THE BRNACH MANAGER vs KRISHNAPPA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 5023 OF 2013 (MV)
C/W
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.8433 OF 2013(MV-I)
IN MFA No. 5023/2013
BETWEEN:
THE BRANCH MANAGER
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
TH
NO.366/72, 19 MAIN
ST
1 BLOCK, RAJAJINAGAR
BANGALORE - 560 010.
THROUGH REGIONAL MANAGER
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
TH
5 FLOOR, KRISHI BHAVAN
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD,
HUDSON CIRCLE
BANGALORE - 560 001.
…APPELLANT
Digitally signed
by ANUSHA V
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
(BY SRI O MAHESH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. KRISHNAPPA
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
S/O NANJAPPA @ GANGA NANJAPPA
TH
NO.68, 6 CROSS, K.G. NAGAR
MAGADI MAIN ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560 023.
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
2. RADHAKRISHA ADIGA
MAJOR, S/O NAGESH RAO,
NO.5A, BULL TEMPLE ROAD
BASAVANAGUDI,
BANGALORE - 560 004.
(EX-PARTE BEFORE MACT)
…RESPONDENTS
[BY SRI K.SHANTHARAJ, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (AB);
R2 - NOTICE SERVED]
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 23.1.2013 PASSED IN MVC
TH
NO.2825/2011 ON THE FILE OF THE 16 ADDITIONAL JUDGE,
MACT-14, BANGALORE, AWARDING A COMPENSATION OF
RS.1,18,000/- WITH INTEREST @ 6% P.A FROM THE DATE OF
PETITION TILL THE DATE OF PAYMENT.
IN MFA NO. 8433/2013
BETWEEN:
KRISHNAPPA
S/O NANJAPPA @ GANGA NANJAPPA
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
TH
NO.68, 6 CROSS, K G NAGAR
MAGADI MAIN ROAD
BANGALORE - 560 023.
...APPELLANT
[BY SRI SHANTHARAJ K., ADVOCATE (AB)]
AND:
1. UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO., LTD.,
TH
NO.366/72, 19 MAIN,
ST
1 BLOCK,
RAJAJINAGAR,
BANGALORE - 560 010.
2. RADHAKRISHNA ADIGA
S/O NAGESH RAO
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
NO.5A, BULL TEMPLE ROAD
BASAVANAGUDI
BANGALORE - 560 043.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI O.MAHESH, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
R2 - NOTICE SERVED)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 23.01.2013 PASSED IN MVC
NO.2825/2011 ON THE FILE OF THE XVI ADDITIONAL JUDGE,
MACT-14, BANGALORE, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION
FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF
COMPENSATION.
THESE APPEALS ARE COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING , THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
ORAL JUDGMENT
Challenging judgment and award 23.01.2013 passed by
XVI Additional Judge, MACT-14, Bengaluru in MVC
no.2825/2011, these appeals are filed. While MFA
no.5023/2013 is filed by insurer, MFA no.8433/2013 is filed by
claimant.
2. Brief facts leading to these appeals as per claimant
are that at 09:30 p.m. on 24.01.2011, when claimant was
walking by side of BB Road near Green Country School, driver
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
of Car no.KA-05-MF-6666 drove it in rash and negligent
manner and it dashed against claimant. In accident, claimant
sustained grievous injuries and despite treatment, he did not
recover fully and sustained permanent physical disability and
loss of earning capacity. Claiming compensation, he filed claim
petition under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 ( MV
Act ) against owner and insurer of Car. Despite service of
notice, owner did not appear and was placed ex parte . Only
insurer filed objections denying/disputing entire claim petition
averments.
3. Based on pleadings, Tribunal framed following:
ISSUES:
1. Whether the petitioner prove that the injuries
cased in the accident arising out of the use of
the Car bearing Reg.No.KA-05-MF-6666
occurred on 24.1.2011 at about 9.30 P.M.?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to
compensation? If so, how much & from whom?
3. What order?
4. Claimant along with Dr.Ramesh Krishna K., deposed
as PWs.1 and 2 and got marked Exhibits P1 to P14.
Respondents did not lead evidence. On consideration, Tribunal
answered issue no.1 in affirmative and issues no.2 and 3 by
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
assessing total compensation of Rs.1,18,000/- with interest at
6% p.a. and holding insurer liable to pay compensation.
Aggrieved, these appeals are filed.
5. Sri O Mahesh, learned counsel for appellant-insurer
submitted that accident occurred at 09:30 p.m. on 24.01.2011.
Immediately after accident, claimant was taken to Columbia
Asia Hospital. Thereafter to NIMHANS and later shifted to
Victoria Hospital. It was submitted, Ex.P9 - emergency case
record of NIMHANS would note history of injuries as 'alleged
Road Traffic Accident on 24.01.2011 near Kodigehalli by
unknown vehicle'. Even subsequent medical record namely
Ex.P3 - Wound Certificate issued by Victoria Hospital, accident
was stated to have been caused by an unknown vehicle. It was
submitted, in cross examination, PW.1 admitted that Car had
dashed against him from behind and immediately after
accident, he had lost consciousness and came to know
registration number of offending vehicle from Bettappa, who
accompanied him to hospital. It was submitted that said
material would indicate that accident was caused by unknown
vehicle and without any basis, insured vehicle was implicated in
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
collusion with Police. Under similar circumstances, Division
Bench of this Court in MFA no.11443/2006 and connected
matters disposed of on 18.07.2012 had referred to another
Division Bench decision in Smt.Revathi & Anr. v. Smt.Kiran
P Suvarna & Anr. reported in ILR 2010 Kar 5394 held that
in case of delay in filing police complaint each other fact would
require strict examination. It was submitted, complaint was
given on 24.01.2011 i.e., three days after incident by son of
claimant by mentioning insured vehicle number but without
stating particulars or source of information. It was also
submitted that Ex.P6 - Motor Vehicle Inspector's Report would
indicate that insured vehicle was examined only on 08.02.2011.
It was submitted, no police officer was examined or seizure
mahazar of vehicle was produced casting inspection under
cloud and substantiating collusion between claimant and
insured. Despite same, Tribunal failed to notice above facts and
held insurer liable to pay compensation. Therefore, appeal was
filed.
6. None appears for claimant in insurer's appeal.
Respondent no.2 - owner has chosen to remain unrepresented.
There is no representation in claimant's appeal either.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
7. Learned counsel for insurer would oppose claimant's
appeal on same grounds as in his appeal.
8. Heard learned counsel, perused impugned
judgment, award and record.
9. From above, it is seen that both insurer as well as
claimant are in appeal. Insurer is challenging impugned award
on liability on ground of false implication of insured vehicle by
claimant, while claimant is seeking enhancement of
compensation. Therefore, points that arise for consideration
are:
(i) Whether Tribunal was justified in holding
insurer liable to pay compensation?
(ii) Whether assessment of compensation calls for
modification?
Reg. Point no.1:
10. To substantiate actionable negligence against
owner/insurer, claimant relied upon Police records namely, FIR,
complaint, charge sheet, wound certificate, accident spot
sketch, spot mahazar and Motor Vehicle Inspector's Report
marked as Exs.P1 to P6 respectively.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
11. Perusal of complaint would indicate that it is filed by
claimant's son but three days after accident. Ex.P2 would
indeed implicate driver of car having caused accident. Claimant
also relied on medical treatment records. Ex.P9 - Emergency
case record issued by NIMHANS would note in history of
injuries column that accident was caused by unknown vehicle
which is echoed in Ex.P3 - wound certificate issued by Victoria
Hospital. There are no records from Columbia Asia Hospital,
where claimant was taken to immediately after accident.
Admittedly, accident occurred due to Car dashing against
claimant from behind. PW.1, in his cross-examination stated
that immediately after accident, he was unconscious and had
not noted registration number of vehicle, which had caused
accident. Though he stated that particulars of offending vehicle
were disclosed to him by Bettappa, said Bettappa was not
examined. Admittedly, Exs.P3 and P9 - public records are relied
on by claimant himself without any explanation for discrepancy
vis-à-vis police investigation records. Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Oriental Insurance Co.Ltd. v. Premlata Shukla & Ors.
reported in 2007 (13) SCC 476 held that claimant cannot rely
on contents of documents in part while denying remaining.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
When facts and circumstances are considered in cumulative,
suspicion about implication of insured vehicle for purpose of
claim would stand substantiated. While passing impugned
award, Tribunal has merely referred to prosecution records and
held insurer liable to pay compensation. Since finding is without
adverting to entire material on record, it would have to be held
as perverse. Consequently, point no.1 is answered in negative .
12. In view of point no.1 holding false implication of
insured vehicle for purpose of claim, point no.2 would not
survive for consideration.
13. Consequently, following:
ORDER
(i) MFA no.8433/2013 by claimant is
dismissed ;
(ii) MFA no.5023/2013 by insurer is
allowed ;
(iii) Judgment and award dated
23.01.2013 passed by XVI
Additional Judge, MACT-14,
Bengaluru in MVC no.2825/2011,
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62301
MFA No. 5023 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 8433 of 2013
CNR: KAHC010243632013
is set-a side and claim petition
stands dismissed ;
(iv) At request, amount deposited by
insurer is ordered to be
transmitted to Tribunal for
refund.
Sd/-
(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE
AV
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 14