M/S Shiv Anant Enterprises vs State Of U.P. And 3 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
Reserved on 04.11.2026
Delivered on 18.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - C No. - 40904 of 2026
M/s Shiv Anant Enterprises
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 3 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Rajeev Kumar Singh
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C.
Court No. - 5
HON'BLE PRAKASH PADIA, J.
HON'BLE INDRAJEET SHUKLA, J.
Delivered by Indrajeet Shukla, J.
For the sake of exposition, instant judgment is divided into
following segments:
Index
Serial No. Heading Page Nos.
1 Facts in Brief 2-6
2 Case of State-respondents 6-15
3 Contention raised on behalf of petitioner 15-20
4 Contention raised on behalf of State-
20-21
respondent
5 Authoritative pronouncements qua
enforcement of contractual rights against the
21-24
State or its instrumentalities
6 Analysis and Reasoning 24-31
7 Conclusion and the Final Order 31-33
2
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
1. Heard Sri Rajeev Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the petitioner
and Sri Dharmendra Prasad Singh, learned Additional Chief Standing
Counsel appearing for the State-respondents.
2. Instant writ petition has been instituted with following prayers.
“a. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of
certiorari to quash the impugned order/Letter No.1387 dated
29.09.2026 passed by the respondent no.4-Divisional Food
Controller, Basti Division, Basti as well as impugned Very
Short Term E-Tender Notice (Single Stage Door Step
Delivery)/Letter No.1386 dated 29.09.2026.
b. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of
mandamus commanding the respondents to consider the
candidature of the petitioner and allot the contractual work in
pursuance of Very Short Term E-Tender Notice (Single Stage
Door Step Delivery) Letter No.1215 dated 08.09.2026 and
issued the work order in his favour in pursuance of aforesaid
tender notice on his lowest rate.
c. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of
mandamus commanding the respondent no.4-Divisional Food
Controller, Basti Division, Basti to consider and decide the
representation of the petitioner dated 28.09.2026 by passing a
reasoned and speaking order within stipulated period as may
be fixed by this Hon’ble Court.”
Facts in Brief
3. The factual matrix for better appreciation and adjudication of the
controversy in question is delineated as under:
3.1. Under challenge is the order/letter No. 1387 dated 29.09.2026
passed by the 4th respondent/Divisional Food Controller, Basti,
Division-Basti, cancelling the tender invited for Block-Bansi in
pursuance of short-term E-Tender notice (Single stage door step
delivery)/Letter No. 1214, dated 08.09.2026.
3.2. The petitioner has further laid challenge to the Short-Term E-
tender Notice (Single Stage Door Step Delivery)/Letter No. 1386, dated
29.09.2026 issued by the 4th respondent/Divisional Food Controller,
3
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
Basti, Division-Basti, whereby a fresh tender for Block–Bansi, District–
Siddharth Nagar has been invited.
3.3. Petitioner claims to be a registered firm named and styled as M/s
Shiv Anant Enterprises involved in the business of transportation of food
grains and is a contractor in the Department of Food and Civil Supply,
Uttar Pradesh.
3.4. Admittedly, E-Tender Notice (Single Stage Door Step
Delivery)/Letter No. 3543, dated 11.03.2026 was issued by 4th
respondent inviting public tender for transportation of food grains from
godown to public places for 35 Blocks of Districts– Basti, Sant Kabir
Nagar and Siddharth Nagar; a copy of the E-Tender notice dated
11.03.2026 has been brought on record as Annexure No. 3 to this writ
petition.
3.5. In response to the E-Tender notice dated 11.03.2026 as many as
three contractors applied, viz M/s Hamara Pump Itwa Fuel Center (for
short ‘M/s Hamara Pump’), Shiv Anant Enterprises (petitioner) and
Vaibhav Laxmi Enterprises.
3.6. The opening of the technical bid led to cancellation of the tender
with respect to 25 Blocks for want of competition. Subsequently, with
respect to the aforesaid 25 Blocks, fresh tender notice/E-Tender (Single
Stage Door Step Delivery)/Letter No. 868 dated 14.07.2026 was again
published inviting fresh tender for transportation of food grains from the
operative godown to public places for 25 Blocks of Districts– Basti, Sant
Kabir Nagar and Siddharth Nagar. The said tender notice is appended at
Annexure No. 4 to this writ petition.
3.7. The opening of the technical bid in pursuance of the tender notice
dated 14.7.2026 led to cancellation of the tender notice for Block–Bansi
and Block–Uska Bazaar, District–Siddharth Nagar and thereafter, a fresh
short term E-Tender notice (Single Stage Door Step Delivery) vide letter
no. 1215 dated 08.09.2026 was again published by the 4th respondent
inviting a fresh tender for the purposes of transportation of food grains
from the operative godown to public places for only two blocks, namely
Block– Bansi and Block– Uska Bazaar, District, Siddhartha Nagar
4
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
respectively. The said Short Term E-Tender Notice published vide letter
No. 1215 on 08.09.2026 is part of this writ petition as Annexure No. 5.
3.8. The E-Tender notice dated 08.09.2026 was responded to by
submitting technical as well as financial bids by as many as three
aspirants, i.e. M/s Hamara Pump Itwa Fuel Centre, Shiv Anant
Enterprises and M/s Om Traders. The technical bids of all three aforesaid
tenders were opened on 14.09.2026 and were found responsive.
3.9. The case of petitioner is the technical bid of one of the contractor
i.e. M/s Hamara Pump did not merit acceptance and for this reason, an
objection was raised by submitting the registration certificate of vehicle
i.e. UP55-80 1041 (tanker) same being plied for transportation of liquid
product (petrol and diesel) was unsustainable. Thus, the vehicle
proposed by contractor M/s Hamara Pump did not meet the standard
prescribed in the tender notice itself. It is also not disputed that since the
bid evaluation committee found the technical bid of all three contractors
responsive in pursuance of the tender notice dated 08.09.2026, as such,
the financial bid too was opened on 22.09.2026; consequently, M/s
Hamara Pump was declared as L-1, whereas petitioner’s financial bid
was found to be L-2 and the third contractor M/s Om Traders was
declared as L-3.
3.10. It is the admitted position that before opening of technical bid,
the objections could have been raised in terms of the conditions
mentioned in the tender notice but no such objection was raised, and it is
after financial bid of M/s Hamara Pump was declared L-1, the technical
bid was sought to be disputed through complaint made by one Vijay
Prakash on 22.09.2026. The work order was issued in favour M/s
Hamara Pump on 23.09.2026 under the signature of the 4th respondent,
and thereafter, a de novo complaint was again submitted on 24.09.2026
by the petitioner.
3.11. The complaint with respect to the technical bid was enquired
into, and finding substance in the complaint, the work order dated
23.09.2026 issued in favour of M/s Hamara Pump was cancelled vide
order dated 26.09.2026 bearing letter no.1369. The said cancellation
5
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
order has not been put to challenge by M/s Hamara Pump; probably, the
reason best known to him , one of them might be a flawed technical bid,
as the vehicle proposed was not fit for transportation of food grains, but
rather was a tanker, which is in direct conflict with Appendix 1 being
part of the tender notice.
3.12. On 26.09.2026, vide letter No. 1369, Respondent No. 4 floated a
proposal to the petitioner, being L-2 and another Contractor M/s Om
Traders, being L-3, to extend their willingness to perform the contract
work of transportation of food grains at Block Bansi, District Siddharth
Nagar, at the rate L-1 offered by M/s Hamara Pump. The petitioner was
required to furnish a consent letter in response to the letter dated
26.09.2026 by 01:00 pm on 28.09.2026.
3.13. The further pleaded case of the petitioner is that in response to
letter dated 26.09.2026 issued by 4th respondent, it was made clear that
once the technical bid of M/s Hamara Pump was not found responsive, it
was incumbent upon respondent to cancel the technical bid which would
lead one and only one conclusion that the financial bid offered by
petitioner should be treated as L-1 and there is no other possible
conclusion survives. Several reminders were given to accept the offer
made by the petitioner, treating him as L-1, as the technical bid of the
M/s Hamara Pump was non-responsive. It has also been emphasized that
the petitioner has represented his cause on 29.09.2026 before the
Principal Secretary, Food and Supply Department, The Commissioner,
Food and Supply Department, U.P. and Commissioner, Basti Division,
Basti, but they all went in vain.
3.14. It has further been pleaded that without considering the
representation of the petitioner made on 26.09.2026 and 28.09.2026,
finally the tender notice, i.e. letter no.1214 dated 08.09.2026, has been
cancelled vide order impugned dated 29.09.2026. Thereafter, fresh
tender notice vide Short Term E-Tender Notice (Single Stage Doorstep
Delivery) letter no.1386 dated 29.09.2026 was published, which is on
record as Annexure no.2 to this writ petition and is under challenge. The
non-consideration of the representation, despite the petitioner being L-1
6
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
due to the non-responsive technical bid of M/s Hamara Pump in
pursuance of the tender notice dated 18.09.2026, is an arbitrary and
illegal exercise on the part of the respondents.
3.15. The petitioner has brought to the notice of this Court, through a
supplementary affidavit, an exemplar that, in similar case and
circumstances in Basti Division, the technical bid of 11th bidder M/s
Mishra Traders at Block Nath Nagar was found non-responsive by the
Tender Evaluation Committee and during negotiation, the contract was
allotted to 12th bidder M/s Pratap Enterprises; thus, the same treatment
may be extended on the part of the respondents to the petitioner also.
Case of State-Respondents
4. The Divisional Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti passed an
order on 29.09.2026 bearing letter no. 1387, cancelling the E-Tender
notice dated 08.09.2026, is well within competence and jurisdiction on
the ground of interest of the public as well as the Government. The three
bidders, namely M/s Hamara Pump, offered 55.010% BSR below the
scheduled rate, whereas M/s Shiv Anant Enterprises, the petitioner,
offered 0.010% BSR and M/s Om Traders offered at the scheduled rate.
There being no complaint till opening of the technical bid, the financial
bid of all three contractors was opened and, being the highest bidder, the
work order dated 23.09.2026, brought as Annexure No.CA-9 to the
counter affidavit, was issued in favour of the M/s Hamara Pump.
5. Pursuant to the receipt of a complaint against the L-1 bidder, M/s
Hamara Pump, in respect of the tender invited through E-tendering for
Block Bansi and upon verification of the said complaint, the office letter
dated 26.09.2026 was issued by Divisional Food Controller, Basti
Division, Basti and thereafter, it was the petitioner, who, under the
negotiations, was offered to accord his consent to execute the work at the
rate quoted by L-1 bidder by 28.09.2026. The petitioner failed to respond
to the proposal floated by the State Respondent and in place of accepting
the same, started representing to the authorities, claiming himself as L-1.
Thus, it declined to furnish its consent to execute the work at the rate
7
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
quoted by the L-1 bidder. A similar failure was found on the part of M/s
Om Traders. Since none of the bidders agreed to execute the work at the
rate quoted by the L-1 bidder for Block Bansi, District Siddharth Nagar,
a short-term E-tender was invited in the interest of the Government as
well as the public at large vide E-Tender notice dated 29.09.2026 issued
by the Divisional Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti, with the
deadline for submission of bids being 12.00 noon on 05.10.2026. The
order of cancellation of the erstwhile tender and publication of fresh
tender notice are under challenge before this Court without any locus or
authority of law or for any justifiable cause.
6. The further pleading raised in the counter affidavit is that smooth
and timely transportation of food grains through the door-step delivery
system in Block Bansi, District Siddhartha Nagar is connected with the
public interest; thus, the fresh tendering was the call of the hour, keeping
the public interest as well as saving public revenue. The cancellation of
earlier technical bids with respect to 25 blocks was never put to
challenge, as transparency and healthy competition were an attempt by
the State authorities. The cancellation of tenders even in past was due to
the absence of adequate competition, being a practice consistent with the
prescribed rules to safeguard the public interest and protect Government
revenue. The work order was issued in favour of the M/s Hamara Pump
without mala fide, as the flaw in the technical bid could not be noticed
by the State authorities. In the absence of any complaint or any emerging
material brought to the notice of the Tender Evaluation Committee. At
the first opportunity, noticing the technical bid submitted by the highest
bidder being flawed, the work order allotted to him vide order dated
23.09.2026 was cancelled vide letter dated 24.09.2026, and there is
absolutely no challenge to the said cancellation. At this juncture,
reference is made to Appendix -1, which is part of the tender form and
becomes part of the technical bid, which depicts that the appropriate
vehicle with registration number and capacity was to be detailed. The
Appendix-1, having been brought on record, reads thus:
8
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
" -1
परिशिष्ट
- .
सम्भाग का नामः ……………
( )
तकनीकी बिड
, ,
सिंगल स्टेज डोर स्टेप डिलीवरी व्यवस्थान्तर्गत भा०खा०नि० सी०डब्लू०सी०
/ /
एस०डब्लू०सी० बफर गोदामों व अन्य नियत स्थान से खाद्यान्न चीनी आदि का उठान करते हुये उचित दर विक्रेताओं की
दुकान तक पहुंचाने हेतु हैण्डलिंग एवं परिवहन कार्य का आवेदन।
20 ..
वित्तीय वर्ष ……………
1- - .
जनपद का नाम ……………
2- / - .
ब्लाक केन्द्र का नाम ……………
3- - .
निविदादाता का नाम ………………
4- - .
निविदादाता का आधार नम्बर …………
5- - ..
निविदादाता का मोबाइल नं० ………
6- - - .
निविदादाता का ई मेल ………………
7- , ……………….
निविदादाता के बैंक का नाम
पता , एकाउण्ट नम्बर ……………… ...
. . . - .
व आई एफ एस कोड ………………
8- - ( )
निविदा शुल्क ………………… रसीद अपलोड करें
9- - . )
धरोहर धनराशि ……………… रसीद अपलोड करें
10- - /
तकनीकी बिड हेतु संगत अभिलेख प्रमाण पत्र अपलोड करें
I. ..
पत्र व्यवहार का पता ……………
( )
प्रमाण पत्र सहित
II. - ..
स्थायी पता …………………
( )
प्रमाण पत्र सहित
III. स्वयं के ट्रकों व वाणि ज्यि क छोटे
-
वाहन के पंजीकरण नम्बर तथा क्षमता
..
ट्रकों के पंजीकरण नम्बर एवं क्षमता……
-
छोटे वाहन के पंजीकरण नम्बर एवं क्षमता ……
IV.
अनुभवल का विवरण …………
,
V. हैसियत प्रमाण पत्र संख्या
- ...
व निर्गमन का दिनांक ………………
”
7. With respect to parity claimed in the case of Block Nath Nagar,
District Sant Kabir Nagar, it is stated that a total of 3 tenderers were
found eligible in the technical bid by the Tender Committee, and
thereafter, the financial bids were opened with respect to:
A. M/s Mishra Traders @ 05.00% ASR (Above Scheduled Rate).
B M/s Pratap Enterprizes @ 09.00% ASR.
C. Sri Ramesh Chandra Rai @ 11.90% ASR.
9
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
8. It is further stated that from the above, M/s Mishra Traders, the
L-1 bidder, was declared ineligible before issuance of the work order.
Accordingly, the L-2 bidder, M/s Pratap Enterprises, was called for
negotiations by the Divisional Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti,
vide Office Letter No.1059 dated 12.08.2026. During the negotiations,
M/s Pratap Enterprises, vide its letter dated 13.08.2026, consented to
execute the work at the rate quoted by M/s Mishra Traders.
Subsequently, pursuant to Office Letter No.1244 dated 12.08.2026,
issued by the Divisional Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti, M/s
Pratap Enterprises, vide its letter dated 12.09.2026, furnished its consent
to execute the work at the Government-prescribed rate. Thereafter, the
work order was issued in favour of M/s Pratap Enterprises in accordance
with the prescribed rules, vide Office Letter No.1289 dated 18.09.2026.
9. In contrast, in the case of Block Bansi, M/s Hamara Pump, the L-1
bidder, was found ineligible after issuance of the work order dated
23.09.2026 in its favour. Accordingly, the L-2 bidder for Block Bansi,
namely, the petitioner, M/s Shiv Anant Enterprises, was requested to
furnish its consent to execute the work at the L-1 rate vide Office Letter
No. 1369 dated 26.09.2026, issued by the Divisional Food Controller,
Basti Division, Basti. However, in its letters dated 26.09.2026 and
28.09.2026, the petitioner declined to furnish its consent to execute the
work at the rate quoted by M/s Hamara Pump Itwa Fuel Centre.
Consequently, in the interest of the Government and the public at large,
the tender was cancelled by the Divisional Food Controller, Basti
Division, Basti, vide Office Letter No. 1387 dated 29.09.2026, and a
fresh tender was issued vide Office Letter No. 1386 dated 29.09.2026, in
accordance with the prescribed rules. The factual distinction disentitles
the petitioner to claim any parity.
10. In order to defend the order impugned as well as re-tendering, the
provisions contained in the Rules, titled as Uttar Pradesh Procurement
Manual (Procurement of Goods), have been relied upon by the State
10
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
respondents with further submission that the administrative decision to
cancel the erstwhile tendering process and re-tendering is based on
fairness, good conscience and to subserve the public cause. The said
procurement manual is statutory in character, having been issued under
Article 166 (2) and (3) of the Constitution of India coming in force on 01
April 2016, and governs the field and realm of contract where the State
is one of the parties. The relevant excerpts as contained in Chapters 13
and 14 of the Procurement Manual read thus:
“Two Bid System
13.28. For purchasing capital equipment, high value plant, machinery,
etc., of complex and technical nature, tender enquiry document,
complete in all respects, may be issued as usual. However, the tenderers
should be asked to bifurcate their quotation in two parts. The first part is
to contain the relevant technical specifications and allied commercial
details and earnest money (wherever asked for) as required in terms of
the tender enquiry documents and the second part should contain only
the price quotation. The first part is commonly known as 'Technical Bid'
and the second part 'Financial Bid'.
13.29. The Technical Bid and the Financial Bid shall be sealed by the
tenderer in separate covers duly super scribed and both these sealed
covers are to be put in a bigger cover which should also be sealed and
duly super scribed following similar procedure as prescribed under para
13.13 of this chapter. The Technical Bids are to be opened in the first
instance, at the prescribed time and date and the same will be scrutinised
and evaluated by the competent committee/authority with reference to
parameters prescribed in the tender documents and the offers received
from the tenderers. Thereafter, in the second stage, the Financial Bids of
only the technically acceptable offers (as decided in the first stage
above) are to be opened for further scrutiny, evaluation, ranking and
placement of contract.
14.4. The officer nominated for handling the tenders for initial scrutiny
etc. will receive the tenders along with other documents from the tender
opening officials in a manner as described under para 13.26 of chapter
13. In this context, it should be ensured that no tender is rejected by the
tender opening officials at the tender opening stage; they are to open all
the tenders as received and send them to the officer concerned as
prescribed above.
14.5. All the14.22. The Procuring entity reserves the right to accept or
reject any bid, to annul the bidding process and reject all bids at any time
prior to contract award, without thereby incurring any liability to the
bidders. Reasons for doing so shall be recorded in writing in the
purchase file. tenders so received will first be scrutinised to see whether
11
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
the tenders meet the basic requirements as incorporated in the bidding
documents. The tenders, which do not meet the basic requirements, are
to be treated as unresponsive and ignored.
unresponsive and may be ignored, during the initial scrutiny: The
following are the important points, for which a tender may be declared
as
(1) The tender is not in the prescribed form (where forms are prescribed)
(2) The tender is unsigned.
(3) The tenderer is not eligible, e.g. The tender enquiry condition says
that the hidder has to be a registered SSI unit; but the tenderer is say, a
Large Scale Unit.
(4) The tender validity period is shorter than the required period.
(5) Required EMD has not been provided.
(6) The tenderer has quoted for goods manufactured by a different
firm/company without the required authority letter from the proposed
manufacturer.
(7) Tenderer has not agreed to give the required performance security.
(8) The goods quoted are sub-standard, not meeting the required
specification etc.
14.10. After completing the stage as per para 14.9 above, it is to be
examined whether the remaining tenderers (i.e. other than the
unresponsive tenderers) meet the required qualification criteria
incorporated in the tender document. The tenderers, which do not meet
the required qualification criteria are to be declared unresponsive and not
to be considered further. Details of such tenderers, which do not meet the
required qualification criteria are also to be recorded in the purchase file
along with the grounds for their becoming unresponsive.
In case of Two Bid System, the technical acceptability of the offers are
first determined and, thereafter, the Financial Bids of only the
technically acceptable offers are opened for further scrutiny and
processing for placement of contract. (also refer paras 13.28- 13.29 of
chapter 13)
14.11. (1) The bid evaluation committee's determination of the
responsiveness of a bid should be based on the contents of the bid itself.
A responsive bid is one that meets the requirements of the bidding
documents without material deviation, reservation, or omission where:
deviation' is a departure from the requirements specified in the bidding
documents;
12
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
(b) 'reservation' is the setting of limiting conditions or withholding from
complete acceptance of the requirements specified in the bidding
documents; and
(c) 'Omission' is the failure to submit part or all of the information or
documentation required in the bidding documents.
A material deviation, reservation, or omission is one that,
(a) if accepted, would: -
(1) affect in any substantial way the scope, quality, or performance of the
subject matter of procurement specified in the bidding documents; or
(2) limit in any substantial way, inconsistent with the bidding documents,
the procuring entity's rights or the bidder's obligations under the
proposed contract, or
(b) if rectified, would unfairly affect the competitive position of other
bidders presenting responsive bids.
The bid evaluation committee shall examine the technical aspects of the
bid in particular, to confirm that all requirements of bidding document
have been met without any material deviation or reservation.
(2) Subject to sub para above, the procuring entity shall regard a bid as
responsive if it conforms to all requirements set out in the bidding
documents.
(3) The procuring entity may regard a bid as responsive even if it
contains minor deviations that do not materially alter or depart from the
characteristics, terms, conditions and other requirements set out in the
bidding documents or if it contains errors or oversights that can be
corrected without touching on the substance of the bid. Any such
deviations shall be quantified, to the extent possible, and appropriately
taken account of in the evaluation of bids.
14.15 (1) The criteria fixed for evaluation of Technical bids shall be
clearly mentioned in the bidding documents so as to keep transparency
in selection process. The criteria once fixed for evaluation of technical
bids shall not be changed or relaxed.
(2) Techno-commercial qualifications of the bidders shall be evaluated
on the basis of the weightages of marks assigned or minimum
achievements fixed in the bidding documents for various criteria of
qualifications in the area of professional, technical, financial, managerial
competence, etc. like number of years of experience of the bidder in the
subject matter of procurement, satisfactorily completion of similar
contracts in past certain years, each valuing not less than prescribed
percentage of the value of subject matter of procurement, financial
13
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
turnover of the bidder in past certain years in relation to the value of
subject matter of procurement, the value of works in hand of the bidder
at the time of submitting the bid relative to the value of subject matter of
procurement, etc.
(3) Bidders securing prescribed minimum percent of marks or have
fulfilled minimum achievement norms may be considered to have
technically qualified.
(4) The number of tenderers qualified in technical evaluation should not
generally be less than 3 (three). If the number is less than 3 (three) and it
is considered necessary by the procuring entity to continue with the bid
process, reasons shall be recorded in writing and included in the record
of the procurement proceedings.
(5) The bidders which qualified in the technical evaluation shall be
informed in writing about the date, time and place of opening of their
financial bids. This date should generally be not later than 15 (fifteen)
days from the date of issue of letter.
Evaluation and Ranking of Financial Bids
14.17. (1) Depending on the terms of delivery and the projected
requirement, all the applicable components of the costs, as quoted in the
responsive tenders, are to be added to work out the ultimate evaluated
costs of the tenders. The evaluation is also to include applicable taxes,
duties etc. in the tender prices. Further, if the tender document provides
for any price preference and/or purchase preference for SSI/PSU etc. the
same is also to be kept in view while evaluating such tenders.
(2) Sometimes, while purchasing sophisticated and costly equipment,
machinery, etc. the purchase organisation also gives special importance
to factors like high quality performance, environmental friendly features,
low running cost, low maintenance cost, etc. To take care of the same,
relevant details are to be incorporated in the tender document and the
criteria adopted to assess the benefit of such features while evaluating
the offers are also to be clearly stipulated in the tender document so that
the tenderers are aware of the same and quote accordingly. While
evaluating such offers, these aspects are also to be taken into account.
Such details, whenever considered necessary, should be evolved by
competent technical authority for incorporation in the tender document,
so that there is no ambiguity and/or vagueness in the same.
(3) After completing the entire evaluation process for the responsive
tenders on equitable basis as above, these are to be entered into a ranking
statement in ascending order of the evaluated prices (like L1, L2, L3
etc.) along with other relevant details, so that a clear picture of their
standing as well as comparative financial impact is available at a glance.
14.22. The Procuring entity reserves the right to accept or reject any bid,
to annul the bidding process and reject all bids at any time prior to
14
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
contract award, without thereby incurring any liability to the bidders.
Reasons for doing so shall be recorded in writing in the purchase file.
Dividing the Quantity
14.23. As per standard procedure, each schedule of requirement
incorporated in the tender enquiry document is to be covered on the
lowest responsive tenderer for that schedule without dividing the same.
The tenderer who does not quote for the complete schedule as required is
normally to be treated as unresponsive and ignored. However, there may
be special occasions of purchase of very large quantities of goods which
are beyond the capacity of a single tenderer and the lowest responsive
tenderer is unable to take the load of the entire quantity. In such cases,
the remaining quantity may be ordered on the second lowest.
responsive tenderer (L2) at the rates offered by the lowest responsive
tenders (L1), as far as feasible and for this purpose negotiation may be
held with the above tenderer (viz. L2). In such cases, it may also become
necessary to divide the requirement under a schedule by placing multiple
contracts for part quantities on more than 2 (two) responsive tenderers.
Such eventuality should normally be foreseen and provided for in the
notice inviting tenders. The formula proposed to be adopted for
allocation of orders to multiple (responsive) tenderers should be clearly
brought out in the notice inviting tenders. The splitting of order by
purchasing organisation should be an exception rather than a rule. (also
refer paras 14.30(3) (d) and(e)
Restriction on negotiations
14.30. (1) In case of single source procurement, the negotiations will be
conducted in accordance with para 8.8 of chapter 8.
(2) To the extent possible, no negotiations shall be conducted after the
pre-bid stage. All clarifications needed to be sought shall be sought in
the pre-bid itself. The bidding documents shall have a copy of the
contract enclosed and the same shall not be altered.
(3) Negotiations may, however, be undertaken only with the lowest
tenderer (L1) under the following circumstances :-
(a) There should be no post-tender negotiations with L-1, except in
certain exceptional situations. Such exceptional situations would include,
procurement of proprietary items, items with limited sources of supply
and items where there is suspicion of a cartel formation. The justification
and details of such negotiations should be duly recorded and documented
without any loss of time.
(b) In cases where a decision is taken to go for re-tendering due to the
unreasonableness of the quoted rates, but the requirements are urgent
and a re- tender for the entire requirement would delay the availability of
the item, thus jeopardising the essential operations, maintenance and
15
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
safety, negotiations would be permitted with L-1 bidder(s) for the supply
of a bare minimum quantity. The balance quantity should, however, be
procured expeditiously through a re-tender, following the normal
tendering process.
(c) Convincing reasons must be recorded by the authority recommending
negotiations. Competent authority should exercise due diligence while
accepting a tender or ordering negotiations or calling for a re-tender and
a definite timeframe should be indicated so that the time taken for
according requisite approvals for the entire process of award of tenders
does not exceed one month from the date of submission of
recommendations. In no case should the overall timeframe exceed the
validity period of the tender and it should be ensured that tenders are
invariably finalised within their validity period.
(d) If after due processing, it is discovered that the quantity to be ordered
is far more than what L-1 alone is capable of supplying and there was no
prior decision to split the quantities, then the quantity being finally
ordered should be distributed among the other bidders in a manner that is
fair, transparent and equitable. In cases where the department decides in
advance to have more than one source of supply (due to critical or vital
nature of the item) pre-disclosing the ratio of splitting the supply in the
tender itself must be followed scrupulously.
(e) Counter-offers to L-1, in order to arrive at an acceptable price, shall
amount to negotiations. However, any counter-offer thereafter to L-2,
L-3, etc., (at the rates accepted by L-1) in case of splitting of quantities,
as pre-disclosed in the tender, shall not be deemed to be a negotiation.
(4) In case L-1 backs out, there should be a re-tender.
Note (1) Subject to aforesaid provisions, the bid evaluation committee
(BEC) shall have full powers to undertake negotiations. Detailed reasons
and results of negotiations shall be recorded in the proceedings.
Note -(2) Negotiations will not make the original offer made by the
bidder inoperative. The bid evaluation committee will have option to
consider the original offer in case the bidder decides to increase rates
originally tendered or imposes new terms and conditions.”
Contention raised on behalf of petitioner
11. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted with vehemence that
while rejecting the tender notice dated 08.09.2026 by the impugned
order dated 29.09.2026, the 4th respondent did not consider the claim of
the petitioner in the correct perspective, as the technical bid of M/s
Hamara Pump was ineligible since its inception; as such, there was no
occasion for opening its financial bid and declaring M/s Hamara Pump
16
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
as L-1. In law, the financial bid offered by the petitioner was the highest
and, being the highest bidder, he had the right to get the work order, but
in a very arbitrary manner, the claim of the petitioner has been brushed
aside. The respondent fell in error, firstly in not scrutinising the technical
bid of Hamara Pump at the occasion it arose and thereafter, compelling
the petitioner to execute the work at the rate offered by M/s Hamara
Pump. In a contract matter, fairness is the essence and no party can be
compelled to accept the work order at the price offered by another
contractor being a participant in the same bidding process.
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that while
rejecting the tender notice dated 08.09.2026, the respondent no. 4 did not
consider the application of the petitioner dated 28.09.2026 wherein he
has categorically stated that in similar fact and circumstances in the Basti
Division, the technical bid of L-1 bidder M/s Mishra Traders at Block-
Nathnagar District- Sant Kabir Nagar was disqualified by the tender
committee, during negotiation resultantly, the contract was allotted to
L-2 bidder M/s Pratap Enterprise after negotiation considering his
offered rate, which is clear from the order dated 12.08.2026 passed by
none other than respondent no. 4.
13. The learned counsel for the petitioner invited attention of this
Court to the short term E-Tender notice (Single Stage Door Step
Delivery) letter no.1386 dated 29.09.2026 which has been issued prior to
cancellation of earlier short term E-tender notice (Single Stage Door
Step Delivery) dated 08.09.2026 vide impugned letter no.1387 dated
29.09.2026 thus, the fresh tender notice appears to have been directed to
be published prior to cancellation of erstwhile tender notice. This
indicates a prejudged and premeditated mind of the respondents,
reflecting bias.
14. The alternative submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is
that the petitioner has never refused to accept the rate floated by State
respondents in pursuance of the letter dated 26.09.2026 in unequivocal
terms and only expressed his desire that, being L-2, where the technical
17
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
bid of L-1 has been found to be disqualified/non-responsive, the
financial bid of petitioner ought to have been honoured.
15. The further contention is that, if the writ petition fails, he is ready
to accept the terms offered by the State Government, i.e. the rate offered
by L-1 M/s Hamara Pump at this stage.
16. Lastly, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
cancellation of the erstwhile tender notice and publication of fresh tender
notice for the work in which the petitioner was in fact, L-1 as the
technical bid of the contractor, who was found L-1 was disqualified/non
responsive, would attract the protection of Article 14 of the Constitution
of India.
17. To bolster submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
petitioner, the petitioner has relied upon the judgment of the Delhi High
Court in of Inderjit Mehta Vs. Union of India, 2015 SCC OnLine Del
11661. Relevant paragraph of the judgment reads thus:
“15. It is an admitted position by Respondent 2 that Respondent 3 was
ineligible to participate in the tender process. The affidavit submitted
by Respondent 3 was found to be false and Respondent 3 has been
banned for a period of 5 years by Respondent 2. As Respondent 3 is
stated to have filed a petition impugning ban, we are not examining
the merits of the claim or otherwise of Respondent 3 and Respondent
2 qua the documents submitted by Respondent 3. For the present, we
are assuming the stand of Respondent 2 to be correct that Respondent
3 was not qualified to participate in the tender process as before us
Respondent 3 has not placed any material to show that Respondent 3
was eligible to participate.
16. Since Respondent 3 was ineligible to participate in the tender
process itself, Respondent 2 could not have issued the bid documents
to Respondent 3 entitling them to submit the financial bids. The
situation that emerges is that the bid of Respondent 3 cannot be
considered at all and the tender process has to be considered as if
Respondent 3 had not participated. If that is the position, then the
rates quoted by the petitioner would become L-1.
20. The mere plea of Respondent 2 that that the Accepting Authority
is of the view that lower rates may be possible on re-tender, does not
stand to reason. The lower rates, if any, would not enure to the benefit
of Respondent 2 but would enure, if at all, to the benefit of the earlier
contractor as the subject tender is at the risk and costs of the earlier
contractor. There is no cogent material placed on record to show as to
how the accepting authority has formed such an opinion. The only
18
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
reason that appears from the record is that the petitioner had, in the
first call, quoted higher rates of approximately Rs 172 crores and in
the second call has quoted rates of approximately Rs 162 crores. This
cannot be a ground to form an opinion that in the third call the rates
are further likely to go down. It is not the case of Respondent 2 that
there are only two bidders. The rates quoted by the other bidders
apparently were higher than the petitioner and that is why the
petitioner is now L-1.
21. We are thus of the view that the decision taken by Respondent 2 in
cancelling the subject tender and resorting to re-tender cannot be
sustained. Accordingly, the tender notice dated 17-3-2015 is quashed.
The respondent is directed to declare the petitioner as L-1. In view of
the substantial delay already having been caused, we direct
Respondents 1 and 2 to award the contract to the petitioner subject to
the petitioner satisfying the other conditions of the tender. The petition
is accordingly allowed in the above terms leaving the parties to bear
their own costs.”
18. Another judgment of the Delhi High Court has been relied upon
by learned counsel for the petitioner, rendered in the case of M/S S.B.
Transport Company v. Container Corporation of India and Anr. (2015)
09 DEL CK 0152, paragraph no. 18, read thus:
“18. Having considered the facts of the case and the arguments
submitted by the learned counsel for the parties, in our view, the
requirement of submitting the EMD was an essential condition of the
tender. This is clearly discernible from the mandatory language used in
the Instruction to Tenderers as also in the tender conditions. We have
already pointed out clause 5 of Chapter 1 of the tender conditions
which clearly stipulated that if at any stage during the evaluation of the
technical bid, the EMD was found to be invalid, the respective bidder's
bid would be summarily rejected. Furthermore, in clause 2.3 of
Chapter 2 of the tender conditions it was categorically provided that
documents submitted without EMD 'will be summarily rejected'.
Clause 7 of Chapter 1 of the tender conditions also stipulates that if the
EMD is found invalid at any stage during the evaluation of the e-bid,
the respective bidder's bid would be summarily rejected. All these
stipulations have been provided without any relaxation or any other
condition which would enable us to take a view that the requirement of
furnishing the EMD was not an essential condition of the tender.
Therefore, this much is clear that the requirement of furnishing the
EMD was an essential condition of the tender. It is also an admitted
position that T.N. Singh had not furnished the EMD on the ground that
it had an MSME registration. We have also noted the submission made
by the learned counsel for CONCOR that this was an online bidding
process in which the bidder was specifically required to indicate as to
whether it was exempt as a micro or small enterprise or whether it was
19
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
applying under the general category. T.N. Singh had exercised the
option indicating that it was bidding as a micro / small enterprise.
Admittedly, T.N. Singh was neither. Therefore, T.N. Singh was
required to submit the earnest money deposit which it failed to do. In
our view since the requirement of earnest money deposit was an
essential condition and T.N. Singh had not complied with the same, he
was not eligible to proceed to the next page, that is, of consideration of
pre-qualification bid and / or to the further stage of consideration of the
financial bids. We agree with the submission made by Ms Acharya that
the decisions in G. J. Fernandez (supra), Poddar Steel Corporation
(supra) and Pes Installations Pvt. Ltd. (supra) were on entirely different
sets of facts and circumstances. There is no dispute with the principles
of law l aid down in those decisions but the factual matrix of the
present case is entirely distinct and different from those obtaining in
the said cases. It is clear that there can be two types of conditions -
essential and ancillary. If an ancillary condition is deviated from, then
there may be scope for consideration of a particular bid. But if an
essential condition which does not permitting any deviation, is not
complied with, then the bid is to be rejected summarily and cannot be
considered at all. The consequence of this discussion is that T.N. Singh
was not entitled to proceed to the next stage beyond the consideration
of the EMD and, therefore, there is no question of T.N. Singh being
regarded as the L-1 bidder or the successful bidder and in that respect
the decision of CONCOR in cancelling the Letter of Intent cannot be
faulted.
19. This takes us to the consideration of writ petition filed on behalf of
S.B. Transport Company. In view of our decision that T.N. Singh was
ineligible and that the cancellation of the Letter of Intent by virtue of
the letter dated 21.08.2015 was valid, the next point for consideration
is what is to be done with regard to the subject tender. In this regard,
we feel that the approach adopted by this court in Inderjit Mehta
(supra) could very well be adopted in the present case also. Since T.N.
Singh's bid was not to be considered at all, the tender process would
have to be considered as if T.N. Singh had not participated in the same.
That being the case, the bid of the S.B. Transport Company would
become L-1. CONCOR would have to be treat S.B. Transport
Company as L-1 and proceed with the tender process there from. We
may also note that Ms Maninder Acharya on instructions from Shamal
Singh, Proprietor, S.B. Transport Company and who is present in court
also stated that, so that there is no loss to the public exchequer, they are
willing to match the quote made by T.N. Singh. That being the case
CONCOR shall consider the bid of S.B. Transport Company as L-1 at
the reduced rate equivalent to that which had been offered by T.N.
Singh and to award the contract to S.B. Transport Company provided
that they comply with all other conditions and formalities.”
19. Learned counsel for the petitioner further relied upon the
judgment rendered in the case of West Bengal Electricity Board Vs.
20
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
Patel Engineering Corporation Limited, 2001 (2) SCC 451. Relevant
paragraphs of the judgment read thus:
32. We find no force in the submission that as under clause 14.2
“
items against which no rate or price is entered by the bidder will not
be paid by the employer when executed and shall be deemed covered
by the other rates and prices in the bill of quantities, the unit price in
items containing errors be ignored and the bid be considered on the
basis of the total price bid which is the lowest. In our view, there is a
basic distinction between a case where against some items no rates or
prices are quoted and a case where some rate is quoted. Whereas in
the former case the bidder will not be entitled to claim any specific
amount for the work done by him in the absence of any rate for that
work, because in the aforementioned clause it is clarified that the
bidders will not be paid by the employer and that the execution of the
work shall be deemed covered by other rates and prices in the bill of
quantities, but in the latter case the bidder will be entitled to claim
for the work executed on the basis of quoted price/rate.
33. We may, however, clarify that the appellant is not obliged to
award contract to any of the bidders at their quoted price bid. It is
always open to the appellant to negotiate with the next lowest bidder
for awarding the contract on economically-viable price bid.
34. For the reasons abovementioned, though the impugned order of
the High Court insofar as it relates to quashing of letter of the
appellant dated 18-12-1999 falls within the purview of judicial
review, yet the direction to the appellant to permit correction of
errors by Respondents 1 to 4 in their bid documents and consider
their bid along with the other bid, goes far beyond the scope of
judicial review, as elucidated by this Court in Tata Cellular [(1994) 6
SCC 651] . In the result, we uphold the impugned order of the
Division Bench insofar as it relates to quashing of communication
and letter dated 18-12-1999 and set aside that part of the impugned
order giving direction to the appellant to permit Respondents 1 to 4
to correct bid documents and to consider their bid after correction
along with other bids. The appeal is thus allowed in part. On the facts
and in the circumstances of this case we leave the parties to bear
their own costs.”
Contention raised on behalf of State-respondent
20. Learned Counsel for State-Respondent, Sri Dharmendra Prasad
Singh submitted that the order impugned cancelling the tender process
dated 08.09.2026 and the decision for re-tendering dated 29.09.2026 are
based on the statutory rules named and styled as the procurement
manual.
21
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
21. The further submission is that the negotiation was offered to the
petitioner, treating him as the highest bidder once the technical bid of
M/s. Humara Pump was found non-responsive after the work order in his
favour was cancelled, but the negotiation failed as the petitioner, in a
recalcitrant manner, tried to force the State authorities to accept the price
offered for the contract, which is alien to the constitutional mandate
requiring fair treatment and equality.
22. The further submission is that the highest bidder does not acquire
any right to have a contract concluded unless the formal agreement is
entered into. The State is not bound to accept the highest tender or bid
and the Government validly retains its power to accept or reject the
highest bid in the interest of public revenue. Petitioner’s case of treating
him as the highest bidder is of no consequence for conclusion of
contract.
Authoritative pronouncements qua enforcement of contractual rights
against State or its instrumentalities
23. It is no more res integra that the State and its instrumentalities are
not exempt from the duty to act fairly, merely because in their business
dealings they have entered into the realm of contract. The Supreme
Court, in Shrilekha Vidyarthi (Kumari) v. State of U.P., (1991) 1 SCC
212, reiterated that the State is bound by the mandate of Article 14 even
in contractual matters and cannot act arbitrarily merely because the
relationship arises out of a contract. This principle was reaffirmed in
Madras Aluminium Company Limited v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board,
(2023) 8 SCC 240, holding that State action in the contractual sphere
must conform to the constitutional requirements of fairness,
reasonableness and non-arbitrariness. Further, in Association of
Registration Plates v. Union of India, (2005) 1 SCC 679, the Supreme
Court held that although the State has discretion to prescribe tender
conditions and determine the eligibility of prospective contractors, such
discretion must be exercised fairly, reasonably and in the public interest,
without arbitrary discrimination. Similarly, in Air India Ltd. v. Cochin
22
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
International Airport Ltd., (2000) 2 SCC 617, the Supreme Court held
that while the State enjoys commercial discretion in awarding contracts,
it must adhere to its own prescribed norms and procedures, and any
departure therefrom is amenable to judicial review where the decision-
making process is vitiated by mala fides, unreasonableness or
arbitrariness; however, judicial interference must be exercised cautiously
and only where warranted by overwhelming public interest.
24. The Supreme Court, in State of U.P. v. Sudhir Kumar Singh,
(2021) 19 SCC 706, reiterated that State action in contractual matters is
not immune from constitutional scrutiny under Article 14 and that
cancellation of a tender must satisfy the requirements of fairness,
reasonableness and principles of natural justice. Similarly, in Udai Pal
Singh v. State of U.P., Writ-C No. 36416 of 2018, decided on
22.01.2019, the Allahabad High Court held that cancellation of a
contract or auction without affording an opportunity of hearing to the
successful bidder, particularly after compliance with the requisite
payment conditions, is arbitrary, perverse and violative of natural justice.
The Court further held that executive orders cannot override statutory
bye-laws and that cancellation decisions founded upon inapplicable
Government Orders, or exercised inconsistently and arbitrarily, are liable
to be set aside as suffering from unreasonableness.
25. The Supreme Court, in ICOMM Tele Ltd. v. Punjab State Water
Supply & Sewerage Board, (2019) 4 SCC 401, reiterated that State
authorities, even while acting in the contractual sphere, are bound by
Article 14 and must ensure fairness, reasonableness and non-
arbitrariness in their actions, which remain amenable to judicial review.
In Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Ltd.,
(2016) 16 SCC 818, the Supreme Court held that constitutional courts
should ordinarily defer to the interpretation and understanding of tender
conditions by the employer or project owner and should interfere only
where the decision-making process or decision is vitiated by mala fides,
arbitrariness, irrationality or perversity. Further, in SEBI v. Bhavesh
Pabari, (2019) 5 SCC 90, the Supreme Court held that where no
23
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
limitation period is prescribed for the exercise of statutory power, such
power must nevertheless be exercised within a reasonable time,
determined with reference to the facts and circumstances of the case, the
nature of the default, prejudice caused and creation of third-party rights.
26. The Supreme Court in Save Mon Region Federation & Anr. v.
State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors., 2026 SCC OnLine SC 526, held that
public procurement must be transparent, fair, non-arbitrary and capable
of objective scrutiny, and that repeated departures from competitive
tendering, absence of recorded reasons for dispensing with tender, non-
production of vouchers and other core procurement records, and
allegations of conflict of interest/related-party benefit are not matters
which can be brushed aside as mere administrative irregularities. The
relevant remarks in Save Mon Region Federation (supra) are reproduced
hereinbelow:
“10. The award of public contracts is an exercise of public power. It
involves the expenditure of public funds and the conferment of
economic benefit by the State. Such decisions are not insulated as
matters of private contract. They are subject to the discipline of Article
14 of the Constitution of India, because the State must act fairly,
transparently, and in a non-arbitrary manner when it distributes public
resources.
11. This Court has repeatedly recognised that State owned or public
owned resources cannot be dealt with at the absolute discretion of the
executive. Public interest is the paramount consideration. One of the
ordinary and safest methods of securing that public interest is by
inviting competition through tenders. A departure from competitive
tendering may be permissible in a limited set of situations, but only
when the departure is justified by rational and recorded reasons that do
not suggest discrimination. In Sachidanand Pandey v. State of W.B.2,
this Court emphasised that appearance of public justice is as important
as doing justice, and nothing should be done which gives an appearance
of bias, jobbery or nepotism. That principle has particular force in
matters of public contracting, because secrecy, discretion and personal
proximity are precisely the conditions in which abuse of power
becomes difficult to detect.
13. The discipline that governs State largesse reinforces this position.
The State and its instrumentalities cannot confer benefits according to
the whims of any political or administrative functionary. In Akhil
hartiya Upbhokta Congress v. State of M.P.3, this Court held that every
decision to confer benefit must be founded on a sound, transparent and
24
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
discernible policy and must be implemented by a non- discriminatory
method, free from favouritism and nepotism. The same understanding
informs the statement in Centre for Public Interest Litigation v. Union
of India4, that whenever a contract or licence is granted the public
authority must adopt a transparent and fair method so that eligible
persons have a fair opportunity of competition. These decisions do not
lay down tendering as a mechanical ritual. They treat transparency and
fair opportunity as constitutional essentials in the disposition of public
resources.
14. These principles are especially stringent where the allegation is of
conflict of interest or related party benefit. In such situations, the
constitutional concern (2011) 5 SCC 29 (2012) 3 SCC 1 is not limited
to whether the State obtained value for money. The concern is whether
public power was used, directly or indirectly, to confer private
advantage, or whether the process was structured in a manner that
excluded competition and enabled a preferred beneficiary. Once such a
concern arises on the record, it is not answered by showing that the
overall percentage of work awarded to related parties is numerically
small. A constitutional violation in public contracting is not diluted by
statistics. Even a single instance, if established, undermines equality,
the rule of law and public confidence in fair administration.
15. At the same time, it must be emphasized that judicial review in this
field does not convert the Court into a tender approving authority. The
Court does not sit to choose the contractor or to re-evaluate technical
bids. The Court examines whether the process conforms to
constitutional standards of fairness, transparency and non-arbitrariness,
and whether the record supports the decision. Where the complaint is
not about comparative merits of bidders but about systemic opacity,
repeated departures from competitive methods, missing records and
alleged conflict of interest, the matter travels beyond an ordinary
contractual grievance and raises questions of constitutional
accountability.”
Analysis and Reasoning
27. At this juncture, it is pertinent to point out that in pursuance to E-
Tender notice no.1386 dated 29.09.2026, as many as five contractors,
including the petitioner, have applied/participated. The law does not
entitle any bidder/contractor to compel the other party to accept the rate
offered by him unless a formal contract is entered into, thus, the
petitioner has no legal or enforceable statutory right. The bleak attempt
of the petitioner to equate the tendering process for Block Nath Nagar,
District Sant Kabir Nagar with the E-tendering process for Block Bansi,
District Siddharth Nagar is wholly misplaced and circumstances
25
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
surroundings the two tendering process are entirely different. Prior to
issuance of work order for Block Nath Nagar, it was only upon finding
M/s Mishra Traders, the L-1 bidder, ineligible the L-2 bidder, M/s Pratap
Enterprises, was called for negotiation by the Divisional Food
Controller, Basti Division, Basti, vide office letter no.1059 dated
12.08.2026. During the negotiations, M/s Pratap Enterprises, vide its
letter dated 13.08.2026, consented to execute the work at the rate quoted
by M/s Mishra Traders. Subsequently, pursuant to Office Letter No.1244
dated 12.08.2026, issued by the Divisional Food Controller, Basti
Division, Basti, M/s Pratap Enterprises, vide its letter dated 12.09.2026,
furnished its consent to execute the work at the Government-prescribed
rate. Thereafter, the work order was issued in favour of M/s Pratap
Enterprises in accordance with the prescribed rules, vide office letter
no.1289 dated 18.09.2026.
28. In contrast, in respect of Block Bansi, after the work order had
been issued in favour of the L-1 bidder, M/s Hamara Pump, the said firm
was found ineligible. Accordingly, the L-2 bidder for Block Bansi,
namely, the petitioner, M/s Shiv Anant Enterprises, was requested under
negotiations to furnish its consent to execute the work at the L-1 rate,
vide Office Letter No. 1369 dated 26.09.2026, issued by the Divisional
Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti strictly considering tenets of the
provisions contained in the Procurement Manual coupled with the
principles of natural justice However, in view of the petitioner's letters
dated 26.09.2026 and 28.09.2026, whereby it declined to furnish consent
to execute the work at the rate quoted by M/s Hamara Pump Itwa Fuel
Centre, the tender was cancelled in the interest of the Government and
the public at large, vide Office Letter No. 1387 dated 29.09.2026, and a
fresh tender was issued vide Office Letter No. 1386 dated 29.09.2026.
The said action is in accordance with the prescribed rules.
29. With respect to parity sought for contract qua Block Nathnagar,
the case of the State respondent is that the tendering process relating to
another block, or the case, cannot be compared with the present tender
due to factual dissimilarity. The Divisional Food Controller, Basti
26
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
Division, Basti, has taken a just and appropriate decision in the present
matter after duly considering the facts, applicable rules and requirements
of financial transparency.
30. At first blush, the argument advanced by learned counsel for the
petitioner appears to be very attractive, as, unless the erstwhile tender
notice is cancelled, for the same work, a fresh tender notice cannot be
directed to be published. Both the orders of cancellation of the erstwhile
E-tender notice dated 08.09.2026 vide order dated 29.09.2026, and the
direction for publication of fresh E-tender notice appear to be of the
same date, and at this stage, learned counsel for the State-respondent
tried to defend, saying that it is only a typographical error and the
decision has been taken simultaneously on the same day. Firstly, the
erstwhile tender notice dated 08.09.2026 was cancelled and then
thereafter, the fresh tender notice was directed to be published vide order
dated 29.09.2026 with two different letter numbers. The letter numbers
appear to have been interchanged. The error noticed appears to be
inadvertent, as the decision to cancel the erstwhile tender notice and the
publication of the fresh tender notice have been taken on one and the
same date and once the authorities decided to cancel the erstwhile tender
notice and published a fresh tender notice, mere mention of interchanged
letter numbers would not render any assistance favoring the petitioner.
Though, the tender process requires fairness particularly when State is
one of the parties, thus, the State Authorities are cautioned to be careful
in future.
31. Thus, the cancellation of the earlier tender and the issuance of the
fresh tender were inter-related processes and were carried out on the
same date. Therefore, the petitioner's allegation, founded merely upon
the serial numbers of the respective letters, is devoid of merit.
32. It is found that M/s Mishra Traders, the L-1 bidder for Block
Nathnagar, being declared ineligible, the L-2 bidder, M/s Pratap
Enterprises, consented to execute the work at the L-1 rate, i.e., 5% above
the scheduled rate, and subsequently also agreed to execute the work at a
rate lower than the rate quoted by the L-1 bidder, namely, at the
27
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
scheduled rate. Thereafter, in the interest of the Government, the work
order was issued in favour of the L-2 bidder, M/s Pratap Enterprises, by
the Divisional Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti, vide Office Letter
No.1289 dated 18.09.2026.
33. On the other hand, in respect of the tender invited for Block Bansi,
the petitioner, M/s Shiv Anant Enterprises, which was the L-2 bidder,
declined to furnish its consent to execute the work at the rate quoted by
the L-1 bidder, M/s Hamara Pump Itwa Fuel Centre, i.e., 55.010% above
the BSR (Basic Schedule of Rates). Consequently, in the interest of the
Government, the Divisional Food Controller, Basti Division, Basti,
cancelled the previously invited tender for Block Bansi vide Office
Letter No. 1387 dated 29.09.2026 and re-invited tenders through the
very short-term E-Tender Notice No. 1386 dated 29.09.2026.
34. Admittedly, the technical bid in pursuance of the fresh tender
notice published on 29.09.2026 has yet to be opened, and finalization of
the technical bid was made subject to the final outcome of the present
writ petition, vide order dated 14.10.2026, and it has been informed at
the Bar that, as on today, the same has not been opened.
35. Though not cited by the parties, this Court is cognizant of the
Supreme Court decision rendered in the case of U.P.Avas Evam Vikas
Parishad & Ors. v. Om Prakash Sharma, 2013 (5) SCC 182. The
paragraph nos. 28, 29, 30 and 31 shed light on the issue in question,
which reads as under:
28. It is also an undisputed fact that the offer of the plaintiff is highest as
per the terms and conditions of the sale of plot in question by public
auction are concerned, 20% of the bid amount deposited by him that by
itself does not amount to accepting his bid by the competent authority for
grant of leasehold rights of plot in his favour.
29. This Court in Meerut Development Authority case [(2009) 6 SCC 171 :
(2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 803] has laid down the legal principle that the bidder
who has participated in tender process has no other right except the right to
equality and fair treatment in the matter of evaluation of competitive bids
offered by interested persons in response to the notice inviting tenders in a
transparent manner and free from hidden agenda. The relevant paragraphs
are extracted hereunder: (SCC p. 182, paras 27 & 29)
28
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
“27. The bidders participating in the tender process have no
other right except the right to equality and fair treatment in the
matter of evaluation of competitive bids offered by interested
persons in response to notice inviting tenders in a transparent
manner and free from hidden agenda. One cannot challenge the
terms and conditions of the tender except on the abovestated
ground, the reason being the terms of the invitation to tender are
in the realm of the contract. No bidder is entitled as a matter of
right to insist the authority inviting tenders to enter into further
negotiations unless the terms and conditions of notice so
provided for such negotiations.
29. The Authority has the right not to accept the highest bid and
even to prefer a tender other than the highest bidder, if there
exist good and sufficient reasons, such as, the highest bid not
representing the market price but there cannot be any doubt that
the Authority's action in accepting or refusing the bid must be
free from arbitrariness or favouritism.”
30. In support of the said proposition, the learned Senior Counsel for the
defendant, Mr Rakesh Dwivedi has also placed reliance upon another
decision of this Court in State of U.P. v. Vijay Bahadur Singh [(1982) 2
SCC 365] . The learned Senior Counsel has rightly placed reliance upon
the judgment of this Court in Rajasthan Housing Board case [(2007) 1
SCC 477] which reads as under: (SCC p. 483, para 9)
“9. This being the settled legal position, the respondent
acquired no right to claim that the auction be concluded in its
favour and the High Court clearly erred in entertaining the writ
petition and in not only issuing a direction for consideration of
the representation but also issuing a further direction to the
appellant to issue a demand note of the balance amount. The
direction relating to issuance of the demand note for balance
amount virtually amounted to confirmation of the auction in
favour of the respondent which was not the function of the
High Court.”
The law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid paragraph in
support of the proposition of law that so long as an order
regarding final acceptance of the bid had not been passed by
the Chairman of the Housing Board, the highest bidder acquire
no vested right to have the auction concluded in his favour and
the auction proceedings could always be cancelled. Further, he
has placed reliance on another decision of this Court in
Laxmikant [(1996) 4 SCC 208] referred to supra. In support of
the proposition of law this Court has rightly pointed out that the
“State” or the authority, which can be held to be “State” within
the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution, is not bound to
accept the highest tender/offer or bid and the Government
could validly retain its power to accept or reject the highest bid
in the interest of public revenue. In support of this contention,
he has placed reliance on State of Orissa v. Harinarayan Jaiswal
29
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
[(1972) 2 SCC 36] case, relevant paragraph of which reads as
under: (SCC pp. 44-45, para 13)
“13. Even apart from the power conferred on the Government
under Sections 22 and 29, we fail to see how the power retained
by the Government under clause (6) of its order, dated 6-1-
1971, can be considered as unconstitutional. As held by this
Court in Cooverjee B. Bharucha case [Cooverjee B. Bharucha
v. Excise Commr., AIR 1954 SC 220] , one of the important
purpose of selling the exclusive right to sell liquor in wholesale
or retail is to raise revenue. Excise revenue forms an important
part of every State's revenue. The Government is the guardian
of the finances of the State. It is expected to protect the
financial interest of the State. Hence quite naturally, the
legislature has empowered the Government to see that there is
no leakage in its revenue. It is for the Government to decide
whether the price offered in an auction-sale is adequate. While
accepting or rejecting a bid, it is merely performing an
executive function. The correctness of its conclusion is not
open to judicial review. We fail to see how the plea of
contravention of Article 19(1)(g) or Article 14 can arise in these
cases. The Government's power to sell the exclusive privileges
set out in Section 22 was not denied. It was also not disputed
that those privileges could be sold by public auction. Public
auctions are held to get the best possible price. Once these
aspects are recognised, there appears to be no basis for
contending that the owner of the privileges in question who had
offered to sell them cannot decline to accept the highest bid if
he thinks that the price offered is inadequate. There is no
concluded contract till the bid is accepted. Before there was a
concluded contract, it was open to the bidders to withdraw their
bids (see Union of India v. Bhim Sen Walaiti Ram [(1969) 3
SCC 146] ). By merely giving bids, the bidders had not
acquired any vested rights. The fact that the Government was
the seller does not change the legal position once its exclusive
right to deal with those privileges is conceded. If the
Government is the exclusive owner of those privileges, reliance
on Article 19(1)(g) or Article 14 becomes irrelevant. Citizens
cannot have any fundamental right to trade or carry on business
in the properties or rights belonging to the Government—nor
can there be any infringement of Article 14, if the Government
tries to get the best available price for its valuable rights. The
High Court was wholly wrong in thinking that purpose of
Sections 22 and 29 of the Act was not to raise revenue. Raising
revenue as held by this Court in Cooverjee B. Bharucha v.
Excise Commr. [Cooverjee B. Bharucha v. Excise Commr.,
AIR 1954 SC 220] case was one of the important purposes of
such provisions. The fact that the price fetched by the sale of
country liquor is an excise revenue does not change the nature
of the right. The sale in question is but a mode of raising
revenue. Assuming that the question of arbitrary or unguided
30
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
power can arise in a case of this nature, it should not be
forgotten that the power to accept or reject the highest bid is
given to the highest authority in the State i.e. the Government
which is expected to safeguard the finances of the State. Such a
power cannot be considered as an arbitrary power. If that power
is exercised for any collateral purposes, the exercise of the
power will be struck down. It may also be remembered that
herein we are not dealing with a delegated power but with a
power conferred by the legislature.
The High Court erroneously thought that the Government was
bound to satisfy the Court that there was collusion between the
bidders. The High Court was not sitting on appeal against the
order made by the Government. The inference of the
Government that there was a collusion among the bidders may
be right or wrong. But that was not open to judicial review so
long as it is not proved that it was a make-believe one. The real
opinion formed by the Government was that the price fetched
was not adequate. That conclusion is taken on the basis of
Government expectations. The conclusion reached by the
Government does not affect any one's rights. Hence, in our
opinion, the High Court misapplied the ratio of the decision of
this Court in Barium Chemicals Ltd. v. Company Law Board
[AIR 1967 SC 295] and Rohtas Industries Ltd. v. S.D. Agarwal
[(1969) 1 SCC 325].”
(emphasis supplied)
31. In view of the law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid decisions,
the learned Senior Counsel Mr Rakesh Dwivedi has rightly placed reliance
upon the same in support of the case of the first defendant, which would
clearly go to show that the plaintiff had not acquired any right and no
vested right has been accrued in his favour in respect of the plot in
question merely because his bid amount is highest and he had deposited
20% of the highest bid amount along with the earnest money with the
Board. In the absence of acceptance of bid offered by the plaintiff to the
competent authority of the first defendant, there is no concluded contract
in respect of the plot in question, which is evident from letters dated 26-5-
1977 and 8-7-1977 wherein the third defendant had rejected the bid
amount deposited by the plaintiff and the same was refunded to him by
way of demand draft, which is an undisputed fact and it is also not his case
that the then Assistant Housing Commissioner who has conducted the
public auction had accepted the bid of the plaintiff.”
36. It is a settled position of law that the exercise of contractual
powers by the State and its instrumentalities is not immune from
constitutional scrutiny under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
Even in matters arising out of tender proceedings, the State is under a
constitutional obligation to act fairly, reasonably, transparently and bereft
of arbitrariness, favouritism or mala fides. The contractual character of a
31
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
transaction does not confer upon the State an unfettered discretion to act
at its whims or to depart from the standards of fairness and non-
discrimination. Although the constitutional courts ordinarily exercise
restraint in interfering with commercial and administrative decisions
relating to tenders, such restraint does not extend to actions which are
arbitrary, irrational, discriminatory, perverse or actuated by mala fides.
The scope of judicial review, therefore, extends to examining the
decision-making process to ensure that public power is exercised in
conformity with constitutional principles and public interest.
37. It is equally well settled that the principles of natural justice
constitute an integral facet of fairness in administrative action,
particularly where a decision adversely affects the rights and legitimate
interests of a person participating in a tender process. Any decision to
cancel a tender or deprive a successful bidder of the benefit accruing
from the tender process must be founded upon cogent reasons, taken
within a reasonable time and, wherever the circumstances so warrant,
after affording the affected party an effective opportunity of hearing. The
State cannot justify an otherwise arbitrary action merely by placing it
within the contractual domain or by relying upon internal
communications which were never duly communicated to the affected
party. Further, the decision-making process must be transparent,
objectively ascertainable and supported by the relevant records. Where
the action of the State suffers from procedural unfairness, unexplained
delay, absence of cogent reasons or non-observance of the principles of
natural justice, the same becomes amenable to judicial review under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Conclusion and the Final Order
38. It is not in dispute to either of the parties that the technical bid
offered by M/s Hamara Pump was non-responsive, leaving no right to
open a financial bid. The vehicle offered by M/s Hamara Pump bearing
Registration No.UP 55-80 1041 was registered as a tanker, and the
permit is for transportation of petroleum products; thus, it is beyond any
doubt that the technical bid offered by Hamara Pump was flawed from
32
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
its inception. Even if it is assumed that the technical bid of Hamara
Pump was non-responsive and its financial bid was not worthy to be
opened, and the L-2, i.e., the petitioner, was in de facto L-1 but
notwithstanding highest bidder it does not get any indefeasible right to
get the work order it has only the right of negotiation being a species of
principles of natural justice, which was offered to the petitioner vide
letter dated 26.09.2026, but the said opportunity to revise the rate was
blatantly refused by the petitioner as he failed to furnish his consent to
execute the work at the revised rate in terms of the proposal floated by
the department. Since no bidder agreed to execute the bid at the rate the
department wanted, the department, in its wisdom and in the interest of
the Government and the public at large, cancelled the erstwhile tender
notice dated 08.09.2026. Neither any mala fide is alleged against the
department nor is it borne out of record.
39. Thus, on the appreciation of the factual matrix, the relevant case
laws and the procurement manual lead to the inevitable conclusion that
even if the petitioner, in place of L-2 being considered L-1 for all
practical purposes in pursuance to tender notice dated 08.09.2026 and is
treated as the highest bidder who participated in the tender process, no
other right exists, except the right to equality and fair treatment in the
matter of evaluation of competitive bids offered by interested persons in
response to the notice inviting tenders in a transparent manner and free
from hidden agenda.
40. So long as an order regarding final acceptance of the bid has not
been passed by the competent authority, even if the petitioner is
considered to be the highest bidder, does not acquire a vested right to the
conclusion of the contract, particularly in view of Section 4 of the Indian
Contract Act, which speaks of when communication is complete. Thus,
as has been held in Om Prakash Sharma (supra). The highest bidder has
limited rights of equality, fair treatment and negotiation; the bid offered
by him cannot be enforced unless the same is translated into a formal
contact, /agreement.
33
WRIC No. - 40904 of 2026
41. In view of the aforesaid, in the peculiar circumstances,
notwithstanding that the petitioner is treated as the highest bidder, he
does not have an indefeasible right to contract; thus, the writ petition, as
framed by the petitioner, fails, but in the alternative, admittedly the
technical bid has not been opened in pursuance of tender notice dated
29.09.2026, as such no right to the bidders therein has yet been
crystallised.
42. At this Stage, Learned counsel for the petitioner, on instructions
from his client, submitted that the petitioner is willing to execute the
contract at the rate quoted by M/s Hamara Pump in pursuance of the
tender notice dated 08.09.2026. In turn, the query was made in this
regard to the State Counsel, who on the basis of instructions, expressed
no reservation and clarified that the order impugned cancelled the
erstwhile tender process and the decision of re-tendering was taken in
view of the interest of the public as well as the Government qua revenue
issues, and even at this stage, the free and voluntary consent expressed
as above would be honoured by the State respondents.
43. Thus, we permit the petitioner to file a fresh representation
according his consent and willingness for execution of work at rate L-1
as offered by M/s Hamara Pump, and if such offer is made within a
period of one week from today, the same shall be honoured by the State
authorities and the work order shall be executed accordingly with all
promptitude, if there is no other legal impediment.
44. In the wake of the aforesaid, the writ petition is disposed of.
45. Costs made easy.
(Indrajeet Shukla,J.) (Prakash Padia,J.)
November 18, 2026
Mohit
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
Digitally signed by :-
MOHIT KUMAR KUSHWAHA
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad