Hari Singh vs State Of Haryana And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-15957-2020(O&M)
Reserved on:11.11.2026
Pronounced on: 18.11.2026
Uploaded on: 18.11.2026
HARI SINGH -PETITIONER
V/S

STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
-RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KULDEEP TIWARI
Present: Mr. Sumit Sangwan, Advocate,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Vivek Chauhan, Add. A.G., Haryana.

KULDEEP TIWARI, J.
1. Through the instant writ petition filed under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has challenged the validity
of the order dated 30.11.2018 (Annexure P-1) passed by the Collector,
Charkhi Dadri (Respondent no.3), in the proceedings initiated under
Section 47-A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, whereby the petitioner was
directed to deposit deficient stamp duty amounting to Rs.2,28,670/- and a
registration fee of Rs.14,950/-, as also the order dated 15.10.2019
(Annexure P-2), passed by the Commissioner, Rohtak Division, Rohtak
(Respondent no.2), whereby the petitioner's statutory appeal was
dismissed. The petitioner has also challenged the clarification dated
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -2-
29.12.2008 (Annexure P-5), issued by the Financial Commissioner and
Principal Secretary to Government of Haryana, Revenue Department,
with regard to Article 55 of Schedule I-A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899,
on the ground of it being unconstitutional and discriminatory in nature.
2. The issue that arises for consideration before this Court, is as
to whether, a release deed executed between the cousins attracts stamp
duty or not, specifically, in view of Article 55 of Schedule I-A of the
Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as applicable to the State of Haryana.
3. In order to adjudicate the issue, it would be appropriate to
briefly refer to the relevant facts. In the instant case, the petitioner-Hari
Singh, received land measuring 1 kanal 4 marlas (706 square yards) from
his cousin-Ajmer Singh, vide Release Deed No. 6889 dated 28.03.2016.
The release deed was registered without payment of any stamp duty or
registration fee on the ground that one cousin has relinquished his rights
in the ancestral property in favour of the petitioner, the said transaction is
not liable to stamp duty.
4. For the purpose of clarifying the relationship between the
parties, the padigree table is as under:-
Bhagmal
______________|_________________
| |
Mani Ram Harkey Ram
| |
Hari Singh (petitioner) Ajmer Singh
(Executant)
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -3-
5. In the instant case, the petitioner-Hari Singh and the
executant of the release deed are cousins, having a common ancestor, i.e.
their paternal grandfather (Dada)- Bhagmal.
6. The Audit Department raised an objection to the effect that
since the land in question measured less than 1000 square yards, it was
required to be treated as land used for residential purposes. Accordingly,
its value for the purpose of stamp duty, was required to be assessed on the
basis of the prevailing market rate of abadi land, which had not been
done. Pursuant to the audit objection, the Sub-Registrar made a reference
dated 01.01.2018, to the Collector concerned, who through a show-cause
notice summoned the petitioner, and accordingly, vide the impugned
order dated 30.11.2018 (Annexure P-1), the Collector assessed the
deficient stamp duty and registration fee, as mentioned hereinabove. The
statutory appeal preferred by the petitioner against the order ( supra ), was
also dismissed vide order dated 15.10.2019 (Annexure P-2).
7. In addition to assailing the legality of the impugned orders,
the principal thrust of the petitioner's challenge is directed against the
clarification dated 29.12.2008 (Annexure P-5), issued by the Financial
Commissioner, which, according to the petitioner, is discriminatory in
nature.
8. It has been contended by learned counsel for the petitioner
that, as per Article 55(a) of Schedule I-A of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899,
as amended by the Indian Stamp (Haryana Amendment) Act, 2000 , an
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -4-
instrument of release is exempted from payment of stamp duty in case the
release deed qua ancestral property is executed by a person (renouncer),
in favour of brother or sister (children of renouncer's parents) or son or
daughter or father or mother or spouse or grand-children or nephew or
niece or coparcener of the renouncer . However, vide the impugned
clarification dated 29.12.2008, the Financial Commissioner, has extended
the scope of the release in ancestral property, made in favour or and by
widowed mother; bhanja (sister's son); bhanji (sister's daughter); mama
(maternal-uncle, mother's brother); mama's son; bhua's son (father's
sister's son); bhua's daughter; devar (husband's brother) in favour of
bhabhi and bhabhi (brother's wife) in favour of devar. Therefore, the said
clarification extends the benefit in case of family transfer pertaining to
the transfer of immovable property from female descendants, but does not
extend the same from male descendants. It has, therefore, been argued
that such differential treatment is discriminatory on the ground of gender,
is prohibited under Article 15(1) of the Constitution of India and also
violates the constitutional guarantee of Right to Equality.
9. No other argument was raised on behalf of the petitioner.
10. Per contra , learned State counsel submitted that the release
deed in question is not covered in Article 55(a) of the Indian Stamp
(Haryana Amendment) Act, 2000 , but falls within the ambit of Article
55(b) thereof, thereby requiring the petitioner to pay the assessed
deficient stamp duty.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -5-
11. It was further submitted that since the total area of the land
was less than 1000 square yards, the same was required to be treated as
residential property in view of the instructions issued by the Revenue
Department. Accordingly, stamp duty was required to be assessed on the
basis of the prevailing market rate of abadi land.
12. This Court has considered the submissions as made by
learned counsel for the parties concerned.
13. The Haryana Government, vide Haryana Act No.10 of 2000,
notified on 19.04.2000, amended the relevant provisions of the Indian
Stamp Act, 1899, and substituted Article 55 of Schedule 1-A thereto. In
order to appreciate the controversy involved, it would be appropriate to
have a glimpse upon Article 55 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp
(Haryana Amendment) Act, 2000, which is extracted hereinafter:
(1) Description of Instrument (2) Proper Stamp Duty
"55. Release, that is to say any
instrument (not being such a release
as is provided for by section 23-A)
whereby any person renounces his
interest, share, part or claim:-
(a) if the release is made of
ancestral property in favour of
brother or sister (children of
renouncer's parents) or son or
daughter or father or mother or
spouse or grand children or nephew
or niece or co-parcener of the
renouncer;
Fifteen rupees.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -6-
(b) in any other case The same duty as a Conveyance
[No. 23(a) relating to sale of
immovable-property] for the
amount equal to the market value of
the share, interest, part of claim
renounced.".
14. The aforesaid extracted amended provision, prescribes a
separate structure of stamp duty for instruments of release, specifically
where ancestral property is released in favour of the family members
prescribed therein.
15. Article 55 of Schedule I-A to the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, is
a fiscal entry classifying instruments of release for chargeability to stamp
duty and does not, of itself, confer substantive title. Excluding
instruments governed by Section 23-A (which pertains to mortgages of
marketable securities and has no application here), sub-clause (a) of
Article 55 prescribes a concessional stamp duty of Rs. 15/- only where
two cumulative conditions are satisfied:
(i) the property released is ancestral property; and
(ii) the release is executed in favour of one of the
enumerated relatives, namely, the renouncer's brother or
sister (children of the renouncer's parents), son, daughter,
father, mother, spouse, grandchildren, nephew, niece, or
coparcener.
Conversely, sub-clause (b) is a residuary entry governing all
other releases including releases of non-ancestral property as well as
releases of ancestral property in favour of persons outside the enumerated
categories and subjects them to the same stamp duty as a Conveyance
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -7-
under Article 23(a) of Schedule I-A on the market value of the share,
interest, part, or claim renounced.
16. Applying Article 55 to the undisputed pedigree, the
petitioner and the executant, Ajmer Singh, are first cousins (sons of two
brothers, Mani Ram and Harkey Ram, respectively). A cousin is not
among the familial relationships enumerated in Article 55(a). Further,
although Article 55(a) includes a "coparcener of the renouncer", the
petitioner neither laid any factual foundation before the revenue
authorities nor raised any contention before this Court to establish that
the subject land constituted unpartitioned joint family coparcenary
property or that the cousins stood in the legal relationship of coparceners
rather than separate co-sharers or collaterals.
17. An analysis of the aforesaid provisions make, it crystal clear
that where a release deed is executed amongst cousins, the same would
fall within the ambit of Article 55(b) and not Article 55(a) of the ibid Act.
In the present case, the petitioner who is a beneficiary, does not fall
within any of the categories of relatives prescribed under Article 55(a) so
as to claim the benefit of concessional stamp duty.
18. Another issue which may assume significance is, as to
whether, the instrument in question can be classified as a release deed, for
the purpose of attracting the provisions of Article 55. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Kuppuswamy Chettiar v. A.S.P.A. Arumugam
Chettiar , AIR 1967 SC 1395 : (1967) 1 SCR 275, has settled that
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -8-
nomenclature is not conclusive. While a release is ordinarily employed to
enlarge a limited or pre-existing right in favour of a person already
having an interest in the property, a deed called a deed of release can, by
using words of sufficient amplitude, transfer title even to one having no
title before the transfer-taking effect, upon its true construction, as a
conveyance where supported by valuable consideration (or as a gift under
Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, where executed
without consideration through a duly registered and attested instrument.
19. In the present case, however, it is unnecessary to examine the
recitals of Release Deed or adjudicate whether the petitioner possessed a
pre-existing right in the subject land or whether the instrument operated
as a transfer de novo : even proceeding on the petitioner's own premise
that the deed validly operates as a release, it falls outside Article 55(a)
and squarely attracts Article 55(b), which itself prescribes the same stamp
duty as a Conveyance under Article 23(a) of Schedule I-A on the market
value of the share, interest, part, or claim renounced. Equally, if construed
as a conveyance under Section 2(10) of the Act (an expression wider than
a "sale" under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882), the
stamp duty leviable under Article 23(a) would be identical. The wider
question regarding the true nature of the instrument is accordingly left
open.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -9-
20. Turning to the challenge against the clarification dated
29.12.2008 (Annexure P-5), it is necessary to distinguish legislative
substitution from executive remission. Article 55 of Schedule I-A was
substituted by the Haryana State Legislature, the Indian Stamp (Haryana
Amendment) Act, 2000 (Haryana Act No. 10 of 2000). While Section
9(1)(a) empowers the State Government, by rule or order published in the
Official Gazette, to reduce or remit stamp duties, the Financial
Commissioner, Revenue, has no competence through an administrative
circular to add to, subtract from, or alter the statutory categories enacted
in Article 55(a). However said issue is not challenged before this court.
21. Be that as it may, once the instrument in question squarely
falls within the residuary ambit of Article 55(b), the operation of that
statutory mandate renders the petitioner incapable of carrying the
challenge to clarifications dated 29.12.2008 (Annexure P-5) any further.
Consequently, the web of arguments woven by the petitioner fails to
evoke an adjudication of the validity of clarifications dated 29.12.2008
(Annexure P-5) on the anvil of Articles 14 and 15(1) of the Constitution
of India.
22. In view of the above discussion, the instrument in question is
liable to stamp duty under Article 55(b) of Schedule I-A of the Indian
Stamp (Haryana Amendment) Act, 2000 , as it falls within the category of
instruments covered by the said provision, and does not qualify for the
concessional rate prescribed under Article 55(a) of the ibid Act.
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-15957-2020 (O&M) -10-
23. This Court has also otherwise examined the impugned orders
passed by the authorities below, i.e. the Collector and the Commissioner
concerned, and finds no perversity, illegality or jurisdictional error
warranting any interference in the exercise of its writ or supervisory
jurisdiction under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India.
24. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed .
25. All pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly.
(KULDEEP TIWARI)
November 18, 2026 JUDGE
dharamvir
Whether speaking/reasoned. : Yes
Whether Reportable. : Yes
DHARAM VIR
2026.11.18 18:20
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document