M/S Shri Balaji Agro Industries vs State Of Punjab And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
221-1
CWP-6160-2024
(O&M)
Date of decision: 11.11.2026
M/s Balaji Agro Industries ...Petitioner
VERSUS
State of Punjab and another ...Respondents
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD S. BHARDWAJ
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER MALIK
Present :- None for the petitioner.
Mr. Mohit Kapoor, Sr. DAG Punjab.
Ms. Ridhi Bansal, Sr. Standing Counsel,
for respondent No.2.
*
VINOD S. BHARDWAJ, J. (Oral)
1. The present writ petition challenges the show cause notice
dated 21.11.2023 suspending the registration of the petitioner firm on the
ground of the same having not been decided within the specified time-frame
under Rule 22 of the Central Goods & Services Tax Rules, 2017/Punjab
Goods & Services Tax Rules, 2017.
2. There is no representation on behalf of the petitioner(s).
3. A written statement, by way of affidavit dated 13.08.2024 of
Mr. Bhupinder Jeet Singh, Excise & Taxation Officer-cum-State Tax
Officer, Ward No.10, Patiala, had been filed, wherein it was stated as under:-
“3. That it is submitted the Central Goods and Service
Tax Act 2017 r.w. Punjab Goods and Service Tax Act 2017 is a
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
complete code in order to seek redressal in GST matters and
that petitioner instead of participating in the suo moto
cancellation proceeding initiated under section 29 (2) of the
Punjab Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 have approached the
Hon’ble Writ Court, without exhausting the remedies enshrines
in the statute therefore filing writ petition under article 226/227
of the Constitution of India is not proper where complete
redressal under statute is available.
4. Moreover the order of suspension under section 29 of
the Act 2017 r.w. Rule 21A of the Rules 2017 has been passed by
jurisdiction authority where in Show Cause Notice in Form GST
REG-17 dated 21.11.2023 has been issued to the petitioner as to why
the GST registration should not be cancelled “as the petitioner was
not found at the given address” and the petitioner never filed the
reply to the above SCN on the common portal which is the only
mode of conducting the proceeding under the GST Act. That it is
pertinent to mention here that as per Rule 22 r.w. Rule 26 of the
PGST/CGST Rules 2017 prescribes that reply in Form REG-18 has
to be submitted electronically on the common portal i.e.
www.gst.gov.in as notified under Section 146 of the Act 2017
consequently the reply submitted by any other mode except the mode
or reply discussed above cannot be said to valid submission of reply.
That it is settled principal of law that if the law requires something
to be done in a particular manner, then it must be done in that
manner and if it is not done in that manner, then it would have no
existence in the eye of the law. Now in the present case the
Petitioner has never submitted any reply to the above show cause
notice on the common portal despite of the fact that the Petitioner
counsel was advised by the respondents to file the reply on the
common portal consequently the petitioner stands gets obliterated
that respondents have not decided the SCN despite of ling reply to
the SCN therefore cannot take the shelter of Rule 22(3) r.w. Rule
21A(4) of the PGST Rules 2017.
5. That non prejudice to the above submissions it is
submitted that the time limit prescribed under Rule 22(3) read
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
3
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
with Rule 21A(4) of the PGST Rules 2017 are directory in
nature not mandatory. That it is settled law proposition of law
that the use of work “Shall” to be construed by taking into
consideration the nature, design and consequences, which
would flow from construing it one or the other way hence the
question whether statute is mandatory or directory, would
depend upon the intention of Legislature and not necessarily
merely by looking at the language in which it is clothed. That
in the present case suo-moto cancellation are curative and
precautionary measure being adopted by the revenue
department in order to stop the wrong full availment of bogus
ITC and further passing of bogus ITC by the tax evader. That
GST (being based on the theory of one nation one tax) is a very
dynamic tax regime here, where the ITC flows more swiftly than
the water as it whole process of passing and availment of ITC is
by electronically and has a PAN India replication hence the
movement it comes to the knowledge of the authorities that the
tax evader is availing/passing of bogus ITC then same have to
be stopped immediately. Now the suspension of registration
followed by the cancellation of registration is the immediate
step whereby revenue can stop the further outflow of bogus ITC
the movement the revenue gets the prima facia information of
allegation mentioned is sub-section 2 of section 29 of the PGST
Act 2017. Additionally, it can never be the intention of the
legislature that the tax evader be allowed to evade tax despite
the knowledge of evasion of tax by the tax evader consequently
because the order was not passed either ways within the
stipulated time period mentioned is sub rule 2 of Rule 22 of the
CGST Rules 2017 it would not be deemed to be automatic
revocation of suspension order of registration.
6. That in the present case during course of
investigation the officers of the answering respondent visited
the premises of the petitioner for physical verification and the
petitioner was found to be non-existent leading to the prima
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
4
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
facia view that the petitioner has obtained the registration by
fraud. That during the course of verification of inward Supplies
of Petitioner were verified and were found to be in genuine as
there were bogus inward supplies from firms which were non-
existent or which had been suo moto cancelled by their
concerned jurisdictional authorities under Section 29(2) of the
Act 2017. Following are the detail of bogus firms which were
suo moto cancelled alongwith detail of tax evaded by the
petitioner:-
Financial Year 2018-19
Dealer No. GST No. Amount of Bogus
ITC (Rs.)
R.S. International 07ACFPS7129B1ZO
18,92,414.00
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Financial Year 2019-20
R.S. International 07ACFPS7129B1ZO
9,82,921.00
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Financial Year 2020-21
R.S. International 07ACFPS7129B1ZO
19,41,864.00
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Ruby International 07ABBFR1868DIZA
1,76,342.00
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Total 21,18,206.00
Financial Year 2021-22
Labh Enterprises 07AAJFL109IKIZA
2,45,72,307.00
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Kirti Traders 07BVEPP056P1Z7
1,76,21,929.00
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Tamish Enterprises 07AASFT422D1Z7 34,65,917.00
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
5
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Swastik
07FIAPS1561R2ZL
7,20,000.00
Enterprises
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
R.S. International 07ACFPS7129B13ZM
5,64,838.00
(Suo Moto Suspended)
R.S. International 07ACFPS7129B1ZO
4,60,760.00
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Total 4,74,05,751.00
Financial Year 2022-23
Labh Enterprises 07AAJFL109IKIZA
4,07,08,964.00
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Tamish Enterprises 07AASFT422D1Z7
2,36,61,372.00
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Crown
07BGRPP2502G3ZB
1,97,28,772.00
International
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Swastik
07FIAPS1561R2ZL
39,15,540.00
Enterprises
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Crux Enterprises 07BGRPP2502G2ZC
8,64,180.00
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Crown
07AAQFC4014Q1Z1
7,58,321.4
International
(Suo Moto Suspended)
Kirti Traders 07BVEPP056P1Z7
6,63,110.20
(Suo Moto Cancelled)
Total 9,03,00,259.00
7. That it is pertinent to mention here that the Goods
and Service tax (Value Added Tax) is a value added tax.
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
Accordingly at each stage of the value chain, the tax is payable
only on the value addition at that stage. Though the tax is
payable on full consideration of supply at each stage, the
supplier is allowed to offset tax already paid on the input
supply procurement and thus cash is required to be paid only
on the value added at each stage. It is only logical that the
offset is allowed only for the amount already received by the
Government. Section 16(2) of the CGTS Act, therefore lays
down mandatory requirement for availing ITC. Possession of a
tax invoice or debit note issued by a registered supplier, receipt
of inward supplies and payment of tax charged on such supplies
to the Government are mandatory conditions prescribed for
availing ITC, Payment of tax charged on supplies, of which
credit is sought to be availed, to the Government is thus a very
important conditions for allowing credit. If it is so found that
taxes have not even accrued or have not been paid to the
Government or not received by Government, credit cannot be
granted to taxpayer.
8. That from the above facts it is clear that the
petitioner alongwith some other person are running a web of
bogus firms in order to evade tax by issuing good less bogus
invoices in order to avail and forward ingenuine ITC through
such bogus transactions without paying any tax to the
government Ex-chequer at any stage of the inward supply
chain. Further, same modus operandi of all the firms reflects
the connivance among all above firms to defraud exchequer,
without paying any tax resultantly the above action of
suspension of registration of the respondent is well with the
four corners of law in order to safeguard the interest of the
revenue.”
4. Notwithstanding the specific stand taken by the respondent(s),
it is evident that the provision as enshrined under Rule 22 of the Central
Goods & Services Tax Rules, 2017 read with Rule 26 of the Punjab Goods
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
7
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
& Services Tax Rules, 2017 have been held to be directory in nature. The
‘
Delhi High Court, in the matter of Fayiz Nangaparambil Vs. Union of
India ’ reported as 2024 DHC 2050 (DB), has held that the expression "shall
be passed within 30 days" used in Rule 22(3) of the CGST Rules, providing
a timeline for passing of an order on a SCN issued for cancellation of
registration, is only directory, not mandatory. The authorities would not have
lost the right to pass an order, after the lapse of the period of 30 days from
the filing of the reply. Thus, the star argument of the appellant stands
countered through judicial pronouncement.
5. Even otherwise, the specific case of the respondents in the
written statement filed by them was to the effect that the period commences
from the date of filing of the reply by the person aggrieved and since the
reply has not been filed, hence, in the said circumstances, the said clause
would not become operative.
6. Notwithstanding that the written statement had been filed more
than two years ago, no rejoinder has been filed controverting the assertion
made therein, hence, the submission remains uncontradicted. The stand of
the department thus remains undisputed.
7. Considering it from any angle, the foundation of the case of the
petitioner thus does not seem to carry any weight. It seems that it is for the
said reason that the counsel for the petitioner is not appearing. It is also
evident that the question raised in the petition already stand answered.
Besides, the challenge is only to a Show Cause Notice and no final order had
been passed.
8. In the said circumstances, the present writ petition is disposed
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
8
221-1 CWP-6160-2024 (O&M)
of at this stage with liberty to the petitioner to pursue his remedies before the
statutory authorities.
9. Disposed of with the liberty as aforesaid.
(VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)
JUDGE
(RAVINDER MALIK)
11.11.2026 JUDGE
Mangal Singh
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
MANGAL SINGH
2026.11.18 17:42
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document