M.K.Peer Mohammed, vs Selvanayaki,

Court
Madras High Court

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Date of Reserved 30/10/2026
Date of Pronounced 12/11/2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MS JUSTICE R.POORNIMA
CRP(MD) NO. 2529 of 2023
{CNR: HCMD011062862023}

Case QR
and
CMP(MD)No.13120 of 2023
M.K.Peer Mohammed :Petitioner/Petitioner/Plaintiff
Vs.
Selvanayaki : Respondent/Respondent/
Defendant
Prayer:- This Civil Revision Petition is filed under Article 227 of
Constitution of India, against the fair and decreetal order, dated
26/06/2023 made in IA No.4 of 2022 in OS No.315 of 2021 on the file of
the Principal Sub Court, Tirunelveli.
For Petitioner : Mr.H.Lakshmi Shankar

For Respondent : Mr.G.Prabhurajadurai

1/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
O R D E R
This Civil Revision Petition has been filed seeking to set aside the
fair and decreetal order, dated 26/06/2023, passed in I.A No.4 of 2022 in
O.S No.315 of 2021 on the file of the learned Principal Sub Court,
Tirunelveli.
             2.The petitioner is the plaintiff in O.S No.315 of 2021, filed
against the respondent/defendant seeking a declaration of title over the
suit property and consequential relief of permanent injunction. During the
pendency of the suit, the petitioner filed I.A No.4 of 2022 seeking
appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to survey and measure the
suit property with the assistance of a qualified surveyor. The said petition
was dismissed by the Trial Court. Aggrieved by the same, the present
Civil Revision Petition has been filed.
  3.The petitioner states that he traces his title to an extent of 10
acres and 40 cents in Survey No.64, which originally belonged to one
Veeraputhira Thevar. The said property was subsequently inherited by his
son, Kaalamuthu Thevar, and thereafter, it was inherited and alienated by
various persons. Subsequently, one Nazeemabeevi purchased the property
2/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
and, thereafter, Sulthana and Asaraf Nisha purchased the same from the
said Nazeemabeevi on 14/06/2007. Thereafter, the plaintiff purchased the
property from the said purchasers on 04/04/2008 under Document
No.3312 of 2008. Subsequently, patta was granted in favour of the
plaintiff on 18/11/2009. The defendant filed a written statement claiming
title over the suit property stating that the property originally belonged to
Veeraputhira Thevar and his brother Madasamy Thevar by virtue of three
documents, viz., Document Nos.233 of 1903, 2839 of 1912 and 2872 of
1922. The defendant further contended that the said Veeraputhira Thevar
died issueless and therefore, his brother Madasamy Thevar inherited the
property. Thereafter, the property devolved upon his sons, namely,
Nallakannu Thevar and Sudalaikanny Thevar, and subsequently upon
their respective sons, namely, Sangu Thevar and Issakki Thevar.
Ultimately, the property devolved upon the daughters of Sangu Thevar
and Issakki Thevar, namely, Pechiammal and Sudalaivadivul. According
to the petitioner, the defendant is tracing her title in respect of a different
property, though she claims the same to be the suit property. Therefore,
according to the petitioner, it is necessary to identify and measure the suit
property with the assistance of a qualified surveyor. The petitioner further
relied upon the proceedings in O.S.No.197 of 2008 and O.S.No.362 of
3/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
2012, contending that the property was already the subject matter of
litigation in the said suits and that the defendant had succeeded therein.
According to the petitioner, the properties involved in the said suits are
entirely different from the suit property in the present suit. Therefore, in
order to establish the identity and distinguish the properties, the petitioner
sought appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to inspect and
measure the properties with the assistance of a Government Surveyor and
to submit a report regarding the nature, boundaries and extent of the suit
property.
  
         4.The petitioner further contended that since the
respondent/defendant had stated that it was the duty of the plaintiff to
establish that the property involved in O.S No.362 of 2012 is different
from the suit property in the present suit, the appointment of an Advocate
Commissioner would be necessary to identify and distinguish the
properties. However, the Trial Court dismissed the petition on the ground
that the suit property is stated to be only to an extent of 5.04 cents,
whereas the property claimed by the defendant is stated to be an extent of
3 acres, and that surveying both the properties would cause confusion.
4/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
According to the petitioner, the very purpose of seeking appointment of
an Advocate Commissioner is to identify and distinguish the respective
properties and therefore, the said reasoning of the Trial Court is
erroneous and unsustainable.
          5.In support of his contentions, the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner relied upon the following decisions:-
(i)In Ponnusamy Pandaram Vs. The Salem Vaiyappamalai
Jangamar Sangam, rep. by its President, Palanivel, reported in AIR
1986 Mad 33 , wherein it has been held in paragraph 8 as follows:- 
“ 8.Coming to the question as to whether, on the
basis that the order passed by the Court below is a
case decided, there is a warrant for interference within
the meaning of S. 115 of the. Code, I find that it is so. A
controversy, as we could see from the pleadings, has
arisen as to whether the constructions put up by the
third defendant are within his land or whether they
have encroached into the lands of the plaintiff. A local
investigation is the best way to find out the position
and the party, namely, the third defendant coveting to
place the evidence before the court through local
investigation by the Commissioner cannot be shut out
of that right. A misconception has weighed in the mind
5/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
of the Court below when it reasoned that there is no
dispute about the ownership of S. No. 289/1 by the
third defendant. That is I not the point in issue,
Shutting out the evidence which a party is entitled to
place before Court to substantiate his case, definitely
decides that right 6f the party, adversely against him
and in this view, the order passed by the Court below
is a 'case decided' and apart from that, on merits the
order passed by the Court below comes within the
mischief of the ratio adumbrated in S. 115 of the Code.
There has been a failure to exercise jurisdiction vested
in it by the, Court below to a patent misconception of
the position and this obliges me to interfere in
revision.”  
(ii)In C.B.Manokaran Vs. P.Valli and others , reported in 2021
Supreme (Mad) 813 , wherein it has been held in paragraphs 18 and 19
as follows:-
“18.In Sivagurunathan Vs. Ramalingam and
Others reported in (2005) 3 MLJ 525, it had been held
as follows:- “12.When the controversy between the
parties is about the area of the land or the identification
or the location of the land, local investigation by a
commissioner is necessary. It would clarify the location
and extent in which the plaintiff is in possession and
6/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
would explain any doubtful points on the evidence on
record. When there is a dispute over the extent,
measuring of the suit property with the help of surveyor
and the plan thereon would considerably reduce the
oral evidence. The object of local investigation is to
obtain evidence which could be based on only from the
spot and the inspection. Report of the advocate
Commissioner would enable the Court to properly and
correctly understand and assess the evidence on record
in resolving the contentious points.”
19.It is seen that even in the instant case, a real
dispute had arisen, in view of the fact that the plaintiff
claims that Chellammal sold 16,000 sq.ft., in
S.No.73/50 to T.D.Purushothaman. However, after his
death, the legal representative of T.D.Purushothaman
had conveyed to the 4th defendant the lands in
S.No.73/48 measuring 17.5 cents which the plaintiff
claims to the ancestral property of Chellammal.
Therefore, there is an issue which had arisen which
requires elucidation and this is local in character and
can only be done by local investigation at the spot. The
assistance of a Taluk Surveyor would certainly clear the
doubt whether the property conveyed to the 4th
defendant was S.No.73/48 or 73/50. It can be easily
verify by looking to the boundaries found in the
documents of sale namely, the Documents registered as
7/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
Doc.No.467 of 1996 dated 11.04.1966, Doc.No.1917 of
1967 dated 06.12.1967 and Doc.No.1828 of 2011 dated
10.03.2011. Identification of the property can only be
done by a Taluk Surveyor and the presence of an
Advocate Commissioner would only give further
authenticity. This would certainly help the learned
District Munsif to give a fair judgment with respect to
the issues raised in the suit. It is no doubt true the
application had been filed at a late stage. However, the
report of the Advocate Commissioner would certainly
not affect the existing evidence already recorded and let
in by the parties. The Advocate Commissioner is only
an officer of the Court.
H e is an extended arm of the Court. The Advocate
Commissioner is certainly not appointed to collect the
evidence but only for elucidating matters in dispute. The
local investigation is the best way to find out the
possession and to fix the identity of the property which
had actually been sold. Though Commissioner cannot
decide the dispute, his inspection and report would help
the Court in deciding the dispute.”
(iii)In Rukmani and four others Vs. A.S. Chinnaiah , reported in
2002 (5) CTC 104 , wherein it has been held in paragraphs 2 and 4 as
follows:-
8/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
“(2)The petitioner herein filed an application for
appointment of Advocate Commissioner before the trial
Court and the same came to be dismissed on two
grounds: (1) The petition is highly belated and (2) that
if an Advocate Commissioner is appointed, he has to
seek the help of the Village Administrative Officer, the
Surveyor and almost in all the cases, the Advocate
Commissioner complaints that the Revenue
Department, more psrticularly the survey department is
not co-operating in carrying out the survey and also
refuse to bring the field measurement book, village
accounts, etc., inspite of the fact that the said situation
has already been brought to the notice of the higher
officials concerned.
4.With regard to the apprehension of delay,
which could possibly be caused by Revenue/Survey
Department as perceived by the Tríal Court, we cannot
ignore the observation. But, that cannot be the reason
to deny the opportunities to the parties, by dismissing
the petition. The trial Court feels that the Revenue
Department is not co-operating with the Court to carry
out survey work, which would delay the disposal of the
suit. It is a common knowledge that many suits are
pending for want of the report of the Advocate
Commissioner and especially in partition suits, final
decree could not be passed for several months and
9/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
years also, as reports not filed. The Advocate
Commissioner is not able to file the report, as they are
not able to secure the help of Survey Department to
carry out the survey/division. The Revenue Department
is expected to render all necessary help and assistance
to Court and if the said assistance is not forthcoming, it
is not as if, the Court is helpless. Advocate
Commissioner is an Officer of the Court and he is
entitled to have all the assistance from the
Revenue/Survey Department, with regard to survey.
That in order to alleviate the difficulties, experienced
by the Trial Courts, the following directions became
necessary.  
           6.Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondent/defendant submitted that, according to the petitioner, the suit
property is a house plot formed as per an approved layout and the extent
of the suit property is only 5.04 cents. Though the petitioner claims to
have traced his title through his predecessors in title, he has not clearly
stated the particulars of the vendors through whom he derived title. It is
further submitted that when the petitioner claims the property under an
approved layout, there is no necessity to appoint an Advocate
10/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
Commissioner to measure the property, as the said issue is a matter to be
established by evidence.
 
7.The learned counsel for the respondent further submitted that it is
for the plaintiff to produce the relevant title deeds and establish his title.
According to the respondent, the petitioner cannot seek to establish his
title by obtaining a Commission. It is further submitted that the petitioner
has disputed the title claimed by the defendant and, therefore, the issue
relating to title has to be decided on the basis of the documentary and oral
evidence adduced by the parties. The learned counsel therefore submitted
that the order passed by the Trial Court is proper and does not call for any
interference by this Court.
          8.Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and the
learned counsel appearing for the respondent and perused the materials
available on record.
11/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
          9.The petitioner claims to have purchased an extent of 5.04 cents of
land situated in Survey No.64/1B1, which is stated to be a house plot
formed under an approved layout situated at Melapalayam Village,
Palayamkottai Taluk, Tirunelveli District. On the other hand, the
defendant claims title over a larger extent of property and states that she
purchased the same under a sale deed dated 09/08/2021. According to the
defendant, the property is an agricultural property and the original
purchaser was one Madasamy Thevar, who purchased the property under
three documents, namely, Document Nos.233 of 1903, 2839 of 1912 and
2872 of 1922. Subsequently, according to the respondent/defendant, the
property devolved upon the daughters of Sangu Thevar and Issaki
Thevar, who are stated to be the descendants of Madasamy Thevar, the
brother of the original owner, Veeraputhira Thevar, who died intestate
and issueless, leaving behind his brother as his sole legal heir.
          10.Thus, the dispute between the parties is essentially with regard
to the title and identity of the property. The petitioner now seeks
appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to measure the property in
Survey No.64/1B1 and also to identify the property which was the subject
matter of O.S.No.362 of 2012, with the assistance of a qualified surveyor.
12/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
             11.The petitioner has relied upon various judgments relating to
disputes regarding boundaries, identification of properties and fixing of
boundary stones. However, in the present case, the main dispute between
the parties is with regard to the title to the property. The plaintiff has to
establish his title on the basis of the relevant title deeds and revenue
records. The appointment of an Advocate Commissioner cannot be
resorted to for the purpose of collecting evidence or for tracing the title of
a party through measurement of the property.
            12.In the present case, the petitioner is required to establish his
title and the identity of the property on the basis of the documents relied
upon by him. The mere appointment of an Advocate Commissioner and
measurement of the property cannot establish the title claimed by the
petitioner. Therefore, this Court is of the view that the Trial Court has
rightly dismissed I.A.No.4 of 2022 and the said order does not warrant
any interference by this Court.
          13.In the result, this Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No costs.
13/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
Consequently, the connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
12/11/2026
Index:Yes/No
Internet:Yes/No
er
To,
1.The Principal Sub Court, Tirunelveli.
2.The Section Officer, VR/ER Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court,
Madurai.
14/15
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )

R.POORNIMA.,J
er
order made in
CRP(MD)No.2529 of 2023
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:00:07 pm )