A N GEETHA vs VINOTH KUMAR P

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025







IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 4 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 1577 OF 2025 (MV-D)

BETWEEN:

1. A N GEETHA
W/O H.S. RUDREGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS

2. H.S. RUDREGOWDA,
S/O H.C. SHIVANNA,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,

3. NIKHIL. H.R.,
S/O H.S. RUDREGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS

ALL ARE R/A HULLEKERE VILLAGE,
DANDINASHIVARA HOBLI,
TURUVEKERE TALUK,
TUMAKURU DISTRICT

NOW R /A MALLASANDRA,
TUMAKURU TALUK AND DISTRICT.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. RAGHU R, ADVOCATE)











Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


AND:

1. VINOTH KUMAR P
S/O PERUMAL,
AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
R/A DOOR NO.170, PALVAL STREET,
SHANKARI TALUK,
SELAM DISTRICT,
TAMILNADU STATE-637301,
REP BY HIS GPA HOLDER
S. SRIRANGAN, S/O SENGODAN,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
R/A DOOR NO. 1D1-F,
PALLAVI STREET, SHANKARI TALUK,
SELAM DISTRICT-637301

2. THE MANAGER,
ROYAL SUNDARAM GEN. INS, CO. LTD.,
RD
REP. BY ITS MANGER, 3 FLOOR,
JNR CITY CENTER,
RAJA RAM MOHAN RAY ROAD,
SAMPANGIRAM NAGARA,
BENGALURU-560027
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. RAVI S.SAMPRATHI, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
R1 -VINOTH KUMAR P, SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED)

THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 26.11.2024
PASSED IN MVC No.281/2023 ON THE FILE OF THE I
ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND CJM, TUMAKURU,
DISMISSING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION.

THIS APPEAL IS COMING ON FOR HEARING THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR


Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed by the claimants challenging the
dismissal of their claim petition in the Judgment and
Award dated 26.11.2024 passed in MVC.No.281/2023 by I
Additional Senior Civil Judge and CJM, Tumakuru.

2. The Appellant/claimant made a claim petition
praying to award compensation for the death of Deepak in
a road traffic accident occurred on 06.02.2023, contending
that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of the driver of Ashok Leyland Lorry bearing
No.TN-52-C-4774.
3. T he Tribunal, after recording the evidence and
appreciating the material available on record, dismissed
the claim petition on the ground that the claimants had
failed to establish that the accident occurred due to the
rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending
truck. Aggrieved by the said judgment and award, the
claimants have preferred the present appeal, challenging
the findings recorded by the Tribunal.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025



4. Heard the learned counsel for the appellant/
claimants and learned counsel for the respondent No.2/
Insurer.

5. The learned counsel for the appellant would
contend that the accident occurred on 06.02.2023 at
08:15 p.m. during night hours and on the same day at
10:15 p.m. first information has been registered by one
Deekshith. Based on which, Ex-P1 - FIR has been
registered against the driver of truck bearing No.TN-52-C-
4774. It is further submitted that the police after
investigation have filed a charge sheet (Ex-P11) for the
offences punishable under Section 279 and 304(A) of IPC
against the driver of the truck for rash and negligent
driving. The said Deekshith, who filed first information and
who was eyewitness to the accident has been examined as
PW2 and he has categorically stated regarding the rash
and negligent driving of the driver of the truck. The
Tribunal without considering these aspects has
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


hypothetically considered the documents and probabilized
that the accident is due to the rash and negligent riding of
the rider of the motorcycle/deceased. He places reliance
on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case
of Ranjeet and another v. Abdul Khayam Neb and
1
anr and contended that filing of the charge sheet against
the driver is sufficient to prove the rash and negligent
driving and there is no need to examine the eyewitness.
He further submits that the documents produced and the
evidence on record clearly indicate rash and negligent
driving on the part of the driver of the lorry.

6. He further submits that the deceased was an
engineering student studying in second year and therefore
his income is to be taken at Rs.25,000/- per month and
places reliance on the judgment of this court rendered in
MFA.No.641/2023. He further submits that the claimants
are parents and younger brother of the deceased. The

1
SLP(C)No.10351/2019 decided on 25.02.2025
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


deceased was aged 20 years. With this he prayed to allow
the appeal.

7. The learned counsel appearing for respondent
No.2 /insurer would contend that the truck was loaded
with sand and cement and it is a heavy truck and it cannot
be driven in a zigzag manner. There are material
contradictions in the evidence of PW2. Considering the
evidence on record, the Tribunal has rightly held that the
accident occurred due to the sole negligent driving of the
deceased, who was the rider of the motorcycle. With this,
the insurer prayed to dismiss the appeal.

8. Heard learned counsel for both side and
perused the judgment and award and trial court records.

9. The following points arise for consideration:
i. Whether the Tribunal is justified in holding
that the claimants have failed to prove that the
accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


driving of the driver of the lorry bearing
registration No.TN-52-C-4774?
ii. Whether the claimants are entitled to
compensation if point No.1 is answered in the
favour of the appellants?
REASONS
Point No.i:
10. The accident occurred on 06.02.2023 at 08:15
p.m. Ex-P2 is the first information and it is filed by one
Deekshit and based on which Ex-P1-FIR has been
registered against driver of the lorry bearing registration
No.TN-52-C-4774. The police after conducting
investigation have filed a charge sheet as per Ex-P11 for
the offence punishable under Sections 279 and 304 IPC
against the driver of the lorry for rash and negligent
driving.

11. PW2 is the said Deekshith, who had filed first
information - Ex-P2 and he is eyewitness to the accident.
PW2 has specifically stated in his evidence that the lorry
which was going ahead of the motorcycle of the deceased
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


suddenly took a change in the lane from lane 2 to lane 1
and as a result of which the motorcycle of the deceased
dashed to the back of the lorry and accident occurred. In
column No.17 of the charge sheet the said aspect is
mentioned that the driver of the lorry suddenly changed
his lane, due to which the motorcycle of the deceased
dashed to the lorry and accident occurred resulting in
death of the deceased Deepak and pillion rider yeshaswini.

12. The respondents have not adduced any
evidence to establish that the driver of the lorry was not
negligent in driving the vehicle.

13. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Ranjeeth (referred
supra) has held as follows:
" 4. It is settled in law that once a charge sheet has
been filed and the driver has been filed and the
driver has been held negligent, no further evidence is
required to prove that the bus was being negligently
driven by the bus driver. Even if the eye-witnesses
are not examined, that will not be fatal to prove the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


death of the deceased due to negligence of the bus
driver".

14. In the case on hand, the charge sheet has been
produced at Ex-P11 and more so eyewitness PW2 has
been examined. The evidence on record clearly establish
that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the lorry. Accordingly point number
1 is answered.

Point number ii:
15. The accident occurred on 06.02.2023 and as on
the date of accident, the deceased was aged 20 years. The
relevant multiplier applicable is '18'. Ex-P13 is the
certificate issued by Basaveshwara Thantrika Maha
Vidyalaya and Ex-P14 - College ID of the deceased clearly
indicate that he was a student Studying in second year. In
view of the decision of this Court rendered in
MFA.No.641/2023, the income of the deceased is to be
taken at Rs.25,000/- per month as he was a BE student.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


The deceased was a bachelor, therefore, 50% is to be
deducted towards future prospects and 40% is to be
added towards personal expenses.

16. In view of the above, loss of dependency is
calculated as:
Rs.25,000+40%=35,000-
50%=17,500x12x18=37,80,000/-.

17. Learned counsel for the appellants would
contend that, the claimants are parents and younger
brother of the deceased and they are entitled to
consortium. The accident occurred in the year 2023, the
escalation at 10% is to be calculated on the consortium
since the accident occurred after six years from 2017 as
per decision in the case of NATIONAL INSURANCE
COMPANY vs. PRANAY SETHI AND OTHERS reported
in AIR 2017 SC 5157. In view of the same, the claimants
are entitled to loss of consortium of Rs.44,000/- each i.e.,
Rs.1,44,000/-. The claimants are also entitled to funeral
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


expenses and transportation in a sum of Rs.18,000/- and
loss of estate in a sum of Rs.18,000/-.

18. Considering all the above aspects, the claimants
are entitled to total compensation under various heads as
under:
Sl.
No.
Compensation Heads Amount(in
Rs.)
1. Loss of dependency 37,80,000
2. Funeral expenses and
transportation of dead body
18,000
3. Loss of consortium 1,44,000
4. Loss of estate 18,000
Total Rs.39,60,000/-

19. The claimants are entitled to total compensation
of Rs.39,60,000/- with interest at the rate of 6% per
annum from the date of petition till realisation.

20. In view of the above, the following:
ORDER
i) Miscellaneous First Appeal is allowed-in-
part .
ii) The claimants are entitled to total
compensation of Rs.39,60,000/- with
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62351
MFA No. 1577 of 2025


CNR: KAHC010141492025


interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of petition till realisation.
iii) The claimants are entitled to share in the
compensation in the ratio of 40:40:20. The
claimants are entitled to release of 50% of
their share and remaining 50% shall be
kept in fixed deposit in any
Nationalized/Scheduled Bank for a period of
three years.
iv) The respondent No.2-insurer shall deposit
the compensation with interest before the
Tribunal within a period of six weeks from
this date.


Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

(SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR)
JUDGE
AG
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 51