SRI M NAGENDRA vs SRI B S RAMAIAH

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP SINGH YERUR

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 3450 OF 2020 (CPC)



BETWEEN:

1. SRI M NAGENDRA
S/O LATE SRI MUTHURAYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,

2. SMT. N THARAMMA
W/O SRI M NAGENDRA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YERS,

3. SMT M VEENAMMA
SINCE DECEASED BY LR'S

3(a) SRI. DHANUSH KUMAR N.,
S/O NAGENDRA
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS

3(b) SMT. LEKHANA RANI N.,
D/O NAGENDRA
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS

BOTH ARE R/AT
NO.98, 3RD MAIN, 5TH CROSS
VIDYARANYANAGARA
MAGADI ROAD, TOLL GATE,
BENGALURU- 560 023.

…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. RAVISHANKAR, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. KRISHNA J C., ADVOCATE)










Digitally

signed by
VINUTHA M
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



AND:

1. SRI B S RAMAIAH
S/O SRI SABAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 68 YERS,

2. BHAGYAMMA
W/O SRI B S RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 57 EYARS,

RESPONDENTS 1 AND 2 ARE
R/AT NO.63, 3RD CROSS, 3RD MAIN
VIDYARANAYANAGARA,
MAGADI ROAD TOLL GAGE,
BENGALURU - 560 023.
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. M.D. RAGHUNATH, ADVOCATE FOR C/R1 AND R2)

THIS MFA IS FILED U/O. 43 RULE 1(d) OF CPC, AGAINST
THE ORDER DATED 18.01.2020, PASSED IN MISC.
NO.25188/2012, ON THE FILE OF THE LXXIII ADDITIONAL CITY
CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, MAYO HALL UNIT, BENGALURU
(CCH-74), DISMISSING THE PETITION FILED U/O.IX RULE 13
OF CPC.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:


CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP SINGH YERUR

ORAL JUDGMENT

1. This appeal is preferred by the appellants-petitioners
before the learned LXXIII Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge, Mayohall unit, Bengaluru, in Misc.

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



Petition No.25188/2012 (Misc. Court). Appellants are the
original defendants before the learned XXVIII Additional
City Civil Court, Mayohall, Bengaluru (trial Court) in
O.S.No.26925/2007 and respondents herein were the
respondents in the Misc. Petition No.25188/2012 and
plaintiffs in O.S.No.26925/2007.

2. Though the matter is listed for admission, with the
consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties,
appeal is taken up for final disposal.

3. Parties are referred to as per their status before the trial
Court for the sake of brevity.

4. Suit in O.S.No.26925/2007 came to be filed by the
plaintiffs against the defendants for the relief of specific
performance of an agreement of sale dated 23.11.2004.
The prayer sought in the suit was as under:
"A. Grant a Judgment and decree against first defendant
for specific performance of the agreement dated
23.11.2004 by directing him to execute and register the
sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs in respect of the suit
schedule property.
B. Pass Judgment and Decree against the defendants
declaring that the sale deed entered on 07.09.2007
between the defendants with regard to schedule property
are not binding on the plaintiffs.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



C. For a permanent injunction restraining the defendants or
their agents, servants, henchmen, beneficiaries or anybody
acting on their behalf from entering upon or in anyway
interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of
the property morefully described in the schedule to the
plaint or in any way dispossessing the plaintiff forcefully
without the due process of law.
D. Direct the defendants to pay the cost of the suit."


5. During the course of the original suit proceedings, upon
summons being issued by the Court, the trial Court in the
original suit proceedings noted that even though the
summons was served on the defendants, they remained
absent and they were placed exparte. The trial Court, in
the absence of the defendants, due to their non-
appearance and not participating in the suit, decreed the
suit of the plaintiffs and directed defendant Nos.1 to 4 to
execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs with
respect to the suit schedule property within one month
from the date of decree, failing which the plaintiffs would
be entitled to get the sale deed executed through the
Court. This order came to be passed on 23.04.2011.
Aggrieved by the Judgment and decree of the trial Court
in O.S.No.26925/2007, the appellants-defendants
preferred Misc. Petition No.25188/2012 seeking to set

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



aside the exparte Judgment and decree passed against
the defendants. In the Misc. Petition, the respondents
therein i.e., plaintiffs were served with the notice. They
contested the matter. The miscellaneous Court after
taking into consideration the pleadings and the evidence
adduced by the parties, did not find favour with the
defendants. Accordingly, dismissed the petition filed
under Order IX, Rule 13 of CPC by impugned order dated
18.01.2020. It is this order of the trial Court in
Misc.No.25188/2012 that is questioned by the appellants-
petitioners-defendants on the following grounds.

6. Sri. Ravishankar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
Sri.Krishna J.C., for appellants submits that the Misc.
Court has committed a serious error and perversity in
passing the impugned order without taking into
consideration the relevant materials placed on record, the
facts and circumstances of the case, the endorsement
issued by the bailiff/process server with regard to placing
the defendants exparte in the original suit proceedings;
he further contends that apparently the Judgment and

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



order is passed post service of summons on the
defendants, which is evident from the judgment at
paragraph 13, where the defendants were placed
exparte; he further contends that the trial Court has
failed to appreciate that on going through the order sheet
also it is found that the appellants-defendants were
served with the summons and placed ex-parte on the
very first date of service of summons on 23.11.2007.

7. Therefore on this ground itself the trial Court ought to
have set aside the impugned order placing the
appellants-defendants exparte, permitted the appellants
to contest the suit by allowing the Misc. petition and
setting aside the exparte order of decree; he further
contends that the trial Court has committed a serious
perversity in not allowing the petition to set aside the ex-
parte judgment and decree, despite the summons not
being served only on the ground that it was refused by
the defendants and that summons was duly pasted on
the door of the residence of the defendants; he further
contends that the original defendants had filed a suit

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



earlier in O.S.No.27169/2007 for the relief of permanent
injunction. Even in the said suit the very same address
was shown in which the defendants were served and they
had contested the suit. So also it is contended that
subsequently in the original suit proceedings in
O.S.No.8754/2010 the appellant-defendants filed the suit
against the original plaintiffs for the relief of possession in
which the respondents-plaintiffs had appeared in the
matter. Despite filing the written statement on
04.07.2011, they did not utter a single word with regard
to the suit for specific performance having been filed and
decreed and the execution petition having been filed.

8. Learned counsel further contends that it is only thereafter
in the year 2015 to be precise on 05.12.2015 additional
written statement came to be filed by way of an
amendment by the respondents-plaintiffs bringing to the
knowledge of the Court the execution of the sale deed
through the Court by the respondents-plaintiffs.
Therefore, he contends that the plaintiffs have
deliberately suppressed the fact of the filing of the

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



execution petition and filing of the suit for specific
performance and original suit in O.S.No.8754/2010,
which is apparently evident that it was only deliberately
done with an intention to see that the execution
proceeding is proceeded further by the execution of the
sale deed through the Court and thereafter it was brought
to the knowledge of the appellants-defendants, thereby
causing severe injustice and miscarriage of justice to the
appellants-defendants; he further contends that the
address shown of the defendants is the very same which
was depicted in the earlier suit and also the later suit filed
by the appellants themselves.

9. It is further contended that the question of appellants-
defendants not accepting the notice and refusal of it
cannot be accepted. Therefore, he contends that no such
notice was served on the appellants-defendants in the
original suit proceedings and though the plaintiffs were
aware that the defendants had filed a suit for possession,
as mentioned herein above in the original suit in
O.S.No.8754/2010 nothing prevented the plaintiffs at the

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



earliest point of time revealing the same in the written
statement as they were the defendants in the said suit.
Having not done so the act of the plaintiffs is mischievous
and deliberately done to avoid the knowledge of the
defendants being placed exparte in the suit for specific
performance.

10. Learned counsel further contends that the trial
Court has come to an erroneous conclusion that the
report has been filed by the process server regarding
refusal of summons by defendants and that he has
affixed the copy of the summons on the door at the
house of defendants by taking signature of the local
witness and service having attempted several times and
followed by compliance under Order V Rule 17 CPC.
However, learned counsel contends that the process
server has not complied with the provisions of Order V
Rule 20 CPC. There is no proper service of summons as
contemplated under Order V Rule 17 or 20 or for that
matter Order V Rule 19 CPC wherein it is contemplated
that when such a summons is refused and it is pasted on

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



the door of the house of the defendants, the
bailiff/process server is required to file an affidavit to the
Court accordingly the same is not properly followed and it
has been conveniently ignored by the trial Court and has
passed a technical order dismissing the miscellaneous
petition which calls for interference and an opportunity
requires to be provided to the appellants to contest the
suit.

11. Learned counsel further contends that admittedly
the suit by the plaintiffs is filed for specific performance
of an agreement of sale. Consequently to declare the sale
deed executed in favour of defendants to be not binding.
He also contends in the original suit proceedings in the
operative portion of the judgment and decree, though the
suit is said to be decreed, there is no mention with regard
to the setting aside or not binding nature of the
registered sale deed executed in favour of the appellants-
defendants. Therefore he contends that the trial Court
has not taken into consideration all these relevant
aspects which are crucial for determining whether the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



service of notice to the defendants is properly made or is
flawed. Hence he contends that the impugned order
deserves to be set aside by allowing the appeal and
opportunity requires to be given to the appellants-
defendants to contest the suit by allowing the
miscellaneous petition.
On these grounds he seeks to allow the appeal.

12. Per contra, Sri.M.D.Raghunath, learned counsel
appearing for respondents-plaintiffs 1 and 2 vehemently
contends that there is no illegality or perversity in the
impugned order passed by the learned trial Judge in Misc.
Petition No.25188/2012. He further contends that
plaintiffs filed a suit for specific performance in
O.S.No.26925/2007 against defendants and also for the
relief of declaration to declare the sale deed entered on
07.09.2007 between defendants with regard to suit
schedule property are not binding on the plaintiffs and for
consequential relief of injunction with regard to suit
schedule property. It is contended by learned counsel
that suit summons to the defendants came to be served

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



by process server and acknowledgement to that effect
has been placed by the process server before the Court
and the same is forthcoming in the original records which
is pointed out and contends that prior to 23.11.2007 on
23.07.2007, 22.11.2007 and 15.11.2007, the process
server went to the suit schedule property of the
defendants. He made an attempt to serve the summons.
Since it was refused, he has pasted the same at the door
of the residence shown in the cause title in the plaint.

13. Learned counsel contends that the matter was
listed before the Court on 23.11.2007 on which day due
to the non appearance of the defendants, they were
placed ex-parte and an order is reflected in the daily
order sheet as defendants refused to receive and
accordingly placed ex-parte in the suit. The trial Court
has thereafter considering the pleadings and the evidence
adduced, decreed the suit of the plaintiffs. Learned
counsel further contends that the defendants aggrieved
by the judgment and decree passed exparte preferred a
Misc. Petition No.25188/2012 contending that there was

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



no proper service of notice as against the defendants and
took up the plea that the summons was not served and
notice was not properly received and neither was it
refused. Learned counsel further contends that when
such a plea is taken by the defendants in Misc. Petition
No.25188/2012 to set aside the ex-parte decree firstly,
the onus is on the defendants to establish the fact that
the service of summons was not in accordance with law.
Secondly, that the defendants did not receive the
summons and neither did they refuse the summons. So
also it was not pasted in the residence of the defendants
as shown in the cause title of the plaint.

14. Learned counsel contends that these were the
contentions in the petition and the appellants-defendants
ought to have examined the process server, got marked
the shara of the process server of serving of notice and
refusal of summons by the defendants in the misc.
petition. Whereas such a process and procedure is not
adopted. Though PW1 did not examine the said witness-
bailiff, the exhibits were marked as Ex.P1 to P3, there is

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



no marking of the shara of the bailiff and he was not
examined as to whether the defendants infact had
refused to receive the summons, who was present at the
time, or for that matter whether he did not paste the
summons on the door of the residence of the defendants.
Such being the case, the defendants cannot take the plea
that they have established the case to show that the suit
summons was not properly served in compliance to Order
V Rule 17 or for that matter Order V Rule 19 CPC.
Learned counsel further contends that in the suit
subsequently filed by the defendant in O.S.No.8754/2010
for possession of the suit schedule property against the
plaintiffs. In the cross examination conducted by the very
same learned counsel appearing for the parties,
suggestion was put which is answered in the following
manner:
"It is true to suggest that first defendant had filed a suit in
O.S.No.26925/2007 against me and Govindaraju. I had
appeared in the said suit. It is false to suggest that I have
not appeared in the said suit."

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020




15. Learned counsel relies upon this portion of the cross
examination of witness PW1 wherein Nagendra who is
none other than the very same witness who has adduced
evidence in the Misc. Petition No.25188/2012. Therefore,
he contends that when such a statement is given by the
witness PW1 in his suit subsequently it was very
specifically confronted to him that he was aware of the
original proceedings in O.S.No.26925/2007. He
participated in the suit but did not appear in the suit has
been answered in the affirmative as recorded by Court. It
is apparently evident that the defendants were aware of
the suit being filed by the plaintiffs in O.S.No.26925/2007
and did not deliberately appear before the Court to
contest the suit as they were inclined to protract and
prolong the proceedings.

16. Learned counsel further contends that the trial
Court has examined all these aspects taking into
consideration the contentions of the defendants and also
the contentions of the plaintiffs. The version of the
process server-the bailiff who had carried out the service

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



of summons by an endorsement of refusal and he has
followed the process provided under Order V Rule 17 CPC
and pasted the notice at the door of the defendants as
shown in the plaint and has filed the report before the
Court with the said shara which has been accepted by the
Court and accordingly he was placed exparte and does
not show any mischief or illegality or non following of the
procedure in accordance with law. Therefore he contends
that the defendants have not made out a valid case to
establish there was any mischief or non following of the
procedure by the process server and therefore in placing
the defendants exparte in the suit thereafter.

17. Learned counsel further contends that the Misc.
Court has taken into consideration all these aspects and
passed a reasonable order which is not perverse or illegal
or arbitrary. Under the circumstances when the
appellants-defendants have not made out a proper case
or placed any cogent material to establish there was any
mischief by the process server or on the part of the
plaintiffs in service of summons or for that matter the

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



petition of summons shara which is produced and placed
before the Court and that there was non affixing of the
summons on the door of the house of the defendants.
The trial Court has rightly come to the conclusion that the
appellants did not make out a valid case for allowing the
petition under Order IX Rule 13 CPC and has rightly
dismissed the petition which does not call for any
interference. Hence, he seeks for dismissal of the appeal.

18. Having heard the learned counsel for the appellants
and learned counsel for the respondents, the points that
arise for consideration are:-
"(i) Whether the impugned order passed by the
learned trial Judge in Misc. Petition
No.25188/2012 calls for interference?
(ii) What order".

19. The short point for consideration by this Court is
only to the effect whether the summons so served by the
process server in the original suit proceedings in
O.S.No.26925/2007 was proper in accordance with law or
whether it is flawed only for non-following the procedure

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



as contemplated under Order V Rule 17 CPC by the
bailifff/process server.

20. It is apparently seen that the appellants-defendants
filed the Misc. petition to set aside the exparte Judgment
and decree have not bothered to examine the process
server. They have not got the shara of the bailiff/process
server produced or marked in evidence to show what was
the nature of the service of summons. What was the
process adopted by the process server in service of notice
to the defendants. It is also not disputed by the
appellants-defendants that the address of the appellants-
defendants in the trial Court in the original suit
proceedings filed by the plaintiffs in two suits and in the
suit filed by the appellant himself in O.S.No.8754/2010 is
one and same. So therefore there is no dispute to the
fact that the address is correctly shown by the plaintiff in
the original suit proceedings in the two suits and also by
the defendant themselves in the subsequent suit.

21. What was required to be seen by the trial Court was
whether the notice was properly served. Process server's

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



shara has been placed by way of report to the trial Court
which has been accepted by the trial Court and placed the
defendants as exparte in view of procedure and the bailiff
affixing the summons on the door of the residence of the
defendants. It is relevant to note that the appellants-
defendants have not examined the process server with
regard to submission made that there is no compliance of
Order V Rule 19 CPC in regard to the affidavit not being
filed. The appellants-defendants has not taken the trouble
to examine the process server or call him as a witness to
elicit as to how the notice was served and why the shara
is shown and the affixing of the summons on the door is
flawed or purposefully not following the process of law.
So also the said summons is not produced or marked in
the evidence by PW1.

22. These aspects have been noted to by the trial court.
Considering the fact that the cross examination in the
subsequent suit filed by the appellant themselves, there
is an acceptance by the appellant that he was aware of
the suit in O.S.No.26925/2007 and he had participated in

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62215
MFA No. 3450 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010191112020



the suit. This Court does not find any good ground or
cogent reason made out by the appellants-defendants-
petitioners to interfere with the well reasoned judgment
passed by the Misc. Court in Misc. Petition
No.25188/2012.
Hence, the following:
ORDER
dismissed
Appeal is .
Ordered accordingly.



Sd/-
(PRADEEP SINGH YERUR)
JUDGE


SBN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 28