, J.
rkm
Pre-delivery judgment in
S.A.No.1163 of 2007
16.11.2026
18/18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:45:30 pm )