Sandeep Kumar vs RAILWAY

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
Nainital Circuit Sitting

O.A. No.4509/2026

th
This the 29 day of October, 2026

Hon'ble Mr. Ajay Pratap Singh, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajinder Kashyap, Member (A)


Sandeep Kumar (Male) aged about 38 years S/o Chaman
Singh presently posted as Track Maintainer, Gang No.
06/RWL, Senior Section Engineer, Rail Path, Dehradun R/o
Railway Colony, Prateet Nagar, Raiwala, Dehradun.

… Applicant

(By Advocate: Mr. Kishore Rai)

Versus
1. Union of India through General Manager, Northern
Railway, Headquarter Office, Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New
Delhi-110001.
2. Divisional Rail Manager, Moradabad Division, Northern
Railway, Moradabad (U.P.)
3. Senior Divisional Engineer-1st, Northern Railway,
Moradabad (U.P.)
4. Assistant Regional Engineer, Northern Railway, Haridwar.

… Respondents

(By Advocate: Mr. T C Aggarwal through VC)







KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026


O R D E R (ORAL)
As per Mr. Ajay Pratap Singh, Member (Judicial)
1. Heard the parties.
2. The matter is On Board under caption ‘For Admission
(Subject to Office Objection)’ as Registry has raised
objection that translated copies of the documents have
not been filed.

3. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that he has
filed legible copies in Hindi and immediately the
translated copies are not available and seeks permission
to take on record vernacular documents.
4. In view whereof, objection raised by Registry is overruled
and Registry is directed to assign appropriate O.A.
number to the application.
The Issue At Hand

5. The precise question that arises for determination in the
present Original Application is-
“ whether exhausting remedy of revision is mandatory and non-
exhausting of such remedy under the service rule- The Railway
Servants (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1968, would stand in the
way of Applicant for approaching the Tribunal ?”.




KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

Prayer
6. Applicant is working as Track Maintainer, under SSE/ P.way/
Northern Railway, Dehradun has filed the present OA, invoking
jurisdiction of this Tribunal under Section-19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following relief(s)
[as extracted from the OA] reads as:
“ this Hon'ble Tribunal/ Court may graciously be pleased to
issue -
a. An order or direction to quash the order at 13th of May
2026, by which the appeal against the punishment order to
the applicant has been dismissed by the appellate authority
further quashing the order dated 19-07-2025/25-07-2025
(annexure No.1 and 2) to this original application whereby
all the SET (2025) FACILITY TICKET ORDERS have been
stopped with immediate effect.
b.grant any other relief to which the applicant is found
entitled under the facts and circumstances of the petition.
c. Award full cost of the petition.”

Facts in brief
7. Basic facts not in dispute that SSE, Northern Railway,
Dehradun issued the warning letter dated 02.06.2025 relating to
negligence in duty on 31.05.2025. The applicant submitted reply
dated 09.06.2025 to SSE/ P.way/ Northern Railway, Dehradun to
the disciplinary authority. Thereafter, the disciplinary authority
issued memorandum of charge dated 26.06.2025 for imposing
minor penalty under Rule 11 of The Railway Servants (Discipline
& Appeal) Rules, 1968 ( in short Rules, 1968 ). Reply/
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

representation dated 02.06.2025 to the S.F No.11 was submitted
by the applicant and after giving such reasonable opportunity, the
disciplinary authority found the representation dated 02.06.2025
not satisfactory and prima facie found negligence in doing duty
and inflicted minor penalty dated 19.07.2025 of withholding of
privilege ticket orders for 2025.
8. Applicant preferred departmental appeal memo dated
10.04.2026 before the Asst. Divisional Engineer, Northern
Railway, Haridwar and same stands dismissed vide impugned
order dated 13.05.2026 ( Annexure A-1 ) upholding the order
dated 19.07.2025, passed SSE/P.Way/DDN. Hence, the OA to set
impugned orders dated 19.07.2025 and dated 13.05.2026 to
restore all the set-2025, facility ticket orders.
Arguments
9. Learned counsel for the applicant contended that present OA
has been filed against order dated 13.05.2026, passed by the
appellate authority and there is provision to file revision petition
before the revising authority under Rule 25 of Rules, 1968 and
same is not mandatory. Applicant has already exhausted remedy
of appeal under Rule 18 of Rules, 1968 and provision to file
revision petition is optional.
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

10. Learned counsel for the respondents on advance service
raised preliminary objection as to maintainability of the present
OA as section 20 of the Administrative Act, 1985 envisaged that
the application cannot be admitted unless applicant has availed
all the remedies under relevant service rules. There is statutory,
efficacious remedy available to the applicant against the appellate
authority order dated 13.05.2026 to file revision petition under
Rule 25 of Rules, 1968 and the present OA is not maintainable
and deserves to be dismissed in limine at admission stage.
11. Heard learned counsel appearing for both the parties.
12. Short issue for consideration is- "whether remedy of revision
is optional and not statutory efficacious alternate remedy"
13. Section 20 of Administrative Tribunal Act 1985 reads as
under :-
"Applications not to be admitted unless other remedies
exhausted-
(1) A Tribunal shall not ordinarily admit an application
unless it is satisfied that the applicant had availed of
all the remedies available to him under the relevant
service rules as to redressal of grievances.
(2) For the purposes of sub-section (1), a person shall be
deemed to have availed of all the remedies available to
him under the relevant service rules is to redressal of
grievances,-
(a) if a final order has been made by the Government or
other authority or officer or other person competent to
pass such order under such rules, rejecting any appeal
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

preferred or representation made by such person in
connection with the grievance; or
(b) where no final order has been made by the
Government or other authority or officer or other person
competent to pass such order with regard to the appeal
preferred or representation made by such person, if a
period of six months from the date on which such
appeal.
(3) For the purposes of sub-section (1) and (2), any remedy
available to an applicant by way of submission of a memorial
to the President or to the Governor of a State or to any other
functionary shall not be deemed to be one of the remedies
which are available unless the applicant had elected to
submit such memorial. ”

14. Rule 18 and Rule 25 of Rules, 1968 are extracted hereunder
for ready reference:
“ 18. Orders against which appeal lies.-
Subject to the provisions of Rule 17, a Railway servant
may prefer an appeal against all or any of the following
orders, namely-
(i) an order of suspension made or deemed to have been
made under Rule 5;
(ii) an order imposing any of the penalties specified in Rule
6 whether made by the disciplinary authority or by any
appellate or revising authority;
(iii) an order enhancing any penalty imposed under Rule 6;
(iv) an order which-
(a) denies or varies to his disadvantage his pay,
allowances, pension, Provident Fund Benefits, service
gratuity or other conditions of service as regulated by
rules or by agreement; or
(b) interprets to his disadvantage the provisions of any
such rule or agreement;
(v) an order-
(a) stopping him at the efficiency bar in time scale of pay
on the ground of his unfitness to cross the bar;
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

(b) reverting him while officiating in a higher service,
grade or post to a lower service, grade or post otherwise
than as a penalty;
(c) reducing or withholding the pension or denying the
maximum pension admissible to him under the rules, if he
is a pensionable Railway servant;
(d) reducing or withholding the Government contribution
to Provident Fund and Special Contribution to Provident
Fund or Gratuity admissible to him under the State
Railway Provident Fund Rules and Gratuity Rules, if he is
a non-pensionable Railway servant;
(e) determining the subsistence and other allowances to be
paid to him for the period of suspension or for the period
during which he is deemed to be under suspension or for
any portion thereof;
(f) determining his pay and allowances-
(i) for the period of suspension; or
(ii) for the period from the date of his dismissal,
removal or compulsory retirement from service to the
date of his reinstatement;
(g) determining whether or not the period from the date of
his suspension or from the date of his dismissal, removal
or compulsory retirement to the date of his reinstatement
shall be treated as a period spent on duty for any purpose.
Explanation:-
In this rule-
(i) the expression 'Railway servant' includes a person who
has ceased to be in Railway service;

(ii) the expression 'pension' includes additional pension,
gratuity and any other retirement benefit .

"25. Revision -
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules -
(i) the President, or
(ii) the Railway Board, or
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

(iii) the General Manager of a Railway Administration or
an authority of that status in the case of a Railway
servant under his or its control, or
(iv) the appellate authority not below the rank of a
Divisional Railway Manager in cases where no appeal has
been preferred, or
(v) any other authority not below the rank of a Deputy
Head of a Department, in the case of a Railway servant
serving under its control (may at any time, either on his
or its own motion or otherwise, call for the records of
any inquiry and revise any order made under these rules
or, under the rules repealed by Rule 29, after
consultation with the Commission where such
consultation is necessary, and may) -
(a) confirm, modify or set aside the order; or
(b) confirm, reduce, enhance or set aside the penalty
imposed by the order, or impose any penalty where no
penalty has been imposed; or
(c) remit the case to the authority which made the order
or to any other authority directing such authority to
make such further inquiry as it may consider proper in
the circumstances of the case; or
(d) pass such other orders as it may deem fit:
Provided that -
(a) no order imposing or enhancing any penalty shall be
made by any revising authority unless the Railway
servant concerned has been given a reasonable
opportunity of making a representation against the
penalty proposed;
(b) subject to the provisions of Rule 14, where it is
proposed to impose any of the penalties specified in
Clauses (v) to (ix) of Rule 6 or the penalty specified in
Clause (iv) of Rule 6 which falls within the scope of the
provisions contained in sub-rule (2) of Rule 11 or to
enhance the penalty imposed by the order under revision
to any of the penalties specified in this sub-clause, no
such penalty shall be imposed except after following the
procedure for inquiry in the manner laid down in Rule 9,
unless such inquiry has already been held, and also
except after consultation with the Commission, where
such consultation is necessary.
(2) No proceeding for revision shall be commenced until
after -
(i) the expiry of the period of limitation for appeal; or
(ii) the disposal of the appeal where any such appeal has
been preferred
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

Provided that the provisions of this sub-rule shall not
apply to the revision of punishment in case of Railway
accidents.
(3) An application for revision shall be dealt with in the
same manner as if it were an appeal under these rules.
(4) No power of revision shall be exercised under this Rule
:-
(i) by the appellate or revising authority where it has
already considered the appeal on the case and passed
orders thereon; and
(ii) by a revising authority unless it is higher than the
appellate authority where an appeal has been preferred
or where no appeal has been preferred and the time limit
laid down for revision by the appellate authority, has
expired:
Provided that nothing contained in Clauses (i) and (ii)
above, shall apply to revision by the President.
(5) No action under this rule shall be initiated by -
(a) an appellate authority other than the President; or
(b) the revising authorities mentioned in item (v) of sub-
rule (1) - after more than six months from the date of the order
to be revised in cases where it is proposed to impose or
enhance a penalty or modify the order to the detriment of the
Railway servant; or more than one year after the date of the
order to be revised in cases where it is proposed to reduce or
cancel the penalty imposed or modify the order in favour of
the Railway servant:
Provided that when revision is undertaken by the
Railway Board or the General Manager of a Zonal Railway or an
authority of the status of a General Manager in any other
Railway Unit or Administration when they are higher than the
appellate authority, and by the President even when he is the
appellate authority, this can be done without restriction of any
time limit.
Explanation- For the purposes of this sub-rule the time
limits for revision of cases shall be reckoned from the date of
issue of the orders proposed to be revised. In cases where
original order has been upheld by the appellate authority, the
time limit shall be reckoned from the date of issue of the
appellate orders.
Note: - Time limit for revision petition is 45 days from
the date of delivery of the order sought to be revised. Where
no appeal has been preferred against the order of the
disciplinary authority the time limit of 45 days will be
reckoned from the date of expiry of the period of limitation for
submission of appeal [E(D&A) 84 RG 6-44 of 2.12.86 W.R. No.
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

188/86], the authority may entertain petition after expiry of
period if it is satisfied that the petitioner had sufficient cause
of delay (ibid)."
[ Emphasis Supplied ]

15. Before examining the issue framed herein above, we would
first like to deal with relevant case laws:- In Arun Kumar Jain
vs. Union of India (1986) 1 AISL 51 had held that remedy of
revision under the corresponding Rule 29 in CCA (CCS) Rules
1965, should have been exhausted within the prescribed time
limit.
16. In Raja Ram vs. Union of India , OA No.2113/2002 decided
on 16.09.2022 in Ram Avtar Gupta vs. G.M. Northern Railway
that remedy of Revision has to be exhausted before approaching
Tribunal.
17. In J.K. Kumawat vs. Union of India in OA No.1164/2005
(CAT Bench-Jabalpur) decided on 31.10.2007held that unless one
exhaust the remedy of revision prescribed under Rule 25 of Rules
1968, cannot approach this Tribunal.
18. In case of G.D. Sharma vs. Union of India , OA No. 87/2010
decided on 28.03.2011 by Principal Bench of this Tribunal held
remedy of revision is mandatory requirement and not an optional
and non-exhausting of said remedy will stand in the way.
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

19. The statutory provision of Section 20 of Act, 1985 extracted
herein above provides that this Tribunal shall not ordinarily admit
an application until satisfied that applicant has availed all the
remedy available to him. So also Sub Section (2) of Section 20 of
Act 1985 further provides that for the purpose of Sub Section (1),
a person shall deem to have been exhausted all the remedy
available to him under relevant service rules for redressal of his
grievance and if a final order has been passed by the other
authority, then competent authority may pass such order under
the rules thereafter Tribunal shall ordinarily admit an application.
Analyzing the scheme of Rules, 1968 particularly Rule 18
provides that filing of appeal against an order imposing any of the
penalty specified in Rule 6 to the authority to which the authority
imposing the penalty is immediately subordinate. Rule 20 relates
to period of limitation of appeal, Rule 21 & 22 relates to
submission and consideration of appeal. There is also provision
for filing Revision under Rule 25 of Rules, 1968 .
20. Analyzing the scheme of Rules, 1968 . Rule 18 provides for
orders against which the departmental appeal lies. The order
imposing any of the penalties specified in Rule 6 made by the
disciplinary authority.
21. Rule 25 of Rules, 1968 , envisaged the provision of filing
revision petition after expiry of the period of limitation for an
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

appeal or after the disposal of appeal. So also clause (3) of Rule
25 of Rules, 1968 further provides that the power of revision is to
be exercised by revising authority, it has to be higher that the
appellate authority. Clause (b) of sub-rule (5) of Rule 25 of Rules,
1968 further provides for revising authority, the period of
limitation other than when revision is undertaken by Railway
Board, General Manager or the President. The explanation to sub-
rule (5) of Rule 25 of Rules, 1968 also provides limitation for
revision from date of issue of order of the appellate order and note
appended also prescribe the condonation of delay in filing the
revision in case there is sufficient cause for delay.
22. The Scheme of Act, 1985 and Section 20 of Act,1985 provides
that Tribunal shall not admit an application unless satisfied that
applicant availed all the remedy available to him for redressal of
his grievances. So also Rule18 and 25 of Rules, 1968 provides
the remedy of filing appeal and revision respectively.
23. The Division Bench of this Tribunal, Bench at Jabalpur in
case of Sudama Prasad Kori vs. Union of India in OA No.
285/2006 decided on 01.05.2009 followed by Principal Bench
of this Tribunal in case of G.D. Sharma vs. Union of India that
exhausting remedy to file revision is mandatory and non-
exhausting such remedy would stand in the way of approaching
this Tribunal.
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

24. Hon'ble Supreme Court while dealing with the matter relating
to harmonious construction of statutes, laid down principles and
rules of harmonious construction in the case of CIT vs.
Hindustan Bulk Carriers, (2003) 3 SCC 57. Their Lordships has
held reads as "that Courts must avoid a head on clash of seemingly
contradicting provisions and they must construe the contradictory
provisions as to harmonize them. The provision of one section
cannot be used to defeat the provision contained in another unless
the court, despite all its efforts, is unable to find a way to reconcile
the differences. When it is impossible to completely reconcile the
differences in contradictory provisions, the courts must interpret
them in such a way so that effect is given to both the provisions as
much as possible. Courts must also keep in mind that
interpretation that reduces one provision to a useless number or
dead is not harmonious construction. To harmonize is not to
destroy any statutory provision or to render it fruitless."
25. On analyzing the Section 20 and scheme of A.T. Act, 1985
and also the scheme of statutory effective remedy provided under
Rule18 and 25 of Rules, 1968 read with principal laid down by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, this Tribunal finds that there is a
specific object behind enacting provision under Rule 18 to prefer
appeal and in Rule 25 to prefer revision. The specific object is to
confer jurisdiction to higher authorities to provide remedy of filing
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

appeal and revision to the lower strata employee so that the
higher authority considering the facts and law decide the
quantum of penalty.
26. This Tribunal examined contentions of applicant raised at the
Bar in light of aforesaid settled principles, when a final order is
passed, on his appeal the mandate of Section 20 of A.T. Act is
fulfilled and it did not require exhausting the remedy of revision.
If contention of learned counsel for applicant is accepted, will
result to reading down statutory provision in Rule18 and 25 of
Rules, 1968 framed under proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India and would stand nullified and effect of
deleting from the statutes i.e. Rules, 1968 . So also the object
behind Section 20 of A.T. Act, is all the remedies provided under
service rules should be exhausted before approaching this
Tribunal. Sub Section (3) of Section 20 of A.T. Act to be construed
harmoniously and only on exception where discretionally remedy
of memorial preferred before President or Governor.
27. This Tribunal having considered the scheme of A.T. Act, 1985
and Rules, 1968 that provides statutory and effective remedy and
reading section 20 of Act, 1985 suffice to held that there is
specific object and intention behind such rules to make available
effective statutory remedy to file revision petition to employees in
the Department which forms large chunk.
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'

Item No.13 O.A. No. 4509/2026

28. This Tribunal does not find any merit in the submissions of
learned counsel for applicant and repelled whereas find force in
the submission of learned counsel for respondents who raised
preliminary objection.
29. In view of above analysis, this Tribunal hold that provision for
filing revision under Rules, 1968 is mandatory requirement and
is not an optional remedy. So also it is suffice to hold that non
exhausting of such alternate and efficacious available remedy
would stand in the way of applicant for approaching the Tribunal.
30. In the result, the present OA is dismissed in limine at
admission stage as not maintainable.
31. However, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case
noted hereinabove, liberty is also extended to applicant to first
exhaust mandatory remedy of filing revision accordance with
Rules, 1968 . If such revision petition, is preferred against the
order of Appellate Authority within a period of thirty days from
the date of receipt of certified copy of the order passed today, it is
further directed that competent authority shall dispose of same
on merit waiving period of limitation. No order as to costs.















[

(Rajinder Kashyap) (Ajay Pratap Singh)
Member (A) Member (J)


/ kr /
KARAN
KARA 2026.11.17
12:30:42
N +05'30'