Madurai Farooq Ahmed vs The Principal Secretary To Government, Tamil Nadu Highway And Minor Port Department

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 903
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No.31444 of 2025)

MADURAI FAROOQ AHMED …APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS


THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO
GOVERNMENT & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T

VIKRAM NATH, J.

1. Leave granted.

2. The present civil appeal arises from the judgment
and order dated 25.07.2025 passed by the High
Court of Judicature at Madras in W.P. No. 21364 of
2025 (hereinafter referred to as the “impugned
judgment”), whereby the High Court disposed of the
writ petition preferred by the appellant, who was the
petitioner before the High Court, seeking, inter alia,
directions to the respondents to expedite the
construction of a Limited Use Subway in lieu of Level
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
SONIA BHASIN
Date: 2026.08.21
15:38:11 IST
Reason:
Crossing No. 81 at Vaniyambadi and to complete the
same within a stipulated time frame.
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 1

3. The facts giving rise to the present appeal are as
follows.
3.1. The appellant is a resident of Vaniyambadi in
Tirupattur District, Tamil Nadu. Level Crossing
No. 81 is situated at Vaniyambadi between the
Vaniyambadi and Kethandapatti Railway
Stations. The railway line divides the eastern and
western parts of Vaniyambadi Town and the level
crossing is used by a substantial number of
residents and commuters for movement between
the two sides of the town.
4. The Government of Tamil Nadu, by G.O. (Ms.) No.
272 dated 13.11.2007, granted administrative
sanction for construction of a Road Over Bridge
(hereinafter referred to as “ROB”) in lieu of Level
Crossing No. 81 at an estimated cost of Rs. 13 crores
on a cost-sharing basis with the Southern Railway.
During the subsequent examination of the project, it
was found that construction of the proposed ROB
would require acquisition of a substantial extent of
land in a heavily built-up area and would entail
considerably higher costs. An alternative proposal
for construction of a Road Under Bridge (hereinafter
referred to as “RUB”) was, accordingly, considered.
4.1. In the meantime, the appellant had approached
the High Court in W.P. No. 26319 of 2018 seeking
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 2

commencement of the construction work or
reopening of Level Crossing No. 81 for public use.
During the pendency of those proceedings, the
level crossing, which had earlier been closed, was
reopened for public use. The said writ petition was
ultimately disposed of on 18.07.2023.
4.2. The proposal for construction of the RUB was
thereafter pursued by the State Government and
the Southern Railway. The Government of Tamil
Nadu, by G.O. (Ms.) No. 158 dated 16.12.2019,
approved the change in nomenclature of the
project from an ROB to an RUB. Subsequently, by
G.O. (2D) No. 3 dated 22.01.2021, proceedings
were undertaken for acquisition of the land
required for construction of the RUB under the
Tamil Nadu Highways Act, 2001 (hereinafter
referred to as the “Highways Act”).
4.3. The land acquisition proceedings for the RUB
continued thereafter. The proceedings included
enquiry under the relevant provisions of the
Highways Act and a meeting of the District Private
Negotiation Committee with the affected
landowners. The State Government also accorded
revised administrative sanction towards the cost
of land acquisition.
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 3

4.4. Subsequently, upon further examination of the
project and a joint inspection conducted by the
officials of the State Highways Department and
the Southern Railway, the proposal was modified
once again and a Limited Use Subway (hereinafter
referred to as “LUS”) was considered in place of the
RUB. The revised Land Plan Schedule for the LUS
contemplated acquisition of a reduced area of
approximately 5009 square metres. The alignment
of the LUS was approved and the proposal for
change in nomenclature from the RUB to the LUS
was submitted to the State Government.
4.5. The Government of Tamil Nadu, by G.O. (Ms.) No.
84 dated 15.05.2025, approved the change in
nomenclature of the project from the RUB to the
LUS. The State authorities thereafter initiated
steps for undertaking the requisite land
acquisition proceedings and obtaining the
necessary approvals for construction of the LUS.
4.6. The appellant thereafter preferred W.P. No. 21364
of 2025 before the High Court seeking, inter alia,
a direction to the respondents to expedite the
construction of the LUS and to complete the same
within a stipulated period. The High Court, by the
impugned judgment dated 25.07.2025, noted the
submission made on behalf of the Southern
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 4

Railway that the land acquisition proceedings
were pending with the State Government. The
High Court observed that the relief sought by the
appellant would effectively require it to continue
monitoring the construction of the LUS and
declined to keep the writ petition pending for that
purpose. The writ petition was, accordingly,
disposed of.
4.7. Aggrieved by the disposal of the writ petition
without any specific direction regarding
completion of the project within a stipulated time
frame, the appellant approached this Court by
way of the present appeal.
5. We have heard the appellant, who appeared in
person and the learned counsels appearing for the
respective respondents. During the course of
proceedings before this Court, the respondents
placed on record the current status of the project
along with additional documents and brief notes
detailing the progress made with respect to the land
acquisition proceedings, the approvals obtained, the
tender process, and the proposed time frame for
execution of the respective portions of the work.
6. From the material placed before us, it emerges that
the project has now progressed beyond the stage of
consideration and the authorities have initiated
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 5

steps towards its implementation. The State
Government has clarified that the land acquisition
proceedings are to be undertaken in terms of G.O.
(Ms.) No. 84 dated 15.05.2025. The said decision
was communicated to the concerned land
acquisition authority on 26.02.2026. The State
authorities have also taken steps towards
preparation of the designs, drawings and detailed
quantity estimates for the LUS.
7. Respondent No. 2, Southern Railway, has also
placed a short affidavit on record stating that a
tender has been floated for construction of its
portion of the LUS. It has been stated that seven
bidders participated in the tender process and that
the tender process was expected to be finalised by
the second week of August 2026. Respondent No. 2
has further stated before this Court that, upon
award of the contract and subject to the State
Government making available the requisite land in
the approach portion for casting of the boxes, the
work falling within its domain can be completed
within a period of six months from the date of award
of the contract.
8. The brief note filed on behalf of the State authorities
further records that the tender for the Railway
portion has reached the award stage and that the
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 6

work would commence upon completion of the
award process. The remaining processes on the part
of the State, including the land acquisition and the
preparation and approval of the requisite designs
and estimates for the Highways portion, are also
stated to be underway.
9. In view of the aforesaid developments and the
specific statements placed before us by the
respondents, the controversy has now substantially
narrowed. The project, which has remained under
consideration in one form or another for a
considerable period of almost 20 years, has now
progressed materially towards execution. We take
the aforesaid statements and assurances of the
respondents on record and expect the concerned
authorities to proceed with the remaining steps with
due expedition and in coordination with each other.
10. Before parting with the matter, we consider it
appropriate to place on record our appreciation for
the efforts made by the appellant. The record reflects
that he has consistently pursued the issue
concerning Level Crossing No. 81 and the proposed
grade-separated crossing over several years, not for
any personal benefit, but with the object of securing
relief for the residents and commuters of
Vaniyambadi. He has approached the authorities as
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 7

well as the High Court on more than one occasion
and has continued to pursue the matter until the
project reached its present stage.
11. These days, Writ Courts are frequently called upon
to deal with proceedings styled as public interest
litigations which, on closer scrutiny, do not advance
any genuine public cause. The present matter
stands on a different footing. The appellant has
demonstrated how a vigilant and bona fide citizen
can, through sustained and responsible engagement
with public authorities and constitutional courts,
draw attention to an issue affecting the community
at large. Such constructive civic participation
deserves acknowledgment.
12. In view of the aforesaid subsequent developments
and the definite statements and assurances now
placed before this Court, we are of the considered
opinion that no useful purpose would be served by
keeping the present appeal pending merely for the
purpose of continuously monitoring the execution of
the project. The statements and assurances made
on behalf of the respondents before this Court are
taken on record and shall be duly complied with.
13. The State authorities shall proceed with and
complete the pending land acquisition proceedings
and all other approvals and processes falling within
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 8

their domain with utmost expedition. They shall
ensure that the requisite land is made available to
Respondent No. 2, Southern Railway, without
avoidable delay so that the execution of the Railway
portion of the LUS is not impeded.
14. Respondent No. 2 shall finalise the tender process
within the time indicated before this Court and,
upon award of the contract and availability of the
requisite land, shall ensure completion of the work
falling within its domain within a period of six
months from the date of award of the contract. The
State authorities shall, in the meantime,
simultaneously proceed with the designs, estimates,
administrative approvals and other necessary steps
concerning the Highways portion of the project so
that the work may proceed without any further
avoidable delay.
15. Respondent Nos. 1, 3 and 4, on the one hand, and
Respondent No. 2, on the other, shall file their
respective compliance affidavits before this Court
upon completion of the work falling within their
respective domains and, in any event, within a
period of eight months from the date of this
judgment, setting out the steps taken in compliance
with the directions contained herein. The Registry
C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 9

shall place the compliance affidavits before the
Court upon their filing.
16. The appeal is, accordingly, disposed of in the
aforesaid terms.
17. All pending applications, if any, shall also stand
disposed of.


……………………………………J.
(VIKRAM NATH)


……………………………………J.
(SANDEEP MEHTA)
NEW DELHI
AUGUST 21, 2026




C.A.@ SLP(C) 31444 OF 2025 10