UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD vs KUMARI SANDHYA D/O AJEET CHOUGALA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD


TH
DATED THIS THE 5 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.G.SHANTHI

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.103783 OF 2023

(MV-I)
BETWEEN:

UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD,
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
PHARALE BULDING, K C ROAD,
CHIKODI, DIST. BELAGAVI.
REP. BY DIVISIONAL MANAGER
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. PREETI SHASHANK, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. KUMARI SANDHYA D/O. AJEET CHOUGALA,
AGE: 13 YEARS, OCC. STUDENT,
R/O. BELAKUD, TAL. CHIKKODI, DIST BELAGAVI.
SINCE MINOR REPRESENTED BY HER M/G AND
NATURAL FATHER SHRI AJEET MARUTI CHOUGALA,
AGE: 37 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. BELKUD, TAL.CHIKODI,
DIST. BELAGAVI, PIN CODE-591 222.

2. SHRI MALLAPPA KALLAPPA MIRJE,
AGE: MAJOR, OCC. BUSINESS,
R/O. MANJARI, TQ.CHIKKODI,
DIST. BELAGAVI, PIN CODE 59101.
OWNER OF HERO HONDA BEARING NO KA23/EC-8659
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ANAND BAGEWADI, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. SHIVARAJ MUDHOL, ADVOCATE FOR R1; R2-HELD SUFFICIENT)

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173(1) OF MOTOR VEHICLES ACT, 1988,
PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS CONNECTED WITH MVC
NO.778/2016 ON THE FILE OF THE COURT OF THE VII ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT JUDGE AND ADDITIONAL MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS
TRIBUNAL, BELAGAVI, SITTING AT CHIKKODI, EXAMINE THE SAME
AND MODIFY THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 01.06.2023 TO
REDUCE THE COMPENSATION TO JUST LEVEL IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE.

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023



THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.G.SHANTHI

ORAL JUDGMENT

Aggrieved by the judgment and award dated 01.06.2023
in MVC No.778/2016 passed by the VII Additional District Judge
1
and Additional MACT, Belagavi sitting at Chikkodi , the
appellant being the Insurance Company before the Tribunal
filed this appeal challenging the quantum of compensation.

2. Parties are hereinafter referred to as per their ranks
before the Tribunal for the sake of convenience.

3. Brief facts of the case are that on 20.02.2016 at
9.30 p.m., near Basava Nagar at Manjari village, the petitioner
and her parents were proceeding on the left side of the road. At
that time, the rider of the motorcycle bearing registration
No.KA-23/EC-8659 came in a high speed, rash and negligent
manner and dashed to the petitioner and caused the accident.
Due to the said impact, the petitioner sustained grievous

1
For short, ‘the Tribunal’
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


injuries and immediately, she was shifted to the hospital for
treatment.

4. Prior to the accident, the petitioner was hale and
healthy and was a student. Due to accidental injuries, she
became permanently disabled and therefore, she cannot work
and lead normal life as before. The petitioner has spent huge
amount towards medical expenses. Accordingly, she filed a
claim petition before the Tribunal claiming compensation.

5. On filing of the petition, notice has been issued to
the respondents. They appeared through their counsel.
Respondent No.1 has not filed objections to the claim petition.
However, respondent No.2/Insurance Company filed the
objections denying the averments of the claim petition and
contended that the compensation claimed by the petitioner is
exorbitant, imaginary, miscalculated and that the
compensation, if any, granted should be subject to proof of
valid driving license and conditions of the policy. Accordingly,
prayed to dismiss the claim petition.

6. Before the Tribunal, the guardian of the petitioner is
examined as PW1 and the doctor is examined as PW2 and got
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


marked the documents as Exs.P.1 to P.12. On the other hand,
the respondents neither adduced any oral evidence nor
produced any documentary evidence.

7. On hearing the arguments, the Tribunal allowed the
claim petition in part and awarded compensation under the
following heads:
Sl.
Heads Amount in Rs.
No.
4,00,000/-
1 Towards attendant’s charges,
food, nourishment and
conveyance expenses, towards
pain and suffering already
undergone and to be suffered in
future, mental and physical
shock, hardship, inconvenience
and discomforts, etc., and loss
of amenities in life on account
of disability
2 Towards medical expenses and 29,050/-
incidental charges
3 Towards discomfort,
inconvenience and loss of
earnings of the parents during
the period of hospitalization
25,000/-
TOTAL 4,54,050/-

The Tribunal further held that, the respondents No.1 and 2
are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation to the
petitioner, and directed the respondent No.2/Insurance
Company to deposit the compensation amount along with
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition
till realization within 30 days from the date of the award.

8. Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation, the
petitioner preferred this appeal.

9. Learned counsel for the Insurance Company argued
that the petitioner was aged 6 years old at the time of accident
and as per the evidence of the doctor the petitioner suffered a
disability to the extent of 28% to the particular limb, but the
Tribunal assessed the disability to the extent of 14% to the
whole body which is exorbitant. Further it is argued that the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal is on the higher side.
Hence, prays for reducing the compensation awarded by the
Tribunal.

10. Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the
petitioner has suffered grievous injuries in the accident i.e.,
fracture of left tibia and fibula which affected the career of the
petitioner, so the doctor rightly assessed the disability to the
extent of 28% to the particular limb and the Tribunal also
rightly assessed the disability to the extent of 14% to the whole
body. It is argued that the compensation awarded by the
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


Tribunal is adequate and reasonable and not excessive.
Accordingly, prayed for dismissal of the appeal.

11. Heard the arguments. Perused the materials
available on record. The points that would arise for
consideration by this Court are as follows:

(i) Whether the Insurance Company proves that
the compensation awarded by the Tribunal
deserves to be modified?

(ii) What order?

12. Points framed by this Court for consideration are
answered as follows:
Point No.(i) : Partly in the affirmative.
Point No.(ii) : As per the final order, for the
following:

13. Regarding Point No.(i): The petitioner met with
an accident on 20.02.2016 at 09:30 p.m. At the time of
accident, she was aged 6 years and she has treated as an
indoor patient for four days. As per the evidence of the doctor,
the petitioner has suffered disability to the extent of 28%. The
doctor has given evidence that the petitioner was having pain
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


and tenderness and deformity at left leg and fracture of left
tibia and fibula. He also deposed that at the time of assessing
the disability, the child complained pain in the left leg, knee
and ankle, difficulty in daily activities. No doubt when the child
was aged 6 years, can recover fact compared to older
individual. The doctor in his cross examination deposed that
due to fracture, there is a shortening of more than ½ inches
and it comes to 4% disability to the particular limb. Though the
recovery is fast, there is a disability to the petitioner. By
looking into the injuries sustained by the petitioner and the
treatment undergone by her, the Tribunal has rightly assessed
the disability to the extent of 14% to the whole body.

14. Learned counsel for the Insurance Company placed
reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Master
Mallikarjun v. Divisional Manager National Insurance
2
Company Limited and Another , wherein at paragraph No.8
has held as under:
“It is unfortunate that both the Tribunal and the
High Court have not properly appreciated the
medical evidence available in the case. The age of

2
2014 (14) SCC 396
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


the child and deformities on his body resulting in
disability, have not been duly taken note of. As held
by this Court in R.D. Hattangadi vs. M/s. Pest
Control (India) Pvt. Ltd. and Others[1], while
assessing the non-pecuniary damages, the damages
for mental and physical shock, pain and suffering
already suffered and that are likely to be suffered,
any future damages for the loss of amenities in life
like difficulty in running, participation in active
sports, etc., damages on account of inconvenience,
hardship, discomfort, disappointment, frustration,
etc., have to be addressed especially in the case of a
child victim. For a child, the best part of his life is
yet to come. While considering the claim by a victim
child, it would be unfair and improper to follow the
structured formula as per the Second Schedule to
the Motor Vehicles Act for reasons more than one.
The main stress in the formula is on pecuniary
damages. For children there is no income. The only
indication in the Second Schedule for non- earning
persons is to take the notional income as
Rs.15,000/- per year. A child cannot be equated to
such a non-earning person. Therefore, the
compensation is to be worked out under the non-
pecuniary heads in addition to the actual amounts
incurred for treatment done and/or to be done,
transportation, assistance of attendant, etc. The
main elements of damage in the case of child victims
are the pain, shock, frustration, deprivation of
ordinary pleasures and enjoyment associated with
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


healthy and mobile limbs. The compensation
awarded should enable the child to acquire
something or to develop a lifestyle which will offset
to some extent the inconvenience or discomfort
arising out of the disability. Appropriate
compensation for disability should take care of all
the non-pecuniary damages. In other words, apart
from this head, there shall only be the claim for the
actual expenditure for treatment, attendant,
transportation, etc.”

15. As per the above finding, in the present case, the
petitioner has suffered disability to the extent of 14% to the
whole body. So when the disability is between 10% to 30% to
the whole body, the compensation to be awarded is at
Rs.3,00,000/-. Accordingly, the petitioner is entitled for
compensation of Rs.3,00,000/- towards “attendants charges,
food, nourishment and conveyance expenses, pain and
suffering she has already undergone and in future, mental and
physical shock, hardship and loss of amenities in life on account
of disability.

16. Further, the Tribunal has awarded compensation of
Rs.29,050/-, under the head of “medical expenses and
incidental charges” and Rs.25,000/- towards “discomfort,
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


inconvenience, loss of earning of the parents during the period
of hospitalization of the minor”, which does not call for any
interference.

17. Thus, the petitioner is entitled to receive
compensation under the following heads:
Sl. Amount in
Heads
No. Rs.
1 Towards attendant’s charges,
food, nourishment and
conveyance expenses, towards
pain and suffering already
undergone and to be suffered in
future, mental and physical
shock, hardship and loss of
amenities in life on account of
disability
3,00,000/-
2 Towards medical expenses and 29,050/-
incidental charges
25,000/-
3 Towards discomfort,
inconvenience and loss of
earnings of the parents during
the period of hospitalization
TOTAL 3,54,050/-


18. Accordingly, point No.(i) is answered partly in the
affirmative .

19. Regarding point No.(ii): In view of the findings
on point No.(i), this Court proceeds to pass the following:

Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023


ORDER

(i) The appeal filed by the Insurance Company
is allowed in part.

(ii) The impugned judgment and award passed
by the Tribunal is modified. The petitioner is
entitled to receive compensation of
Rs.3,54,050/- as against Rs.4,54,050/-
awarded by the Tribunal.

(iii) The compensation amount shall carry
interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of petition till the date of payment.

(iv) Respondent No.2/Insurance Company shall
deposit the compensation with accrued
interest before the Tribunal within a period
of six weeks from the date of receipt of
certified copy of this judgment.

(v) Draw modified award accordingly.

(vi) The excess amount in deposit, if any, shall
be transmit to the Tribunal along with
records forthwith.

(vii) In view of disposal of this appeal, pending
applications, if any, do not survive for
consideration and the same are accordingly
disposed of.
Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18176
MFA No. 103783 of 2023


CNR: KAHC020154492023



(viii) In view of disposal of this appeal, pending
applications, if any, do not survive for
consideration and the same are accordingly
disposed of.


Digitally Signed by KADAMBADI
GANESH SHANTHI on 19-11-2026

(K.G.SHANTHI)
JUDGE


SMM/CT:PA
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 28