Bholla Singh vs State Of Punjab & Anr
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 1
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
st
Reserved on 21 of August, 2026
th
Pronounced on 19 of November, 2026
st
Uploaded on 21 of November, 2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No
Whether full judgment is pronounced? Ye s
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M)
Bholla Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others .....Respondents
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
Ram Narain Singh ....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others .....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE PANKAJ JAIN
Present: Mr. Ram Lal Gupta, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. H.P.S. Ishar, Addl. A.G., Punjab.
Mr. Pankaj Bains, Advocate for respondent No.4.
PANKAJ JAIN, J.
These afore-captioned two writ petitions involve common issue.
2. Petitioners are aggrieved of the orders of eviction passed
against them under the Punjab Public Premises and Land (Eviction and Rent
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 2
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
Recovery) Act, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the 1973 Act’). The
petitioners claim to be proprietors of the village. As per their case, the land
recorded in the Record of Rights as ‘Jumla Mushtarka Malkan’ being the
land owned by the proprietors of the village which does not vest in the Gram
Panchayat. Accordingly, their possession over the same can neither be said
to be unauthorized nor they can ordered to be evicted under the provisions of
1973 Act.
3. Counsel for the petitioner has argued CWP No.2594 of 1996 as
the lead case. Thus, the facts are being culled out from the same.
4. The land in question is ‘ Jumla Mushtarka Malkan’ land situated
in village Hassanpur. Consolidation in village Hassanpur was effected in the
year 1960-61. The petitioner claims to be in possession thereof prior
thereto. By way of mutation No.1106, dated 07.06.1964, the land was
transferred in the name of Gram Panchayat on the basis of order dated
22.09.1961 (Annexure P-5) passed by Deputy Collector, Revenue. It
appears that vide order dated 01.10.1982 (Annexure P-6), Additional
Director Consolidation, Punjab, Chandigarh ordered that Jumla Mushtarka
Malkan land measuring 398 Kanal 0 Marlas including the land, in question,
as Mushtarka Malkan, be distributed among the co-sharers.
4.1. The order dated 01.10.1982 (Annexure P-6) was assailed by the
Gram Panchayat before this Court. As per the petitioner, the writ petition
filed by the Gram Panchayat was dismissed and SLP No.8262 of 1984
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 3
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
against the same was also dismissed. The petitioner remained in possession
of the land.
4.2. Gram Panchayat initiated eviction proceedings against the
petitioner under the Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the 1961 Act’). Commissioner vide order dated
08.09.1976 (Annexure P-7) ordered that the question of title is involved and
the same be got adjudicated by approaching Civil Court. Respondent No.4
Gram Panchayat again filed application under Section 7 of the 1961 Act
seeking eviction of the petitioner from the land in question. The application
was dismissed by Collector vide order dated 26.05.1986 (Annexure P-8).
The Civil Suit bearing No.117 dated 02.06.1978 instituted by Gram
Panchayat seeking decree of declaration to the effect that Gram Panchayat is
owner of the land in question also stands dismissed vide judgment and
decree dated 24.08.1979 (Annexure P-9). Having failed to dispossess the
petitioner, the Gram Panchayat initiated eviction proceedings vide
application under Section 4 of the 1973 Act. The application was dismissed
by Collector vide order dated 18.01.1988 (Annexure P-10).
4.3. In appeal preferred by the Gram Panchayat against the same,
Joint Director Panchayats reversed the order passed by the Collector and
accepted the appeal vide order dated 24.01.1989 (Annexure P-11) and
remanded the matter to the District Development and Panchayat Officer for
deciding the same afresh. District Development and Panchayat Officer vide
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 4
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
order dated 25.08.1989 (Annexure P-12) ordered the eviction of the
petitioner. The appeal preferred by the petitioner against the same, stands
dismissed by Commissioner vide order dated 13.10.1995 (Annexure P-13)
5. Counsel for the petitioner has assailed the orders passed by the
authorities contending that the petitioner through his predecessors-in-interest
remained in possession of the land as owner thereof since time immemorial.
Neither any chakota nor any rent was ever paid by the petitioner to the Gram
Panchayat, either in cash or in kind. The petitioner faced murder trial from
the year 1972 to 1975. He remained in custody. During the said period,
Sarpanch fabricated record to the effect that the petitioner came in
possession by way of auction which is against the record.
5.1. Ld. Counsel further submits that repeated attempts were made
by the Gram Panchayat for vacation of the petitioner from the land in
question. Gram Panchayat lost suit for declaration. Application under
Section 7 of 1961 Act already stands dismissed. These orders operate as res
judicata . The petitioner being owner cannot be ordered to be evicted
holding him to be unauthorized occupant.
5.2. Mr. Gupta further submits that the land in question is bachat
land and does not vest in Panchayat. The land vests in proprietors of the
village. Petitioner, being proprietor of Jumla Mushtarka land, is owner in
possession and thus his possession cannot be said to be unauthorized to
initiate proceedings against him under Section 4 of the 1973 Act. In support
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 5
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
of his contentions, counsel relies upon ratio of law laid down in the case of
The State of Haryana vs. Jai Singh and others, 2025 INSC 1122 ,
Bhagwan Singh vs. Director, Consolidation of Holdings, Punjab, 1997
(2) RCR (Civil) 365 , Gurjant Singh vs. Commissioner, Ferozepore
Division, 2000(2) RCR (Civil) 437 , Mahatam Singh and others vs. State
of Punjab and others, (2011) 4 RCR (Civil) 498 , Labh Singh and others
vs. State of Punjab and others, 2021(3) RCR (Civil) 284 , Sadhu Singh
vs. State of Punjab and others, 2010(2) RCR (Civil) 761 , Gram
Panchayat, Amir Khas through its Sarpanch vs. State of Punjab and
another, 2009(12) RCR (Civil) 790 , Gram Panchayat, Village Balad
Kalan vs. Ajmer Singh and another, 2000(4) RCR (Civil) 288 , Anand
Naryan Shukla vs. Jagat Dhari, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 827 , Mary
Pushpam vs. Telvi Curusumary and others, (2024) 3 SCC 224 , Daryao
and others vs. State of U.P. and others, 1961 AIR Supreme Court 1457 ,
Meher Rusi Dalal vs. Union of India and others, 2004(3) RCR(Civil)
244 , State of U.P. vs. Nawab Hussain, (1977) 2 SCC 806 , Abdul Kuddus
vs. Union of India and others, (2019) 6 SCC 604 , Rocky Tyres vs. Ajit
Jain, 1998(2) RCR(Civil) 17 , Amita Shekhawat vs. State of Rajasthan
and others, 2003 AIR Rajasthan 230 and Kalpu and another vs.
Sanaurar Khan and another, 1982 AIR Allahabad 307.
6. Per contra, counsel for respondent No.4 would submit that the
land, in question, is Jumla Mushtarka land. Though, the same does not vest
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 6
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
in Panchayat, but is under the management of Panchayat. The land though
mushtarka land owned by proprietors of the village was carved out of their
holdings on pro rata basis to be used for common purposes. It used to be
auctioned and the income so received was being utilized for the benefit of
the village. Even during the tenure of the petitioner as Sarpanch of the
village, the land used to be auctioned. Thus, he is estopped from claiming
that the land is in his possession since time immemorial.
7. I have heard counsel for the parties and have carefully gone
through records of the case.
8. It is not in dispute that the land in question is Jumla Mushtarka
land which was deducted from the shares of proprietors during consolidation
on pro rata basis. Counsel for the petitioner has argued that the land, in
question, having not been utilized for the common purposes is a bachat land
and thus does not vest in Panchayat and is to be partitioned among the
proprietors as per order dated 01.10.1982 (Annexure P-6) passed by
Additional Director Consolidation, Punjab which attained finality upto
Supreme Court.
8.1. Mr. Gupta however is not in position to dispute that though
order was passed but the land has not been partitioned among the proprietors
till date.
9. The East Punjab Holdings (Consolidation & Prevention of
Fragmentation) Act, 1948 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1948 Act’) was
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 7
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
amended by Punjab Act No.39 of 1963 incorporating Section 23 A, which
reads as under:
“[ 23 A. Management and control of lands for common
purposes to vest in Panchayats or State Government. -- As soon
as a scheme comes into force, the management and control of all
lands assigned or reserved for common purposes of the village
under section 18,-
(a) in the case of common purposes specified in sub-
clause (iv) of clause (bb) of section 2 in respect of
which the management and control are to be
exercised by the State Government, shall vest in the
State Government; and
(b) in the case of any other common purpose, shall vest
in the Panchayat of that village;
and the State Government or the Panchayat, as the case may
be, shall be entitled to appropriate the income accruing
therefrom for the benefit of the village community, and the
rights and interests of the owners of such lands shall stand
modified and extinguished accordingly:
Provided that in the case of land assigned or reserved for the
extension of village abadi or manure pits for the proprietors
and non-proprietors of the village, such land shall vest in
the proprietors and non-proprietors to whom it is given
under the scheme of consolidation]”
9.1. The 1948 Act stands further amended by Punjab Act No.6 of
2007 incorporating Section 42-A which reads as under:
“[ 42-A. Prohibition to partition the land reserved for common
purposes. -- Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act or in
any other law for the time being in force, or in any judgment,
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 8
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
decree, order or decision of any court, or any authority or any
officer, the land reserved for common purposes whether specified
in the consolidation scheme or not, shall not be partitioned
amongst the proprietors of the village, and it shall be utilized and
continue to be utilized for common purposes.]”
10. The issue w.r.t. vires of the Amending Act and the retrospective
operation thereof came up for consideration before a Division Bench of this
Court in the case of Mahatam Singh and others vs. State of Punjab and
others, (2011) 4 RCR (Civil) 498 . While considering the effect of the
Amending Act in light of import of Section 42-A, Division Bench observed
as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
20. It would need to be noticed here that prior to the
incorporation of Section 42-A, there was no provision under the
Consolidation Act, 1948 which specifically dealt with the Bachat
or surplus land and how the same was to be dealt with. The scheme
of the Act as such did not provide an answer to this situation where
the land is reserved for common purpose but has not been ear-
marked for any specific common purpose. It would not be out of
place to mention here that there is no provision under the
Consolidation Act, 1948 or the Consolidation Rules, 1949 which
provide for partition or distribution of land reserved for common
purpose amongst the proprietors of the village and reason for this
is not far to be found. The definition of 'common purpose' under
Section 2 (bb) is the answer, which is inclusive and wide enough,
capable of taking care of any common need, convenience or
benefit of the village and, therefore, leaves ample scope of utilising
this land in future with changed situations and circumstances. The
Legislature was conscious of this and had appropriately defined
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 9
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
common purpose. To appreciate this aspect reference to its
provisions would be beneficial.
Section 2 (bb) which defines 'Common Purpose' reads as follows :-
"2(bb). Common purpose means any purpose in relation to
any common need, convenience or benefit of the village
and includes the following purposes:-
(i) extension of the village abadi
(ii) providing income for the Panchayat of the village
concerned for the benefit of the village community.
(iii) village roads and paths; village drains, village well,
ponds or tanks; village water courses or water channels;
village bus-stands and waiting places, manure pits; hada
rori, public latrines; cremation and burial grounds;
Panchayat Ghar, Janj Ghar; Grazing grounds; tanning
places; mela grounds; public places of religious or
charitable nature; and
(iv) schools and play grounds, dispensaries, hospitals and
institutions of like nature, water works or tubewells
managed and controlled by the State Government or not."
21. The above definition has a very wide sweep. Common
purpose, according to the definition, means any purpose in relation
to any common need, convenience or benefit of the village and
includes the purposes which follow. These purposes when seen and
analyzed, a common current flowing through this stream is, the
common need and convenience or benefit of the village, which is
the guiding force. To give effect to these common purposes and
others which may crop up with the changes which have come
about with the passage of time and advancement in all spheres,
leading to change of habits and basic needs and amenities required
for common purposes, which is an ever increasing and now with
the expanded and increased role, functions and responsibilities of
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 10
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
the Panchayats with the Constitution (Seventy-third amendment)
Act,1992, the 'common purposes' is a growing field which, when it
falls within this definition, would require land. The definition thus
cannot be termed as a restrictive one but is an ever expanding and
need based common purposes of the village. Some purposes as
mentioned in this Section 2 (bb) do indicate the reservation of land
for future needs and requirements which gives an insight and
reflection on the intention of the Legislature. Despite there being
no provision of return of this type of land to the proprietors of the
village by redistribution/repartition but in the absence of any
specific provision dealing with the remaining land left out after
earmarking the land for the common purposes as per the
consolidation scheme, the concept of Surplus/Bachat land was
coined and imported. This resulted in proprietors of the village
claiming repartition/redistribution of common lands which were
not specified in the Consolidation Scheme. This concept although
alien to the scheme of the Consolidation Act, 1948 but in the
absence of there being any provision barring resort to such course,
the same was accepted and given effect to.
22. In Gurjant Singh's case, directions, reproduced above, were
issued proceeding on this assumption, this we conclude, in the light
of deletion of the passage "This exercise, it appears,has not been
done throughout the State of Punjab and Haryana and villages
forming part of Union Territory, Chandigarh even though there is a
specific provision for doing that" apart from another passage where
directions for carrying out the exercise of repartition/redistribution
within a specified time limit were given by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the SLP preferred by the State of Punjab in Gurjant
Singh's case (supra). In other words, it can be said that directions
were based on the interpretation of the provisions of the statute
existent then. With the insertion of Section 42-A of the
Consolidation Act, 1948, the Legislature has addressed and
redressed a difficulty which was earlier not dealt with under the
Act and plugged the breach in the channel which unintendedly
creeped in stealthily, draining out the precious water meant for
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 11
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
common purpose. Had there been Section 42-A at the time when
Gurjant Singh's case was decided, the directions therein could not
have been issued as there would have been a specific provision
dealing with the land reserved for common purposes which was
not specified in the consolidation Scheme. What Section 42-A
provides is that land reserved for common purposes whether
specified in the consolidation Scheme or not, shall not be
partitioned amongst the proprietors of the village and it shall be
utilised and continue to be utilised for common purposes
notwithstanding anything contained in the Consolidation Act, 1948
or in any other law for the time being in force or in any judgment,
decree, order or decision of any Court, or any authority, or any
officer. When tested in the light of the principles, as have been laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Indian Aluminium Co. and
others (supra) and S.S. Bhola and others (supra), it cannot be said
that in exercise of legislative powers, the legislature has over-ruled,
revised or over-ridden a judicial decision which would be thus in
violation of the legislative powers rather the Legislature had
removed the basis on which the decision had been rendered, which
is permissible within and as per the Constitutional Scheme of
separation and balance of powers between the Sovereign
Functionaries. The amendment, which has been brought about, is
consistent with the provisions of the Constitution and the
Legislature also has the competence to enact the same, which is not
under challenge. It cannot be disputed that in exercising legislative
powers, the Legislature can enact law with retrospective effect
which may have the effect of making the decision of this Court in
the case of Gurjant Singh's case (supra) ineffective but in the light
of the affidavit dated 04.08.2010 filed by the State of Punjab
during the course of hearing stating therein that all judgments,
decrees, orders or decisions of any Court or any authority or any
officer where partition of Jumla Malkan lands has been
implemented/given effect to before the date of notification of the
East Punjab Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of
Fragmentation) Amendment Ordinance 2007 i.e. 22.05.2007, the
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 12
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
amendment would not be applicable. The stand of the State is very
reasonable, just and equitable which cannot be faulted with.
23. In view of the above, the vires of Section 42-A in the East
Punjab Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation)
Amendment Act, 2007 (Punjab Act No. 6 of 2007) (Annexure P-1)
inserted after Section 42 and before Section 43 in the East Punjab
Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation ) Act,
1948 are upheld and we hold that the Act is valid. However, its
applicability will be as per the affidavit dated 04.08.2010 filed by
the State of Punjab, as mentioned above.
xxx xxx xxx”
(emphasis supplied)
10.1. Thus, after enactment of Section 42A in the 1948 Act by way of
Punjab Act No.6 of 2007, the law w.r.t. bachat land has undergone sea-
change in Punjab. Ratio of law laid down in Jai Singh’s case (supra) is not
applicable to the present case as the same relates to State of Haryana and not
State of Punjab. Ratio laid down in Gurjant Singh’s case (supra) has been
explained and distinguished by Division Bench in Mahatam Singh’s case
ibid . Ratio of Bhagwan Singh’s case (supra) relates to position of law as it
stood prior to enactment of Section 42A. Reliance placed upon Labh
Singh’s case (supra) is misplaced. The same reiterates the position in
Mahatam Singh’s case ibid .
10.2. Similarly, the ratio of law laid down by Co-ordinate Bench in
Sadhu Singh’s case (supra) is against the proposition being canvassed by
counsel for the petitioner. That apart, the ratio itself would not be applicable
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 13
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
as in the present case it stands proved on record that the land was being put
to auction even when the petitioner was in office as Sarpanch and the
income derived was being used for the benefit of the village. In the case of
Gram Panchayat, Amir Khas (supra), the effect of Section 42A has not been
taken into consideration. Ratio laid down in Gram Panchayat, Village
Balad Kalan ’ s (supra) relates to position of law prior to enactment of
Section 42A in 1948 Act.
10.3. The issue w.r.t. possession of a proprietor over the un-
partitioned Panchayat land came up for consideration before Division Bench
of this Court in the case of Gujjar Singh vs. State of Punjab and others,
2014 (36) RCR (Civil) 636 . The Division Bench observed as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
6. A perusal of para 1 of the petition filed by the petitioner
under Section 11 of the Punjab Village Common Lands
(Regulation) Act, 1961 shows that the land was left for common
purposes after pro-rata cut was applied from the holdings of the
proprietors. Such land was said to be not being used for common
purposes and Bachat land. Section 42A of the East Punjab
Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation) Act,
1948 has been inserted vide Punjab Act No. 6 of 2007 in respect of
Bachat land. The legality of such provision has been upheld by
Division Bench of this Court in Mahatam Singh and others v.
State of Punjab and others, 2011 (2) L.A.R. 75 (P&H DB) =
2011(4) RCR (Civil) 498 . Since the Bachat land was not
partitioned prior to insertion of Section 42A in the East Punjab
Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation) Act,
1948, the petitioner is an unauthorized occupant of such land
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 14
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
reserved for common purposes during consolidation and has been
rightly ordered to be evicted.
7. In view of the said fact, we do not find any question of title
arises for consideration in view of the specific assertion of the
petitioner in his petition under Section 11 of the Punjab Village
Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961 itself.
xxx xxx xxx”
10.4. Same issue was considered vis-a-vis provisions of 1973 Act by
another Division Bench in the case of Mohinder Singh vs. Commissioner
Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar and others, 2012(68) RCR (Civil) 281 to
observe as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
4. We have heard counsel for the parties, perused the
impugned orders and find no reason to interfere. The land, in
dispute, was, admittedly, created during consolidation and is
recorded in the revenue record as Jumla Mushtarka Malkan i.e.,
land created under Sections 18 and 23A of the East Punjab
Holdings (Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation) Act,
1948, read with Rule 16(ii) of East Punjab Holdings
(Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation)Rules, 1949. If
land is described as Jumla Mushtarka Malkan in the revenue
record, it raises a presumption that the land was reserved for
common purposes of the panchayat and other common purposes.
The ownership of such land vests in the proprietors, but its
management and control vests in a Gram Panchayat. The Gram
Panchayat has a right to claim possession of such land for use in
accordance with common purpose assigned during consolidation.
5. The petitioner's contention that this land was not earmarked
for any common purpose during consolidation and is, therefore,
bachat land, has to be raised by the petitioner by resort to
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 15
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
proceedings under Section 11 of the Punjab Village Common
Lands(Regulation)Act, 1961(hereinafter referred to as "1961 Act").
6. In view of what has been said hereinabove, the impugned
orders are upheld and the writ petition is dismissed with liberty to
the petitioner to file a petition under Section 11 of 1961 Act. In
case such a petition is filed within a period of two months,
dispossession of the petitioner shall remain stayed for this period
of two months.
xxx xxx xxx”
11. In view thereof, this Court finds that even if the plea raised by
counsel for the petitioner w.r.t. land, in question, being bachat land is
accepted, the land having not been partitioned prior to incorporation of
Section 42-A of the 1948 Act , the possession of the petitioner cannot be said
to be authorized. He cannot escape the conclusion that his possession is
unauthorized and he is liable to be evicted under the provisions of 1961 Act
or under 1973 Act.
11.1. So far as the issue w.r.t. suit for declaration filed by the
Panchayat and dismissal thereof is concerned, the issue stands answered by
the Division Bench in the case of Pardeep Kumar and others vs. Joint
Director, Panchayat, Punjab and others, 2014(1) RCR(Civil) 188
observing as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
6. A perusal of these provisions leaves no room for debate that
land recorded as "Jumla Mushtarka Malkan" vests in a Gram
Panchayat for management and control. A Gram Panchayat may,
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 16
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
therefore, validly, while claiming possessory title, seek ejectment
of a person in possession of such land. The petitioners filed a suit
for declaration of their ownership, before a civil court. A perusal of
the decree reveals that though the Gram Panchayat and the Gram
Sabha were arrayed as parties, the Sarpanch did not come forward
to defend the suit. The suit was filed on 8.1.1964 and was decreed
ex parte on 20.2.1964. An ex parte decree is binding till such time
as it is not set aside by a court of competent jurisdiction but where
the decree has been obtained by collusion or fraud, it may be
disregarded by the court, before which it is pressed into service.
The appellate court has rightly held that the decree is vitiated on
account of collusion. The Sarpanch did not come forward to
protect the rights of the Gram Panchayat and, in fact, colluded with
the petitioners. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in Gram
Panchayat of Village Naulakha v. Ujagar Singh, (2000) 7 SCC
543 , that a collusive decree does not bind parties and may be
challenged in collateral proceedings as it is not necessary to file a
civil suit. xxx”
11.2. That apart judgment, Annexure P-9, does not advance cause of
the petitioner. There is no dispute qua the finding recorded by Civil Court
that Gram Panchayat is not owner of the land. However, in terms of Section
23A, the land having been reserved for common purpose at the time of
consolidation, the management thereof vests with Gram Panchayat. Thus,
Gram Panchayat is within its right to seek eviction of petitioner from land
reserved for common purpose not as owner but for management of such land
which is duty casted upon Gram Panchayat by law.
11.3. Further reference can be made to ratio of law laid down by
another Division Bench of this Court in the case of Gram Panchayat
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 17
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
Mangwal vs. Joint Development Commissioner etc., 2014(1) RCR (Civil)
856 wherein Division Bench observed as under:
“xxx xxx xxx
7. The land, in dispute, is admittedly recorded as mushtarka
malkan, i.e., land created after applying a pro rata cut on the
holdings of the proprietors in accordance with Section 18 and 23A
of the East Punjab Holding (Consolidation and Prevention of
Fragmentation) Act(hereinafter referred to as `the 1948 Act') and
rule 16(ii) of the East Punjab Holding (Consolidation and
Prevention of Fragmentation) Rules, 1949. A perusal of these
statutory provisions reveals that the land, so created and reserved,
vests in the Gram Panchayat for its control and management.
8. The private respondents are, admittedly, in possession of
land described as mushtarka malkan. The management and control
of such land vests in Gram Panchayat, thereby, conferring a right
upon the Gram Panchayat to seek eviction of an unauthorized
occupant in possession of mushtarka malkan by resorting to
proceedings under Section 4 and 5 of the 1973 Act. The
respondents contention that the Gram Panchayat has failed to
adduce any evidence to prove that the land, in dispute, was given
on lease to them, is irrelevant for the present controversy. The
contesting respondents have not been able to refer to any material
much less a revenue document that would raise even a prima facie
inference that they are entitled to remain in possession of the land,
in dispute. This apart, after the land was reserved as mushtarka
malkan, the right of management and control has come to vest in
the Gram Panchayat,entitling the Gram Panchayat to seek eviction
of an unauthorized occupant,even if he is one of the proprietors of
the village. The Appellate Authority committed a patent error in
recording a finding that asthe land, in dispute, is not shamilat deh,
it does not vest in the Gram Panchayat or the Gram Panchayat is
not entitled to seek eviction of private respondents.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.15623 of 1992 (O&M) 18
CWP No.2594 of 1996 (O&M)
xxx xxx xxx”
11.4. The issue w.r.t. dismissal of the earlier eviction petition cannot
operate as res judicata in the present case as the law stands altered by the
Amending Act.
11.5. The plea raised by the petitioner being in occupation of the land
since time immemorial, also falls flat to the ground in view of the factual
finding recorded by the Courts below w.r.t. the land being auctioned during
the tenure of the petitioner as Sarpanch of the village. No material has been
placed on record to show as to how factual finding recorded by the
authorities below can be said to be perverse.
12. In view of above, this Court finds no reason to interfere in the
present writ petitions. Consequently, the same are ordered to be dismissed.
13. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed off.
14. A copy of this order be kept on the file of other connected case.
November 19, 2026 (Pankaj Jain)
Dpr Judge
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : Yes
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.21 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document