Dilbagh vs State Of Haryana And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -1-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
118
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND PUNJAB AT CHANDIGARH
1). CRR- 40 -2023 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026
Dilbagh Singh …Petitioner(s)
Vs.
State of Haryana and another …Respondent(s)
2). CRR- 125 -2023 (O&M)
Naveen …Petitioner(s)
Vs.
State of Haryana and another …Respondent(s)
Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice N.S.Shekhawat
Present: Dr. Pankaj Nanhera, Sr. Advocate assisted by
Mr. Sachin Jangra, Advocate,
Mr. Anurag Mor, Advocate and
Mr. Aman Mehta, Advocate
for petitioner in CRR-40-2023.
Mr. Ankur Lal, Advocate
for petitioner in CRR-125-2023.
Mr. Rajinder Kumar Banku, Senior DAG, Haryana .
Mr. VP Sangwan, Advocate, for respondent no.2.
*
N.S.Shekhawat J.
1. This order shall dispose of two petitions i.e. CRR-40-2023, titled
‘Dilbagh Vs. State of Haryana and another’ and CRR-125-2023, titled ‘Naveen
Vs. State of Haryana and another’, whereby the petitioners have challenged the
common impugned order dated 01.12.2022, passed by learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, whereby the petitioners have been ordered to be
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -2-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
summoned as additional accused to face trial under Section 306 IPC, by
exercising the powers under Section 319 Cr.P.C.
2. The FIR in the present case was registered on the basis of the
statement made by Sudhish and the same has been reproduced below:-
“Statement of Sudhish son of Phool Singh caste Jatt, resident of
Datoli, aged about 45-46 years, mobile No. 9050065045, I would
like to state that I resident of above noted address and am labourer
by occupation. We are three brothers. Eldest is Satbir who has
expired, younger to him is Pardeep who is retired from Indian Army
and I am youngest. After the death of Satbir, his wife Satbiro was
married /attached to Pardeep and Satbir has two children, elder is
Kuldeep and younger is Sandeep who are not residing with Pardeep.
Ranbir has retired as teacher. Pardeep and his wife Ranbiro along
with their children are residing in Badrha. We both brother are in
visiting terms to the house of each other and we also know about the
money transactions of each other. My brother Pardep had given Rs.
18,50,000/- to Bheem Singh son of Kishan Lal caste Jatt resident of
Dwarka. My brother has informed me and his nephews many times
in this regard that Bheem Singh is not refunding his amount. In this
regard my brother Pardeep has also filed court case in the courts at
Dadri. I also came to know that my brother has also given
Rs.1,82,000/- to Dilbagh Gignayu and Rs.1,10,000/- to Naveen
resident of Dheerana, due to son of which my brother always
remaining under depression and due to said depression my brother
gone from the house. We were searching him and we also got lodged
case in Police Station Badrha regarding his missing. My brother
Pardeep has committed suicide due to the harassment for not
refunding amount by Bheem Singh son of Kishan Lal, Dilbagh and
Nabeen as well as the threats given by them. Legal action be taken
against them. Statement got recorded, heard, same is correct. Sd/-
Sudhish.
”
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -3-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
3. Learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner has
vehemently argued that from the averments made in the FIR itself, no offence
under section 306 IPC is made out against the present petitioner. In any case,
after registration of FIR, the investigation had commenced and only the suicide
note written by Pradeep, deceased was recovered. After conducting detailed
investigation, the police found that there was no outstanding amount against
both the petitioners and as such their names could not be connected with the
alleged offence. Ultimately, both the petitioners were declared to be innocent in
the present case and challan was only presented against Bhim Singh co-
accused. During the course of trial, the trial Court had recorded the statement of
PW-2 Sudhish, complainant and from his statement as well, it was discernible
that the threats were extended to the deceased by Bhim Singh, co-accused only.
Even, cases were filed only against Bhim Singh and not against the petitioners.
Apart from that, the petitioners had never extended any threats to the deceased,
still PW-2 Sudhish had named both the petitioners as well. After recording his
statement, the prosecution moved an application under Section 319 Cr.P.C. to
summon the petitioners as additional accused in the present case and vide the
impugned order dated 01.12.2022, the petitioners in these two petitions were
wrongly ordered to be summoned by the trial Court. Learned counsel for both
the petitioners further submit that the power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. is an
extraordinary power and should not be exercised in routine. It is thus prayed
that both the present petitions be allowed.
4. On the other hand, learned State counsel, assisted by the counsel
for respondent no.2 - Sudhish, vehemently opposed the submissions made by
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -4-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
the petitioners on the ground that both the petitioners were specifically named
in the FIR as well as the statement of PW-2 Sudhish and specific roles were
assigned to both of them. Pradeep, since deceased, had given a sum of
Rs.1,82,000/- to Dilbagh - petitioner and had also given a sum of Rs.1.10,000/-
to Naveen – petitioner. Even, both the persons were not repaying the loan
amount taken by them despite requests. Even, Pradeep - deceased, used to
remain upset and mentally disturbed due to the said financial transactions and
ultimately he left home without informing anyone. Later, he committed suicide
by hanging himself on a tree near ITI, Loharu and a suicide note was also
recovered by the police and both the petitioners were named in the said suicide
note as well. Thus, the petitioners have been rightly summoned by the Court.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
carefully with their able assistance.
6. While interpreting the power of the trial Court to summon
additional accused under Section 319 Cr.P.C., the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held in the matter of “ Brijendra Singh and others Vs. State of Rajasthan”
2017(3) RCR(Criminal) 374 , as under:-
“9. Powers of the Court to proceed under Section 319 Cr.P.C. even
against those persons who are not arraigned as accused, cannot be
disputed. This provision is meant to achieve the objective that real
culprit should not get away unpunished. A Constitution Bench of
this Court in Hardeep Singh v. State of Punjab & Ors., 2014(1)
RCR (Criminal) 623 : 2014(1) Recent Apex Judgments (R.A.J.) 384
: (2014) 3 SCC 92, explained the aforesaid purpose behind this
provision in the following manner:
"8. The constitutional mandate under Articles 20 and 21 of the
Constitution of India provides a protective umbrella for the smooth
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -5-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
administration of justice making adequate provisions to ensure a
fair and efficacious trial so that the accused does not get
prejudiced after the law has been put into motion to try him for the
offence but at the same time also gives equal protection to victims
and to society at large to ensure that the guilty does not get away
from the clutches of law. For the empowerment of the courts to
ensure that the criminal administration of justice works properly,
the law was appropriately codified and modified by the legislature
under Cr.P.C indicating as to how the courts should proceed in
order to ultimately find out the truth so that an innocent does not
get punished but at the same time, the guilty are brought to book
under the law. It is these ideals as enshrined under the Constitution
and our laws that have led to several decisions, whereby
innovating methods and progressive tools have been forged to find
out the real truth and to ensure that the guilty does not go
unpunished. xx xx xx 12. Section 319 Cr.P.C. springs out of the
doctrine judex damnatur cum nocens absolvitur (Judge is
condemned when guilty is acquitted) and this doctrine must be
used as a beacon light while explaining the ambit and the spirit
underlying the enactment of Section 319 Cr.P.C. 13. It is the duty of
the court to do justice by punishing the real culprit. Where the
investigating agency for any reason does not array one of the real
culprits as an accused, the court is not powerless in calling the
said accused to face trial. The question remains under what
circumstances and at what stage should the court exercise its
power as contemplated in Section 319 Cr.P.C.? xx xx xx 19. The
court is the sole repository of justice and a duty is cast upon it to
uphold the rule of law and, therefore, it will be inappropriate to
deny the existence of such powers with the courts in our criminal
justice system where it is not uncommon that the real accused, at
times, get away by manipulating the investigating and/or the
prosecuting agency. The desire to avoid trial is so strong that an
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -6-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
accused makes efforts at times to get himself absolved even at the
stage of investigation or inquiry even though he may be connected
with the commission of the offence.
10. It also goes without saying that Section 319 Cr.P.C., which is
an enabling provision empowering the Court to take appropriate
steps for proceeding against any person, not being an accused, can
be exercised at any time after the charge-sheet is filed and before
the pronouncement of the judgment, except during the stage of
CRR-2441-2022 and other connected cases ( 8) Section 207/208
Cr.P.C., the committal etc., which is only a pretrial stage intended
to put the process into motion. 11. In Hardeep Singh's case, the
Constitution Bench has also settled the controversy on the issue as
to whether the word `evidence' used in Section 319(1) Cr.P.C. has
been used in a comprehensive sense and indicates the evidence
collected during investigation or the word `evidence' is limited to
the evidence recorded during trial. It is held that it is that material,
after cognizance is taken by the Court, that is available to it while
making an inquiry into or trying an offence, which the court can
utilise or take into consideration for supporting reasons to
summon any person on the basis of evidence adduced before the
Court. The word `evidence' has to be understood in its wider sense,
both at the stage of trial and even at the stage of inquiry. It means
that the power to proceed against any person after summoning him
can be exercised on the basis of any such material as brought forth
before it. At the same time, this Court cautioned that the duty and
obligation of the Court becomes more onerous to invoke such
powers consciously on such material after evidence has been led
during trial. The Court also clarified that `evidence' under Section
319 Cr.P.C. could even be examination-in-chief and the Court is
not required to wait till such evidence is tested on
crossexamination, as it is the satisfaction of the Court which can
be gathered from the reasons recorded by the Court in respect of
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -7-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
complicity of some other person(s) not facing trial in the offence.
12. The moot question, however, is the degree of satisfaction that is
required for invoking the powers under Section 319 Cr.P.C. and the
related question is as to in what situations this power should be
exercised in respect of a person named in the FIR but not
chargesheeted. These two aspects were also specifically dealt with
by the Constitution Bench in Hardeep Singh's case and answered
in the following manner:
"95. At the time of taking cognizance, the court has to see whether
a prima facie case is made out to proceed against the accused.
Under Section 319 Cr.P.C., though the test of prima facie case is
the same, the degree of satisfaction that is required is much
stricter. A two-Judge Bench of this Court in Vikas v. State of
Rajasthan [2013(4) RCR (Criminal) 948 : 2013(6) Recent Apex
Judgments (R.A.J.) 356 : (2014) 3 SCC 321], held that on the
objective satisfaction of the court a person may be "arrested" or
"summoned", as the circumstances of the case may require, if it
appears from the evidence that any such person not being the
accused has committed an offence for which such person could be
tried together with the already arraigned accused persons.
xx xx xx
105. Power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. is a discretionary and an
extraordinary power. It is to be exercised sparingly and only in
those cases where the circumstances of the case so warrant. It is
not to be exercised because the Magistrate or the Sessions Judge is
of the opinion that some other person may also be guilty of
committing that offence. Only where strong and cogent evidence
occurs against a person from the evidence led before the court that
such power should be exercised and not in a casual and cavalier
manner.
106. Thus, we hold that though only a prima facie case is to be
established from the evidence led before the court, not necessarily
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -8-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
tested on the anvil of cross-examination, it requires much stronger
evidence than mere probability of his complicity. The test that has
to be applied is one which is more than prima facie case as
exercised at the time of framing of charge, but short of satisfaction
to an extent that the evidence, if goes unrebutted, would lead to
conviction. In the absence of such satisfaction, the court should
refrain from exercising power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. In Section
319 Cr.P.C. the purpose of providing if "it appears from the
evidence that any person not being the accused has committed any
offence" is clear from the words "for which such person could be
tried together with the accused". The words used are not "for
which such person could be convicted". There is, therefore, no
scope for the court acting under Section 319 Cr.P.C. to form any
opinion as to the guilt of the accused.
(emphasis supplied)"
13. In order to answer the question, some of the principles
enunciated in Hardeep Singh's case may be recapitulated: Power
under Section 319 Cr.P.C. can be exercised by the trial court at any
stage during the trial, i.e., before the conclusion of trial, to
summon any person as an accused and face the trial in the
ongoing case, once the trial court finds that there is some
'evidence' against such a person on the basis of which evidence it
can be gathered that he appears to be guilty of offence. The
'evidence' herein means the material that is brought before the
Court during trial. Insofar as the material/evidence collected by
the IO at the stage of inquiry is concerned, it can be utilised for
corroboration and to support the evidence recorded by the Court
to invoke the power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. No doubt, such
evidence that has surfaced in examination-inchief, without cross-
examination of witnesses, can also be taken into consideration.
However, since it is a discretionary power given to the Court under
Section 319 Cr.P.C. and is also an extraordinary one, same has to
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -9-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
be exercised sparingly and only in those cases where the
circumstances of the case so warrants. The degree of satisfaction is
more than the degree which is warranted at the time of framing of
the charges against others in respect of whom charge sheet was
filed. Only where strong and cogent evidence occurs against a
person from the evidence led before the Court that such power
should be exercised. It is not to be exercised in a casual or a
cavalier manner. The prima facie opinion which is to be formed
requires stronger evidence than mere probability of his
complicity.”
7. Now, I proceed to examine the facts of the present case in the light
of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this Court has to
examine as to whether the power under Section 319 CrPC had been rightly
exercised by the trial Court while passing the order.
8. No doubt, both the petitioners were named by the complainant in
his initial statement and it was alleged that the deceased had given a sum of
Rs.1,82,000/- to petitioner Dilbagh and a sum of Rs.1,10,000/- to petitioner
Naveen. However, both the petitioners did not return the amount of the loan
taken by them to the deceased and he was stated to be depressed due to the said
fact. In fact, the said allegation was investigated by the police and it was found
that there was no evidence to show that Pradeep had extended any loan to both
the petitioners. Rather, it was found that Pradeep - deceased, was having
litigation with Bhim Singh, co-accused and the deceased had not initiated any
legal action before any Court of law or legal forum against both the petitioners.
Even, no complaint was ever made by the deceased against both the petitioners
anywhere and thus both the petitioners were declared innocent during the
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -10-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
course of investigation. Now, during the course of trial, only the statement of
PW Sudhish was recorded, who reiterated the same statement, which was found
to be false during investigation and he could not produce any evidence to
substantiate his version. Except the statement of PW Sudhish, there was no
other material on record, which could impel the trial Court to exercise the
discretionary power under Section 319 CrPC. The trial Court failed to
appreciate that such power has to be exercised sparingly and not mechanically
and the degree of satisfaction should be more than the degree, which is
warranted at the time of framing of charges against others in respect of whom
charge sheet was filed. Only where strong and cogent evidence occurs against a
person from the evidence led before the Court, only then such power should be
exercised.
9. Apart from that, even the Hon’ble Supreme Court has recently held
in the matter of Juhru and others versus Karim and another, (2023)5 SCC
406 and held as under.:-
“16. It is, thus, manifested from a conjoint reading of the cited
decisions that power of summoning under Section 319 CrPC is not
to be exercised routinely and the existence of more than a prima
facie case is sine qua non to summon an additional accused. We
may hasten to add that with a view to prevent the frequent misuse
of power to summon additional accused under Section 319 CrPC,
and in conformity with the binding judicial dictums referred to
above, the procedural safeguard can be that ordinarily the
summoning of a person at the very threshold of the trial may be
discouraged and the trial court must evaluate the evidence against
the persons sought to be summoned and then adjudge whether such
material, more or less, carry the same weightage and value as has
been testified against those who are already facing trial. In the
absence of any credible evidence, the power under Section 319
Cr.P.C. ought not to be invoked”.
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRR-40-2023 (O&M) with -11-
CRR-125-2023 (O&M)
10. In view of the above discussion and the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, both the present petitions i.e. CRR-40-2023, titled
‘Dilbagh Vs. State of Haryana and another’ and CRR-125-2023, titled ‘Naveen
Vs. State of Haryana and another’, are allowed and the common impugned
order dated 01.12.2022, passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani
is set aside, qua both the petitioners.
(N.S.SHEKHAWAT)
16.11.2026 JUDGE
sunil
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
SUNIL
2026.11.19 16:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document