m d patel vs BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

:: 1 :: OA No. 15 of 2024





CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 15/2024

th
Dated this the 18 day of September, 2026.


Reserved On: 10.09.2026
Pronounced On: 18.09.2026



CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

1. M. D. Patel,
Retd. SDE, Godhra SSA, BSNL
Aged 71 years, Male,
Having address at: 201, Evan Flats,
Near Patel saw mill, Lunawada, District: Mahishagar – 389 230.
Present residing at: D- 101, Sharnam Flats,
Near Gada Circle, Harni, Vadodara 390 022.
… Applicant

(By Advocate Mr. Nayan D Parekh)

V/s.

1. Union of India,
Notice to be served through The Secretary,
Department of Telecom, South Block,
New Delhi – 110 001.

2. General Manager, BSNL,
Vadodara Business area,
Ambalal Park, Karelibag, Vadodara. Pin – 390 018.

3. Telecom District Manager,
Now redesignated as Deputy General Manager (OP),
BSNL at Godhra, District Panchmahal. Pin – 389 001.

4. Chief General Manager,
Gujarat Telecom Circle, BSNL
Lal Bungalow, Telephone Bhavan, Ahmedabad. Pin – 380 006.

… Respondents

(By Advocate Ms. R R Patel)
P ANUKUMA

:: 2 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




ORDER

Per: Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed the present Original Application under Section
19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking directions to
the respondents for settlement and payment of his medical
reimbursement claim amounting to ₹11,56,459/-, incurred towards the
treatment of his wife, Smt. Savitaben M. Patel, for brain
haemorrhage/aneurysm at Bhailal Amin General Hospital, Vadodara,
during the period from 02.10.2019 to 20.10.2019 along with interest.
2. Brief facts of the case as stated by the applicant are as under: -
2.1 The applicant is a retired Sub-Divisional Engineer (SDE) of Bharat
Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL), formerly working under Godhra
SSA. The applicant was entitled to medical facilities under the
applicable BSNL Medical Reimbursement Scheme.
2.2 The wife of the applicant, Smt. Savitaben M. Patel, suddenly
developed severe and persistent headache. On medical advice, an
MRI/CT scan was conducted. Upon examination of the scan reports,
the applicant was advised to immediately consult a Neuro Surgeon as
the condition was diagnosed as a case of brain aneurysm/brain
haemorrhage. The Neuro Surgeon advised immediate hospitalization
and surgical intervention, as delay could result in rebleeding and could
be life-threatening. Consequently, Smt. Savitaben M. Patel was
admitted to Bhailal Amin General Hospital, Vadodara on 02.10.2019.
2.3 The medical records placed by the applicant contain the hospital
declaration regarding the emergency nature of the treatment. The
applicant has specifically pleaded that the hospital certified that the
condition to be an absolute emergency and that if left untreated,
bleeding from the aneurysm could become life threatening. She
P ANUKUMA

:: 3 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




thereafter underwent the required surgical procedure and was
discharged on 20.10.2019 in stable condition.
2.4 The material on record shows that the admission was not for routine
or elective medical treatment. The circumstances commenced with
sudden severe headache, followed by diagnostic investigation,
consultation with a Neuro Physician/Neuro Surgeon, identification of
aneurysm/haemorrhage and advice for immediate surgical
intervention. The applicant’s decision to take his wife to the hospital
was, therefore, dictated by medical necessity and the need to prevent a
life-threatening deterioration.
2.5 The respondents have taken the stand that the hospital was not an
empanelled hospital under BSNL. The said fact, however, is not by
itself disputed by the applicant. The applicant’s case throughout has
been that the treatment was taken in compelling and emergent
circumstances and in such circumstances, the restriction relating to an
empanelled hospital could not be mechanically applied.
2.6 Further, on 03.10.2019, immediately after the admission of his wife,
the office of the Telecom District Manager, Godhra addressed a
communication to the Assistant General Manager (Administration),
GMTD, Vadodara, informing the latter that Smt. Savitaben M. Patel
had been admitted in Bhailal Amin Hospital, Vadodara for indoor
treatment on 02.10.2019 and requesting that an officer be nominated
to visit the hospital and submit a visit report. It demonstrates that the
respondent authorities had contemporaneous knowledge of the
treatment and of the hospital where the applicant’s wife was admitted.
2.7 After the treatment, the applicant submitted his medical
reimbursement claim. The claim was submitted before the TDM,
Godhra on 19.11.2019, for an amount of ₹11,56,459/-. The
respondents themselves have admitted the submission of the claim and
the amount claimed. The applicant continued to pursue the matter and
P ANUKUMA

:: 4 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




he submitted a representation dated 18.11.2019 along with the medical
bills and supporting documents in which he explained the
circumstances in which his wife had suddenly developed severe
headache, was diagnosed with brain aneurysm and was advised
immediate admission and surgery.
2.8 In his subsequent representation dated 24.08.2020, he stated that
immediately after admission he had informed the TDM, Godhra and
CAO, Godhra twice during the hospitalisation so that the formal
hospital visit could be made. He further stated that his wife was
discharged on 20.10.2019 and that the medical bill was submitted on
18.11.2019.
2.9 During scrutiny of the medical claim, the CAO (CA), Vadodara, vide
letter dated 10.07.2020, raised certain queries/deficiencies. The
respondents have relied upon the said letter to contend that the
applicant had not furnished a visit certificate, genuineness certificate
regarding emergency treatment, certain countersignatures and other
documents.
2.10 The applicant visited the concerned office on 21.02.2022 and
requested the concerned officers to process the claim further. He
stated that he had already replied to the queries pertaining to him and
that there was no lapse on his part.
2.11 The applicant thereafter made further representations, including
representations dated 25.07.2022, 25.08.2022, 09.11.2022, 10.11.2022
and subsequently in 2023. He also approached the authorities through
the RTI. The record indicates that even after repeated representations
the claim remained pending.
2.12 The applicant’s case was also placed before the Medical Adalat held
on 29.04.2023 at the office of the CGM, Gujarat Circle. The
documents placed on record show that the case was described as
relating to treatment for brain haemorrhage and aneurysm, with the
P ANUKUMA

:: 5 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




amount of the bill stated to be approximately ₹11.56 lakh. Even
thereafter, the applicant addressed a further representation dated
10.10.2023, pointing out that his bill dated 18.11.2019 remained
unpaid despite repeated representations and despite the matter having
been placed before the Medical Adalat. He was informed that the bill
was “under process”.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant has submitted written notes of
arguments and submitted that that the applicant’s wife suffered from
brain haemorrhage/aneurysm, which required immediate medical
intervention, and that the hospital itself had certified the treatment to
be an emergency.
3.1 Learned counsel submitted that the record establishes that the
respondents were informed of the hospitalization immediately. In fact,
the office of the TDM, Godhra itself wrote to the Vadodara office on
03.10.2019 requesting nomination of an officer for hospital visit.
Therefore, any failure on the part of the departmental authorities to
conduct or preserve such visit could not be attributed to the applicant.
3.2 Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant had submitted the
medical bills and relevant medical documents and had thereafter
continuously pursued the matter. The delay of several years was
wholly attributable to the respondents and not to the applicant.
3.3 Learned counsel placed reliance upon the principles laid down in
judicial precedents concerning medical reimbursement, particularly
the decisions relating to treatment taken in non-empanelled/private
hospitals in emergency circumstances. It was submitted that the right
to medical treatment is connected with the fundamental right to life
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India and that medical
reimbursement cannot be denied merely on technical grounds where
the factum of genuine treatment is established.
P ANUKUMA

:: 6 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




4. Per contra, respondents have filed their reply and denied the claim of
the applicant.
4.1 Learned counsel for the respondents submits that the applicant
submitted an indoor medical claim of ₹11,56,459/- for the treatment of
his wife at Bhailal Amin Hospital, Vadodara for the period from
02.10.2019 to 20.10.2019.
4.2 During scrutiny certain deficiencies were noticed and a letter dated
10.07.2020 was issued calling for the required documents. The
respondents contend that the applicant did not submit the visit
certificate, genuineness certificate regarding emergency treatment and
other documents required under the departmental instructions.
4.3 In this regard, the respondents have relied upon the communication
dated 20.12.2012 issued by PGM (Finance), Ahmedabad, according to
which cases of treatment in non-empanelled hospitals were to be
forwarded only where they fell within a genuine emergency category,
such as accident, heart attack or life-saving treatment requiring
immediate hospitalization.
4.4 The respondents have also relied upon the letter dated 06.04.2016,
requiring the distance from the residence to the private non-
empanelled hospital and the distance from the residence to the nearest
empanelled hospital to be specifically indicated.
4.5 Another objection is that the medical card placed on record was dated
24.07.2017 and its renewal copy had not been submitted. They have
further stated that the address mentioned on the medical card was
Lunawada and that the distance from Lunawada to Vadodara was
approximately 130 kilometres.
4.6 The respondents have further stated that a certificate of the General
Manager, Vadodara, concerning treatment in a non-recognised
hospital was eventually mailed on 03.02.2024. Thereafter,
administrative approval was received on 08.03.2024 for processing the
P ANUKUMA

:: 7 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




medical reimbursement, but the amount considered eligible was
restricted to ₹1,28,772/- as per CGHS package rates. Therefore, the
applicant is not entitled to reimbursement of the entire amount of
₹11,56,459/-.
4.7 Learned counsel for the respondents reiterated that the hospital where
the treatment was taken was not empanelled under BSNL and that the
applicant had failed to submit certain documents required for
processing claims relating to non-empanelled hospitals. In view of the
applicable departmental instructions, only genuine emergency cases
could be considered and that the applicant had not produced the
required visit certificate and genuineness certificate. It was further
submitted that administrative approval had subsequently been
obtained and the claim had been considered admissible only to the
extent of ₹1,28,772/- under the applicable CGHS package rates.
5 . Applicant has filed rejoinder and reiterated the submissions made in
the OA.
5 .1 learned counsel for the applicant has cited the following supporting
judgments in support of the prayers sought in this OA:
(i) Order passed by this Tribunal in the matter of SMt. Hansaben
Karan Ghedia & Ors Vs Union of India & Others in OA No. 555/2018
decided on 06.05.2026.
(ii) Order passed by Principal Bench of this Tribunal in the matter
of Zainuddin & Union of India & Others in OA No. 2345/2007
decided on 29.05.2009.
(iii) Order passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Jammu & Kashmir
and Ladakh at Jammu in OWP No. 1726/2015 decided on 28.09.2022.
(iv) Order passed by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the mater of
Smt. Jagir Kaur Vs Union of India and Anr. In W.P. © No.
15460/2023 and
P ANUKUMA

:: 8 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




(v) Order passed by Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal in the
matter of Nitesh Kumar Vs Union of India & Others in OA No.
130/2020.
5.2 Learned counsel for the respondents has cited the judgment passed by
the Principal Bench of this Tribunal in the matter of Jagir Kaur Vs
CGHS in OA No. 592/2022 decided on 05.07.2023.
6 . Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
7 . The following points arises for consideration: -
i Whether the treatment of the applicant’s wife was taken in
circumstances constituting a genuine medical emergency?
ii. Whether the fact that Bhailal Amin General Hospital was not an
empanelled hospital is a valid ground to deny full
reimbursement in the facts and circumstances of the present
case?
iii. Whether the alleged deficiencies relating to visit certificate,
genuineness certificate, medical card renewal and other
departmental formalities can be used against the applicant?
iv. Whether the respondents were justified in restricting
reimbursement to ₹1,28,772/- on CGHS package rate?
v. Whether the applicant is entitled to full reimbursement of Rs.
11,56,459/- and consequential interest?
8. The applicant has consistently stated that his wife developed a sudden
severe headache, underwent diagnostic investigation and was advised
to consult a Neuro Surgeon urgently because the condition involved a
brain aneurysm/haemorrhage with immediate surgery upon admission
because rebleeding could be life-threatening. The hospital records and
declaration placed on record support the applicant’s account and
hospital certified the emergency nature of the condition /treatment.
P ANUKUMA

:: 9 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




The patient was admitted on 02.10.2019 and discharged only after the
necessary treatment on 20.10.2019. More importantly, the
respondents’ departmental record demonstrates that the applicant had
informed the authorities during the hospitalization and the office of
TDM, Godhra requested the Vadodara office to nominate an officer to
visit the hospital. The departmental communication dated 20.12.2012
itself recognizes “life-saving treatment which required immediate
hospitalization” as falling within the genuine emergency category.
9. The next objection of the respondents is that Bhailal Amin General
Hospital was not an empanelled hospital. However, such conditions
cannot be applied in a manner which defeats the very purpose of
medical assistance in an emergency. The applicant’s wife was not
taken to the hospital for convenience or for any non-essential
treatment. At this stage, it is important to mention that the Hon’ble
Apex Court, in the case of Shiva Kant Jha v. Union of India reported
as 2018 (3) SLR 328 (S.C.) has observed as under:
“13. It is a settled legal position that the Government employee during
his life time or after his retirement is entitled to get the benefit of the
medical facilities and no fetters can be placed on his rights. It is
acceptable to common sense, that ultimate decision as to how a patient
should be treated vests only with the Doctor, who is well versed and
expert both on academic qualification and experience gained. Very
little scope is left to the patient or his relative to decide as to the
manner in which the ailment should be treated. Specialty Hospital are
established for treatment of specified ailments and services of Doctors
specialize in a discipline are availed by patients only to ensure proper,
required and safe treatment. Can it be said that taking treatment in
Specialty Hospital by itself would deprive a person to claim
reimbursement solely on the ground that the said Hospital is not
included in the Government Order. The right to medical claim cannot
be denied merely because the name of the hospital is not included in
the Government Order. The real test must be the factum of treatment.
Before any medical claim is honoured, the authorities are bound to
ensure as to whether the claimant had actually taken treatment and
the factum of treatment is supported by records duly certified by
Doctors/Hospitals concerned. Once, it is established, the claim cannot
be denied on technical grounds. Clearly, in the present case, by taking
a very inhuman approach, the officials of the CGHS have denied the
grant of medical reimbursement in full to the petitioner forcing him to
approach this Court.”
10. Further, regarding the absence of a visit certificate, the record contains
the communication dated 03.10.2019 issued by the TDM, Godhra to
P ANUKUMA

:: 10 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




the Vadodara office specifically requesting that an officer be
nominated to visit the hospital and submit a visit report. The applicant
informed his department about the hospitalisation. If the departmental
officer did not visit the hospital despite the communication dated
03.10.2019, the applicant cannot be penalised for the omission on the
part of the department.
11. As regards to the genuineness of the certificate, we find that the
genuineness of the underlying treatment is substantially established by
the hospital records, medical documents, payment receipts and the
departmental communication acknowledging the hospitalization. The
respondents themselves have not disputed that the applicant’s wife
was actually admitted in Bhailal Amin General Hospital from
02.10.2019 to 20.10.2019. Indeed, the respondents have processed the
claim and have subsequently granted administrative approval for
processing reimbursement, although restricting the amount to
₹1,28,772/-.
12. The respondents have not disputed that the applicant’s status as a
retired BSNL employee or the fact that the medical claim was
submitted under the BSNL medical reimbursement scheme. The
question of the validity/renewal of the medical card is an
administrative matter subject to verification of the departmental
records. It cannot be used as a substitute for examining the actual
medical emergency and the genuineness of the expenditure.
13. The treatment took place in October 2019. The medical bill was
submitted in November 2019. The department raised queries in July
2020. The applicant continued to pursue the matter thereafter through
several representations in 2020, 2022 and 2023. His case was also
placed before the Medical Adalat on 29.04.2023, where he was
informed that the bill was under process. Ultimately, the respondents
themselves obtained a certificate concerning treatment in the non-
recognised hospital in February 2024 and administrative approval on
P ANUKUMA

:: 11 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




th
08 March 2024 restricting the amount to CGHS package rate to Rs.
1,28,772/- against the claim of Rs. 11,56,459/-. The judgment passed
by the Principal Bench of this Tribunal in the matter of Jagir Kaur Vs
CGHS in OA No. 592/2022 decided on 05.07.2023 cited by the
respondents will not be applicable in the present case as the facts are
different in this case.
14. In our view, such prolonged delay is inconsistent with the object of a
medical reimbursement scheme, particularly where the beneficiary is a
retired employee who had already incurred the expenditure from his
own resources.
15. In the present case, there is no material placed before us to establish
that the applicant chose an expensive non-empanelled hospital despite
availability of immediate and appropriate treatment elsewhere. On the
contrary, the record shows that the applicant’s wife was suffering
from a serious neurological condition, that immediate surgery was
advised and the applicant informed the department of the
hospitalization while the treatment was continuing.The applicant’s
medical bills are supported by hospital records and payment receipts.
The record contains actual payment receipts issued by Bhailal Amin
General Hospital on different dates during the period of
hospitalization, demonstrating that expenditure was in fact incurred.
The respondents have not placed before us any material to
demonstrate that the treatment was fictitious, unnecessary and
fabricated. The respondents have therefore failed to establish a legally
sustainable basis for restricting the applicant’s genuine emergency
medical expenditure to ₹1,28,772/-.
16. In view of the above reasons, the OA stands allowed with following
directions:
(i) Respondents are directed to process and release the applicant’s
medical reimbursement claim for the treatment of his wife, Smt.
Savitaben M. Patel, for the period 02.10.2019 to 20.10.2019, of
P ANUKUMA

:: 12 :: OA No. 15 of 2024




Rs.11,56,459/-, after deducting any amount if already paid towards the
said claim;
(ii) Respondents are further directed to complete the aforesaid
exercise and release the admissible amount to the applicant within a
period of 90 days from the date of receipt of certified copy of this
order.
17. There shall be no order as to costs. MA pending if any, also stands
disposed of.


(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)

//Anu//
P ANUKUMA