Ms Rana Sugars Ltd vs Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle 1, Chandigarh

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court


IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

(1) ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M)

M/s Rana Sugars Limited
.....Appellant
Versus

Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle 1, Chandigarh

.....Respondent



(2) ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

M/s Rana Sugars Limited
.....Appellant
Versus

Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle 1, Chandigarh

.....Respondent


1. The date when the judgment is reserved 05.11.2026
2. The date when the judgment is pronounced 21.11.2026
3. The date when the judgment is uploaded on the 21.11.2026
website
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced
Full
5. The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full Not applicable
judgment, and reasons thereof


CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK SIBAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNISH BINDLISH


Argued by: Ms. Radhika Suri, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Sidhant Suri, Advocate and
Mr. Abhinav Narang, Advocate,
for the appellant (s).

DEEPAK SIBAL, J.

1. This order shall dispose of the aforesaid two appeals as
common questions of law and fact arise therein. The appeals arise out of a
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [2]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

common order dated 04.08.2025 passed by the Income Tax Appellate
Tribunal, “B” Bench, Chandigarh, through which the appeals of the
appellant for the assessment years 2010-11 and 2011-12 (ITA
Nos.512/Chandi/2023 and 513/Chandi/2023), both of which had been
filed with a delay of 1862 days, were dismissed for want of condonation
of delay. For the sake of convenience facts have been extracted from
ITA-104-2026.

2. The appellant company claims to be engaged in the business
of manufacturing sugar, alcohol, spirit and power generation. On
24.09.2010, for the assessment year 2010-11, the appellant filed its income
tax return through which it declared its total income as “Nil”. The case of
the appellant was selected for scrutiny assessment. On 27.06.2012, a
notice under Section 142(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short – the
Act) was served upon the appellant. Thereafter, the company’s Assessing
Officer (for short – the AO) passed assessment order under Section 143(3)
of the Act dated 28.02.2013 making certain disallowances in the
appellant’s case and assessing its total income at Rs.11,45,15,249/-. The
appellant challenged the assessment order dated 28.02.2013 through filing
of a statutory appeal which through order dated 08.05.2018 was partly
allowed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-I, Chandigarh [for
short – CIT(A)]. The order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018 was then
taken up in appeal by the appellant before the Income Tax Appellate
Tribunal “B” Bench Chandigarh (for short – the ITAT) through ITA
No.512/Chandi/2023. Such appeal was filed on 12.08.2023 and there was
a delay of 1862 days in its filing. The application seeking condonation of
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [3]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

such delay was moved by the appellant only on 17.07.2024. The appeal of
the appellant was heard by the ITAT along with the appeal of the Revenue
(ITA No.1048/Chandi/2018), which had been filed in the year 2018 itself
against the very same order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018. The ITAT
was of the view that the delay of 1862 days had not been sufficiently
explained and therefore, on the ground of delay, the said appeal was
dismissed on 04.08.2025. Through the same order, the appeal of the
Revenue was also dismissed on merits. The present appeal is directed
against the order of the ITAT dated 04.08.2025 and seeks to raise the
following questions of law:-

i) Whether the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in law while dismissing the appeal
of the appellant company vide order dated 04.08.2025 on the ground of
inordinate delay in filing the appeal even when the appellant company
has a bonafide case of delay and that it was not due to any negligence
or wilful disregard by the appellant company but was a genuine
oversight and much dependence on professional employees, who
subsequently resigned without informing the management of non-filing
of the appeal against the order of Ld. CIT(A) and hence, making the
management of the appellant company unaware of the same?

ii) Whether the Hon’ble ITAT erred in law in dismissing the appeal of the
appellant company without applying its mind on the issue of
disallowance of Rs. 24,33,125/- made under Section 40 (a)(ia) even
when the total amount of interest paid to the NBFC in A.Y. 2010-11 was
only Rs. 18,49,244/- and not Rs. 24,33,125/- and that the payees have
duly shown the said interest received as income in their balance sheet
thereby not making the appellant company as assessee in default in
terms of Section 201(1) of the Act along with its proviso?

iii) Whether, the Ld. ITAT has erred in law in dismissing the appeal of the
appellant company without applying its mind on the issue of confirming
the addition of Rs. 53,21,407/- made by the Ld. A.O. by restricting the
rate of depreciation to 15% on trucks/tankers even when the same was
eligible for higher depreciation @ 40% as these trucks were used by the
appellant for transporting goods and freight was earned by the
appellant?

SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [4]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)


3. The facts in ITA-106-2026, which pertains to the assessment
year 2011-12, are similar. For the said assessment year, on 27.09.2011, the
appellant filed its return declaring its total income as “Nil”. Through order
dated 28.02.2014 passed under Section 143(3) of the Act, the AO made
certain disallowances and computed the total loss of the appellant at
Rs.46,17,90,109/-. The appeal filed by the appellant against the said
assessment order was partly allowed by the CIT(A) through order dated
08.05.2018. The appellant challenged such order of the CIT(A) before the
ITAT through ITA No.513/Chandi/2023, which too was filed on
12.08.2023 with a delay of 1862 days. The application for condonation of
delay in that appeal was also moved on 17.07.2024 and was based on
grounds identical to those taken in ITA No.512/Chandi/2023. Through the
common order dated 04.08.2025, the ITAT dismissed the said appeal also
on the ground of delay, while the appeal of the Revenue for that year (ITA
No.1049/Chandi/2018) was dismissed on merits. In ITA-106-2026,
question No.(i) is identical to question No.(i) reproduced above, whereas
question Nos.(ii) to (iv) relate to the merits of the disallowance of interest
of Rs.93,92,737/- on account of capitalisation of interest on capital work
in progress under the proviso to Section 36(1)(iii) of the Act, the
disallowance of Rs.18,49,244/- under Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act and the
addition of Rs.32,44,775/- on account of restriction of the rate of
depreciation on trucks/tankers to 15%.

4. Learned counsel for the appellant has been heard.
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [5]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)


5. Our answer to question No.(i) shall determine as to whether
questions Nos.(ii) and (iii) (and question No.(iv) in ITA-106-2026) need to
be opined upon. Therefore, question No.(i) is being taken up first.

6. As per Section 253(3), every appeal under Section 253(1)
and 253(2) of the Act is required to be filed within sixty days of the date
on which the order sought to be appealed against is communicated to the
assessee. In the case in hand the order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018
was sought to be challenged by the appellant through filing of an appeal
before the ITAT. Admittedly, the last date for filing such appeal was
07.07.2018. Since such appeal was filed on 12.08.2023, there was delay of
1862 days in its filing.

7. In the application filed before the ITAT, the appellant sought
to provide “sufficient cause” for the delay of 1862 days in the filing of its
appeal. It was submitted that on 16.02.2018 a search under Section 132 of
the Act was conducted on the premises of the company and that in the year
2019, without handing over charge, since the appellant’s Chief Financial
Officer (Mr. Manoj Gupta) and General Manager (Mr. Pardeep Singhal),
who, owing to the actions of various agencies including SEBI, had started
disengaging themselves from the work of the company, resigned, the
appellant was not aware as to whether any appeal had been filed on behalf
of the company to challenge therein the order of the CIT(A) dated
08.05.2018. The company further submitted that between years 2018 and
2022 the appellant changed its tax consultants three times and that none of
these three consultants identified that through order of the CIT(A) dated
08.05.2018 the company’s appeal had only been partly allowed. It was
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [6]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

only when the present counsel conducted a thorough review it was
revealed that through the order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018 certain
disallowances had been made in the appellant’s case which needed to be
appealed against and accordingly, on 12.08.2023, the appeal was filed
before the ITAT. It was further submitted that the management of the
appellant was too much involved in various other matters like handling
actions by various other agencies. In the said application, the appellant
also stated that against the order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018 the
Revenue had filed a separate appeal which was pending before the ITAT.

8. The explanation offered by the appellant for the delay of
1862 days in filing of its appeal before the ITAT is found to be vague as it
lacks specifics. As per the company, without handing over charge, its
Chief Financial Officer and General Manager resigned in the year 2019
and that they also never informed the management that no appeal has been
filed against the order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018. The respective
dates of resignation of these officers are not forthcoming from the record.
The claim with regard to them not handing over charge is also not backed
by any supporting evidence. No document such as the resignation letters
of these officers or the record of the company accepting their resignations
has been placed on record. The application for condonation of delay, as
appended with the present appeal (Annexure A-3), is in the form of a letter
signed by an authorised signatory of the company and is not accompanied
by any affidavit. Even otherwise, the resignation of these officers in the
year 2019 does not explain the failure of the appellant to file the appeal
within the period of limitation which expired on 07.07.2018, i.e., at a time
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [7]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

when, admittedly, these officers were still in the employment of the
company. The explanation is also not consistent. While before the ITAT
the appellant claimed that a search under Section 132 of the Act was
conducted on the company on 16.02.2018, in the grounds of appeal before
this Court it has been pleaded that on 16.02.2018 a survey under Section
133A of the Act was conducted on the company and a search was
conducted on its management.

9. In its application for condonation of delay the company
further goes on to state that between the years 2018 and 2022 three tax
consultants were changed. No specifics with regard to such “explanation”
is found in the application. It is utterly vague. Neither the names of the
three tax consultants nor the periods during which they were engaged have
been disclosed. Such explanation even otherwise does not account for the
failure of the management of the company itself to ascertain the outcome
of its own appeal before the CIT(A).

10. Explanation for the cause of delay between the year 2022
and the date of filing of the appeal on 12.08.2023 is found completely
missing. The date on which the present counsel/Chartered Accountant was
engaged and the date on which the alleged “thorough review” of the order
of the CIT(A) was conducted have also not been disclosed. Further,
though the appeal was filed on 12.08.2023, the application for
condonation of delay was moved only on 17.07.2024, i.e., after about
eleven more months, for which also no explanation has been offered.

11. Most importantly, the plea of the appellant that its
management remained unaware that its appeal had only been partly
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [8]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

allowed by the CIT(A) stands belied by its own admission. In the
application for condonation of delay, the appellant itself stated that against
the very same order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018 the Revenue had filed
a separate appeal which was pending before the ITAT. Such appeals of the
Revenue for the assessment years 2010-11 and 2011-12 (ITA
Nos.1048/Chandi/2018 and 1049/Chandi/2018) were filed in the year
2018 itself and the appellant was the respondent therein. In the face of
such proceedings arising out of the very same order of the CIT(A),
pending before the ITAT since the year 2018, the appellant cannot be
heard to say that for over five years it remained unaware of the contents of
that order or of the fact that certain additions stood confirmed against it.
Rather, in its application the appellant itself admits that the major portion
of the confirmed addition under Section 36(1)(iii) of the Act was directly
connected with the issue raised in the appeal of the Revenue.

12. Further, the submission that the management of the
appellant was “too much involved in various other matters like handling
actions by various other agencies” leading to the delay in filing of the
appeal before the ITAT shows negligence on the part of the management
of the appellant company to take prompt steps to challenge therein the
order of the CIT(A) dated 08.05.2018.

13. In the light of the above, we find that the explanation offered
by the appellant for the condonation of inordinate delay of 1862 days in
the filing of its appeal before the ITAT lacked diligence. It does not
constitute “sufficient cause”. Therefore, there is no error of fact and law
depicted in the impugned order of the ITAT. Since the ITAT exercised its
SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh

ITA No.104 of 2026 (O&M) [9]
ITA No.106 of 2026 (O&M)

discretion under Section 253(5) of the Act upon consideration of the
explanation offered by the appellant, no question of law, much less a
substantial question of law, arises in this regard.

14. Since question No.(i) has been answered against the
appellant there is no occasion to deal with question Nos.(ii) and (iii) in
ITA-104-2026 and question Nos.(ii) to (iv) in ITA-106-2026.

15. Both the appeals are dismissed.


(DEEPAKSIBAL)
JUDGE



(SUNISHBINDLISH)
JUDGE
21.11. 2026
gk / sunil yadav

Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No

Whether reportable Yes/No

SUNIL YADAV
2026.11.21 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order.
Chandigarh