Mannat Kaur Aulakh vs Union Of India And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-15837-2026
- 1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
201
CWP-15837-2026
Mannat Kaur Aulakh
... Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and others
... Respondents
Judgment
Reserved
on
Judgment
Pronounced
on
Judgment
Uploaded
on
Whether only
the operative
part of the
judgment is
pronounced
Whether the
full judgment is
pronounced
31.10.2026 12.11.2026 12.11.2026 No Yes
CORAM:- HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUVIR SEHGAL
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH GAUR
Present: Ms. Ridhi Bansal, Advocate,
Mr. Sagar Ratusaria, Advocate,
Ms. Sidhi Bansal, Advocate,
Mr. Aditya Bansal, Advocate and
Mr. Kartik Patial, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Ms. Geeta Singhwal, Senior Panel Counsel - UOI
for respondents No.1 and 2.
Mr. Karan Bhardwaj, Advocate
for respondents No.3 and 4.
SUVIR SEHGAL, J.
1. Petitioner has approached this Court, inter alia , for
issuance of a writ of certiorari quashing Clause 18.7 (a) (iii) of the Prospectus,
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 2-
P2, issued by the Army Institute of Law, Mohali for the academic session
2026-27, to the extent it prescribes discharge/release after a minimum of 10
years of service as a condition precedent for a ward of an ex-serviceman to be
eligible for admission to the Army Institute of Law (AIL). A consequential
direction has been sought to treat petitioner as eligible under the category of
ward of ex-serviceman/ex-Army personnel and to consider her candidature for
admission to the Five – year B.A. LL.B./B.Com. LL.B. course in AIL for
academic session 2026-27.
2. Facts, in brief, may be noticed. Petitioner is the daughter
of Major Manmohan Singh Aulakh, who was commissioned in the Indian
Army as a Short Service Commissioned Officer on 04.09.1999. After
completion of initial 5 years, he was granted extension of service, but during
the extended period, he sought release from Army, which was granted w.e.f.
27.05.2008. Petitioner's father rendered approximately 8 years and 8 months of
service. Release certificate dated 02.11.2010, Annexure P1, reflects that he
was released on his own request during extended tenure of Short Service
Commission. AIL – respondent No.4 issued Prospectus, Annexure P2, for
admission to various courses, including, Five – year B.A.LL.B./B.Com.LL.B.,
for the academic session 2026-27. Clause 18.7 provides the eligibility criteria
for wards of dependents of ex-servicemen. Sub-Clause (a) (iii), thereof,
provides that children of ex-serviceman, who had been discharged or released
after 10 years of service, would be eligible to apply for admission to the
various courses.
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 3-
3. Counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
eligibility condition creates an artificial classification amongst ex-servicemen
by excluding those, who had rendered less than 10 years of service
notwithstanding their recognition as ex-servicemen. It has been argued that
this classification has no rationale or nexus with the object of providing
educational facilities to the children of defence personnel and is violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution. Reference has been made by counsel upon the
policies of the Panjab University as well as the University of Delhi, which
recognises the wards of ex-servicemen without prescribing any minimum
period of service. Counsel has placed reliance upon Deepak Sibal Versus
Panjab University and another (1989) 2 SCC 145 and Army Institute of
Higher Education Versus State of Punjab and others 2007(7) SCT 467.
4. Petition has been contested by respondents No.3 and 4 by
filing a joint written statement. A preliminary objection has been taken to the
effect that the writ petition is not maintainable against the aforesaid
respondents as AIL is an unaided private institution established by the Army
Welfare Education Society (AWES), which has been registered under the
Societies Registration Act, 1860. It has been stated that AWES is running 34
Army schools and 12 professional colleges, including respondent No.4,
throughout the country. Expenses for running the institutes are met from the
Army Welfare Fund and no financial aid is received from the government.
Defending the criteria, aforesaid respondents have taken a stand that the policy
of excluding wards of ex-serviceman, who have rendered less than 10 years of
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 4-
service, was taken keeping in view the limited number of available seats as
well as peculiar hardships and disadvantages faced by families of long serving
armed forces personnel. It has been submitted that the minimum qualifying
service for granting admission benefits has been extended to the wards of
Army, Navy, Air Force personnel uniformly across all categories of serving
personnel and it is based on an objective consideration. Still, further, it has
been submitted petitioner’s father had moved a representation, in anticipation,
on 04.09.2025, Annexure P11, which was rejected on 10.02.2026. A writ
petition (CWP No.10732 of 2026) was filed challenging the aforesaid
communication, which was withdrawn on 09.04.2026 with liberty to file a
fresh petition.
5. Counsel for respondents No.3 and 4 has urged that AWES
is not an authority or instrumentality of the State within the meaning of Article
12 of the Constitution of India and writ petition is neither maintainable against
it nor against the AIL. It has been argued that the policy of excluding wards of
ex-servicemen, who have rendered less than 10 years of service is based on an
objective rationale, which has been sought to be achieved by granting benefit
to the wards of long-service officers and it does not infringe Article 14 of the
Constitution as it is applicable to all the three wings of the defence forces. Still
further, it has been submitted that the petitioner’s father was discharged on
27.05.2008, during the extended tenure of short service commission owing to
his selection in the Punjab Civil Services (PCS) and his daughter, petitioner
herein, was born on 10.11.2008 after he had left the Indian Army. An assertion
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 5-
has been made that petitioner cannot be said to have adversely suffered
because of the service conditions of her father. Counsel has placed reliance
upon G. Beena Versus A.P. University of Health Sciences, Vijayawada and
others, A.I.R. 1990 Andhra Pradesh 247 and Kohal Sharma (minor) Versus
Union of India and others, A.I.R. 2005 Punjab and Haryana 67 .
6. We have heard counsel for the parties and considered their
rival contentions besides examining the documents relied upon by them.
7. Before examining the merits, it is necessary to deal with
the objection regarding maintainability of the petition. This issue is no longer
res integra . While dealing with the admission criteria of AIL, a Division
Bench of this Court in Kohal Sharma's case (supra) held that even though an
institution is privately established and not receiving any financial assistance
from the government, but as it is performing public function of imparting legal
education, a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is maintainable
against it. The primary objection, raised by the contesting respondents, is
outrightly rejected.
8. The principal question that arises for consideration in this
petition is as to whether the prescription of a minimum period of 10 years of
service for extending the benefit of admission under the Army category to the
wards of ex-servicemen, who have taken discharge or release from service, is
discriminatory or violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The
restriction of a minimum 10 years of service has been laid down in Clause
18.7(a), which deserves to be noticed and is reproduced here under:
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 6-
“ 18.7 Common Eligibility Criteria for Wards of Dependents of
IA, IN and IAF Personnel.
(a) The applicants must fall into one of the following
categories for admission to Army Professional
Colleges/Institutions:-
(i) Children of serving personnel with a minimum of 10 years
of continuous service in IA/IN/IAF to submit Certificate No.I/V/VI
as applicable .
(ii) Children of IA/IN/IAF ex-servicemen (ESM) granted
regular pension, liberalized family pension, family pension or
disability pension at the time of their superannuation, demise,
discharge, release medical board/invalided medical board. This
includes Children of recruits medically boarded out and granted
disability pension to submit Certificate No.I/V/VI as applicable .
(iii) Children of IA/IN/IAF ESM who have taken
discharge/release after ten years of service to submit Certificate
No.I/V/VI as applicable .”
9. A perusal of the above reproduced clause reveals that
separate eligibility criteria have been prescribed for children of serving
personnel, children of ex-servicemen receiving specified categories of pension
and children of ex-servicemen, who have taken discharge or release from
service after completing 10 years of service. Wards of ex-servicemen, are
required to fill in the prescribed certificates. A specific stand has been taken by
the contesting respondents that petitioner has failed to furnish the required
certificate, even though she appeared in the examination for admission to the
LL.B. course under an interim order passed by this Court. Concededly,
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 7-
petitioner's father has put in less than 10 years of service and does not satisfy
the relevant eligibility conditions. Examining the relevant provisions of the
prospectus issued by AIL for session 2004-2005, a Division Bench of this
Court in Kohal Sharma's case (supra) held that an applicant seeking
admission under a particular reserved category must satisfy the conditions
prescribed for that category and produce the eligibility certificate. The
eligibility criteria cannot be enlarged merely by adopting a wider interpretation
of the expression used in the prospectus. As petitioner's father does not possess
the requisite service, petitioner cannot be considered to be eligible under the
prospectus issued by AIL for the current academic session.
10. A somewhat similar provision came up for consideration
before a Full Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in G. Beena's case
(supra) The question considered by the Full Bench was ‘whether the rules of
admission specifying length of service and/or prescribing preference based
on length of service for purposes of claiming admission in the quota
reserved for children of ex-servicemen, are arbitrary and violative of Article
14 of the Constitution of India?’ Full Bench was called upon to examine the
constitutional validity of admission rules prescribing different lengths of
military service for extending the benefit of reservation or preference to the
wards of ex-servicemen. After examining the object underlying the reservation
and the classification so made, Full Bench upheld the validity of the
conditions. It was observed that the authority providing benefit of reservation
or preference is entitled to prescribe reasonable conditions for availing that
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 8-
benefit. It was held that prescription of a particular length of service is
primarily a matter for the competent rule-making authority. In exercise of
judicial review, Court is not expected to sit in appeal over the wisdom of such
policy and cannot substitute its own assessment merely because another view
is possible. In particular, it is apposite to reproduce the following observations
of the Full Bench:
“17 ………. The period of five years prescribed in the impugned
Rules is the minimum period which an army personnel is expected to
serve for obtaining benefits under the conditions of service. The
classification of ex-servicemen into those who have put in 5 years of
service and those who are released at their request, without
completing 5 years service is, in our view, reasonable classification
and has nexus with the object of the Rules, namely, conferring
benefit on the children of the ex-servicemen. On the ground that
inherent risk is involved in the defence service, classification based
on the minimum length of service, cannot be said to be arbitrary.
For all these reasons, the definition of ex-servicemen contained in
the impugned Rule 8-E(4) cannot be held to be arbitrary and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.”
11. The Full Bench rejected the contention that prescribing
different periods of service by different universities would constitute
discrimination. It was held that admission rules framed by separate educational
institutions need not necessarily be identical and the mere existence of
different eligibility criteria does not render them unconstitutional. The ratio of
the aforesaid judgment is directly applicable to the present controversy.
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 9-
Reliance placed by the counsel for the petitioner upon the admission policies
of the Panjab University and University of Delhi would not assist her.
12. The object underlying establishment of Army professional
educational institution is to provide educational opportunities to the children of
army personnel, particularly those whose families have experienced
disadvantages arising out of peculiar conditions of military service. Such
disadvantages include frequent transfers, separation from families for years
together, postings in remote or operational areas or harsh climatic conditions,
lack of adequate educational infrastructure, repeated changes of educational
institutions as well as inability of parents to supervise the education of their
children because of service exigencies. Contesting respondents have
specifically pleaded that the minimum service requirement was prescribed
keeping in view these conditions coupled with limited number of seats
available in professional educational institutions. In the considered opinion of
this Court, length of military service constitutes an intelligible basis for
distinguishing between different categories of personnel for the limited
purpose of extending educational benefits to their wards. Personnel, who have
rendered prolonged service in the army and their families, may be regarded as
having faced greater hardship of military service than those who voluntarily
sought discharge after a comparative shorter tenure. Prescription of 10 years of
service, therefore, bears a reasonable nexus with the object sought to be
achieved.
13. Reliance placed by the petitioner on Deepak Sibal's case
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 10-
(supra) does not advance her case. Panjab University had excluded employees
of private establishments from admission to the evening LL.B. course. This
classification was held by the Supreme Court to be violative of Article 14 of
the Constitution. In the present case, classification is based upon the duration
of military service, which has a reasonable nexus with the disadvantages and
hardships sought to be addressed by granting reservation for admission
educational institutions. In Army Institute of Higher Education’s case (supra),
this Court did not find any justification in reservation of all the seats
exclusively for the wards and dependents of army personnel on the ground that
it is a private unaided institution. Division Bench held that 100% reservation in
favour of a particular category cannot be justified on the ground of
institutional autonomy or source of funding. This judgment has no
applicability as controversy in the present case and stands on an entirely
different footing.
14. As a result of the above discussion, it is held that
prescription of a minimum period of 10 years of military service for extending
the benefit of admission under the Army category to the wards of ex-
servicemen, who have taken discharge or release from service, constitutes a
reasonable classification having a rational nexus with the object of admission
policy. Principles laid down by the Full Bench in G. Meena's case (supra)
support the validity of prescribing a reasonable minimum length of service for
availing an educational benefit intended for children of ex-servicemen. This
Court does not find any ground to interfere with Clause 18.7 (a)(iii) of the
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-15837-2026
- 11-
prospectus, Annexure P2, issued by AIL for the academic session 2026-27.
15. Consequently, finding no merit in the present writ petition,
the same is hereby dismissed with no order as to costs.
16. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
(SUVIR SEHGAL)
JUDGE
(RAJESH GAUR)
JUDGE
12.11.2026
Brij
Whether Speaking/Reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
BRIJ MOHAN BHALLA
2026.11.12 16:57
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.