SRI H M LOKESH REDDY vs SMT SUDHA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 639 OF 2019 (SP)
BETWEEN:
1. SRI H M LOKESH REDDY
S/O. NARAYANA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS.
2. SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O. SRI H M LOKESH REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS.
BOTH ARE RESIDENT OF
HEBBATA VILLAGE, KASABA HOBLI
SRINIVASAPUR TALUK
KOLAR DISTRICT – 563 135.
3. SMT. SUNITHA
W/O. SRI. RAMEGOWDA,
D/O. SRI H M LOKESH REDDY,
EARLIER R/O. HEBBATA VILLAGE,
KASABA HOBLI, SRINIVASAPUR TALUK,
KOLAR DISTRICT – 563 135.
PRESENTLY R/O. KUDENURU,
MALURU TALUK,
KOLAR DISTRICT – 563 130.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. BASAVARAJU P, ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
VANDANA S
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
AND:
SMT SUDHA
W/O. H M GOPALA REDDY,
R/O. HEBBATA VILLAGE,
KASABA HOBLI, SRINIVASAPUR TALUK,
KOLAR DISTRICT – 563 135.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. VASANTH KUMAR H.T, ADVOCATE)
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SEC.100 R/W ORDER XLII RULE 1 OF
CPC 1908 AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 01.10.2018
PASSED IN RA.NO.178/2016 ON THE FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE, KOLAR, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 05.11.2016 PASSED IN OS.NO.62/2012
ON THE FILE OF THE ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC,
SRINIVASPUR.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT
WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
The appellants were defendants in O.S.No.62/2012 filed by
the respondent-plaintiff against the appellants-defendants for
specific performance of an alleged sale agreement dated
03.02.2010 and for other reliefs. According to the plaintiff, the
appellants-defendants, who were the owners of the suit schedule
property, acquired the same in the year 1994-95 by virtue of a
grant made in their favour, which prescribed a non-alienation
period of 15 years from the date of grant. It was contended that
after expiry of the said 15 years non-alienation period, the
appellants executed a registered sale agreement dated 03.02.2010
agreeing to sell the suit schedule property for a total sale
consideration of Rs.3,10,000/- in pursuance of which the
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
appellants-defendants received a sum of Rs.3,00,000/- from the
respondent-plaintiff, who agreed to pay the balance sale
consideration of Rs.10,000/- to the appellant at the time of
registration of the sale deed which was to be done within a period
of two years from the date of the agreement. It was contended that
since the appellants defendant did not perform their part of the
contract and did not take necessary steps to obtain the survey
sketch, revenue records etc., the respondent got issued a legal
notice dated 21.01.2012, to which the appellants issued a false and
frivolous reply, leading to the respondent-plaintiff instituting the
aforesaid suit seeking specific performance and other reliefs
against the appellants-defendants.
2. The appellants-defendants filed a written statement
inter alia disputing and denying the various allegations and claim
made by the plaintiff. It was contended that the transaction
between the plaintiff and defendants was only a loan transaction
and the said sale agreement was not a sale agreement but merely
a security towards a hand loan advanced by the respondents-
plaintiffs to the appellant-defendants and that the respondent had
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
concocted, manipulated and forged the signatures of the
appellants-defendants on the said document and consequently, the
question of the respondent being entitled to seek specific
performance of the sale agreement would not arise in the facts and
circumstances of the instant case.
3. Based on the aforesaid pleadings, the Trial Court
framed the following issues:
“1. Whether the plaintiff proves that the defendants have
executed an agreement of sale dated 03.02.2010 in
favour of plaintiff with respect to the suit schedule
property?
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that she is ready and willing
to perform her part of contract?
3. Whether the plaintiff proves that the defendants are not
ready and willing to perform their part of contract?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the specific
performance of the contract as prayed in the plaint?
5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief sought in the
plaint?
6. What Order?”
4. The plaintiff examined herself as PW-1 and two other
witnesses as PWs.2 to 4 and got marked documentary evidence as
Exs.P-1 to 6 on her behalf. While, defendant No.1 examined
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
himself as DW.1, defendant No.2 as DW.2, defendant No.3 as
DW.3 and one witness as DW.4 and got marked documentary
evidence Exs.D-1 to 4 on their behalf.
5. Thereafter, the Trial Court proceeded to answer all the
issues in favour of the plaintiff and decreed the suit in
O.S.No.62/2012 in his favour and against the appellants-
defendants by holding as under:
“
The plaintiff has filed this suit against the
defendant No.1 to 3 to execute registered sale deed in
view of registered sale agreement dated 03/02/2010 and
obtain sale balance consideration.
2. The brief fact of the plaintiff case is that the
defendant No.1 is the husband and the defendant No.2 is
his legally wedded wife and 3rd defendant is their
daughter. The defendant No.1 is the absolute owner and
in peaceful possession and enjoyment over the suit
schedule property. He acquired the same by virtue of
grant made by the Darkasth committee, Srinivaspur in the
year 1994-95 subject to non-alienation for a period of 15
years. After the expiry of 15 years from the date of grant
the defendant No.1 along with his wife and daughter
agreed to sell the suit property and executed registered
sale agreement dated 03/02/2010 in favour of plaintiff for
valuable consideration of Rs.3,00,000/- and Rs.10,000/-.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
Out of the total amount of sale consideration the
defendants have received Rs.3,00,000/- to meet their
legal necessity in the presence of witnesses and agreed
to receive the balance sale consideration of Rs.10,000/-
at the time of executing registered sale deed in favour of
plaintiff within 2 years from the date of registered
agreement. The suit schedule property is PYKI land for
which survey sketch is required to be done before the
executing the regular registered sale deed and it is to be
done at the cost of defendants to set right documents
required for registration and to that effect the recitals are
incorporated in the sale agreement but the defendants
have not set right revenue documents for registration till
today, the plaintiff is ever ready and willing to perform her
part of contract. Further she is also ready to comply her
part of contract, she is ready to bear registration
expenditure and also ready to give balance consideration
in favour of defendants at the time of registration process.
But the defendants are not ready and willing to perform
their part of contract and the same is against to the
registered sale agreement’s recitals. The plaintiff met the
defendants for several times and requested them to
comply the recitals of sale agreement, but the defendants
not obliged the same. Hence the plaintiff has issued legal
statutory notice to the defendants through RPAD on
21/01/2012 demanding them to perform their part of
contract, same is served on the defendants. The
defendants caused reply notice through their counsel on
03/02/2012 by denying the transaction and put forth their
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
own story contrary to the registered sale agreement
altering the entire transaction with malafide intention.
Hence plaintiff filed this suit against the defendants
seeking appropriate relief from this court. Hence decree
the suit as prayed for.
3. After registration of the suit, suit summons
were issued to the defendants. The defendants served
with summons. The defendant No.1 to 3 appeared before
this court through their counsel and filed the written
statement as under.
The defendant No.1 to 3 filed the objection and
contended that the defendants have not at all executed
any sale agreement in favour of plaintiff at any time as
alleged sale agreement replied upon by the plaintiff dated
03/02/2010. The said document is manipulated,
concocted and forged the signatures of the defendants by
the plaintiff in the registered sale agreement. As such no
reliance can be placed on it and suit filed by the plaintiff
against the defendants with regard to alleged suit
schedule property to knock off the same from peaceful
possession ad enjoyment of the defendants. Further the
defendants are the owners of the suit schedule property.
The defendants have approached the plaintiff for an
accommodation of hand loan of Rs.2,20,000/- for which
the defendants have agreed to pay the said sum with
interest at the rate of 2% per annum, on the said amount
inturn the plaintiff has paid a sum of Rs.2,20,000/- for
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
which the defendants had offered a security of said
property shown in the plaint of the plaintiff. The said loan
is only money transaction but not transactions pertaining
to schedule property. Even till today the defendants are
ready to clear all the debts along with interest borrowed
by them from the plaintiff. There are no any offer to sell
the suit schedule property to the plaintiff nor received any
part sale consideration from the plaintiff and they never
subscribed their signature to the said document. It is not
necessity for them to sell the suit schedule property to the
plaintiff and plaintiff’s main intention is to knock off the
valuable property of defendants. Hence defendants prays
to dismiss the suit filed by the plaintiff.
4. Based on rival contentions of both the
parties, my learned Predecessor in Office has framed the
following issues :-
1. Whether the plaintiff proves that the
defendants have executed an agreement of sale dated
03/02/2010 in favour of plaintiff with respect to the suit
schedule property ?
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that she is ready
and willing to perform her part of contract ?
3. Whether the plaintiff proves that the
defendants are not ready and willing to perform their part
of contract ?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled
for the Specific Performance of the contract
as prayed in the plaint ?
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief
sought in the plaint ?
6. What Order ?
5. The plaintiff in order to prove her case
examined herself as PW-1 and got examined 3 more
witnesses as PW-2 to PW-4 and produced as many as
6 documents at Ex.P1 to Ex.P6. Per Contra, the
defendant No.1 examined himself as DW-1 and got
examined 4 more witnesses as DW-2 to DW-5 and
tendered as many as 3 documents at Ex.D1 to Ex.D3.
6. Heard the arguments on both sides and
perused the documents produced by both sides.
7. Having heard both counsel on record having
given anxious consideration to material on record my
findings on the above issues are as follows :-
Issue No.1 : In the AFFIRMATIVE
Issue No.2 : In the AFFIRMATIVE
Issue No.3 : In the AFFIRMATIVE
Issue No.4 : In the AFFIRMATIVE
Issue No.5 : In the AFFIRMATIVE
Issue No.6 : As per the final order for the
following:-
R E A S O N S
8. Issue No.1 & 3 :- As the facts involved in point
No.1 to3, they are taken up together for common
discussion to avoid repetition.
The plaintiff in order to prove her case examined
herself as PW-1 and got examined 3 more witnesses as
PW-1 to PW-4 and produced 6 documents at Ex.P1 to
Ex.P6. Ex.P1 is the RTC Extract of Sy.No.53/P38, Ex.P.2
is the Legal Notice, Ex.P.2(a) to (c) are the Postal
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
receipts, Ex.P.3 is the Postal Acknowledgement, Ex.P.4
is the Reply of Legal Notice, Ex.P.4(a) is the cover,
Ex.P.5 is the Sale agreement dated 03/02/2010, Ex.P.6 is
the RTC Extract. Per Contra, the defendant No.1
examined as DW-1 and got examined 4 more witnesses
as DW-2 to DW-5 and tendered as many as 3 documents
at Ex.D1 to Ex.D3. Ex.D1 is the RTC Extract for
Sy.No.53/P38, Ex.D.2 is the Legal Notice dated
03/02/2012, Ex.D.3 is the Receipt for sending Legal
Notice.
9. The plaintiff has filed this suit against the
defendants and got examined herself as PW-1 and
reiterated the plaint averments and in her chief
examination deposed that, the defendant being the
absolute owner of the suit schedule property for that
aspect the PW-1 got marked Ex.P.1 and Ex.P.6 are RTC
extract of suit schedule property which is indicated that
the suit schedule property is standing in the name of 1st
defendant and further deposed that the defendants were
approached the plaintiff for sale the of suit schedule
property. And plaintiff shown his intention to purchase the
same and on 03/02/2010 he entered into an agreement of
sale of suit schedule property for valuable consideration
of Rs.3,00,000/-and Rs.10,000/- by executing agreement
of sale and received an amount of Rs.3,00,000/- in the
presence of witnesses. The defendant agreed to execute
registered sale deed by obtaining katha in his name
within 2 years from the date of agreement for that
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
contention the PW-1 has got marked Ex.P5 at sale
agreement dated 03/02/2010, further deposed that the
plaintiff approached the defendant and demanded them
to execute registered sale deed by receiving balance sale
consideration amount of Rs.10,000/-. But defendant
evaded to executing the same. The plaintiff is always
ready and willing to perform her part of contract and
ready to purchase the suit schedule property by paying
balance sale consideration amount and ready to get the
sale deed executed from defendants. The defendant
evaded to execute the registered sale deed. Hence she
issued with notice calling upon them to execute the
registered sale deed. Though, the said notice served
upon them and they did not turn up to execute the
registered sale deed for that contention got marked Ex.P2
which was issued by plaintiff to the defendant No.1 to 3
and Ex.P2(a) to Ex.P2(c) of postal Receipts and the
Ex.P3 postal Acknowledgment which was served on the
1st defendant further the PW-1 got marked the Replay
notice issued by the defendants at Ex.P4 those
documents were well established and shows that there
was a registered sale agreement exist between the
plaintiff and defendants as per Ex.P5 with respect of suit
schedule property and further the plaintiff is ready and
willing to perform her part of contract for that intention as
per Ex.P2 legal notice issued to the defendants, but the
defendants are not ready and willing to perform their part
of contract for that aspect the plaintiff has shows that she
is always ready and willing to pay the balance sale
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
consideration amount to the defendants. Hence the
plaintiff has issued legal notice as per Ex.P2 to the
defendants which is duly served to them. So it would be
indicating that the plaintiff had to perform her part of
contract i.e. she is ready to pay remaining sale
consideration amount to the defendants. Even service of
notice to them and they had given replay notice as per
Ex.P4. In contra the defendants were avoiding to perform
their part of contract which is agreed by themselves
during the execution Ex.P5. When perused the recitals of
agreement of sale deed for better appreciation.
“ ¤ªÀÄä ºÉ¸ÀjUÁUÀ° CxÀªÁ ¤ÃªÀÅ ¸ÀÆa¸ÀĪÀªÀgÀ ºÉ¸ÀjUÁUÀ°Ã
¤ªÀÄä Rað¤AzÀ ¸ÀjAiÀiÁzÀ bÁ¥Á QªÀÄäwÛ£À°è £ÉÆAzÀtô ªÀiÁrPÉÆqÀ®Ä
¹zÀÝgÁVgÀÄvÉÛêÉ. ¸ÀzÀj ¸ÀévÀÛ£ÀÄß ¤ªÀÄä «£ÀºÀ ªÀÄvÁÖjUÀÆ ¥ÀgÀ¨ÁgÉ
ªÀUÉÊgÁ¢UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ªÀiÁrgÀĪÀÅ¢®è, ¸ÀzÀj ¸ÀéwÛ£À ªÉÄÃ¯É ¨ÁåAPï ¸ÉÆ¸ÉÊn
ªÀUÉÊgÉUÀ¼À°è ¸Á®UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀÅ¢®è. ¸ÀzÀj ¸ÀévÀÄÛ PÀæAiÀÄzÀ PÀgÁgÀÄ
«ZÁgÀzÀ°è vÀAmÉ vÀPÀgÁgÀÄ §AzÀ°è £ÁªÉà §UɺÀj¹PÉÆqÀÄvÉÛêÉ. ¸ÀzÀj ¸ÀévÀÄÛ
¸Áé¢Ã£ÀPÉÌ PÉÆnÖgÀĪÀÅ¢®è. MAzÀÄ ªÉÃ¼É ¤ªÀÄä£ÀÄß ©lÄÖ ªÉÄîÌAqÀ ¸ÀéwÛ£À
ªÉÄÃ¯É £ÁªÀÅ ¨ÉÃgÉAiÀĪÀjUÉ ªÀåªÀºÁgÀ ªÀiÁrzÉÝà DzÀgÉ ¤ÃªÀÅ £ÀªÀÄä ªÉÄïÉ
PÁ£ÀÆ£ÀÄ jÃvÁå PÀæªÀÄ dgÀÄV¸ÀĪÀÅzÀPÉÌ ¸ÀA¥ÀÇtð ºÀPÀÄÌ PÉÆnÖgÀÄvÉÛêÉ. ”
The PW-1 had categorically deposed that, the
defendants agreed to convey the property in presence of
witnesses and received Rs.3,00,000/- and agreed to
execute registered sale deed. Further more consider for
the contention of the plaintiff that the PW-1 has been
subjected to cross examination by learned counsel for
defendants, during the cross examination of PW-1 the
defendant counsel suggested as in page 5 and 6 of cross
examination of PW1 that
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
“ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ £ÀªÀÄä §½ ¥ÀqÉ¢zÀÝ ºÀtªÀ£ÀÄß ªÀÄgÀÄ ¥ÁªÀw
ªÀiÁqÀ®Ä ¹zÀÝjzÁÝgÉ JAzÀgÉ ¸ÁQë CªÀgÀÄ PÀæAiÀĪÀiÁqÀĪÀÅzÁV PÀgÁgÀÄ
ªÀiÁrPÉÆnÖzÁÝgÉ JAzÀÄ £ÀÄrAiÀÄÄvÁÛgÉ…..
“¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ½AzÀ PÀæAiÀÄzÀ PÀgÁgÀÄ ºÀtªÀ£ÀÄß ªÁ¥À¸ÀÄì ¥ÀqÉAiÀÄĪÀAvÉ
¥ÀAZÁ¬ÄÛAiÀiÁVvÀÄÛ JAzÀgÉ ¸ÀjAiÀÄ®è.”
The suggestions which are made by the
defendants themselves is to be admission for executing
the Ex.P5 that would be clearly shows that the defendant
was executed the sale agreement in favour of plaintiff and
further reference in the
Indian Evidence Act section 17 :- An admission is a
statement, (Oral or documentary or contained in
electronic form), which suggests any inference as to any
fact in issue or relevant fact and which is made by any of
the persons, and under the circumstances.
So that the admissions are relevant made by
defendants are best piece of Evidence. From overall
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence of plaintiff
it could be safely held that, the defendants counsel did
not elicited any material which would render Ex.P5
unreliable. Further in order to substantiate her case, the
plaintiff got examined attesting witness to the said
agreement of sale as PW- 2 to PW-4. The said PW-2 to 4
have categorically admitted their signatures on Ex.P5
document and signatures were identified at Ex.P.1(a) to
(c). And the PW-2 and PW-3 were categorically deposed
that, the defendants agreed to convey the suit schedule
property to the plaintiff. And they were present at the time
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
of negotiations. And this witness also deposed regarding
passing of advance consideration to the defendants and
the defendants put their signatures and thereafter they
have affixed their signature as per Ex.P5(a) and Ex.P5(b).
Though these witnesses cross examined in length
nothing has been elicited to disprove their testimony with
regard to execution of agreement of sale. The PW-4 is
document writer with regard to Ex.P5 of sale agreement
is concerned, he was also cross examined by defendants
side and the PW-4 deposed in his cross examination that
“PÀgÁgÀÄ ¥ÀvÀæ ªÀiÁqÀĪÀ PÁ®PÉÌ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ §A¢zÀÝgÀÄ.
¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼À ºÉýPÉ ªÉÄÃgÉUÉ PÀgÁgÀÄ ªÀiÁrzÉÝêÉ. 03.10 ®PÀë gÀÆ.UÀ½UÉ
PÀæAiÀÄ ¤²ÌµÀðªÁVzÀÄÝ D ¥ÉÊQ 3 ®PÀëªÀ£ÀÄß ªÀÄÄAUÀqÀªÁV ¤ÃrgÀÄvÁÛgÉ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
G½PÉ 10 ¸Á«gÀ ¨ÁQ EgÀÄvÀÛzÉ. ¢£ÁAPÀ 03-01-2010 gÀAzÀÄ £Á£ÀÄ
¸ÀzÀj ¥ÀvÀæªÀ£ÀÄß §gÉ¢gÀÄvÉÛãÉ. PÀgÁgÀÄ ¥ÀvÀæ §gÉAiÀÄĪÀ PÁ®PÉÌ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ
ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¸ÁQëzÁgÀgÀÄ EzÀÝgÀÄ. ¸ÀzÀj PÀgÁj£À°è 2 ªÀµÀðzÀ M¼ÀUÁV 10
¸Á«gÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥ÀqÉzÀÄ PÀæAiÀÄ¥ÀvÀæ §gÉAiÀÄĪÀAvÉ w½¹vÀÄÛ.”
10. An over all the evidence of PW-1 to PW-4 is
consistent with each other regarding execution of
agreement of sale and passing of advance sale
consideration amount. And said oral and documentary
evidence are also consistent with each other about the
person who are witnessed the said transaction. Hence on
overall appreciation of entire oral and documentary
evidence of plaintiff it can safely relied upon with regard
to execution of agreement of sale by the defendants and
the plaintiff has always ready and willing to perform her
part of contract and the defendants are not ready to
perform their part of contract. During the argument the
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
learned counsel for plaintiff has placed citation that as
fallows.
1. HCR 2015 Kant. 356 SRINIVAS NAIDU
AND OTHRS V/S MARY PRAKASHI PREMKAR
AND OTHERS wherein held by the Hon’ble High
court of Karnataka as fallows :-
“ Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section 12- Specific
performance of contract-Agreement for sale of
land-Non execution of sale deed- Agreement of
sale has been denied by defendant-It is plaintiff
who has to be prove agreement of sale and
consideration that passed on-Appellate Court on
appreciation of evidence on record as well as
relevant signatures of defendants has rightly held
that agreement has been proved-First appellate
court erred in law in not granting relief of specific
performance of agreement-Relief of specific
performance of contract granted. “
2. HCR 2015 Kant. 364 karnatak state
financial corporation V/s Siyaram arcade (m/s) and
others where in held by the Hon’bl High court of
Karnataka as fallows
” Specific Relief Act, 1963-Section 16 and 20 –
Pleadings of the plaintiffs categorically stated in
the plaint that they were always ready and willing
to fulfill their part of obligations-Defendants
evading the execution for one reason or the other-
Held that plaintiff is entitled to relief of specific
performance. ”
11. On other side the defendants had taken
specific contention with regard to forgery of his signature
in the documents and further the defendants have not at
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
all executed any sale agreement in favour of plaintiff at
any point of time as alleged sale agreement replied upon
by the plaintiff dated 03/02/2010. The said document is
manipulated, concocted and forged the signatures of the
defendants by the plaintiff in the registered sale
agreement. Further the defendants are the owners of the
suit schedule property. The defendants have approached
the plaintiff for an accommodation of hand loan of
Rs.2,20,000/- for which the defendants have agreed to
pay the said sum with interest at the rate of 2%per
annum, on the said amount inturn the plaintiff has paid a
sum of Rs.2,20,000/- for which the defendants had
offered a security of said property shown in the plaint of
the plaintiff. The said loan is only money transaction but
not transactions pertaining to schedule property. Even till
today the defendants are ready to clear all the debts
along with interest borrowed by them from the plaintiff for
that contention the defendant No.1 had got examined
himself as DW-1 and tendered as many as 3 documents
at Ex.D1 to Ex.D3 and same got marked by DW1 at
Ex.D1 is the RTC Extract for Sy.No.53/P38, Ex.D.2 is the
Legal Notice dated 03/02/2012, Ex.D.3 is the Receipt for
sending Legal Notice. And further got examined 4 more
witnesses as DW-2 to DW-5.
12. The DW-1 reiterated the averments of his
written statement in chief affidavit and during the cross
Examination by the plaintiff he was admitted in page 4 of
cross examination that
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
“ ªÁ¢ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ £À£Àß £ÀqÀÄªÉ ªÀåªÀºÁgÀ £ÀqÉ¢vÀÄÛ. ¤¦-5gÀ°è £ÀªÀÄä
¸ÀªÀÄPÀëªÀÄ ªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ªÁ¢UÀ¼À ¸ÀªÀÄPÀëªÀÄ £ÁªÀÅ ¥ÉÇÃmÉÆÃ, ºÉ§âlÄ
UÀÄgÀÄvÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¸À»UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ºÁQzÉÝêÉ. ¤¦-5 £ÀÄß ªÁ¢UÀ¼ÀÄ §gɹzÁÝgÉ.
CªÀgÀÄ §gɹgÀĪÀÅzÀPÉÌ £Á£ÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 3 gÀªÀgÀÄ ¸À»
ªÀiÁrgÀÄvÉÛêÉ. ¤¦-5 gÀ°è §gÉ¢gÀĪÀ «ZÁgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß 3 £Éà ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ M¢
w½zÀÄPÉÆArzÁݼÉ. CzÀgÀ®è §gÉ¢gÀĪÀÅzÀÄ ¸Àj EzÉ JAzÀÄ w½zÀÄPÉÆAqÀ
£ÀAvÀgÀ £ÁªÀÅ ¸À»ªÀiÁrgÀÄvÉÛÃªÉ JAzÀgÉ ¸Àj.”
Further in page 5 of his cross examination
deposed that
“£Á£ÀÄ PÉêÀ® 2 ®PÀë 10 ¸Á«gÀ gÀÆ.UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ªÀiÁvÀæ ¹éÃPÀj¹zÀPÉÌ
AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà ¸ÁQë ªÀÄvÀÄÛ zÁR¯É E®è. £Á£ÀÄ ªÁ¢UÉ §rØ ¤ÃrgÀĪÀÅzÀPÉÌ
AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà zÁR¯É E®è. “
So the appreciation of oral evidence of DW-1 it
was cleared that there was not cogent material and also
not any documentary evidence with regarding to loan
transaction between the plaintiff and defendant as taken
contention by the defendants in their written statement.
Further the defendants got examined DW-2 to 5 for
substantiated to their defence the 2nd and 3rd defendant
got examined themselves as DW-2 and DW-3 and they
are also reiterated in their chief examination the
averments of their written statements and further the DW-
4 was son-in-law of defendant No.1 and 2 and husband of
defendant No.3 and deposed in his chief-examination
about the loan transaction between plaintiff
and defendants but during the cross examination DW-
4 admitted that
“ ªÁ¢ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢UÀ¼À £ÀqÀÄªÉ 2010 gÀ ¥sɧæªÀjAiÀÄ°è ºÀtzÀ
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
ªÀiÁvÀÄPÀvÉ £ÀqÉ¢gÀÄvÀÛzÉ….. ¸ÀzÀj ªÀiÁvÀÄPÀvÉ §UÉÎ ¥ÀvÀæ ªÀåªÀºÁgÀ ªÀiÁr®è.
¥ÀvÀæ §gÉAiÀÄ®Ä AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà vÉÆAzÀgÉ EgÀ°®è. “
Further the DW-5 also deposed as per defence of
defendants but he was admitted in his cross examination
that there was no document with respect of loan
transaction. Hence over all the defendants made an
efforts to succeeding in their defence but they are not
succeed in establishing it, with cogent material or
documents as alleged in their written statement. Hence
plaintiff is succeeded in discharging his initial burden to
prove the said Ex.P.5 agreement of sale. The said Ex.P.5
reveals that, the defendants agreed to convey the suit
schedule property for valuable consideration of
Rs.3,10,000/-. And the said Ex.P.5 document further
reveals the passing of advance sale consideration
amount. Hence the said admission makes it clear that,
though the defendants had executed an agreement of
sale in favour of plaintiff and he took that unsuccessful
defense. If he really unaware of said agreement of sale
he could have enquired the plaintiff with regard to said
agreement of sale or he could have take the steps to
prosecute her for creating documents. Further the
defendants counsel made effort to prove the contention of
defendants through filling their written arguments which is
contain the averments of same Wirtten statements,
Hence from the material on record it would goes to show
that, the defendants had entered into an agreement of
sale in respect of suit schedule property. And they had
taken unsuccessfully defense to oppose the suit claim.
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
Further the defendants themselves admitted that the 1st
defendant is the owners of suit schedule property by
producing document themselves i.e., RTC Extract at
Ex.D1 and reply notice, at Ex.D 2. In my view the
circumstance taken for consideration which are all
available in the both side oral and documentary evidence,
it shows that the defendants had executed an agreement
of sale in favor of plaintiff by agreeing to convey the suit
schedule property and agreed to get registered sale deed
within 2 years after from the date of sale agreement.
Hence for the above all reason I have conclude that, the
plaintiff had succeeded in establishing the fact of
execution of agreement of sale by the defendants. Hence
I hold Issue No.1 to 3 in AFFIRMATIVE.
13. Issue NO.4 :- Though the plaintiff succeeded
in establishing the execution of agreement of sale deed
as per Ex.P5 and always ready and willing to perform her
part of contract, that would alone entitled her to claim the
discretionary relief of specific performance of contract.
Hence I hold issue No.4 in the AFFIRMATIVE.
14. Issue No.5 :- In view of the aforesaid
reasons and discussions made above in issue No.1 to 4,
she is entitled for the relief as claimed in the plaint. Hence
I hold issue No.5 in the AFFIRMATIVE.
15. Issue No.6 :- Keeping in view of the above
findings and conclusion arrived at issue Nos. 1 to 5, I
proceed to pass the following,:-
O R D E R
The suit of the plaintiff is hereby decreed with cost.
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
The plaintiff is entitled to get registered sale deed
in view of sale agreement dated 03/02/2010.
The defendants are directed to execute the
registered sale deed in favour of the plaintiff as per the
terms of the sale agreement within one month from the
date of decree and if the defendants fails to execute the
registered sale deed, the plaintiff is at liberty to file
execution and got the registered sale deed executed
through the officers of the court at the cost of the
defendants.
Office is hereby directed to draw decree
accordingly.”
6. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree of the
Trial Court, the appellants-defendants approached the First
Appellate Court in R.A.No.178/2016 in which, the appellants not
only assailed the various findings recorded against them by the
Trial Court, but also filed two applications viz., application under
Order XLI Rule 27 CPC seeking production of additional
documents and the application under Order XVI Rule 6 CPC for a
direction to the Tahsildar to produce the grant records pertaining to
the grant of the suit schedule property in favour of the respondent-
plaintiff. By the impugned judgment and decree, the First Appellate
Court not only rejected the contention of the appellants on merits
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
but also dismissed the aforesaid applications filed by the
appellants-defendants under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC and Order
XVI Rule 6 CPC and consequently, dismissed the appeal by
confirming the judgment and decree of the Trial Court. Aggrieved
by the impugned judgment and decree of the Trial Court and the
First Appellate Court, the appellants are before this Court by way of
the present appeal, which came to be admitted by this Court on
17.04.2021 by framing the following substantial questions of law:
“i) Whether the Courts below committed an error in holding
that the bar contained under rule 108 J of the Karnataka
Land Revenue Rules, 1966 was not attracted by the
execution of the sale agreement dated 03.02.2010?
ii) Whether the sale agreement dated 03.02.2010 was
against public policy and therefore, was not
unenforceable in Court of law, in view of the judgment of
the Apex Court in Civil Appeal Nos.7630-7631 of 2019?”
7. Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned
counsel for the respondent and perused the material on record.
8. With the consent of both sides, the following additional
substantial question of law is framed for disposal of the present
appeal:
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
“Whether the first appellate court was justified in rejecting the
applications filed by the appellants under Order XLI Rule 27 CPC
and Order XVI Rule 6 CPC thereby dismissing and consequently
dismissing the appeal filed by the appellants.?”
Re. additional substantial question of law :
9. A perusal of the material on record will indicate that
according to the plaintiff, in the plaint itself she has contended that
the suit schedule property had been granted in favour of the
defendant No.1 in the year 1994-1995 and it was only after the
expiry of the non-alienation period of 15 years that the defendants
executed a registered sale agreement dated 03.02.2010 in their
favour. Before the Trial Court, the defendants denied all the
allegations and claim made against them and put forth the
contention that the transaction between the parties is only a loan
transaction and the sale agreement was obtained by way of a
security towards the loan advanced by the property. The said
contentions of the defendants having been negatived by the Trial
Court, the defendants approached the First Appellate Court in the
aforesaid appeal in which they filed the aforesaid application
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
seeking permission to adduce additional evidence by producing a
xerox copy of the grant certificate bearing No.LND.RUO (K)
6/1994-95 dated 19.05.1995. In addition thereto, the appellants
also filed an application under Order XVI Rule 6 CPC seeking
summoning of the records from the Office of the Tahsildar,
Srinivaspura Taluk in relation to the said grant certificate and grant
made in favour of defendant No.1. In the affidavit in support of the
application, the appellants-defendants specifically contended that
the grant was made in favour of the defendant No.1 on 19.05.1995,
which can be established by summoning the original records as
well as by permitting the appellants to lead additional evidence and
if the grant was found to be made on 19.05.1995, the sale
agreement dated 03.02.2010 executed within the 15 years non-
alienation period would not be specifically enforceable at the
instance of the respondent-plaintiff and as such, the said additional
evidence and summoning of records were extremely relevant, vital
and crucial for the purpose of determining whether the respondent-
plaintiff would be entitled to the discretionary and equitable relief of
specific performance. The said applications having been opposed
by the respondent-plaintiff, the First Appellate Court proceeded to
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
answer point Nos.1 and 2 formulated by it against the appellants-
defendants by rejecting the said applications on the ground that
since the appellants were alleged to have executed only a sale
agreement in favour of the respondent-plaintiff and not a sale deed,
the said documents could not be relied upon by the appellants in
support of their claim and the proposed documents were not
relevant for the purpose of adjudication of the issues in controversy
between the parties.
10. In this context, learned counsel for the appellant
submits that if it is found that the suit schedule property was
granted in favour of defendant No.1 on 19.05.1995 coupled with
the undisputed fact that the alleged sale agreement was alleged to
have been executed by the appellants in favour of the respondent-
plaintiff on 03.02.2010 within the 15 years non-alienation period,
the suit for specific performance seeking enforcement of such a
sale agreement would not be maintainable in the light of the
judgment of the Apex court in the case of Narayanamma and
another Vs. V. Govindappa and others -AIR 2019 SC 4654 and
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Sri. T. Annayappa –
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
Dead by his LRs. Vs. Smt. Chinnamma and others – RSA
No.1597/2013 dated 02.04.2024.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent submits
that under identical circumstances in the case of B. S. Lakshman
Vs. Sri. Puttashetty and others – RSA No.1358/2022 dated
27.06.2025 , one more Co-ordinate Bench of this Court has taken a
view that the suit for specific performance in relation to seeking
enforcement of a sale agreement executed, albeit within the non-
alienation period was maintainable.
12. A perusal of the impugned judgments and decrees of
the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court will clearly indicate that
both courts did not have the benefit of the aforesaid judgments
relied upon by both sides, since the aforesaid judgments of the
Apex Court and this Court have been rendered subsequent to the
impugned judgments and decrees of the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court. Be that as it may, the First Appellate Court clearly
fell in error in rejecting the applications filed by the appellants under
Order XLI Rule 27 CPC and Order XVI Rule 6 CPC without
appreciating that in the light of the undisputed fact the alleged sale
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
agreement was alleged to have been executed on 03.02.2010,
coupled with the specific averment in the plaint that the sale
agreement had been executed by the defendants in favour of the
plaintiff after completion of the non-alienation period, the actual
date of grant would be extremely relevant and essential for the
purpose of determining whether the sale agreement had been
executed within the non-alienation period or whether it was
executed after expiry of the non-alienation period and the said
fact/circumstance would have a direct/substantial bearing on the
enforceability or otherwise of the sale agreement relied upon by the
respondents.
13. Under these circumstances, I am of the considered
opinion that the impugned judgment and decree of the First
Appellate Court not only dismissing the appeal but rejecting the
aforesaid applications is clearly erroneous and the same deserves
to be set aside and the matter be remitted back to the First
Appellate Court for reconsideration of the appeal afresh, by
allowing the applications filed by the appellants and to proceed
further in accordance with law.
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
The additional substantial question of law is accordingly
answered in favour of the appellants.
14. In view of the findings recorded by me on the
additional substantial question of law, the question of considering
the substantial question of law Nos.1 and 2 would not arise in the
facts and circumstances of the instant case.
15. In the result, I pass the following:
ORDER
i) The appeal is hereby Allowed.
ii) The impugned judgment and decree dated 01.10.2018
passed in R.A.No.178/2016 by the First Appellate Court is set
aside.
iii) The applications, filed under Order XLI Rule 27 and under
Order XVI Rule 6 CPC filed by the appellants are hereby allowed.
iv) The matter is remitted back to the First Appellate Court for
reconsideration afresh and in accordance with law.
v) The Registry of this Court is directed to transmit the Trial
Court Records of the Trial Court as well as the entire records of the
First Appellate Court together with the applications, under Order
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
XLI Rule 27 and under Order XVI Rule 6 CPC and the
accompanying documents to the First Appellate Court for
reconsideration afresh and in accordance with law.
vi) The First Appellate Court is directed to receive the
documents produced along with the application filed under XLI
Rule 27 CPC and issue summons to the Tahsildar, Srinivasapura
Taluk and secure the records referred to in the said application filed
by the appellants under Order XVI Rule 6 CPC and proceed further
in accordance with law.
vii) Liberty is reserved in favour of the appellants and
respondent to adduce additional oral and documentary evidence in
support of their respective claims before the First Appellate Court.
viii) All rival contentions on all aspects of the matter including
legality, validity, enforceability etc., or otherwise of the sale
agreement dated 03.02.2010 are kept open to be decided by the
First Appellate Court and no opinion is expressed on the
merits/demerits of the rival contentions.
ix) Both parties are hereby directed to appear before the First
Appellate Court on 14.12.2026, without awaiting further notice.
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63605
RSA No. 639 of 2019
CNR: KAHC010094632019
x) The First appellate Court shall reconsider the entire appeal
and dispose of the appeal afresh and in accordance with law,
preferably within a period of six months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this judgment.
Sd/-
(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
BMC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 49