The STATE OF CHHATTISGARH vs OM PRAKASH @ LODHI PAW
- Court
- Chhattisgarh High Court
1
CGHC010224012021 2026:CGHC:47429-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ACQA No. 184 of 2021
Judgment Reserved on : 11-9-2026
Judgment Delivered on : 18 -11-2026
The State of Chhattisgarh Through - District Magistrate, Bilaspur
•
(Chhattisgarh), District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
Versus
1. Om Prakash @ Lodhi Paw S/o.- Shivbagas Paw Aged About 24
Years Occupation - Labourer, R/o.- Village Pahanda, Police Chowki
Belgahna, Police Station- Kota, District - Bilaspur (Chhattisgarh),
District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh.
2. Jan Singh @ Janu S/o.- Ratan Singh Aged About 27 Years
Occupation - Labourer, R/o.- Village Pahanda, Police Chowki
Belgahna, Police Station- Kota, District - Bilaspur (Chhattisgarh)
... Respondent(s)
(Cause title is downloaded from CIS Periphery)
For Appellant/State. : Mr. Soumya Rai, Deputy Government
Advocate
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Rajeev Kumar Dubey and Ms. Maya
Chaturvijani, Advocates.
DB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas &
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sudhir Kumar,
C A V Judgment
Per Narendra Kumar Vyas, J.
1. The present acquittal appeal has been filed by the State under
Section 378(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 against the
2
judgment passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge (FTC),
Bilaspur, (C.G.) dated 16-02-2021 in Sessions Trial No. 150 of 2018
whereby the respondents/accused have been acquitted of the
charges punishable under Sections 450, 376(d) & 506 of IPC. The
appeal has been admitted by this Court on 21.06.2022 and was
listed on 11.09.2026 for appearance of the accused. With the
consent of the parties, the appeal is heard finally.
2. Brief facts as reflected from the record are that the victim aged about
22 years lodged FIR (Ex. P/6) bearing Crime No. 0/2018 before the
Police Station Belgahna, District - Bilaspur (C.G.) for commission of
offence under Sections 450, 376(D) and 506 of IPC against
respondents No. 2 and 3, which was subsequently transferred to
Police Station - Kota, District Bilaspur and registered as
Crime No. 377/2018, alleging that the victim who is a resident of
village Pahanda, Police Chowki Belgahna is residing with her
husband. In the night on the date of incident 08.09.2018, a cultural
program was going on in the village, after seeing that program, she
came back home with her husband at about 10 O’clock. It is also
case of the prosecution that when the husband of the victim had
gone to outside the house to answer for call of nature, the victim was
alone in the house then the accused/respondent No.1 Om Prakash
@ Lodhi who is the victim's brother-in-law in relation, and his
nephew Jaan Singh Paw, both opened the door and forcibly entered
inside the house and as soon as they entered, accused Om Prakash
caught the victim and threw her down and thereafter accused Om
Prakash climbed on the victim, tore her blouse and pulled her sari-
3
petticoat up, pulled and removed her undergarments and forcibly
committed sexual intercourse with her. It is also case of the
prosecution that when the accused Om Prakash was committing
forcible sexual intercourse with her, at that time her husband
returned to the house from open defecation, then accused Om
Prakash forcibly pressed the mouth of her husband and before him
he had committed sexual intercourse with her. Thereafter
accused/respondent No.2 Jaan Singh Paw committed forceful
sexual intercourse with the victim. Thereafter, victim along with her
husband went to Police Chowki Belgahna and lodged report against
the accused. On the report of the victim, Crime No. 0/2018 for
offence punishable under Sections 450, 376(D) and 506 of the
Indian Penal Code was registered at Police Chowki Belgahna.
3. In order to prove its case prosecution has examined as many as 12
witnesses and exhibited documents from Ex. P/1 to Ex. P/22.
Statements of accused/respondents have been recorded under
Section 313 Cr.P.C., in which they denied the allegations leveled
against them and pleaded innocence and false implication. In order
to prove their innocence, the respondents examined DW/1 Uttam
Singh, DW/2 Ramdayal, DW/3 Ramlal and DW/4 Nanki Paw.
4. The victim was medically examined on 09.09.2018 by Dr. Renuka
Samuel (PW/3), Medical Officer, who submitted her medical
examination report vide Ex. P/2. In her report, the doctor opined that
the victim was habituated to sexual intercourse. However, no definite
opinion can be given regarding occurrence of recent sexual
intercourse. During the course of investigation, the prosecution
4
forwarded the undergarments of the victim and the accused persons,
along with other seized articles for chemical examination. As per the
chemical examination report, human sperm was detected in Articles
A, B, D, E and G, whereas no human sperm was detected in Articles
C, F and H. The report further indicated that the quantity of human
sperm detected in Articles A, D, E and G was insufficient for
conducting chemical matching.
5. After appreciating the evidence on record, the learned trial Court did
not believe the evidence proving guilt of the accused and acquitted
the accused of the charges levelled against them. Learned trial
Court while acquitting the accused has recorded its finding that there
is no cogent, reliable and convincing evidence available on record
against the accused to establish that the accused have committed
the aforesaid offence. Being aggrieved with the said judgment of
acquittal, the State has preferred this Acquittal Appeal.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant/State would submit that the
learned Trial Court, without properly appreciating the evidence and
material available on record has acquitted the accused/respondents.
He would further submit that the learned Trial Court has committed
illegality in discarding the evidence of the victim (PW/6). He would
further submit that the learned Trial Court ought to have considered
the evidence of Rajendra Kumar Paw (PW/12), who has
categorically supported the version of the victim. He would further
submit that the learned Trial Court ought to have convicted the
accused/respondents on the basis of the testimony of the victim,
which is of sterling quality and does not require any further
5
corroboration from other evidence. Thus, he would submit that the
impugned judgment of acquittal suffers from illegality and infirmity
and, therefore, the same is liable to be set aside and accordingly he
would pray for allowing the appeal.
7. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents would
submit that the judgment of acquittal passed by the learned Trial
Court is based on proper appreciation of the entire evidence
available on record which does not warrant any interference by this
Court. He would further submit that the learned Trial Court in
paragraph 18 of its judgment has recorded a finding that from the
statements of the victim (PW/6) and her husband Rajendra Kumar
Paw (PW/12), certain material inconsistencies emerge with regard to
the commission of the alleged offence. While the victim has stated
that accused Om Prakash alias Lodhi first committed forcible sexual
intercourse with her and, at that time, her husband returned home
and objected to the same, her husband has stated that accused Om
Prakash was standing in front of the door of the house and he saw
accused Jaan Singh committing sexual intercourse with the victim.
He would further submit that the learned Trial Court has also taken
note of the fact that despite a hue and cry raised by the victim and
her husband, no one came forward to rescue them, nor did any
person residing in the vicinity inform the police about the alleged
incident which creates doubt regarding the credibility of the
prosecution witnesses. He would next submit that Dr. Sandeep
Dwivedi (PW/8) who has examined the accused has stated that
there is a possibility of the flow of sperm, whereas Dr. Smt. Renuka
6
Samuel (PW/3) who has examined the victim has opined that no
injury was found on the private parts of the victim. He would further
submit that there are material contradictions and omissions in the
statements of the prosecution witnesses with regard to the identity of
the accused who first committed the alleged offence. Thus, he would
submit that the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond
reasonable doubt and the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court
while acquitting the respondents neither suffers from perversity nor
any illegality warranting interference by this Court. He would
accordingly pray for dismissal of the appeal.
8. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
records of the trial Court with utmost circumspection.
9. From the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties,
the point emerged for determination of this Court is whether finding
recorded by the learned trial Court acquitting the
accused/respondents suffers from perversity or illegality warranting
any interference by this Court?.
10. For appreciating the point to be determined by this Court, this Court
has to analyze the evidence brought on record.
11. Dr. Smt. Renuka Samuel (PW/3), who examined the victim on the
next date i.e. on 09.09.2018 has given her report (Ex.P/2) that
victim was habituated for sexual intercourse and opined that no
definite opinion with regard to immediate sexual intercourse can be
given.
7
12. The victim (PW/6), in her examination-in-chief, has reiterated the
prosecution case, however, in paragraph 18 of her cross-
examination, she has admitted that her husband had gone to
answer the call of nature at about 10:00 p.m. and returned after 10-
15 minutes. She has further admitted that at about 10:00 p.m., a
quarrel was going on between her and accused Om Prakash with
regard to forcible sexual intercourse and, therefore, she could not
have noticed the exact time. She has also admitted that while the
quarrel was going on, hue and cry was raised, but no neighbour
came to her house. She has further admitted that no assault had
taken place between her husband and the accused on the date of
the incident. She has also admitted that her husband and the
accused persons used to consume alcohol. Further, she has stated
that she had informed about the incident to the younger brother of
her father-in-law, but she could not say as to why the said fact was
not recorded in her police statement. She has also admitted that the
younger brother of her father-in-law has not supported her case.
13. Dr. Sandeep Dwivedi (PW/8), who had medically examined
respondent No. 1, Om Prakash, has stated that no injury on the
private parts of the accused was found. He has further stated that,
had any injury been noticed during the medical examination, he
would have certainly mentioned the same in the medical report.
14. Rajendra Kumar Paw (PW/12), husband of the victim, has stated in
his examination-in-chief that upon returning after attending the call
of nature, he saw accused Om Prakash standing in front of his
house. When he attempted to enter his house, accused Om
8
Prakash allegedly pushed him back. He further stated that he saw
the other accused, Jan Singh, climbing on top of his wife and
committing sexual intercourse with her. Upon raising an objection,
accused Om Prakash allegedly pressed his mouth tightly, while
accused Jan Singh forcibly committed sexual intercourse with his
wife. He further stated that, as the incident had occurred late at
night, he lodged the report at the Police Station on the following
day. However, in paragraph 18 of his cross-examination, he
admitted that if any such incident had occurred, the villagers would
have gathered at the spot. He further stated that the accused had
pressed his mouth at the time of the incident. He also admitted that
when the accused persons were assaulting him, he raised a hue
and cry. Significantly, he admitted that he did not disclose the
incident to anyone. He further admitted that although the accused
persons had assaulted him and thrown him to the ground at the
time of the incident, he had not sustained any injury whatsoever.
15. Uttam Singh (DW/1), has stated that the victim had implicated him
in an offence under Section 354 of the IPC and has further deposed
that there existed a dispute between the accused persons and the
victim regarding a pathway. Similarly, Ramdayal (DW/2), has stated
that a dispute was subsisting between the husband of the victim
and the accused persons in relation to the pathway. He further
stated that, as his house was situated near the house of the victim,
he was aware of the said dispute. He also deposed that, on the
night of the alleged incident, the husband of the victim had
threatened the accused persons, thereafter all the persons returned
9
to their respective houses. Significantly, DW/2 admitted that his
house is situated behind the house of the victim and that any noise
raised by a person in the vicinity would be audible to him. He further
stated that, at the relevant time, he was sleeping outside his house.
16. Ramlal (DW/3) has admitted that there was a dispute between
accused and victim with regard to path-way Smt. Nanki Paw (DW/4)
has admitted that accused Om Prakash is her maternal uncle and
accused Jan Singh is her husband and victim is her Maami. She
has also stated that on the date of incident victim’s husband came
after consuming alcohol and he was demanding path-way of the
land which belongs to her husband and maternal grand-father,
therefore, they were not giving pathway, as such dispute arose
between them. She has also stated that after quarrel she advised
her husband not to fight, thereafter she had gone to inside the
house, but in the cross-examination, she has admitted that no civil
suit is pending regarding pathway and also admitted that they have
not lodged any report in police station against victim because no
incident has taken place and ordinarily quarrel takes place between
them, therefore, report was not lodged.
17. From perusal of statements of Rajendra Kumar Paw (PW/12), who
is husband of the victim and the victim (PW/6), it is quite vivid that
accused in their evidence as well as in 313 Cr.P.C., statement have
stated that due to vacating the quarter a dispute was occurred
between victim‘s husband and accused on the date of incident and
assault was made between them, therefore, the victim has lodged a
false report. From the evidence of victim PW/6, it is quite vivid the
10
victim lodged report against another relative Uttam Singh for
commission of forcible sexual intercourse in the year 2017 and also
admitted that the courtyard of the victim and the accused is one
and same and at the time of incident the mother and brother were
also residing. She has also admitted that at the time of incident
wife of Jan Singh was not there and she was not residing with the
accused. She has also admitted that accused threatened her to
assault, therefore, she had gone to Police Station to lodge the
report. She has further stated that the accused have not assaulted
them and only they had threatened them regarding vacating the
house. She has also admitted in her cross-examination that on the
date of incident the accused has threatened her regarding assault
and they have gone to the Police Station to lodge the report of
assault. She has also admitted that the accused have not assaulted
her husband, but they have threatened her husband.
18. From the foregoing analysis of the evidence available on record, it
is quite evident that the testimony of the victim does not satisfy the
standard of sterling quality so as to warrant reversal of the order of
acquittal. Further, upon consideration of the testimony of Rajendra
Kumar Paw (PW/12), husband of the victim, it is noteworthy that his
deposition does not disclose any specific intervention or objection
on the part of the accused persons when the alleged offence was
being committed by them one after another. Although the victim has
categorically stated that her husband returned within 10–15 minutes
after attending the call of nature, the said circumstance, when
considered in the light of the medical evidence of Dr. Renuka
11
Samuel (PW/3), assumes significance, who has categorically stated
that no definite opinion regarding the commission of rape can be
given, particularly as the victim was examined on the following day
of the alleged incident. Further, the absence of any matching of
sperm as reflected from the medical evidence, is also a
circumstance requiring consideration. It is also pertinent to note that
the victim has not specifically deposed before the learned Trial
Court as to whether she made any attempt to resist or extricate
herself from the alleged clutches of the accused persons.
19. Further considering the admission of PW/12, particularly with regard
to his failure to disclose the incident to anyone, absence of any
injury despite the alleged assault and the circumstances
surrounding the alleged occurrence, are material circumstances
requiring consideration while appreciating the credibility and
reliability of his testimony of this witness. Similarly, the testimonies
of DW/1 and DW/2 brought on record the existence of prior
animosity and a dispute concerning the pathway between the
parties constitutes a relevant circumstance for consideration while
appreciating the defence version and the overall credibility of the
prosecution case. These circumstances, when considered
cumulatively and in the backdrop of the inconsistencies and
deficiencies in the prosecution evidence, give rise to reasonable
doubt regarding the prosecution case. Consequently, the
prosecution has failed to establish the guilt of the accused persons
beyond reasonable doubt. Having regard to the settled principle of
law that in absence of testimony of sterling quality and where the
12
evidence gives rise to a reasonable view in favour of the accused,
the well-reasoned judgment of acquittal recorded by the learned
Trial Court ought not to be disturbed, this Court finds no sufficient
ground to interfere with the impugned judgment of acquittal.
20. The law in this regard has been considered by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Santosh Prasad Vs. State of Bihar reported
in 2020 (3) SCC 443 wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
as under :-
“6. Having gone through and considered the deposition of
the prosecutrix, we find that there are material
contradictions. Not only there are material contradictions,
but even the manner in which the alleged incident has
taken place as per the version of the prosecutrix is not
believable. In the examination-in-chief, the prosecutrix
has stated that after jumping the fallen compound wall
accused came inside and thereafter the accused
committed rape. She has stated that she identified the
accused from the light of the mobile. However, no mobile
is recovered. Even nothing is on record that there was a
broken compound wall. She has further stated that in the
morning at 10 O’clock she went to the police station and
gave oral complaint. However, according to the
investigating officer a written complaint was given. It is
also required to be noted that even the FIR is registered
at 4:00 p.m. In her deposition, the prosecutrix has
referred to the name of Shanti Devi, PW1 and others.
However, Shanti Devi has not supported the case of the
prosecution. Therefore, when we tested the version of
PW5 -prosecutrix, it is unfortunate that the said witness
has failed to pass any of the tests of “sterling witness”.
There is a variation in her version about giving the
complaint. There is a delay in the FIR. The medical report
does not support the case of the prosecution. FSL report
also does not support the case of the prosecution. As
admitted, there was an enmity/dispute between both the
parties with respect to land. The manner in which the
occurrence is stated to have occurred is not believable.
Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the case, we
find that the solitary version of the prosecutrix – PW5
cannot be taken as a gospel truth at face value and in the
absence of any other supporting evidence, there is no
scope to sustain the conviction and sentence imposed on
the appellant and accused is to be given the benefit of
doubt.”
13
21. Again Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Nirmal Premkumar vs.
State Represented by Inspector of Police reported in 2024 (20)
SCC 293 has examined the issue and recorded its finding as under:-
“22. This Court was tasked to adjudicate a matter involv
ing gang rape allegations under section 376(2)(g), I.P.C in
Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2012) 8 SCC 21.
The Court found totally conflicting versions of the pros
ecutrix, from what was stated in the complaint and what
was deposed before Court, resulting in material inconsis
tencies. Reversing the conviction and holding that the
prosecutrix cannot be held to be a ‘sterling witness’, the
Court opined as under:
“22. In our considered opinion, the ‘sterling witness’
should be of a very high quality and calibre whose version
should, therefore, be unassailable. The court considering
the version of such witness should be in a position to ac
cept it for its face value without any hesitation. To test the
quality of such a witness, the status of the witness would
be immaterial and what would be relevant is the truthful
ness of the statement made by such a witness. What
would be more relevant would be the consistency of the
statement right from the starting point till the end, namely,
at the time when the witness makes the initial statement
and ultimately before the court. It should be natural and
consistent with the case of the prosecution qua the ac
cused. There should not be any prevarication in the ver
sion of such a witness. The witness should be in a posi
tion to withstand the cross-examination of any length and
howsoever strenuous it may be and under no circum
stance should give room for any doubt as to the factum of
the occurrence, the persons involved, as well as the se
quence of it. Such a version should have co-relation with
each and every one of other supporting material such as
the recoveries made, the weapons used, the manner of
offence committed, the scientific evidence and the expert
opinion. The said version should consistently match with
the version of every other witness. It can even be stated
that it should be akin to the test applied in the case of cir
cumstantial evidence where there should not be any
missing link in the chain of circumstances to hold the ac
cused guilty of the offence alleged against him. Only if the
version of such a witness qualifies the above test as well
as all other such similar tests to be applied, can it be held
that such a witness can be called as a ‘sterling witness’
whose version can be accepted by the court without any
corroboration and based on which the guilty can be pun
ished. To be more precise, the version of the said witness
14
on the core spectrum of the crime should remain intact
while all other attendant materials, namely, oral, docu
mentary and material objects should match the said ver
sion in material particulars in order to enable the court try
ing the offence to rely on the core version to sieve the
other supporting materials for holding the offender guilty
of the charge alleged.”
22. Thus, upon appreciation of the evidence available on record, the
learned Trial Court has rightly recorded a finding in paragraph 17 of
the impugned judgment that the victim had stated that she had
disclosed the incident to the younger brother of her father-in-law;
however, Harishchand (PW/5), categorically admitted that he came
to know about the incident through the children, who informed him
after reading the newspaper. Although the said witness was
declared hostile, he specifically denied the suggestion that the
victim and her husband had visited him on 09.09.2018 in the
morning and apprised him of the alleged incident. In view of the
aforesaid material discrepancy, the learned Trial Court has rightly
found the alleged disclosure of the incident to the younger brother
of the victim's father-in-law to be doubtful. Such a finding, being
based upon proper appreciation of the oral evidence and material
contradictions appearing in the depositions of the prosecution
witnesses, cannot be said to be perverse or contrary to the
evidence on record. Furthermore, the learned Trial Court has also
rightly observed that, owing to material contradictions and
omissions in the statements of the prosecution witnesses, the
prosecution has failed to satisfactorily establish as to who had first
committed the alleged offence. The existence of a prior dispute
between the parties concerning the pathway is also a relevant
circumstance which lends support to the defence version and
15
warrants due consideration. Accordingly, the findings recorded by
the learned Trial Court are based on a plausible appreciation of the
evidence and do not suffer from any perversity, illegality or material
irregularity warranting interference by this Court in exercise of its
appellate jurisdiction.
23. Learned trial Court on appreciation of evidence and material on
record has rightly recorded its finding of the acquittal in favour of
the accused. Even also considering the well settled position of law
that in case of interference of the appellate Court in acquittal appeal
as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Krishan
Kumar Malik v. State of Haryana reported in (2011) 7 SCC 130 ,
that although the victim's solitary evidence in matters related to
sexual offences is generally deemed sufficient to hold an accused
guilty, the conviction cannot be sustained if the prosecutrix's
testimony is found unreliable and insufficient due to identified flaws
and lacunae. Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
“31. No doubt, it is true that to hold an accused guilty for
commission of an offence of rape, the solitary evidence
of the prosecutrix is sufficient provided the same inspires
confidence and appears to be absolutely trustworthy, un
blemished and should be of sterling quality. But, in the
case in hand, the evidence of the prosecutrix, showing
several lacunae, which have already been projected
hereinabove, would go to show that her evidence does
not fall in that category and cannot be relied upon to hold
the appellant guilty of the said offences.
32. Indeed there are several significant variations in ma
terial facts in her Section 164 statement, Section 161
statement (CrPC), FIR and deposition in court. Thus, it
was necessary to get her evidence corroborated inde
pendently, which they could have done either by exami
nation of Ritu, her sister or Bimla Devi, who were present
in the house at the time of her alleged abduction. The
record shows that Bimla Devi though cited as a witness
was not examined and later given up by the public prose
16
cutor on the ground that she has been won over by the
appellant.”
24. What flows from the aforesaid decisions is that in
cases where witnesses are neither wholly reliable nor
wholly unreliable, the Court should strive to find out the
true genesis of the incident. The Court can rely on the
victim as a “sterling witness” without further corrobora
tion, but the quality and credibility must be exceptionally
high. The statement of the prosecutrix ought to be con
sistent from the beginning to the end (minor inconsis
tences excepted), from the initial statement to the oral
testimony, without creating any doubt qua the prosecu
tion’s case. While a victim's testimony is usually enough
for sexual offence cases, an unreliable or insufficient ac
count from the prosecutrix, marked by identified flaws
and gaps, could make it difficult for a conviction to be
recorded.”
24. Considering the statement of the victim which is not of a sterling
quality to upset the well reasoned finding of the learned Trial Court,
which is based upon a proper appreciation of the factual matrix and
the evidence adduced by the parties, therefore, the finding of
acquittal recorded by the learned trial Court seems to be just and
proper which does not warrant interference by this Court. Even
otherwise, it is well settled position of law that if one view has been
taken by the learned trial Court which is in favour of the accused,
normally the appellate Court should not interfere in the case of
acquittal, unless the finding is so perverse that only one view of
conviction is possible for the appellate Court. Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Constable 907 Surendra Singh and Another vs.
State of Uttarakhand {2025 INSC 114} dealt with the issue when
an appellate Court can interfere in the order of acquittal passed by
the trial Court and held in paragraph 12 as under:-
“12. It could thus be seen that it is a settled legal position
that the interference with the finding of acquittal recorded
by the learned trial judge would be warranted by the High
17
Court only if the judgment of acquittal suffers from patent
perversity; that the same is based on a
misreading/omission to consider material evidence on
record; and that no two reasonable views are possible and
only the view consistent with the guilt of the accused is
possible from the evidence available on record.”
25. In the present case, as observed by the learned trial Court, the
prosecution has failed to place on record any evidence to show that
the respondents have committed the aforesaid offence, therefore,
we are of the view that the learned trial Court has not committed
any illegality or perversity in acquitting the respondents of the
charges punishable under Sections 450, 376 (d) and 506 of IPC
which warrants interference by this Court.
26. Accordingly, this Court is of the considered opinion that the present
acquittal appeal is devoid of merit and deserves to be dismissed.
Consequently, the appeal is hereby dismissed and the judgment of
acquittal dated 16.02.2021 passed by the learned Trial Court in
Sessions Trial No. 150 of 2018 is hereby affirmed as the findings
recorded by the learned Trial Court are based on proper
appreciation of the evidence available on record and do not warrant
any interference by this Court.
Sd/- Sd/-
(Narendra Kumar Vyas) (Sudhir Kumar)
Judge Judge
Raju
RAVVA
SATYANARAYANA
RAJU
2026.11.18
17:34:47 +0530
RAVVA
SATYANARAYANA
RAJU